Karnataka High Court
Ramangouda S/O Hanamatagouda Goudar vs The State Of Karnataka on 12 February, 2020
Author: S G Pandit
Bench: S.G. Pandit
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH
Dated this the 12th day of February 2020
Before
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.G. PANDIT
Writ Petition Nos.105785-105923 of 2020 (CS-ELE/M)
BETWEEN
1.RAMANGOUDA
S/O HANAMATAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 14
2. DODDAVVA W/O VENKANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 70 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 320
3. ANNAKKA W/O RAMANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 125
4. MAHANTESH S/O RAMANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 28 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 293
5. BHIMAPPA S/O NEELAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 62 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 173
6. SHANKARGOUDA
S/O BHIMANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 234
7. SHIDDAPPA S/O BHIMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 75 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 224
8. SURESH S/O MALLAPPAMOTARANGI
AGE : 40 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 77
9. SHARANAPPAHANAMAPPAMOTARANGI
AGE : 42 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 70
2
10. LALSAB S/O MAKTUMASABPINJAR
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 336
11. BHIMAPPAYAMANAPPAKURI
AGE : 50 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 220
12. YALLAPPA S/O YALLAPPA DANI
AGE : 60YEARS, OCC : AGRI 169
13. SANNANINGAPPA
S/O HANAMAPPAKALLAPUR
AGE : 62 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 19
14. SANGAPPA
S/O DODDAHAMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 49 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 69
15. RANGANAGOUDA
S/O HANAMANTAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 42 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 207
16. SHARIFSAB S/O NOORSABPINJAR
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 289
17. YALLAPPA S/O BHIMANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 46YEARS, OCC : AGRI 316
18. RAMANNA S/O SIDDAPPA HATTI
AGE : 52YEARS, OCC : AGRI 157
19. VITTAL S/O BHIMANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 47 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 313
20. YALLANGOUDADHULANGAOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 123
21. BHIMANAGOUDA
S/O HANAMANTAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 40 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 264
3
22. DATAGIRASABALLISABNADAF @ PINJAR
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 197
23. BHARAMAPPA S/O SHIDDAPPAKAMBALI
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 229
24. MAHAGUNDAPPA S/O BASAPPAANGADI
AGE : 53 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 198
25. KALAKAPPA S/O BASAPPAANGADI
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 10
26. SHEKHAPPA S/O BASAPPAANGADI
AGE : 46 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 221
27. YALLAPPA S/O PANDAPPA DANI
AGE : 28 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 65
28. HANAMAPPA S/O BASAPPAPUJAR
AGE : 41 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 356
29. YACHCHARAPPA
S/O HANAMAPPAGOUDAR
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 152
30. NINGAPPA
S/O SANNAHANAMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 115
31. HANAMAPPA S/O KONAPPA DANI
AGE : 40 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 206
32. KAMANAGOUDA
S/O HANAMANTAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 37 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 307
33. SANGANAGOUDAHANAMANTAGOUDA
GOUDAR, AGE : 39 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 277
34. YALLAPPA S/O SIDDAPPA HATTI
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 238
4
35. SHAVAKKA W/O TIPPANNA HATTI
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 288
36. BASAPPA S/O NAGAPPA HATTI
AGE : 60YEARS, OCC : AGRI 322
37. KONAPPA S/O NAGAPPA HATTI
AGE : 66 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 256
38. HANAMAPPA
S/O YAMANAPPANINDIKESHWAR
AGE : 47YEARS, OCC : AGRI 138
39. FAKIRAPPA S/O NAGAPPA HATTI
AGE : 45YEARS, OCC : AGRI 357
40. MARIYAPPA S/O NAGAPPA HATTI
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 321
41. HANAMAPPA S/O BASAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 172
42. BHIMAPPA S/O NAGAPPAKALLAPUR
AGE : 70 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 32
43. SHANTAVVA
W/O SHIVANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 251
44. HANAMANTAGOUDBHIMANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 70 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 187
45. PARVATEVVA
W/O HONNANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 3
