M K Gopal vs Life Insurance Corporation Of India on 12 June, 2009

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M K Gopal vs Life Insurance Corporation Of India on 12 June, 2009

1:4 TEE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAEZA AT B5XI«§§f3Vs§gE.;_§;}~R.£{ DATED THIS THE 123." EAY (>1? ;:;;:q::%%2é§a%?é'{ ' ~ Bﬁmgag ' THE-P3,. }+E€.'}€:~VB§_¢.E-. MR. 3:;s':§C§: W249 BY}?;A;?;»§:i)Ei§'2*.:Av':":. R}EG1}§_,AR ms': A?PEA§'#V:No;23V5 9:4' 2<§::'s:

BETWEEN: L 'L % M,K.G<_apz;:§ V H Aged 65 yeam? { - _ -

Sin Iaic M,§_.,.KJ£s§i'é.~:1a l'yiis:{l%};;V' "

No.48, 53"' LE€§_Cu1_g:}§;_V ' » HI Bios}: Ea3L'i..¥e2§{ana;.;ar, ._ Baﬁga "rev <,5'§% om APPELLANT (By Shri. "7¥%«:3ga Advm:-ate) Wm;

' .Lii?: igtsagféénge Corpuraiiuzz uﬁyieiia, B}*..i1:";.'Chairr::az:, .*s~».T . "'~Ys:g'a§%;';:~h€§::ia:' "-«.,§ee*g'»a:: .E¥~§;:::a Mazrg, ?%.?'E.um§3ai§ ?vTa}1ara:~';¥%tra Siam 'ﬁenai Manager;

' {Life Insamnee Corparatiga 3f Iadia, S:':i1ﬁ1 Ceﬁtra¥ §",:'3r:ej Hyticmbad ~-- 5&3 463

3. The Sr::n§ur Divisiunai §'«:i:magr::r,, 2 Fa} LIC ef India, N.R.Squar$, }.C-Raad, ﬁangaium W 5&0 cm "

(B3: Shri. S.EvE.Gaj-xneimn, A&w.,n.:aitr"iiﬁf'i?¢3puz;ai;§ﬁi:<_3€o;'3;V«' ié'; Respemicnt No.3") #$;$¢ This Raguiar Firs! Appcai '"iis,_fi§::L§' unﬁiar 'S<;:-:§Eior};_ §é Read with erder 41 R1 of Code of Civii. Ffixiedure, £§'-'L13, again$t' the judgement and L§t:I'.31'€".;_£'.'.:"'~,_ d2_éicd }._é3..,1'i--,:Z0{}0 passztsd in ().S.N:;>.30§0f93 on the ﬁle" Off ii2¢f':;§§XIV.t Adé%§:i:3na1 City Civéi Judge, Bangaitazwz Ciry, [Fitz ft): deeiamiien;

damages. A ' ' 'V ' This 512::-f1_:t:VI?;;t1*'"3'.§§r$i;:..,,e'5'¥3§;€1ai"'._:iw,x%ing been heard and reserved an (}2Li}6';2*(20f? anéugaaiing :j.=;3n 1132:' yronwncemeni sgxf }udgm;:"ri{"iE:'is.V§3ay, C::¢;:*i <ieEix;%:;~:rv:£i Eh: fs_:i§¢.:wing:.. Ejigarrj the C;'m3s3.:«:s:§ far 1316 pariésg, V' ':Zf '»-7f§1v.%MV;:;:;ff§.§r.:s art: r£:{'t:rmd R: by ihczir ragzi'. §{:§f!I"€: Q22: izéai ciszzgjt.

'Th: facis, as staicé in Sm gyiaini. an-:, £215; ihc p§ain§if§ " _ ' 'A.s;éar;..appointcd as an Aaséamﬁi in the 9:13;: sf E239 Scams

-~-}}ivis§9na§ Manager, Life: insurance C-grygraiiun usf imfia, Z Bangakrrtz (fzarazinaﬁa-:r r::;§t:rrr.:£§ Eu as 'EEC' fur §3i'*;".,'"'éi!j;?".:}x.' r is a siaiuiory Cc-rpuraiiun izicorpuraicd ::mi_ér.'1§3;é,€' "Egg; Insurem-:3: Ccxrpmaliun ui' India Am'[,I.93f:3« {:i'1':c.f:°i.:i;:;:1}:i«:2"_ rcikrrsé to as the 'LEC Ac-Q' for bm;zii_}:}_ figs p§a iI1'i§ﬁ"' x%hg.< i*aa.$'--..

appoizzicd in the year 3956 §3;;3§;'<§;L>pmenE Ofﬂcer in September ilgai £3-&£(§¥£:: in Nmzembtzr l96:6,.._Ht*: 1"a::2::;e.V,=$é;'&_I:1::»*:<.i."§§:Aaf& {)ff§e.;m from M365 £9 E??? ht: sagas lrcxalsfassrrasd Eu Tumsuzr,' Ii' _i:§ _s.£a§§:£§ mmunczaiimz sf i}:;:x 'c§a>p:m":z2£ €)f§c$r§ in £.%2t* i.;i€'I 95:15 reguiaied by 3. :~;c::§s.:s mi" ggrccmcgis A '%v;{we€iL1A«§,IC».._a;r:£.i £222: Naiiunai Fccicmraiéaxz 9? insuranct: Ficiﬁ " ._§%f'¢,}:*§aié§'.éV"_a>f ifzgciita. Gnu such News Agrccmcni Ezcid ii}: ﬁeizi. when i! rams un§§:«,:%5miiy r$p§a;:§c§ 533 2.:

