State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Girdharlal B Lutharia vs Hukamchand M S Gupta on 2 November, 2007
an-as ctésza F'LClL3<.l3L afiuetw oyaztxzt 2t°m, MHELQLE.
i""'"--'"'-- "1 E?2t"i\.-'st vt'»15a--»3E~3,*:aoo=§ J9 wwr1w-any'; w y ~ - u - V ~ \ u n u w . . u w u V ~ ~ w ~ ~ -- V V w u u u x V . . x ~ u w w V v - x V - u V V u 1 V ~ < ' ' 'w 3[l%'-'4J.3.'1Gil~':t <'~L"'o"l3tCvL §;£€LL2'Iii1 $5. gg:.Lv.12u «4,I_<'i+'«>;a_, 'cu-+'s'».v,Ici §,ur§: 5» e, git-x25'.
LLL I:wv--
I\ IN, z'l2--'=$Lv.sva (1) gsaziz 2s\m.23'm.23ym mos, am 41:32, °3.~Z<.:E1:a."L.aL"§a
-£1 nmi, via; its, agaq.
umtz». mam---a GR.
3;. <1.'e.a».--<u.3, «>+.i.=?+.s,s--. ._»§n.+u?a,ea., Iiswtrfl [$_1¥'m~. am, $5»: 215, Eghl.
:>[1fa,m;+','irg_Ie< g3d1dH,m:e?'4>1H3m"iuu f.':\My Datum: nt's\'Z0(l7-CASE\DCl'0BER\3 63-'Z006.doC
-av-_-awn' usfleit :-- Stfiétra ct'-«.3: :~ cuilaail 23m. it, an; aflzzilrs-a «as :--- qélasfl. 2:121. 3. am;
flan :-- '9i36LZ$fl 9&1. ea"; Igélléviltfl 9w-tasflnfct cit-1.t€t~1 til. E'-A125 am. :--- when allvda ed-aolvt I12. éemf l.'i'§\r-:§\--3d «ue?v¢----2g°z 112 one
--: 6 2161 :~-
(Q) élétvfl wflca. mus gaau um acct: rfl !xC-[31-'lu Esau;
gm. mmcuuu 4012-9 vufl gm Fmtt -'alas smug F+.cu=a-21 a.12waa.ma vi. 3:-sq/«cc ~u sumi cu=.'l1»t-- ac}:/zoos -u ah' sic-L gsaui -19. 1°; 21:34} életrfl mule szie, $3.
(2.) j0L=$?.'1'~lLi. #132 szqmi zzuélefl 243% A g°x<»t -'&lPiLCI.L<l.t ri<»1:a--<t,e 245% c vtL'oit3i. zigsct MA gas 21%! °5'cw'-l*E.lQ a:u.&eu:~»tvR Etmitzil ailvaél-'1 at. 'B',dx9,'-lOO/- qgc-1 sun «.4+ig.%Il cmfls 6: x -u cam ilcild. {;,sc:.cu-11 gm !xQ<1l'li 2»u&eiL wit (mum ztmtqtm-M1 éilzuél-1 weds HtrRl'L*s'2I.l%L 11% .31. a,ooo;'- 'ox-it $78.1?-8.l.E.vtl\'t-'i-u gt. 1,ooo/- 11-21 =5,3a.cu--it gm szqmi wilt-.{L. e-u.s'!vu 2a,mL<=uwLt=e»i1 m='t uiafis zfta fyfllllfi. as saqtni 2»u&.c-it ucfl ma A ?lrL0u(3 C:\My I)ocIDenIa\1007-CASE\OCl'0EE!l\363-2006410:
w.=~ucuuu "i6l2-C: 1]} age; 21.2? gscig eg.éu=z1s<t =$:>.'1=u€Hl eélscm gsuanti vflit 3°56: 23.
(3) um-fl wile: got 2u=u,cu<at -iot2---9 *-u-"oi sole; 2}) Pmi Peiifi zwucuou 'i.€'L2~- 9. «tau 3 29 a gut a2'la1mi aw-ucuvu 4612-1 2:1-1 c ecu M31 6lL§'1-it Jlefla sir: Q, $%'1'{t'E.'i'i zuntqttnt ail}: «(lit 3% uatsm-11 (36€1'°l 33¢: 23».
}yjL§3'1*-lli. vim --aauz'c:g3»¢u'Le. vi. 3&3/'02 'tli{l4tI.clLULl1"' (1) 1121212 Eqauiira at.
