Sri Devaraja vs State Of Karnataka on 29 May, 2012

[Cites 3, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Sri Devaraja vs State Of Karnataka on 29 May, 2012

Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar

ﬁnmml.

 

{N THE H§G%§ CQSR? 3?: §<!éRE\§,3\TA%<.:fl AT 8,éi'\§S%i_$R_E

m::"E§ THEE "WE 297%; am' 9%: my 2322 

SEFQRE

THE Hsrxyggg MR; jiL5E?£E'ECE M€.Z':HA€x§"§ﬁ;é3a§:f'T;%§\éAi§§§«¥.;V%j:R§§ 

WRET PE'§ZT£§!\§ NO,9S93, SF 2£%.G?._{L/¥K§j§:g *
gm?   " % % '  
WRIT PETETISN f\ECI,8?§9/28$? :'::1.;8j<;3 293? "19:3?§ 2&3?
14256 29% ?553 203? 955.9"V25:3.? ?5'§8,.é2G33
34C%5?i'2OG2, 38086 2G§;__€3 48e:V5%'%2Q§3%,% 3833'2G§8
34-488"2§iG 48$?-<2? 2'?€}3":'»?S»8;'E;f:?S':?.? and
BES57 2{;:,i%%.( L'A;-i{H''B~ :» 

IN wp.   

SETWEEN: %%%% H

3;; §evasaj§._ . . a    
SEQ Q3 "LaE~<:;?::"s":§%é5%_Lg;.§:>'a~~._ A"'»«. 
ﬁged a§@s.sé'5_:A :ge§r_S'  " 
R55 i\§{f2;2; Has§a.;:3§V§'g3a"i.a§£Ga:%

~ V.!5}:§EaEs»»s-%:s;r*;55':T';.%, §T%<%z'--E<.?i:s:~:?:

 §a:i;g'a%@:'é¥§76§§é_ 35:2;

:   W'/@AS';Ca %a§§_:::2§

Agéd bag': '33 ;:%:'§

 .T'_j~..«44_%1%.::';,12;, %;'E§?f"A'"§'i"§aEi': ﬁagd
 ':§*~é.a;i::;;L::1f':3§§a Layezgi"
 ;4:--%E_:5;§a_$4::::édrg:': éfiééége

-.A€;'§§<";%< °?G$i§, Veiahaaka Hgéié

  .;8j5_:§ga%5:*€£



'Mm

3.

{By Sri Deshraj 8: R Changaéamya    

Navasémha Murihy

SZQ Dsdda Gbaéaéah

gﬁgeé absué: S4 yearg

Rja §\Eo.162,/2; 3% Main

2" Cross, Maruthinagar

Yeiahanka, Sae':ga§Qre~64.  _

ANS :

L

State 915 Karnataka _

By E23 Secretary '  ;  V.
Hoasing 8: 'ajrban $e:;eEa§r:':_T;e?'§:tL-...1" 
Autherétyi Vii-<a3a S~3_<3udhaw '
Basﬁakereg v   . '

The CQmmis§§0n_sé'r_ "
Kamatai<a__%iEQi;:'~::§€ég«:.;$_Qa:iQ'
Cauvery ,i3hax?'aAnj7 _ 7';  
Baizgaéerag * ' 

S €523 f~'Ea;:agé%'=._  V

Karségia; 345: ﬁgugé-.r:Ag} 'géafé .

 " f?§Q3?e::": "f3§f§%.:e, a»'esa;: a.::_.i«:&

:"V.§Sa::*1g§VE:3r§' §X;'::_é*§:«§tf; '°§'a§i;i<¥

'§'%:"é:._§-§3_::€§'?§§"';;,;ag:%§vV;£3v::§:,§%$%%é8:§

' V'  Csffécasf,' %<a:§1§&;j5§¥:a Heugiag

£E>e§:'§,""{:a':zé;€iv;'"%; Shavaié

 *4.§fa.mga§G:?'$,_ 3

"-i:%i:y"§%%%u_;%'2%:%§a§ 5:@£,%§"%C§§
_ '~':*T'-%3§3¥j%a:":§<3, §§§§§§§Gi'§
T ':'%ig?%.§?;»g}-77%;'); $35 CC:ﬁ"§§'1"!iS$§3¥'§%£';

  



M}

ﬁaeieé V,C,§ dgted ZQEQQZQQS

5: The ﬁ3&SS§S§§§"%t €@mm%ssim§r
Bangafare Naﬁch Ta§:;i<
Barggaéege.

Ii The Tahséﬁdgr
Bangamre Nerth Yaéuk

Bangaierea V   ,.f{~g$'pg'r: §*e%:~t s"'.

{By Sn H3. \/agaﬁth Kasmari Ad\s;';~L.f{::r R2 
SEE Basavarag" 1!. Sabarad; Aévg, fQ.:i  
Sr; K; Kfishnaf ASA, far' R:;L;-R6 ;3ﬁd R7§_,:. "~«..

RS éeéeteﬁ}  -   L .. "

Thig wag PeEi€:§'f,jEV{§'._i'$ mame;%%%;;g:g¢:E%:225 am 22? 0%'

ihe Canstétutim  E§?1i2€,:ia.v;ra:;:'hg  %:2:: ':qé;:g:«:;:§*: the mssesgien
§etter dated 26§€f,r;'2§}Q2'- §g*§.j:,§§d~e;__ ,4€%V_n":%:é3x_;:re~AA. DE

EN wuss, NQ;8?§ 9i; 2&1?    

8ETWEE§'si:

1% R. Krgghna Remy 
VS/Q %5.E:.;§ Ramg Rédidég _
 ;€i§ed"ab'@%£;%E £%*8égearSf """ "
"'?};j';%_i%§'::2.?jS;  'ikssa
§"'§a.§EéJ.%'?"§§fg3§:§'&..E;§§5{}§i§
&§§5'§3s"{:s%:a§?a'7§;;;%§@§,2t; §%<\;%< @333

j  gangamgégég '$53

  ,;%sh%'%;:a::?%aQ;::a

 ._§;"':_,;«éiai?g« Eggiiféggaggga
._;§.:§i§;».d"a'?§§a%: 53 yggyg

.  EE C5383

"--4.§"f:'§?:5;§;*;*':§;'::§a Laywét



ixéiaéagaszdga Laymsi:
GK':f!»<'P@st, Yeiaﬁanka ﬁabii
Ban§a!§r§~*S6S€365E

L Shashikaia

W/G Parameshwaraéah N
Aged absui 48 years

R;/a é\§Q.23-=80, 3" Cross
Hanumappa Laysut
Aﬁaéasandra Layout

GKVK Past; Yzeiahani-za ﬁsbié
Ba:':gaEQre-556865.

av, Eienkata Krisfma

S/Q Vasudevas: ,  

ﬁged abaut S9_.§:«:%a;r"*;ie 4

Rfa N336; EE_C:'esf§ %   %
%-iamsmappa =7E.ayi.i;:;f""'*V.. .   "
Alialasamyav £;<a.§;"0é§:.v

GKVK Paystgjyegzhasiiigé  

Ban§aE@%"%--*E§{}£35i?;'-.._ =  

:axm§5e:.!5:i:.§:é%a.y V

%'\.if'@ 8; '§r§:'ar2'%a#V.FR?ea:i'é3.I *
v.«-'V':5%§€C§_"¥:"§}{3j§f}.§: 38 3;*§e€a;'f% .... 
 :2/"g3E'~§{3~2'i§; §"7.?%;*~§3._E.Q,§_§
ES£%"::%£a;v%iia:f:'s:%f%*:a§;3a Layﬁagi

,,%§"§';?=;_%2:é$a §"?{'§ %€"i5;.v,_§..:3.%§v{2'%.;%

  GE<V§<_é3a§:g'§%f;%£?é§s2%a %-Egbéi
.B§nga?'§s:rs:%5S%3'*{'}C%6S;

 E%€V§;i§:;Ea §a%é"'
 --.  S,5.§}*3Q'_¥'€§@'s1fGé
'-  ----;£%gé.--;Q aiisaggig 'E6 yeaza



M Raga:
S/Q Mzgdéaéah
Ages: 536:}: 48 yearg

Petét§e:'*:e§*s 5 am T? 35$
R/a N99, EH £5953
Hamgmappa Layout
Aiiaiagandra Layaut

SKVK Fest; Yeéahanka Habié  _

Barzgaiere-553065.

