Karnataka High Court
Dr N L Subbaraju vs State Of Karnataka By Cbi/Spe on 20 August, 2008
Author: N.Ananda
Bench: N.Ananda
ae ME OMARINATARA INH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C
a1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 20° DAY OF AUGUST 2008
BEPORE
THE HON'BLE MB. JUSTICE N AL maa -
CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO. ay OOF 2006.
Cow
CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO.I27 so as :
-S ©8L .8.P 80.1207 oF 2006.
Bs RTT
di ae leer
sy
sort
oS, :
36,5. BELLARY woaAn EEN ne ee re
Dp Sikes DRE GANG 2
are ,
gE
-- Ser ear Terre erreacs ses ~
ae SUSLRINTENDENT OF POLICE
JlBY BRI BSHOK HARANAMAT, hil, ADY.,}
ee pete wees or Stor gees TT 2 eS
Pha Leb SL LS | UP ELED OY S397) Bye
a sof ae Pare aed % Pe ae ww rrrer rer
GR. F fd BELLE ALLY Doe TE ELSE TRE PEE LT TON
aE ot '
EDL SB 3
Pry *
cane 2G
402
ER
® Ay
ig fa Fi ad on fe
Y Eb je OT
a4 ¢ 5a"
ca P
Oo rx ra ri a Ow
| e rd MOO GS ao
H = " a 7 bea a
a bd 5 x orn) ey 2
oe E z gree, ds
we i ' Gn ow
es OE i mo § g
Peel fA. i me H fi cj bs
ans & a Biba oF
fe: Tey e : a) - no cy Py Pa at
ey ae * 7 ee fa Q i i
; - ° bn, t m ie
ma Ey coe _ 2 a Oe BS
He Oe ae ma py PS wr £2
one w 4 Gia aa Hy
3 at te "ob be EN wo Me
cs] . 7) a Ma tes B {3 yh oh
ae , psd ped as " be dd 3
Sey os ; me fF we
a) a u oy 8
ee af rs:
ut rh ey ran
re : ot gj fs
, a i od
pet " " mos
~ ey rf baat cp ob
. a
g . a E
" att "Eh
ar
a fs
bes Eyr G
ays Bs n= ae
waa ay ied a
DO HOIW WIVIVNEVH 40 LINOD HOIH VOAIVIVNEVN JO RINGS HOI ONWLIYNAYS 40 ENNOS Ged ener on ech oo
mG i es | = 7
by, a a . a . w B oe "ts *} _
eaeg a a Ef i a3 : ct a ®
oo a iL . Ds re
i a meg LS
fe @ ar Und a rd a
| a4 eal ns Oe han ig "ey
Ma re ea ' a S wo
es iz GF io
Yn, "4 & ad a i
wa tH ped tig 4 - a
re a a SO ans id = i
ing wd oe : 5 er
ul ot on
{3 rs ' an " PSE 7
ee ve iA ed a #e
. iy ol a pe
fap A a | eo,
' ° = bof es tg
co ie oy a Le a
Ml og ee x
a _ . an oe " .
Ly hd a fs aed 2 . a
is ey re & . 7
a 4 e ae
cm id te "7
ved fl |
a cM as)
* "a
z i :
i -
He C3 ;
a a is
a ea
ah i
os mt
ay
By
Bd O .