A'C§cr§a:.-rzzzzzcni Order ilﬁitjwcii up by 2123 amsmiﬁzeni Eu éfms Life Vgirzsur-a.m:»:: Curpzuratiuzx :31' Exzdia {S£a.§C§) Rcguiaiigng, l'§3é:'li,(§1t:rci:3afi::r rcfarrmi :9 an; iht: 'ﬁiaﬁf Rv:gu§aiiz§=:z>;"} by 3";

xrirlzse uf which, ihc rtsmuncraiion ;:rf3§)c:xie§L3p322cn§; €',.)§.§s;..'§:-"1r'«:~.-:_ was mwasumd in {suns of the Suimduie Firs: Year F2"t:A;i:i:~z7::z:z;1VVEz1'é:i;rgi1*tz: ' éesriveé from p<3§§:;}r»§1{;!ders? whisﬁ: armaéztd 2: i_:;»:ri;>£i:;:.i4m§f2éz§£s:.z3£Ea:

it: ihc: pay pauiwi and crzkaiiczd 3.ﬁI'II:"i§VI1E£:§~i_{.¥.I} iI1 i--§I£:"»€:vici§§§ '§}i£i~_ pcrfonnancc 0i' 3 Bﬁxfﬁiﬁplﬂﬁﬂ1"-._§§ﬁC-ti!" xs.r-hifh :i%saS1.b1néasurcé aitsu in {arms :33: ifw é;t}=::V_umt:.V'k3£:'£¥§:-:{E); x>v2-ggrlzf grawzzmium amuunis paid by {he pa:1it:y'[-'t;_e§#ité§"a§, §&i§"'7§3§x}{;§£;§i.r par. rfheazzgg {hem wars 2: _L -3.51' uzi:se3ic§iaiEéi2r!'i;€§;;V véhé sen-*i§.:=a cenaiiéium, w§2§a:h xwrci:;r%i:_£r;;zé§§;"imgrséic-;§i§'2mﬁ'gE {gut Emiéa, ii}: ii§ig:».:i3§e,3zz was :sn.S--uc£:r::~:sf-.1iVi§':%:,a;il=;trV ;éS[..£§i::__empieya:::st were cmrzcamrs §. 'Tizt; §2§;;:§:ii§.£fi+Lén his iyansikr ii} ﬁle: Tzmgiaur Emma:-E1 fﬁiiica $35, i;.'Z}'1A§§I§.§'t§i£§:§G£§ {ht-.: Meier L3? Emnsfsr by wet}: ﬁfe: civii :.~;u§§ in an the iboiéng iiéai {Em giainéiff was rm:

gzmxfiécé' wiih Eire rcqtzisiic agcmsy iiizgmr: and iﬂciécnéai gzzrvict: {hereby pausing 3 gz"2n»*e si§tz2:£§::2n :2? Q1: pizcziuéff {mi Ewing aigic £0 geszmzraic azxy busizmgs at aii, in wivgieil evené, ha: zwuieﬁ fact: :4. uui iz: his rzzxzzaizzemiigsrz zmé aarwtzéki Ekcs éize régig cef 6 ianuiuaiiun. An inictrittc-zxk:-ry Quiet uf i*.:z2:§2urar§_: iz:jm1e,:i§un was granlxztd ix} his iiwuur. Huﬁwczécr, ﬁzz: suii was u§£ima£$§'}; zﬁiszxésseci and g rczgtzizir appcai §§§r::§ 2:i§_3,E£iﬂSi 23321:: same was gigs.» dismissed. firm plaintiff wazz ezarmpcéisé 5:0 ilsgzssiiaarz i:2}':.§.a:F~,.ii"~,$"a!€:}3"§ aciverse s:-emziiiéorns. And {he mnscqacncc es? i§;c.A"{m:z:;§§1;:zf:"' ~ eziaiﬁctei the ptzrﬁsnnanmz apgraisai pez"i:';§d.;¢;i' {he piéiizitiiii .e§{§:ic§1 was for 82:: pezrisxi De::s::n%,~t:r~E'~é<:x»=r.::izfs«ti:*. 2%: i:::i;i{EE:§'3}'«. ¥5i'?S*%£ii§E._ year anti conscquwntigr, was wi:.:§§'§';>c:£i by !.$'v{'sV§ iii' s:»2.§a§}x V apart fmm imposing~:§isizzr;é:iéi1r.€;s"zzgzci uiviirzzavisiy, xraas Ecnninaicé fmm V:.'~;«:.:if'v,i.t§::*:_<.$t2?.__Z§ 1991. §E1 "§,h€3V'.;lE}§trfI?3§._§I§{£~¥¥h3;, the: gmpascd mi in saiary w§1§¢.:§3 A :v;a:;s""r¢:;;s;r1n:(i it.) by was aisax a:haE§t7ng¢::§. by ihczt. pi:.»:§n§,i§§ §y 't»ga}?'::ef':1'Vc£s}"iiT_sci: in €J.S,Nv.966é:' 19853?» As in:-grim artist :3? if2j.;;nL:£i;;:2 $;=ga.::r.':é graﬂicd msiminiag fizz: £313. fmm iasnninaiézig; {Em Apiainiiif,«:' 1:: Ehtz mtzanwkiizz, {he spziic vi' chaiiengas £9 SE23 SE35? ' Ragﬁiatiuna §235.«'éz"§g fﬁihili, by vir§.u::: egf 3 aiﬁcision mi @326 §~£:g._;;A ~--C'-(gut; uf Kamaiaka ami smasrgi uiéacr 'Z:-;mr£:~;, LEQ haé apprtzacixczi tfzis Cmzri by may :35 a grit.-'ii rczsisimn pssiéiign Q 6 cixaiiangiag the gran: £35: orcier L215 injum;-tizsn in i%.vm:r L33: 824;: piainiiff, wizich wars aiiuswcd amt? {he iniarim agrder gizmti mmiiﬁctd and ihc giaiuiiff war; a.:ii%ma§¢i§z icnainaicd. ' in;:i£§cniz;§§j~;, during the; jtxesar 398%, 5d. i}§3am:1__ g3mg.;.,;f;i11"::"x.r"»2é_$_' ' was arranged by Ehtt Naiéunai §5udr::m.:=:Eun £3? ._E£ﬁ§[Ei;'}{§$S Vi~::§:3:'*:". the Kauai M::mager°.>: ufﬁazc at Madras«331$V.amun§§".AAi§§¢§§:2Sa3:¢4§.$"sf dtzmunsiraiuzs {Em i-di;;¥..i§{ swat!' e.}i1':.: E4?-,L§~aa.='¢:i»='s2,': ﬂit'; iaimiff 7 . . " 1 was marked, aiemg \x}iii_1:"i}1r%:-:2 i--:3£.'§2'~:_r_'».V¢i§§c@-bearers mi' Ekc Feeismiékﬁ vé§~.";§'§: i:::gi.'zc:{.§. Sh" rssziczzzssc: myiis;-ca-; zmeicar She Rctguiaéimgs.

