Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Smt K Bollamma Machaiah vs State Of Karnataka on 24 January, 2011

Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, B.Manohar

r-- 9

£®§«.Jj..J f\.RE"*Z R fffi':
PALP,£-'&E'€E':Z .i-.£f5'E.'..»'§{} If}

C E} I:i-'i."I.'1 §'"E.AE,,§ E35}

PEN 5?"? 248».

S0 17%/§'J\-i'£'*.I-9iP[%3'i' '?z'\a.§f{_§'§{
'E{C§iT)f§(}EJ §L}§S'I"'R.I{1'§'.

{RY M /S. E---I.i%":£} 1+: A;E~3S{T)(':Z;'-'x'1'.§*3E?. ,s'°:§)'\f'E§;}
A§\ED:

:1. S"I'A'1'i%': OF KARNA'1'AKA,  _
RI%lPREiSEN'E'EI) BY 1'E-.SECRE%3'i."ARY.V " -» _
RI:<:vE:N15E: [')E3I.3ARTMEi1N"F ' " ~., V. 
EEANI) ACQUiSE"E'£Oi\I} " _  ,
MUIJ1'1S'1'OR£+";Y'f$1') f3UIL£)VI'E\}.(}; ._
BANGALORE5.}5{3.G om. ' ' - 

2. TI--i'I':'; 1)12r={u'1V  -- 
KODAGU*D1£5TRVIC'fi',.f-~ '   1- '
KO{)AG'U. *  * '  '

3. TI---1 :5, ASSi.IS'1"ANT ._e:QM'M1ss1b1\:ER AND
_. LAND.» 44%;: QU1S'I"iEON--..O 1433:: 12R,
 aw-x:)I'ié:£«:I4<i.1"LsUE3--I::'1v1SK5N$
"v.E_<:c>:3m_::::_,  --. 
'4. " T    R:§s§;>QNm«:;N'rs

gm?"s§z:---V  ' '2{§z:s}---am, A<;;x;

.5. .;;;§5;é:%.§:::.;:;_;q~s'*1'3:' - 



"ET'HE§'rS 'X?'sF.R1.'TE" A§'*E-3Ei',z'-7s..§.J {S3 §*7'§.E..,E}ZEfi)  ;'TE;% 41% OF '.£'EH?§
%iAE2NE\.'E"§§K;§ ET-Hiéi-"E" Ci} UE€'§" ..Fa{f'i' PR;-EYENG '§"'€'j§ E5355'? 

*1?»-1 E. OR'§_3E%3E-3 p2\$$£_a1.;> IN Tma: :v'za_1':' :ié':'ié:?':*:*;£*fLf<::f§.:vv.

NC). Z9205/2008 €'E,A~§5€ES_} £.iL'~X'£'I.§Ej} iZ7,f'f_,2'2OI0y

mac. vs. Nfi}. 8:~;55;'_:0 IS i'?II--j%Z'£I}--..L§/:33' :_,;%3f':'*-'I(;;~F°*:"ft»31.Ie:'L'V..A
cpc P§E'ZA'y""ING "E"'C} syzmr' "rm; o_£zms:§a ,<:>::«f?' mgs:-.L;E%:A.£z&A:;;:1:s::;_i
s:NGL,:«:: ,3 3311311319; m;r-z«:;:) 2ZF['Q7f20f§£? V-rm1>_¥:~4:--"~'A 43$; 'w'1f>.::*:_*

;>§~:'r:'r:0_N NO. M3205/08 {LA} ::>'L::§é;';V:\:G "_i.V".§--iii if-*§::;°~;;*:):}i;::*g;ié':*{ }:::;«*
":'_1-H: w';2z_:";:' :r>:2m':0:'x: BY_;xmJ<:31?«;'1'1'x:':;..fm_1_s3 z%}§'E3'}_K.E{jz'3;'..E';}'()N' ma:
'2';-IE: IN'{'E';R£:?S"£' 014' J:;s'::;--C :;_* Ar~%_:j> gigiu-:f:%i"'~% _

'1';--1:15 mm" gag:-3E:A:;"A;/~*2%§{ :v11;::{»<:_.v§?_'. <:{C'::§§1NG cm' FOR
PR1+3LIM.INAR'r' I--ii.4}'i~r°gf§_§IE\§vE}A ?f_1*'i-ifs  SABHAE-1'1"!' J".
DEI,1"V££Ri?;1";'i"E*E:§3%?§ :«*i5i%;I;0w:N-G; 

     

