Jharkhand High Court
& District- Ea Akpura vs Ws Wo Nee. Oe on 13 September, 2021
Mano? Saha, a'o Bhinvan Saha. ro wi
INUTHE HIGH COURT OF IHARKH AND AP RANCH]
(Criminal Appellate furisdiction3
Criminal Appeal (2) Ned88 of 2017
with
(riming} Appeal (D3) No.of of 2617
with
Criminal Appeal (38) No.227 of 2017
with
Criminal Appeal (DED NoQ58 of 2077
with
Criminal Appeal (DR) No.8! of 2017
with
Criminal Appeal (2B) No? of 3017
with
Criminal Appeal (M3) No.334 of 2017
wilh
(riming! Appeal (ENB) Nu.778 of 2619
Shed et ages? eerie: y
PREEOELEOFE Ea! XE peed CRIS ars!
In Criminal Appeal (D8) No.489 of 2017:
Rua Choudhary, s/o Late Suresh Chauei tary, po vill
Ralmahal, Disirict-Sahibgani
ln Criminal Appeal (DD) No.20] af 2047
Dowakar Kumar, sic Lats Awehes!
& District- ea akpura, Bihar,
PO-Pakur, District-Pakur
fa Criminal. Appea! (DB) Ne22? of oe
Rahul Rhawat, s oOo Shyam Sunder B hagut, oo Bhagat Para, PO} & PS S-Pakur,
District-Pakue . Appellant
4
in Criminal Appeal (DB) No 258 of AT:
Vivekanand Mandal, s'a Late Arind Mandal, vo villape-Cokulpur, PO
Pakur, PS-Pakut iM), Dist irict-Pakur ..Appellani
In Criminal. Appeal (DB) No.281 af 2O37:
dil afa Ganair Pandi B, PFaS air:
i-Sahibeant
"yam Pan
AL
In Criminal Appeal (OB) No 329 of 207 ? :
Any Paswan, sfo Bhishris Paswan
Paitangan} (Sakrigall), PO & PS-Talihad, oMstr
fa Criminal. App ral GOR Na 334 af a0) ?
PS-Raimahal, District-Sahibean|
fn Criminal, Appeal (DB) NoP7S of 20UG
Kasim Sk. sfo Sarfuddin SK. fo wlag
Raimahal, DistriesSah ibeans
»Burbi Tole, PO: & PS.
Appellant
The State af Tha 'Shand
CORAM: HON'BL E ERS JUS Nice SHREE CHANT R, ASHERHELAR
HCE RAPNARER BUE GRA
Por the Apnellanies)
For the State
BRR URE a a ne at
AT oR
JUDGME
ne
vee
. nave? ~ ron
"A no
roree, on.
'not Sot
x
fos one
at ed
wee Sere,
rt wed
we
wo zt
fy fe
tag we
pein
yee nae
ao
oe
en. oe
oo ae
ow Zs
x V3
a %
OPOSCCHTGT! Cs
when =
a _ ae "
é ote
prod
= eeewep x
5 6 ry
| g Oo San?
5 = x,
x 0 gw
: a 4 z
Le ger ao oe 5 3 5
a : eS fees a
oe med Ys me : =
oben, " z | :
AY pa 3 2
Seat - we tA S 2
gee poe, a 2 = :
gees ened, ab pies :
me a x * .
oe a 5 Ss 2
: " ro fe 2
C LS a cae 'ae! -- Ned
cy 4 'sim dea yee a an coe 5 : :
é Z © aa Pe m onl Foal
ora ws a S )
peed ee un 43 mn o z e
7 " 2 43 wt x
we a ae tn a = =
we Ned! areas, , on A = =
x v7 on = : : 2
RB 4 2 eo oo , Se
a Sew ie wwe" ones me £
"eee! . pons so) 2 . " :
poe G2 oe. oye we. own ye ns y
' ~~ of oe So - se :
'tad on ~~ 7 e et Lf =
ys = os wet igen, ce os i
3 5 fet we . 2% rf. a
oh 7 ih 4b > wen, vert aE "
5 5 = & = ek one ares
ot xb "3 ee Peooal " 8
: . open on" "
° be Feed weve ne : " z =
: on ot ee " " fe 7 fa os
t wG "ft oe = * Zz 3
: : = ees
ms 2 . ;
& - ped = - :
b a os a "5 ne
2 3 . Spee
. ag oS 5
o bees
= ne Z
Ob = :
wor, ;
: x
+
te
£4
gen Sah
pew ae
wee. we"
aren,
"ned?
%
tary
ayy
Nk
HL
Ss
PO
p
one we fe
we dna ee
as ~,
aye lat
ad
feos oy.
yen wn
fe
a
ae
oo
t
&
oy
ee
>
if
te.
PERE
aPhePo
eens
AL
'
me
GM PE
ery
Bi
oe
Se
pope
bik.
2
é
"4
ro ty
ty
Xe
Wirt
Ty owas
1
a
see wlyic
}
wane.
'a +
'A bd
mS
be LS
vd nh
pod soe
CREE
ie
Na,
re.
ge
art
°y
3
OG
Le
8
{
IQ.
Me
y
y
>
5
aE
nal
rt
iG
cha
&
tah
x
Ag
=
« o rae Sud ye reo ee .
3 4 3LS fepeae GENT :
tale UG 2 proses EE yeety a 88 33 ARE sy ota.
VR Rie "OS eq) b y 2 Ae Ye ¢ z The e a a i aay ¥ am ¥;
Af hit } R VAS * th the accu ny x Wi Sri Ram Yad %.
Fal prosecu ¢ x ?