Sikkapga
35$ Javane Gewda
Agéd about 39 yéarg

R/a N981, III Cmss  'v A

Hanumappa Lay€22:.';';'. _
ﬁdialasandra §.,.a;'%;fioL=;'§.'"  . '

GKVK ?QS'£; 'r'%'eia_§*"':"a_;'11f':"<:'3-.  ;  V

Banga!Qre:§§C3'Q5S;.;:1;  , "

Sh%v§:'aj§.mm'a .     
SE9 ate §\'%:,:%§':§;u3p';:>g'  "
§«.ge<':€ abaat 3:§«.f?_§;.§a:s '

RES NQ_a5§3{ EEC-,?""GSS"

 «~"§'?§_f§F3L§%f'§':§';;i%§§%3 ;aya::'i«... ..... 
':_ég§§'a§a;3§?%§f'2*:si La«§;@:,::

§.%<5':,5§<T PQ$?,:g ""5{€"%§i§':'3 F": ks E-wbéi
Eaé"3g'a'§_§.re'-v-  {}§:£;;

 %'K§37§':g:§ "§§Q%z'=§53

 3353 éaie" %%é;~2c§:e ﬁewﬁa

 ';{é2g&;:5a;5§%,:t 5% yéagg
 §';;A3V§$§g;23; E} Swag

_  '-«;§*%§f'1gi.,%F§"£§§§& Laxggai
' :' V,%§.§§aT%asam§r§t 3.33232}:



{By Sfi $833113} 8: P: Chamgaéaraya Redéy; Advs§,_E;'_ "' . '_ ..: 

§%<\./'K Pest. ":r'eEair2a::§<5 Habié
Baaga%s§€»§58§6.§g

£333 :

1

State 0? Kamaiaka

By its Secreizary  _
Housing 8: Uyban Deveiopmesli
iiutharétyi Vékasa Ssudha  
Bangalere, ..

2 The Cammisgéeneg"

Kamataka Hanging BO§éf"::'§... '= 
Cauvery Bhava:n«'«.A_V  I '
Bangaiare. ' 

. "ﬁne fﬂaﬁavqg:  {

§<a maiafia H§T::%§.%ng 

ﬂgject {§..f%Eic:§:? Y%3iV>§'%2A3's%.T§<a.TVTA"2 ' '
EangaEere'«i¥s%'€h'?§§:.g'§<€   

4, "Rae Sggcéafi Lé:"ac:V§ A;ég<:5ga:i';1§§EA%v0::"e

v »i3ﬁ'iC§: §§;;;'m_ata %<§' «%%..Q.:.,:.5i $29

 §isa:fé;. i:5::%s;é;~*.3{ Siiaasan

M

"§;3:::gja:'%Ve:;;<:?.%_"% _ 

£§%:3%* E9%5?:;;':i§_§.§:35$'3§_ iieugcéi

 .'¥'§§a§'§':?§?'%§<<§ ;§é55%"§§&§§£'€
 by ;2':s _ 3::Q%"E'1§'E'1E§S§§§"%€§1

   1&3 éatéﬁ zggmgggg

;,?et§iE{{>;?;'g'%3_



%, The éixssésianiz C8§'§'§€T§§$S§C?':€§"
ﬁagéggiore Nartéz '?a§:,;%<
Bangaiara

1?, The Tahsiiéar
Barsgaiarg ﬁigrih Taiuk
Banga§<3re.

(53; SmE?ushpa%<am:hafAév5,@2182, .é;3 &.R4; % ' % L
Sri K, Krishna, GA; fa" R1, R6 a'::.zj"f§?; ' '
RS Cieieieé}  "

Thig vm: Petitéegé is s;se -Q? ur;%'d eL%Ek%A&:;k§j§e«s225 Aiafﬁé 22? GE
éha Cssgiétzgtim Q? Endéa §3:'a'§€'§E€;;-..;'iC3' §_;;;a.3§f1 "'{~;?je pesseggém
§§t':er dated 26§é.2GG;2. sf é.z,i_:;'e ;s~'?\.§::f'§ex':s_:" éf':~;I§'=Cr"i.

IN w.P. No.14.8%<.g_;§{:§§g;]. Q    ;--  

BETWEEN: ____ H
3.. CM; GL:f%.E<a-:5' . "  '
55$ §\/§9:;§a5:::;a* % _  V. 
Ages §beas'*:?"§§% '~;'éESi".$  " 
R53 C3555, S,F,V.SA;'%%;§u§l§s
    _____ 
V" 'V.VYé%{:sh7a::%<";'2:' Eﬁ\§E:éil¥&;%.. E":3::a:r2
'3L3§?:V§;ia='§w::: :'@4j'éé3.~  ' 

 Eétféé  €'%:'*t.:%§iA§aia%

.1fsJ;'§ C'ha:§{;§a§'faé Eam

 a§a2.s%:. 56 ";.é'€a§'"§
 "§f'<';»;f8 :%<§;'2,"§\%.%; §i€e§t
 .'  [%*;§'ag:i;a:'%':§§: Cmga
" _ =5Eaz*:;gaEare~§2g

   « /.  , Ra*.§:'§a:3n..vc;%5Ee'-Vs'*e%:3"'.



SA)

0"}

Fathima

Dye Imam 35$

Aged abezﬁs 4G 'y'€é?S

R;/a Ngeiéﬁg Rh-.§aR§ Bzgiiﬁmg
Veiankam Rggd
Gartgamma f:%i'C§E
Banga§Qre~52.g

La%:hand ﬁunarzécharzdji
SEO $33333 Chandji

ziged abaut 50 years _
Rga 1§8,/'1; $u:*aj Mari<e?':_
5.3; Lana. Chickpet H

Banga§Qre~S3,    A

E' Parvathamma. 