46. NEELAPPA S/O BHIMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 68YEARS, OCC : AGRI 333
47. BHIMAVVA
W/O HANAMANTAGOUDAGOUDAR
5
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 5
48. ASHOK S/O HANAMAPPANANDIKESHWAR
AGE : 35YEARS, OCC : AGRI 283
49. BASAPPA S/O HANAMAPPABALGOUDAR
AGE : 63 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 1
50. MALLAVVA W/O HANAMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 211
51. GANGAVVA W/O BALANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 50 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 310
52. SHIVANAND S/O RANGAPPAKALLAPUR
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 235
53. RENAVVA D/O NEELAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 46
54. DHULAVVA W/O DHULAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE :60 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 6
55. DYAVAPPA
S/O DODDAHANAMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 72 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 303
56. RANGANGOUDA S/O BASANGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 67 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 16
57. TIPPANNA S/O YALGURADAPPAGOUDAR
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 18
58. SIDDAPPA S/O NINGAPPA HATTI
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 66
59. MUKAVVA S/O SANNAHANAMAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 56 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 119
60. BASAPPA S/O CHANDRAPPAKAMBLI
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 121
6
61. HANAMANTAGOUDA
S/O VENKANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 68
62. HANAMANTAPPA S/O NINGAPPAKURI
AGE : 44YEARS, OCC : AGRI 126
63. NEELAVVA W/O MAHADEVAPPAMUSTIGERI
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 133
64. FAKEERAGOUDA
S/O SARANGAOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 70 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 134
65. KARIYAPPA S/O NEELAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 135
66. KONAPPA S/O HANAMAPPADALAWAYI
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 146
67. ABADULSAB
S/O MAKTUMASABNADAF(PINJAR)
AGE : 41 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 147
68. BASAPPA S/O LAXMAPPAMUSTIGERI
AGE : 51 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 148
69. MAGUNDAPPA
S/O YAMANAPPANANDIKESHWAR
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 297
70. YAMANAPPA S/O BHIMAPPASANNI
AGE : 44 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 150
71. MALLAPPA S/O BHIMAPPANANDIKESHWAR
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 155
72. HUSENSAB S/O NOORASABPINJAR(NADAF)
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 156
7
73. SHEKHANAGOUDA
S/O FAKIRAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 191
74. BHIMAPPA S/O MANAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 46 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 194
75. HANAMAPPA S/O RANGAPPADALAWAYI
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 216
76. SHANKARGOUDA
S/O HANAMANTAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 46 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 13
77. SAIDABI W/O BALESABPINJAR
AGE : 60 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 218
78. MALIYAPPA S/O HANAMAPPALAYADGUNDI
AGE : 40 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 250
79. ROSHANABI W/O LALSABPINJAR
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 285
80. MUTTAPPA S/O HANAMAPPAMUTTALGERI
AGE : 34 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 291
81. HANAMANTAGOUDA
S/O RAMANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 60 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 72
82. SANTOSH S/O MEERAJAPPASURYVANSHI
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 402
83. FAKEERASABSABANNANADAF
AGE : 35 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 410
84. SURESH
S/O HANAMANTAGOUDABALAGOUDRA
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 418
85. DHULANAGOUDA
8
S/O HONNANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 28 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 419
86. MANJUNATH S/O MARIYPPA HATTI
AGE : 30 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 426
87. MOHAMMAD S/O DAVALSABNADAF
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 429
88. FAKEERAPPA S/O TIPPANNA HATTI
AGE : 26 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 431
89. NEELAVVA W/O PARAPPAMOTARANGI
AGE : 45 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 434
90. CHIDANANDA W/O YAMANAPPAKALAGUDI
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 412
91. MALLAPPA S/O NEELAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 26
92. SHANTAVVANAGAPPAKAMBALI
AGE : 48YEARS, OCC : AGRI 118
93. SHANKRAPPAYAMANAPPAKELAGINAMANI
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 121