Be fee ya en on us word ones, "ee OTE = Sn 2 oa z Sad "3 ns i oe . bas y Sad very wy La a a lon al o, ; < wt ot wT i, net e ae toh 4 tees wer oy pon. oom ene ae oe uf ge fee Ne a we aah foe, un me ne. weet patel rang Seed eee wg a sree "a aes ny on Le ve cee al -_ oo ¢ aed tak ; A ken a oo wee oe 44 QS oe aeons, - weer? ton oot ay mn wed "es oon m"
ee sod wort st poked, dae go hee eens ' on * "4 wn ten Seal ao ww . a8 ye pee fi ~ 03 TS ve aan on 22 oe we Fo oe om aw, 29 rope os ore Z TH ot oa te "
she one 3 * of ? 2 on ft . oh my Ve ae wt xD . ad 43 oo , pe an ehh i, eos reece . pine oe Sohd ea a $2 B&O ae 4 ens Ime pares pee a fad ae we Son oS wes wa io ae ae
5. yer wee vepes = on rte aes oon ne ne ne Newt Ms an Sony Seat penne, wn neers ae ~~ ; * os ; ~, ne poe "a oh 3 peed. sad qos wowed, an ae . aed pt a oS , vy. L on i ae og ped "0 + Lo on a or oo oon o so me xy oF = 4 xn ny 2 Nn oe Ww pen. we ~ ae Ly rs mo m% "es Lee v 4 a rt z a - & By 2S Bb» o 2 2 2 2 # oot "gt aoe. eons : sete wf oo = ~, es eS peed Pee, ' oe whee sat int "0, o ¢ rd " me 5 "4 ws rm gene , Lepee ee o "mee beni wat - sae we os ons ~, EOF : ~ oom TR £2 - 8 < pened, 03 a oe } . a ~ wpbee! a 03 ; .
"ny, ie, "geet on nA 4 ~ ~ 7 ron Aho a pee : "y : 4 . ( om x mo Se mm " re : ne cee WA tenet es who : ~ tg , ty oe me we ed nh, Na fy dl oy fer eee we aed wor AG ad pe We coher 23 son! speed yon , ae "at fom yew . ny pew paren, ny bat 'on, veews " = $8 x tt fen ° ' x - Fea oo tee oa x on : Da on ve of st: peed oo. " = roan 4 sf tas on : " " ef: Z 3 fede : ae oo 5 Oo fe "" oS ¢ . if" we wae , aa nee wenn, eee fen, we we anne bee ane 4 ee _ a £5 * Oe soe, oe xe ¢. oo ~, a nat oy Pe Pee Se edo oon ae gon = S "4 oe ae ns xf = me oe we Me "a feted, . aft ~ wee nee My a wn m= ss or) or oe. aes " ast <n -- ae we" v7 het ton na " on > F% . eens poy : phere ee mee oa y ay : seen . ne eS oe : a mene ipiee : eo 3 x oye wee % ben on, 'bee we oc er Sons - ~~ 20 ne oe oo ww waeeg at oo a3 2 pene feos oe fon os a . ot oes 4 Soon "s . =o amas <= sy poe 4 wm 43 * epee "ae eden "nest a3 ei ot: ayes cetene Lf Lg fat OD on cane aaeee nebo ot oat 44 eA . wees a "aa 'ected, gree o pons we "4 oe, * ~ we mp we, a om toe oe ee paced ~ o, Serve a wie wtned 'aot oe oA fen oa, reba an nd a a yee odo A wt xs oo vo mE o ny ON oe Ce we ro ed mets pees a he E = om, So ow ta a A mens ee ea whan om ne 7 "oy . Cm wee Loo mm ~ : no wd LG Nad ", ip we spe peer im poe' a as - a4 x nal 6 we nae " os, mo innsew, epee 3 tee aD on ty deve 'ah ay beet me sw nee, oS ' pat 3 Lee . on n % oy ee "? od pen noe a Caine nt ey "id we * CS AL ret eee we oon ~ Ei en x, we o a oe oa ne . Ef ay ey veped ED om " * o a oeal mw Sent owe on wy vapel mm a xo j r on oa py x, nb My a to vere a ~ fener 3 Ce Sen. Lo ry ad so Y ith soho "et r . eaped pee vs ws wo nee. oe aS mp cm ee "han! t CK Cy ae mt py a a snes ge " owe 'y ws a beet paveh, vet ra at SS = woh Has ~~ yeas ae eae, deere wy we o x , . : rt . 7 * pans oe Y ae mm yee 'ne "2% moors a a . oo, "S to : Niet ~. ts a ny sae : ms ne Rt nn ree of , a3 oe . f ay x x we oe Na ~ heb me ones, ae os af yen yet Z "a se oY nee Ah, a f ean a ~ alt veeet ' of, . nw "nt aes pee Tae " : ee Sete nbone Ceeees ooo a 43 xt GF ae A; gees oe neon Ww SE at we , es 7 : . " ore ; 4 £, Y é ", wees Lt poem oS nee:
Go ms gs ie ek oe 42 > wees . ows oe "Lb we ez por soe os rn eet ee oe a we hot os Ea reget: ~ Sow ot en on sete + ee oe soe ben ron x, my, #3 i fon , ie ~ ~ 6 won , wt s vot fan ot 4G toed re en fe ester, > pew tut ms KL, a mm. on ~ baad, wet ¢ we! we ne red on oo what 7. ose ret ' as fy 'ne Le Saw DP By oe veoee a veges wo og anne, oven a Nped, attr, oy 4 "3 whe ~, nod % t oe " tay, 4 : . vee 4 ney om 2 sot, ed : os "4 3 cy a an ee oe ay "s te OE ta SY Cy va 7 nh wt Fo unk as nin ae 3 pane mers ae See ey a "2 wed g eure ad ae 2 nee = os sen, ; A 'ne rete x TA bene ws wee! ~~ rs 44 £3 poe, ae re ' sana See! oes aon, rd Fy ee "3 > , : % ' es : ms ory "ad at L " whew Sl a yon . BOS *, S40 om eed wh a3 ~ or os ' ar woe we oe ning ry se ' Lf oS ot hee wy So on Noes Le Coe ne ree a fy "a . we we deed do on L. ye : waned, ww ee vaned 43 ¢ xe oye wee fen "A send aa < nee o ow wee ~~ - cad f Seah 3 eae, 23 oF of eh setene ' aes a feos oa a z m te y " OG oon "
Ch Fs: hs fm had SS am ~ ao om , oe it po ey a4 we ae tend? Hy oe a ha et vaen San f Coe 7 Seed ot . ~ By a " ha wp poon gen taal ras Seeder ew wy, pone a ae om Saat reek en we os rey, oh cower fan ae a wa Dewees ww we, id B 8 m= FO PB ee ; OA nA , nee .
has alse denied that a live cartridge. mobile phone with SIM card and Here ¢ Honda matoreyele registered in the name of Ani police, PW has flatly cefused in the Court that he saw REPRE ro WSS Made my his presence. The Manage Henda Showroom at Pakur was examined as PW? He was also declared hostile but ni the cross-examination by prosecution he has admitted that the an motorcycle shawn to him by the Passwort.