W/g éate N. Fia?:2'e3:ji :i$é-V-.    
Aged abQu%§VTv63V.y'e§.;i§_

R/a NQ28; r4a:.%s;m%=:%a 3}'§§$_'Ga§!f 

Lﬁigaarpeig 8aL::§3§s.é{:*e;%   

E Sangagpa !ii::4ga:%§ ' .  '

SXS Gzsvéavppa ;'3;§2wr:_;_;a':§§V"

;.é;§ged,_"fa::'§3Q:_,§: £5»? §;e'1¢r.§ .... 

 gig. ;4»:<;>.<48,:?   

u"'"m§ 

 %.».,£1'?2§§:§a§'§a%
 Sjgiaiéae S: ?ra§<;§§§§ R3}

_  ﬁgéié absaséi 4-Q ggarg

'  ~?.f&'§%i@g2?; Sanjegva Eaiaék Lﬁﬁﬁ

ifznégziffé E {$2 §;§§§.x"'

$§ 'G!§§ {§§33"i E:.§f§§~. 'V

'   £:;b%:§§':peEj.C*%5§::§'§

.8ar:ga"§*<;;'é:%~f§2i';

i





ﬁosegwe Rgad 393$
Bar:ga§§:e»$2;

8f ﬁxshsk £\L Dhage

Sis fate Narasmgh Rag
Aged abgut 51 years
No.1G4;, 1,3?" Mam

31$' Crass; Budécéaé Layout
GKVK 993; Bangawre-65,

§, Eaya Kumaré
W/'0 iate Ratanchagz SE ;;am
Ageé abaui: 58 yearg '  --_
R53 N@*%3,fS§, Baiﬁ "§'ex?:i%eis_" '

Eumma Masjid Read  '

8ar:ga§<3r'e=-S2,.  

 ' gﬁetétisrzers

{By Sré Eeshraj :3;  édvsq}

ﬁ§\}D :

1 State Q?' K'::«2V;:~:'13i:a%«;g  "
Eyéis $ec:re';:§r3;.v '_ _ 
E'-%a2;s%§>..g  L,f;'éaVG 3'Ei2'€§ §3§m§§Et
V " éuih 1:} E:i:%i3a,__L Vi kg 53 §«£=...r..:.::i«:*: a
"'._Ba:*:gjé§:;%::*'éf 

2; "§'%%i€= . €{;Z-Em': En §?§§;;%§ :%:_%es*'

'   §<ar%°:ag_t a%<a_E?%£:%3§_§§%§:g B9556

?;aa:veé*y Eimaiaré

_.  '««E.a:2§a§@'§'a,'1~

 4  'gVi<§a_'§¥;a§er

 __ --«§!<i'5r'§5%:a§<a %-imggmg Eéard
" '?§T€§}:S€i Sf§:ca, '§"$§a§'3§n;%~<§

 'B§:2ga§Qr& fiééﬁéz ?a§:;§-<a



5%, The SpeC§a§ Lama f3\€QL§§S§'E§§i'"E
Gfficer; Kayaataka Hauséag
Beard; Cauvery Shavar:
Bangaiare,

City Mzmicggai Ceunaéi
Yeéahankag Bangaiere

R€§ by its Cgmméssierzesx

Deleted vgcgg dated 23g1o%2%e:ic3 A

£ Tbs Assistant Comm§ssé§f1"a3r 
Bangaéére Ncrth Taiuk '
Bangaigreg

; The Tahsiidar H _ 1 _ _ --A  _ ._
Bangaieré N€;%*t§é_'*1'"3év'L§'i§»  ' ' V
Baﬁgaioreg ~ ' " - 

'NJ

Haespgndentg

{By Sr; HiG;vasa:é:%:~m{;m%a§;%Amg far 22,, R3 5: R4;
8?; K, Krishna, i;2A¢f. -§§'r"V'E<:i;~%é»..5.:---zd R3;
R5 deéeieﬁ) ' '  7 = 

% _ ?n:s4L?V:;:%;@; P§i§§é(;:;3 §_§___f§.:€é zméey Artécées 225 3:25 22? 9?
téég €As'r;S~'ci:s,:'*:'%'<,?:rz""..:;f§% Ezédia pragriag :@ Q%,:&S§"% thé §§SS€SSE®§E
ietis?' {:§a?t&;G   9? R? zgéée ;'--'\nr:e><::.sré~Ré

 w,:£%:£ai§*3?§;2§§?

  %%%MT'T%;g,§f_%"*;;:E:E§\g: ~  

'  $--%%_aé§;'s§"_€'a§

 .:;":{.@;"~§; f'a§ai3:"a§
 §x_s;$§ aﬁwt 3% '£355

 "R/3 fxfaééfzf Ramgiah



 

ii

Sagdergg Hamsmagpg
Laygutg é§%aiasa::d:'a
'{e§aban%<a
Bas':ga%Qre---558565.

2, EM. Pfajayarz  
S/G 8.8. Medagspa I '
éged shew: 32 years
R/a N954,/':; Ramaiah
Garden; Hanumappa
Layaut, A§Eaiasaa*':dra
'feéahanka   --.    
Banga§ore~S6S S65, V  _     "?et%t§Qners

(33; Sri Deshraj 8:, R €:2"gang:a~E~;2:;aj3.'aV  

ANS :

L State 92' E<_a_::2a":::a $<a"1--:;;:._ «.
Byits Se:,Cret3:'"yﬁ.v  _  .
ﬂagging 8; iﬁribasn' {fie-x;4ef»§;ép-::§V§en': '
§x:;t§*:a;'Ei':ﬂ a,%?i<zzSa' sm3;:a%  
Bangaésre, ' - °  

23.4-We C€3§§2??}_§[:§$%%;G?sef'""  ..... 

 V.§<a3'm:a_:"ai§<3' ;§f'i$%;§7::%E§"%g Eagard
{:3 :3: V:r$%;*T.  g 2% :2 " --.

$a§;.gés%s:;::%"é';   

713; "Elie §*4a;':*:ag5e€ " 
~ --f "~§€§'§"%'§§':§K& _§"§§i§S§f3g Bwrﬁ

 V'§3..:%:f1j§és;::;...§§f§:@g, Vgéahgﬁkg
"3j§:f:§§.§Gz?'€ %'é@§'ih T3§%.§§<5

£%'¥,':f'E§%§$.;<§§eC%a§ L535 zéscqaégiiieré

 "€;?3f 8:85; Kgraaiaka HQi.i$§§"%§



 

13

Bsard; Camxery Bhavaﬁ
Bangaiare,

52 City Munigéaai Cstmcéi
Yeiahanka; Bangaiere
Reg by its Cammissienarz  

Beieted v,c,G dated 24,2912 

%g The Asséstaget Cammégsiener
Bangaime North Talak _

Bangaiera
73 "Ehe Tahséédar  .
Bangalore f\§0:":fh"_%';:»3I_;,:k  .  . 
Bamgaiare.       "R€S§Qﬁ£§€f§E$

{By Srf Basavaréj_\Ji; S$lﬁéi=*;:z5;~':.%g'3afj€;r';'; ma; R3 & R4;
Sré K. K§'"§S1"i?"i&'§;"'{3,%V_";:.5 §:::%3§:.§"~%.1;'R§.a:'2§*%'%I*";
R5 ﬁeie€ed)i  " '* "   _ '

This 'J9rét'~?e"%:%%éi@'n i$.§iE.e§§----._Lm5er Aréisies 226 am 22? 0?
the C%r':3:%§L;_':%@;"2 14:12?  ;5€,;.,_r"a5*g:9§s*':g Ea §€{§§f€ tisgé: the 5am in
$y_.Vi'*é0g§4;'._?:i 56.338 é::.:e::: :3? 1 53% 13 gsgrstas is me? vagied
£215 the §<a§*'§:;§-Lé:a§<§ %~§@a,§§';%'%é§ aagré ass mg m Subgisiééég
;*§§%*;_':3» efiiéé :_he.%§:»:§:"a§__i:: gagegiém by viiiue G? E318 greééménaiy
;f:a'i%*§"'i£3':%g3§é"d_§%;_§::?€%_,%Z:.e1§89 am aiga ma? :'§§*§i€%£:a'{:%{3n daieé

7" _2§,3.:E1*§ E_--.*x:ié%e«';%--§1§2=é%<:s§*€s~?:< am '*5 %re$;;:e£i%z!eiy.

