B Vijaya Kumar S/O Basavarajappa vs Sri M B Mallikarjuna S/O M R ... on 19 December, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 6]

Karnataka High Court

B Vijaya Kumar S/O Basavarajappa vs Sri M B Mallikarjuna S/O M R ... on 19 December, 2011

Bench: S.N.Satyanarayana

 '§~::>' .15

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALGRE

DATE!) THIS THE 19m DAY OF DECEMBER 20::
BEFORE 

mm HONBLE MR. JUSTICE S.N,SATYANAR5¥.$?§:§V'1' " 

MISCELLABEEOHS FIRST A.?PEAL 1\¥{3¢1037(}_.f.1I?;"::.'30C:i:{f:  ..  

BETWEEN:

B.\?ij aya Eiumeug

S/<3 Bagavarajappag
Aged about 28 Years,
Bu:-3 Ckaazler,

R/0 '£{0z1a::¢.u.r Vﬁlageg

CHITRABL'RG§; TALEEK 3: m"~$':*:_§.:{::3f', ~_ 9, A?§E§;L&R'T,

{By Sri.I\/Eaimsh Rﬁgpin;   
AND: H   

Sri.E\ffgB.1¥{Ia_1_Ii}:;5_:j_é;§:12:;~__V"=...__
S /0 Eff';§3E1Sgi'€&1ﬁﬁ{?h$ii£}§§i.,4 
Age: ?v'{aj"0r,* ' " 
M ,/ S , Kaghi' ~i?:'sh %s,x--%2m
V Megtgoi' S€I"ViC§':'; 
" V'  V€x_iE{a,§Les§n.$va.ra Evieaiittai Sizareg
 , E;,§'.%.B1_%-43  
  13A%*.ar{AGjgRE TALUX

'  1§i$EB;1;§*£»

£'>:s;r2 er} :3? %--'_.¢:??:ic:k3

 '?;3A~«?,8? E .

fa}: ?{1';£ V

., "§':'z'::--.-4: §f}:i%.?§$5i<}:t221_E eiglazggféix
'  @ri_{é:':€2:i E31:-1;:,::°21r:{%e: CG. §¢'iZ§,§
"?;3i*%;isi<3:122;E Gfficeg

   ,_._.'{{eshvapura, Hubii.



IX.)

Policy issued Branch:
Orientai Insurance C0,, Ltd,
N932', Uihmar Gandhi Saiazig
21%? F100;", Rosy TQVKGTS,
Nungambakkam,
Chennai,
TAMK. NADU. 
S. Hanumanthappa,

Sic Ajjappa,

Age abaué 48 Years,

Briver,

Haiiagawadi F051;, V  

CEKITRABURGA TALUK" _ 

AND DISTRICT, T

3;, P:'a$a.rma E{u:1::2.a:j;_'--
SE3 §€u{§:'s.;:%;7§a5 5; __ é _ 
Agﬁ abQuf,§38_§?"€8:fS",---- . " 
C0r:dL;c_:ii_,05r§  V   1 '

Konazgéur Vilidg-,§e?«V vi  
Hallagasvadi vP0Si:]; %  _  " :
cmrmmvnsa. *:";az.§3I£  "

AND DIsi*R_1§:gj.  ' .. RESPQNEEE5I"£'S¢

{By$93193."'a?'Naré§;*a:1aswamy9 Adv. fer R2

 L._.'E'}:;_§_is    §'3:1:C? *§ Llﬁdéf 8€<:"£;i0'r::; §?3i};) ofM651:@r Vehicies

 Act a;§>;aérr3;stV"{irI1js: '}:§u&g1i':2en?é ané Award datﬁd 13,88.2@§Q

x ""'pass€d ﬁg: §vf'i:'{"i_ §?€'G.§5f2{}8'?{@§§ N{),§§2f2*73§§} 52:; the £326 of
'77__':h{~g EH Aééﬁjtieﬁal Qfudge Smisr 9:14; Jueigs am; Ev:'L:5a€"E',
" "~E1?a§73;:':ag§€:'f:;é'§$mis55:ing 32% {?}i2:1?m g3éé§§t;'.{::: fa? {E{}fE3.§<3EESa"€ii{}?3.

 T " Eappétai :3<}m§.ﬁ.g ear: far .:%_&m§5:~<s§@:1 ﬁzig iiay, {E38

 ' ' '_j ..C_6z,=ér'*i £§<e':;i.V:>.reﬁ the faiiawizig:



JKIDGMENT

Ciaimant in mzc No.55/200'? on the file 3 f.. 1§'E,:%;<'3T,

Davangaréz, has some up in this appeal impr§V;g::ifi§g---_ {'%*;s.é'.