" a Ny
2 HSIN WAVLIYNAED AIO 1HNOD HOI VIVIAN 40 NNO YO Weiwannn GA pun Aan cine.
~pd
ond
a
7
a
3 iv
Sti
hd
a SF
a
Pa
aehed
|
a
eh
agen
on ba
is 3
an
ke ee ee
Far
Pca Har Bae
yey pe ee
Pe
#
tee
the
insurance
v
¢
&
Tndia
Pe
Pa
ted
os
Aa alte
fy
pa
5
4d
a
<3
ie f
ob hed RB ME a0 i) ue) rf ite i he fs" i
al Oa g a ie a aH * } Ao 3
re HP ag cy iy Ae z 4 ce) 8 i}
a> or er mn S sos <a "
" Be ne i - : "f = "Y
4a as oe be "4 ao g a bm ars mh
a re ee ne, rat te HOU a s ,
: ob os 2 Soa & a8 HS
a j 2 ns : f :
th a ne 5 "OE = >
ay iby OTT * oo ens rd eh it re
: sey i . AG whe - a re, oO cs in
i A a ae oe co es Pe) Ra Ee ae ia -
She ° Bed ey ot ie ih, aS ey Ae "4
* a ees o ot 4 3 c
we o a a ' a ved
6 ae | oh oh zi wd a ei "
i rs rr are ar re a
ie) 3 4 Goo Ae : ea rood o G ns
HO og . a
0 es a ul bed = 5 bd
ms we 8 o fF -
dh ab a at ° "rd bed re a
ee teh a a a ma
A cf 4 4) ay "e a
io rd a bt 0 a
Mo a "4 a od r
ee ee is
i An ay ia tod ope i
ey fp 44 "t Me
fe 3 we He
rf OU 4 OU w
uw ni Ey a XY
s ved , ce > fo
a rd wT os a
C3 Poe 8 cfs
#t wd aed ri
. a > 3 hed 4m
"4 a as a z #:
uh fd i ae a3 S
i bb ed iM Go
a ei pom ery god
ut « oy ay eof
te a z way bl Fae au ie
fis ont i ai af Pe) wt Lod
memes ER A POAT LA WWI 40 ENNOD HOI OWENS 40 exNOD HOH OYA 4 IT cra enn ne oo
pH
$) = eM OT aay 7
a ae a 2 9 BA Gg giooo« Ei on ee i) he
: o Sof Ss ou R | e
Ae Hy » OF To oe cl sooo
ns ee fon be a @ OR &
5. Sed Oy a
aa "3 tf': " i : 4 a
ey a @ ee eo as DF mw.
a © ay o " a & op
a] ra a ae ht a ed dat vend eo
"tt Do op 8 Be go eg a8 oe ow DB
ih Oo og om oa n ee ee
o 43 = me Tg te
: iG ee rm OB me me og 4
oh in a a "4 apd me id .
a ef 4a 1 f a a |
me bef 7 eee - 8 oe 8 gos 4
rs) mh ' 3 » ; ia ce i an x cs i
7 CG by ER fs " ' rn at
\ 0 i Se ee eo et
SB OB e ei fod ue
} veg care wow £ wy Bw
7 i La 2 4 op
4 a ee " wom 4
e " 3 is 6» fb e
ced ha a My by ed
oy fa ad Ae ty
if ee th Up de
"ae ef om 4
. we = Aa dud iy $j
G ag is i mond
: bee : anc ee
a tes e C za
" "8° ae oh Bs
hk 0) as ee 2
dep a m4 BA
cl ei ry ate
et, ag a ay ooerd ogy
he BAL fan Ung ae be
-- _
sa ged "ed
SHON WIVIVNAYY AO 14NOD HOM WW NY HO EAM Ue wowrwannar LA Cun an cen fee ee!
pth
ud
ns a 2 ed oe cS ee es ee | ~ ®
m8 od od rd | Hoe go ou oo a oe
pioge 3 Pease a OF
e "* a rt 4 * a ad
oe ob HO ® ™ i ay = be
+ f | HG a 4 a
ef 2 1 4 a G 4
mY ee) by ae qf
"4 2 OB Cp. my © Md 'eG do
So oa cf & : ad 7 iy OD
id ' " * : Dp
"5 2 2 v oe a
O mS wae sors
ra Cf to ' "bool pod ae
bl to foot
# fs woot 4 a
1 we S . t
Ma "
ae i
od ne nt
wo 3 can) oe _ = Ff
ce, : "3 re ee ee.
wha esi td e _ * on
cy nt t 43 a fog
a a 5 4 a ° re ri ap
r . : ed A i} ca
& e 8 ibe a fb ee
ne oi tn ~ og 8g
Bd a $e, e
. x Sg 4S me BL
®) a ne ae i 4
en rl i. ar: er es « he aq
a i fp RE By i ie
4a bd a GG Boj mS
os oe ad a a @ mp
ij ee es es: "i Lk "yd
us . oop oH maw
ds bel .) ok a be 2 LQ 1g
AA GEL WAI HRES UA OS HO WWWIVANNYY 40 ENfMOD HOI DNVLYNAYUH AO LNNOD HOI wiiWitAn GA airs cami caus. oH.
4 @® ef Th 4 wg 4
" > + @ gw Dw
oe ef) a
vd bt GH Pgs ig
g tl {3 mtd
Bas) a ul a ne
ey Mme God
: a foM
eh ft re
a aq overt OU Og >
4d 430 W 44 aa ow
_ oa fot oy
fa) Cd nop "
2 i a re 7 tt
rn .
