Karnataka High Court
Sri Noor Mohammed Sharifi vs The Special Land Acquisition Officer on 30 September, 2010
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar
gg' BAE{§.&L@RE
E2'? '§'§"§E HEQEE €@§R'E' §§"
§&TEE THIS THE 367% DAY 9? $EP'§'E§§'§EEE; 281%
BEFQRE:
THE E~i$N'BLE MR. JU'S'E'ICE RV, §1§mE:%:;:s.iR§;§;,'}§::i§i;§xa:;§;.g
Wm; E'e§':'.{,z'oz': Z\:'0.4§28 of 205%; azgmfgéjgég V '
SRE NCEOR MCBEEAMMECE} E3HAREE?'§
S,/0 .m:.:'£«: SE.-IEEEKE-i EaE»:A%»:AB:JE>E)§:-\:_
AGED AE%OU'i" 73 YAERS
RIA S2-%.S £%.PAR"FPs:EE3\}"E'S V. '
§?'L'3{§'E'~IQnZ3{}§, §iA§xEE<ZANA§}§ V
3sx£AN:;A£,<3R§: --- :2? N '_ _4 V pE'E*:*§'§(>Ix.?ER
{E3}.-* SEE 'Jij a.}i2:E«:'Li.ma:', .5'-'sé'%:,E
AKE:
E. 1:':-{EVgmi':A:§:é:,}é,:a1_:}'~._
éé.CQ--U'§S§'E'i€;}I'£ _,<:r;i1«*:a::::":2e._ *
E%§«N{}AL0RE'E§'£§'*.}":Z7L€3rE?§'vfEEE\E'E'
§a{.1';*:TT:{3§%;:.'1'2";« E%EZ'.E,;;i-AE%:3{f RGAE}
£3AN€_:';5a§.,{3§%§: f ' ~~
2" 3 ._§ "E?-2&1; <:{>11;?i.;v§.:Vs;s;§§:}2s:§:§2
V. aANs3.AL£'>RE:' :3--::--:; F T,<>2>Mza:x2':'
;a:3'T:':~:<§z::i%'Y, E¥§+3LEAR':' E€{f};-ii}
' _§?;:.;;3as Q;:a;.€;§§.:%:
%. §§§a;::"':~5a::;£:fg:v::';'
V £{§-Ef.5§}A E§{}3l§"E" «£33 YESEERES
3 4' 2?:é.<§§:;a:~vz:%v:§:,£}
E-'s.v{}§'i}3Z} ;'%.E§{_}'{IT LE3 °':"§:1_51E-?;E€%»
V. f_' V» 'T . :~i-;M*:'- 1%§i§i§i7'i%%E :3:
52%;: ?vié*s.J{}E€
{:4 $?%'§f? I:iEa%'E E'-IE§:§I.£'§
T 5-'§{}§:?;: E'*«s'§A:.I {ER
?C Efi«R:'ET SEXZEEEZIEA
_r-K} ES: %'§z%l {E R
8., SM'? AEBEIEA E'§§2{}§nJFa/E
A€}§§: :"v'Ej»Kz§ {BR
$3. EEEFKE" FAM Eiiiflfi
AGES: §\!§2'kJ(}R
R3 T0 R9 EXEQEZ 'E'E*iEi E§{.3I'~§E'~§
AN 1"} §}AU~i§I*I.'%"I13§%$ GP' ._
§,.A'I!'E3 A882} L 'W§§E~§AB V
E»?/Ki' K{}ET\3ASA.N§} Rri
E-E EZR,/EEX-'EI{§EPU E%i[3:-- 1 VILM-X{}Ei
E{§§N€}E'..§3.§ P§{}BE;§, V
£3ANGAL.{}RE ;':'£-()U'E'i-E ':*AL%;;§{§" _ V EéEjS'§>G1<;{:>EN':'§ V
ifiy 3:2: :3' Aigdjguli Khadeflékdxtfiv fer R3: «&;;22
Sri R :{§hr2:;ir*§:€:L21'§%;,V "§E9s;* R4;
R3 "ci§>:~ §3'..5eF;€§;e :.S6f@j{':«€i} M _
'E'E"£EE~; §>E:'.:.'z'fi::.>N' ES Eé':v;;:::.:§-uN:)§:§z 226 ,!'a,§.\E§3 22?' 5:»?