Judgment dated £3.08,201G passed §,h1€_rein_."&is:§;;§éiﬁg. hi$ V

Ciaim Petiiiora,

2. Brief facts Eeadjing :0 this ap'§€§1'§»é3.r@ aS.:,:.f3%;dif5r: 

Appeﬁant hereiny ciaifr:$,nt"-§§ef§:§.r.§"{2*§::, 'Ji7§fibu:1ai contend

fzhai 33:: iE,Q§e2G%f?5' at §i:§{§:;:§: Wéziéa hf? 15555

iraveiiing _fr0m__. ~'{":v}1'ii§Ya.{:?1i1*g;:__V"-in  Vishwanatha Bug

bearing ._<:I;rii:'er of the bus an the way
near EhavihaﬁFiﬁE§+3gé"':§$€{%4cs{%¢.d ﬁrm Etiaimani: 3:0 check, the 36:51;
whee?  bus. Accﬁfdiﬁgiy the ciaémant gait ﬁown it} Check

ﬁ :;%_*«érhe.<~:_§. __'iZiH1€, the ﬁriveazx responéerzt N93 befare

 @é':,h<3{};1"€ 52%? f:.§E1.§ bug ;:*u.m:i::g ever C§2zim.an€: and hi? SiESE3;%I1§§}§:

c =in§L::"§%::s'T SW21" the b<3<§§;: ii: is 3233 {:35-3:-3. §§r:3;fz, imzszéjééaiéigr 1?;-5:

ﬁﬁéaiéd as inpatient fmm 11,09.2;@G8 and subsequenéiiy he

 u the "§"§°;=b z:r:ai'cii?€;<:s§'j:=iV.E.*1e bug in 3. negiigﬁmi {manner :°e$L§Ei:i:1g inw

 sshifted "E0 Bapujé Hogpiiah {Ea};-'ang*er€§ Whgre he "W38

Q/§ 



was shifted "to CG. Hegp-Eta}, Den-rangers, wherein ht-.___te0k

ireaimgni fmm 12.G9.2QO8 :0 12.18.2606, It is aijs€;".?V::i';%;*§4'L:€rTé;;~3.;e:

that he has spent 2: sum 0}" RS.'?0,0G0,/--  

treat.m€nt and he is stiii under' t.r6§a{i:11e:<:';,  (.Z'§?1g}:VI'£':V1V'£%.1'V:£;$Z.

further' contend that prim' £0 §i{?CiCi:E'3?17: "}i€ 

healthy and was ea,3;'n.i'ng RS.4,QG@,f}"--~;3er ﬁ'i81fii,}3,:.§33?'V.'i§L$Vi%1g S16 V

work of bus; cleaner, due t.G"'a2,§:cid:3ﬁi:  Ltgtaﬁgf Véigébied and
he has gaughi far c<3.r1f:p€I":sati;o::3 'i:'::    Rs.6,QQgC1GG,/ ~

gayabis by 'ihéf re$jg§<3t};:fV%*;:1§;  ?;.72::i«:§ 2§<§§:;§§}r ané s;e%;e2*a2.EE}a

3. In féihev's_aicI"p%d{:§¢vd3njg:§_é regpgggéjezzi '§'$0.2 ~» insurance
Comgany ev1'*":t€:'€dV a;p§éf'£:;ira;§'<é::§ "fiIc5£i statement cf ebgiezéiiens
denying the fa:é£«~..§§.ac'{:-£,d%;J;i€;A. ~7Th€ Tribunal after framing ihﬁ

ivS:5'i,}.f$S Ifz';"€;?£L'!IE'€L_"%1;€33€§_ t§VE&7€':1'*:C.f.f':..* 0:2 behalf ef the claimant, he

a.d!€h3,?C€d"€Efi{j.,1€:'§£{é'€' §a;--::.13,W,1 amd in supp@:*': cf his Case, he hag

 '=..__Ve;§{amii:e§i"%fh¢A.:é{§i'i;:'§i>:', P."§%?,2 ~ E}r.G«ha;::at5 Ts%i2;{i§1:,:E§a:" {S8 fa:

 533:5? evéééeriiie Qf 'ibis d§§{:%.@r is {ﬁ{}E1Q€}.".'fE.€3§; aéi. Caafis WEEE

' .'_§*:g:v'%3." .;£;_{} "_«.£{><:3z<_ $1713} ii. 2x;E'?{h €T:§1;""{?E}EF§S§}€3£?§f.§{}E§ §*€ga;:"&§ng