 

 

 _  '  §,.§§%:m§d§V§§?'§f§'E§
' v ._'W;4'Q'E'."$r%§'am& Reédy
".._ ;€x§;e;.:'::§ gmssi 3% ';f€§§'°S



 

Rig §\i0,Ii§; 1': Crass
Hamzmagga Layeut
waiasgnéra Layam:
's"eEahani<a Habii

GKVK Pest
Barzgaioreﬁéﬁ 865.

(By Sri Sesbraj 8a Pg C%war:ga§araya R«:;+:«::;;:';%   

2%

if

3

ND:

Staie Qf Karnataka
By Etg Secretary _ % --_ 
ﬁeuséng 8; Uféﬁﬁ Bex,ieEQg:5z9'r?;1eé;1':-.v.3" 
Autharity, vikasa Soudha. _  '
Baﬁgaﬁgreﬁ »  

ffhe CammisS§§n_:;--i'r """ .  
Kamata kg %_Eji§G7{;:.$§"::§.;:B_Qa;f:§ _  "
Cauvery:'VBha%;fTa:§_v   "
Bangaicafe.    '

"Tag E'v?a§2age:'».__  . _ 
E<ama:a*E~--i.5:_ HGSE-iféig" [Bag-rd

 " '?j_r$je,::§'«:.G:ffiQ§f, ':*'§%?'.5: E2 a.afi:é:a

:_8a7:~.ga'?'§a:>ré :'§'€§r;i:._fa "'%'a§::%<£

g °?%§i€._S-§::g§.€:'a§"La§;§~;f-éggagigitéesé
, Gff%c«€_rj, %<a_:ir§?:c:*.i3.§::i%<a Hguaiﬁg
Eaarég Cé--§§':£"€?'§' §§§E'.4'2?§f3
-«4_§;:%:"2ga§G%>§g1~

 '%':"é_:»;u%é;s%§;§E§{:'; €s§mT2%§S%:::n@r
..E~;§5:v:g§1'l§r§ E°'>~éQ:*"E;%3 Taizék

  Vgggggaiareg

  



 

5. Thg Tahsiidar
Bangaisie Narth Taéagk

Ba gs gaéera . . sR;e3g§:¥:%:i';%:'§~;%.§*%"f€vs

(B3; Sré H.G. Vasaath Kumarg Adv'; far R2; R3   M

3:: K. Krishna, Gf5a.; far R1,, R5 3:25  _ --~  '

This Writ Petition £3 feted under }:a::;;'2es:;.§ 2'2._$"~a:ﬁd:;§2--?":Ef
the CG!'33t§3::i§§Q{"i of Endia prayimg. ta dec§aé<e tha»t.":::§}e '£ar:;d*ér': 
Sy,Ne,E4/2 m the extent sf 1 aaie-...?;8 gzsratas Es f'E§i*\!.§2"St€d * '

%r: the Kamataka E-{easing B0ai"§V._§§'3é h'a~:,:. 7m:;¥ sugbsésténg
rights we? the %and if': quegtésn ES}? x?"§vr.t:§--$_ sf thev.p:§!iminary
nQ%:.%f%ca'::en dated 554.1983'§--f":d3§SQ §i.§if§a_f"ET';Gt§f:iCat§Q§'§ dated
25.31991 vide Ar:r2e><ures~f'é'i' :_:;:'r':::§3&3':ies_§e.:{:§§.?e.Eyg

IN w.s>. NO,7653,3*i2V:(3-£17   
BETWEEN:     %V Q} «

. G. Sach§daﬁV3'r:<Ev5a_V V _ 
S50 RE G1Q§a§a3§«;'aVs':2.y"%. 
égeé EC: wears ' "
Sen§:a§pa€:'a%33i!.§
Settahaigggr ﬁégéy " 

_.-*"E_a§2gv_a§':>rg_ '§:€§:*:%2   ..... 

 83ng3'§€3r§%§52._EE?z

}.....Vs.

25 §vZ";'f'~{% ;'-["333 :35  V V 

_ 3/9 §'«i'_§3%2é5_gif':é';§:ir:g 
égeﬁ E34 '§ e3'r$
.«..L?~;a.21;§??'§%4&;n

" 7};;'%,';"::;;%;a%1a5"§ Exiéazgéan
 €5a,n'g,;5§%3r§&S§§ §éEg

  R 'xjédya

 '"*:('£/§ E. ?§'g%<@;§%r



 



'  '--~§?--'~§aiL'§§%:':g Qgpgrtmmi

" »§{;'§sh_:f3i :3. C_G;mg_pEe::{A  ~
 E*é[eEa:f_Wa§"e;':V* "_§'"a:,s§§~::
&<§d2%ge%3§v§.§b_§;% EBg::1g.a§era§

15

Ageﬁ 28 ygarg
$£\§Q.12S@

13:" Main; EH Cmsg
Eudicéai Layaut
SKVK P93':
Bangaiare-EEG $63

$3; Menaka
Dig A; P§ﬂﬁ€€§" Sefvam
Ageé 25 yeas

M2259; 13?" mam :11 Cress  

Judiciai Layeutf Gt<':;'§< P93:
8angaiere=E6G 065% ' 

Smte Jamuna P

Wfg GA; ?aE'}E"1:€?@'%:'.'§VSVf'i53§¥;i:§;'Al'"§"%  

Ageé S0 yearsl, _ _ .. « 
?\i0,12SG; 13?" f'3é.;:s%;r':;"I--w§{I, 
Eudécéaé Lay%oLs:;'5%::};§: 93:-;;:'~ *
Banga§Q:fe~56{:.T§Z3_65;"f_' 

Sm: K, ﬂai§S'h§'%;;'  
'vi/jg: K. Nagarfgaj. _
Aggé Eﬁgzears  " '

 Sré  3;.a:'§:%;?.g::;:*é%<§§§z, éaéizag}

£3 

 ":;a"i§_  Kgraaia ka

  'i'vT§.,_$. Ezsiiajmg

 '=§3&§*:ga§@§*"a--~§§G GS:

..§e%%%:§${*:er$



 

15

Rep by ite Secretary.

