Karnataka High Court
M/S Acc Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 October, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
123% TEE HEGH saga? GE' mmfarfim gr Emaggfiag
Ef}2=2I:;-sci Ems; iiqe 3:3"? $33,? ea? (}e:':£:<i;7:;»{;%:; Qél} « 5 _»__ '
E?}E€E§SE%ZN'£"
THE EEQISPBLE MR. ;§Us*:f:e=:;fE1%s?
ANS
TEE E£GN'BLE MIL ms§*'§:*:§f§
Wzfi Aggyseai .1"\§:>&2; €;§.,z§f~i{?G8 €'F~E{S'T'
{E §€'"f°W£*§ {EN :
5*:£f;'<Tfi i:z.:.L, V' V. -.
{}G?;;'§5 €;"}:'s;:m,::':::£ E*"3;:";<}2" ._
'°'"§.'he §3ssE.za::'é'§_ * V
Nssfi "E 2 E. 9_ E,§§<:E.:'€:'1Vs=§{'>:2§%{>s::§:;;§
E3z2.§.:;§g§§:"£{jr<': ~ 56$ $42
' V' Egg}-A.L,_E§;,.? :§;1'%§-%;:s%;.:.'E.§ M21§'iEi¥§§€?§" z'%{:<%<:uz'1%::<?,e
.§'v'£':3
_S:;a1:*a?:;:i 7%-'é3::3;1*:'::,E": Eizfii
r R k/ 3E"§.'§:=:§:§'$' ..,,E§§}§}€:%§§2':*.I'.?;E'1
f_ §.§f".%§; 8?: 5% §%z~:1':'::1 $32. if} §fi?§':§{i'i§.€S%§§.g
.»'-'z::§'2:*<::t:.;=:'£::%5s}
.4.__'w.g§~s:}:
E. V " f:%§"2':%i:€> if}?§{23é'§"'1'1.;E.3'§.2}§{§E
V ~'§§Z€;E§}E7€i§%{fZ'§'£.aE?{1 '::-:3; 22:3; §?iz'":;a'::':<.i°£3 $f.*€.?;E'€fE.2':.f'f;'
'a,?£:iE':;aI'12-T: ${_E§.3.rZiE12i;
E}§2;zn;;,,§22.E:>::"a-2 W 5638 85}:
Ex?)
"figs? {.1 {.}Vt°?I"§":§I'1fi?3'"1E €22" §{21§"'z':zf:i:'a§<;;:
§{6;}:*:%s»§e';%:':';t%{§ E3}; ifs: 'E'-'*'i11;'~:;'":<1:é;*.*. §'}€3'*.£f§'€§Ei2-iE'}-"
'Jé.:§:}a:'2;2 5S{§u.s:§ ig 21
E3ar1ggzr:E{3:*e «~ 585} 66%
3 'E.'h{:é Efi}<":§mi.j'y* C1E,'}§'1'1E'§E}§S%f%ZéEGEEQQ" <3?
C<>m2:':ét1fCiE:ETaxszs T '
{R£:€rs}s:€?r};'} -- E E
331? 1'1iva'x$a Ca;m§:)1r:~.x
Ses:2hz:<ir§pu:°2i::'1 . L
EE§21;1.;_§2iE<>':"<3 -~ 5&0 {E:§€;~.. ' ~ '*...,,E{r;%:§p<3':";::3;:~s~{":E5§
{By 8;? 8h_i§;é:_3;.{;g;'§s;:,a§;m"i§;'v.V E-i§{*ij§;_'-.'r'_E*§
"E'E1e:*$s: --V.?;?'£§~.i :1'; 5-'x§.:>;3§e';?.§Ts%§'vL.' §31éT:i :1a:i<=::" iS€.',{.'§..§.{i>I§"2 4 Q5 é".E';€
K21;"z'1;1i'.;:2{2.:"[§ E3; 3;. Ca'; 'E; A{:%_» E§2;*'2:},"§:€g";"€.«:} Si'? zissiaie {hat <>;°z:,§er _p8.f:§E-§§{;?{§
:2': me 'i,?g"§ii'._E??:éi§':.:;f}:'fz..E4113,§.'3?@3 «:.>.{ i_E:€}{}8 {§€;FZ.{;'.€i "E E~€}8~2{}G8°
'fE'§§z£:*f:>:.§*: "Jia£:'§i'.=.53;p';<3i<:«i, §f"'«--__<§{:§éé_i2':§;g GEE §'E::;* ;1{EmE5,~:.Si§):':: ?i,11é.<:a {E35-;.,
2% £{"Z}'§§v§A.R J}, {.%:é1iv$=_:':%::¥_ mi?'-~§E)EE{;>W§:":g§j:
.....