This 21=pp€.;1_I  hfikd  E1136 1: r:sL1<:§:{2sSfi1l pei:'i'i:i0ne:'s3

_ i:'1 \,'&2',,.E:?::'   'iii-'%i:'1g ziggrieveai by the GE"'Ci€'E" dig

'*_2"?.?'I€';--f2Q};.Q; w}:€.:*ciz1 i:._h<»3 i€E12'Z1f;':d S£ng.§E6 Judge Gf ithxise;

Cc){,s1;f-.hz1$' -'€i::éfijE=i_f:<3{f in quash tihifi 21<>i'.ifi<:as§§0::.'2 undsgz"



;.e: ;w

S:;2c.4{iE} 0? '£I§'1ci= Lzmiti x"a<%q:,zi:§£fi<';:': Ae:%*é.. <3.  §.,i2(}{§€§ 215:»;

.::;1E:~i;0 ihe iérizii Izmfificziéiaré.

2. The appeE§e1:'1t.$ lmrein f;'A1§;ja:i fhéif "';"%':":=fii_~ Pi-%'i:§ti.ig>r:;.L_' 

No.E€)2U5/O8 SCf€:Ki§'1g £01" qL.:a::2I:1i :=1g 

:1<_>tifi.r:::ai:.i<>1'1 cit; 3.8.1.2006 ' :_:_:i';--ci§. fE.1i1"2.=1} i".i()"£j;,§.».f._P'i"e€3é,';. {,i'(,'-1171;' -*<}.t.
2.83.2006

21:5 per A2'1;':e.§;z.m;=. 'iI}5.._2ii2.ci &1i'1'O:"1"}§}3AJ[1i}:i{E£iJ{Zi{}'I1E5 <:1i'., 532.2088 anci 5.6.2058. _;?u'1.t'1eX'L:re:ss 'L' Ii: i.s:fijh¢'¥c:ja.st; G_f film pctii;i()ners tilat they' are 31¢ <)w1j.'e1'ss«.{>f I5' §1£::i*e$"+:>.f..--~121:1d beearirag sy' NU68/A Si1Li1e':1{,(:'.£i V'21I';;_ vB<j§.l_u.:*._ "v.$§%i1I21ge% Kushainagar h0b1L _ S<éII1w§§::;p<>i. t::i§1:_}:, K.c)da1g1; {iiSi'.§"'§£?'E'., Preliminary ._ :"§'c}1i:j.iTié;:.:'ai$15512' §SS{,£{f{if made? S<3c.4(E) <1»? the? Land '"A,{7f§1A§i'Et3§fi(>1:i' ..Az§i_"~..dE.m 18;G.i.2008 and E'E°1.%:%:*e2>.ftier {$31.21.}. :10ii:i_§'i't?ai,§<}i?;7.'*Wi's; :'s,;$1:zed an 18,Cf7,2OG€S. H<:swe\;<::r, in $123:

_ ssizziéi ":7:<}§:.i.§'i{%a§:«;E'Qz1s; nzzmss: 0f the p:%U'_iim::€rs; as £.I£i1€ <_m2'.1.';{;ér;%s <3? Elm: lzmd 'w;:a.sI~; zmi: $E':<'>w'§1 221 n d ET)€i}{4£I'Ed21§'§€;'=5 <7;f aha izmd :=s;<:su;_:}':i: {(3 b6' EIEEFE/§1.IiE'{?{'E w<;:'r°é:: 2:»2_i;<_~:e::> ::'1{>i: z':1.é;%.m:'i<).1:1e{i. }1.<;é2:ri1.':g Ilhéif ;>e::2'{.iti<m<;érs zzmd :¥;}1{%é:' 2:{ix,:'<)<:a1:€s-5 (;.::;..$;&:<,:V_5<:%;"é:i '' }'3e21..rir1g c/i:»;:1'§<;*:s3 1"es;p<>r:d<;%11i:5; r@aIi$é:{§ €,h.2{:;t;._V_i,iE--2c:'s;{" w-".;s.s3"' §::iSi.2:tke in mm, ;":'1e1':1'.:i.<:;:;':.iz"1g zm; n;'12I1.€;:_Q I'j. '£'."%i1;.x.-2': ;;)5£':ti4*:iz'3r:;c:r.s,_T f as U38 <>\.v:1<::1"$. \'fi1.e:1fef<>3>«L~:g.. a11':€@11'c'1<-aci ,»g)'i'§;é.§..i:11§:'1éxryé E1{}'{.§f]°.{TE1TIE'(}1'1 xxms issauc3£i on é3.2.2'{?QE%3 as A:11'1eég:Lu*e 'L' to {ha-'% W1°i'i. Pei;.it.i0:'1. V'§T1i£:1ft:%;;;£'"£:t;:_i?,. fixjizéxi"~:'10i:ifi<:aticm F1213 Ex-§:e.11 1&3-:.,;€;*:d cm OV5(Q6t2.GQ8:"aS '-921:1' 'A:iv:::f:2:::¥;<";:'_1"'<3r $10 the Writ Pem;,ion g.1V1aggr:ev,ed _13}§'f1I*i:3 €l:§é£I11e 'Writ, Petiticm was _fi1._ec1 }_)§?vL'._~.1'.1}&%3V.V p--:§tfi'£.iQnT_€%1_*'s; -- appe.I1;1I1ts~.=s hesrein ::<)r1t:e,:3:1i'1'.'2.g t'.hai,-- '§I1*i€"{i'f:E_> \?£§i'S»..32-O h<3aFi:1§-_;", no ezxqéziry we-15; held and 1a':m_;i is r3r;:v_'z: A2;_(t"c;2.:~if1"ed for public. puzrpose as; the L:1md,.:ai.§h§ci'h was; ;~s=:T:';;g,§}'1::, ':19 be a<t{;:.:iré3u:£ fa)? 2'{)21€f wide:m?.:'3g piarpicéx':-fie §*:=.::;,__<»_%;"._;1}.rez:dy been ds:r1<>t;if§::.{i. '§_'hc }.:9:g¢_:':*1e::<i 'E§_iIi.g;§1c%' V' "E3ff?;..si'fi° <t()ns3ic1€:'iI1g i:}.':;_<:*. <:::::u':'£:e:f1*£:i{>;:3 cxf {he k:zi3".r1£é'(i <i:<3'Li:';s3ré§ e:ppe.2*u'iz1g fox' €:E':<;% parttiess; heéd ihati
--Vpe£;.iEit§:'1e:*s3 éi:é1:'1n{3%. be: ;:Jermii".iie:?{'E "£::<::»~ a%ai}§':i,en{i 3121:' éE:<:j5,:
,._ '~' 2: g [WI/gf?' _,.
K V. k, \..v Q;
:6 2--
'W€3'§'éf 1"::')'i: %1£::2::'{'i in Ii.E"2€é E1'§Ei'§.i.€tE.' sg.i:'::_%<% zméy ;2zi"%<%'I' §'EiiT'.2i§'i§'E§'_§ '£*.§'f:¢3i*Ii3;3. a:1':«:;r:T:(;1:;-=:'r{:i .I'1€.}§,i{$672-iEiE€I}i'1$ }'1ax-w: ':3<::z_~i::'1 i.s4s-s5:..:é-?{.i 22::'?;.d_ET1-';c':+;;.?:: kw' §3:"<;é1i:ni:'1.aL1j§y-* rmééfE<':aI'_£.<3:'1_ Ems bc<%.z} is;;=:;:.;E%c3; {i>'1j'E.-:__§%.4€;2'§i{:3 2~::":d fizml :mt'.i.fic.tai.i011 I'121:<5 '::>€:c1T1 p21$§i§3.{£_ on 1'10: <i;§3£:é:'1 'z;<;> {T h -:2 g;':s:%t.i':,§L<:>'1:7;erss; {fa :'%ei2:13;:@:':C?§'Té;%i211':'"é;1:'it;>}f' iE'1E?-£_fi§'~-.f'1E}./.A k:?1e>vsf};<éc1g£? of {tile preii1:2i.fi;§'2"§7V_ E3221' A:':1'1c:xure 'L' .211'1<i a.:in:\.ii:i:e:3'1§{V.--i;§;;{jv-_£é_1#3A§i £i:',.f§]1,i.if%"€3{i f(}3' w':icie;'1ingg of the mad ;§f§'e{§;&r€'%33i3 Ejifld §\/£§Jssa.