VEWHEZ C{}NS'I.TE1J_fWCfN:'{:3}? EN '{"C}' f)§RECT EWEEE R}. ANY}
R2 TO ;xm'::f;*--:f1¥1%;:_1z*, 5 ':Ni<j~'£é.:~§frwE s;1'i*Es TO THE PE1'E'I'.If'£O3.\3ER
AGA§E\ES"1.7 E:§T::_"~3 '.LAN'r51:;gxcg;%._3:R§::3 ma. E«i"0RM1NG Bz"«xNASHA.E\2'KARE VI
STAC;§«:,L,A§<"<)EJ'f1';»§;%e PE;.§RSU.}1§\E'CE GP' 'm':«: FINAL NO'1'HF§CA'§'EGE\E 1)":
2E,8'2€}{_3§.,--.£317%C)E}:E€.»ET£'§_£a'Ef £'.N1*~.E?jLXURE fl E' AND ALSO A'. WARD
PASSEJD 'E3? *§'}*IE;-I1>E?>fiJT§'Y«..i%'3.MEv1ES8iQN§3E2 EN FAVGUR {)E?"1'HE R};
ANE3 mg: '§;%E::':?rri':<§f*s;:?;'§% 'e;t>N"~---f;:a12.:2;€}<>§ "'~.?'EDE AN§'~E£§}{3;ERE£ W <2 AND
ET€ b _ ,_ _
V, E-"}Ef;"'§V.'§"E';E.€.7T}E'*~Z" {.T{}FvEEN€} {EN FGR PRELEMIN;'7&E%§' E*{E?;A§{E3.\§{},
\V 4, iza' s::e.§2;::::E,.§-Ea "§EiES :2;s;{;"%'1';?-§§': {Li{}{J'R'i' EXEABE '2"-3%: r«"<>:.;,:_.1"y<?7a.f::'~s{:?:*
. ._ . _. ;Q;_.§R_»;w§
"'vV"§€:"'i%.:V~:;2{¢5%?i,ii"€,i£}::'; 'Sf; §}€f.fS{}§1 {TiE§.§§E'§§EEg §§3%;<:3'é:$i in Szibgfisti
Eaézzfi' 2H7:§g:E.§'"%;=r{% E35; iikg §%.3"iEE§§E"§;§{}§"€ §}ears3E<";pmem. §§:,:%h<>z'%€.§? £1-S
_ <;asz»;:%f:.€53r €12"? EEK': Ezmaié ifi <3"? SEEK? éeed; {ézzéczé '?..'}'.E_§%2
§é>«${i%€;¢:<é<i bgr I°€3E§§}{}i"§{}.€:§"§§i:="::§ 3 ':0 9% iii} €E"1§s%; *s2s:'z*i§;. ;:;€iiE';i{}':L
2: H. 2:§;:»é.=a:"s%; féiéé f~;3p€Ef{.'.iéEE Egmd ;"m{gz2is:2iE;§<:¥11 Qffigtaz' has
{iii-§3'Lf:E°;':2t';?{§ {:0m§3m::$z-:t:.§.<:>§': am{>u:":':: payabis £11 3"{iS§3§;'.{3§i {sf the
iaazad in EZ§"i'§"§§"iS 0f 23. ;§::<:§;,>;I:":emE. 8? "she ::§*<;:iE cz::*;:r':1-"fig; LAC
$30,344 2:)? ?fiC32 in a 1'€3fe'£'§'€EZ}{E€ :'1{1a£i€
e':<:q:2;§Si1;:i(§n €}§fi{3:';%§' 5:3. i'E2:': iféfitaiiiiféf :31" :'€;%ssp€:=5'1'2._é:«:vr:T*:§Z3 "?;.::::{ 9
{3§3;§.§1§i11§_.§ §.:'1i{::°e$E. in £1238: sszlbject: §:;m<i '<:<:<:,§--;._ -S
3. it ':3 t;hE:§°eaf'E&r {he ;3_re:s:;e:A:'éA 'Writ :'::éi,_if,:.:§Q§:
getiiiener praying €01" the f(}HdVi%?§_i'1g;{_§'€§1§€;'f;E'=?»Z:A" '
éssmi £1; u:.z:fiE'«-- Qf~"1'W(EI'iv§ei1,_{f1L£7:?.' or direcéiarle
dérercfizzg €316_§€€?S§30{£d{j.FivZS' NO.E £2, 2 {Q
aéioéwihe 5 Irzcgéfizivae 3ii<é*sg §':{;'~f?,_§--"m% Psséiéianer
" a§j5s:;£r:$5?.§ ?:._is» ._:E<:m& _ uireaii jbr h jbr*z?1£:'zg