.-- , The "i§§;;i;:£iV§f V9325 'giiaeisai zzmivsr smgprznsémz wiih cﬁksz-i pctéiiirég an anquirgf anzi he was azafarésé Si!.§:?i15i ."E<§Lé1'I>I§$§3>v£:i§E.?}'%'§:§}T§£3§;3. The ureiar sf zmgpcnsisn 'EEES in {arts iii?"-.4.4..,_'i Than ii; Siikiﬁd rsaigkmi. "xi: tstaizgry §}2£§g'%£§§F:

V *f.§.?£3fiﬂg 'i§:12ii perémi apart fmm ﬁrm amagung. pc,%.i(§ as §:L£:.~:p<:3';5§:33"2

--¢zﬁL}ia!:»s,z:1:c, wax»: nm:¢:.:1" paici $4,: ﬁn: piaisaiifi Tia: piainiéff wim 'mwas isrminaieé in Jazgzxaxfg E992 isms pvasi $5 anai in {gyms gaff ifﬁc amt:-nticzd Staff' Reguiaiions, he was iﬁeiigibic is he zgbgurﬁcé K ink: ﬂag atizsaizzésiraiému. kfhis €.'.§fL'3£§I}3$§{~i¥}§§£3 izzui s.s:u:'m* ii: 2; §:a2e:~;>.; 9,-niy an accuuni of ihc wiiy maniptgéaiﬁzrzs mi :~.%<:;2é.u:r%«':;;§§:§a§s:; grumgissai by maﬁa ﬁtics and E33 Ezarismzrrzé agaénrzté Em .:g;i:z5i§§'ii--T The cause was aisu £a§<x:n up by ﬁn: E,-ié§'<:'::§i,§g>:f§ az3:,§:i11 é_'}2é ~.--.a.%"'2:i§<.x<':{-- 131' iizcz cry fey jusi;it:t:., Eht: gm-siiion of iﬁitgiainiiiff £z;='v:v£:~:'n<:1_;Q:i_;&'ir:;éi'~ anti ix: order 19 mmady {he xa:m§1'zg;;<§.§zm piainiiff :s:a$1.»a§$:{>§§cL§ into scsrvic-2: as per 2: §v:i!.ér~~g_>i'3.g:J;:L:i§:i--s§:a:r£E-iiaéed i'?.§.§€§9'2 as a Ciasswiﬁ czrzpivgzw, 1 B}; a Hg;-§'ice'}1j;i:ii¢:d 2SiéiE§}§?;-_ tE'2:::" vp§«:§§:2§§.€§ was §22iE>§*::'2e¢.§ that hi: xx;:_2%;§:§ §}{ir1;1""':~:tir*;-degtxfg an 3€3.«i§.i9§.:§ 22.1%.? Eféaé aI1l£3£1¥1§§"§?fdf:=$';{§$¥§!!f.' V5.2' 33-';'i'zI1V'is1--.:$:.2i{i§{'§: be s;::i,i§::{§ 2&r§§,§2£}a;E rafsrratzzazs £9 nmzwgafgmczrii-. sf .:ai _§3r§{ ilzir ihc pnrimi iixai Eat: 3:233 gnxgim"

sz:a~1g:3':l:t1$i_:_.5:i.Vv Ii ié"'§¢ir:h.g:___g;:v§a£z2§i§:§"s s..:-aasrs éimi £25: had £:tI§§€£"!::£:§ Liza: ,:~.:¢s's.-ﬁicazgs «;:si'--.i;.§1"t;rV Cwxpumiimn as as Cia::;s~§:§E cmpiuysc am? as L"'3i:§§I(;a§ al'e{its;;, §iaa;i" i:>t:@ - -II aggoénimi 31:02 cunﬁmlttci 23.3 3 §:i§33:«:-«ii t3r11;:'s_i_*.}y«;<;~ ¥.}é}2:u:e£3r;ii;1I;ct: wiiil Eh: Sm?' §3.:.:g_;:s§a§éo£;3 anii Ezaxi 'n,agz:é;t3 aﬁsmrbcd 33 3 C§a33~»H§ mnp§<.§}26:e ami sinus: 2316:: :§ctV'§--¥.:§.¢ c::m£§i§§a}3'§:-; prsxcriﬁsd ':--'\--'§"E*:f.! it ::§3':::'§::§§ 3}:-2 >ge:rz=?i::§*;~; mi' é the EEC cunikrreztd a riggizi is E: in gcrviazc: iii? Em r«:ta;§;:ﬁa§ i'§:~¢*a§g$ of 66 and {his 'wczizlg appiicabis $1.3» 231 c:m;3§<3}iie74:'$ z-.:§§;av;:3z.$é::é::."::§_f V 'tr-c:§§.§rc: Ma}: 13383, iffy: nuiicc issutjé 1:; 4ii};"«pi:;:%n§§Vf§_VE.§$ai'V héi? xwusﬁd rtziire an 3{}.4.1§*93 whVr:':1 _hr.: wmgiti ¥2a2~:.%4..*:r:£} (.:«z3if;s E38, was an arbiizmy ac-{Emu ant} was 15:=v;i:2:»;§urc was tsppmcd Ea: {hes sarxéicc cundiiiuzis ariaiaﬂ" }.%?i§i€:E5§ v§xe"iA,?21t5.'c::*:1;:3§e:2}:::;.i. It is iz1;"£§:Es;_§§%.:¢.:§;§§m§1m§ 5lir§a£"i§§§e..§.3§__;;§ﬁ§§§§ hmiitzg Eaéicé Eu cerwinca iii: 1I5?;€nva;__§,e:f£:cn'E"T{§f §ii;~;..£;a3£;, ihc: Sui: swat; ﬁicszai 3:'.-eieiiag a &cciaraii£,)nA"EE;-a,{_a§.E:E§ ag_1;:i'=x3§ r¢§.é:'<.:zm:z3£ cf Eh: piaéniiff was {$5.} ;-.r::::.11'3, as.._appiécafb§¢VA'i::_ '.3i§N4dJ§'I§}'Ji§¥.}j;'*;i¢\'i:~t of Ciatézs-EH f:§pp<_.>§E1E£€,§ Ma}! i§'S.é_3V_ a'11d ﬁaai $316 piainéiff 2,-wuéti have rtziéreei uni}! . iafigr '*?v'hiit: ihc piaéniifi: aisu ciaimué fizz: arretars vi: *..~;z§§':»»a:z'}_.: v3:L3'I;."',i§ ::Vl':!'".!Q§}{:'§.'r3 when he was amciczr su:>;p-ansiuzz 3.11:5 far Gamzzggég fist pmmaiure icrm.é22a%.i§_§:z ssfgsrvia:-ac. Tht: écihndani - LEG had! cuniéssiagi £2394: rgzsii; §1u§z.§é:2.g.,j éimi ' p3ainiii'§ had azi:n§§icei§y rsziizmi ﬁm/11 :~:r:wi¢.:¢: zimi aii b:.:§:e:§i§s aim: Eu him ws:::"<:: scilicti. ii was Eizréhcr cogsicngéazgi E2121? $146 piaiggiiéff 6 wire haé aucepirsgi the fresh appgénimmi is} Eh': ;34J::;§«g_»_§* Iii cmpiuysaz, an his irsmzirztsiien ﬁrum :=.r:rv%aj::; 'mg ::s A_T%?_.f§}::~2;<*:;#'~i3;T ' e:n1;2§s=§:t:e, 311$ having Liszixmi éimr %£.»'*:'Tf,3'Z1>::ﬁi*;,f"€§L§§t}i$§~;§1§§_§;§'§g?.,V "s';':"?;:§>3§'!§« :£.ppi._}iI2§¥!}¥;':Il§ is !;2:§E{}p§3t!€.i §3'!;,';:'f} -._§;g>11§c%2g§i§';g: i§:::,:;:i Eyzé ¥,»a;a;€; i's.;:i; q guxiemcd {he icrxrzsﬁgici pf 2-.§.§'.'L§:';2ii»:.::_r25%%%c ég {ha pusi 3&3 gm' iizs %;/';gg;;.E;;:ig.g§;.,{;--.. izscxzaéssza, he iéaai drewm the icr§ni:§z:i__ baggéiiis piainiiff is no:

Vt?-':£l£:'.d xxii§§:"a."§_§.g;§AAi%i 'Q ii. is Ema: iirsai Eh: p3ain§.i§i}"'iw»>;V Déi}'.;e:'§:3;§z;;e-rxé *I3}§§s;=:i and had £{}ﬁii!1L£€i§ in ifigai cadre: 'tmiii acting'"w¢ais._§é:i;,¢f;_. {er I'l£}'£!-'§'3!;3I'§€.1'2§'1!}fd§':£:*:.* in irsmm :2? i the. -LEC1 Fi'i::ig i {?§:§§ct';~_r V'§iKé'ur§ $59335, the nmrms whi:.;§: warm .g:TEi';.{§§t§ri§ge{§..«by §§xé""£:::zp§s.;y::as imé:-: bi:-czn mmgaiéxicé by ﬁat: :€3s§2::§fi?ui' imiia and Ems sgiiaitmzzé .§n:§Eii§; E ii is under iE§£)S$.--_E'*§ﬁr¥:i3 ihai this gsrxéiccs :3? Eim pEs;2§n§.i§§' wf.»::$ ierznixzaimi 33 A 33;: wéizs fmsmi uaﬁi £9 cuniimgrs as 3 Bexisimpmmné. §:3§§€:ﬁ§°. Hééwtzvar, ix: axsrmiﬁc uf ﬁn: {§5§.:l"€,*-i§€.3¥§ §rmr*§z:§s;& §.§_',é @335 iii: unciﬁr ﬁn: 'Kari: Ngmnss am} taking ink: a;:a:<3:mi gm §~:_>:g$§§3§c harcisrfzzip ihai zaruuid Ecikii ptzrsuns, sum}; as Eh: giéaérziifil ma 2 ii crmascd S3 §,r'c:::,ars sgfaga whiash éissniiiité him EELS: rs_:«.;'§3:gé:a{% "*2"

in icrnls of Rtzie 12 {xii 81:: Séafi' §~?,§:;;:.s§a§i2;>n:::._-- h:.:_€{%&:x:{,*~:f; having rciaxed Eﬁe upper agc §§'a3x§i;_'-Ailﬁf' §a;;.sn:;i€i-:::ri:tégL.___ maggxginimcni in Ciamx:-«IH £2»-'c,!Li§'$. "~__.'.'*.'i§h Aéigct €.§":=::- --. L age: :31? supcrdnnzsalimn gxfeuiﬁ Vgéazs, 332$ ihemgh the age 13? z*::£i1r<':z;:'<:.':«.z.f-L' v4':§:»;:§u}!e¢x wirzesza EEK:

§§§::iiI'}!:.i§:.{.'\'§L'£§1'§f:';(i:.V§§T.'\.Af;:."§V ",¥&!E« 653 ytars, in 531:; ycmr 1§?€é3; 5;/,;§.g:;:ii£.;*I1 as a }§}e:vu§::§zz:«:n:

fﬂ%.§§;$¥}i;;;E2§ 2:;;,§.;:- was :,:pr.:.:2': aééaézzézzgz 53 ;zt:a1r;¥:' in ihai waif: iii? iim gmas" ES???

anti $32'; Exizg fze;;zh'a;é;auin§ri:$12§ 29:; a C-§a:»;:~:-iii £:.f¥}'£§}§€}}a'€I€3 én Q11:

"'9 gzgzii' E932, V"i;,'z::tt ﬁaizziiiix w:4..:; tiizseziéiiicgi $0 ttiaim Qmi ﬁgs: s:,:wie.:«::

s;z3».?;a§i iit::i;*.»;._a:s.xEi.--v3xisim§ prim" is E933 in rgspccé 9?.' ﬁf-122.3:-:~§_Z.E smug:-§u;gw:;§:$':11:§ rzigarda: ﬁn: age: {sf supcyammuiien amgixi Em appﬁg ami i}}t'fii;t3§.'(J1't:¢ msgaiiwtd iha main céaém :3? the pia,%§1§é§£ £33 fsgzzwrds {E16 Liz-zniai £33: hi:s{sa§ar§,I Liuriggg the pcriuxi :3? zauggzacnsian ' £132" }9 mainihs is mncesneai, 23;: '§'r§2~§§ €3m:r§ Ems {Emmi £22 id'-wewrrgss"

cf ii}: p§ain':if§. if is againsi £§y:: £3és2z:§::sa§ :3? L312 mi? (.2? that Z piainiiff insufar as the main rtziiai' is cmaccmcék §.hai §§3£,*";3§*é::;:c::"g§ appc:a§ is ﬁieé, Shri Yug,anara:~;im§2a_. Se:/giux" .*3;.g§t:<3¢:e«;:§?:._ «ilk? 331%':

w<:r:.:iL§ .~.2a:§mi£. that i.h::.: Trial C-u:§r_i"§2_av§ng -EE2§:::;i i§*é§::'§ _;}§a=£3:3%%§E' _ VL was vsniiiicd E31' sa.§a:"_~;= '_'£..i!,£I'i!Ef:':_.§.é%%.'".,${£??$?5!Eg;QI£. 9?: ii} mmnihs and having agracﬁ' is; 33;: Ewe,-:i<.:a§ 22:;