'Hie Kemetake Heeséeg Seem
Ceevery Bhavae; KS. Reed
Bar':ge£eree56CI 809

Rep by Cemméesieeesz

M)

Specie: Lead Aequéeitéee

Officer; Kamataka Hanging
Beard; Ceuvery Bhavan  
E-«CG. Reed; Benge§@re«§6OOG9;"* 

'Lid

4; The Assistant Cerzzmiseieeeer 
8: Sub-Bivéeieeai f'='!ag§St:*e:te*-   
Bangaéere North Teiuk   T
Bangaiere. A'   "

S. Tahesiédar 1 _ V
Bangalere Nesih»-.Te'E
Banga%o:*e;"  "1"

"   ﬁxeseeeeeeie

{By Se Beseiierej we ;S@ﬁ;5'3i3'>¥g€,§-,{:L:;VVV?As'.'»iﬁ'3(.;'§'%'g'x; fer e2 & R3;
ee K, §<:*§ehee,,"':3A.,v €55: F%:A1,*  ene 25)

 . ?hée.3--};'v'r§'ei ?et%*::e.n,,§_S ﬂied eneer Ariéeéee 226 end 227 ef
the"'£e:éet%*:€;i'%;%ee..«ef Eiééia eeayéeg ie eeeéere ihei the
eeq--z;i'5i.:§§ee ~ee%:%f:~ee:.%_ee ieeeeé eeder Seeéiee 4(1) ef 'the
Leedw,ee.eeT§e§.'::§'e§é ,{§?:'ete ACE': z3;eee:<e:e~N ﬁetee §xIL1§89

'j =.._f£'3'§'E§ gezeitee'-'eﬁ';_r:>e §8,:gi§§Q ieeeed 53/ iee eeeeeé
 res§3eeﬁe'e: .ee:§.«~"1§ee§ereiiee dazed 2S,3.i§9i eéeee eeﬁee
..4_TAe'_--§_eC::.i_en §{~:?}'t.e§'"' éihe Lew Aeqzeeiiéee {S%:e:e 336:) iéeieé
_2§;3_i3:§§_§ aﬁréei eebiieeee ie ihe geeetie ee §.:,4.f:.9§: eiée

_ _» "~..,§5ge.e'eé<L:§e?€?§ ey Eghe ii: ée éeeeéée eeeé éeeeeé $3! eeeeeeee ef

 



 

 

 

§E"{\!'=iEE¥"-3:

3..

 

Dauiath Maiiappa Nagavi
Sis Maiéapga

Aged absui 6% yeag

C/0 Saba; Bedding Hauae
BDK Qcgmmgxf 5.3; Read
Yeéahanka, Bangaiagewéé

Kannaiah
fa Chemziyappa
éiged abwi: 8G years

C/0 Babu B8dd§nQ._§"§QUSS~- f  A
EEK Com§£ex;';-Read Z. 
Yefahanka, Bia.r*;.ga%1§:{r§~Sé)§_  _

; Smt. L§ngV_a_{1;f':b'iV!§§= 'V«:.;:__  

"v'\Z;'Q Veeé'ach'a*5'_

aged ab<:;s'€'--é?.v§;:'{'§*.s"A  '
C59 Saba §S€f4j§ﬁ§_ E*%::'e~.33g;~..A__" 
EEK CQm§Eé:><:i_g 31,8. .Ri:,a'§_ ..*
":'9£a§*:a;":é<:a1A§ B3§:§3a'§§%e~=§4g

:E§$- 532:3 $ri4;:g§s5aéé': 9gb
é':.§$::'§-g%b<§i'%;,s.%:'*~:iE;E':iV.'§:;%'§ rg

. C/Q Esbas v;Bféé1.§iAé'%°:g ﬁggga
EEK £:'::srr:'--§§§aef',<; 355; Raaé
-~._f%"£%§aha:2'%«:a;_g1~Ba§:ga§er'e~54g

 §&§.§<';*::§:E.{§§§: Saﬁ
'--«§,i¢3:%--=%a;$$5%§*: Saba

V%  ﬁgaié aéaaéi: 42 yegra

 *:';'I;j@ gm; §:eéd§§:§ HQQSS



 

@353

MCI?

SEEK Cﬁiﬁﬁiéxg B8. Raaéi
Veéahaaka, Eanga%s:*e#§£,

Smi; Siiﬁaja

Wm Sangameshwaz'
Aged abeut 45 yearg

Cja Babs; Bedding Haagse
EEK Campiexg BB. R056
Yeiahanka, Bangaﬁayewéé.

G, Sﬁgdhammi
S,/Q Eats Mg Sagatakrishrga
éged abeui 55 years A '

18

ii

C53 Babs Beéding Hsaisé' "

BDK Camptexf B355. Road 

'zeiahankag 8anga:¥';'s:,e=§;%L

Snét. 5! S:.2r2«E2':i«:,%;é;:!ﬁ"§'r:'z'§:>':__ V   

W50 Narasa Re;d'd3.»5;__ 3
4§\§€{j abw': ?:%e-33,533 

Cfs BabyBeddifzg-§:§_»é;:§'e-H"---.__   %
EEK C<;m;.§e>:,, B.--B."§:':2;a%a*§..__ 

Veighankgg ":ia§:*:a;3a§i:g'€:  '

E, .§S mi.   ?'a?'::é§
   
';@§%.é 'e3;b::a;§;»é;1V yea $3

§;'::; 55;: ?:;g-..%ﬁ~:;:;_§§.%.T;f:(:;~' ﬂaugs
B§§<:AC:;;:§:*:@§s*>é:';% ESE; R@a§

 _'{e§$%3:s--;é§<5;',;'§:.:::'%'2gaEa:'§~é£n

_ _§. '€§{"S:r:%.;,é<:§§§' Mg ?ai&E
V '   W} ﬁaiei
.   gésasi Eé yggrs
  'T%"*--.VV{_;§;{i ﬁabzs Saéééﬁg H{}%,§f~;§
 "«8®%€ C$m@§§>{; 8,3, Raaaﬁ



 

3.1,

13%

15"

19

'fefahasékag 88§"?g§§D%"€"§4;

Sm: Mahadevamma

W/G late S§TK Natekar
Aged abaut 6? years

C/§ Babu Bedding Hause
BDK Cempfex, BEE Read
Yeéahankag Banga!Qre--é4.

, Bharzvarvariaf

S/é Sohaniai
Aged about 3? years
Cjg Babs Bedding Haagse

BDK Camgiexg BE. Raaéj. ._
'z"e§ahar:E<a, Barsgaiareﬁéié. '

Smt. Hemavatéfté.-1:' 

Wfa iate Chik§{.amfad_::ia;Eé. 
Aged absut 44 }i*e;é"r'*sl._ >     V.
C/0 Babu fBedvdi"n§«:.;E:ieLsse '~ *
am: CQrfr*é;§'fé'x,. V1BaB."i:'fi=2:..3_a5:ﬁ._   
'felahanégag .5a:§g"a§::;fle:aT;5':§«T,T .. '

MS; Saba" V % .
S,/Q §ai§..$L%§§:;:'§.;3%"§~ 

..w.;$?~§€d_%%ébGV§ii S? y1efa«rsLL..V
 C;'1:i:VB*ab::'-E';e5:iA:é;%:1s§ Hausa

 Bi:r§<' '{£Q:;*z.g3§'E'§>;-,. 3, R@§d

'*{;"~:i.a'§<:';3:i*:é<:%;"~A;?B~j{5 :'%7;§V:é'§@?&~--«63;u

Smi, "'i'*'§:;:%.'ié2ev3§"§i<a§a:"§'::':25

 ':s'if;'§ égteéig ?"'?i§§§§'y'é§§a

 *;2gs:~:%s:'§L.5§@{s't: £2 yegrg

  C;'§uB;a%'§§u B§6§%§"§§ §""§{Z?E§S€

.  .jBD7§~{: ifamgéexg SEE, §§§ﬁ
 .?s'§§_g?§§13:*:i<§; B§ﬁ§§§SE"§*§4§



 

16.

