Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
D Pakkiri Swami vs M/O Railways on 7 July, 2022
a Ee) =o ti i i a 6 ee 0 6 i sk a & A el ER Ge My sq G ad @ CPR a io B hcg vd eS eet ett a8 : et pe cS 2 soo a | M4 4 2 "
A a A . » i ijt a 5 ed @ ai S a a ref) nn a * ees ard & Moo SE BE Ob eo , 2 ued ' ee mr 2 Pp i> . Sox ea : ; o "y ea o "s "A " cae : Boe a goog 3 #4 . H Bo et wel 2 o 2 | o Ae se Dek ¢ os 4 fi ie oe fs hors Bo wg : 5 3 if ;
eat t o <4 oS nS + 5 Py ee So oa . rH a ZO & - ps 4 Gee AS 3 ® Bs ve fq a a aS 43 % wes Bee o Re ey an, ag eo e : : he BD ed peared 2 om 3 HO gf 9 oq u A cs ae OBB FF a ~ oa WH 'S) ay , pad ne re Gh a +p fA ed "3 6 ' Fal ; 8 v 4 6 a vA Re ed os Po OG j 1a : ' . (hos y 'S Ceod nf fe OS G fd ae Y :
zl $8 'eae iB Ye s 0 oF 3 yo al a Mg anes oe i " pee sort ea a fe foe Gg , ee Dy as & AQ ; o oA a eg ee m o re r: Ae i a a & oO LW sed peo 3 vet og Bd Boy D © 5 a '6 a; u At Re ! RA "ers 38 Boog te cd * ved A gS poppe GD : g i fs] He £3 e : a ce 4 e Ee a Me eS 6 & iG Oey yt of O Boo @ J Pe = peo ss a a a i 2 a ey it fe g2 GO is he ee e on te Ee x as Mog 6 a eG a MS Ce Ea "rf ee a ie BG os mo ey i rt B % ao Pa hy nt 8 i toe me i Ge eal a eo AT Bom its} ved a fay: LA ei fo S rr a i tal: Mest se) uw 4 FS) ba ty eet a moog a ay Lo See B re 4 © fy o © : aod a 5 « oO a Hog re g Mae ° ih ey Bo a) "
' : we Pe ae Poe aw 4 on Ate OS a a 4) § " DM OW Le ee 4 B feed eG a a ed % Q e Be EY Qe a ee ee UL Sed nt 5S ao Dg ME 8 w "f BS wo fo he et eon ep © Roh tH Ye Pe Bee RB be Ose 6h wg eB ig e Ma DM a ay % eg Ee a Be Qo ® OQ mw & GOW go OB @ 2 BBS BS 2 a "F qo NS ov : S: . phe 4 a Se athe. t Oo Be BO @ 3 mB oo 6 OB o " OD BEE AE gf eos fe ee ES Py te ee 3 re Bet EE EEE ae gh aS oe ae ee oe ee 3 R neh sed ed OU Ba oe a et ty : XS rR Me BS OSS ist by @ sed oO bee Ba DO Le * S : sh a $4
6) Bi We CAE OE SE * vt es on "ee 4 fo & + aS a) a " @ B5) O a iY G cs y 44 o a 5 i oh re) oy it C 43 al oD Be os % a sed 1 ag +}. 4 8) rest : faa [on We a ct cok ag ~ 5 pa ms ~ O43 CS eo ea) @ xt a ee 43 veered oe us a MO pg Os et by on} 2 ed S: : ay mo HS aa a Ba ee Bo BY Q oA Sp Sy a @ ey 4 mT @ ay hs Rs 3 op ge Epa 4 6 g, repay pp ote og ee; A 43 S oe 4 Aah 43 Ey & SS nage a a : rae! i 7 Crt ace tc ot 4 O we: ya ved ® Papo, oh co) 4 A 43 Wy fe Seg eu ee yeh: ct gon a Dy ye ee Var ps ea a uM a 2 D 13 % Be yo ved es x. £2 ce oe wood 2 o ee 13 ch is so @ o£ ky vot Sep Ay a Pa oe Bd: ted p a ¢t ord oo Yj 4 bee oy ot XS. es ey a G tek: a ny 33 ¢ 2 2 . o @ hs Rey 43 ef ot cS ry rg a) oa oe wu 4 : oe as Be cso} ay v its Lane 43 re pooh ae iQ ry Be es + : Se 4 Ba ay ue ch Pea Ct in OY Ri i fan "3 ot a at 4 3 sel byes a 2] tes ; "rf Pose * ~ 2 py AS © A 6 G3 Who ed a Sage Ss aes oes 2 nD i 3 ne my Me , oe "4 6 TD bdo ey : G3 ~ a i 4 3 a wi 44 © vee s 2 ta on otha ere a mr ; e ) Ds 7 Ce BB Fg vet ng ve 44 oy} ved te "4 st w x i) ep we Hy vag Dy & Ly 2 Li "e oA a 1H fi "id Oe ged 3 ™ foe a Bo " L m6 : "a A a oa ay uy a 4 horpe oh br ep oy ie) G a ae ard Lt 5 cS eet g oe fe 8 i Oe a4 pp rd 7G Q o CG " it G wy 2 po ss Soy m ah ; ' " : na . a -