Pia er a Q
we
ft or i 2
: we i
Ab ' moe a
"et i, rr
By a ce
5 aa
ahh kd
ne nye " oe Pp
ay a o ky
ay} "et th 43 -- rs
eo é fy
ee en "on
mw nm $y rr fi, OS
s RE 4 a Q
ey gy 4d re um
Mean fo tala ia By
OE ER LE LL PATA A ESA LER ee re ee ee ee we ee ee
oy o 2 er oH > © G
re a? red Ca oe a ee
del i a ord rs ee
) fa) ee | mo Ma
ee O -eG oP Ed a
SJ os =| . vord
of 2 BOO w
a m4 mo
a © ss i ug
is at a : cd ied A
: u #2 Oo 2 8 We :
ahd ie Ms 4 eh
5 48 :
z ru pod a rhe
<A ae nd pond
ia had o pa * a ri
a o & rt a i
iy it ood nei fg
ss had eg ea 2 coos ee Fe) af
Fa I. 4
a ed ES
. et a oo
at Be 'fh ee
* mi : ce re e ie) Cy a
we <r Aa 4
ay ) 4d ee 44 4
y (3 fog
hd 13 , * #4
el ri di or ot im i
i A fob @ SF
i + aed eo mm * oo
wd my fi " cP ord i
a ced a rr H "4
id Ago i oor
Vi Ay cl, at is be LS
ws 'a
A st
we em Ue eA LEC WMWIWAENYY AO DNMOD HOW CNYLYUNAW 46 LANGS HOW wividyADWY am oeins CECRIL EG ere te
2 @ Oo Oy oar ow ah. 6 oT «bow fy y #4) 8 & T+ @ « m
os re <i ae nF wey oe © e eS a eo ee Oe a 43
he ee oe eee 4 Boo cet ER gh 4 SG i f © mm «
oS OR a ee ee & © a
oO . g om @ bo og I mn fo # G@ Pa og @ & HO in
Se ee ee es 3 ved cf ay UG ee rs t) ed UG 4
Gost or mg wp & G "ad om i i Cy oe 4
Sd "ag fy fe rn ow, _ ff Ly
: che OE ic * aera
iB z 3 ogy cae) oe og et ord a nn are
cs re Wo yr u os 4: eto hl OO en: ee
@ 4; gob 38 re er rd ort Fg a af aS
tha mt Cy a wt be bl be eS uz ra fy by ® hd > a
ee rr) ae ee oso + Eo th ©
Le tS a 2% @ | @ mw 4 =
od wo iy my AR oo: a
wd a cy OS ane v3 iy rs ap 4,
a , it . ee eo ei 6 "
m og Fos cog oo 6 8 @ 3 oo @ = 6
kl it pb og " een nas a oo © Lp
o~ a . AG at 4 ml ey 4d an ey et
aa 6 rd " ao Ss @ : 43
ae > - ct HOM Li
nO i Pe ee "8
Sn crs! or wy . pl aon oT we PO 4
Soe oy ' ce ~ ° 4 oo ge os gj
© mood wf a ¥ mS hope my 0
a Vo & a me 0 eS "OR eg ae ns er
an ca i Ag ag a ord oO 2 WY 4s
wef "se sd "pe. 4a O 4) a> att
a a iy df ig a ry Ry 6 0 BM
S Hort Bo 8 'r a ob Pore ® Ss 6
m i: i a 4 cae ped a Bed ry ped bed ar
'n La iy £3 ed aie sed Aa a red 2 bd
cir] o} i a spa Mag
wo LS at bey. ao are: i 1 wo of}
ved
ad
bya
re
ee ee ee ae ee ee ee ee ee ee et ee i ee ee. ee ee ee ee re ee
af mo: oe oa" a 6 ft Mm da & = tb - :
ef ot @ 3 "gh eo ow ow 8 ys F Ge a & a = a a S 3
4 ttt (Bae oF 2 oo OO Bb « 8 4G @ & 8
q ord ao # © i oO G5 8 es U4
i gs Moe i 4 Roy a SK ds
ym of C * he eh OO 2 ow om ke "4 @ mw
ba a . s we pa ai # a Tt " : ral peed a cy a end a a
booty it : ee | obo ae.