3. 12 :1-123, 31. 2»1i«-"L553. slumt, l3«t2'l :a'Lr'm.z 14121, 2'19; 215, gut.
(2) 9.'laL 0t§,2L<=tttS Ham ?5. e/ii, 2?m.°gg ém, 949111 ( aw.) @6123.
(3) age: cueictoutfi' 3331241
25. '10, ?.l'7!<'tCl'l, =u§Lag2L--2>micJ.1 (2') Ma [3.'é.fltLt3 2.Lc1°JIou2S u2d.wL'l2u
25. 23L<ai1.[2x9, éfzmilu (u.) 5'L[&<:ueL 6t=3,ou2S arlcmnflat
3. 10, °x'n=flgam1mué1, fie} 22-.214 'H.801, °gv1LI>L&.. (2) F12'°m 9412. Email
3. <»£lf2,2u:1'aLac?1a, 912.2321 214,. :2»Li<»ucu&L wtstqzz.
C:\M:r DocnmInII\200'I-CA8 B\GC,'l'O£ER\36_3-2006LIIoc (es) ai12'ru2'l geuvflzru
25. gm_L:a'12»ue.I.@u, 2»u-{mu sg-gs as, *gg--gouS
(c) ~>fl2'=uz"l<«1L<=t g3=3i1qHousS'%1%€a1uL
3. °L.am2~1r»t$;, $931315. 215, aztaial ((5) 'bt't?f!{a~§. <*flc1L<*u6 aim-71
3. Win m§, %{l'5'~ll its, vtL:a'aL},;:¢:.~ 2.-manna. (<10) *t'j_y'vu%3 051. ;>3:«.1-e.'1vq1cuou
5. -"8t--%c, [seq qayzat ma, ==_U33L aim uL:S4.,g=x1. (11) oa.i;l;z'. 2'1. =t{%.ca Es. E/it, C}-1., ~ui@L<."I. ( Em.) $4.23.
('12) <'t3l<lL*t£t%L °zflcm°z;<~u2S' =11:
2». [?mt[Ew.L:a u"mmé1,v£Ls 215, agmt.
(13) guwécfl 0t3tCu"lEl%i M3 ('N3') zatfvic-t [5l°iC't zxuawi <:D.'1qte°L=3t Etrfl La 9."l?+LaH£ ¢*arI9u€:.r.1 £0 3;, 2u=+.I,a.I.<n;L ri<»+.'«.~a uurfis eflvillés .r;u~{l 23 3431 ¥{'fld'~'{:.'«"Ll r*;c-:3. 2 an ".1; 91+.
3.m5.3a21 cta"L?s 33;'?! <=¢°2m'4,<1x. écti. 2431 m.a"m»--:.:.-mu'<:u ru. 21->5"
mritru 'tL5t I-«.919. lake. Imls 95233: -':€m1:5L>3e. zsrsrgo =i9.viI.
vi.2'lr-It szcuvfl zzwfl sic-fl, *1 §L%*fl 1»z=;'lfl aiea. «EH: 3:. 101- iii:
C:\My Documents'-20!) 7-(7 ASE\CICTOBER\'i64-200 6.110:
31. 2re,ooo/'-- 'ti QR. was 3%: (3'+2"i,s«L z«;a=t 3;-{'«:+-L 241$ 2Sr.{i-qu 2.513 s§rEu1afi.«au"I4 ;«m+_JqncnI vim-_--<4 vfi Au-+_"I:+i Had umfl $"L=h1 3-z>;<-.1 exit civil zen 'U21 =g3rftc1. ~:.:{'. -"M aw-15,2, %lL't1"Ll'--'LL vietvra ;=;tm'1 aflvuflvtt in -3; gig; 29i<:{ia"«'tra ¥xiL'3iti '~L:;'«:__g r*{l9.'~1.LE 212 fitdla -1 szcu EH1 \§1?tfiCl3.1 wt. -1. Mi {w§1 £.=I=."I.?-m, 3%. 93 M31 silatml qfggfli °a't2u<:au $2561 mama £1211 L.£tr.flct'--:"l 2tmLcu<ILL2»1 ~'.x?.'1?«LLiE.'H aawfl elct :11 atéwu men 'ii mm? 3<;L*5 $1241 [Md 31. 't3.'{,'- 2L6 ém 2:131 & Ml amt ém, MEL Em-F1 3;.