oS 8 4a eo Bb go 8 in o e a "4 fg Won 4 Eas ~ : TH co st a 44 vel ; & ~: ws ' dG fy ba 24 a c ae Oo vet D Fe] RQ:
= a 5 @ 4 1 . os " 5 oh a" aot 0 © va 7 a fag ok 13 ira) Os boegoy 4d Ae 3 43 i' w ie $4 = ae eB 3 a 6 , we ON Og g ¥ Wg a ® eee a a uj Begs & ao A © a6} 4 ms eC Cp eG it 4 "i £2, oO "3 a - a4 ver, : a : :
© Sy) OB fray i i, iG a i 43 ee & w ved aa ed A "4 mt Gy art ., a : 4 , we as "3S a fo 4 oe val * eet Fa pie Reef dB v a foo $4 a go ort ty 3 ; ih ory ee tg seed oa 4B ts Oy when pee ses Go hee ta oft ra os hy : 8 fg bs ey oop Go ® 43 i hob td u te 'a i ' ep © Ly EH xd "4 78D oa Gos oe gy o 8) ee Oo ow f Bo % Te reef Sty as LE 4} re) a we a hea o ' ah ne oa 'Ca Z, ' 0 ee ea A AS Sa PB oe #38 ue : # ta ot 6 a CMO AER Ba w eh te @ S e ' "
aN op oe Ba S be w w SOB : a rot ted » 6 o oo Sea reg si oy : a Oy By ip G wl Ea : O a a @ "et iE Q a 4 "ed co be : 3 oe) i Shes en ed 2 ot Q ats we ¢ im Ch rt is . hed O Be $8 to het a w ' 0g * ms ay 0D BB " iy Ba aD ry © sy oh "
un Osh vet y An fea kt ip or wh uy + ta ¥ o Sr I a io Ww is) oF 00 Us et EN} ent o vet Peet aa Q afck a they co Q Qo e181 ened Uy Sy C "EE i By as a ES @ wh & € bd 2) G 2. oh a fea @ ©.
nt eh 5 a os oe Bd g « . a " @ Bo i oe cl w ~ mw : m coed cd Seg C3 pt ty £3 ¢ "A eer ae a 3 © 8 e Ce : vs 6 m4 BO Be 8 ie i é i oe ' so a bi 3 i he a 3 t 3 4 hs a 2 ie a in is Eos Ae oe ed y va ih " ¢ EB o 8B sh 4 f '| a - pe j oe L. * 3 mt s wy ps o fers ie 4 Oo tht at i G i AS co S 4 ws e 2% ie) ea 2 ao 7% ; is a e ed Gs o > "@ Q * a 5 4 a "s 3 ' Bae Bs "4 DY aE Ca bi 83 oO D " aa ; 3 @ na : a £2 w 4: RS we Se 5 é Oo % TS ea Va x t sie aa , S ee a Gene ee . eo my 3 = ri "4 i we re) . a oA a ry uy @ 5 iy i woes MA 6 (IS 2 2 5 ; a ray a eZ & 1 o qs Cal i Fa B ea Bo het set i 22 core o ay a 4 Co A 7h cy A is " cs i és fe iB "a Bs i Q ae: Oo ad : atts is Sed o C B M xs DD a oO A 43 « 3 3 8 oe ted cy $4 in = a ot Ds ay 2 Pd Moy rl as no ue & ? £3 > oe fo ik pee a 3 3 £3 M E is, > re Hog 8 wo & 8 e Ho Ge eo oO 2 fi iB © Bee Beet C3 Yad a fa Ct ved es ry oo . ted fy ; ie 3 4 5 = ae wes is we " iM E 42 iy * 4 i) Oo vi 5 j G pb Mo ® es a 3 a ne te ne i a se 9 C EA ty as 8 ¢ i x 4S c O w i $3 Sey RARE os at De a ' i = zr * af BA) @ bed Bo ee ea " a we pe pe os " 3 gas oe a iG ies ss G wv aS he a Cg B o> o ih ed @ eS th Q re ch in Col a So CG c ct Cha 4 - C2 Ss o
1) " o uw w : io By 3 zed oh La ive yb ar 3 ' KN vy ica) i 4h iva) Ley Soon :
Bo im " % gp o a ved qr ie a) cr us Osh ey © $4 3) ea cea z nes ex ya ged
0) Yh.