e o ® 7G " gg HE i ee, | Sou 5 O
wd " pe eg : a ibd : wt ra hd isan bs, bi a ved i dl ra
wee ra) ved a "AD ne 7 . is 2 3 a ce as i "ed a fe) ath
Book "4 ° A 4 Po. @ iH a
e 2 @ Bo roa ce see oe ee)
eS gored 7 Sedo nt cc ~ ree ; i
eS i rte a woo moos
as a gy iy me ne ye th SY he
a a ae 7 op a ee ey orl wy *
rn rn > " a2 el gy aks nN rm
oO meted & A Vag! id ee ©. g a go
Se Se ne typ a] -- my
_ rp: fi % ib Cpe i a ; fred £ : rd hd @ ed . ee ;
sf ogy ted he. co ne a ns on
a ee ee on ee © rn Sees 0G CN oo
fl i pet - wl a ae S a s a et om yi ap bo
ca ie eb gy Vom ag © oe ay Ho S28 8 8
ry = a ha " =| = hug a o : . * e s Pan sa " s
ane ae o 8 opt Oe, hp a ou a
os a re er 2 | doo@ Gy a4 ye a ae Tk
GE Goo" ob Gs ae nee R = 4s
: 4 > = 6 +7 te y os 2 Pee ged core)
3 0 7 og Te if a Sod oy Hi
44 45 oh ib ad bad (i a ih Ei sgnd i The th ih hi an ml
54 rh, | ee oe ee S| tebe ch me ' of
Of we ct rt ood gk Row Se ee OO ay ie be
f, t W tos 4 ES od oo oe Bi caren iy "op EP ay ae
M, © tet oO Fo og GO shot cet 2 oe eh eee ee
ee ee ee = re ad a ay
HAHA WWYIYAINYY 40 PHNOD HOI UNYLIYNNW 40 EHMOD HOI CAWIVNAYS 40 ONO Gee enreiwarw: cA cu Ww.
\k
OL
with
active -
Cis ec
ar
--
~ WEL Tneurance a LPs AY No. aim fe & ao ft.
ee ged t- Aah isd mem rn rote Lot Cs ef "a3 i i cme -
eed al i.
7 ;
ae : 7 a a rr wg Md png Me fy © wa ef TFA eed oF wa ware ood MD | UF of Lantl fratdu mt
--
c ef cy ae Th ee Tue Go Pe ee Re os ear Fike ee ee ee ee £ £ & C A my 1 several L OB, i "ge 4 ss a i a "i "3 a ed : > ab % eon bp og SB : = good "5 i Mr, if cy or ee y = ne ci 6 mud nm mG og Ee rm ® et 3 pen i pa ty, i} ae a PoP g in Ga a es Fe i & a cH gs 4 (ag rs 3 4 ef a x @ be iy a 8 #8 ib i . a t bdo bef oy a fl Cc py ke of by if "oe fe) ui ts =~ oa. : AS rs Fis * an ry » = Pai a fe Ej mo OG eo Pe 1G a er, mB cae a4 a _ ry " Bed : a ae nn a.
ag ah a Be = : 4 ne: ay Pe tks 7 4 id ~ Ve a pe OY ay " bs vd 3 ted od Boo Bk or ne : _ neff re a ah ee Ae A CN BRIE EMA HOH wi.
i) "i woo TT og ds 6 @ Fa e Me in 0 PR ks m OS tho ot : 4 iF Ae & #8 3 : gE aga Lb . 3 -
ig et a 5 "
rp ee nt . " 2 re} pod pond rd fi m my oo ie ee oc oo @ a '@ i hed & oO mu cmd HEE vend vod gs | ee ee es ee ee ad hood Ox yd , ood ord a ~ " go Foe 6 ud A Ag bse th ia qe a ad is "ca "Ch Le a imo # it i 3 ny 4 ne: ere ee , re eS re:
ig os oO bed a ty ots of a i?
iy a be we A LO WYWITAINYY 20 DINO HOM YNYULONNYY 40 LHNOD HOI GAY LYNAYS 40 CHAOS HOt eneiwanien cA uma oo...4
Be Unit ol ar aeci i a cone apps Sue a os tan Omi ary é EELS C % Fa foe ARUTAL ce L yA da.
peg i Ho or i < & 2 CW ow & : rv ct oo Om es G6 oP BO Zi Oo a ee 7 ee 48 wg a go am ¢ 4d M4 ? fay oe % a rod 'et 8, a aa, to Gk ais : e @ eGo Sy ge, %o on * ee pe rm pon . ) 4 eof a og a # ® & "a oe : 3 oe ee: ee} _ a a o er; a 5 a he " 4a . .