a',ca,u,oo,'-- vfl MLCL-3 aw' aim wig; ramtruowil zs2"au:1-"1 212 ='3'+.«:--i\.a -1. zx$,c--u é7r.ca.:.afl, 9131.91 j1..5%.+i-1 elm u.|.31c--.s 1?), %2:'Ti +n.4ucnum»i| H151 as °ii3LCtL3ii =vu%1c--iL (X) muucuvu ~Li=»¢;;--1,3.2;V,v;: mi} c ~u-"o{1~': ~{'1eI'..a tvmca.cI,mé 2»u,€1efl uég, HIHHEUII -1io4.:e.--=+,.ra,'>r mi: «9 «1n»fI2¥+ M °6C|.l0t vg .£s3.<:-t vtzil.
(It) azu am-11 gslzl °a?m"L %u"*1L<iL<ill 't0i5<.'--C ru <t%$9-PL °ar<:u<»t 2:191 ac-flcil w;L31 éml éilqtelii sit? %taT£:Tssa mé 'tLl3li emucwrzfl qgtfi 2>uii<*:t «§tcu~{1 dam (3.sLc1et -12:'! M-1 .%2'L>+r$1-u 51% 2¢ta'[$'£3<a rtél wucu Htéru an-gufi "L kggemft aim] vwfl. 331 riiitcfi L°5"I.2§a3{ E fclkcuvt {£1251 Emvv. aismuj. v?4;df|. «in». 5:53-I. 31 5+, A. O amucuuu «M2.--3 M91 7: «L221 ciL2'1'+*'u'x,~;7: *1 [:'L5:g\L 21:'; misai C:\My D(1m|rnent.°\2f]07-('ASP'\O(TOBFT'R'TlB4«20D6 dnc 29 {War 2u=ucu.Uu ri<»t2~2,u,§,'1o ea 13* val": «izrfla *»af{ 2&2: -L é:lCI,l?i1 Emrl éélqtzaietl ;s=fl g'«:cuH.i ?bt|.3l,<'=l 23>, °z,<euJ ?{.I,9tl.fU.Ul,I *i;':s.Ia,--<: jg wmm am:-1 £9. LéM1--t ¢1q=1a€l1LLs'.1<t2»,é9i1 men gucu qéli R1141 cm 521% Es, 2mL»u'u1-L vim =<»'v"i c =3'
81. qbtrl :2u=ucuou -1',c»3--=s_ -+1 £l?J.,3. ea: ém é.s9.'ltu_+i,'L-a"I_L 1%.%'H. 'gsscacu. °2r<:L1'ot:.L2>, £9. m=tL=uvu2:{t 2t'&1Lcu'J1'n5.':L% 3 -mi': ezztril vet'-{lei sic-t Q9 €w;31 zmucuuu vic>L:«.--'t Mr': ca -1; 33 Iotggssi 'cu '<:m"mHi. m=ucuvu ribn.--:=. M31 3 £9 EH41 «am am wag Em-1 {trite sraqmi 2»uc1etL€9. mu am-11 vfléla 0t'K(1.l¥lL'tlC£l".lL rif2R~'i 231ac?{$ gut azlqtal ct-'<'.$Efl IFMM cL&'let8fl 3l;t¥.l.%{'1.3LI.é. Hs.'<$Ei «mi-2, 21.94.61 éw ML mi iisliiva M51 zwucuuu =>Steéf£$ 3;"; swuélvu Wrm qslasflmlrfl said: aiowlcu"-{'1 3:tl5{C-1 9 M41 Eat-u sL~'>wC1 rinzvéi c3tcuH'L :m.I.&c«t :39.