'v,'§i:£'iZf;}F€C'i;ié'I£€SS 0:" genuineness of the same as it is ebserved 'Q37



'J1

this Caurt in several judgmenig, he is in ihff habit 0f_~-giving

61-idsnce in 211} faiseé and fI'i'%'G1OE,1S C:££S€*S} and anatberipéifﬁgén,

P,W.3 W K,'F.Basavarajappag Said {(3 b6 3. t3zi.tHes:3::i:0,  

accident. In ssupport of his <:ase,"Eiée:'"E'13zs{.  p_r=r{c}'a;:ed'-iwaﬁd

marked 33 documesnizs 21$ EZxs'P~1 ta 

4. S0 far as H16 F€SpOﬂd§§HiS ax'-€---- ?:::.5Q:1{i'<2.:jr3€d,«' tin r..€:><;a:11ined
three 'i¥,,?i{.I16SS€S, R.\;V;,i ~« Hué;r:1,;:n'2:nf*5:§ji&ﬁ--p$é.;'».R;IﬁJ,2 ~ Prmanma
Kumar and R."\f\?.3_   pmduéigd in aii

SEVQYE decumezzzé :.:?é,_:3:{"~v:';?1;;«:i'i€;¢:§i,L '?:'::;C'n;:"'3.--s.,.fjX5-RA2 anﬁ R2 amé

another fiveV'éiéT{:'u':iéeni§'§. }?3§~;:::yE?;w 1 éiiiﬁv R~2 are repeateﬁ i:wice.

5. The 'f'ri§U§i23:;3;}. {§3;;.._ app:j_é":ia§;ien sf pﬁeaéxinggg Grai and
d.s¢ume;1'€;aryLA'ea§'i§€ri{te.,.a:;&iEab§e an regard, hag came "[9 the

Qaé::.§:E::.é§o:r; 'E}.}18;i:ivh.é -claim is faise and §:*iv@E;0usA R: 38 ebsarved

  i:hé"?f}fburéa.?V:v'L: the Qiaimani: xx-'-"hiie gﬁixing admmieéi E2130

_ "~«:f}§é;'.%?\{}S§§?§,"£§,a32.21% giafezﬁ as S"€,8;§i€§E'§€E7:E b&f"s:;rs:: the §:Z}{f?;{}§I ?I'rf£.2

' _'_"%:%:_a'é  E15 féfﬁ fmm 21 ba§EE0§:i.<: iffcifi 1/"{%§sz:E€.§::";gj Er: ':I7Ej*i1éf°§€f;'§,, which ha

H s2§T§'fe§*ed .213 observed by the said ﬁgctsr. Subsequentiy it



{S

z1pg:se=a.:*ss {hat 1':h<:% c:1a.im2.-mi. pm: '::f<;rt E1 21 {ii§*f€::z"e':1:i: s3'z.<>r3.-?t1I*f;2-1%

he was 2:. i:._"Eea'«m<-_-'72' in Kamhi VisI':wz2:'"m'£'E';21 $1,155 beé:g::"§m<:¥ Eéléigﬁiiy

1.

7/z«":~28?} on 3. m<J:1é;h1y s3ai21.r},-7 {sf Rs:;.<ii~.{)0Of~ 2;~z~1~:1' relcvamt ci_2m3 21:: &:Eb{)£.1§. 3.30 p'm.. I}€'.E}..I' B1_'12:viE1_:g;}_' ihéz'; ci3":i.t.s*-3:1' of ?.'.h£-3: Ifmiss :'eqa1es3t.eci him {:0 ;,§€;%ff,C1(}'£-§.?A§7.« g;.zﬁt_i. {ih'€¥{fk'1§}'Tg{;? Zgéfii' wh<:*,<-:*;E {sf éhc %::1.2ée Eilid 21$: 't:hz-:1' §.i31"1§'3"§.E';(? a<€{:':.%<§_%3s'1ii t.<i:g3'§V<:'v;3.i21{:e.";

6. Or: geing E.E1.z'<>z.1gi1 1.';.he §°£:':ci§iiig:.§ of iT.I::{%.* ;Ti"iba1if':ia£g it; is

4..

