Karnataka High Court
Sri. G Krishna Naik vs The Management Of B M T C on 3 February, 2011
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, B.Manohar
EN '.I.'§"i ii ¥"EEC§H {)C¥U§*?;fF (3%? ii!-§E€T\l:'X'I7§X?{5%u §:3§%.NGA1JO§2E §.])2'{T'£€§}3 'i'¥"§ES '.E'§'"i§%L SEW' I'}A'r" OE' E*'E%ZE3RiJ1"iF~{'¥I 291 §RESENY THEE E---IC)N'E3£.§E3 EVER. JUS'E"iCE.<Z- m,gm:§mj::1;v% V AMI?
'2';--IE: :~~1o:\2*I-sue": MRJ US"I'EQIi: B) r_\g:';§_N'Q}TTI,:>;}-Tz~VV. 2 "
"sNA NO. 3913 014:' zdizzs._"{':_,~§<sR5:'c3 _"T NEIS<Zi.\?'J 1'~I.€_Ifi';«. z_0:33zi~§. gig? :1} E%EZ"E"WE.EZN: ' SEE G. Eifiisrméx r<§§{g£"ig_, . "
S/G SR1GAEEC1-A.'E*l,5XE'2%ii~V._ V _ V. AGED A£30m=._4s_:.*§.;E;§A..__r2s,--. .. ' Rm NO§.,_28--+f:.--_; *~:>*"::R<::;§':3, - -
3'7'm MA:1'~z'R@A:3--,V * V ' 3.12. :\:A£;A:Ie;,L 31'! 'f P:>rzAs}3; .. V E3ANGALOR1§"=~ 55'€30_C:?8';._ ' ' M AP§3"E;§§,LA.N'T V. {:3'~,:i éxqr '*%;;?,};<;s_ f~§z?;§E§, ;mv,;
"
_ 'i'1#"'i.I*=f§-""E&z"£;'"%.1?€:»;i%;»'-§';:f_?':'§§iME:N':T' <3}? E:%.M,'.E."1{T1. V . _C§:1E'€'E'E~;A L «.3:>§m<: :5;
3 7 ' * --- _ E§E:':{;?§"?'»3'E'1?€--A}(3g%kE2, v..jE;a:ix?'~;:i*;.ag_,<):::£a -- 5% 8212?, E5%§<-1??'-3'9:E%Z$§§F'~i'§'E%Z€} E%"':"
" '§T'§3-SE; a'":m.s?..2=' 'E'R£-'a§%'E?'E§.{f {>§>m{:is:§'"<.
4 9: §%i§%Z§%E3{}§?'=§EL}E%:?=J'E' TE-{ES \?i?P~ZE'I' APE3I3AL( §3EI,EC'If) U _;'S 4'; OF §§zXRNA'1'z°x.KA 1---11:3: COUHE' AC'? PRAY'ING TO S.{§'£'.«'£kSE'£)fE._ TH E ORDER E3'ASS§ZI} IN "E'I"-"iii? W' R1'? .§7~E?f['171.' NC). 1<3'?35,f'20OE} {E,--KSRTC} If)z¥FE-I) £6,506/2QQ'§*----. _ 'E3 " ..
§'vEISC.W 350, 103353;' 10 ES mi...-;.«::i:': 'U:€I3:§§::_.éEé;%;i":'i¥:;+Ni'.5 or 'I'I.--{ii LEM1'1'A'§'EQN ACT }"E~U-':'_z.'£fisI<;'; fm f:v::<3_:wf*':3_0':\s:+:V '<2f;~::::,.
