Central Administrative Tribunal - Chandigarh
Harvinder Singh vs M/O Railways on 12 January, 2018
Author: P. Gopinath
Bench: P. Gopinath
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHANDIGARH BENCH
...
O. A. No.60/1238/2017 Date of decision: 12.01.2018
...
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. SANJEEV KAUSHIK, MEMBER (J).
HON'BLE MRS. P. GOPINATH, MEMBER (A).
...
1. Harvinder Singh son of Niranjan Singh,resident of H.No. B9-1093,
Vishnu Nagar, Jagadhari workshop,Haryana.
2. Rajesh Kumar son of Ram Chander, resident of 112 J, Bhoor Bharat
Nagar, Raj Colony, Ghaziabad (U.P.)
3. Rattan Chand son of Chhunku Ram, resident 337/2,
Railway Colony, Shakur Basti, Delhi-110034.
4. Jagat Singh son of Jelly Singh, resident of Village Akinpur,
PO.Bambavarh, Distt. GautamBudh Nagar, Uttar Pradesh.
5. Hari Singh son of Khunna Ram, resident of 171/8, Railway Colony,
Kishanganj, Delhi.
6. Colvin Stephen Wright son of Late C.S. Wright, resident of 6 D/D,
Railway Harthala Colony, Near Small Railway Park, Moradabad, UP.
7. Hari Om-III son of Nat Ram, resident of Railway Hartla Colony,
Q.No.H-134, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
8. Dinesh Kumar Sharma son of Sohan Lal Sharma,resident of H. No.
155-B, Near Nehru Junior High School, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
9. Azad Singh son of Late Bihari Singh, resident of Railway Hartla
Colony, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
10. Irfan Ali Khan son of Late. Yakoob Khan, resident of MIG 80, Azad
Nagar, Near RTO, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
11. Abhay Kumar Pandey son of ShambohNathPandey, resident of
Milan Vihar, Near SaiMandir,Gali No.3H, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
12. Shivnandan Prasad son of Dwarika Prasad, Resident of
RajkiyaAdarsh Colony, Near 23 P.A.C, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
13. Laltoo Singh son of Chotte Lal, resident of Meerpur, Milan Vihar,
Near AkanshaVidyaPeeth, Inter Collage, Moradabad, Uttar
Pradesh.
14. Ram KhiladiMeena son of Bhappu Ram Meena, resident of 427-A,
Railway Colony, Bathinda, Punajb.
15. JagdishChander-II son of RadheBallbha, resident of DurgaVihar,
Ghuni No. 1, Kathgharia, Haldwani, Nainitaal, Uttrakhand.
2
16. Ramesh Chand - III son of Late Om Prakash,resident of Loco
Colony, Near PeliKothiLaksar, Ward No. 05, Haridwar, Uttrakhand.
17. VedParkash son Sher Singh resident of JulanaMandi, Near Rohilla
High School, Jind, (Haryana).
18. VedParkash son Dhannu Ram, resident of Railway Loco Colony,
Jind, # L53F, HQ Jind, Haryana.
19. Satish Kumar son of Sher Singh, resident of Railway Loco Colony,
Jind, (Haryana).
20. Hukum Singh son of Parmala, resident of 4810, Sector-11, Jind,
Haryana.
21. Partap Singh Son of SurajBhan resident of 358/2, Chanderlok
Colony, Julani Road, Near Cattle Feed Plant, Jind, Haryana.
22. Pyare Lal Son of Ram Singh, resident of ChanderLok Colony, Julana
Road, Near cattle Feed Plant, Jind, Haryana.
23. Raj Kumar 335/2, Ward No. 4, Rambir Colony, Railway Road,Jind
(Haryana).
24. Vijay Kumar son of Hari Singh, ShardaVidyaMandir, Block No.
288/J, Dhobi Ghat, AmbalaCantt, Haryana.
25. Satpal Singh son of Chandan Singh, resident of 481/2, Ward No. 2,
Rambir Colony, Jind, Haryana.
