Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnataka vs Gadigeppa on 22 March, 2011
Bench: Subhash B Adi, N.Ananda
I
IN 11fF IfIc,HCOI.RrOI KARNklhA
(J[( ('Ti BE'%( I' A' L)I-1WVfl
DUN HIS rii DkYOI M4RH I L
q
il-lF lio'\rsi± XIi? St S1IUL U. L'1fSH B 4W
NI)
THE i-U )N'BLE MR .JUSTICE . ANANDA
C RIMTh L WI El o 1841. 200z
BET WEFN.
T
{
1 t((11 Kainilaki
B Pulki. Inspet wr
Savanur Police Stat inn Apnellanr
(13 ri , M.Hana .az \rtditic.na' S 2
ct' ligeppi.
S 'k Ktanar' pp.t.
Ma' ik'iz rai a' " 11
' ,
ci c
CX '
L
12jh '' i'r
P . !.r,j' :
'• 1 i T 1 1
ktCae 'C 's... .':c .a
t'r tJ1 1
' 8 t
R '
•t :•• 'stt 1. 1'
t
2
3. Nagappa,
Sb. Bilappa Savanur,
Age 30 years,
0cc: Agriculture,
R/o. Mannanagi,
Taluk Savanur.
4. Mallikaijun,
Sb. Basappa,
Malakannanavar Urf Yallur,
Age 20 years,
0cc: Agriculture,
RIo. Haravi,
Taluk Hanagal.
5. Virupanna,
S/o. Mallanagoucla
Doddagouda,
Age Major,
0cc: Agriculture,
R/o. Kalmadu,
Taluk Savanur.
6. Basanagouda,
S/o. Motanagouda Patil,
Age 52 years,
0cc: Contractor and
Agriculture,
R/o. Kalmadu,
At present Savanur.
7. Fakldragouda,
8/0. Basanagouda Path,
Age 18 years,
0cc: Student,
R/o. Kalmadu,
Taluk Savanur,
At present R/o. Savanur.
3
8 Pt (* p
S c ,n -ikw p t I N u
$7( 8'a r
Oe \d'o to
R Mar nraç
At pr smt Hub r
UN 63( aIR
(hait my magar
Hubbilh Respor lents
1315r KiPit 'idc 'nc rK t R
Sri R 6 KocIhi Adi.o itc for RI t R8)
INn, nmina rpp I rsII ci ni r e t no r
of thc C P (rr in 1 oct ir th St tc ibl
no fi c a p r fe pt ig
Inn
Ii 4
< (iC C)) CR C) C)J CR 2 CR CR 0 C)
CR C) - CR H CD CR
CD j C C) $
-- -- CD p C) 2
--.
I H CR C) CR CR ci C) CD 2
C) CD rt CD -) CR
-) CD
(ft c Z CD o C) z 0
2 n CD C) C) C) C) 0 CD C)
2 CR
H
CD *
CR - C) 0
o CD C) C) C) -- () CD --. --
C) CR ON (IC C) CD
CR 2 ii CR o
n n CR 0 CR C) C)
CR $ CR C) 0 C) CD C)
C) (CD CD C) CR CR ' (IC CR r
N-t 0 j C) C) 4N
C) C) CR) CR
H H CR: CR CD C)
CR a 2
CR$ $C)22-
1: cC) C) CR I t CR CR CD
CD o C) C) C
.CD(iCRCRi($4(iC)
CD CD CR --*
CD CR C)
CR D)) C) CR CR C) CR CR CD
2s CRC) C) ft CR CD CD CD C)
ft
N$C) ftCR --
C)
ftft
C)
fta C)
C) - C) CR CR C) CD (ND
CR CD CD C)
CR CR CD C)
ftCD CD C) (I (IC
CD r- CD --.
CR CR CD
-- CD C)- CR CR CD CR CR C) CR
CD CR () CD C) CD :
CR CR CR C)
I
CD
H z < C) CR *___**
C.. () CD
CD -- -,. 0
. C) C)
CD CR CD CR - N)
CR. CD CR
.
CR 0 CD CR
2 C)
CD.CRCD
C) 0 CRC) CRC) -
CR
ft ft ft N)
-. .N C) CR CD C)
CR
ftCD 0
CR 0 CD C) C) (CD 7 CD CR
CD -- r- C) C) CD NH C) CR
CR C) r
C) CD H 0 C) CR C) $ C) C)
CD CD S (C) CR C) C) C) CD
CD CD CD
C) -< CR
(C C) C) (IC CR C)
C) C) CR C) CR
--
CD CD
C) CD CR 0 C) C. C)
CR CD CR CD
CD CD CD CR - CR CD
CR CR H CD H CR
.
C) CR C). C) CR --.
5
oC 4ccuscd N 8 s Ui sscs s tic Ic. sd
L hIuchc s, ioU sst ad
No 4cisc1 r
t. d\ a
AtuedN 'cc a: *hc oft nd
P11 Ictapp iPt'sttc or P1W c a
Ui if ptta
t
PW B1fl)sc' Ui
GLA tdVCtrdfl3fV) ad hi
s ha
Ii '
art dadr r 4
ibri a L. 1
U d
6
1n in thc land tie kI' C lous t ibct S (., n
1.1 ' tiC .it .r I '1' Ut '
. tIta %IsaLc taiii
(1
\ 17 Up.tii. ipp k.ii.'jt.it I( l'fl' 1
'itt t, t9g '
u cr f W. tidiF ik Fi Ic
rcl 1 r•
sr'i-1
%
4 srr :ass.ju!tiIlti 'tie unit. i%tdj P\ had
her suit PiA I md ')IC1 him tO n' t the 'diLl PI flu t
unning t ftc Iii d and r In inisab (PW 1O) as prc sent in
th 1 iii' i ( Cl j%( 1 I Vt i ' 't'i C tS%fll 'Si' i'z 'Fit dt u rascd 'cr1'
'Lub mnd S13MiE \' ci sc'tI Eu etu I tsklIfl '.it
4ni ..d 4 k ' rt % idirn. Mm tht dee. cnt.uI
;c atm ii "n the csTh-rn sick cii the !ind ne.ar 1,3%fll;rn ib'vvr
Ian P\kl ri tic.id tIr'r ice f it'' )S 0
titt ttd at Ca it 'at I
I'.jir ssh,dbc.I_.. PW a'-zr ..lLuIScit. l':it.a •e v: :
'p ar t Xc ii 1. t. C c'ci
r ' Iii i. on' .st.
S. . • P% .t ti •.: . S •i i --. ' :
ii ! 1' 11
1•, .t. , 1. ,,,'iti •h
7
st')flCs tlw"r onh tttcl cb.istcl i-" alit n i'V : rn.' lit ii
%la.kix fli Pi. I ' B.. .t .
i
1 'i _p tilt I "
list K 15,1 N'
.15%.'. ;lTflCi P'V ' it . .