1)EII.,A'y' OF 458 IDAYS IN FIE.-.iIN'G 'F§"K?'§ j:§.j'|:)'}:jE{1\li{X..IJ~.' = THIS APP£<:AL. A,/W iv£1I$'c::,w CQMINQ w::«*'€:3§z I4"RF3L-EMINARY EIEARENG '.1'1--%;;s" gum? » .sjA;B'£AaA:;i1'1* J; m:£,1vE:12E:I3 ':1'1~1£: F01,;,0\VING:----~ , 'V J'U%;"}Gr§;§;'%%af:' This; app€2§§.¢_V§$.£"i1éd .fi'i€w};iIiS'<}§iCi€E§'SfL11 pe'{iti011e'1' in W.P.i\1'o.1023345,/2'3§fJ'§3"5'..§:1§:21'r1g:..Kéé§g§g§fi:eé'éci.V.by the order dated E6~§~2i3_09--. \iv}"1V<:E:"&:.iI':.V}£iIt:::'E~s;?§{1*:.1e':i-Singglsi J1,1.dg€, Ems de:<xEir1ed to ii'}'{'.ffFf€E'7€?."'i?';"Z:i.vh i1r1.€§e:' awazrd timed 2%--9--2QO8 ;.)21s':=;§§§e':i'V by zliiciz fi__dd§.L2:bou'1* Caurii. E'«ar1gai«::«:'€ in zeméi €§31SI11isS€3€i the wrié. p€'é;i'é:.i{>:":. 21"_;:_>§§e3Z21.§:§ hr2r€:ir1 - w"2"E%;, ;}€:EI§'z.ir:>:1€:' wasss Ws:>:§"Ki.:1g.;»; as :5; e::<;»'-.2}{§:§:u:}:'é.{::' in 'z:.§3:=, §_%21z1§_§;.21.E<}:"fi T\;E<:?tr<§:g3GEii,2:.n "§"':"ans§p<'}r'&'. ._{35?z;*§3<>;"'2iEf:i»:m {'E§§'sfETC° 501:" :~§%:{>:rt}, While he was <:7<};:€h,2<?i.§:1g;j I§'i.§_"'i€§' '$2.23; an §f§f.£i~2}{'}€3é§ in §°«:.>u'i&% ?\§'{>¢%§f3E§. £:h2:t E3213 1.-2:225:92 ""§'E'§'§fi1£":'?€'§_§E§?{i§ gmfi i,E':<% §:':sag:w3z::§§.§2:': <%<>m: by :-m s;::;z:.;3.{§ gmtié ii. was found {that {he}; had failed in :"21§«:e: i.nt.<> a<::<:<>1.;:':i_ #55.' i:i{:tEic3'£:-3 21I1€§ had re.~i§;ss:,:c%:1 6 i.ir:E~::3%.:a; 25;'? Rss.4~,f¥ <'::a<7h .:i::s.d' :§1'<;<_3; {."O1I€*{f'."i,(.".(,'E €1I"1"1C}L'i1"i1. <>§' Rs..18,!-- aalnci iaiieci ti} ii-3S{1f;'."-"i.§'£T}';E'E§,Sx"{5} four pass€;3.g<~:;"s. Eficeingg uni. sa§.is£'1ed xxzifi: the .;*é';j1'y--.;I;'ix»*€t:1 by"
the "ir(}X°k£,I'I€i;I.'jg d<:)m€$'1'iC €'I"1(ifLiiII'},7 wag: =.€A_z3.;"£,iz§;icjr9i 2§{--!1Ci--.S';1'ffTi{T?i€?§}i . 0pp0r*t.u11it:y was affarcied to {he w0rk1i::;1r§ V-and §':I<i-E. e. 11quii.*y {>§f'f1ce:° heid ihai. the ChaI'g(f*. betén-._p;:Q§}g::d:"1.: Th<«:
diascipiizrary a1.1t:E1o1'ity ;:£,€:§:;3i.e3c;§V"'i11:}§_:'-répgxft. €Z)"i;'Vi.1*}.€~ E€qL1iF':g' e{fi<::e§: dated 12~6~2008 of dzzsnfissai ETQIE1 s€:"vi.(:e ibr Ehxzv r§1i§?3:£?'éi'3':T1»'..j:L:i'E?1';:.'* by the E'$E":lI1"Kf§ dvVi.S;5't1%,€A :we1s;§'ii?:'2;is%:d -zzzadéf'"'SVéc'{,ion 1C:~4{A) of the I:1duSt:'ié1.§_ (ACT? for Sh€'3E'I'.} in E.i},NG.
