Karnataka High Court
Nagaraja S/O Hanumanthappa vs M/S Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 15 October, 2009
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
ER' mg: HIGH CQURT {:35 KAR§~EA'fAKA A"? BA.?~3{;;;;3g.{§£2;:;vf 2 m;:*§;;:> THIS mg ifim 9A3-" 01: ::;>¢*i4§:i= B§e;VR_gm::2x3 V " % BE;F{)RE;_. % ma: fI€}:sV'8LE}vIR.J€?STI€E 5. SR§..f§:w1:/r:45EM {:Q";4-@3;;; AA ;¥iISCELL4NEO£i ' FIR§':i'@éiPPEZ§§i'V;§'(i¥fl1r§'§§z2Q&8--{§»9§"€"}, Beiweegz V Nagarajfi, -------- g. -.::, SE31} flanumanihappa;¥[_.. H ziged about 3% yam ' Ric Eioia11e;e.re'i?,0aé,, V V Exéear E'sz;i3xa1*333¥3a "}.'~3::3'3<;;9.§eg . _ ..
Ch;itrad:;rga,,.. 'V V Appsellam.
:--§.:i:t§..:V
" V ' E fiisizraxzce Ca' Ligi,
Syifgs iiiivisiaezzai Managsr,
» A E3fI§$1a§z'v{:'{1*f}1§}1i*X.,HF§GCsf§
.. A Eiesghwaragrur, Hubii.
%"
Id
Tejfaj Sharma,
350 late Pukizraj S§1am1a,
Aged abeui Si} yeam
€}wn$I' offitzs E'$oxKA-f}l.5AA-7272, V b
Rajeizdra Néiaya, N<3.T?59, " "
Sm Main 'Re3a.d$ 3"; Grass,
Ksmmangaia,
Bangaioré M 34.
{By Sri C. Shankar Raddy, Adv. For Ry: _
Sri B-.C. Avinaslg Aév, "
T'f1isV1.§'sriisc*slia3§€3:-ms' Afppa&3 "is flied {illdfif Sectiém 3€§(1} af WEV Aci. against lhe:_":¥ated I1.}2,;2C>{}'}' passed in §&'CA.Cr.E\E0.3(}4;'2§§3 "rm" file: 9f the Lamar Cifficet mad Cemmissiogtzer fef~vW£:rrk;2ém 'Caziipensaiiozz, Chitraéurga, eic. Tliis i§;?iisc3¥::§§&:3esm3$"'§i§s*£ Appeai eseméng an 5::-r Eiearirzg {big V.£$r§"3 file {:<>z:;fE':£e1§iféerg::iti;e foliowingz J{:$i§.z*i§£Z%V?' fiség is ts? figs: ciaizfiaai £232" ezsfizaiisszziefii s:>f 333% V' séeinsfiéfigatieii awaréeé hjs; the Lamar anal tfezzzzzzéssiener K 5:23' 'a'%'sf':o z*i%$ne:3 CGI}1§C!€3E}S3{i{}§§., Chitradugga {izereiaafiar referreasé ta " H'"{3@§m'z1§s$i@:2e:*' far shaft}.
&' and {3{}C1l:}}€?fi'£a§"fy' evideace 0:1 regard, bf; the inzgugaeti ju<:ign::é_f§"£"1 has heid that thua claimzzzat has estabiisheé 3331 he is 3 §*«?Q§"?s;§21a¢1:;3w;'&._§$' "
q».a:3temp§a'£e& urxier Seciiam 2{§}{z1} ef the Ceznpirnsaiéen Act {her-ei;3a_fier referred tapas Eh; _ T has sustaizzed injiizies in the accid<z11tQ<,:c:;1"reéE iiitize ce:.s:9é22§éf'a:1§§':
eat af ::mpiayme;:{ and he fig $;1*ii§§a+:i' "is: seeiéi.~.§:£§§:2;§ez':§:§£i<:=n, Tiriafeafier, iixe Cfirrzaiziisgiazzer 3.§é;essé%:g Qfiiie {.'§&i.§'§'.é§32§ at Rs.3,§fiG:"~ per mom}: ané theVV§§}§.<::._;:=i".%§$:.r?}£:3gr~.cé*%as;:é;_ at 4{3%§1:-%;;a awafded C*i?§I1p€}§1Sfl§.i(i;3'E"$5E,S'.}3?9;399§=* wétli interes;§: 21: E2'?---'5 gas arisamn 3:36;' 3% éfihe avesméi. Aggéeveé by the _ ;q1:a31h;mj £221' *c0mpén:~;:_i:;im3 afiaréeci E3}; the C»3=::1:2§é$siet3e:*, 'aha ' ~ s:Ea§z1'12m: is; in A is :10 éiiggme regafiiizag izijuffé £é«'££S¥.3§E}€§ by {he " ciaénzant i.fl,f:i1";e aceiéefii mcurrsé ix'; {fie cazzrge «:3? 311% 92:? Q2? "'~::§*§}ié:>;}%:1§§:§1i aztsd iiaer §ia3;3i¥§i§; afihe inslsrsmae segzpaanjgg the 931%?' % gagfistéfitéai gaze-§£i<3;2 fizai ariw @132" C-<;m2:i§era:[email protected] in the apgeai :52: W"