@ ms 4 u So p 4s cr Lb mn" 2 en ja rl Wf a ou S SF eet ea " cs i mn Se ee i a 9 oan a i ot Oh #l, = ne e "a eg dM wi a } wf it a bp Oo ¢ ay hed et aa ns ao i a ; nt re 5 , ii mys pa i ey a) sl -- on eS ra a i ; ee Eee fe _ x iF) " i be ae = " ra tH nn eS en a a I oe i) "ogy 7 a oh - is aq « "ey a oot po ag a és to Tt oD is LD mo oo @ i ved re i i med ue ve i we 4B fed eo & ooo oo ip Qo fb HM i ow i - + £8 WwW GS & na ne a ra | mo oy 'D ed i i vhs het = en ee en a a es ee a . "4 end oof nyod wt ee ee ee re ee ee Pe ry PAW CTs WRUWEWRIMWS UE ENA LC ok & a. S) es 2 er FI god 'hae . om Li | ne or? imp po: G 4.4 oO ep cE i a pond FT fa . gl aes ed feat 4d f 8 eo of a ty By ved a da. od ° . ra * j tie a akg 7; 8 : kp ' ot a} i on a faa fi Me greed Oo OB ir) ' ; it py fe jad ren wp wt vhs of ~J 6 *
--_. c Ba eo 43 its on i ad ted At ef ry i a3 red mo A hy He er: rf pd RA oes $ feu ee ees ob Ni oot 8 Rm ek a eh ot fy ote if 4 - ee ey ou, G8 a 4 sped bd, ie & 24 fa cee ke AA EAI WAIRAISYY AO PNNOSD HOI CONE LIANNYS 40 1NNOD HOM ONWARD am fies cmd Caren 2 Lk Is
-- me ee ek .
Pr ee LT a el _ x an:
god o i e 'eg © ae te ey Bt Lads Fine died ie Ue Pee eee eee * ood a a BS i fed ged "4 ae) "oat 4 7 o be p be a fae rt ca VLGL ee ee
---c ee oe Has power or ia rod * fad -
co a8 Sood Mo 4a ae i Po ed bf ® ® a ey cuct,;
a oOEL seg 3 Spd f¢ ih a Me, oh ct oe fi a9 " 'ad 4 ie q oO "4 . ak ~ 3 a ; ee ee my 6 . %3 2. Be "ed eg 3 P a b ~ fo i r ie Wy g =| age rd 8 2 i aa a ' rs ned a # as a : ne | he # su » wi .
$ 8 4» A 8 & i G 3 fey ia ved 4 ee: ia fe i = C4 e an "an oi te we oe a sgn Ld | " oe ha ay Q hd 6 a = ad a Lak Wi be Pa a ye th sy ce es 2 4.3 me | A a ce. 4 is oh ui 4 a es = fa te Ey i 2 Py, wD. 3 Wa e Shed : i a Ca a wl =) " 4 8 spook td Es is) ts nal a Bef . a me G » an ne a OS 3 > i :
oe a Fs ped ja a 1 del a a re mi a Rg cee ee ee a ee WRIA EOS HOW ONWEYNAYN 40 2dNOD HOH VHYLWANNYY 40 DOS BO puwiwane on Dun AR cia a 2 6taé wmeaterial ~~ -4 © f) Tl @ | » © b @ ke e3 cea eae ge he %s bats _o 4. * ' a _-- "
7G OR eo" 8 8 @ oo oa @ eR ot moo. G ea re Mi tb cs) o mw © o - io jd "eet : had ted i wie Wed to as "4 re re a ; Py w "ol - is rn ww a aoe : i bey ci . : ge ete po & 5 m Bos g ih. ", - i opr od eh a iy a Su a ee spd uh is "te & co re ee) a ao ~ e : 2 @ _ ae Be a i ~ em : 7 9 a ee. ce : Go. 4d _ a gy ui a MB wot Be. 8 o@ 4 go doe E Fi on Ad wif _ s £8 £3 sven & nd F 6 yy MS pe ob go oa & «2 & BR YM BB om ie eM 42 s e i a . a é @ eo & m= 8 WO fh ee Ag a i ces a | ee mo & Gort & ef © © sh a Ud eos Oo om @ fo et & mom Ho af bal we . . rs it € .
t 4 es 4 Lat 'ts het crs me Od ey Ae iH et "
m el c pd peo} a a wom co a i] wi ood hag ve cece ee amma UU RE EES, CEE TWAS OC EMO HO! 13 wi mm iD aD i Hel 4 3 a of @ 8 YO z» OC & 8 34 we motel 43 a t AS . ib 5 eg 8 Hoag 8 8B go 3 wef ted ged a a ro ad a 8 i a 4 ort 7G 4 i o way bd a ay iva i ts a - set 4 go il La a 3 at 8 oo ded . ef . oc . A a 2. at ra - a @ tH 4 "e a pt 8 . ¥ a . a Pa] et » oo ae om « ty ms i . a pa i i Co ui " u ay . Aba ju qed 4 be i . cf gc oa © . : #3 ee ve a % Pe Mh hY_ Bo om ery aes? =p] uk wend & ce) ig 4 . he a eo 8 8 a cf be rh ord OS cs) Fi a Sw oo § 8 om oa) W 4 + a Pe ie) } _ m4 ; im is ay nyt a aed w d dea * god fed 5 4 OS o ' i HOR Os ey oi aged om ni o wed a td "
he re ta 1 F: Bred we ' : 44 G a 4 a ia ge aed wa OR Loe ee ee UAE EO EMSS HOHE oA EWNNYN IO 2409 HOH GIVEN AO EXO bes ceria a DURA ee.