26. Surendra Kumar-II, son of Late Ram Swaroop, resident of H.No.
114, Street No. 19, Adarsh Nagar Colony, Roza, Thana Roza, Tehsil
Sadar, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
27. Ram Narayan son of Munna Lal, resident of Q.No. L-33-D, Railway
Colony, Roza Junction, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
28. RiyasatUllah Khan son of FarhatUllah Khan, resident of Q.No.169-
A,Railway Hospital Colony, RozaShahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
29. Ramjivan son of Chine, resident of Q.No. BW-82-B,
Railway Colony, BhawalKhera, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
30. Gyanendra Kumar son of Subhash Chandra, resident of Kothi No.
L-3B, Railway Colony, Roza, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
31. Mohammad Aslam son of Abdul Rasid, resident of Q. No.BW-111-B,
Railway Colony, Roza Junction, PO.Roza, Shahjahanpur, Uttar
Pradesh.
3
32. Abdul Majeed Ansari son of Mohd.Hameed Ansari resident of
H.No.167/B, Railway Colony Hospital, Roza Junction, PO Roza,
Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
33. VedPrakash-II son of Mewa Ram, resident of Gali No. 3, Adarsh
Nagar Colony, Roza, Tehsil Sardar, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
34. Raj Kumar son of Hans Ram, resident of Roza, Adarsh Nagar
Colony, Shahjahanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
35. Mohammad Hafeez son of Abdul Qauum, resident of Q.No. 75-C,
Railway Colony, Loco Shed, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
36. D.K. Sharma son of KishanDutt Sharma, resident of H-187-A,
Railway Harthala Colony, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
37. Akram Khan son of Umar Khan, resident of Q.No. L-87 C/D/E, Loco
Shed, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
38. Shiv Kumar son of Jai Parkash resident of Ram H.No. 640/1/2,
Avtar Ki Mandi, Khalasi Line, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
39. Om Parkash Singh-I son of Harbans Singh, resident of
LodhipurJawahar Nagar, Ward No. 15, and PO. Agwanpur, P.S.
Majhola, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
40. Sudesh Kumar son of Late Gamman Lal, resident of SherKothi,
Mission Compound, Civil Line,Rurki,Uttrakhand.
41. Chander Pal Singh son of Jahbba Singh, resident of
LaluwalaDhanora, Nazibabad, Post Jalalabad, Distt. Bijnour, Uttar
Pradesh.
42. RameshwarSahai son of Shri Ram Sahai, H.No.1/1809, Lakshman
Singh Colony Mission Compound, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
43. Pawan Kumar son of Chimmin, resident of
GaliaraRoad,NearNandVatika, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh
44. HariNath son of VaijNath, resident of Manas Nagar, Rai Bareli, Uttar
Pradesh.
45. Chandrika Prasad son of KantaParsad, resident of 666/13,
Ambedkar Nagar, Rai Bareli, Uttar Pradesh.
46. Nand Kumar Singh Gram Post, Khalispur, Distt.Ghazipur Uttar
Pradesh
47. Rajendra Kumar Tiwari son of S.S. Tiwari, resident of village
Bhangwa, Sadar, Distt. PartapPur, Uttar Pradesh.
4
48. Virendra Kumar son of Basantu Ram, resident of Pakraul,
Azamgarh, Uttar Pradesh.
49. Chhedi Lal son of KedarNathYadav, resident of New Colony, Bitari
Road Lohta, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh.
50. Om PrakashPandey son of Lalta Prasad, resident of Belwan, Post
Pahora, Distt. Mirzapur Uttar Pradesh
51. Satish Chand-4 son of Chaubey Lal, resident of 340/36 Kha,
Mehndiganj, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
52. Shamsudin Son of Latir, resident of Rail Awas, S.259-A, Type-III,
New Loco Colony, Uttar Railway, Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh.