! • : . i In I: I---- \ . d
8 akn as%duIcd PiA P'W'i. l' 0 mcI I'W I 's ui-ti ,'nh
Wl (b PW Ut. r Ox incident PW.2 als' %cnt I thc 'gx
on 1 5 ')n 200.3 ii. abuu 32 PooP PW 1 er'i
SaanLiI .biuh
pcslirt-- sI.liluii. it IS .tt .t tlislai.c ')f a) bins ficrn
Ow phcr of rcidcr't and fuel a zn 'n 'onpidint F I I
snipe 'as rr'gr.arinl ii Unna Nn. 20u3 PV '' s.-: Iii%l
informatio i ii 'h .TMF'( it Sn anur s ocr La F I ar .1
tt ) lit' t I a cirititec' iru
I'arclznanLO .'-ltI Ott ild'' cm ; jr is a--, Pa P
p pi I Il ' I
)( 4 J
t
't 'C
5.4 t tS • 'IJs" '10. ' 'n tr
'i. ' • ' • ' tiat -- --
(C" _i . .V -- ' -
: -
I
) I I
'.- ': Ji' i--,: • .•. •i •n: I --
• .. t, '1 • • . I
I V
1• . Ii
8
bh ccIii:' as rtstilt •': n'uiiiplc' t%tcrn.1 .i'tl '
1 r;.;
•ijr
itilUlig S flit it Ut ' d'.i .1% .$
t,
13 ( • . I? l'i' ''rs pry r
pis r"tcr '.a r i'i Tn s lot I'
•Iie 'uruid it tutu .•c
J)\ n. .L • c "t
1
t\,a.'' i'
'n 20 ike 003 md cc llccusl I ST and snolwic al t'
p
t ort AItc
onpk tion ,t in' cst'u it 'or P2 filt d liarpe bet t tw tirist
tIit Jct.tIst ci Pr a
4 id
mic'ic " uflrne't's ti (hi i nrnnntiaL. thy Itarncd St ssiC'ln .Juclgc secut-.! thi prcscnc c c f at ascd md framea the fo'louing c hat gcs
--rhat •'n 14 n Jilt) night 'on the abnvc' said .trcustd i Kim d' illa n (isbn U I-nut rIispitc- ht !.'t-cfl ..niüIcLiiicstitS I.itt."i C A't ci i i • flhillflci; C '.nsptr€t' L UI It Iii '4 '1 .ji' Nct i ii! 1' ir 'UI' itit ''i-ill c .i .. r ' : itb' '-':..r.*rt Ii ;t..
et ir t1 'c S it 14's .'t .• •'_.•,•,'.
.'
-'o'
'1 t'
() is a
- t.
ic 1
.s I,
- I ... j,_,•
1 * I I
C)
iii itlatIC)t t( land dlSl)Utc flf 1% 1S I and
1:' lB .ib"iir iikiitg hei' :nrses%InI th&rrb
''fliflhltic C' Hfl i)Itiflht t jMIail%liJt'lC U S 4. IR '" •' .ffl.Iti/ 'Pt' On tic sin-ic late mc ann plicc u tw bovc saia arc used be'riQ inemlwt i dii 'inlaw ful :i%sembl' and iith rofllmflfl bwrr en' 15 n 2003 at abn't X..0 d.m. 'vhen ceranago'jda P au1 a 'n a lurid 9 No jr ) ' K'nubaramallur 1 c'c armed utF clubs in] 'il a tones. ommitted r tm, and it r b tnmrnit'ed an offe-'w c- pur'ishablc indnr e lion 14M r n t i-P-i [PC ad itIitn Tfl a fl1flfl' t ) ) a a a1ictiC d ' -iii I hi 10 •'N ill fu-'d!dfl;hI • 'i:J • - -' ,! .-',,gt -- , - Cl i L useel No . t. • a tn -'151st alit •' l ('ttira
-L L1setI •-' d 1.' ci :r.' . %s-l::I '-Li A sun 1 C( el I'
--
a V
_2 '-4 •i •- --
-- ,;.__
I.
V
10
On thc. same d itt taic i I plac c hc
jNne sand dc'uusc 1 No% 6 q b"ttcd Al t V
intl nina oinnu 1 o)qee 1w. rt.t,IflflT :nugwjg'i (It
\r( nasc i. it P jI an i 'lareL' ''ni' "rd -In
dftriey r I' r I TN
aflt 1
i
t hi:. fli% '.2szi/.t.
On I , 6-2003 at ibout 3 t yr "c u tht
abow said accused nih onimon )bjc c't
ro
criminalI trrspasstd t1 at land S No n 2 u
Kairiharamallur villapt with •in intention to
'omm t nminal lien e against 'ec ranagouth
Pat 1 in c.latic r to I rnd dispute they b
n)nImnled an '1kncc punishahl" u 447 r
.rrlozi I Vi IPU rid v itJ'in rim ;gnit nrc
hi 1 %t dit lyric 1
i' '.( It
•ihnt c
:
1 cj i' c- Astd i1.
j--
1 .ot'fl'.,i. t'bi. •
7.
'rc'fl41U
i
1 est'L 1
''
e cj i
4 ,Jj
erj.I IJ.Irll ;!'n
to ft 3 ar N 2 fts ar
r 1
7 % C
:ilia 'vii '•flhi
r 1). .:.:,.i.', :,.(. %. ' T
.t 'I J•( 'b S 4 •? I
1
It tel 1, a
•. • r •,_
It •%t , a .' .' ;)•r
I ' •c. .
'I
II
Litid Piitt..na Ha'lin ..nd t),en"b :'flinnhltlf ri in
offcnw punishtbk' i % )Oo i ' 'im 1. 1-9 Ilk md within nfl ''wi Zant On the a flc' da t nil pHi.. 'C cLl)UVV 'dud dl tu'wt ,'iuii C()fILITI')ii .'LNc'l ttirrattutd coniplahiaiit Slit.ttappa (mud Pdtil and ta Ballan and thereh committed an nifenee punishable .i s O6 r' section 1 fl TPC and withit ins e. )J scifltL On thc sami late. urn and pla e ',c U thi abos ',aid ac usea ,uth ..' mmu'i :,bje U i t .) d.S%aLlltt'i • on.pla'n if' Siwtfappa tn'ud:i Paul cad Sin I fltcb Bill ii v th 1 1 rd
--.!r"le, ..nd '.t'ier dt ic_'tj ttiSt1a', ' in 'A) t!iLI hut tne . it aus d xdil 4 arc orrir j ulki e oil is a ft U 3' I v in.' : 14'' IPU cAi'Ci 1 %ff I'ib !'4 £ I II I -- 'i%'(l ( at ''t :' ! d. n 1 d .
.• 3 r I
n WI 't
\'):
F i,' ..'
. 4 ,. '1 , •I, --
r s • )
4;
) I
:%L--l ._ :L°:s,-- •''•.''
u..•'.;t_--•
)t
•
''3 i' "
' _Ad T
47 i C, '' i. 1
' ai sr
5t' . ) I •d P 4 • .3 t IT' p.o
.