OL wise fore of clon Sct '< a ow iG . cd @ - - ; isd ts ry So I h ae ww fo @ - 2. @ & Bg eG ag 4 8 2 A GO 7 Oo OQ A og c ¢ cS) & i & 1 dee + at o Ww ensive a3 ae ed = hig Bh an e as , vd g ing hd i wo 4a vy uy] e ' Gi oe ped Q : a ; 3 oo 2 od Aa eb oo mB @ © eS Ww Ce om & 4 18 es a Go "oom ©. ¢ © gw , 28 0 rt mo veel ft : he re i re Tr i ud rd a " a bal i' a or a BM ord "e} ia ns - 3 rc) ne. er yo i Cael & w Go ge moe 'i ee a g ms a rs | 3 " we th i iT sy a ow Ad eg DY re _ 7 "3 Pag! 1 ah ca é an © Be) gt os a oe ~ ar, ee oe oa 7 a ; vod oy at a n . 4 # 'B 5 a an 4 i a oy vl et # gs S 0 4H : : i" ee: Oe 3 :
a ved ord h 44 re ; . ; op 8 i ee: woe PER cq it 1 a oo a Bom Be ct 2 8 FF Bp a sg pee at ga Gu gga s a te i ) 7 ae 7 ; Hs an oo * Q %y o : ci . hl ; ee 3 ) bt 5 Pel re mg @ # we Fs oS _ 8 "Woo 4a cob sO oo an 4 FB cs a 7 a "i Mo oot a 8 oO "to oM OY Go es o @ oh in cy ie aes; ede sand Bad er: re . (i rt a ci a . ~ a ae . a is , & s . 4 ta ¢ ed ig . 8 t . ae Te ee ee a en need - i a _ ee ee i. 2 wm Go
4. ot Dy wond eed me
- i MN 4 i a 3 Ce * ' bd ed ekg a ud yee Set awe Pay a bed ie al 1 : a 8 i te oa AY Te) vd id in iG (me em ES LL WEE A OAS LEE RARE en tag the ach CSWTL @ a a 4 a " O oH eM a ip 4 e fy ded ~~ ded H a al ved ae te op co ae oy or 8 8 cd A Qo yy * ae Vind ot g ad "yt a Bag 3 é my of me nr og 8 ER 8 ae . 2 a oR O _ 43 on a a ya a 4 i ) ag © op U ons re ae ; ode , #4 i . 0 G » 4 Bop ge syed ge oo * j fi ee wp Sey v hy a H bel gro = eo ol & ob - ved a i ag et os ih "4 wm del ;
mood q3 end a id AA LEAL HIWEAEIY UO ENOO HOM OMVIYNEWY 40 1105 HOI DIVLYNNYS 4O LXNOD HONE wiaiwane GA GEAR cra cee ee | o go re ha pied ee ® oe ah ded i+ 8 et Ss ee es ee eo Aw 4 ie op aed hed Wr ad . ke a a) z:
oe cl or Oo 8 det mt o " a9 med oh Y ce) ft baa 2 € td ef » A FO HG wy cy u vd - a. ae) ped Oof u ope D4 nl a mn Seo ha ig ; Ms i ad ot iS a nae fe
-- ee g aus re] ha gj yo oe oa e "
an ved ce pt tj th pon je gg a Fy ae Ba a He rr it ie QO HSIH WIVIYNYVN dO 1LHNOD HOI YIVIYNAYY 40 ENN Beds Winner IA Una cea cee ee arce + Lon ons ery i NI, ah ne ap Ho oh G bat a H is ae rf fly mL booed e; © pnd Hoy ty be gt wt od a4 o th % ats Hoo Bt wb oe rood rd "
© uh a 1D HOIH WIVLIVNEV) JO LYNOD HOIK MIVLIVNEVA JO LYNOD HOIH OWLYNAYY JO ENO Hes erowiwarar oa i | 74 o dl ee ae " or ns 7558 88 os es ee 4 # s 34 8 4 ' Y re) 3 yor Le "4 ¢ 2 tl th = Pa) 'b Sal +» e i 44 - ie e 33 : i 2 doa ou send Uy in AG oped ed Moo A 4 sr ved fe 4 4 ts ae oe chy i oO G 44 'ed ir ? Moy 1 8 eg m~ a Li » a a o 4d "ged g 4 a if} 4 4d Wa : fe au Be Wi x ea, ts ey roa od fod a e th hd is ca Be Bs fia ret rf AHO YNVIVANYY 40 INOS HOH DWI ADAY AO DOIN ie eroded ER cum a ce.