53. Anoop Singh son of Jagna Singh, resident of JJ puram, Near
Laxmipuram, H.No. 27, Saharanpur Uttar Pradesh
54. ChanderParkash son of Chhedi Lal, resident of H.No.37-H,
TedhiPulia, Alambagh, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
55. Mohd. IdreesKhan son of Usuf Khan, resident of L.D. Colony, 21-
G, TedhiPulia, Alambagh, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
56. Mahipal Singh son of Atma Ram, resident of Railway Colony, 88-
AB, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
57. K.D. Pandeyson of SatnarayanPandey,resident of village BelaSadar,
PostAbhilya Kala, Distt.Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
58. Purnoor AhmedSon of Miraz Ahmed, resident of Dr.Tufail Ahmad
Mard, Narhi, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
59. Rajendra KumarSon of Laxmi Chand, resident of H.No.2043,Gali
No. 7, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
60. Bharat Singhson of Lt. Umrao Singh, resident of SarvpriyaVihar,
H.No.925, Kankhal, Haridwar, Uttar Pradesh.
61. Dharampal Singhson of J. Singh, resident of Railway
Colony,BhateriBaga, H. No. 468, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
62. Randhir Singh son of Raghuvir Singh, resident of H.No.960/1, Shiv
ViharGaneshpur, Rurki, Uttrakhand.
63. Pradeep Kumar Sharma son of R.N. Sharma, residentof H.No.224,
Muthiganj,Gandhinagar, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh.
64. Ashok Babu son of Sunehri Lal, 89-B, Railway Colony, Saharanpur,
Uttar Pradesh.
5
65. Manohar Lalson of Murlidhar Sharma,resident of H.No.108, Railway
Colony,Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
66. Kedar Singhson of Mehar Singh,resident of L-20/B Railway Colony
Dehradun, Uttar Pradesh.
67. Ajmer Hasan son of Ibrahim, resident of village Sethpur, PO.
Laskar, Distt. HaridwarUttar Pradesh
68. Rattan Lal son of Lala Ram, resident of Uttam Nagar,
Galiara Road, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
69. Mohd. Yaqub son of Sareef Ahmed,resident of Railway Hospital
Road, SimliLaksar, Haridwar,Uttrakhand.
70. C.P. Singhson of Ram Swaroop, resident of Shanti Vihar, Shikara
Road, Gali No. 4, Bareli, Uttar Pradesh.
71. Kamal Kishore son of JagannathParsad, resident of Subhash Nagar,
Rajiv Colony, Gali No. 3, Bareli, Uttar Pradesh.
72. Om Prakash-13son of BhimDutt, resident of H.No. 288/7, Shiv Kuti,
Subhash Nagar, Bareli, Uttar Pradesh.
73. Rais Ahmed Khan Son of Mohd.Swaleh Khan,resident of 108/341-A,
TalabGagniShukl,Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
74. AdilHussainson of Sardar Ali, resident of NayaKakan, Budheshwar,
Mohan Road, Thana Para, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
75. Dhoom Singh son of Ganga Ram,resident of VPO.Brahmpur,
Bijnour, Uttar Pradesh.
76. Mohd. Umarson of GulamRasul, resident of RustamVihar
Colony,Nadarganj, Amousi Airport, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.
77. Ashik Ali agedson of Sahab Ali,resident of 133, Ghoasiyana,
Paharganj, Faizabad,Uttar Pradesh.
78. Mohd. Mustaquim son of Abdul Wahab,resident of
PipratalBhadarsa,BaharBhadersaKund, Sohawal,Faizabad, Uttar
Pradesh.
79. Surendra Kumar Yadav son of TribhuvanYadav, resident of Toniya
Man,YaduvanshPur, Faizabad, Uttar Pradesh.
80. Bihari Lal JailwalGaya Prasad Jaiswal, resident of 904,
AbhkariGodam, Naka Chungi, Darshan Nagar, Faizabad, Uttar
Pradesh.
6
81. Sant Ram Yadav-2son of Kalidin,resident of village Ganga Ram
KaPurwa, Sarethi, Darshan Nagar,Faizabad, Uttar Pradesh.