<:iear':y S€i':€'.3'} ihatz t.i"3_e ;'.1c<%i{iA*::_13'" "§'y},-"éAl'§{\§%ﬁj§(%é§iSji§§'i:€{§. 31:3 .§.si:_§u:*i<-is iii} {:}E2'--:§ma:1:, £25; s;"i.ai«:%:§i §'}§,»'§f:i_::;:{_ ':':':& E.§§E"}ii'i :35 E":'i.$ 21dmis.,v-3163351 {:3 §':e1§1i'§i}§§k'E'(3H1 buIi<}<7§~; :ia1"%L ii. is 329921 §':§";;2_§: {E {:a::§§§;<s:.i®z1 b€i:';*s's;é91": {he :i:§3§1z1:;1m,,, §}::C:':'z2m.21?¢.<: Fv'§a.e:§E;1z:1§§_z1:' zmczi g_ﬁi'..i:€?1f"S :1"; :2-ggg-{he $211313 w§*i:E?,i:": "Elm zm1T0ii'; 03' ;{m1%:,z:>:° ; zéamigi Siiélkii £:1a.§..m ibr %'i.h{-5% <:<>zn;::e::§saéiéa;n.

""?

'E'E";_:§ v;}":_z3_E{: '1.;:%:;%s:;*<?is;<% a§3§;€:::a.:°:a=; 3:9 E33 _§"1'2'm{§:.:§<a%:':'£', in :%'1;:«":"i:u:'€:.(

-. -'a'2z§:':::fé% éh:;=:"is:§ A:é1_~;a~; :39 éii?£;'iLT:f§§': :3? E:§.Cf'{i§3E'i %E':<;%;r E": @2231: 'E:§°§:::<:% 'Ea {tr§:é;=;..§5:

siaé'; . E~';Qr §.'a;:1mt{:1:g; éhe '§':"§'i31.2f:*§a§ af:.c:* «:::<)::':_$%{ia%2*i.:_':§,§ ihé-3 £2*e3i§§<é:':;t@ " E':--:-13 éeﬁn i.E1§.3 {--:xer(:is3e 2.-md 21:13 yégiﬁégi £>E'3§€,1'°W:d 3:1 {mm 2',1pp:f&:<*:i;1£;§1'2g 211} the E-rvi(i£én<:.e a\:'2;1:l_21§r}1<: on ;*é:a~::<::rV<3V-'--.__ and di:§z1'1§3s;e.{i 'i':hs;=z (:12-zim ;:z€t".iE:%{}11 fileii E33; §ii'1.{*§ a.p;3cHaI:1.é }j;¢:*é3ii'1--. "

z«Xﬁ.e1' g;:3i1'1g ?.111"<}1,1g}1 the j:.1£igg1f1":<;:é:'1§. i111p1.:g:j:<Ec§ A;-j1::"';:v€.'?{ ' rc21.s<>:1.i1.":g; gix-Fm': E.':':.e3rrc~.iz'1 by *{:1'1::*: '§."1"'i1'.){,1I'f'aé:'s.*§'.ii. £3]s9;:::«:5;ﬁ*%EW2:t..§;§f1.ei'e:é :51»: :zeii;E1<;%':' iiiageiéiiy :30? irreg__§:.:32:_:'E§'§» 1g_;€ 2>:'p'§x_:9£.:--.=;%;2:fié{:i3.,3Fiﬁ pieezciéxzggss ansci a:~*s;i{i€é11<%e :a;Vaéi.z1E3}e;': ':"m::{>:i§§ "é}:"1§?i;éV'if'§fib:..m2:E "

and $1322": _f§_1'1<iingg g;ive:'1. '*?{.i'1€=.r§3§'n i:=:::»-':=a;%:§;_53;--«¢;ﬁz1b};<:t a1é'1s';f gzétzfteptzibie 2a?'iiE': :"::=r§€::'23::':{.:=té {<3 éhaé 5.2:}*;,.:':'n{?:2":%$ <31": :*é2=::<::r'i§. TE3::';°:*?E"<:::'<2 §.hi:=a: {f:):,2.§'€'--.§Eﬁ{% §:Ej:a§'_, 'i',E;é.&:z€.:V g2:i:S<}E:.:§.@:E}; :25; wagém ti:

iz3i.€:1"f<::"e xw§E.§'1H:§§i'¢;€. _..x$§%§. m§is3E3_;'.:€;i:{§_-- 3VfH: 2{[i§§:':}<;é1'":t: pass:-3<%d by Eihe 'I'1'§bune1§ in :'§;*E's{'{: %N<:.55;%2r:{{5:é §{@'§d §\E{3.9£32,/2{3{)6§ mi ::m: {:16 emf E'vIAC'E', I32;xr21:j;;3{€:1;é-3,,'-. U .

A<.§é<t>:"ci§f:g;f:»;.«_ {he appeai fﬁézsd E3}; '€;'h%Ei2 ;¥a§;ps3§Ea:r:.!;: J

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court