i a Had vend +S ee | ee i reg g 2 be fag yo Os a Et?) 2 4 a ry wos _ afd oD 4: fa Le a hg a 8 re:
wot pod & ei Shen | pereon
2. 4 © 4 Ad a
-
a oy ot w Spd 4 es dud 0 ee ace) er er.
a Past : car any ES el garg ba red ad he nd fae mi be.
aft la el ; a ap + :
o a 20 bet ey wn Ng "hd ad a mere ven RS Fed «i is re oh ay alhat bd ne HOI VIWEIVNAEW 40 LHNOD HOW VNVIVNAVH dO LYNOD HOIH NIVIVNEYWS 40 ENO OE erwin: 2 ene _--
a pe fe: o ga & m @ me oo i a os oa 44 "ed 4 4 HG rd ip i i) Gk oO e ood g f 8 & Hi o a ze : hyo i 4 a. ee hd 42 rl o ra hed a on el ns | re) "rf ep 3 i aa + re ej a ct a 3 Cl im f ee : » 8 g 8 ; . A a a us tn a ha a ud ioe oe Te Be a « ae ky '4 C BoM ORs geo et 3 4 fea '. . 4 te ter fy : 43 be M "ORY e; a f t o oe 3 oi wi € e th. a vo AB a Mt hey foe oR ; a yg ae g ae al = a ib eg / = Ee i as at hel Y ua el hd ia ot a ° a a4 4a a ie a we, oe aS ey we ci be ha! a fal area | ' - it aaa Be > es be Sg bay coop BE ia a ee up 6 6S ie ers wv 2 a) oe G i Tee 4a noo i dad "4 : G Pat fe oa ine Sen ri om ae he hod "4 ae , d 4 Ld Q = ri a : aos fa oR S es a fa Kp Re F ee ® Go 4 4 a |e : aoe 8 if o a al a Ba % Ay M4 i oo os 4a 4a cn i : > 44 iy ra 2 oy 4 fe rl red mi ay a at k : ny ca { =] oj ' it bd GG LA eh La it . bed iby : a it a iD 's i ip i "rl it 4 ia Q hi a es " a a a a 3 rf a 4 yo 4a a a3 i i i a ID HOM WHINY AO. ExPOD HO OW TYADIWY AO EAA Le Wrens Cr ce ee Tneurance "
WEG raw Poni or cadres lent cadres to. de AF GW gm ge eo OW om wy :
ped ba 7 cd : ch - 8 Be dof aed 2k & a a = ; , 4 i oB ap HG q a} > & iy Ag ak og c ie g wy Ks o ny Bi ib eo . yp. ti s 4 ka th a : ye er: ee ee ee Rhos ' Bs PG 2 2. & yo RP
4 im, 4 tad , ed 4. Bal # = we cp iy a oe 7 4d i « ti ra 4 ba al 3 a fy _ ma A ae Fo} xi © nn Gb 8 8 «4 i cl me AB be re OES a a , ' rd apy = a ee @ . 34 & ey ae . a * re | ip shel a it } mes Bs a er "at . ah ee zl tae } os e bf ; oe4 Sy a 8 oe fi iv a ai a oe a beg ify ja = "} Ya Pe k i fel Yad cs vet "4 ie oss é a 8 u ig SR Chg. ay a ie ee ¢ a4 y fo ge 8 Rg pe 8 SR : a ae att cae "
: Ea "e & a o . mat o oy Mod og Fa a dd plied fi rE iS he m5 # P x rol @ bed a e i : . od Ja i uo nd es ie aR Poi . $4 mg ag ~ oh "3 ot : nd x © mt ao "es a goo 'ad "a ra " " b pe od
- oy id ve gh mise te ek . rs 'ies gob oe s dod nl fea dot a
- 4 be iy et a at ib a if cb a bod a Ad et a * TA LIA WYHWITTRINYWY 20 PIANOS HOW WWHEIVANAYS 40 EXOD HSIN OHWIYNAYY 40 ENO Ge ewiwarwen on cin irae EhP POoLne ek learned counsel ority & rab.