'(fies mm' 3§££'.i!.£!:":{§2!g 2 iim piaizsiiffs :;g;; iH§V§ir;g§a§, R22" éixtt r:'2::~:m:

ihai iirisr; p§a§nti§f§v§1a_xii11g"§3~:;%:§3__krtgrji mzé €}§ :::e::;"v£2:rs £222' E53 rzzsméizs far :39 fauVi'1._;3i' Exit: nzyﬁfmrfurnzaﬁca 4::-<_m§:j. 219% be 3 g2"m.2:::;i «_ ﬁ:r_~'i23'§.:s Vigéiminatiﬁzaﬁ V§g§t;;ci21§i}r", when Eﬂha: ﬁcwssiaggmani iﬁéficers V :21' fat: piainiéff am paisi 2212?}: grupgriiuzxaiiy Em é.%2<:: smzgriéi :§;e;;,»' 5j_g£22£:rai:: and I:un~p§:ri22r::°:a.ns;a reziazaisaig is: 23% b::$i:z€§;g':.i§1e:§: gg:m:rai.c szniaiiing aiégéncszsgiéxics imiuaiimg 13:6 _ iiﬁfiifiziéiiieii 1.35 azarsziezs. if iizct aiicgcé 2:a}::-;:;3::z"§m"::':.2:;':e:s égéﬁg V___§7§y~:- maps-nsiun periué is exeiuzissai éim. pzryéugé mi' zmgz:- pcriﬁnaanec wuzzizi a€:£;}Haai.§§;z:§§§: gsti tgagaéguzavzd am}. §§:'::r:*.§>z"<:' E E3 ihe pisgéiziiff' was aiigibic :1; ri:£.i;*r.: aé ﬁgs agt: uf 136%-§u;3zz:cn§. {}{§£;t:r.

The serimzs uircumsiazwe E§;;;iim§VE'ia.=:A2s :m€_:.§2; :§é_gg3::§r:5.V neari}! six years, éhtz ma1;age:n1c:V:._£".§3a;§ r£;_;$: ' ~!;2£~§am2 .;;::~ acﬁxiinisiraiévc giesazi:-zion as rcgléiéitié'-Eh: siaiisﬁé'eff?a§;'1v§:v:;%i§§av}§t*5, who was feund Eu Exam é$§'A%:;.:;:p:,>§:s¢ is 2:

caii by {Em Afgi India <3? 1%s§§§*;.:§§ £23 piainiiff xa2z§.;_sV by tit::5§g,;12 fgai his it:rn1i::ta"i§é.S:1' Ltrgessaéi ibis: a.;_.;*: axéﬁ 53, as uihcrvgiugg «hé étzziéiicd E23" absmrpiiaén £22 ﬁzz:

C1a;;s:II§ eséiﬁrg Vcxian 'ii: Eis pzzrilynxrazxeze as 2; §:'t:V€§.€,}§*!11€E§§ ' §}'f§.cc%"Lwas..a$:;esssé£i"a::; Ring bttiuxw par. Tim fast;-E Ehai tigers .w[2;>;&TA;2:§:"V;*gt:1g§?z;*s2:ncr: appraigai :3? ihcz piainiiffz-3 p<:;rf01"Inam:t: t3£§i3E§.i§§{}3;i3§:}21;§.:g;"' fa}: smrtzrai gegcarx, is a sass: ix": puiné is eiéxzxxgggagiyzsic = 9.1:; maﬁa Eéc mziéun £35 £311: managesmani in maigizsg ii. ﬁrm: éizzegi. ﬁaisxiiff was being, acarummaxitcgiazi mzi cs? piéy as 3 %'C§:;~:sg-iii 6fil§§L.}}~'§i£'3 t-nstsn aficr he had azretsscr,-ai Siwizaazxz. ii; wzzs apgvaiszzé ihai-Eire managcmani had cngineamd {his exercise ctgmg-;:§ous§y 8 H» and wiiﬁ pxt:-ci§c£c:*£mi::a,iiunu Tim éizégaztis is b¢£v».r;:§:¥f.%._4:::§r.%:;%g:;a:is. anti {Em asunizsniimx 121" {he rsagzaanéczais siimi figs"gzsiéiigiii:-"~§:gx-iiéag _ ' agrczcd is,» {he uundiliezn imguasé iiégzi zéjﬂitéei' _::;;§:*--§;e:'i'e.:.. « §:§'i§.f' cundiiium £113}. he zmzzici aiiaénﬁztz. age s?;s§2crz_aV::'r:i:;;§;§:,sz; cadre ufC§a:s:s-II}; an reaching: i§:g:__é£s,__';r;:_- u~.£_' 38. "Ibsen iizsjmgix as an tzmpluycc who izad ctiiézrvsgi. s'a=rxi§.é:§: 3:4; 19%;, Ehs: sscrssﬁsc 3-mzdiiiun £hczz4.:§3:?§:~\:a§:f:nl'V"\w{g3_:_§{§«..V:'L»Ts1avx: .._e'-z5'1i§§§t.~:-xi 3 Qiasx-iii '5 cmpigzycez id *ﬁ'::iz3.._V::;:i'1«'_ie:::" a:'--£'§.§*g<_:;*~ em: 13,, {$3. Thzs :"E":"i.:«; mm.

£.Z§.§!.£I'§E132-i I£'Q£. i%§kt§f§--ﬁ iz:l£;>--.g{:-a:a3uii;"Vii*::: amgiastz §2f2§§:;r;::1::-az zxzixésgfzz 22:: cmpksgier wizsiég $31 §.'L!.EZ1€§;i§;£?§} aszazzsia 222-: iiazr: :«.g§;s_w: Q1} £3313 em§§§.s..:}'s::. "t::§r_i:2»h'a$ "§_iiﬁ%;§ chtyiaze %c§w::m: ¢;::::p§z}§:n2%:1;§ ami R 'sian*a§;§§'J:}_'v~-- Azsci Vﬁmis in éiiés mix: 332:; ii}: S€:::icn 1--=;¢.:%*sT,&$2;a§:: . 'é-'§'L)E4£'Ki£§-. {:';'€,I>i's;'2?;'S§;. '€.3§.i§£3!"' cgznianiéazns is mg: Eiéaé gas: p§:;2iz:E§§_§ is aﬁ'i§§i::».;§" .§L"'"'(ZU1£E}§}*§5B$&§iiU¥I €22: ésgiai 5»? sgngaéazyziasgsi. zmﬁ Stag * §:§na§i"ihaE he we:m§& have gaéncé. if Egg had §:ez1§,i1m¢-ai in >3a::"s:§a.:c- i:i'§i aE£air:ir:g the: age Qfég mini \3.f(_¥E£§€§ szﬁaméi Ehai éizc &.=.p§%¥;,t-£:£§ 52;: ' aiiuwcd.