94. YALLAVVA W/O BHIMAPPAKENCHALAVAR
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 123
95. YAMANAPPAYALLAPPABELAVALKOPPA
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 148
96. DAYANANDI
W/O YAMANAPPABELAVALKOPPA
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 149
97. SHANKAR
S/O YAMANAPPABELAVALKOPPA
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 150
9
98. SHIVANAND
S/O YAMANAPPADALAWAYI
AGE : 44 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 90
99. MANJUNATH S/O MUDAKAPPAKAMBLI
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 160
100. HAVALAVVA W/O BHIMAPPAPUJAR
AGE : 65 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 147
101. TIPPANNA S/O BHIMAPPAPUJAR
AGE : 46 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 144
102. POOJA W/O TIPPANNAPUJAR
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 145
103. SHANKARAGOUDABHIMANAGOUDAGOUDRA
AGE : 51 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 88
104. NIRMALA S/O RAMESH PUJAR
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 146
105. SAVITA W/O SHIVAYYA HIREMATH
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 152
106. BASAVARAJ S/O IRAYYA HIREMATH
AGE : 32 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 136
107. BASAVVABASAYYA HIREMATH
AGE :66 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 119
108. CHANDRAVVA W/O RANGAPPAHULLIKERI
AGE : 66 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 2
109. DODDAHANAMAPPA
S/O BHIMAPPAKALAGUDI
AGE : 76 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 3
110. DURAGAPPA S/O RAMAPPAHARIJAN
AGE : 62 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 34
10
111. FAKEERAYYA S/O SHIVAYYA HIREMATH
AGE : 42 YEARS, OCC : AGRI ALL ARE 103
(SL NO 1 TO 111) R/O HIREMUCHCHALAGUDDA
TAL : BADAMI DISTRICT : BAGALKOT
112. MARUTI S/O TIPPANNAYALIGAR
AGE : 62 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 56
113. BASANGOUDA S/O NINGANGOUDANARAGUND
AGE : 67 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 35
114. MAILARAPPA S/O GUDADAPPAPADATAPPANVAR
AGE : 52 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 53
115. MALLIKARJUN S/O ISWARAPPAYALIGAR
AGE : 35 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 389
116. YALLAPPA S/O ISWARAPPAYALIGAR
AGE : 38YEARS, OCC : AGRI 390
117. IRAPPANINGAPPASOBARAD
AGE : 33 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 417
118. SIDDAPPA S/O LAXAMAPPAHANGARGI
AGE : 36 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 287
119. LAXMAVVA S/O TIPPANNAYALIGAR
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 213
120. MAGUNDAPPA S/O SANGAPPAKALAGUDI
AGE : 55 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 202
121. MAHAGUNDAPPAHANAMAPPA
NAKKARAGUNDI
AGE : 41 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 225
122. BASAVANTAPPANEELAPPAYALIGAR
AGE : 56 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 222
123. NETAJI S/O PAKIRAPPASOBARAD
AGE : 56 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 28
11
124. MAGUNDAPPA
S/OGUDADAPPAPADATAPPANAVAR
AGE : 42 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 34
125. SIDDAPPA
S/O DEVARAYAPPAHAKARI
AGE : 43 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 43
126. RANGAPPA
S/O YALLAPPAKALSANNAVAR
AGE : 50 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 118
127. FAKEERAPPA
S/O NEELAPPAYALIGAR
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 130
128. MAGUNDAPPA
S/O TIPPANNAYALIGAR
AGE : 44 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 214
129. YALLAPPA
S/O YAMANAPPAYALIGAR
AGE : 38 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 245
130. NAGAPPA
S/O KALASAPPAKALASANNAVAR
AGE : 48 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 318
131. RANGAPPA
S/O AYYAPPAKALASANNAVAR
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 354
132. CHIKKANAGOUDA
S/O MAGUNDAPPANARAGUND
AGE : 60 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 29
133. YALLAPPA
S/O RANGAPPANADAKATTIN
AGE : 62 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 106
12
134. BHIMAPPA
S/O ISWARPPAKALAGUDI
AGE : 35 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 208
135. BASAVARAJ
S/O DYAVANAGOUDAPADATAPPANAVAR
AGE : 39 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 195
136. NEELANAGOUDA
S/O MALLANAGOUDANARAGUND
AGE : 86 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 86
137. NINGANAGOUDA
S/O NEELANAGOUDAGOUDAR
AGE : 58 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 104
138. SANGAPPA
S/O MAGUNDAPPAKERAKALAMATTI
AGE : 40 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 110
139. FAKEERAPPA
S/O RANGAPPAKALAGUDI
AGE : 54 YEARS, OCC : AGRI 30
PETITIONERS NO 112 TO 139 ALL ARE
R/O CHIKKAMUCHCHALAGUDDA
TAL : BADAMI DISTRICT : BAGALKOT. ...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. P.N.HOSAMANE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF CO-OPERATION,
M.S.BUILDING, 6TH FLOOR, BANGALORE.