.!.1--Ss. --..'
F
JC L I' t L P 'a 4j 1SU ))
'TU'; U f'U nflJt.1T1 '"ILZ.Ljt' (Ifl p CflL'gSflS 4' •U sPT.
I
• cc n '.t
' at n . '4 I
1LIU..sqfl )1flO. IflUi 'In
a:°q \d WI 'ltfl 1P41
q pa npisip sn pm c i L d ) T4
1
uapT* T
n asc id i (q paunuvxa csos
)LZ1 .s?q] PUt {flO4 Sr pnna fl U-fl' C I Md 'IS? r I kd '0! Nd
&M :iw n ao;j nm uon',nosd ,ti pzoddns ai
PU otd Q[ icI vi i.j 1d C,\4 t lid T•lld 1 %id 'p-)UTJTPt.
cassauzi ' qi zsivu>urp •UCLTJ L1flO' TPL.tl nil JJflJ.)fl 'fly
S ' ' .okl•i.t•1 10tJ(J'sj()j\
'(J r'
U '111* f -
-- ( ) \ P' 91'() 1\ tltU ITITUTUS ç 1%
.t)UTi% )VgI .Jg,% jlfl I )flflTg
.. !Cl
'1
p"'1q 1 t 0 lb
'flOl U) '
(I (IN SlTPddt'tl) J° " " IT OW
£ 014
13
i P1.. n inti lliai tnt 1)1 tilt at ' ha'td PW I P\\'' Ii:ss
%1;).IAI bat .it tiSt c! 1 't' ttink M.c .
• %J fl. 1(1 J •j)% 0p
fv
t
tt'tiic it lad t'sv 'Wt 'W W £ C p
•jq
ft It 1
•t'ttct( •fl!j' .ti !,.hs lI,.i st..t)t's '•1,' " '!'e
net d u thus tht snd urns and pirkup M C) F c M 0 10. is i n' c l'asing ib PW I frnr'i thc. tPst plu c cd ii ( dt ni Furthet. tilt fulfiL ot dti'ffllct t' C iitflrSS W'l$ ti';t rn'--nti.nnrvl irthcomplantExP i it Fit ctylain ta itt PWn aconipanied tb Ut ct-act-i atfIrr i1 I h- I:iitl ' ith met lie' person.
12 PWG has statc.i that tF .1 (USeC t iricd
.wsault in PWI -- M€dir oft 'F( usccl ) CF ci p MO t'
ti' NI (t 10 ilit Ill ii 1
CULt! t1i%fltilCVt LI r' :dr itce ' l'W', is
.4i' ' ii u' at e
.a1 '
sit. v It ; '1 tiC t' P(') I fl tiI.tit i1
r. '--". '--,i;'! t' it.. ri •r I.
Vs ,. C I 1
.--'• 1
'!r.. I. .-- •
•.I
•1• . • • • ti
I I a i ' I ii
14
he statercnt 01 Pikt 4ouli not ha c txtr uttrdc I t C 30
;) ii .I '7 U p.ii.i •i. 4
tj •I jtt •4 Lb it ii' 1 h.:!
PW' . it 1,'
'w )nr rd Ic ndLnc ti i'i Ca' . i
aalnici'i \ i Ibt a'e.l. I-',i '''-- nhi,t'it 'i 1..,t 1 r ha.! 71)T
disck,s d tic. ii cadc i t t in mc is U c. wider t
((7 it-' Irk tlir 'icU sp.4per 'i' t hr nt 'a dit my! ning
Hoievcr thc hargt. sheet shus that thc statLnlert 1 PWn
'tas ye. nided t. same' d€n. nhieh atI1flflt be it cc Ø.(C1. LU h s staunwnt be fore fle 1 x i F'ke ,a', ic.' st ted tni he had gone tt the nui;%c il de:icd IC 'tic F' a er pipe i'he l.t,rj 'herr :ne n ide 'it tcs•k pl..cr eecljricrlir tn ihr r'.ad a d tic nilencc ½ 0- 1 t 'n 'c. r•z r ', lllap(,c., ii 'e Th'r ,it ? I(' ..iT. !' t i: t'wide ii: 1i.scI 'c 1 t'itec ;jt :hai t . I' i_I ) C 'I '_H ':ilat' ts & P !-"A'.. PC ':t,rr àre h,. L 'ti' r 1 1 1 ,.. 1 • i.et • •, r d •• c-- . i;
• ,.'
I . ii
..• P. * '' ' j ";
is
Sessions .iudge. obsen itit 'hat rite' prestli. '4 these
'messes thc placc rtIe I. HI it ihi is
.fl''flsi%fl'r
.. it,
fl' ir ' tr!rp. 1 hr .' ujrrn t j.(..
•' 1
hi-- k trg s Ix s'. nil . -',-niabit i N i.'i .. Is uZ' "cr
acquitted thc ac used 1 4. We havt heard Sri \ M Hanakan icarrrd dditiotiaI qat Public Pic'sec'utor for the appellant md i K I .Pa ii.
warned counsel for an used I to 5 and Sri R (1 Kinili. icanieci ounscl for accused C t 8.
15 Though the pr•)sec u'i'n has .-xannnnl .22 witnesses
°1, PWÔ 'W PWI & PW er t
a r n'cl
lIjk%St ' •kn. an' nit iii. P. . tn tflaIflr 4 jfl
J• . ( S
• onsoir.t' brt,i,rcn v i' ci i 1) f 'ii'. S. :jt,.--j n r' s I
)rI \c ha ,nc tccl t
jt 1t
.t..çe.',sirj .nd .iIsu I
t
1 rC
t'Cs3fl PWI .. T'1 s uec -
1
r"
r •
. U,a • 3
t' ; r 7 'it•
'1 • _t.% i .•' •
j';i,j
itn' -- ai.ti-, i (i_il,; v(.I
St • .1 ii 'I JF1 Ii
16
nislavai of M () I is, \I.() It' i%\ h Rt.c1tippv .1 aId iS tnt
rcss sc,i iii'i of Mo t MO PVv14
'1. gh gj; ).,ctrj p ,
p-tins fig irs' pllt(1TW.st.n. t. 'n
.JiFL_ ii Si. •n'u PV C' 1' Ku L:I •s II:r pol!
h took ilu. tic ad bout I kte ist 1 to boson ii ft t
'nofl in cxa
ni'iaticn
1 PWI6 B I.) I ilwir 'cas enp.wc I for
senich of atcusrd '" i ['WIT .Jn.trarn "anird 1 scaird
tit ty ics in F SL at B,np,i,'tt ''tatla N
PW I ts--Knsi
1 alkei 1
is esteda u 'di a PWI H iiirc.idv Ku k u
F SI. report front Banealorc. PW_. Ashok Bisappa i a
I • init't Eiuvn'r' pt .'çtirud ht- skeic h .1 sec--ne ("I 'it ('Lii ft 'is •'
PW 1 B S T3cniin the PC Ii c tt'ii' t. bit, v Fc CttlI d lvi I)
MOl fir. t I r S d
•, _s ( :;. Pt i.c t .%t 't • ! 4 IL' s ii jJ. t. • •' s
•g iJ:' its
:, •n.'t: t . i- ç,'c. s ' •s -- I':. "., • •. , ' r;.
