Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 17]

Karnataka High Court

Divisional Manager United India ... vs Smt Jayamma on 27 January, 2009

Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao, S.N.Satyanarayana

we'

IN THE mar; coum' 05* KARNATAKA, " 

SATED THIS THE 27% DAY 01:' J20p9%L%% 1% T 

PRESENT   
'THE HONBLE MR.  
   2 && ' «   .
THE H0N'BLE MR. J{iSfF1CiEv}£§§N,::}'S;53:%Y£;NARAYANA

"fig-. F';A. 1xa<5§'3€;AVi:9):;_§é-.213 fmrvi
  h1.,;'.g®N0,§§go;2s03

H.F'.A. 310.3511?!g,9t-.§§ *A%?T%   ' :1 A
mv1s:o:§zA:,_, %mmm;g%:2  H 

UNITED 1NDiA1;:ésU-RANc§'~~'Lco LTD
AKKAwiAHADE"s:§R'oA9,'

 V. tMi\4::'~?::ors4PLEx, :3AxIA.2.~sGERE,

'z~;oW"RE'?iRg$ENTEn BY rrs

 E1§',.G§{)N--£'g£;~ h?iAI*im.GEEk'
i3NI'.'i-'EDDvvIN»I}§A.VA'iP§$URANCE co LTD

R1':':GI'GI\¥AL {'}_F¥?3ZCE,
SHAE§_KARAF§ARAYANA BUILDING

 3 390.25, Mg; Rom,
  'BANGALQ§<E 560 00-1

. .. APPELLANT

: gm' sm A N KRISHNA swam, ASVCICATE)

T  Min

V A. 1 am: JAYAMMA

W] O LATE RAMACHANQRAPPA
NGW &{}E1l:) ABOUT 24 YEARS

V



_. U1' .

NCL25, M G ROAD,

BANGALORE 560 00}

AND

(BY SR1 A N KRISHNA swam, 5DvQCA??;}v .   _  1'

SMT. SHARADAMMA
W/0 LATE KARIYAPPA  
NOW' AGED ABO{J'{'.{32 Y;:~m::~s%_;'-- 

GGWRAMMA 
D/O LATE KARIYAPP5  ._   
NOW A<3g1::.jABQ{r;1'* 14"x'EARSf,'--._ -  '
MINOR     g 

pEDDA3§:M .;    _  A_ *
S/Vo%.1,ATE%_xA$:IYAPPA_   V
mw AGES» AE'{)UT"1.(_) YEARS
Mtmg 1  _   M %

SII){);€t.Miv1A 

D10 LATE §{AR--IY}aPP}i

,, gfisowr AGEUABOU1' 9 YEARS
V-_Jv;1:;LoRv%. A. ' '

T "GEETw'uy_1MA

"-1;: /"O.'L3¥fE_' RARIYAPPA

A ' Naw.Ac;:2:D ABOUT '2' YEARS
"=M¥1'iOR 

.  ;<A'm}A1DPA
"S/0 LATE KAREYAPPA

V'  ROW AGEQ ABOUT .3 YEARS,

MINOR
SINCE R2--6 ARE MIEQORS

REPRESENTED BY THEIR NATURAL
€}UARDiAN/ MOTHER THE 137 RESPONITEENT

4/



 

 ';:«1ccié1;e }1t5»-.i§vd' dfiea":t}V§S. 5{i{:11I"red; two separate claims were

V 4V£:§;a::~pe11satioI1 by the L-Rs of tha deceased
  < perfiifils.  has found that the negligenae of
 H  vehicies at 50% each and awarded

A  :.¢€)'£i1%%1SatiGn 1:0 the petifioner and directed both the
  to gay compenmfian at f;0°x{:> $3.61'). In MFA

 " ' M36691 2903 and 3672/2003 M/S Naiional insurance

(BY SR; 8 M SIDQAPPA, ADVOCATE FOR_.F~:Z'7,  5:)   ' .
SR1 R JAIPRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR R1.-:3)  ' v T
THIS Mm. 153 FILED U/S 173(1) 0? MV«A<;'3\A:5A1NsT 
THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD; {)A'E'.ED:*  31';-o1';2Q_o;:2:,JA
PASSED IN MVC No: 248,101 on THE S?-{LE OF' THE Af)--DL., "
MACT, CHi'I'RADUR'GAg PAR*:*=m'..__ ALLt€>w':NG T.*F'H.E.4_,CL5;1M%
PETi'1'iGN FOR CGMPENSA'I'ION,»..,  V '    "

These appeals  01:;  thi$ day}
S1'-ZEEDHAR RAG J., de1ivf:r€riv--vth:.*i 

 -m.- tJj2€*' accident where in
thare $35.3 Té::'<:a;§1iifpV0s"z'7%';g3:' 1i¢'g]ige1'z¢é"' if two vehicles. One

Vehicie iéii;&sufedVVW;i:hp N~fif&or1a1 I11sura{1<:e'C0., Ltd., and

another. Witl§ 'ZIf1i:§<1  Insurance Co., Ltd, in the



 

£30., has chailenged the compensation awaI'der1'----.pas

€XC€SSiV€. This court: in the said MFAS dgcifieé' :€;;I1* V.

9.13.2005 has haid that the c0mpensa£i0§1H»'£fi:§fa.+§§E§€1  

iess than the just entitkément.

M/stnfimn hxm1Inm§an¢3fib"}m$_fi%d fim 

above two appeals chaflefigéfig _ thé~ _  as

excessive, In  gf "<':0urt in MFA
530.3669]  ::t_lf:s:_ figzove appeals are
dis.fl1i9$*§Q;2  K,   * ?

  is t{) be transferred to
the1tfinn$a1b:;$g§ficnfi7

 .....  

Twdge Sdi-4 }&ge