. V'":i'%f;_l{4:»- "?:':e5<§s:;.<v3:--;§a::<-E Ezziaa §::'€§'%:?§°:°£?e::§ '%§":;§:'a: 2.:;§.>pé:22_§ <7§:22z§§{%:éggi:':g éiiizr:-% €}§'{§¢?_§' 3321:, _ §§"§1:"?E §6::::'m3::E $§.:"z.§__;§Eaf a-_§'s.:{'§;;{é3; {3§E5f'1E§fi'é§f~;;§E'E§_:: :32? '%::"i.%;
"..§§€:'é:i1§.i{>:'i_{>"%=g 'a,E'fz:E §§;2*<>u:'::§ '£:E'2;2':"€. !:.ET:.e:% EE§."}§}§?§§;§%E"§§. §:%:?s,s§ E-.§§§'.é':;*.E"§'}.€?;E.§'v'é'.' 22:33 N 5:-:
{E £3 'T§"2%3 {:;m~r5:«;§'.§{3;z :'2:i::;s:?::E in aha §:>::';*E,'i~'é:§.<2:i'f§Z '' §i.;::.§.3:'é:¥é''.:; :3? ihéjff 2;:s;&:{%§;:am% 1.9 332:3; E2--2::< in §}i,§§'5§1L.§€5;.I'\§§:9€'€35 E}E§§¥;fi'f:{§§I.1é;f':."f.§: '~';i?§}i(T'§"§ 1 322:5; g:§;iw:~:1 §":%£.;*<>s,;p::=:::§ivé;=. affibctig Tin'? {§.:1{1i=«§'e'§:;'.'é'is}';s..wz:.>e;«?:3j€§'$§as.1r§:§: :'§%E'4:"€}&%s§:~£%{:E3£"-56 <};3::=.':r'a:%.i:};';, 131:? a":;.<5;;*=;c=;s:a::<*::';=:"*é.a»-*:4:':e:_ ma? Ei.a§;;':}§é%' {:3 g*:4;23l-®1.2:;;L §:::.°§{3:' 1:3 a:'*;':en{.%:£:}=:%;<";.E; <::<3i.:§e:i be E'é.§'s;.*;é%':';€{§. '«.}.:§é';T:3_ €EI§*;v%V.=E'ia§3;§i:Z"E}g' :9 pay 3: 11:1: §}:£f%1, 'i:E':e»._$:::i_€E '._q::;;;:::::i'€:v3j:'23;" <::>;'1&;ie:§@:"e{i by 2-'; r I §}§V'E$i:}:'} E:§€§1<:.h e:3§'i.'g.E";iée; €T;3§2z,.:;:':{._§1:i:. "=;7%.~..;;7N€:-;'24«'.E'~?;"C? dispasstzéd (3.? an 2?"-3 ;'~"«,Mjg?:z'1:'E ..._<;;€-- §'\;r§;'s; ¥'"s;:shn:s inszizizz FVL Lizi, E-".s:';, S';,a1i.<t <}§"%'"é p-grate: 1.1 §:'he";.;»' Ezaiwfi s5i.ai.€:i :m.{§€-1":_ L . _ V. ._ LV 4;: §':Ts:r€;;*;;:;3rg:i'§§:;: £33" {Em s;a.§d {m'z5-mciecé ;3@r§2'(;:2 5;!' VS§.§13{%¥-4s;é{;*§j'{)§'§ Ss5zis>z'3 {'8} smzx-2; :':.<;i.§',fE'.e>{§. {"0 51313 " E33; is'=;:4:in§; §"f'za% 2";r;:»£§;"§.