1.1. C t S It t
( 1 ' I ' • I. •n c •ii
••..,; '!'. %:.J : •:.'
I I
•r
17
and nut 'd sail hind. surve't No .L. \. :nea'suies I a' z-e s arid
sar '%icI-Pnicsrs1arcsatai 1 .trc' s
pLir' IlaShi fly ?fle 'ln'e ?snj f.' thi$ Inni tI'i. fr 3 ,-% di'.!.- 'P
ix 11cc i th t.jj r •, P'Vl (die..' isctiI w I i s's ci r,
brothcrJ 1h casts icrc 1 g betcei 'I-c ir'ceased in I pend n u'brI "k. n 4€ ilisni N'' 6 dfl(I hi's suns in lai arid ntlk"
rclatiws h id thrc au nc d thc dccc ised s'atmg that ti C 1ould kill him on 1' On.20u3 .tT about 8.iO -a itt. hi1c P 1. is a 'ic'mc PW9 wlc 0 unIt Ih irlormea 1-'W2 Ihat thr deccas d s bc'raiz r,sauatccl b ic.used 1 to .s flS2 mfnrmcel PW1 ar'd PM, cnI , 4 t the- lard arid s-rn a' i used JO clhi s i r - $ s ultngflc Ieasec' i-f 1u1,s ai tutu rt p.i; t-- 'I - £ t b n1 •fl in deer -ss'--d 'ti ''e .
- 1 tgc net 1'! lc'- ci r 1' SctU In ce ci Wc is ifli (f t. U 'tic 0 1' P 'oc ds '\lt.'i..- )r_ -ititi st-,f-7yfl flt,, I '.'(f - !.-
S
11-. - ' n • ' '.-- -. - s. ' _ T e •- -at
i_It ' A %t, I- I'
- (1 f
I I •
18
P% l( linumsat' lull. k. P\ I lIuchL.pp Puiar rum n the
'scu'otF' f.PW in hr'.PW1 ntt tic i lrcl
Ic ant th.t 'i Itt z jc 1 isccb 'is asatltt. r iS
ii.-'acl 1fl o'U ejj)r' ,ai •' ti •-
iIi)iiflf% PW I alleged 'hat tin- iris. hit lit bad 'aLt ii l)IUtr
he. ,i'e •f 1 twe en the deceace'l and
'he l.;nrl elispute h accused No', PWI namcd l, ac,caMd and nher xi his '0mph Iflt I In hs Hence, PWI vt' stated thai on thc latc A incident hi' lather Vet an goudi Pan' arid P14o hhurushidbasha tnt 1(1 the MaIIige land'. liinvevn. in the' '.nipaitI CE I; i) diet rj;1 t;jtr thai ht father wrr nlflfl, Eat, t PW 1. i'l M 1- A -it i % c Cl C' isid • iivc c ?V . a C liz '1 il r5l'1 L. fvløi ('n C Mitrs;
d i'r a' h. :.j i.
'- :'lei V l14% •-..'
,
!- L'' rfl,l-e •-: . ,_
. •-. ,. t:,_-
._
1 •_.
t -t
• I ie ar.IP • - I ' t
r
• ) J
) • I • • C.
S
Cl) D C) CD CD Cl) CD CD r CD CD CD
CD ° ° cx
Cl) 9 9
E. ; 9 E 9
CD• 9 9 CD 9 --
1 --
CD --
CD •C CD --j CD CD
-- rt r Cl) CC Q D
CCD - - CD
CD CD CD CC C) 1 CD
CD 9 CD
Cl) Cl) r
9Cl) p C) CD
CD 9:
CD
CD CD
9CD CD
CD 5 CD 9
CD C). _ < -- -I CD - C)
C )) CL - C) C) CCL CD
- C CD CD CD CD
CD Cl) C) - C)
9 CD 9CiCD -- 9 -
9 9: 9C) Cl)
9
CD CD C) - CD
- CD
C) CD
9CD
CD <
Cl) CD C)) CD % 9: 9: 9: C) >•
Cl) CD C) CD -- CD CD Cl) DC) Ci. C)
C)) CD CD
CD - CD j CD CD -- CD
CD CC-.. it
C). CL CD 2 9 CD 9: CL 9
9 9 9
CD) C) 9 CD CD 93 9
CC C) .
C)
9Cl) 9C) 9C)
CD -CD
9 CD 9 9
C) Cs) C) C) - CD CD
C) 9. CD 9 0
C)C)
9
9:CD9C)C)CDCD9C)C)9LCL 9.
i C) CCL. CD CD CD CD CD C)
9- 9:
-9 2 9
.
-tC9 --÷ C) CD CD
' CD
C) CD C) CD C) CD --
$9 0 Cl) CL
CD CD C9 CD CC CD CD
CD 9 Di
9Di
9
-
9
C)CD CD CD
CD 999 9 CD
< --
C) .
-- CD -
9-i CD C)
C) Q- C) CD C) CD < C) C) CD
C) CD .
CL CD 0- CD C) (Cli C) CD 0- CD CD
C) Cn Cl) --, C)
-- C
20
had t-ainuwd P I 0. P's \ issued Ex.P IS t F.x.P.
1 iwn in
it is sited dii: PW. aid 1
PV ir "xnw'n 4 ''
)('0b2003 Tn° jaw 4 'r idtrt s )f O) 'n a t.
I%4 un V -' tI 1
- is s t d t'-i t mi irus r hi t
to 7 dais cid 411 'he thrc injuries statcd b PW4 lound 01
the bod' ,I PWL ire simplc in ntuzc md the ta iwunes
tound on PWr erc tenderness over lion: ol chest on both
sides of mi'icIk hut- upptr Thin and iendernns n'r let' any
upper and t'u'er pdr's and they 'wry simple in n:i"l' 1". PWI has stated 1a1 1 PW was 8(' tears .'la and she was assaulted with thr lulis .ind sin its. n' tn e nr ding nju. e 1 s I nm'- or t1 erso i I P4 k I c r.