6?',ff£OG6 6:5; *fEf1s:3 '.f:".1'E<§ {he IE1 £':dé§.Lab<>u1" C<:>u:ri.., E321:1g:a;Eu*;°r:A. V"E'§*-#9:' V 'E,;ab:3:.:1" Court. a;ft.£2;: <f0:18ideri::gg the: '"€?U'i<i<:f£1§f:e:_;§:,ci{'§u£te "i3y'ii'r1'«3' pa1r¥;.ie3S, {Ti{}'I"if-3id€i'.3'€d {he materiaé an :'*«:*::t{}ie§. a;»:1§§':::¢§':?§if:'s?;i,i:>:":ss 0? {ha ;>22;rt'§e3s 2;},Z'}{'§ heid iécazrz <:%:22.;"g§&: ;~:{ga~';;':1§E "éhé"_w:>'z'}~§:':i.a.z"1 Efzaci. been ;31°G's:@.d and hzwizzg; :°£:ga.:'d 5:2 133$"'§}F{)'%fi§€. f?1iS{TC}§1dL§€'ZE'.§ "ma: §mp<)s»;:%?;,is:>r1 <3? ;:»s:na3'§,}r 3%' K {Eié;z11i:=%s£éa§__{%2u";*::<::E '£35? smiii 18 be 3;.%é{3<:§§i:.":g§}y d§§§;§:2§°<>§.3{:z""i.iémzitéi '=_s~i%<:y 2&2: §é:):"" §.::1.§.<-%:"i.%.-%:"é;*;':53%: <2? {?:>£'i'f:°€',fi::<§{? am}; <§.§s<'::"e§.§:3':: 2 3*': .:' ;
2 2 ; _k z, --
g,_'<,,v. 7 pt-§l' 6' 3 'K3 zmder S€t<?t,i<m 'ilnék of ihfi? Ac?t. and acc:(>rdi11g£y :iissn}iS.$éd Ems: £:?.f§}}7}Ii{TiE¥.'i.i€}I'"L Efieizlgj; 21gg:'i£:Ved by the ss::§f11r3;;__ workman fiiad W'.P,3'~.§(). 1€}?35/2009,
3. The 1€tar1"1e3d Single Jllihifi :h;1j.3iI1g, h.6:"21:"d" *f;:§:£::=:;TA L;
COLIFISES1 appearing for me p23=ri.:ig%_sg héid 1151a: ;.:r;'a;i,:51fvia} _1§.>n % I"f;'f(.'.(}I"('3. wank} cIear}};* Shaw {k121i was guilty of I111-sC.cmdu<?:t:' hi.m and his exp}anat:i.(m. {.h3.{.A¢'<:he(:§§i{1g j" §'/f.-L1,;eI1 ii? Wt:
iéctkets which .big5§ --v.21nd..EP1z1x*e made false aiiegations é.ga§..ij;{.é':_§ thfe pét:££;i01'1'<;é:".; ctiésphot. be ac:<:c=:p'ted. The def7eI1.