3 zy. yep RINT EEN i. . eexsiehogyerne tron efeapese ay BUR? ss Li, in our opunan, the evidences fendered by PW fo PW in the examination-in-chief can be used by thi 2 . . 6 that m the evening of 10.06.2012 firing took slace and the accused deaving motorcycle an the road « away amd were uitercep and one af from a country-made pistol duc ta which he sHied semare of LAWA robe phone and a Hive D4o noke is that PWHE BW?
admitted their signatures over selaure-meme and mere deniz MG SOLsure was made in their PYSsence iS riot enough Pre "s prosecubhan evidences, Even though eed Ie otateamente prey iS slateanents made > before these witnesses in the cross-examination by prosecution together with Be "& Ma OK Re om, Encl noe ™ "nee! ann ae on ene Ogt vat x Or ag od ?
fi Be of ee a rer a z
-
oes oe mi nn, Crore.
cd red eae.
g re ey oe, oe 29 RAe f . 2 ie. Mr A. KK. Ka shyap, the learned Senior counsel that And} Paswan was a stranger i ian witnesses who identified Mimon the dock bul befare that he was produced in the Court on severa! ocrasioms without any er' funie in the Court was Phe fearned Nemior counsel would further contend that the circianstances that a motoreyele without a number it i plate purchased in the name of Anil Paswan was scived on occurrence and that SIM card nes.
a, "Y nag Seog gf RE ETM aye * Mare OF Ad # amd Naat SEA.
i, Mrs. Alpana ¥ mia, the fearned Amicus has cormtended that na af occurrence and the bullet was recovered from the frst place in the crime was not produced in the Cayut and while sa the prosecution ablish that Raju Choudhary fired at Sri 'read Armicus further subimitted that Prakash Jreanrarnt. Phe les the prosecution that two unknown persons visited Sr 10.06.2012 was substuntailiy changed and the wit Court about three persons coming ip Yaday and such immroavements by the witnesses render ey z 3 3 Byes fo rigarignys Pass vyggad oo bycan Phe fearraxd cause Aas mide significant umprovements in. the referred io the judgrment in "Aaya ys, identification of Ky identity of Raju festimony af the a deseripiion of fuir-camplexioned challenged by hin < would refer 1G he wend mot fs that an tnlured witness provik Hnplicate an inmascent person to shiokd
16. A& Tesi identtication F gation in which PW1O0 and PWS sere asked to identity the accused, INVES! b 2LAR "PR eg don es Phe proceeding datec SORPARLLTA ES roy f oo i SESDS } K :
' % POLISE aus, tt MIS Fonsg the QUT HE e < "a a, ee oY naa we % tor MHL > Farid he .
x yds eet sennes weno?
eyele Obes mn 1a i t bles ore :3 3 7
PS borrowed sare ae Ok ' ?
;
e No, 169 ef 24 a Re police Tih tot bow ve Lo par "uae ay a: noe S aod ay ng 'od ae Sane Li Poa Bey ade AQOT weg ks ROD RAG has . aye o a toe 2k "es ot ne oe ee on " ww ster. we eee wee nan vee we yo oe eines on us wee eeeee re a q ae , oon oe = ee a "
ee = & oe 2 % cee wet te PY cae sae! pone mS eevee. 2 " as aa Ls rh oat wy an Ted OG a tee i on ad meh wee $ Sh teen ra at 4 we wee os poe vs sone on pen ae f iw pee , >= ane we Set . "3 new, oe pee we Ye aa pe coer . 60% oy . xr _ oh 44 ged. 'eet ey a yee ano, we ei oe Le vat aa ~ re > ny eon peas BD Sen iy Sd 'paws we Se oe Cre gee a free ee . eas oe, ane whe, spool a " aad oped Me an ee ' , ee on beee a tan . me : a -. See ad 3 . te x oh irk wn oor ; oe " Gedoe ve yen vee oe Lh + pan Lh 5 Re! é a 4 :
oe ss 7 "eotee TS a ws wal oe ot a nap % oe (woee vo we a 2 ug depos wed, we, ropee, wert tn tap anand 32 nee ar" bee. he oy, ners ae "anne M's . . ¢ ay va! 3 aan . ea ps o ~, é e uw Wee a rr. oe ot a sal ; a re ot ne oe rn wee + Sar Ce ¢ : oo on wooed wd a 'need ~ waeee ee toad op . ow seed , ner . on , a "A ee os + "3 - SS oo tx ny aan ys nodes ~ oy: eed, a alow wen y Ae a Ma nt im Po ~ anes ee" wee beet aoe venere " sect thi = " ond s ne to ws Sane wy x we wa on wee. See Hoe rn ~ ee me a " . wo f ~ 06) C : wy . g a ef wee ae S ay vt on ~~ ILS te ~~. wee o 4 one s te ? woneny > pont a ; 2 open a geo re ay on. be. A "alt 7 spent : OS hows "D paved tae vee en, : we ' en aebeet con ~ an Saeed ~ 2 paw a so we : ms vee Gt oe pont ony "2 < ee lew Le fot ann i Fe *3 wn aon LO f ~. oe 7 soe a A , 43 at we, sawet et td ood 2 