.1 5 ii c ii. \ a t r I a t -
'rn t ' at I- I i T$ C 1 ii I't 1 P PV - 'i 1 Li t •'t it a' C. ' £ - I--c. r- Si ' c • '1 r 4 C 21 ccordni' to PWb h itd t% acitci ti-c I canc I I cc isid (j(1 1 ilL . 'fl i i :j .4 h%lIti -- ' li t • * j 1 L'\7 • c ii. I I •)fl ihei,r , tit% c f 1 i'd r Sa 'r ar i' ne's th •it--' C t%( ci lot ii ie l.ist 20 't . ilk rltt c ascii hULL 3 r)hlcil shop at Say anur mci PW6 isas ilso upplving apr tiltUra. product' to th shop of h dec cased. PWt, ii 1 n g I md of 1 tires at Satanur. hi t. iamv 11 • tilt).. on !c dt:c Ot incident t rip Ct lttr pipc Ironi h Inc 4scd appear' tn hr unndturai. tbdt P6 h ning La .1 n's "I md • I h s 'nw and hdting "ippi'. ul agiii'iilti.ral pioducr 1) L tht tleci.ac,ed ' I r t a. t 1 s sc cr '' • )fllr •it -- -- .•t t . ili I. • si • jr i •• I r •._ I' L a • "upUt ..7 ii•.t fr ii. arii-'' 4 , h.n'.t • I 1 '4 .: '' • -- : ' i'.ç 1 f li r. • •• r • .: L3. ',ialaat),jt '••• - . . -, I ' C •'j: • _ • '_ .' r .._..•:. 22 that thur It mis n'nlw •n thr r'.jdenrt that Ui'' land whrie thi incdc tat i s attd : , hnc akin vlat t is hr tun i 0$ .() 1111 andJYOU im 1 ko i ng Pi& ibti ic ii •% I U() %tLp tton lc'tl C h, •'j 'I It '.t: £ (flfle ifl flat cl Plc'?..' I ol P 1 Ui it peoplt I id uatl -rt d flt at UK place ,fn irk it Rut PW) has shied ib a lit did 't n nst ltrn c 'ti k' I't tfl Thr pit scTh n fl% s dotabtiul 'is E P1 F.t.R. t,irn oy PIWI does tnt rca. o PWt arn'rna t hi h'u4 of derea%rd at U?'Ofl a rn. •tflfl gt'itic ,ilorij tutu, the cite easni tcsarjs the land 2 In the cross-txarninaflon tic clefc nc has spec fit'all supeied that nE'P. ' ii .atri 1 P\43 -I t'l' ph.nic.d PW'2 it is .ulst' ji':t stca: a tI;;tl P13.'...' nets rn'c 1 ivt' . TCfl)i dli iJ%i'i ,b I 71 •1 • ii: '' ut :v •s -i' Lt F.x P 1 f1 9 c stiC r a'• . .1 ':1'. •' .t. •,'' ' c.' ?' -t I' L. .1 • •--• Pt !.: '.'- . t 1 r -- '. ..' . . ,: j -, .. ' 1 ' It I flj P ' a a. • F, S.. vt PM t' dC 0114) 111% Ifl" h's (cttLci . ir Eta' ii hi I n n'•s.' ',nrcl 'ha. PWn '1% iliac 'if 111( t'ts.k. ".h.' c ;I1t t. h's r'"" ' I 1 b urtn ,. ;fw'ij n PM( hid (lilt' o &r ' r 'F'r i i. t isu c + 12 yi fr4r f ipwith t OO) a.ns. to tetch a tt it"r pipt it is in thrsc. jrvlarnstana t icIt'nrr 'I PM 1 v as disbtliei.i ci fl% haVing seen tlit' int'nkiii Ac wding ic P2O. thc bstancs is abr,ut 2 km r kss flow Kalinadi. '. lhgc. lb u"t lu. "'i I r( )t PW' hc s ti PW2 rr. rit ci trirphi;tic ili :rc.n T'%\ Ca hos ii %upportrd the . at' :4 prosi cunc,ii. it pw ') had tont t'a i all PW2 it wiephotie. lu must la c 1 1 he il tt fi 'ncidcrr mi orr all I PW1 rt he t'i ph 'w. d. 4al'Lilit (+ ,F' :t 'Li' .1111. tg.tt pI'on' ', a .,ritcd 1' 's tr 112's tIlt 'Ji1't 'iWt 5 .' •" 'hai PY .'t.ihi Ii a "' ).., 1 lt:' t' ' .i ac .1 C. a, 1 '. 1 •l a C iii' • 1 t ci ICC C a)i 1 4 i • 7 a_I --. I il' .1. . . • '% t ) . .• • 4 .. I • 1 ,.•_ t. I. ; •, ,,, ....._. • I t ,. I, S S I ' ,I c S ) 1 1 t • ' .' b' Ijs . -- 'L' ,., :_ _ •• '. " ,.• .' .•-- •.' .•.• • I ' (1 14 DI r • ' i.!'' . ! i 4' .';; . ¶. • %%_13 Jt: I J' 'I 1 O' • p ii fl tLTs'313--1)pPi 1.11! ' j "I lit ct j4 ) 1' )', )Jt ?t '1 PC 11 flT; g 1 .;(ffl .t-Jr, SjQtIi :J t'vs'p "Ti f'i ;lI•at' I_%ld 'fliT: LI3Tli3 pnirpvq 'a pap Pt pq) I qnxa, aqis 4I3 jJdSCjS scq 1 114 Plt'JdP ?44 1 Inrss' Ut) zlu I pti • )qtt.'"i W ta'.it4 p )%' .1 )Lu \d ,' .-a%ii')4 •fl•1 4 lAALJIj I' IE1S4 1j III' ' 1.1k q pfl'I)TI " Md lid P • t!( nmvctp r jJaLjaflW UhiIUt)JU! £)IJI? pure )ucqd. i •.j •j tT!P W3•1I bT.IOqd atp fltj 6Mcf ITflP%%P 10 iinp flit Jflt) fj% )U) Sq PmU)P %i UI Ii UI OtjW (d WOIJ UtRIPIUIOJUI au i $ )J; ;j)_ { 4'"1' 1'" '1' i1f 'i '$ Ija I 'L'JIIji' )Pd14., )I f' • s ''it, )JL 'h' ''LI 'liT 1)q,JIv ( ;en"• •' : L l\cI % ).JrSLtL je'U3 'LU! flUt [mi_I 'i\.. •AILl'ITflI_I JI' 1111% 1! 1 "1 • 1 ''J tz 25 It' ifli. dnt br till 2' a." 2003 Pi& 4 I''ttor lij. *sI.jfrd 'hr injut it a'r sinipir 4 ( si..cr ic ' 2 ti; 1 p iF nc it d 1 i nat't I tlic &, h.aI a ci )'rc ' pond ng r 1 K rin H cn a vs doubt •ts t', htthei P i aim JAk 3 terr issai'iteci li ihc accused Further PM, sN uld habe ilteret çn 'eous injuries 'Ihr dela' in e'cazrnna'InhI oi thc i"j'Ir'et In P\.$ arid distan e between the p14cc ii nccurrenre nd the h"use of F'Wl hc pnscrcc I PW rat a en is d ubt s 'hrthci PW1 hart P .thtcI the pla c' cii nc'idrti' and itnt ssed thc sami it p 4 c' mi, tti s t'. ci beth PW f q 3 p a' tJ, l 'SC. 1' t C 1 '1 ilk '. 