iifheiher {ha CO3¥}fi1§SS.i§:1€fiSju5fiifi€éif} assas5i:1g"£E}'$ x-x%22gaé' % afthe aziaimargi at Rs.3,5fi{},--='- per mmflh 322$ §_<_>ss {3_f€fi§'_!§i§}g; at 453% and awsxdénv cam" nsaiécm of §{s.£A,?9,3A9*}¥°» %2.%ét§2A.iii:,r:§e.%:§§-.__ :3 A 5 . .' _ . ' a: 12% aiiar 38 days fmxzzz the date 0f":;_w_a¥é? A " ' =
5. Sri I)_}4?;.3'~3agaraja., §€:--i~3£'f1€£§ .£';?:ju:§$:€,-E V' iixz c1a:£:3}a:§i_' submits that irhe claizzxfisiifiy E-:«?£§é*§:§z1g.L:s.sA'_:z.V{3;)§1d:.;ci<32" fig:
the has bei311g£r;.g :9; .'£§§;é'---sectigad :ra§E#p«e2z{i er:f;w~..§}e::'駧2 was eaméiig Wages sf E.s,3§Q{}{;%fi-- iiimiiiz exciigéiiézzgbéia vr;-gf R31 if§8f~ per day 3126 t§3e2°ef9ré;,C::a2i1z:1issi'.'§£;::f V;i£;fi:__§'us:ified in 3.sse§si;2g his wages at Rs.3,5§Gf=~ p€.f"§3r:0 r;:j£1, fig 4ii;1:"£i;ef;f..'L'suhn3%t§ that {hue E353 <:='f'earni§1g gtagacity as-gesséd by ':i3ér"C<::_1:;}31s$i@::er at 4§% is {lit} the iezwr Side aéisi .t"fi}f3f€€§i1g. ;;:f.i:13?.;éi*i::sf£_ at 22% per arznum after 33 aiajgs {rem aha daiae ;§f£§ie-.a£%é:*«i~"§s-- ¢{%fi§*&f}' is the guégneat caffixe Supreme Cam':
in the 9;' égsgivyzqz, LA§S£iRsm'€E am am Ms: zgwggg.
.1 &- M» 2§#§¢-{IR S'€§i"'3 E3 Z Ekereibref fie grays « ferj.'?.E£é=§«*i2ag the appeai and e:2§mz:c£23g the cozzzpwsaiiszn. %,
6. Sré C. Sfiaxikaz' Réééfi-2 iemnefi Ceaznse-1 izisurazice Cfiiflpaiiy subilaits axeepi 'Lite 3e¥i}$;::7r?€é:1g sf:-'£égiéms:;:: afitiie ciaimazxt that he xvas earning wages {if ziiazéiiiéa .« exzriudirzg ham of §%s.i{3fif-« per éayjfifij weriiifigas a {fi»:*i-V:z:::i..!,:":°.'i.'{:¢x" £13.'. {£15 bus: beiotigzzg is ihe seccmé .r¢spQ:';é§:2: E1e£§:it:e--,_€he. mt suhsmztiaied the Same E213-A' :G7V:"~3}%.%?Tv %()f the hug err by pmdtzeifig any dfiréuxéigazziary ihat effesci. Eie furfiaer mbmifiz, ?,W2_, the z%v3:V1§;:i._:z'<é'§§e,§£iciaimam has zztatszt-CE ._c§ai;§3$3;t'%;%zL3 géiazigfigaeci 5}'~i}% éésabiiiijg :9 {Egg iimb mzé Em has 336% Si:.2;£é£E_v;I§1éi€; é:s~ f;§:e, '&«%.$»é%§§iiiy szamsed is: {he w§'s::;>§é:= i:@§§.~ aizd '£§§'sZ'?,§®§$ fif e:a:3f;i:§'g~ $3.339;-9&1}; €221 accguzxfi cf §:1_§2.:z"}.-»' sagiameé by Eéim iii" t%1é»'."1ac;c§'<§;ez1t. "ihéfeiéie. 'éhc C0§22missiav:1a«:' is jzggiéfied ix:
éégsésgiiég. §€}§S'vgT.%f:§$3.§3}§¥3g cgpaciifg 2:: 4%% 332:3 haiéae, ha gsrays Em éigéiiggai; §i':§§_;*:}a§§eaik " aceiafieizt was aecizrreé an i%'%.§2,2{§§'2 azzsri the _ &{:--§i§r:3--é'2iiA wag agafi aha}: Eé "yams at the time ifif the agzcédezfi. 'E1:
'€§.€£ifi13i'£Ef'£3S séiaiesi GI} 63%: £313": $32 was eaméng wages: ef R$'3§%§{§,»-='»- 1% per nzenth apart {:02}: bats; 0f Rialiifif- per day by w<:)§s;i11g 35- 3 C1t33}£§£}€.'i0£' in the bus Eeienging is the secand §'€Sg)€=I"§£§§i'I"£f1 E_1e_:."::i_7;'1-..._4 'fhe wzner did :20: cheese {(3 pmduce 3.27:}-? czmira _e-€:i<i§:9:1::'<§g'--- 'V' Sansidezying {he age if 133: zziaimagzt, ztaiuregfgsb agé' . aecideaxt, the saiarjg assessed by the C€sn1n1i§;§:i@r:-fiat' R:'$;:3.§{§_€:é,"» 7* ' mom}: is an {he E0 5&1" Siéé. ii is jéifii 5:36'-g§r9per':Vs: asse$s',§i§s.i.3a§.gg;»~.V1 cf the C33,'.i3'I13§}3L 3: Rs.4,€}G{}:"» yes' :1_;i_¢-§'t;'::.2r;. i_¥3f2f:'~«§.:;v_ 3::-vf Eh: £'€>£}1p€I1S8,i§G§1 vm;*£<;5 cu': '£0 ;p?{§;'~.é§[§_;¢. <§i3{${} re; 560/é 243% ;~; -2:%3.5--"2' %'4§<%»;;k' ""%gs';22_§5,$2?.29 pg; as agaizlgt R2.1,?§,3§§i~ aiis'21_:'fiz:-ci .£E1»i': .C?@:: %:'z3§3$ii323 3;: ' .V P1'-2%Ef£,. %£2;:?"':'I}:0:;:im; whe ireaiesi the ciaixnagit, :3-"iaiesgi {fiat fire is:%a§1;§3:;<9:";.§3.a§é= ss..1s§a:*_2:e<i '?{}'?.'»'ie (§isah§§ii}»* 1:15: the: iimi: 331$ he }'}.:1s§3<:i Ehév idigahiiiéy waged is wiaoie bofiy azzéi whai fig §i2:.=g%'§<3§:éT eazzéizzg eaggaaszity an aesauni ef é.§§u:*y susiaified 233; :E:«.:: _£:£:§:im"a;f:t in ziie aeeédezzt. Eigwevef, aha C§:11:11issi<}ne:° caizgiéerézag V V A fix némra {:fiz2j'1;:*§;, désabiiétjy siiaieci £335; '£336 ifiaasigr isrg: {Essa iézzzb ssrgé V' gbserving {he eanéiiiaiz of the a§&én13;;1 éazrigg flag e:::+m*s:s:: 4:24" £2323 %/..
:3-v£dence, has agfiassad the Eggs 9? eamiézxg cagacéfiv at 2':-iaimartt has sustained fr:»zc'iur»a=- <:=f:*igh3: }';1i;r:j:i>'§'*3,'£':+:*3:<;*t':;-re cf :53 53'. riéés Gfhsth right ami E6.-fi giée, Cezzsaiéierizag bgagize, iiéé: n assesgeé Thy {fie Canmzissiagéer is gzzsi-v.3::§?=€1»p:'e'per.. .&§E§A§*.£'i§é?S'"i;3V§il¥§ caii far any izziarferencsix 9 E32 so far asafwzgréing i11ié1'~{:s:_;a£«..'§ '3fis:;*' 3%} days éfimm the 63:6 ef awasjxi; %'§1¢ iééaaifisi" fize judfigmzifi 0:' aim Supramze Cigzgrt "';§'§;S§S'I{»4:1'CE £76. IE3. 3/"S. .%»1{}fI}). 2»:4;¥f;z%&%zz:zm:r£:g12};A2§a9 4:11;; s*c;w?; :: w§2:3:'e§t*: 3:
_..i§: izeiéi iifies; Ciaizzéaxtf «ivs entitieé fur intaregi 2;: gar arsmmia '§1i'§3I:::fir:§ §ia1e%«:§:'fii£. ;f:Eai;*;3 fiksfiiiiiflfl iii} the date: <31" ihe awalfi anfi E2'%'gér~.2:::1§i3:;£'&a=§%fi£55 date GE award iii? the {$336 9fpa§;'me2&i. 331%. Ae:C§ez*:§§§:2gi§;? Q29 fififisfifii ég aiigzaaieé is; 3333:, *§"'.'::e {:§§i§}'§3::":E énfifieé fits? cauzpezzfiagiim cef' §{s.2,§3,{§3'?.2{§ pg. as; agaigzfii §;.f'?9;3§§.f~ with imeresfi ai. ?%«é% pea' QJEEEBEX} ffifiiii {fie aiafte <12?" zhe . ;'§§z;sé:?2';;:ei£'£%{3:} {$33 ihii észia af ihe awaré anéi 32% my aifiimii £22321:
3, {he dais sf awagé iii} the aiagte $f§}3}f1I1€§}i€. The i!'11§3£ig:%"£€f§§ 35$-zirfij séaixcis ;:2::>£i-ified K: thai' e:-giant. '§'ha=: rest cf ihe a2*¢a3"§A.._:;;;§7 " Cfiiififiéfifiififlfif 10 remaizz as it is.
B?viE%«€,515lB2{309