nal Ze doate, ped heat vs to x 2 "3 cane aad oy "C5 "a ; "eet oon ms fy ~~ " an. ole 3 jon: "nai! . on os, peek ne ton a 43 x " gine. " 4 mt m > pe ae : m™ 'ad ' ta Lab G rh : . e wa , "swine penne, g vaeen, 4% on wt nee vee rf ee oe ny ae "a, oy, now, saaas et a he A ~ poten $ seeees ae ord 25 ne reo 'va oo hes + wad, inne ¢ ~ on ne > ny ee seb bows t wk ~~ one : td Cas : x vee ~ * ~ wei wen : pen 'na , rr "" pase a3 4 o vee we ~ . Date bea oon "a : Cn 3 ; ¢ te ot : 4 > Ms rn pont op A ~ ~ weed oe * +e ood yy aw a> kane " Se "i oa tt on Ay on ny Se pate ">. con ee few, a3 nt ry o con 43 dy oy aa " fone eS od pan "LS 44 coe o> "Anan, Lp A int ee CA aaned, in oa fede an . hi Sot or re po tat esd a os "nb 3 ge ee we so OS to Saad "ant "43 sees wa wthees sant = Wi aA "ry x popes oer "ty sheer oat eM io et o~ oe: seeel " m, ; 04 's ee 2 : ™. - 4 waen be wee EE Senne as ~ wey OS rail * Sd ft "ee irene ng mp ad eal pe. ' ~ eben Fs fon te eeped. het ne ~, ethy eal Fone a, ny ee. ppee ~~ mw ms ved wy on Fy nt o ad 'al wesed . gra re, We Sat ree, : , ¢ "Neat ae) Mh pees ak ow %, ree fom See on "cag on ceed at peed nt rae oe ne ty o, fae. ne . 4 " pee gee veyed, waren rye fs . ee wena! 6 3 wt ¥ peut aned SS " oy pteed Sat nad 0 We on ee aA 63 ay oe se ot . ne ww ont po . fos pwr ni , cage tea yee woot a cal ~ By ages saver "3 ood ny id wee nee, a3 / tS on a tA ae Z 7 s ae ve wae we ¥ wn tA te os ~~, aad owen s ed ook gen cane we wo "steed, Ay +? foe wre doe oo penne " wid oS 43 Le at we coy eeewt, wo ' Cos oo, 'at . " 25 ae ee at ree nat tof et a pads epet a yee at we on nto ot os eer 'ped tp eewe "ane! ns see my o yer ws anne ie ov? eo KS "A we oN $5 saeok m3 ~ aes a3 Vane os ". ~ vee " ms wen atone te oh nen, ee we Sow 34 Ag eae op " os woe! 5 0 'ad Sn vores oF x wren, ; te 6% a owe x whew ~ ox 5 at oe ener, vat mt ~ wit "et fe anes ws 2 : mn Ay we tae an, re . Aw vt > on a : fans * ve. wenn, ns as CS yee ° ye, Z mf 4, a i" set . "A ' in. ware, ma coor xg we os Cx a aes "5 a oh. re oy Sect r "sane mm wt not , ane Loe oe en ye 1 woe a . att a " tom iw steet ° 7 " ashes fee o, fs *, ovee - nf wee "3 Ln, on -- sel we "4 Ld te wn 4 rede Lent Lf dawn vere as wh Le coer ~ te Seded, Cae Sade shpat ae 'ead aM Lo een ww rated, oe bee fa td fp pe eee ae oe oe 'ae he bee. o rapes a eevee o~ a nee, / iene Tyee wee q Cnet "
Km .
a3 ,, eo oo ween eit ee pew ?
2 we tere seed Panne aes sf a, "
a tee a. oa * , eee, ra, ae om vee, aed on oe om Led L ye wee! " ap ni c, os pin ead wenens lf, deme rad oe ont th pea ie %, *;
rot ny ge eg as set vee, Pee teed oo Che eee se pe apt Sl a as ae gee rem Ee me "ee Me . we , a a ae ta , seed pee eR tm nt ae ; bed see pat es tone faee tet wo sents ; aa a ro Not L4 tne stares of cach case fe od who : on ' feet ote we, 'eet wee we .
3 ~~ i, aA woe paar, x sehen , oe ms poe x a a wt am Lt we nt ; co "~~ LA ay hneene oe nee ' oon ref £3 ao a5 te wares ww oh tL ge : re x ny Meine ' . ops oA an wa it en at van a a oe Ln pa * . ms x v4 vee 43 oS go rt pon va we oes fenen 'nae "3 wees ant ped, anor ~ seen a; eran int , : ae "iy oy taped Lae ane - a ay! 2. po , wleee Od o o "ves on oy rs "S poker fetes ae ¥ Mohs opt poe need. . td ar den? Oe as re 7:
3 ~ saat one sana ad x ms ? aa oon 5 Sean' coe ¢ ieee 2 rr, roe! Suk oa wn ews wn oon 43 > "s ie nf fa ss "
we ot " 83 m5 me Ay a "3 Che ts ta kon 43 5 ; rered, pee x ca ewe, a, eed ' ~*~, reds g r ws ad whee ant Sects = jrewed ay wee ees a pees 4 ea f y te oe ae a a fet . ae on x ty ed lal wey oS x vane shad x nt aS ay re wee 'nate wey 7 as aoe os ae ws " inecnd, a7 4 peey bao caa9 on Mp nen LD on , wa ot rs oo . i . oe " f My "
"3 wt ne pee ee pow a ag ad ~* LS serene 4 "vw "deat, wen 2 wrens, wee nae 4g et et o LE ei re ' a5 nw om ¢ Pay eden of 5 por S ~ tad bed pam & we 4 ws on, a ay oo rae ~ ~ ay mn ene oon ae fen bee Peet Se . 'nd ;
oy " é Le sa A SB ed Op ace Le o Sant nae . foe wares wate, Ce we Nee % on 13 LO ne Lo ned ek we opal Foadl A pe
- a bowed, fotos ww on Os vane we teed Sanne ri xy wey mm ct Le cw oo a we yi Paced pu ., cay tee Z. on, popes x voeee weed cate Sat a ne woe
4 meee mp ope = a xy "wd . a woe Cod .