(5) 2»u am 2¥'ni.rE1'v.avu €cIL'=r:u-1. 5L§1':l¥-l11'l't.3»{.'9t?£'1'l gm 6'. ~ac-€le€L £131 um 2?tcfl ac~L'1»:21 E3 3;. bu sfii §~.LiF1','Lu;'L0'1'L *{<'=t'<* % w«;«f'u's eflHTas éuvflait 5; we-as 25% 0tLél9. 1u.scuH.t "once-u Ea, c1.12'1w.--23/1+/can v-u re."L°zr oxen mm mi uzzg, 61 2:12:13 nzzlx-z =Lfx;'e:*a' ru ?.'L°s am Czqzlsct §~+rt'1Hizi'L flazqfi zréi 33¢-u em Liiaéis' :aL°eflrugi =m.u1r5; £1211 EH31 glam mu ml éurtlru éléutet é'+I;2LL nfa lam 32191 $%'1={L£'1rlL éim mi? 3125' °zrcw»m:."L <3'R3fl\L ezufl C :\M5_J_ Docuiriznrs\2(I07-CASFT\()(YI'()BER\364-?.[l(35Adoc vtafl PM-fl <-{Ml adlet flea 23 3, an snmi ezmél-I 515 31:. éitala aim -1 c§l<=lI.!fl ziotfim £15191 .32-ua étcueft £1241» aueae-fl auwmzi wuaax us? 212: mil. mu 5:111. salute aw (HP! ssélsdi flu.-1 émi ailrlérartt Encurt cufiaailvil new aeflemi '4; cm «nan; ém 2:1-7t mu aauilefit Fume: ch; 3;: (ma .s2cu-g 1-Em Gll5t £9 W1 <-Ml sale: arial Euvu gyatzlu «ma Pwfq szcu-+1 $321 vuruu
-tail. mu smvfl 2_;,sL€1 afiqi -'mas at [B3414 $1231 <1 cuctvfl vim V «M1 3 3, avast srwuétvft «:23: avg mic-1 ma 91+-{I-u 23 stiles A aéaitrarfl um vtaet rzfldi zwucuuu '{°l'~?.~-*3 Mr} 'X M221 cu-'€lb1--1/X/ex efl Ftcgt 4-4.23 auleu £9. bu sfit 2?t='1€n.va-u {EML-1 cL41c-Lsllail ztvi iltilé air 2131!'-'VlL"|.Ll*t[*!t3'.--'i w-dis dlwilés in-£1-11 :3 M31 8. éurfl $322121 2»ut'1a égj, a 23 soia $3 24% éurflas 23:32 13.501 23 stile: xinulsaa um vg aiet Q 91 cvtcuit 23 3, auvucucatrfl éuvflil «*2 6233', cam u.13<=u3mi 4:; [Mal um utlefl mil. €'3u.v§\3ct at-I .':l3l°l1d.i'?J.cil ixlgi zmauel saga mica :3 3:, {Eltcu-t mvtvtm gsnemi °x9uc'1c-1 Cauitsn. 2.-umqwu 't6lQ-(3 24-': av (anew aim 6; statvisazl g. ?.'lZlQ.'t Hécu aw: aaru Maire %1a€:2; gut aiflaus-1L zwucttvu vi¢vt2--\9 aililiualatc-1 ag.2'k»u tll.Z'l'-L-"'1/'3'/<1)' ail Cmilact amucuou -ic»t2--<t §'£'{l'ti2[l [ma an? 31503.! Etc; °6"§tt'«L
2). mzuqwu -1'c~u--~41 flea} gut $_2'1<'£.vtl Iatqm czélevzfl C=\My Do¢MIumI\2!If1-CA8E\OC'l'OBER\3§3 --fl0§. the auwnzua. 2} 3, vxqigdl mm mi aacuacxl-M um 2) E1 éu-nos Scieilait =2»m'¢c-1 :3 $1 éu-11:5 231.32. £s..s<n. zauuqmi auaa -ml =8La»:'+?; .éu--fio6 $158 13.601 5123 svlcuél 321-1 aamqmi mda ~1%{1 stwté ti mi in-{Isa me $501 3:. vimvtl swti <% sem--aoa £1601 muqmi =otl<1 23 {-1 éln is twig an 212$ :>."lu'té 94:31 auauu 21-3; mtg -ma. av} °mig;%l1 «Ban Y:.%<l.l5l°K u'lv13a21}°3* etavil 2-vac-ms'. alficlra-u [awn qélaall mg 21 sits. 2?» A aaumvgu «mil «tall 2:131 Rail same"!-{I ¢2'hue.