£§:z':':«:}r'a §.?'2'§§)Z,.£§§§'E€3{§ in «H "-.+1s':?':%;¢% ' %;Li'>L;<f§VA';=g}é§:'§z,'i<3;'s. 1?.'§'2.a* A;3';2a?§§€m§, a.i§a5:§m* {?{i?'E 2*'2z:}§. €f.'{}??"'Vi:f.éf§"'"f.:°f;::',?.; si§z.:::zi 55:5: {:;rirsa3:z.5£s2%{ii ;3r:>:.::5é.<::'2.$ 3:3?" :s:2.§Es~.%;m§.ia;:z S<éc7§'.:'.zm 515%} 53;" {.?S'§" fiéfé" is 229:; :,;§2g*;E£:i*{;§sE.¢% :52 £3. ~..g:_r'2{§ i"f':é¢:*e§_,fi;<;:'a% §§'2:;a> §.§'3'Z_§f}§i§;?'E.&f{§ i'3<:§"§§E{z::£i:2I'2 =:§da:E:Tr'2§; {.-um! /"' {2{§.€§i.Ei(}z':{;:E {fTi}§"i.€i§f'§.{}fE.55 are bzzzi 21?: 55221:. ''}''f:@ {}mi'"z.:. Szzées "E'w: c:<em;:3iz':>:':; in j§f§,:,F{}i»i3" «:.3,f" {fie {f3«:;z3:§3{mg; 5.5:: 52 %3@z'2eg_f'z"§'; '§'!':e;ra-;;&>s"5?. §'}'z.a,* $<:z.ms:>:. ' be {:E{1z"r"z%€i'§ {:5 5:. r22m.E.:3r as" :15/;§':.:':; 'f'E':::% :z;':'z_;::jz§i.;-:::;a§2§i '£:§'_ my g:2m::€.§;fz'Gs'zs (Eff Ss;.>cI.:'z'm 85:33-' ';:3«?T€}S_}§?é'{?§_7?if'}%:3'":;f7}"*T}Vf'??~ V.' E §;":'.'§;"2{}ei?2. z»'§f§:€r {"379 {2fi'2:"5rr"::2'*:j?"z;:32'::§_'2'Eat? Si-3.<_:?€:)::7i the recgz,:€rez':':s~,>r:z, 53;" 5.13:? <;w:;;'2{§.:i€£<';z'f:V$s*._vz:':.'<:; €a.z':f€»'c§;'-rgazifgz. fr: s:.zb--s:=3c:i022; {4} Qf Seczizyg-2 8.;;j{'f?§?2,6 Cg'--TE"fA':??: I??fl§'$€f€2ZGFi§f,;AfE£§}'?E§.£:f{f 22;; 5.}:.¢a----s?:§;<;r?\=§1@s;3:.a ii: 33*».-Q3 :'mE:>r1':::'.i.e.é:i i,I'§:;1§ é;.i:'€: 's:;1.i{§-- L_:}:f':fi%:::* E:2é;s;,2z':;€,;1%z2a%d §1?:";2:.EiE,y. in E.E1:z*2'E' *;:i€:vJ ef i':§':e m;2i;1;};.':%;1 §:'€}V§'(}'%'.7}g:}"3§_E§ i':§fiV@.'éiibé-§.°€f§§§€i€i W'§:::ig;3;:E1€:m"§., éE':€:s~;-:11. wréi aapgészfiés :§§°é* §i§S{Zi"3.§iE:3.';"E§':iEi§:%*3€§. .