god eed ef Sek At o %) w ced seed:
bet ALY , 44 Boto ak ' £3 £4 ee = Re.
eonerxtcd * Fixed & oes 'ad.
ahh ME AS} aa.
foes 0:
Oo oy pa ati Se aye u rer KS aed fe 4 rep Ae fe is Ne vee fon i Wy s ay Ing. te we 5 3 w 4 he on Se @ me aot gs be Br BS td 2 ae s ce 3 ref aS ya > Gg 42 "pd > ac 3 Fs eS ci % ony he " ; ne ' =r4 se a4 soy ae By ter} ae te Be : wade art = Bona Bo AB cae gp ee Be ie v be os Poh, a Ne th eo Oy See ae ayy eaed ony need * od ahs a ae < 3 ot 4 'S rl gered ' . ' Fes #35 SEES ao is 47 3 gerd 2 ay as o ie fe Sind i . : ort % ae a3 £Y ie ee A : . os Boe sug a w Ww or 8 ty Be v a i i u ws poco & es = od set Bee vest dy ae) {) 8 GB oy io eet : ud ae
4 oo oe 8 & Fh ted ae y a 2 oS XG ot cd tod 6 & . 3 a ca] ig . te w a % oO i @ a 44 yg ne : : z
1) red oy ; ; " 4 45 5 g th) :
bey i g o oh io "
tC 2 cd a4 ~~ ud obee er' ts Cx a a @ 5 on : : (ey E iss 4 Ye] 7 Sy i : Q 5, wed c SS 4 " ft me a eo oer. Ay e 8 € ~ wy Bs $s BI C o oh ee a z as fai te ; 43 a i i Es) oy ra Fe =: § oc Se fect 4 4 ° 5. & Ter 5 4 itt eet ip B3 eee 4 ae bed xe wt Be . +35 be ord ae ch a o13 cn At bes eo) 6 a <3 LB fe be a iB t ant a ved : ¥ ay '2 wt ca Digg Bo a a m " > % o os is, 5 : yj o af ths pa % oho oO f 4 a 4 na aan 4) ed 3 * me } 3} wf id Qo B a 8 m ms &ef % i a) my ved At 6 43 a ee) ; = at eo at 3 3 mf i ee re BoB gC a ng my a a 1 83 fs a ;
sed eG eh a ts) " v "T i: rn se ak oo wn aa nd os cd 4 a ta ms es Ry 2 ed ped a a ca "dt 0 to 1 ui i i im "43 £2 fa @ " Q C ht mc 2 ¥ ed 4S ee o nD a Bed "3 G fa B By UD Ma eg oy ms a tt o.