~1w.Im ac-flemi 516 can «mg vtnfl. ea bu fzuzlsa A azménrl ozrlefaii ct] uem azcznaivar =2? mi 2'1u1é vu Moteil lg szqmi. wéta 9 21-1 Eini euwucuuu rim-1 vfl u<-ems dlwflés éu-{M new qvmvu smisaz 3191 mi eumta gt; 325:2 mu -2451 9: <tl'v'.'1bl--'t/'o'l(:3' 2:1 I-ué~2 ni °3~fl faeclbt saqmi waa :3 ?mi 95 Ftcgt axitc-u M31 a?m'uS«a etiteu Hru, rmfl eaifla 53:. Mététd R Ctld mil 0 2;, -{I21 91+-flax $&a2"t-«L1 [SL351 =u2.-zuni =»u&c-D. 3 lug «lg renal $3 3, 13,2. azlqxzlazl 9'; eéafiva 521-31 en}: 93 2»t_r''t 3:: [amid $19.11 avtttuztgct null zmuqmt -it-1-2--3 Ma 2: it Jleflz 393m 9 61-11 'L&€-J. «L31 9 an anti Cauzicmi Mclvavn; lhicurz qslaaazl °} auvucuuu ric»L2~1 séuvfl-u ukulrsaet avg sic-t 23 A 2°J1ee§ su-(1 «mall mmqmi nude: 23 A °a'mi £1 93154 we um 23 3, wui cu2'lb¢--=a3/u/cu. vu 21°; nod}; 2925; ml: mat ctui C :\|ly DocanmnI\20l'I'7~CA3B\OC'l'OBER\3 63-2006.dnc E1 éslact waunai éurflm u'1w1sa=1i°xeLL8ta :3 2.,2:usm=1i.;Letru zlficlré «nil!-1-» 1/xlex ail at-=a'l-113' mic-1 dlcwzil Puget uieat £9 Qzém (aualsct av-1 éflscil éuvflss we «lam-{I 52¢ n1=+=4. ssvicmil :3 AA 221312121 mu fzuzlsa 2.2<u&.°5 ahcu mile: 3. ma é.&'L&d em <13; w-21021 sél mm 3; emvu 23v1c?s.ra <5; 2u=u<:u0u 'i0t3.-x9 uni aisfizil uoefla 623', «am tafseu mi cu2'1vL~-'1,':r/my ail 21°zs'1v1L=j, wfla @123 Ftcgct nu? zggsiat ecti Ptefl :3-1'le1La'lrfl smut; gsqtafl HQ:
°mL<»te._La azucfl ausm rtél. MP1 new 5%,; '>5 etavtt =31\1é':va' am 3:29. 4 91:8 a gg an-{I 3129 "5'ClJ.¢-lEt5l'l ucfl rt «£129 {3'Ri«:t aim 13,23 o_3,s2u.€mvfi :3 2M Guam wuouu «ail. °}2il e2'lms.'lr': usiluw £12 zletla em ecu 3; EH ? 4013 mm mm ..s.s1m1 HQ =ei°a'10il 'A1151 écti aarfl wila Cauzlsm &l-'<'.9fl2i?. u'.°g2i sadl wk :3 {N1 4131 gm-L-El Mu-421 gen a2cu=+ti ma 23.
----z eg 3 H. :--
(1) «mvfl wile: aruigtil mm---u aiulécva 3 °} {gut ¢.:.--'taue=1i mmctLUL1riot2L--x9 écti <1 gzcfl <3 wig: 32241211 zruéi ab 2:1-1 9. 32:11 '*5 gun. $31'-a1wi sacusti 2»u<'1@§L aumqwu vitvL:¢--x9rfl l?t.§*1=1-11 gsn 3.9; g:>.a.:e+1'. -*»-uld. Lu.
(2) arnfla-u. uni rum M gen 31 emu zruqcl -123.
C:\.My Dacu_:uentI\1£l.l1-CA8E\0(,'I'O,'Bfl\36-1DDG'dnc (3) =Af¢c3tva cm": Qflcfl zzguia am $3., {'r+tL=fi an gm:-a=ai at.
au.,ooo,1-- °zr=1Lszt9teuV® :11 a Emir. 14.2 41. 32 cu 24%, Mali}. 2°2r'i'+a"i5:
Mtéaz. ?»uv¢cu*-a,i zauél 93 %, aru QL.$L%t§fi gal Grail Em air .9123' am wttogi étq all $2 éLLé'L aiuléuaru -tmvfi 2R3i:'L3-«a 9123 its :¢'1ft€i"€;'ifL qslaafl 3;{°1.-75t.<'i§3t um as: ch.
(LQH. 'zfl. figfiitfittvfl ) f L'-{'mv5"m bani? } 5mg fix»:
C':\My Decm1Iev11n!2007;(TASE\OC'T0BERY§ 64'-Zflflfiflnr