2, PWc, 'i the-- L cSS \h' tilt U '1 tos flLL q s h ciIi' i 4 a' •1 7. is i.' ci , ba ±1' '--f• t. I • K •• : (3:, : ' • . P , - a: t - -- .3. 4 ic. r -- . .1 2 Ii. t sj r r ' ( (I , 3 ru. . . •t f' • 4 ''Si I.. •3 . 26 itriesscs P\ 2.? had rt cci dd I hc. s' ltcmrnL ot 1U1CSS S h 1 ..r .ji'tci (n.OO .'.fli in itidint' tlr stnteqient lit Pie. 13u1 1WsI) Ii 1% t % ' d t d tli •t he iine hac i. tr',r; ai. vu •u ''u sainc .li 26. ii js in thc,qe ..ir 'umsiancc s thc trial Coui ii 6 dis1xl,recI fin tcjer.. e ot i'Wl, PW P' nd alsc; i'wr PW., on1 %peaks '1 thc conspirac. statine thdt he overheard accused o to 8 talkinc to cc used 1 n , 1 c ire the brothers c.l ,he clecc astd "- r rr ' PW' -.tates that he was nnt st.ncling itt ar i li place i'hi re rhc accused crc talkinq but i was nssing fr ri th sad 'a aid 4 ciief l 1 ' i ' xirer it n ' U -cii is U ih it' b's Pi 7 'Ii na5 fl(f fla r lic ':ilSjMi'ci' it '1 c'. n.t A ft -- ' TT% 1 cLCU It t )P nrnic 'it 'sicr . PW p4. x • n I i-cs s. .1 ' i I 1 • C' -- 1.11 • • : tt_ pjj I 'v n • ,• -- r 27 28 hilt k ring t is lppcdl. 3( 13,1 cd scnc r,rn, tclur i re ti '\ di i C i,t;tI' th.C 'iu CA Hi. . .1% II '1k )'r%'c'crJg t(rtr' t' ',iit 1 (t '.9 !flt sv!tlc,' P'' t'Itr• .si'd .ts .11 .1? ,Qt t;. %4r •1• visual nirnntr similar ('Vt t' ih' ix urdrnu ite acc.ustd %nintifltbfll 1•t der s.n iinn fl_I • ,t jltr p t [a's 't r t ' .4th 'Icfeated ilic wn Purlx)' of ret ording ot t t iccustd snuenc'nt I 's '. iii" • nrh t 'c ucr Iorc d in uak' ten tin obs. wiions tilt bunk n c..' FWO ing ihe lldr'c. 'x ,nd rnis nabk di 4 th 'b' tgaiizs t .IS& at is r tlI tflj p. ')bCt Utk'fl it i' w d'w hdrQC (A %'fl ertgli ;i rnairn.a r It d 1 ii )rcit gird ke r tI 1 ii' ed 3' i V • r inr. ast •.! u' I' ftn"tur' . pr cnn 'in--i acy. I. I(,%S. i1.,•i, ' ,ctini o.. 'I., tat I't ':j tr t.fit t 'I" (1 '3 5 1 F .•'. _•••g•••t t:.i ,. .3 t,.%. ' 1 .' 'I ,.' i :: r" 'i . I': :. f. ,: , I ' . L'.' t • 28 thi piose Ut )' to "c tt. .11' tic tuk.n' e tot thc Sc I utin ui :r.1 i.ifl' • SUIt 1 fl. It : • :. % •''tl the idt't.tt tfli Vt • nrc' (.11 1: In pru%c d it lr:.ct tte';r 2 1 x P I PC t itle "I Crirrs.iaI Pt' i •ftu. prt '.: 1' . tIit' a"'. proc 'durc nf c'ondw t ci iria I hc pr,' cdurc' inc.Iudc s • ppo ' n'ty U hc )c(ltscd 2 In this tjSt . P' 10 .ind P'i 1! 'tic hi direct titiichSc% Ibn 'tarc tn alt d bi tic. çn secUtni a £ ve'itnes'*s (crta n1 thcir evidcncc 's riatcnai o pn fin the tiara a.a nst tic cus ci PW 9 IWI ) and PW' 1 a c turtied 1 hate' hostile cult lenieci that thc had srrti t hr the sc 'Ielr.w'tcf •rnni hr pm '•.u'-- 'ri'idcv. Sit. 'ilnc --.Srs 'i'dtflfliCa ii. 'h pi list • •n --.u I: I.t x trs: 'n ' r ss •• -- S -. T'rS" 1. fit. • .3 I ti(' fl, I ,t I '. Ii 1 t S it ' . Is •(t .•a••: I • . ---- . . .t i• . (5 • • - It t t • -- si. r ;i • 29 is tontrar to ilir n id.'nt e mat Led iii ih€ evidem c ni ih:tt tfl( 4% in :ri. • •t% ( •. •i Ptk ! a c :'n: t :hv ast, bit. thcsc , tnt w s " c. dttr 1 ted 1 rorr tic a t 'tnt start--nients. I hr pithik pr''%nulor nisteaci nI tu11cnin tist sttiled pnkctlure in gettnw the contradiction maiktd in thr cidcncc has fnllocd str nge prorc dun Wholt ci tic statemen' made In PW2 in PW 14 beic,n the Pubis unde' stc.ti')n Iu if thc. C'ndc of thc C rimrn ii Predurc 5 markcd ;tsEPQt;,EP .4 The a is fail ul c t se ln C un adwrt. p, P .r'tc A ' R. 944 c 4lCU.L( . 'n i, the ,' suite' 1 cwr tt' Ral'en'aii'i 'Lb isiLai. •n%'lciu 'he rg tic •t ii. all L cc r 't C) j...,t. 1 f.." It I • .f 'i i•'. Tj . ,. r;.' '.a •!.'• . a I L r.r:.4 •. .:, •'• .... I' '4. • g. . (1 •1 Is ' is this. the attention ut 1)It wflnrss sh(flihl lit pointc dl Jr a n tc th por ic ii c hc. pu uous statemt r t h ( Q.j''.j fit t,'j '. ii' f'! I. 'i 111 %tItrnictt1r iflil lit j nuld N. tsktd to ,,' c tid• plana wi as Ii lank proper in iespec't of the contradienon Ii is .uil that JWJII1('fl .4 the' prrvinus slailrnwn' 'viiic Ii ' •nlrit'ictOn t'' the prescnt ft stimorn could lx. marktd Thc. tnUrf' prc.vious statement in hieh hit eontidclieIlnn Cippears should fbi be put in c.iidc n c bu )t l so much thcre I as is ontradic to
o his test'mnn before the jun 3 The Apex Court n i judgrnt ieported in JR 1?
Supreme 1
(
n nn 214. " the nu--itici .J J3hngu'ar mat• ;' TI'
"tCLte c'f Pinjah Ii has ,bsu' td Ilt .%'
'Ii i i, 1
r(r jt r ' ., .111 'ty.r', .. .