<:ég 0? %...h.e gégiii.j.i3:;:1'1€:s._{};:.;1_': .t§3;e;=: pz1s5ser1.gers hazi bearded the: bus; 'and-- £71.63'&§ffi{%::i31>V{;}}€'~§¥é"OC€SS Qf issu..i3:1g i.iCk€18 has not been s::"h$t:=n:t.i2:,'t:et§ 211151 2:(:m:~d1'I1gIy had "that stharge haS.~fb€tei': §3r<)v€;=;§_ any; having regard "Le {ha praveii ;j'1i.<;{::>:1d"::V{&:;'V grzad s%e1r1i<:r E2 €f€ES€E~3i 0f n1i:aC<>nc§12c:1 againsé the A=T§}€3§.§_{.'E€}i";€3f;«w_ifiifitié §:E':2'£'{, :§mg){>s:£¥;:i.0:z1 <3?" §.}{~':z:aE€.y sf diamisz-321E jusfzyified :a1:i€i~%:_%a:V%::E§§1€ci :15» §z3%eri"cm with {he emsard paissfseci by ] Ems. L;2:1,:<§L:;" {"::>m**:' zmd C§ii*:3§iEE§S,%E~3€?€§ Ehe=.= wrii. pet'i:Ti0;:n E3'E':€IE.iig,§ »_2¢2;;;.,;;;;;:;;%:"_£_<;*.."s.,='s;t<§fi" by $229? $=2i§§'1%';'., w<}:"k:':2a:': §Eé:'if%5 f2°§<;°,~s:§ iE1§'s--: w'I"'i§. 2-igfigféfié-1}' Therrs. ES :21 delay of 458 iizx}-*5; in fiii.1'1g f:h<% }3<7i'i'i;.i,_::§é':f Z\«'.Ii:;c:.'~.-V.N:3. Z0338,' 2810 is filffd for £:<>nd:)m-1i.:i:3:1 Qff"é;11.?:é delay,
5. The 1<;*.2.1I"z2<3c:§ C<>1.1I'1S<3E for i:'r'§.§{ éi {}§?fi:13'c1f3i, LibI}f}f;fi.f§(§"*:i"
{hat Since 4;:ih.E*. bus was i1"1'i6::'(3<:.«;3i',€d §Q<:f.2§re 'i,I1é" A,ig:,:<_;-3 hacii M reszzchcd {he n.e.2<;1, s:.3._g_§€ and E1é17c§' g 4;h.<:=.
appeikant was in '£1153 iigéiirgtg anci
ihereibre. e:iefem:<: G? have been
3.{EC€pI€;€d as regard t0 the:
rzzaterial on is dispropoztionate
:10 the :i'7;;Zs;<?:}:A1A<;ifji,.iV<:'§'V
6" »ha'1\'r'eV (:031Sici~:':mti<m '$10 the
<:<}:";te:it.";mf1ss c}£"'~ }§=:2é;:"§m{§ {rezznsei for the 3§)1:)eEEm1i. and é;0r:.:€i;':Eé'<%:?c£ §.hs%_ 1";"1.:--1'i',r:=:ria':.i G21 reczgrd. :3j'ai,':"é1"§aE an ;'eC0:*<:E wmsid a:t:iearE§;' £;h.c>w ihaé.