Z 3:32" wnim, éiqc: Cuunsci aggsearézgg 3:3; §§:r: §"<i..'!'3f'{§§'?5i'_.§:é';§?;V2.§';*?V.§E% wouié suﬁmit iirafi £312: Txiai C-mar: izaxzirig ibazszé ~:=%._é_~'." as Ehcz rzrcrviccs uf ihc: piainéff :.-mt 1crré§§£éa:.¢:-:§&_a3 a.:«§L_'§r:~§.;:§sg;;§:%:£;iiv« i3f§i::::r as an 3.6.19"-CH and {Eat :f€§§:"f.:E'§§€;:K1i zE,§.;£: uf z';_'v_§}¥;:2.Ar;'is2§:=ﬁi::::'§' ~. £33396: in ihe Ci:-zs;~;~I}§ cadre: bc:§:£g_§§§ anti V33. _:§:1 {:36 Liaéis 9-f §1é::: itzrminaiiung éiét: pi::iui§§1j§i,i2:ing.'VAa2x*:::"_'§f$,.figwetg; mgi étniéiiczé Em' mucznpiuymcni :3; absumiimhn'-.in2'a,:= :§:«;%':';;>~we:~:V <::»;'§airz: prmxéziczsi nngizzr iém 'E{:;§;;1Ea§£E¢;'3ns_.V "I§Q'wg;:~:2 :a_s:~:~.a":s§:éea;;iaE §:'<§.S€ zﬁai Egg: sﬁggﬁ ufﬁ.-rec§'":'r:~;:11§p§u}*i"é;:::3£"'i;1---gizc'§3§:::;v$?«i§E cadre am ﬁzz: .*§g¥a:§:§,§3§.: L:u11éé§_i§;tjz ihai his <';>§t*'::£,yi4:*<;:1nz;::§. zxsazazici E96 5% }'t::<;§"$ me appiicabic a"T:~a'.e {:3-i;=£:ss4i*H '£:§§1§2§Q§a;tes cm ﬁx: aim»; 9:5 maﬁéz . - retbrrifniéjgizxitégzi. '§hii"§§2:inii§f hzwizzg auccpaagi iézég £3L'}E"1{§;§§£..3§} £12 wr£1ir1g. and .§'_:':¢:'¢'_i2:g dtzrix-'ed ii":-.2: bcnsiéi. mi' suciz r:=~c:mg2iu}rn:ez3§ :.22i"~£§2c gsiptz-$i.f§;; ammiiiizxn is csigsgpezi Ezamz ssiaénzing iimi Ezia aggst .' ..t.:~f _sup63'§1n::uaiéun uughi in be wmgzaitzd an EEK: basis: iimé ﬁrm '".€p'§ai'2i£ii'§ had snicrad [E23 sczrviszezsf :25 326 LEE: grim is} iE3S3 amﬁ "ih§rc§3;:rc, {he eggs: sf st:pe1'a.ﬂz1ua.§iu:z 29:: :--£'§I)§';*§£;E3.b§f:: Ea) r.:mpE::~};¢:r;s u:.:§ ihg Ciauszs;-§§ caairtt magi}: :0 be a.§3:;:§%::L§ :9 E313 piainiiﬂ: Q3 E8 noiwiihsiamiing ﬁixai in: was imaimi. as at 5933?: a}:2p<,2§.z§%::£_é" i§1[*.i§z*: C5335-EH cadre on 253.1992 zmci 3:: wmzid sa;§;;_r.:1ii E}':.*:;' ~ finding of 1}»: T:-iai Eiuzzzi is in m;u£3¥=2§»a&I1_£;t: 2»*:zi.é§:' " "iii; £%s:§_$A~a;2%;§ cimumssiaxxazcs and pyinuipics £}fL'c!'J'¢'. .

Ht: wuuisi further suE:rz2§:{V"'L'i§£;é:i i§!c '§£:§_;j':3§é§iiL.';1§:5 5,: LEE hzwe s£a'lz2£u2"}= fz.2r§:t: 22t_1€l'a~,_ i.§2v::V R§g':;§_a;£§%_%ns zzggpiéazzgbirc £1; 2:31 appuiﬁimcni made in },~'.§:3I'_ be vaziatai ées» at:-cuII:r::z:<ia£c:3._ii/1:.{§}§,}§V-§:;i;i,§'£"*::;'Vétasgé, ?§'I§"'§{:£3l£IlSC§ xrmaziai piace miianérgz ._ s:~n i§:t:>._ ﬁ_3i§{;»,§éEi2.g -a£:§§mri£i-:33 £11 supgmré sf his t.:<.rnicn1i{3:iﬁ£i12ni. iﬁz-3 R.ﬁg£i§§§'i.§i}§1S wsssuiai pt»:-va§i_ in iiaai, Isséiiatzr Eht:.«;%zm:i%;::.§e:m::f:£V--.:m>r fim Cmzri 2:-zguici ncuaéez ii:-.2 smm: 22$ EEK: 'i. H . . . . . $ ~ i§1's§g~3;nc.:; £2j{'22.1;1"i:*zi:Ip§m'x,.?::t::

6.vtig;. ¥S:3;L'§.%'§!?££§'§{ﬂ?€£, { 393 323 SE32? Fszge £89 {Z7} Sing}? vs. Bkcsgszinzm, jiﬁ? 3;€3?5 SC E33} " ii vs. sixfza Rzzmcinmdrgg .4m§9e:§:csr_, £33 2 éﬁzi 35:' 21:33' 3'?