Got apd Ch wh sao Ad iG o g is i a At pat eS sy SS e +3 w £3 a vend $+ #4 a a) AG yy iB ap : a a "rl + a ce i is! 2 q) A 44 @ 4 Ash iy aS g et a 44 3 & 4 i - % sd 3 th #4 i : a S ; ie a % 5 &> my ; " : a "et good @ es = at kK Cy bs a ot 3 o z So ee ng i it ee, . te St Gm Wo 8 a bad og Be 42 Q & = ct Se ae ay oo) a Me ot pa aes Oy ys Fe BE os $ 4a ae ei reef ged ? 2 ere as @ £3 9} oe
a) ee G Ooo ay or ay o % Q c oO re * 3 B OQ ven ay} ae a 3. 3 - chee ra 4a oe : - ie ee oe eh % i ced 3 - 4 m - : AG '3 a4, oi re) xt ; a a bs a eed + oe pa EE gt fe4 sh $3 Be 2 4 e a & da ek a s us Ces fa wD i wf re 3 2 Be i oe "A sO SG ced ; a a Be: 53 : 3 : x at 83 4 es uy is a * Oo cs G & + B iF os OQ 6 4. @ e 8 ow G my Og po bes bs a be os 7 i} ay 1G 3a ee a me e orl Ba sea uy ks D tp 2 es o rch cp € - uy io & @ @ B 3 Fea & Rn ks ed , % 0 5 < woos ey @ ct re ts] oO "eS % ¥ vy > a 1 ® UO G6 8 f 6 A om ~ wp & Uo Bs CO 3 pas a3 rag " * 4: Q rt a ; cet ey i % ; Q YD aie « oS aa :
mf Boog Cc ee ow Or go a + 1 . vo ® ; So 9p m™ G Wow eS "a 8 a Le Lied \ 4 ¥ Be oy bet 2 ioe €3 ae : hed io ie m 4 * ert G Be > ifs e?. een orf @ ig : 4 ; ' { 4 1 2 ol " © : BA es bel ba in a i ce
2 s : Me ra 42 g 43 re aD 5 a a be a 9 ret va 5 ih 43. ag ay Spt 4 ed es: a ct Dp be as 6 «i 3 ¢ ad 33 : Sx o o u re 3 44 ; wed 6 C3 eh $4 a u ae wa i iB ae et a i " wa ws s 1S. uy QO ne AG @ $3 fos co % Poe ae ee Q° 2 8 Be ' + > £ Ae", © 8 & 2 3 Bw Bhs 8 ® ha Be 6 2 8 & a 0 oO a 3 t ( oD o ee : z c f UF £4 "a ty poe: rest ms 2 ft. of tf oy ns "i : ae 4 Cy 3 rt 3 oe 5 "4 4G « cy S a fe Gg & : c rot 1s w Wet 2 Go ee 4 4 Q Par ced nd $4 © Bo Mes at pes . o hea M5 ig ey O 42 i % £3 oe @ fs eet goo RR mo gD 3 2. 8 © ii A Ge Be © : wi ES @ a ed ur @ ie a a) re) a) By g owe i As a oa Q ay "cd :
ec os es $4 na cd =: G i my 3 a 4c vert 3 $i 64 ved 3 Co
8) 43 a aed 3 uw 3 wy its wh wt :
ae 4 ued a ae 43 2 is y a3 o iS « wu Be ee ty Oy % 44 eg Se oO Ca Me is x ne} = : a) oy ® th bro 4 6 tS a 2 eG es a o i fa Q A y te a O 44 G oy fe a - be nt is5) 44 a ca i a AS a: fe + Gt ad foes cB) a3 "4 8 a a Q a "3 py a ee eM it at 3 Ee xy ae io vod ot fA Gh oek & wv uy : 2 a ob "7 Sos oe be
- t ot am) cy ee 3 fed ot i £24 SS : . a apd uF [er iw ke OG # S 2 ¢ . ihe a OF x XS ca b : 1 y ct ¢ 8 os og Bg vf 1 y © & a wo Q) 'e 4 Ms 3 3 6 Su bs 43 ia gt ned a a wo fo cd cag ot cory Pah 1 ie ied "
+ * v L r :
eal so de . C w 1 Wy S ged be ei ' ved a @ ® me cs Ee) a es ved y re ay no ™ - BS a i vert i uy 5 13 a Bo, i ob TPs ge re ve @ vs 0 ee a M4 as
- 43 a 4 ae 5 aa co oy # i G 13 Oo rs 5 ee a rh ba es od i is i i e wd . wf w 4 f ; : ' tee a e p a ? A we s Go . in ms a ' QB i ved A 4 - bea a G a " BP Fos a i oS i os 2D 3 ies Ch: Ca es bed. +4 co o - thd. 2;
a OG og ine og ' Bi a Oy a Gg 1 + : o. , c 5 43 ot m : "sy co As me j c3 @ G " : te 4 "ed - Sef ne 13 * 2 2 ip is Qo ey Gog oe yO OM e o o Dy 4 thy vat hey f 3 ops a5 i 2 A o a Bo g § Bog : > 3 :