1%-"E2c§%._ 'E3u,€-3 was; beiiég eii<:=:':::§z:(':'£'.»s3d by the zasppeiiani. an 'E:%f3jw2f3éZ,'3é in :':m€::% Nezzafifiii, éht: E31255 war:-=9 é:"2'£'a7:"{:€g:>:ed zmd _ @:§2'?s'--.<i%'r_3:zé<f:i2:§:§g;f 11%;. '».?¥2:i.S f<.>:::'1{§ ?;.%":2.:%i. E3452 %':ase: fz3'£§€:::§. ac» iaiiazt z':':z<:s .V _;':§f'§{I?€}E.é§'iE' E} ':'é<*E{.{3t;.s&; :a:.'m.'§ 21:3 fr.':a:':3 ;°::§%:;s512é;%<§ {S '%i£(:i{:~:'i'.se; <1? E-€:'~i;.9;'~ 'ix (§<:t:':{3x11i112«n',ic}:z zmd 2115-so (";()H€t(,'.f.f:d ihrs fare of Rs.'i6,f--H i3'_<::¥1'zj1 itmr ;3asser1ger:e; :;,-ma 11222.3 faiiezi ta') issusr t.ick€.~i~:~;. ;,%i"h:§ ' e:x:piam1i.i£311 91' ihfi'. 2?:pp€11am'. éghaé. he W2-1:--: in i_1§1__<: g-3.V1*<3(:A{:é:€:sie of is:a<311i:'zg tickeis zmd that". this irsspezjitizxg E_~$:.;u:é;d t.{3<-->§<ji 1'1p i.h'5: t4iek€i.:'~3 whzicgih had fakken in the bz;s"..21:'i€l I'1£-L1':-'€"':v.']§§;I;I{}i§{§€lf.,<f§C§.N him is not pmbabi1i.s€~<:i {mm thue;.V':11a1'.e1*i211. .(V)11.A_i"'V't;f:L'.{§1:'V*»:"i..VVWTIVIG 11"1a§<a1*ia3_ cm r€<:0§°d sshowgs '{.}1;7£1"'11é_"--hVaei_ alrcéicigf .:::§§§e.<tt6d Rs. 38/ ~ from the passengers' ;11'3.d7ir;'e2 'A.r;0i'.Vissu€d iiatkets to the passe11g<:.1fé:,v.._ Ilfjhe _i:'}. '%:heV~pgfdiiess of issL1iI1g§ 'Li<?.k€:£s. he 3-sxgfiziikgfi 1::t{§i_ Vt:--<)_§Ec-(':i.<:-"id, the fare, F"L1.I"E11er, the d<»:i'eI1c:f5 t'21k€z2 iihai: E1h%}<:céi,{e{i;vhict1i" 'mid fa£Eer1 in the 'anus have been us7<zj{§t:Q Iiiéikcé f1"211..s*i:._2:EE.cga.1,ion of;°e~Ci1'e;:L1§21i,i0n «::>f1,i.{:k<=:"t is :10: at é11i_ Vp<35--:ssibiéA_{é:; §:':i'e1' in '£1116 }§I'E'.S€.§E';, {E21556 hE%.\-'iE1§;§ * V. «_ rr3g{::1i';cI ié' ihe. I122ii;e§1f§_;2;E (2:11 ::@.C<):"d which xx.-*<}:,11é. shaw €;h&.'{. out. '<;;§v=EV:3} ;:>.;:.s:se:1g?e1f_$ 30 gézxaaezzgers were pass he:>id€r:%;, in any Vr*§f';fE"'.5'\;7.~'{}f 'i.E:e_ V;':ié::i.i.s3:, '{.':*:€:re. is; {.'.€}§'£{.';L1§'1'€'.E"',Ef. f§z;<i§:";ggf 9:; ifiihe q§,:;»é:-';i.ia3vs*;. 0&7 Eéici that. szizezrge z1g.;§2m'2ss't the aipgmiiazzi. E1215; §:>eez'; pzff§j<.;*s;':z.ii 5:.n€i 24%;? 322.m<=, e::i<>es:s not": s.--m§'£E:%r from 52113,?" i:1§§.z:n'1§i'y <31' "':i_§VEir;g;2§.§it.}F zmti h2w§:':g :"«:3§§;e::'{.i "£0 éhe §m>v%3;s:§ n'1is:;£:{3mi:.:«::'<:4
- =:§§ri:1g_::;-%:':'£: "i-"§€E¥ :'s';ne:3z.':E£i. '§}{:' i,.;:E«:€é:'1 23§_g:21§§':s'~2*:, ifézif :'~,€:sn.s;"§'z2:'--'%..{>'§;°5; 'sA;h.@ rs...
Q. Ac:{é:>:"CEi:'1g_§§3:, wri: zipgmal ig aiissiikissaeii on :':1_<;%:'i*"i., ;1:'1::§ aési} am {Em g.12:>m1cE ersf €i€§2--3.:,«".