In iiéig bdmkgrezané, ii is is; 'Q: zmiéezcai Ehai itmzirc 4:3? firm ;::iz:in£i§:: as a iﬁivsiezpma-rné i§3.§§ia:$r '§¥-iiﬁlv ramuneraiiun peg-Fabis £9 ihisz pe:rE§.§§zzi2if' ".?':%£€'.:3'§.'I.:"L'*'.-"f<'§.§3', 4i3i::~::::s;i§:-; miaiablc {L} the pcrfcnnanus imigsnns, {xi 'six: éncgrtgygé ';_z<iz2v;t';;z.:'c;e;§* for the: Curpmraiign. it is ;'§ EVL*s,;~:s}:'.sr2:'_}i Taghéz Corpgraiion was unmin£§ i§§ ami z::=i_§1=:::° faciurs ﬁmi we§gi'==_3§§ in :g.*::zrr::.¥"fd:ié£:;é;Aéié§L§§s'§'f;%f:§%'-.iV§"'V"gI2'd:'ii¢:-;:§3.§" aygaa K is iht: vms 3§1:_ss.=s-':3 its haxfﬁ '£3u1";}>:fir§'u;a$"2*::V::ai;:n:e. §°ir:sii}.»', $312 pcziayai <31' Si1:s'pt33'!V$='§§)I£ .'ib;r hsmuid Egg:-{ta am §§y;:- iacsr :2? ii. &i3c§;1:;*::d Ii:?;: --;3::ri3um;ar:t%: .{%3:f ;:z:z'ag§:st:s 0%? p¢r§E3m22s:1w;:

a °>:"3§$3£§. "V'Sccun;i§Vi?';"'12ig Emzzsfatz ﬁem Bazznaiuvs $3 zgzzaséézey . V " . cs piazza' akﬁiétréi wass ma: pruxiiaied vs-xiii: zuirzzqzzaécs ixafm3ér:;g:§:.zr$ ii} £:e1:3%:ra§z::__" ?a::1:..§' gcaaraic éhs miuimzsm inssums its xnaésig his V A.n§1r§ur:r:ancc Eiﬂti hi3 _*ricmna;-L: Em ihég !."¢:i'-'a§'£.§ as}: §'za2.;%:':v¥ §::§-:3 . __ E: is 53

7.a.ccé;3i::d By that Ctgrgmmiigm :31' §:s}: at C-ivii ifgzaazri, zxzizcmz 33?: iyaai 'gtzasiiuzxtrd Siiilh msznsftzr, ié mmaizzmi 2: §€::£:§UI§ £332" his £3933.» pgrfennancc. The ifnini circumsianm iizai; aim ¥C,';3;';:0r:g%é:2z2 é 3% iiscif imu' §:z§§«:{§ in £:££!'I"_§-' uni. perﬁwmzznca agapmésai éhrtzc ycars, 3:§§}€§ s=.z£§:;§c::§§: chest: is mrzyr 9.22:: s:.::.:E: a?1r1 ;~:g::1§¥§é§§;;T;--é§',*[ Simtziiancmmifz, in rtzsptzci 9? $6:-'+.='€.?Ef3§"V_'_é'ié:-£:3"L~:? 'am? a§i:ég' §2ia:fIi'2a':§ creased {ha age of SS, icfi the §:§ai§1§iiZ7__:%ii§2 §%£§§:.*;V_+:.§A1i;%:..:'::ﬁV§?§{£& ié~.

acuespi the ufﬁsr of rs-cmpk};:tz2z:i§égi:3 3:2}; ccngiiiiaé-2:. On an uvemii vigﬁirz £ﬂ31'.'V§§EE'.?V§:2;.¥,*L3§§I~'1%{E"§.€3: uérsumsiaizeczs, ﬁgs piighi £35: ﬁle piaiuiiff a;::_V_;}.§t:a£27a:€;§ E3 '}ié1~vp§;§:;;:s;3"?.3ic argiamczzi in azidrctssing t;9;iE'.;:%h§.9:'2" or .;1 i.:i xafa;s;~:A.§*2{§;!i1£.§"'iE3}r ﬁat caznéiééggs iimi his ag,z4:'"As;:if' in «§'§*:<;V"§;S%.:s:s£ of Cﬁxgaiii gmpiegycc simﬁ bé5§:Z_ ami ;1':;¥i~.Vé'i3,«_. "wiréigzig smzsuié izaxrc £2253 Eiga: mac 2"?-

rcsspje-..:.;§ sf 3:; ¢m;:s§.{-->yei: té.é'§1:.: igaé szniereni gttrzréazrc §j?§"i*;>§" 9:} iiiiafﬁ'

- TEE: ésiher aixpcggi is iééhsih-2:2" iii: iiaéézzzéasxii ~ mspgsniianis wsrar in a.u;*:=_1$i£§Q:a.i':; f::(§.t2ec Tzhc age: sf sugxtmzgrguaiiazri fmm {V3 is; 533 £13; 3"tI."}.f}£3£Ei,.' .{};.€-, an c:::p§§.3"_vc:3 xse'§":§.: hm? agi1m£§i.=::;i,'2}: mitzrtai gsrxéése .' A.g3z"i_;_}r iii" I983. Theugh ii is yicaécé éhai egg éiiezz §e::§mina?:éz.m cf

7.§}1:¢"p¥ain£iﬁ' as 3 Dv:x:ch}pm:::1§ Qfﬁe:--st ami m:+§z%si§§zb.Ea§zG§ng his 2 ~: 1 * 5* = = rxs-cmpzcpytszani as Ed e:§:a:s.fs-11} ez::p§a2}mc ai. a gaicg" palm :3: issue; 2% cannot be: sgici Eizai 3261*»: zasag c-c.:-1:i%:::.:2§i.js_; :12? ::::*:rxs"i<.:: smci Ezcm:-:2, Z 3%' 32:: pie1iz1§if§:is magi ix; a gmsiiiém R3 agtféaim §§'§&§§. éizrt i?;::.tg.,"::A;§:»§i;.::¥:=_:.::_; appi§::a§3?.c: in came: cf C¥I1§3i{}§-"533 wim ﬁaé »*i:¥1'{%§'$<.§ 'S.€;,"-§"%£§:xgE:V*:':":