1?;

185

353:. Susheelgmma

Wis Azzjanappa &

D/6;} éate Narayaaappa
Ageﬁ absut 42 years
C/S Baht; Beading kéeuse
EEK Compiexg 8.3. Read

Yelahankag Ba;::ga§$re~=64.

Mehabaeb Sab

SEQ Eats Masthan Sat:
sﬁxged abeut 55 years
{:50 Babu Bedding Hausa

BDK Campiexf 838. RQa_ %:':'i=. ._
':'e{ahani<a, gaﬁgaiore-é:T;5;_ ' '

é<,R Nagaraj _
S/0 Ramaéahﬂ 

Aged abouiiéz y+..=:{é'f§__ »    V.
C/0 Babu %Bed:§'t'r2§_;,Ho;s_seVR «.
BDK; C0::'*ré;;:iV§Ve":<.,?'3;BLi'}§{<";as;*§._   
YeiahanE§a,,«_§a:é§~;s2'§Q:*e:a'f7_6%'¥;"v. '

, A%ag§ra_"§:.,: @._;'%;  "  '

Sis ;5:{f'§§§1é,§i'E

~ Ageii éébsééi ;48%%ee «
 ; C53 B'a§é;:'L'§e%'§.d§§:§ ééeuse

M 
wr

"»;§&.s<:%§.a;z:%;:eg§%'8§B; Raad
"f'a3§a=;h;_3:%§<:3';--«.,S&.f;':;«aégrs-één

.; ,_ g::~2:;%~:>:~e;:::gasa§ Eaim
 "/éjfc; R§{%3§:.:; 23% Eaia
 "A;g€s:iL._;3§é'é3i: 42 'y€§§"'S
A  '£;%';":»._§aj::,§ ﬁgééing i-éezsse
 ..f.'§3§é%%: éﬁmgigx, 3.5; Read
%"'~..Fzf§iéi'3a§:%<a; Barzgaiargtﬁég



23

2:14 Kum. Swamza 33%;":

£6 Rafzhaa La! 33%;:
Aged absui: 23 years
C50 Babu Séddmg Hausa
BDK Csmgﬁexg BB. Rgad
Yeéahaaka, Bar:gaEer§~§4,

{By 8:; REE, Eayagrakagiz, A::§v_,§
AND :

Es

{may}

Siaté ef Karnaiaka
ﬂagging Sepayiment
2*/LS' Buiiéiség
Baagaiarev-56$ 3?}:

Rep by itg Secretary,    «»

The    

2.

Cauveiy Bha'x2a:}';.§<-;'£::L__. R*Q,§.gj"*~.  V_  '

BangaiGr§f_!S5{{GC:'§_ 3 V
Reg by ifjo-:2*&:'mf§;;S%§:"2'::§;,e'%: 

Sgecial L}:~;.§: :3. A£a:*;;V§%'::%j_¥;~%.s7§':.. 
Gfﬁgesg. %<a:*;:§:ev§<a" §%%€;:ii§5E.§'E§§
8§arc§,. f:a%.;\;&é*';:_' 8§%.§"'*;§§'s 

---.%§i§G,_»§1.'-i§a;;_i';, $3 :':g'a--§Vs:T/%.%,5f£§_ﬁf;"Z:6Qi3 6%

Q'1f?"§'1€",§§$§.S§'&§'i'§_CQE"§§I'F§§SS§Q§'E€E'

&--..S:;_i%?1'a§.%§;;é.$§i:%:":3§j?~rE3g§§i:'§E§
gaggga-iéaré §2§.'?;:,:r:'%i "§a§:,;§<

 B§§:§a._i@§"§:;' , 

M :"'----"§é.:§fra$i%é§~§".
  §%$:*§g§"i~«:_i§r% %'\L:3:'{%: "?a§:s§<:
._ §§':f1g;::'i%*;'>:*§5

Hﬁeggsméageig

Er? B33%'2s'&%"§j :5', Eabafaég ééasg, fsr R2 $1 §3;

  ~.v ;§>é;j:s:§:;::e:s ; " « u 



 

22

§ri vﬁgeyekemer 4%, Paeé, HCGR; fer Rig R4 and R5)

This W32: Petitéee is fééeé eeder Articles 226 ee%§"'2i:i"?:"e,f

ihe Ceestétutien ef Eneie preyémg :9 decéare;""':i*e«e:-...::r3,e'=_
aequésitian notification issued under Section £¥~.{'1}«jef' t§'=ze'e 
Land Acquésétéen {State Act); Amexurefzm de':e.ci{'Vv6;'e,i§89 
and gazetted en 3.8.1.1996 §3s:L:ed"'~by. Eh.e"«._e;e'eene"'.
respendent and Cfecéaretion dated 2'---§.3_';":§;'-9:<._m~eéeV':ied'e.r'
Seetion 6(1) ef the Land Acqesgisitiea '{State,..'~,A:%:}" §'ated'=,
2533999 ane pubﬁéehed in the'.g'e.:ette"-can :_:;..4,":_9*':%§, ~'?\/é§e= '

A:mexere~Z1: by the R1 E3 §msa!:t§e».,a7ed §a;:§'3ed'ebe-Zy egeratiee
Qfﬁgws     

m w.p.. Noszsssgzoos  

BETWEEN:

Muddappa ,  e 

Aged abeui: ?_Q_Vye~a;:*':: 1l:.;._ _,  " A

3533 iate Dhejorr:a--..f5.  _ 

Ria Ch§kkebQm.m3VSes?2e_.re~ _  .,

G§<'xiK*§, %§§e%eee;':--e re' ';!§'E'§fe;~ge'--.._'_TA" 

Yeieheeke Hebe' " _  V'  

Baegeiere, Siéerih "%"e3u'i<V 

Bev:<:ge%e:f»e~%.S§i€é  _____  ,gPe€it§e%':;er

{8V§~..S:'é:.?<;--»STAa *vR:e::é.«S:{'?x§erene*re Seaeeeg Aéeeggg

 Eieie ex' Ke reeie Re

'~*B:,5»%t§eeSee1s*'eé:e :3: ie the

V' =?Ie:;ee_e%: Q€§§3§?§'"¥"§8E'E§';

.f*:'E.S5; Seéidﬁeg

 'j'?%5;%}§e§ere--§6@ BS1



 

M}
U)

3 Hausésg Csmmsséassr
Ksmatsks Hsusmg Bssrd
Causes; 3hax:an
Basgsforsﬁéﬂ 0893

M)

3, Spesésé Land Acquésitésn  
Qfficsri Kamataka Heusisg : '
Beard; Cauvery Bhavan

Bangaiere-55$ 909; _  »,ks:.e:}:;'g§:sesr§:s'fssvs

{By Sri 'xfijayakumarﬁ. Pam %~ECGF>'.a,,?"s;' s:;'s  E
Sr; HE, Vasanth Kama? &,.-§<,R.g jE;a*Es i_<r§s'%1;2asg.&s§vs;; far R2
s R3) '  '   