'tdI'C' :nir'c. in.! t
'r aiy',rdc'' .i
ft ii) 1 i
rd 1p'b_ . 1 4. •1
r
• t,'j 1j:.j •7.
. a'
1.1 r • ._
• .1
.
4 c
31
rciu rated. 'So & ubi hezi utnt si tin ns hostile oi 'iVL%
t ndeia e 1( • liii ctaT ilitili 'z'id(lt . nidc I t"t It sr it'd
c thi Cnd •, c.. uti T:€1 P k dur 1' sb II lit P'n, :1 e
tt no cf si 1 4111*. ouc Ii ir*' itt s pr 1)16
statement hich J% contrailicton sc as itt rnihk tlw ittirs%
, ex1ain the %QPt Ilinjiub th' Pr" t dur' r 'Irs rea
c
5 1
cli setth d hoci nrc z. we found that in somc of the c isn the irarneci Juders ha'e qhonn %Cfl n'%IlaI ippi'o.'b ntlu'ting senior ecs:.n .JLdgt% 4 Oflir tililt s tile Lase itseit sr.inds C Ii ruatrrial untr adk U 'r' 'ant I in 't t 'dc ra.c Wi' JU' ippiet itrtnr the inpoiletncr "1 iia'kin' dc • "nuaclic r 'n he ml ne pm joLts q,jtç en? mach UI ider r. n' in it ' • ,t the tode iCr rir Pr c 1i rrii'c.i i it 's t'erti r a-i' • 1•' t .n 1 st ttr ti h.c i :c r ':
1" ," •CU('Sc. 'Lii uh'. t.?r,flJ, ft. mi . . r,:arkc 1 Ii c i iris iIre.jcmttf 'C .t 't it Ui 5i' )' 1 1 " 1 4,; %jr( (...i .i.tmtt'i .' •.1 Ii IIt,(1 I •,t; . Cl ,)1 'I. C''c.' • .'C) g %'f)
-- •i -- • ,, t. P I' I. .' I It • •• •;, .'I ' St a 4 1
--'tl ,f. •J :%. 'U • .': .1
s -- ,J 3S.
* )
cd t' ) . •A .
)• •t PU 4 '•' P
•4 . 1. rj I). )•)tU --. it'., Sc,
is t' --q
t - (4 XC' ) $V'%,i
)'T -- (iJ
4Lji ,21L:aA ):' ...; .aai) )af., ._;j :ct;t uii;iq
J'' . Is
C ha 11 1 4; 1 U i'! iv ti"fti
st .'-4'Tr'lP!t %S''• .)4. SC.)IIJlU l.'!pTsiiUO I.
'ii
' 1flPt 'flU St 1 21 lot) C. 4(10 S )UlIi
)
)tj: 4'' IUO'U.)Ifls l'ttLi')4 \UC 'Sn '4 .IetlIlIiVtX
cccii 4 saqnn n v ,'i rnapi X( jo ct.T
3
Tfl'tj '-IS S% fl1)IV, 4fl . 4!PaI .194 i)aJjC PI""
pan p iii 'q oi jqir s q)qi uxuiwic
'LI flS!S Lit lIP 44 s a4.11W l() 'U'.!) 1!PE.UU0'
) UflOtUl C 4 4 .a)I )1JJ1l' (4 JTlPSS )'b)U 40U
111.14)1 l.-I .341 411 1t1.)1SISiD)flhi (ITiuIaac
q?n )Lis lU )WIWIS nui iuj ' '9r
sflq,
I) l'1V(' 'I in' 14 11 11) IC .1)) 4. ' 'Qj d'T:
jJl* ' I LI?j ,(jj )%
'4 "41 cr L U'"i )L4' I3UTI)j)T%(1 11
3itq.' j.I'Hç) S. '(ft .atp 'I 'flUl.a J'.kj.'.411Ua' 1.fljJOIIU pHD jo
jiç
".1
3
some eteiit it u'i1d :i't 1K titIpiul I'' 'ontracIwt
ilitit 1iti1t%%
n Tnt-- pr I .i., .n 'Jr•isig,i iiortni •J I I iS
cupreirt C nurt C cflt _1ij) L.a (11. 7 1iPt' I\ h'
4drnin,stration i,' Inbhuz'un \c,th ci'id OtIwr3 while
(onsidenng the scope A Section 11)2 of thc Code I C r mu 1
Procedurt has obscr cd that the 1a is wc11 Sc U d thit
what a iticss hid id during intesti&ati n nrct ic
.zsedt hcrclithm sir nlcsstiitstt rthaj c.'
put v thc itrc s' 'sh le Ac pc s'n' in thr court
37 The cbjc t is to draw the attention of 'he i r ss , U
Pfl1OJ titc icrt d l-im'hn 't-1nrL t1
1 p
u' opjxn tu t he t v ss :, • am tht
1
' s irs
l--l',v •t r r r.. •t.'1, ? .. flisfl --
:s dza * k• • n.;1..t% Wn.,e1
1 • Wr..hr. •L %g.t •tjt
:
I 7 1
•
I
1
..t• ,. •.. . b..., .
. . -- 'l•-- •.'
V I
'
1
h i ,_siJt( t --
t •. . • .. •• IL •
'h. s' 1r.:y•r I ) ..1. ; .: . I :it --
; -- 1 '
!. • ,:•. • . • I' •;. 'i • .t...I •
34
tOt tains ti i am lttt fir its ii fl in not let d b'
' i1%?Utc
tli t,.i. j rft
(
4I,% Iit ._n.: t),.
(fl 1' ru U
1
1 1' 1--
C) 1n i '1 prc. •na i n.c.r us or t ci rot ri ti I"
•.t 'c %tut' Iaatl I t.dtlt •
1
Lnit 4(1. I
1'1_ t'tt T
1
£ t1 • fl
C trnvnal Pro cdure is ni rked ts marking clix uni• r i I hc
witrats'z m l'Irtr a
h
4 ' ' 'Lu" jXltliefl in !l C j)rC Pit
tatc tnt it. shich i usc Au in the Dt • )s c tiiicrn. If flit v nUn
Stctttlfltftt 'S 'iiettKt"Ll '1 a ikes u e. use rn I 't at i at 1
'h
.ight .n.ulablt t V fll%5 I 'C,itY;t?ie" ii) gtt tiLt liLa 11
rXLrat rd tr in t;i ',s. 'ii Ui '- as' ,1
c inp rt art ni
rrhvui' flu. Sfl S t
fl:A
: .C 1 flIt jl%4
mit 'hr pn "at I. iLl i-ni ti_i..
'wht 'C ;cs-cxnrr s ii vttr '.(5 il hat u 4
c.