tot 4 weed and Go me te ' Same "wet on yee pe yoo on YG 2 tet we, pon wee on St Poy oo ae om Fs og 'nent! Jeeee. wae fer. Cait ae 43 fo. o a me yon x Gace . Sa me "eee bene ny -- ~ oon Si ~. Mae wres wa as oS oe we 4 in A vee ee ° 4 wee we OL oS Se, a veal + ores rt. ot o hee a ad oni 4 we WV me ~~ -s oom et wae , pee x Le we » CA gene wG t2 ws x nw Le od peed wo ny " 23 oo oe bed :
ra hoor as en ta fen spar gr hee ae fe we eeeee. ane le one ed wa cp,
- v:
pet oo ny 53 4 vert a A poe eet a wine we we capes ~ Aa weed "a oo wie woe "~~ a owe ' at got on aot enn pee Se ad oe a as rns ye Seat ve 4 oo "ye "2 & 1 5 ce Sot ad ae 4 ae "3 ioe WZ wane, tae we oh : n'y oe ~ wn oe a £0 al ped pores tae uh ae fe 7 fet fre. "ey nl De foot 7 we. on, "eat Pe, heed wt a al ; me wee p om) : = a ws ee pom a sae LPS oe ot so ae OG £7, aaa o, xf ay oo m0 eh x ween Fa wa oo a fe GE. ED my, be ween 'at Ce ™ B Z s ened eee, per ne Lo Aeneas ye : whee a oy, a ; hove Ay ta oo "one bobs oo eR we a aft m eb on pom nal we fs 4g ns Lo oy, wedeat vet yw atten it oe er, vod Daa ioe ae fet SS Mad Cad oe eee fioad eee wet ee bot ty on wk ope A, A See " n3 weeny we , ne _ * oot Oy Fina ae) "ne wr ty ae TN a 0ed vane 'ees, oa a ' ny wor mh tue ve spnet ww ; Sp Cs A "S x Oe See cores a a 28 ; wee, Sie oe wee woe. 3 ae tose nt 03 'sof oe. mm : Ee ye ta wee us To :
5 "3 Z es no, . eotens we an oe ee 3 ve az wih " 4 on weet on ny aA me 5 = » ot Ga -- , soo im ti Gu C4 = i ws woe 4 eee ° eee af, wet teen . oa hen s 2 x 4 ty eed rad oo fee "EO we 03 en Pd oo x :
ty ae noon, od < mod weg yo vee ome "ee 4 ™, Ny z oe wo tt , vans woe cone] os we ot ay Capene f Ly IP we "edew 4 Chae aan te aed "3 hat! be we at we om Lt deed vee pened EN . GF Cows wn whee ' * oo 7 , me me e wa fo 25 te Le oe = ey : , 4 te y yet a ne Ad _ s Ww ~ > my hy oad oan z pois, ae wml ay e yee, ee ~ . aes mS ie a wren ow owe * Kt Ped na oe ee Ze ww, "mat, 4, wae *, oe ws woot A ¥ s L OM er 0295 oe wo Saeed he re. £3 2 pete 3 pees wns ns ~. ne wy we rong nnn, a wet oo TS ened re a! een, LD Cae ot he vowed, pwd one Sones, wey 'a fee aon ws we we anew Faacl Py ee Se, OL ? eve pe oe A% " ge ~ ned we sehen 7 . Me Oe ~ a pe OR nee ' "wet Seat yeyer tank re, ' ee ag a aed aed nat £3 Toad, fe f rowed, 'ep erent, 4 . wea tb on : on an rf pee og) Ss foe or uA wr St w~ ' . oe bo yond en J Fe pee son + een whos ~ OSs rn a d hy "Ld Lb a z we = oe eee "te oo ue ¢ peri Ca , a anor a : Sewn pent om, J om % ad ane aer7 fone + sen te a £3 y nas G ax a . ne "anne! oon bee ad £ CA ee : my $ acon : owe, rm " a = % ay £3 vs fen 2 ne, ower oe > ry ~ 'nat ran : a Qs a ' 4 ewe? s " tee: t : wed 2 4 fs ee re "_s nd 'naan a 7 Se, yt sat es few xy a oe ee heed , tees ae apes, oer a Cael ~<-- ae Mw sheet oo ~, vee soot y is yew we ; rad mA pe on, anes, = eo ove + a ee "~ mand, 23 welone ee fon, oe, Y Spee font + pee mm : oad ot baat Ay SS v4 ws ae °°. aan eo set cree ae nee can td xs ' oy ed, ts we 4 yer) rks ee, nw "a oS a3 haw Ay La ~ 7s . ot of: 'th ae "nat od 2oE3 A a3 ead oon os "It wt wt sf? aft 3 see wy wee on . ; wt 4 a ao bed Soa pes oon) ~ 5 3 red aS ¥ baw £ ee, on ae " ¢ ms Renn et ae7 ss we Noe ae on . ce Snot ne As 4 Capes sma ro z tom x. re, eae om a map) Yn * é : 4 ye Senna Z teat ' ae mo Gp ees bea OE we ll BR wh of, ot = ££ & # te dct BD wd ;
free Fi oS Pod ane ad 'ae! wer. op oon re 2, tees wa "anf or rt 'ead oe me a te a teee ww ms ove ne ores ot vem, pee 2 a "ae 23 poet oS Be LA ase tt ' Ww fees, bem ropes, son ne foe ~~ al tad Se ved sree ne oe ca we toe wt cs, aa a a te ae a3 capes, ert uo et "aed "a Rn Lo or mp on. ro hove A, ". a wee 'oe, ids eens been ae x woe ~ j ~ ot ae wee ', tant Gon Q "
Le x nen ee Seat LA ag on pan ne re On ohne. orn a. ht were awe? fe Lh eee a nen wn bod te oct ee Bon m a wet os a 7 few swe me ye Geto '. ny a ya x vers s. fy . we sen? Lae "ee ne a, . oS < owed, wee Soak "pee =e 2 a woeoe < we "eo oS aed 2 weees pane ca tp "eee? a Ly geee .. ont pon age be veree ae Bs Revie 23 beer tat <2 ~ roe 24 cs Ped ' woe oa . a Wi pe ~ te Fars fet alee re when 4, if toe sae ~~ . ive. dee "ag pect " xy gee ft "9 L: ae ma i "3 x we oe via pose " an ee oS s fy a vee ae " tee ye wer ' ape et ods : ny " wi ww Cd ne, on i" oy "at a, San s _ wetes eg oot , ou . Won :