This \f\f?§: Petiiésn is fiisé. sjncisr=§xr"%:'§:%s's1v,.2'26 and 22? Q?
the Csnstitutien Qfiigjijés ;i;raf.gx%.s?':'g '«t§"{§~iia_Sff? the preééminary
mtéﬁcatésn date_dK 5.5'=_'~"'§5;j8f§. "x.s§:i.e: ,é§gmf~.s><u'ré~A issued under
Ssctésn 4(1) eff m%5vV'Lsr3d"';5;.sq"uwés_;-tis.§§*ACt,, $61 and the
deciaratisn @a;tst:§.._2S«;.;3,V9:., "2%_§%:§s" «§E'}V§2vsxursvC in respsct of
Earzd Sy.No.:8jiV %::.sV1a_suf%V;ig.i=..s:::re .14 guntss sf A§fa§asar:dra
E;'§§§ags§ "{e¥a?§3ar3ks.ﬁgs-§.§_;'sBa':'f:_§s----§Q:s %'x£s:'¥:h Tsiskg Basgsmre,

:5: was; :x:9.37AeQ_S:i x"%2<3 G? 
   L' sssss 

§'«'Esi.§*eeaﬁV:%%s:j §ssj%:s:;ss :* 

 3%§"§f;'Z'E i"§_§'C_€%S§{§'~§ff2§'V."§;;§{S§F

°;;{a} _ S.?T'§f;" SE3 %svs':;:*m§sa

 *-sﬁgsﬁ ass-at E? yssrs

* 'V.Vs.}\£i.f:;..'§ais1" ?~"§C%§§8§'B€"S€€j Eshsq

 i'§%':}§és7%"§*ar§":a§ fvizsstsig

  égisd abﬁijt 32 ysars
 Sm Sass Msharsrssé Essa;



{6}

{3}

{6}

2%

Mehammaﬁ A}; L? Jafar
ﬁsggd Ebééit 27' years
S/Q §ate Mehammed Ishaq

Smt. Bibi Hajeera
Aged about 35 years
D/9 fate Mehammed Ishaq

Sm: Bihi Fathima
Aged absut 33 years 
S/'o iate Evmhammed I.s;.%'2aQ 

Sm: Zgiekha '
Aged abeut 28 years 
D,/0 iate MOh§Fﬁff::€d §[§sh§Q',=

Petiiiéanersi{;3j,."t.Q""'{f}. »a§*e?fjja§i*   

R/'a A3§a_§asa's¢2,d'r3'.:_§¥ef§a2:3Rgad' 

High Way "i'\R:sgi;?; {\i'%§a'r _Y":*:§}§han§éé V'

Tiies F:3vVct§srg;,.VB5gf:-ga%§Q:**a,f~.. ' -

(83; Sr? K, S:sm§;2.?ﬁ2d::;,'}__.'4V'  " 

géﬁéi} ":

3 §"?;e' $§e--.f:e 'vQ4f'~§<§:.:{§é3_ta§<a
By L';-$2 '«E§e«C:v*:%'{a:v:y . %i;a::v'%;"%: 5

  Ravemgé §e;§e:f2*ij%_:r§':e%::
,. §%E;g$§ B:z%§§§:.*:g 
§as'j;ga§%rej5€§G {}@::s

  *;?"%':"§"_%x£.aVr::€.::§aé<z3 ﬁgmséng §z::3§:23?

3?. 5:59: éiéagging C§§"§'%§"fé§S§§Q§"}€§'

  h  '£"§2;§'_§§ry Bhavggé
 5a;;'2ga§23§'a~SéQ Si}?

HP€iii§Q::ers



 

25

3: The Speatéai Lead Acguisiiém

Sffécea. Karnaiaka Haugérzg

Beam, Cauvery Bhavan

Bangaiare-550 GQQ.
(By Sré Vijayakumar A Pam, :--:<:<;P.,, 50:" _Pg:;_  V ~ Y
Sré HG. Vagaﬁth Kumar; Adm, E35' R2"-& §%'._3}' '

Thig Vvrét Petitian is mad u'adV7e:rk%%Ar::?:§e1sk;>:5s'::d%'22%7 as"

:he Cenststutien sf Iadéa praying  tQ'q;1ash"%.%;":e"grégiimﬁnary
mtificatian dated 6.4.83 vEr;i:~3"' -;%mi'a~xure~D"-A and the
decéaratian dated 2S;3a19T=§}ii§_ssi;,;e;§§.aé::_d»er~%Se«::iQr2 5(1} G?'
the Land Acquisitien £Kr::': 3_§é1 Vézgféfﬁ ,€'\ré':*:.Afe.v;><L:'_:e»E ané aise
quash the notice vide Ann§~:»g;.§:e-F--.':iLate':§ 'Z6-';6§2QOZ issued
by R3 and et<:.,.  1 V    

IN wgp. N0.385(j)H13'§_",{'20i',I.?,4"""""'    A  

,._--_....._..ug._

BETWEEN: 

"E1 ikiarayaria §<§d§§.«' '   "
Aged abau: 55 'y€_;aﬁz'vs -_ A
SEQ Th§mm§é3%2 A'  "

     .....

REE: A§'§s,.2.iaéa§":'::%V':f;::\ miage '€e§a"§<:5a;<:§<7a~%:i?::*vi;%§ 1 ' §a:%g3':»::§;*-=é__ §>é¢f§s*%f§_'2..?5%'§';;"§%:§ "?€§:§§§$§'§?3?"

RQEE §'--E--,€"af.vé"& §'3§§"€§"2§§"§ {§{:3;%!AJC§{§§ ﬁavsgg} " T Z "$326 :f3iaE€ Q5 §<;';am3:a§<3 ' §":Z'§*;_.v%_'§:$ S§£'§"E?;a 3'3; 3:9 ihe V _ §:<§§EV€£3§,§8 Eegarimwi 2% MS. Buééééng Bas2gaEQra~55i} G31'

2. ﬁaaséng CO£TE€'i'}§SS§Qi"1E3"

Kamaiaka Hegssmg Bsard Cauvery Bhavan Banga§Qre~S5G 0G9.

3, Speciai Land Acquisitian Qfficezg Kamataka Heusmg BQard, Cauvery Bhavan ' Banga§are~S5G G01. ,",'§"{v<-3.Sp.:;%nde:3%:$ {By Sr; vijayakumar A Patiég j5a:2?_:.; '. Sri HS! \/asarath Kama; Ad.Tx:',_.g §Q!".R§§ 8'~T'R3}§i,*-- This Writ Pe::§_:io=§:'L'V'is: fE!ed:';_:£nd_e'rA:*:E:E'é's 226 and 227' sf the Ccnstitutiara'Cf_"£n'dE;3__ gs"-.»;'j3j-;(%'re--g: ':Q*.qu~ash the greféménary mtéficatien dateé..V6'-,4;_:8§ g'aV:é'€teCf_::a:'2}183.99 issued amder Seciésn 4{:'}'%"":;€. ff:he"3:'}§;arz'é ';'3x:q_:;éE§Et§0r: Act, 1961 vide Annexure-A':__an<§--£:£f%e"V.:':e:'§%afat;§tm dated 2533.91 gazﬁteé an 134.91 issued u;}de§"S_je¢t'§'::§:§'»».;6,.{E.) 3? the Land Acquésitém Act 1%: véde'L:§§r:§e>{:;:'s5B_§:2d aiga gsazghi fer Qasashiag §'%0§§£E 5§{ %%"'i§?8:}'<'%.!._§°€'=E ' datéé 25.%§2Q§2 isguaﬁ by Q3 ::3e}r:3%r:ing.%--A:.:0L'~'f?2§ §a:*:r:i§:--';;____'Sv;;:§:§.3;§2 meas;,:r§s§§ 2 §Cf'ES 26 g:;:*£'§a*gA gs: $%gxsii;.§8[? 25 gunias £2? éafiaiasandra Xféiéggeg Y§§3.§:a%i§;i<'&.V§"=§:*:v§§%, «S§:2_§§E§:"€ §'\§o:*§%': Taiak, Bggzgaime. gr; wﬁ. ::s:%ie§%é$i;%;?.§§k 2683 %%%%TA:"f:sjE;f:?a;a;%$5§;xs: ~ .§'%_:;é<§ abaagé S9 gzearg U"?