82. Gurdeep SinghSon of Uttam Singh,resident of H.No.2249, Street
No. 1, Aggarwal Colony, Jalalabad (W), Fazilka, Punjab.
83. Jasbir Singhson of Gurcharan Singh,resident of H.No.18, Street No.
21, Basti Tanka Wali, Ferozepur, Punjab.
84. Hemant Kumar son of Mukand Lal, resident of Basti Tanka
Wali,Near Railway Phatak, Ferozepur, Punjab.
85. Sukhdev Singhson of Tek Singh, resident of H. No. 1, Gali No. 79,
Basti Tanka Wali, Ferozepur, Punjab.
86. Baldev Kumarson of Yagdut, resident of H.No.4, Street No.1, Ram
Nagar,Tajpur Road, BhamianKalan,Ludhiana, Punjab.
87. Bhikamber Singh son of Surajpal Singh, resident of
H.No.120/4,Railway Colony 5,Ludhiana, Punjab.
88. Vijay Kumarson of late Kherati Lal,resident of 277-B, Punjab
Lane,Railway Colony, Ghaziabad (U.P.).
89. Satpal aged son of Amarnath,resident of SAS Nagar, Surkhpeer
Road, Gali No. 8, Bathinda, Punjab.
90. Harmesh Kumarson of Karam Chand, resident of Gali No. 3,
Surkhpeer Road, SAS Nagar, Bathinda, Punjab.
91. Om Parkashson of Mangal Ram, resident of # 4018, AhataNiaz
Muhammad, Amrik Singh Road, Bathinda, Punjab.
92. Vijay Kumar son of KewalKrishan,resident of GaliNo. 1, Sukhpeer
Road, SAS Nagar, BathindaPunjab
93. SurjooParshad son of Mewa Ram,resident of II MCV2602481,Gali
No. 8, Sukhpeer Road,SAS Nagar, Bathinda, Punjab.
94. Shubh Karanson of Late Jagjivan Prasad, resident of #27/9857,
Street No. 2, Opp. Police Station Canal Colony,Bathinda, Punjab.
95. Suresh Kumar son of Himal Chand, resident of General Office,Block
No. 6, Railway Colony, Near Multania Bridge, Bathinda, Punjab.
96. Ashok Kumar son of Chote Lal,resident of # L39-A, Near Railway
Gurdwara, Railway Colony, Bathinda, Punjab.
97. Raj Bahadurson of Ram Sukh, Resident of 1308,Street No. 2,Hans
Nagar Basti, Bathinda, (Punjab)
7
98. Jugal Kishoreson of Amar Singh,resident 11676, street No. 2,
SamanaBasti, Bathinda, Punjab.
99. Sham Lal son of Dukhi Ram, resident of Brahm Nagar,Gali No. 5,
#3,Ferozepur, Punjab.
100. Puran Mal Meenason of Kanahia Lal Meena, residentof T-77A,
Railway Colony, Bathinda, Punjab.
101. VidyaSagarson of Ram Bachan Ram, resident of Q.No.498-
C,Railway Colony, Bathinda, Punjab.
102. Mohinder Kumarson of Ramesh Chander, resident of # 30046,
Street No. 1,Gopal Nagar,Near Peerkhana, Bathinda, Punjab.
103. Kamalmeet Singh son of Ajit Singh,resident of L-7C, Railway
Colony, Bathinda, Punjab.
104. Om Prakashson of Ram Chand, resident of Gandhi Colony, H.No. M-
670, Near Railway Station, Faridabad, Haryana.
105. Mool Chand son of Shiv Dyal,resident of H.No.63, New Vijay
Nagar,Sector-9, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh.
106. Asharfi Lalson of Ram Lal, resident of H.No.2551/E-266,3rd 60 Feet
Road,Molarband, Badarpur Border, New Delhi-44.