py ods oy . Q . ; i "a ot 4 oS oS g oA @ ie ca 46 red 1 1 4 gt 4 a Hy od a its Aah By tr 32 io . oes v4 wh sed 4 an Oy 8 3 ee & % Oe ow Geo Fs ibe 0 4 = - a o 4A i © im 5 :
& so ce ane m oo (e & at TS mm a 3 isi ce "C4 Gy m4 oad vyd Ps t & 3 int a 07 a ord 5) 43 CS. 43 ay oe cps rs vee 2 is od thee ard ab & '3 wed ed q pe ' At vy & Ci 43 4d ro i be 43 fe % Oy w oes "t% rt Us) M4 2s vert a ced @ ss @ oy & th, ' 43 a $
a) wy Ae ao i) Sep OY er $24 het wise AE ved coef se ay B tf a Ba tht ti 4 sg fo ns a aa a3) en Zz £ fs Cn Re a © 2 x o ce Oe w « ob ro) 43 oy 63 ae eed ig "ct i ard AE wu $1 he Ae "et $2 oS 9 ae an a B we aD a a 4 4 a a Se Lye es ce ¢ ae yy ot wg ny #) z Ck 5 oe o : 5 © Sy er e =, L 4 . . ye i ; os a ew e6 op fet u ved a oo 13 gy n they ; tet : at en m8 BO 3 BE * re i oy o a p &G G oka ® a ie o i rt val a "13 iy re CS ® oO a 2 : : fp A } o tes ¢ i oe be rg re oh peo 12 B Ce Pos Bg -- be . ee +e i ie " ~ m2 Feo 43 @ @ o & os Chi Se Sek ss a Op if wed '2 w i ine 3 Rule s 3 A Ci 3 i i * oo. £3 g Bop ge Sg 2 8 E . a Hoe is sree ; yp : cs 3 % Oo a ee Ww oe e ic ¥ : ss "4 3 ag u 4 f os, : : : oe "4 3 Fr i : 4 4 RB gy @ 6 8 Sf Ag & a & ® < x 3) rk a a cs < : tthe ceed Cy fe 3 be a5 a ww i . on oa oe 2S o Ss 6B wo GG 9 ' ho oye ct 8) ae A Oy ei be > : 2 "et Be eS G w bd Ss 4 o re : 4 oo BO ae eG yw oe D A pes aw "3 de Ee B es oo eB Be, Ooo ue uf he 8 a & wee Cy, ro$ i mn 7 ' a '6 « oe fs a io 5 5 8 ow FE Se a c 2 é ee 2a se 4 8 ws % S a i B oly ae u be oe Bog o iG Be gy @ a4 uy G me 5 f D a ont Cy ie 43 a3 Y PI a : : : ay) \e ek £3, 44 tet e xo t nt im ea rt ot STN aw & A ae rh 3 iy fer 3 ie ;
hh 5 r s re ee G6 ee OS ey AD, ie 0 ie MH ya 2 y 4 a % dl : ad ee HA Bg eR ge a oS us @ Gf te ge ee ees uy a "4 ee tos Oo. Po 0 @ & oe 4 oe si 44 : i of a is Q ay a - pe ro: wy 34 "Eh Ae cn C3 ®D Ky oh A 9 us a: ¢ ena ¥ y BoE : Alo Go @ Ooo oe oo Be 44 '2 ist 4 ei G ard % iw ee es td ao tS o 1 Ha ee a ty BO up te 5 e ot ocd A sed p wr CH] Ch Tt fg es) reef Ch N ie s Sa oy @ AS o g m) ed if a ' Ard ob A 5% , 4a 44 be an fet eh a . So Se os be vod ip 6 O: O en %3 St Sea ba G i et he thd 4 iy 6
i) eat £3 ty isd 4 q aka fa fy Ane iB Ch ies od be wy wv a Oy ee es ray + shea ES: Ee] ca a 2 Q G oa ig ved 4 & SE £3 peed wy bb ao ty ae ahve SE £ oy neck me Y ae 4: Ls Pe Mg ed © thy B : % & Q, : o G ma epg a Bu 4 art eC :
& : ut sed = ee if oe ms ey) af fe ph he "
CH thy £ . a Cc as bet iG AGE Aa 'D GF leg me 57 Hy 2 2 4a ° 3 hed 4 H G2 wa G 7 oe een 3 : 4 "4 b £ ta a 2 a e e os :
44 : 3 oe Be oe ey ' 4 we oa Ly $3 hehe ie vee : 4 = ak Ss E yok 4 o a te € te Hes oe eta ok 4 be C3 = ee i e o i 2 : -
M1 a . is fa} o us fe be a 2 4 v i 4a 0) eek e i bs a me wa rs) 43 a ae os x i a iy ed eh SE S . oF o " 2 a 3 2 Bs wi Ay 's 6 & D a. 2 oF & .