& oD fg 3 as ty ms «nce vee a - " 4b av 5 oe a ay nanny oe to teens wpe! ee 23 oe ab , 'sae rd Ft ban ; as an ~ enw C3 o oo we ie iene wt, on oo yee ot, na me fad an -
anes oe aa z ane cae eves eoeee, : pe HE "a es of we , : a or L ns "Lz So yee oy : oe, mee ip nn oo Nat wy ae Lh n, ra we ne d if 2 we? Snel Ys mx os My ww wnt Bia "ae ven x "4 mm eee oe ao mn e fee : = - ro x ioe a ' on a ~~ 4 re a nS Ce wad - eee weerd, Saas tet Ay ' ay oo. al Nad wet peer hewee, wee pon ns we +s ae wt om wee on #3 om sot aod we ot, hs J oA ~ et a ae we ae ; uf es Oo wet me Z i ve Swe ' popes ou tent ae x nee x meet ~ ~ ' y den? 5, a re v0 ~ bee. ed Py : Ke ene a wn ew ned when See va oe aoe * fod : % oe 5 i road 'ee Me Ped fe Bo» BB eo Bo" ns ee , D q ns "ant ale rh fas % AY x o, f new, me on ad wy ee soon Pia wn ny po ne me , q oY vat arenes a3 posi fees Sesaat sons 2m ae we a ore wee aa oa 'weer Dav) AY ~ "5 soe one o, yews ren ave xo to how ~~ peal ; a aad oe 'at ones, Seer we x vod mt fe ES x os a3 oe i ' eos aA bet = . SS ~ I a) on red gs th, ed we %: fo nw tee? : am? ' * fen "e Bs Sey a, fadt m Sand tow, a te eet wae road %, <7 . L Geded, onped, on. 'eed & ' is *, sy yy £3 = Te, oi Z 43 a MS ~~ rt mm ee vee tee te ee oe so LE nape nn ca Ct on "ene? oS pt 'comes ow a gore read lt gen rs see " oe ene"
He , poeed, om ~ a sore te ee ae one we "wt + wnt toy nh ; "saa ns cert A Sees am we My "> ty wy om ey Dan ae ~~ ~ me aye ~ as a3 be vw a Fe sed " per wc ~ M2 we " tea inet oe ao * ¢ ny ~ as a Qn a7 ve ", te pont weed x . bok vdent os ae a4 tae " vane ; Thawed meee 3 5 mpee As ~ tt oe " pe f os ~ = a ae cecags' ned wd ee and in, oo wees a ° 'eet TP wood v? wee oe ; wy ft he on Senta: ~~ mh now, o a ~ --s os neo > 4 i : feos ve ' pee we sel oP s pee ~ A new, tt . es Y id ~ . wt ab " ' 4 | Ps ene ' og '. os ~~ ft we ew pw, > oe ? ion a, aie XS qeeooe ~~ « mp ro 2 bent aoe Yo oS ef 4 * 5 gun es ee "re ey se we S , x ot A we or] 'eat 'af LA ; at pe se fen, few, phone papi, id as ro ~ end ny ox woe vee yee Co on sg a4 a pee om rn weet wee wf ny oe o 4 &. 4 eee aa Ca we & a B ~ &» 2 & ong n Sy ES a * ad whee Saat beac fs aalen ot 3 D iene Grin tect had oad pans ot "3 m= Sea Suces eet t %3 on me rs aes w pets oa mn Yew o~ a aot oon an mn 9 nt ae we oe an ont 'red, pa ms oS wwe, sone nee / ae ori > woe ; = , er ~ ntod ho oe el er, Wade seed ad wae n re. ead a " ar) - ¥ aoe waged, tad a3 tad "ey wnene 'at "nak <a GF on rey x hw oa m wn wee open, :
7 ot rt mo wo we a when. «me aoe "net doe "Sy on pe Son, a4 oe Lok how Ly a .
tee a : eee 'meee, nee rn See tod gina yee sees caret oy, oe mee ~ om * oY a fe 3 Io3 re < "nen! vo im Jet + me Ld a : igs pe ae A, wwek wey nn w sa oo "
a A Ws se , pon na Z fore vee * ven park on nee ne ed wns oon So i pewed of fs a a3 we " % te popes id, ms por me aed re stone a ~~ vem sane! ' yon mS oe nope, faa spores "nat eet tna Ys oe "st Ds Os ms weet piece weboe wn wpe lees "poo! nano ap wee on wwe, oe ue a mm oot wet oy = "a 3 ved ws mt oF x ae vos "com Pel, wget oe oe0 eden 4% noe *: , pleat, ae ne z ° . . poe 'A " ons rr m fee, one, Saad x om Nereee ore rene Not . " ~ et oe Dohe Saat Ce wh gun Kg oy aed Li e ;
x Sports Of "ee 3 x ta Bh x record Forge ra PHOT repos, 'se "4 LA wee wends > OOD RSSHIS TO See a & Su who hed seen } af persons y y x < FyQy of ws gf Lalibela bein st ROLLE Ra Ra Vs se boety pure orth' my A ROHS GHG ¥ G fH by used t & * Pyayy we ae Bye Tee We ped say oh io OPEstant Uo eyide > x ww i e the COR's eae prasecu st VOC ave also pro inetd Toy PA th ne forming Ye 4 ' £ YY cam lng murd eg vores ee iat tA aoe oon not fom wy a.
ee on "Se ID eee x soe ee a" oa = S od tan neers ty on ot oe ~ SF: hy x, fon ve nen vi ~ ke "ae ene ret ; ad ooh nae gen, o ~ nea, Son 3 cS on :
be 2 " reves & = 2g Co a aie ee . 5 z * . ' ° 2 we on . ' ay ree :
ae $ : reoae s :
q Saewe. fer ort ; f ; ; = : o " Sat 7 * fn; .. ae ; 3 "A "C3 yoy, weeed 3 my os ne 6 mee % ve " me o ower oe vad a eee ; ps a "a a ? g oe nen oad , ae ~ b ie coon id * Paaaaen ow ny Z3 ee nines wen : : i" = ft "3 4 we. of: neon "ews . fy mm a 5 a oe. se a ot ros, a " i tes xt an aa om i" oe nm Niet m3 ' S é med 'ote . 7 " a3 md geo 3 re,
-, ' {po 8 i NS a ers nore ree 2 aan tone om a4 ae we os : 4 uw am oS ne 1 nee onge Boni pes coed . 4 mm yore we ao oo "~ E 3 4 Om a a we wt . mm ie om ooo ms 2 a? vd 3 bu rea "2 on poe.