107. Suresh Kumar son of Chottu Ram, resident of H.No.101, Block
CPA,New Seelampur,Delhi-53
108. Madan Lalson of Radhe Lal,resident of Shiv DurgaVihar, Near
DyalBagh, C-Block, H.No.D-2, FaridabadHaryana
109. Raj Kumar Singhson of Hardwari Singh, resident of Vijay Nagar
Byepass, Shanti Nagar, GhaziabadUttar Pradesh
110. Shyam Sunderson of Om Parkash, 233, Pocket-2, Sector-25,
Rohini, New-Delhi-85.
111. Manjit Singhson of Baldev Singh, resident of 412, Gali No. 9,Rishi
Nagar, Rani Bagh, New Delhi.
112. Udaibeer Singh son of Babu Ram,resident of VPO.Sadarpur,H.No.
557, GhaziabadUttar Pradesh
113. Babu Lal son of Ganpat,resident of Gopal Nagar, Near Shukul
Palace,Gali No.2, BathindaPunjab
114. Bishwambhar Singh H-24, Sector-9, New Vijay Nagar, Ghaziabad,
Uttar Pradesh
8
115. Sushil Kumarson of Tara Chand,resident of 397/2, Ramvir Singh
Colony,Jind Junction,Haryana
116. Shishupal Singhson of Mohan Singh, resident of No.28-A, Gali No.
11, MorbandVistar, Bajarpur, New Delhi-44
117. Jagpal Singh son of Late Kishan Lalresident of Railway Road, Near
Police Chowki, Khurja Junction Distt.Bulandshahr,Uttar Pradesh
118. Diljit Singhson of Balwan Singh, resident of 861, Street No. 5,
Manjit Nagar, LudhianaPunjab
119. Ashok Kumars/o Late Ram KishanSharla, resident of Loco Shade L-
48C,Moradabad Uttar Pradesh.
120. Haridev Singh son of Roop Singh, resident of Railway Hartla
Colony, Near PMT Gate, Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh.
121. Paley RamSon of Chhelu Ram,Resident of Ishwar Nagar, Patiala
ChowkHansi Road, Jind, Haryana
122. Madhu SudanSon of Narain dasResident of House No.
1153GaliSubedaran, Hathi Gate,Amritsar, Punjab
123. Nirmal KumarSon of Sh. ArjunResident of street No.3Adarsh
Colony, Biharipura,Ghaziabad,Uttar Pradesh
124. Rajendra Kumar Dwivedi S/o GopalDwivediR/o 566/60c, Jay
Prakash Nagar, Alambagh, Lucknow,Uttar Pradesh.
... APPLICANTS
VERSUS
1. Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Railways, Baroda
House, New Delhi.
2. General Manager, Northern Railway, Baroda House, New Delhi.
3. Chief Personnel Officer (Admn.), Northern Railway, Baroda House,
New Delhi.
4. Divisional Railway Manager, Northern Railway, Ferozepur Division,
Ferozepur.
5. Senior Divisional Personnel Officer, Northern Railway, Ferozepur
Division, Ferozepur.
6. Malkit Singh son of Balbir Singh resident of Basti Nizamudeen,
District Ferozepur City.
... RESPONDENTS
PRESENT: Sh. Arunjeet Singh Kakkar, counsel for the applicants.
Sh. Lakhinder Bir Singh, counsel for the official respondents.
None for respondent no.6.
9
ORDER (Oral)
...
SANJEEV KAUSHIK, MEMBER (J):-
1. Learned counsel for the applicants submitted that this O.A. can be disposed of in terms of order dated 24.11.2017 passed by this Court in O.A. No.60/181/2017, which was based upon order dated 27.04.2016 of the jurisdictional High Court in the case of Kala Singh & Ors. vs. UOI & Ors. (CWP No.7714/2016), which has also been affirmed upto the Hon'ble Supreme Court by disposing of SLP at the hands of the respondents to await deliberation to be given by the Railway Board. He further submitted that the applicants be given liberty to approach this Court after deliberation given by the Railways, if still applicants are dissatisfied.
2. Ordered accordingly.
(P. GOPINATH) (SANJEEV KAUSHIK) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J) Date: 12.01.2018. Place: Chandigarh. `KR'