2. THE PRATHAMIKA KRISHI PATTINA
SAHAKARI SANGHA LIMITED,
HIREMUCHCHALAGUDDATA;
BADAMI DIST. BAGALKOT.
13
3. THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
PRATHAMIKA KRISHI PATTINA
SAHAKARI SANGHA LIMITED
HIREMUCHCHALAGUDDATA;BADAMI
DIST. BAGALKOT.
4. THE RETURNING OFFICER TO THE
PRATHAMIKA KRISHI PATTINA
SAHAKARI SANGHA LIMITED,
HIREMUCHCHALAGUDDATA;BADAMI
DIST. BAGALKOT.
5. THE DIST. COOPERATIVE ELECTION OFFICER &
DEPUTY REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY,
BAGALAKOT, DIST. BAGALAKOT.
6. CO-OPERATIVE ELECTION COMMISSION,
RPTD. BY ITS COMMISSIONER,
3RD FLOOR, SHANTI NAGAR,
TTMC 'A' BLOCK, SHANTINAGAR,
BANGALORE-560027. ...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHIVAPRABHU HIREMATH, AGA FOR R1
SRI. HEMANTHKUMAR L.HAVARGI, ADV. FOR R4 TO R6)
(R2 AND R3 - SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED)
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER ARTICLES
226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO
ISSUE A WRIT OF APPROPRIATE NATURE TO DECLARE THAT
SECTION 20(2)(a-iv)AND PROVISO TO THE KARNATAKA CO-
OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT, 1959 IS ULTRA VIRES AND
LEISLATIVE COMPETENCE AND VIOLATIVE OF ARTICLE 243ZI
AND 243ZO OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA; AND ISSUE A
WRIT OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENTS TO
CONDUCT THE ELECTIONS TO THE COMMITTEE MANAGEMENT
OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT SOCIETY FOR THE TERMS OF FIVE
YEARS SCHEDULED TO BE HELD ON 12.01.2020 PURSUANT
14
TO ANNEXURE-C WITHOUT APPLYING SECTION 20(2)(a-iv)
OF THE ACT.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR
PRELIMINARY HEARING IN 'B' GROUP THIS DAY, THE COURT
MADE THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER
Learned Additional Government accepts notice on behalf of the respondent No.1.
2. Sri. Hemanthkumar L.Havaragi, learned counsel accepts notice on behalf of the respondent Nos.4 to 6
3. Memo dated 12.02.2020 is filed praying to dismiss the writ petitions as withdrawn. In the memo it is also stated that the petitioner would not press prayer no.1 and the prayer no.2 does not survive for consideration.
4. Learned counsels appearing for the respondent Nos.1 and 4 to 6 have no objection. The 15 respondents No.2 and 3 though served have remained absent.
The memo is placed on record. The writ petitions are dismissed as withdrawn.
SD/-
JUDGE Kms