>:'<3«I\!I;51.(ii1:{f;%.I%i:: ;'§2_21i11§; §;§j:&;;;?!. the Eemd is 21<:c;_L:§.;re(i {inf is' 110 i'I1eg21iIii;y in 't..he:c '..--';iéc§i(1rdi:1g;§1y rtzjatiieci the Writ, P€t'ft.i§}:é. by we: said order of the 1eeu':'u;:ci" E7> i:'_1;g,4§_x:3 ~.:I_1v.'z(1§j'.§c'-2 w2'?.()?C2OE0 ihis Wri': Appeal is §:iE{;=.;i"i33I _:.z'*;*;.s:..1e::(:es-s;s:;.fi.11 wrié' pe3i'.i'ti<2:1<::'1'$( E'1z?w{-;% E'1€z1:"{i the §§:a,:'n<;>:ci {:<:si,1:'1se§ 21§;}p¢;i%';x.ri21,g.,:. '}§:>":' Etéie ap'p€EEar7:ts~s a'n<:i SE16: 1{-E*.E1E"E1€3C§ M} i§{}vé:é:';2:11€§.'";i' 2-:£k:=<:m.g:.1'&% .i.s~; {i%r£::{%i{:(.E to Ezigkgi? :'1€_1€.§@:% far :*<a%s;;;>c>:1{i{::'1*:. Ham, 1 {Ii} 3% E3. L€3.x'5u'"§1<3{i :':<>u:1s3::>.} z-.:§3pea1°ir':g;; for "$1.0 z1p;}§'1]T;i1?:'i.V§; V s.~3uE3:1'1i_t;f.¢t(E maxi: {:a?€::'1.£.I'3:>L2gE2 Eihes e2u*§_ier:r pi"-s::Eir:ii1:1é::"f§,r' ':10»t.ifie::a£:i(}1:1 did rim. S:'h()'W the :1_21m:§% <3£'€:'§;:% §;s._}1»;135e:%-§7E_f.é,'a.';<1fa:s :>1és file: {mg-*:'aers of iiirtuz lanii \>vhi<:}1 v.-21$ -55<3i3! A£s;f1f'T {G 'Q;<>f'.ja-':1§:é:;::_iré:(i.;"A b0Lmd21rieS were: xx-*r()z1g£y :e;11<>xvf'1*..;?i1'1£1 sarmz ix;2.1'<'-;- .r§j<:t4ified by issgxzing fT{:7ff">h pr(e1:mii:;é§;~:y I'.iVA(}'3;,!§_f}'.(3"&:1§if}i'};... Th<:reeafi;.<ar, :10 opp0r1;.LaI1%t.y was give11 "tiq§h.e_a1pp{:118§m:S' su13si:2111tiz1.i;e their ct(}1i1:e11ti:;»:3_.Vt:11'§aj: E.i;i1'1.;_:1 is; not r<~:q'uir<i%d for pubiic puI:'p«:)s€ é:n€i._the3},r 21:};-iLc£V'::Q°3-gigtsviszdge a.b01,1E: 1:116 passing cf the fréeish - p1=§31i1:§1'i£3.;i3*3,r n0tifiC21ti0n zmd final .._:10t:ifi.(?:}..ti<)L:~: e11":ci"{:.m:}{i r.1«:'3f;, fiité {}bj€CfiOE]$a THIS: }€211"1'}€':d Sf.';;L;gf._>;i_<:L:'é "h_a1=*i::1g_§ :f€g2::'<1 114:} i:E:::*. fami, i:_h21§' 531.11.}? af'£;m° hL-aairmg' " ;§vi<21:vif=i<>n€3:'s§«appeE.ia:t:€;s h€§'(;'.'iE'1 izhe ::«3a;:'§i<::_1" ;g31"'€lir_n i:1z::f§,g?'nL<;>i;'if'i<:s1t,ic>11 ctzime £10 be: ITi{)Ci§fif;'f€i by i$sa1i'ng '§:°<:>:-3'1': g3:"£{E§.;32ine1ry n<>i"i.fi<::2:at'.§{}§1_ (iii. 8.2.2698 zgmari fiixai 22§;}pé?t§I.2-&E'2.i'.5:4; E0 :>«:<,>:*i.«;.<:::::§: %'E':<i=. 3'€;'H".§{".'{'i:y' in £:1€'{.?iI}}"€fE£:i§.'}Ci? wéilz .12:m.~° by é§C(?k§I'}§{ fir}hZ?i§'1{?{3§"£"§€}.'}'E 0? :?0:1:p:;?z'}:a2:1i:'.im'1. if ',?",'.}'1E'€f;*.'V~',.' gm: ;2;~_;;',-,§;¢%,_§:*:'<:%v€;'*:<TE ':>§; E.l'1<;:=. ::>:£'§"e;r' n1z»h:ié.> E:>§-* i:'.h€;=. Lzmd z3g<j;:;:§e;:..i.§;;§€;iigé;__ '4 <3f£':i:::e21 SiE1{":E'i {hes apps-?2;2.i {:§i::§;::':i§~::s:tiii ¥_:3:'7§ m€;':zi_ii':%;.; ap;}ii{%21i':Ji<}:'1 fan." smjfz 1:1 £€.E}5£%/':€}""Ci;:v:Vss :'_i:30'i:M &e;11rviv*e fol' <3c3'z'1s;ideyai.i<:>:1 and f.E*;a; --:.=.a3'nc:%§:c{:~<31??diH_g}y di3p<:ss<::ci of.