1g 4 : tet oe at us : cs cee th : 7 ae oe M a 3 @ i ; te td % 2 & o ie ay o it 4 Ths Ly C2 cc "
od 4 es ee t By > abel 5 ped Cs ye re a * tha : © y * od 63 ;
"ea ceed ig o G os {3 O % S ty os fi cl bs % "4 4 GS 3 i ey a3 ou ee v a ee At a 4 ; ¢ V4 os : " " : a v & So Gy Qo " 3 Ms Ak Q x th oo ba B 8 a w Ye nos Q nee oS ce 8 © + <3 bef. i i Ly a oa fe n rd Boe @ Sw es eo ba 3 ts 2 sid G a th, a ot fa et an ee $4 4 2g Q & Ret iy o "4 . £5 4 3 * -- a ea oes ed a % fe od aoe ms me 3B 43 Sa "a a na ive c $5 3 Uy i a te + mies ae ae ons > id £ + ns pe ® a 4 BS i s 5 cF re gr 2 4 (bea we abe 4 od m4 4 5 S soit 4 pe 3 gs i a eo oe @ 8 & es o 6 . peal : oe 5 Be @ a tee i} ty oh is eee neo s. a5 eae i' ; oe 34 a i 44 Ss Oy re 3 ey yoteshende:
ao ce ks! a . eB eg ee uv C og i bed a ct c 2 Lo oe $563 ag *. a set < 4d ra ved a 73 Gy 4A 3 ort a os werd '7 tt CF wy aS > { 2 crt wg 1 be CA i fe +? 33 Ry @ fa + = ot gt { ® a a 3, { 15, ie Ee C iG Bh gy C | ie ~ wad ey Ch, Qi ard 4 ra bad Ogee Go Pe oe
a) 44 y " oO; @ _ 2 * Ne =
-
0. Fy a a yy fy OB gS oe) t oP te > ry é 5 ith ce ene @ te G) " ts Bai 45 MM o a & 5 e o ry - Sys 2 fs ec he Re DS ye a a8 4 tn & i . a o £05 ed ret : G: :
os ih Beg Bo ky ae » pt od ce % C G GQ 'B a Fi La$ 3 2 a oF a oY oO, At sf f Sa a ay £4 (Hacvinder Kaur Oberoi) hos o oad a : 3 i a 4 te o : ce a ant ee #35 ty ae i bed a oes ou cd 7" 7 we 44 aa a ps ct moe Go Goh nts ' ES 7 a 43 oO o <3) a G 6 4 Ly S ie 3 2 ¥ 3 Sef Co a4 BG & BE 43 age ae we oC age s '. : 4 ae Boe Bas yo B® Soop aS Te oh oR veel Be Be Os te ca os : 8 a Pa a it * = te:
Goo ni ei 2) 43 e o a * 6 cs sf * oe * 2 : bg '. i 1 3 % @ i % a "4 i 4 rt st o weet oe; yt ra ~ we LS 'hed * ont to 63 he aot .
cob 7 ee iG 44 G a in ot ey a x o a 6 im © Ok we BB o ee!) of rs in G sa Ga var cot * ed ty 5 ot ad 4 a i 7 a H Soe : Bt epee vd A a a wp 14 3 We o : oS os ig 2 oo od iy - ® 4 git ted sens 3 we * i : ios a3 Za) G @ Ch et ry 5 3 3 i teed Go CG 2 @ ot Un Q & ve qa A he Q 13 . ef & to wh ib, @ p ' bt q pa eA . "ef ie D a =) See vA at oh a5 G 04 os ib "nf i 43 ta st 3 "% Ps,