'OR oF oe es oe itt os hed te ee te ny foe, my es me weve pies . o yn nat penne owes 4, Ce Lo oe vee a go ~~ te a Lt : cx ns or vite ow, eee mn oon, Fi 7" a pe, ve a pees oy a pee, tp tee me pene es bee a4 wth oo arn es oe Ms aed vob LE o ae ace 0 ae ot 4 fe oe net we, 5 "et fea fen eecer few we rere 23 ms a rye we " we we nett wee «os " a ~~ oe 44 ms , = Ay Cee 'set ", a rot te uy of a anneal soe 2 oe ome ae at ca i --
x "ye we v7 oa ws ~ acon fon ie . SS St & o eos mason ' noe ws 4% aN) Me ' oe ~. .
ome bod = oh ce ~ ae) ~~ o pee v: & oo oe < ; bear = oe, owt 4 ¢ "
ms ms oe - et ood, Ry ; vee a et mS ~ ane . ny ' . = wee, paee ry wm G t "
yee, LA ve fs one at m im ., Cat of x oon ped a 4 oc a Foot ei peont SLA wae, fe ao , Fan one ~ Gs 7 ws OG sone, ree oo. "e nents teed re, ete, Fae Lat x om, poe we et "ot oo we * get oy ae" , oo ina mo Ae oe, cath . reve, few a uf ? oS rae;
. mel or, rt tna foot we w 4 a seed me om yen Lae a pono foe 25 os Wes ay BE t i LES seh or CASTE peaeg art AGAR say tpt TALE O PPOVE GY:
OS ue © SASwWer Is FOL PE + rider Pye + + AA Sculan.
is 3 TS x s $ ws Q .
aS tH mot nemessa PO yey REX soy 0 x & yi h o ON GP GIVE i o 3 3 HPO Quest Peeeee robe d akan nnd tibdeadddetidde sisters:
oy Fons dAL <t ;
L nder sec oft fy
- eves meen oft ts, 2 ow oe on . we oe 2 z oe an : eee aL : ay oe ae ye m we wow rae a wy ue Leb we Ly ny as on nt io ve fee, spe, nee Ww eh p 2 ~ an at we seat peoee a nec 4, "on e Le caped ot LQ r need, wed cs oo mS a pa Lee , See oot x * anes, ee, a ms, fan ord ' ee ae fs poe bee. a ~ ne % £ ot: i ry Oa coven ord Le "
Ment pen " eee ot Sat nook tes coed £4 yawn, "aa anne, + toed fy 'mene : tot Cd saewe few Lo r on, oa ms, fee tea? ta feel re, . toa fon Q yor"
ee tS iy a % oe hewle, wee, 43 ye os hawt enree ae, As 5 pas . "eden, ae ne ee teee nn, yet mt = roan | = th. et . Pine " yet "ee, itt eens, roe ver wet eee, S set an Kee seen foe wry ate, ay et eg a aoe vat pe cee 2: yo! ee ay wie -
oe Ps! LG a ne 0 we wae pee 2 wwe : bee, nt iad . red mo onan iy "4 an ad peed Fal pe we tA ~ go! ~ hove oe foe oan | as ines ve! : ae . ween oe eo js Oe S a " profi rae * eye Ay tod foot} <f fe OFS , 43 oe ee .
oe eet on
-- vee! on : 2 iw . saeee eee a awed, aed ween Ieee Fal res 'eons the ~ wee See a4 eed ¢ ane an ve od we st teed :
ae won .
pa ae :
ann, fn "
peel "nat ' m4 oes "
"A ra on y pteed on, rooe oe oe wm Se od net sw Bren o* wien ot on fea! aened, oe Ay po we ~~ 7 Gee rd we wee Ne weet ia wee, 7 ee ww eee bs ae Br : jaw enn wired, i, r. ee" tod mn wae! eet af oat pert Ken, anat . oe me v0 He, one aw senor: re z vy ce: 3 Ly neh "a wi Sone on wa 7 "~ Sp ie ae 3 ms we us ene re ay wevee, r ow we 1d 'pene Sent we wee me, Yo Lo in ne > os yw oe pedioe "net Jews, A a , Lape on sae Lo a? sped. 3 on S A ee oS os = ep spe wet FS "aa! o5 ban :
~_ a fas a * aK aS on Ay capt ven weet wets tae veer eh Z seed fehl toe ed wre we, " ES tend toe, oe 'ed VY om mG oe me eooee, ve pas at net bes a aeeed, yee 4% 'a es .
we ade per whe a ox weed oie. weer me os or, ae 'cet, anew ms ae "ee wWeeetiderenpocnecadedededtdddtddbideie ree Bat Lovet oe a oO 6 oY wn ny srrent oe peers ma eee "
F:
how, ny on tan S peed ¥ * A 42 Or 2 vt Z % %. i he FAT BS y iA pe a x c ada), Sava ee ahi aS .
8h} # fand i 3 ef ay ¢ M aly 3 s sed 2 AY Aa een od "
OES Boe ¢.
¢ e nd a z Mackay ¢ ada \ am ¥ e TYwakar Kaman Vivekanand M fy FRQCOPa.
XN 4 & ' y 3 and f x kan + gh waters % Ve wi V the ¢ rid ap ar at + + x hor a a = ' i : a a See eg POT CHL YOO ee ob sie used whict ~ Ie ACL yn, pore, A; pe ae ne OG es on oA * enene peowe nana vs orn Tad ne a poet 25 , on os , Lp me a ; oraet neo, agi aa whet me fee see see verte, roy Napeat Anon 3 'tap . fond vanes, "on CZ Se oS nf rete, om. No ae beer ne ar a ee. x ' oA creat oe ta "A i"
pee on So, oo we : fe. ine pee. ey wee tt mae ' ee ms ee! aed a, pees os x a + 'we ren aeeeee ee gx Apan sat "0 vane? weet 2 oe ie SS ee pee ere "s ye se Bd we an aoe wa wae : won = pon oe apa 2 ci tat go aren, pee, o ms oe yee, 4 see a, ey we wee , . et ' toes 3 : sot ~ oe ie aan es lowe nA wen wee ea a mh, oS Ld x 4 on rn , te .