_ 'Ba:*é;:2;:5}f£z::§j}z,i<:Q§':v~~._ 'V1 Stage Layoui: in
2 4-pz,zrs uIU;:*zcé"--Q}'~£§1e finai noéyicazierz wide
UE}D}'2?"4;":. 2%-.Xj2GGE§ Bmgazare dated
E_§{}8.§:2{}{;?.E,"'pr0fi:;:.:r£3d 01' Ar::ze,x:::r€ ~--~ E'
and 5:130 s'§wa,rd pasésefi by ihéz Bepuégg
?,/'0:§zr21i;"<3i?s5E3c+:1ef,>r {:2 f<3,v0u.r Qf {he
vf5€'%s3¢sjp0ncier:ET {$0.} and {he Pe€éEi'i9nes* an
" ?"}§i"1 ;%.~2,2GQi wide _s'\J0,E3{)A,?E}C{£,z'i§;'Ei::2a;r§
' «.;';'A:7é61§_;'2Q:'}E-i§;1 pmdzégésd 51:. 1-'7§3":§'Z€;s:"§_éE"&'---=L'§3
.55, V gisgsue arzgg aiizgr gzziéabfe r;vr:{:' <3?' {}?"'€§€?" 0:'
" éir*'€:%iir3r§'z {:3 533:3 E-.§9:'z'E9Es3 Cam": deem jii'
as {Q i'§":{§ {?G$§;:§ and aa§jz§s::?:§3s*:§, Qf.f§:2,:=&;:'£i
a:":3;a:;::":.i'; 5a§aé§'2.3§' fizéf §:*az':2f. aj' §:z{%3§':£'§ye
5=s::'i£3;'=; {G 3316 ps3§'i£i9n.e:° :,m.der £§zef%§:*:£'$ and
:?i;:"°z:.m55E'a:2Ces 9}" :%2£:" (rage, §?ECEL£&§%"%§ as :9
£§":a=, 5:0;-5:5' 3}" §'§Ei$ ififrsfi" fiziiéiarz. "
Z,iSE:é£iZ'E°{Z§ZZ'T:§§ i..'E2&1:4 ha? ii:E':»:": z:m::'_2e;~ 4:}? {E26 E9515: <;w<:%:: if: firms; :35
$213 ssaésg fissd ?::§';2:§; bad b:i'?€£fE§ <;%§;€<:z.2i.{;%€§ by ::"€:&§;3<}.§':<i<z:';.€:&¢, 3 ii}
9 13:} Harms G? fé.§":€% §"€§g;1§S§fi€'E'€3f(i séaile {§€:';€€§ C§Ei'§;If3'€3; '?f?. §.i§§S:?; fang
beibra é'§1<~3: a::qui5s§éi{>:: p2"<;{:a:-':€':{§i:{1g_.;§.%§ vassreit i:2i€.iaE«::'ci.'_f
:"<3§p<H:::§@:1"z::~s 3 éié} $3 iiakirag' £id'v-'aI1f£c"ig€f?_..€fs.{I"*§'.Ef§V€i-.V:..§'¢E'JCi'§'£,§;*fif
E"€3{t{}§°é-5-3 ma? havirlg £§<::E:3t'.@~d figs: :::;2m::§:Qj:f 'é':§f1é:._:':"3s:.';";r€}'§fz_§@§3;i'§:'~;§
3322: hearing :=;§§npE§z* §€i{'3E"i iiiiiiifiéifi ziiggrégf w:i;;}é' ffiflij ::2§+;m€7 €§§»
E:'j%:é-:~ §3€:é.iE§<}§:1s3:" a§§:~{;= afidi in €:._E':éé'v«.;%.':;s3;<:_:2€:{*' 'iixfifipefiiiiamer
1.-$10 Waag {wit {zzf '€:hé<.fé:a::r;.;t§§:;,' V fn.;m21g€d ':0 gei: 2:
fiuégzzzé:-*§":'§ in '£:h:t*s_i:° E":'.3§vf€_m;:< §j;ef{}°:f€'»L._tI?:é_:::¢ii:§»§ éiaurh hagefl Gr:
:5-Yhicih ,%;.i':é:}; %;~§1%yf<;=r ::£:21'a;_:':A~.._i_E:e :i::2mpensa:,i0:': amount; afhaé the pm7{f§3€'s:?;ingEi_ --"?3¥€f2}i-'E; '"5:f.he izsszni 23,<:e:§::i$§I:1?<:s§; Gfficer :'eE~,:u§§;i§-:5; Er; <5::§"::'g}:@'f:3s2?;'-*:.iz§:f: baéirzg gayabie 'CG r€--ssp<:»z3d{--3z3E:$ 3 '{.§"1E:'E. %::'§:3{=, ;}€€;§§:;§{:r1e:° 53;', E62155: xéifzmfid €55 %;:fr:>i:»'_i§i€5<i Siifffi gays? zzifzaéiésbés §E.§"':§€EE" figs: §:::h:::m@ af z2{%'=:§:;:.§§§3?€,:::>:é 352$ £i§:'§{} §i:;ir;_:«,2é: SEi€f§"§; E%§ii'ES§ i'~:%§"§€3Efl€§ E"§{}"§'. '$5: giwzzz .E§{;~- €:E3;_€ z°{%S§~::§::5i:%:*1:§ 3 3:} § 23555:
{.31 1%, E'&5<:%;é<t@:s% Erma? baéezx iSE~3§1€i{3§ Eli} {ha E'*:"iEi-§_§§§{}§'}.£f§€':E1_'€'. -
22.:3€:E:<}§':§é'y :*{:*;;s:"e$e:":%;£-:d E};-F Sr': if Abdui Kézafiéjr, §!f?£:§§"'E'§€{§ ('f{}{EZ'iS€E»
5. Subméssian {)fSri Abdui Eihader, iéearzied ;*,t{:>3%f;1:'?5j;:~.g£E§.' £03"
théa reSp<}nd{~:n':; ~ :%cu{.ih£::°i':y .is; 19:21:". file §.21;%§._€i .:2§;A§:V§;;i§iSi?.$1f':3§1i' affieer h.aS 0111? gives'; eéffssct 12:3 2'j§éé'g;§:;ég§z1§3:::§"é%f f:h{:= {EWIEI 7 <::3m*'i.; "ihat {chem is; SCWEEEE 0bVi{m§s'.né'igfK£.ak€ 1?;f1jih.t>. ilamézéf 31?}? §"€sp<:s:nfi€:m}5 3 is 9 {:€>nEi§';L1,i£;'3§,§ to I"i--gg:.Q'z%§":§:: "i.h€":'€ve:':*e.:é3 wcardg: fhai. the 'r1GY.1"'i€'i::e1'£i<:srim§*§fg:§;; §i%i§._he1ziT Beiitig aways: 05 the acmai réghtg the palréécs §}'C2:éSe5_$'f:.<i xfis;~é:ViS petitiener and §*<f*S'jj5éf)V:i«:3;;=§::t,g t.h.é'é:'1bjecE, iandg ihai whiée :19 excézptiésn '€i'€3;3(§' _E3s:{j~.§::i<;1éi:. «ts; Eihfi' c0ndu<:i: Of the Land acguigitian'"'Qf§}=::z:»% in ?tii$ba:_:'$ing,>j ti/1&3 {fGIfip€fi-Saiiflfi fig":
,,.¢.,;";':'2.x'"':;:-u::.':'* 3-.10? "é;h{i: §°e§§}%i=:é(§<523E,$ 3 {:3 Q GEE €%':€: basis 53:? the L--.;§V*iu;;%;;'_3jz1:.$V:?;.E, {iii-'i§ ssiéagré, ii. apyearsa; {he ;3€if:é£1?a2r:€:° am §"{-EE-<:';E3:_{3f1§.§£i3:'7i_§A§:§'A 3 3:; g are wa':f_E_::§:2g $3.': an azziéiztabixé ":s@';'{'4§e:';*:vz%:§€, is: §i§2aEi:.e:e3 as is EA/-*h{> 3&2}. r:=:€§-zéw-3 éhéi i§}{?€£1§i'£€§ ':~;:§%:.%:;-::=':fi;h§{?§§ fig <}iE':€m:isa=: §:*:::vi{§<:=.e:% K: Eaingi {}'%§-7I§3.rif§T';':'s whase ' " ~»vEa::§d,§}":2:af€_.be{%:1 -2:<i:{§L:§3"é3d 33:3,:-* she:-:-. §"€;'.S§}{}H€§{*,E§§; -- e>:§,2f,E1<}:'é*%:.}£ \ 8 Szzfimis-:~3:i<}z: {>5 1'€§z2 Ef§§21}'£i§&.E1§:E2%.E"; Eazzrazfiié {*:<}m2--s:s€§ £93' f.:E1€;*. §3€3€:ii::i€me:° and ER-«'E":*., §§i"221g§r§z:1a.i:.hg Ee35':'2€3{§ <:{:eu:1$eE far €;§1€:
{earth r€Spz>n§§€:3:1t i>'€§"3;{} aziasner is; 'r€pr~:%s5éa:z:é;€d beiiitxféi {ha {TfQ§,§I£'E. A whs3:":3as Qihszr ::':{311t€si:ing.§ r€$p0z;.;::?<:':2:$ i?i:§:2x*€ mznaaizazsd u;:1re§)r5:s:~;€::i,€d, is %:ha.tI i:%1€j;;' arjgj E:-k€E§;f"~E.Q §€i%'_§é {Egg maiéiiiz' betiweem the p€:i:§iis:Hf;;;::r agéd ~:"e«§3g:i€}:':Vd:+:';?:T.;~2. '3x: 9 ' and requasi. for gm a1<ij0u:":m:é;_:fi f1'1E1Ef;L§§T} .. 2 '?4 E"«J'EI°, fibézsi Khauiar, "V"L'L»§;:L¥:le:3"":_1é:d V§}.:<°' Ehé '£'E3S§{}i"3d€I§'{ a A'athor'§€}"'~$zz';:;fi%f$':?§;ij;':%;%§' 'ihégnfilxiter shauid 'fie séifiied bfiiavsfizti fjeiaefit is €11ti€E€d '£0 the'pe:9s':3::5.'§J'h§%V _{::?E§f:crwiséV'€z:ii'i.Eeé :8 21% per flaw aflfi im §.€E'H1S« af ihqsr ;j5L:E§3:s5_ ga_'§}E'<::§f':=:i:1g aEE0'§:.me§2§;. 0f §:1<:€:::':ivre $563 '3.--'fi§§ (2536:: i:é'%féev §::ei:§fioner zzzgd :'é3$pm':{%€::§,§; 8 :0 § iii; .?:*£;§{>§'x«°<:~:i in aim? Efiéiiififif E~:z1awn ii; ia'w' er "753; m::E:;1aEv_v{:a_zf:3é§:%., bait: Suzi: 3. éigpzzis §E&1"§"E.'{."§{}'§; bg gage mm "'E7*y€%;§":§s;'v¢;:€é§,§r€. in ihis 2%-*:°§i: §%€i§i'i{}§1., §§.€:"é:~fe:}:<°é;=,; zazhiki $2223 %.r2..-*:"§'é: g§%3%.it.ie::§*: §'{}*:' igaae sf ' " "E"i'.'if<E.E7£{3;駧"§}"i§§ '%2%F§"ii{E§§ a;:=.§::z":_ be em? <33: E:§":€--. §";2z.:§§$ €12'? SE2; z:i::§"%:";§§sé '2?
§?X§§?s§.§§}.§§ ;r'§g§.E";£: Es; £§€?{E§§£':{:'i{i,3 'E1? is {>g:>@:: fig'; fi':»z5: §.)§€{.E'§.§{}E"£€.§' fa'; his réghé; in 2111}? <}'i{:§2{:*.r m:»;;a:z:":€r E<;_:§.<3W:1 ':13 §:«2;*2:u*_ 3:" eveszz £10 zzrrim-% at S€:'U;:E€:m€n€; w§£,E*: £'€':'fSp{)i"£€§€-3§:?L3§ £3 {E} piezaies this: fa<:'i:uaE ;3{>=si%;§:i<m 'bef{>:'<£* the :°€$g}{}:*2cic:§§?i 5'ani§:':3vi?iE:§: a::& 9331.131 $52.6: §.m:e:2i:i\:e ifiemsfit; in i,erm6:; saf ¥;:h.;:=: ré§ i'?€%vI21§':%§ 1.6. it is f{;»:' the §3az1gg;::11:3re §§<--:$gé§,::1§§§Vn3é':":.§ i,§1€r:'£321fi',e::' {f{}flSi§€F gush ffiaiiiiiféfiil in" ;;<:(:€;:€E;1fi--:§é"'WRE1 Ezésiv ané if} _paSs:; 21p§3mp§i:«,1--*:';:: GE°d€3§'!':E:e-15"§f,i%?f§;%LE2§§UEif3f1"g A .1 1. Aiiemrdinggly, writ p<:i.§ §"L'iz';':fli:.4€s cE§é'pi:55é'§§ (Bf, ;"§"§z'?"' 'V