dud we, ee ee ra wep BS bg ee "4 OM Sst ee:
aa fi nn te 5 ee ee | ¢ os a --
ti % a we, & 3 af ap fie MB ts a pt 7 ao. a ba id Hoe vi Be eb ged ri ce ~ iy . rat Ba © . sd ied TH i ae ; a Et abel WN. r ee "Fy 44 a i a ced fe ct os a fs a Bl QF ah . a a oy By i re cael ha a 4 be ra ® 3 i Ee rey Lae a ded a id rd he "i, he ey Bu i ma i ce re 44 i 0 a hd ti "
2Moa ef: 4a fa . ud u ; Ae a i e :
cs he ae < EN WE eA 8 EME LIGRILA WINES PTA UI ee LE th ing nae Ore accord grity i Ee PE Ob Cones * roa 4 gO kr ho ord 4 g iy a "fd fed 4 i oO €o om 4 co a a Oe bdo & eid ow o oog Led uo 44 ee ee er iy Boom ms e 2 3 it tS i te a @ 8 a i rod es Ea ay dd Be Ts sj | el Ned ' o we * god -
cp + id : ee ry a jor ees 4 ota a bd.
ut Po gh vend , au :
} syed" ab tee srded by oe yeti Face Sh Ment at ree cence eading Vi L a a d by z prove bs ra we EBS de hak * Sate vee é ; . & oc 8 DG 8 wo @ 4 WY Q ah fi Re oe a) I -t of 2 gS ££ 8 Gow Ad ped nan 2 a we © 22 oo 43 om ab gb 5 Se Bb = a <4 Wi i my » = ey bh At hy a 5 dd cm x ps ' . apg 2 A $s 4 mF ag a mM OD Boag Boom a fod og OS aod 0 oI Q g is 3 i C3 c. ae t : a ., i" ap c ey ; bt oe ! | ha A a me Bp ie ne ee vol eS 4 ip 3 a ae ° th a yd ae , & ss 4 Uo @ OS m0 7 i ig SY g 8 Bo oe a : : / Babe OB Sy ARR eh gE r qh 8 fg He fu 8 "{ vel rho aid , . # - a fo hs i a rd re iw aes oa pe oo Anat i Lae. . ed EN Riba eh , ban My Ee a:
a & u ou oe a hy it bt i weed "te kn ms -- oF a ml = "
'd g 8 6 ft op cp Le ap UE md Gm kb AA oH ie pa QF an a oo 3 ify ee ee eee ee eA LA WAIHI OD PO HOH co SWIWANIYN IO EHNOD HOI OWI ANY A Mtn crete ene ek oe ee | 4 vie "AS -
Ce hi a. cet Weg oo gy aA i a ad "neg AF ih si wo ca .
3 7 vod oh WS ed ~ed CT » ff Shy bo a ® ot = ha a ne og eS aa 3 ig cy bd eg ja ne wd ped i ch © ft AS 4d AA WYEWIWAIWY AO PaO LICL WYYIWAINYWY UO PNAC LICL eruiWaAru GA PUA teres a a sand uot eRe Foe ere
--_ "od co] R b eh A 'el ey "4 A egy rl :
ne eG a 5 v4 m7 e a 4 ee oaeenn usec any fe @ ace 1c L ul an "i ap ag o ch iM 7 a be] ad Qe bed io Shad ap hi ae wot at ra OS is fi "
C3 i at im ra re we al a kp Rye S| © a it zi ts 4 a BS ot a Gi vy To iD Me is o kd ba a © ad rn wh iy i Et 3 t H eB Bee » ~~ 3 do Re Sood @ & gy 'Go QO ee ee Se | o a Oe ee + a o ff En "et iD a goon ue OG 48 se Pe) rn oe mm 43 rt ig " ral mn me 6 OF 8 eh a 3 goo ol aS ; aoe my # a i aad i. . to $4 i weg ey er BS a hy ; "ey : # "a : ag ar: BS a gt o oe i Ae seed Sod ord bv a i cee ee - oo} ; rd mI wl aes ; mv apd shed ane) - 2 . ie) ir 7 & ed tL m eq re a "a fos if wand dd a hy. oa 44 Be bet od hd rr ct i a Ae ' i o iq c By cp oot 4 Mead st i : tS : a a foe on v a8 a La wes el 43 " f " ae on 1 i ed Ch % Yad Be '| eo wo fe be it a es " o %t Jos s it es Yocoe 2s Boo. te, my 4.3 Fe ved "4 Hi vg ae eg m4 a aed a oy MM a TS Ee en 4 bed 4 a " a i us 7 poo * 5 og is ie iM 42 os & fa od i: ah od 44 al < af wy oe a eee ee EWR EO POO HOM, oWWLYNAYY 4O 1D HO VHVLYNAYS 40 ONO Be peiwarr oR cans a