BS te eter ge : Soe foo .. io go on ene r on sepa , as Sent Tee beat o few . vee we wen pen fae oe " "anoe & eee, a nese nr ~ 7 ot perod 4 ob . fi an :
" mm eee es ee ae ene Saree " oe > % ae! te , a ~ se as we % ors we 7 vo nr ne panes or vee ae % Lo wit we eee ay iti . ¢ pe on aeeee tee, er on fee. ie fen fom = tee oad nee: the ~ nae, ee, et Soot BBs os oo n3 wee pone. viene, or:
n ae yon 3 wed we ft ' fy sree . we .
. ; £3 a a L z: xy pa eS ~~? ar tere for nat : we YL poe ne ay weet pee nM 15m oe me "7 a oS 3 : : on, « ae oe we £3 fe ; we Saw oh ny x % vos a pos rong a2 yr Lee head ars vee. *s pope Ce ro? : rene tot y om, : 0 ood panes Oe 4 ee ~ me (tans . we iw: wena . ne . rey oS Was uy m= "SS rn wo = tae sat oe oS 'need? a cm 'seh ~ ae 'ni = ina om ~ ce oe Le3 wee wow ee Saeed oe aed aT ae a" ew re rane pee oot son od ya Seer"
sce noe a ~ how set tieet at fone 2 yee ot ine pin os : ~ ere rf a bees a ieee cpeows oon. ae ws on. Sieve none, wee tne, ' $ "ares we * a sere os ee nt a oon oe Ca coe nt "rene ' ' pee ox m wo nee 5, am ri pet yee Oo nn os. an po, sinne ~~ z Canes on "3 Shoe bees fa ot Joes pane won aA ore, nat = on. a3 ee noon oe Ao "Ch tA free oe oS fos oan os wt oy ~ -- revel pene be eee my tea ret aed ye ren we ees, . ee a mK, vines se? oes oe: ry a . tee 2 o ws pet Nowe, oe LN oe ~ f ', enon, < ' od Lf x an is ny ot, et see? x ae poke, re ae t; : ro a S wi tA an a3 Seae! a pene ny oe or ' me rrh few Ly ~ aint va ood 0 aaa ww ~~, wot =< orn a3 a va apt Cast 4a fae a nen G ' thos 2 on Na Sanat yet ¥ ao. oo x " ue ; shee " ed han pe on ee. wn wns we a ene we x "a a, few . a - ores det ¢ "
a serees ny beet eet re oN at pen. re vee x fea " pent * we a ' m a3 23 enon we ot - we" yy £3 wore oe a poe a Wt s povoel Pf we aA ws : ae ms fi Aad ood "> con) von ~ ween ap on weed es Me we, ca LS op feeeds gC Pil ~ an oe. 3 rs aon bw. ned a Si vet ow Not wee aS foe - now Sadee 4 cows es we con few ww ye fone ett my ws dow ae we "ee, bee «. > me , os oe ws pores fe ae 2! ane : oe on pans . om > ana Saaeew, poner ' Oe bor . ped, es Oe ~ ow, raat noeons eed ret os a fa C wm oo, ~~ ' ny ae xs fet ", mm "spew wade eon sor ne aA ' nal ae uA or; 83 na eft 3 wary ot pa waned, wn, we apes a ae nie oe wn ane at , ot a ve A tg i o4 s, con Nat ny oe Ke, edeed, nn Ye 'a ted 4b spot wee tT, pane £ wet - "me wee ee wes ad fined et rae Lae ye veers a won, mm we Son , os t "oe . ror rae A ee - wee 3 fee sy a yes o A ; "sgn tree a TALS wm oo ee 3 pypeg a ae poe ww ww ot fades t oo Fi wo on ae vowed, "3 a "at % peers mares oD tedeed wey aed a eee aad ve 'at ae we 05 "ee ~ eran: poy apooe ~~ we ~~ AG one ne es ne ~ swe mls Inala sens, ™ wyney "3 woos ad ~~ ve 'aw teed wae. ge ane ey rea a : 'no va at oft Lars ww Nat oo. a wenn f nae' on we . o wep f Pad al " CoS tee Fy oo ry = we howe ' ; £ nue aed A oot not ne Sit eLy rw toot : Saws 2 yew, ed oy ens ~ et Cog
--~ tbe wy Need yt a tees wee 4 yee, YS 2 WG > t oo Cond ~ Yt wt yeees) ra wa pon Og go ti or, an ¢ one. bee 4 Ay os re4 ao wn a wot th oon poe ae = ia ", at "eden + fen fo vee ce ce a nS weer onitey dene wh a pak as gene oS nape i me + per a! rn. nah 2 "4 x ' ae wei iin oa ~ og os rae ond fees cd L3 =x ' :
Se naa x on be. cae ws ond hams ~ toh S Pon ws, me Nat Le ee) > ~~ on % Wa ot 09063 'et Cy y, Nae ne fr. 'net & one tot : ot ne Jew iv "A . ae ", ~ a en ~~ sae! , op "3 * ee ow a ' 5 we "4 owe. ¢ q 5 oe, a we nn oe Le; eo ed whee J ot "3 "4 Fae we bros Foe when ne wy Ley LO oo oe SA - vee 'sd i ua ne in. " om fo a nee en a ee ff ¢ ' %. uf the ny, tat " oe wie Spee ween, hon wey C4 Qf b wee. we 2 ; 2 oe oy Po o y $ $ yest Ne RN NE © the se a a vet ay te wns ver we tA wn are.
CA as LA wot of we poet ne ih poten, twond pres, 3, " :
se feaay whe Re rape Net pee a8 en 2 pied, iShree C ado (Ratiaker Bhongr 3 wee, LONETS, » MEE, wef, aries, gor tebe nd e (hain ap,