is F983 canxmi be }i}'Dt3S§t:d £1219 :§'§i'i"'%:':§.C §;A':>V é::=.§2£; gséhtif':gi::h:%§*:§.f£§2;:é.. requires caaxisiiieraiiun. 'i'h;sx.;g.§.s 4'.'{§:é.i*_V argu:1'zs;;:n;§. rcspundemi:-: is £m:§;nii.:a§§y :<!L}E,£}7¥€f2';.VV.iV'}§\ ézaigigz _givé:a £255., ii; uamrwi he said ihai '3§1 r;%z.#: '-_;¥::a,:«;_:é;:£.>;:%..§i:2;i;§.}! 93 :~:§:m.!ét.:c an Exmlinaiiun fmm V 2: umirg-_ r$~<§rz:§;éEa:j;'z:§';.,'::.% on 22:"; cxpycgs cuzldiiéun in H L'§1.a*;2".Va;':::df*g_V _ié":A._i§*:r.+ i:;;--::vE:s r;%.m;::::~.a£az:s,:t:3 uf ﬁat: prr;:3£:1'1»§.V {i'a:;:£§::,_ as 131:2: £7:'2£;3Qié:i%{§z1 <;§§:.§ 2213?: a;:r%§:<,_»::m Ea"? é.:f:§3S!"fs" am: E§}¢'§st:ff§3r§:£az§c§i"::;p§*:s:"ai:ag§ nfiizrs gsiaéniéif 332$ ismﬁzzaécai ascm-'ices §0z":;:2:i§1.;;:;=,n~p§fi§;3f:z3;;u:ca §;':s::EZ2§:: iv: aiézzémzzﬁi EEK =:3§ . 33; *Li.r§f¥m¥:3'f;_{ he wé.:§{§£{§ i':av:: beam £;:::%ii§:;:§i? Eb? :::§:}sL::*'§.2§iL2§1 ii"; Sin:

§.::~;c3.fe C§%£::.s{%EiE emgimzccs zmai Sim {;':.a§pum.§iuz§ having c§1"m__:s£nV_Viu ':20 uni}! aﬁesr ﬁat §§:iiz':£i§3f hm? €,:-':"£.¥'&§:~;(":(§ 82¢: age :1? V A.§i":x §::«:.mi§:.;i ciaim in haw: sgnixsmvé a iargxsg an ﬁgs piairgiéff msé. 'T.-;>'f§:Aii}:_ E}; aﬁézrgiéng him Ft:-€f1"§'§§§§&3}-'£;¥§¢11§ whﬁégis izt: wzsuizi §22§x='::: " berm enléiicé Eu by Qp::1"z:ii«.:¥:1. mi haw azmicr €316 Rztguiztiéarzza. if Siiﬁh axecrszigc was sarzictai am': §e§c_>1r"z: 31:: az§.i&:in§£§ EEK: age: $.35: 1%., Z as his pcrfennancc was itwsing, assesxeai in I"t:§S§}t;..Z§, 33$"-. f;».:§:£:%; periuci ami xvhixzh rtzquirtxi ii:-s: :"r::~:§>:mc§s:n§::; __{%mf-.:;€;§ V Ehcraibrc, ihe §'*$-!:':¥}1§3§0}>'I!}$n?. 0?: iii}; p§3i::..;é§i_' is .§_;;g4:..§;§:;'g'*'bm. absuzpiimn £319 :4 iazwzsr l.:3i.i§'§.'I --é:i¥1(i like;3i:a§§2£éj§§: §2é1sz_§.f:g,;' ¢.::€.::§"€.~*a§> :sc1r"vis.:c with iht: Cuzpaamiiuz: pziuf §i:€:«_VipT§a§in§§i:§ amghl; Es; be gixezzn £111: bmmﬁl {>i7.§r;sg:.?:r'_:~.~:<::'a*§§:*.:a_'~§f"'§%'gr;: piaéniiﬁf is; Sims csmsinittd ax izaxéng £2L}1'£'§ii"i'§}.6 s§_'§ i12_s*;::*£I§=é:#;2 :§fzjé"rr:~abrs:2rEtc¢§ as 22 class Hi c::13§2§:2~}f't:%§{_ih::: 'Scrgfict:_«~§3§§::guia.§i£3n:e appiicaégic £23 him in ihaf.'VV::zs;;§-axsikfgk .az;"c"7iEi'c E;»::g'uZaié:§%:T$'prcvaierzi prim" £13 £953. '§h:: Managtémcni x»ea_z_1ﬁc3:_j§1;:iv;r__ ﬁe pemcr ice rw-vzriis Q9: grass:-r§§_s£éa3.:z mi' age: of ziupfvsmzzni-;aL§£311 prascrébsé iimreézz 21$ 5% ﬁnale-mi sf V' .Eg?C¥" sun}: a cggntiiiizyn an Eire piziénééff. 213$. iim .§§;1é;i::£i'i'Z5:"'::.g;::§¥;i'-31.): hays: been cezmpeiimi is: 2-uz:§ra£.:§. @133; cf 3 sii§75'p1ai:¢~--;Iéunv s'iai:;im*iEj§ prgvézimi zszzairxr iim Rsgzgiaiieng. :"§}:%p§ainiifi7 has mﬁy been pr-;2mp§.<:<_§ by his ¢§c$g:€:*::.%.§a_::2 "Zia: miztin crngimymezzi. Agx:;:r:§%:zg,§y, E Emigi 2332;: iii: iziai azmzri was in arm: in ncsgaiévigg ﬁzz: piaigiiffs sags.

/é Accurééngiy éim :<£{3{,}&t'&§ is zzii=;vx>w:xiA i:n:2n3:g;;:§g'11é,§§:; ;i§év:. 1-suii miisfs mt: granigzei. The piaizziiff ix: {§e:«.--:;:::c_<.3.,i§5'=§j:a;~«;»%:g~:L"rej.:§'§:t*?:£§ K {rm}: st;:1*'\.-3%.:-t;: as am 30.i}<iK§.99'3 in ihcV=.g:iz1:g%£ﬁ§v :.:§:§g_ :5; :31 §3:.::vv.f,,i£§._T f This Phginiifi' shaii be pz:i§i'vL«}£f§it:. §3:«.:§;:11's;t<;:V Saiiéfgs/'{iL!£§VV§:?Y ﬁat: V pcriud of suspcnsi-an ﬁ:ri_i'S3";_ izzaiitigiﬁ a~g4.';:x§i3.r¢:.i. The Piair:--ii§§._shai§ be 'a:§L§--.§:u§23-:£§'izr:niia§ 'sezzzarsfiis R2}? the period iﬁbctxﬁge-..ci':"i§1_;: dais {if Et:_r::';i:1a:iLan anei 3€;}.{}zi_ §*':,~»'r?§:'§. :'-- 'I'?z:;-- _' {e 2.32:: pstiiiimnztr 5-i;§2:£i§ be rccgznpzzigé as.:;::.'§:f<§§"':<z;;j.ﬂ;§j»g*§' '*-.. _ V' ' ' J " i,,"f§.hc"V--E?ia§::i::§f'i:s;'éniiﬁed in a:<.3si.s atsifiizsz zazuii ami €21: apgwai. Sd/-

Judge I1'?

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court