"I ,st;lv i-ic '
r t'ut !1 t . ( • ! '11 7i)5% vS. 'flu! ;'1' if' )t
StiCf ;s its •' I V 7 1' ftc.. 'r(
•1 i.s V-l. .7 'alt 'e --s n? :, 1l.'L
' •ar.nIit rjt
I) ' I I
.1: .At •n •4?
•f.• •;.(I •'I: •
1 1
.e;. 1
t . 4 T. •
j _. I •:'A -- I %• ".3.l
A.
-I
35
V
;u• Ii (i.js II;t" hei ';lasr 'tflIfl')la tfldl ht ii,d
t ' t i' nrs : till.
lisi )fO'k)a lit tlictttisi tC ladtt I 'i
'%% C\ ut
iti.nt'"'
1 _'nci tft. pr t(!• ire i. 'ho I
o rali ta ni io ii'i )b 4t1 i C 't
it mn defeat rhe ' en purpose c4 Fir proWt Uticfls il'
%JtflQ rpe. it CP tin I!%( .411" the .1 'fe--n C '
10 11w wxedwc shnuld c,t ti, fit in deft' n thc
Jiasflrt. 1 hr lapse on the part 'at the' naurt or the 'ken'are--
mas itsult in dc mating ttit tide.nuar aiair
Ii In this tasc the lcan 1 Session Jide 1 sgi r 'C
hi 1', thj veI
1 setUe--d JLln'ipk- ul i1s.rIins? hc spnrelic 1(1'
314 'r'i nt.
a 1 r I t
,
'1 •
1
%l;ttP
d flt tT ' : ci,.. it .:c_.--sj '
1
r'i • tia • .1' ,
r ii cc ii I 1 t '1
Vt
•I' --. 'I D 'C j j • 1
•• ai. • • .. . .• I , . "a.
I Vj . .
1
36
put post 's t(' gi r .u 'tppn! et .nr'. in I h at usc d •. a'
txpj.ar iPon ic tpcct a trc' icc ic I t ciA ' i i I
t n irti nir atr sttt n'cin trc a 'us.c r ust z.kisti' I
a.' ' Ira i .waiflst Ii:zi, 'en't 1
hi -- dr il •r j r; •
ght. di) V'XL'il1tldt11)ii 1 ' thr sirnt , jip this tihjeri Ihr
1 --n
%tat
t t ',! 'z'
en ctsed is fl'( i nrc' cer tion 313 of 'lu
C ode of C nrnrnai Procedurc in qncstion iauc. k rn. Lc arncd
Judgc ' ill tx hating t-rt'rc prosecution cc nd iF
e udenct It is 'roni ilic. "vidtiac i tilt proc C itioli. !bt
Icairrted Iudt itiuM find out ct% 'o hich is uicrmiüiøtiniz
statcrrent aga!ii'zt Ullic h .. usc Li and SW h L's' lflhl'lc 'li_.!
atimen rr 1% ut pl.at ii arpl dc' t 1 blc igi pc
hci i. r1itsudcryai 1
thc'i i idrsbcrl )
RC. L" 1 I?t.il
XfJ t
4
j- ii v•vt
) 3
---
' 111' • rc,i •i1 ' '.,r •. • I t. r
'..!: It
it I Jt.ij jg .1. Ji . I .3 • ii • .i
•
I •t
• .. I
1 1 _ • I
'
•
1 S
37
cvideia of th % itflt 66 iS p It Th orn ques 1011. tithout i.iksiiQ ')iIt Tile Te'iet diii 11,' rlIfl.Isatii)g m St I ivt),cfl .irk.1 iI:irflh:ig therr ii i'npl 'p ir itt 1 a's' xi
14. in this a asr. thoueh rlii ce 1 tcidez (It each id ii't *itnc sses cont un sescid incnmin itin matc rial igainst the in'Usfll. hcaeer the evidencc is PUT ifl one que%iion. 'liich is not undc rsiandabie ntn ic learned pcrson to kno as to hieh is i ht liii riminaring statement against iiin ['he learned St .Judge has not. Jr mt d tiw gut stion or thc basis of the incriminating staterneni gaiiist eac h of lw.
accused Fur rxarnpk the e' iderce ot PW 4 -
Di K ,c,ia1l tl .. pe€Lk :n. mhnr ot 'u s .tt ii 4 flJiaIies. r'.jtur' ni fliirr% l f 1 t ml fl tF .' 1 4e a '--nq.--.i .iflt' thi' c u" )t ci tt usc. ' apo n irc di :c j4r% '1 r ' a 'i'ftfl' r • I\k i :. ••.• ,. j-
•: .,•,' t - fl•is IC • C.. I k-".% (i:.:. r•.•e • •' •: • -.';r) •:t :1 S J 1 ;j' %•s)? •. T •. •&J % •.• •. . P •i I 38 rrc ordiiig I ht r' aitt'c e .4 prn%ec Ut" Ui t!tflC%%t s ' i !'at tilt. k.arnc d Scsstc.n% lung u'iI hnc 'x.IIlt : 1 j 4 • n ii 4 'h" P osu tion the iecncd cssiwi J dgc. c an %U( ii 'lit tilliafl.tti. ig %t,ltt ftc 111% hi the a' tisni t1 tflt mm t.t questions, to en*bk. the .i cused to ansicr the sirne 1h' questions put n the t n'isc I u1l 1 tip lix 1' xp 1 .1 ke 'r
deciding rite (List 45 We ou1d not hac math. these obsercatinns bitt for aowmp horn setnI judurncnt .1 the 'ess n 1 ía arc t rra k Court regarding improper r' ording '4 the tstteme'r't' )f atcusd ander section .13 of tie C. xlc of Crimin,41 Pr w ciur 4itho .
1 ..t 4 r"isiuit'
wi' 'hc 'a c. '
-- •
saint. It ;es a. jJ1g
rI t nLti 'r r the' tbc ao" isud is ' 's" ie'vd ci
iq'uart rt i f%% f(lfI( t 3' t
'
' .
r'-" tb'. It .1 ) •1
•
Psi. i d jj'ct,. t
•-..:."
fS
.!'. ii . ;t r. i'it Tu.':_t
a
h.p.
3.'' ' I •-- •':"fl. ' I % .
1j. i_f_c' I--h •
It I
I L I
-s
appellate coiri t correct the irrcguianrt The purpose "ould
not lx sened in redoing the snrn tuhet Oh BCC nint of mu
'w thi puipose ma bet umt onh o
ti main; Howner to
protect thc criminal ist cc ',vsten the courts mu t iolkm
f.w and proper pruvedUn. to d%taul the deft' it of justice
mc tel; for tiM follnnnjç th corn ct proec dun.
46 In this case smcc the prosceution utnesscs han not
supported the case of the prosecution as discussed ;ibove and thc prosecution his failed to prow the charge alleged against the accused. we do not find an'. reasons to interfere' mth flu ju4rnent of acqi thai 47 In flu se cirun tarnes he 'appeil filed 1 ft Sr te lath ctiid acenrctiizgi; :t chsmls%cd Uc s',N. Psi-I