{By 8?; REV,:':V}aya§;>;?'$i*'Ee;;:s§*:'§ % M «J ;, 'vi Féarayaaa Rszzfdy éigeé abmst 56 yearg V. Shévaram Reddy Aged abami 54 years Afv. Eagannath éged abeut 52 years ASE are sans of iate ijenkataramanappa Smtg Lakshmamma éged $2 gzéars D/Q \!er:katarama;:ap§a_..... =. A AM are regid§:"';g3._':éi: ;§»V' Aiiafasandra;'v'%§§§3~gé""'--.._ GKVK Psstﬂ BaV:§'g*a9"§_§;_r;e ~ V' ﬁﬁéﬁ :

1, _."§"he Eizaie Sf Ka raséaigg, .vB'?"§§S"§§€€E?'€i'3"%'§é 3% E579 {:§_sf.}'::'§§";"$--.%T%"% €:.r:é; '§.e§*%;;e 3: :2 E Se 95 rimg 52%:

{L{:s'-%"§{§«.";"s;§i{,j;:é§:?.%f:%§'f;}~"§'~'E5S; gggdgsg " . Ba;*':§?§?§;;s:"e»~E§s£.%j_ 535$;

2 ."E'_'he §<é'ma€;?a'%;-:::""'§~%:32g§éskg Eaaré by §'"§*f}L§i%Z'~§§'E--§ Cgmﬁzisségszer ' ' '.{:s3,:s~;§;r_y Bféavasz, %<,§§ R953 "§;'.':g'%;;g.'%§{i%_f{?w£§$Q W2, [ '*«7"%§§€§3__§§;§&s:§a:§ iagéd égqaésétim 'Lgffééer, §s{§m@§a§<§ ?'§G:§$§i"E§ gﬁetétémerg 28 B§a:*§,, Cauasery Bﬁavaﬁ KI3. Rsadg 8&£":g3§€j}§"€"5§§ @335 ,.Res.'p€,éi}§5é.f:f§%E::.

(53: Sré Vijayakumar A $53!, HCGR; far R1; __ Sri Basaagaraj V, Sabarad, Adv" fgr R25; R3) "'"=--- ' This writ Petéiioré is ﬁéed :mderV}'%rt§:.f'ie§§ :T2?6%Aa}:d:":§'2fz'%:':::

the Csnstitution cf India praying ta ":gu'ash :hé..§rr;§:u§3n'ed"VVL» prefiminary réstifécatéan dated '<3_g4;..;8§ §Svs;;ed_ ?r;2.y"«v?g2~~..::*hder"V Semen 4(1) 0? the Land A€qL;§3§'1:é.:_jiré Ait 'a.nd«;éub"si§shed in Kamataka Gazette gr: 18g:.19§Q..--:/éfcive ';i\nnexL:re_+Cv»':and the fénaijmtifécatéon dec§arat';Qf';-..da'i:ed. '2~«§.3;'§: issued by R:

amder S€C§§Gfi 5(1) sf Laad ';%{:q:§'iLsi%;§g:>n_,¥€x<f:'%;,§'§'2§ pubééshed in Kamaétaka Gazette Sn 11=4.._i1S*§,1'.:znje"'25a.n%2~e.::{:re--E and the mtice dated 5.§32QéT13i--8g9;:A20Q3,:E5.gQ~ed._by€23 under Seems: § and :0 9?' Land_,E§:q;§'LEVs§ii§:1 iiact; ::,§:'i;e }?«n"r:'é><L::'e~E< and eta; IN w.p. No,%333V%3;%'%::.9oé * L BETWEEN:

Rs \fe:ékataram'£;L{;33v;vs::§g/.. " .

SEQ iats §'~«'!_RaﬁgaT;:z§a'-T' ' Age 51 *y*::«[2%rs " %%%%% ?;g']a Qﬁxééa$52143;%é'Ar3V%":f§§§§ge ¥'e§3??a;3'k'a..%é«Q§§%§ _ 3a%":g?é§.f§';='.§ §F;::3.§"§;--%3 'L§"§3§%V::v§<g H?Ei§§:§§§'E%? %¥%5'."R; §€§§l}-é'g}:§§af 8: §~§§§"%L Sasgagaéajug édxsag} 4;a'i2:.§';> ~ T L' S[f{;a§i::--'; sff' %<ama'%.:a%<§ '*B§,{§t_:<$ ﬁecreia £3:

' ' ':?§§a:*:m§:":: :12? Rexzgrsagﬁ 2% V§d§'2ar:5 SG§.§d§"%§ 8ar:ga§Q:*e~S6@ G31, 2% The Commiﬁiener Kamataka Hauséng Beam Cauvery Bhavan; KG; Raad Bangafere-S68 38%, 3g The Speciai Land Acquisitiem Czfficer, Kamataka Housing _ Board, Cauvery Bhavang §<1G;R§:3.,d 8anga§Gre«56G Q09' ~. . ; § §éS§:{}§'}§€§"EtS (By Sri Vijayakumar A. PaV¥c;E:§;*~-Aé/iC:f§'3*P,; 3&1 %-LG§ Vaganth Kumar, Ad:£._,_"fa:_§i2 ms Writ Pat§.ti<§:;i«.§_s mgagggae:4%%mzgas:25 and 22? gr" the Constétgziégezigfgrimjéva'. §;:._§'§'{i_¥T.'3§i'-- iG""'§€C§a§"€ that the acq:.3isét§c:m prQQée::§_E-ngf'$"--.i_§;ét§«3téii.._Egyiifse:--- fesgendents herein as per the pm-.§'1'm'§_:;a:';_"'ws'éGi:if§;;a:i:§.n dated 6;4,8§ in §\iG.é<arnaia§<a%"Hoa:::§3Eng"7'}V§Q3':*<j}'£.f\Q_;*G'1i8§--9{S1 dateﬁ 2:81.96 Annexure-E":__ agé "'fE.;";a§'=_§'3Qt§vfi€'af:é§r2 éated 23331 in §\§Q.Cii§'f1:E:31':3§5§'1L§;S}5;?5j 3§'--§3_é:".:53\%'%ﬁ§XL§£'E"§: am eta, :3: wga Nagiééas 275:1;

5§3%7;%§.&gg,E?\§%/;A:' .

M, R3'§'?2?&.§'g§§j >...S;"§ iaté §«'é':;ﬁé.s,;§r:3':«:e<f_;'a@;§a §g§:_<: abéatsi 33;} 3553555 . .._1§2i.;f_"a'; §<=%;0sab€€:3;d:"':.

"%:%'Ta§a1'*§*: a:A:i<:3_ V ' °~8;ia«ag'a§_§@.5fe¥"§i§G éifééég $§P§t§E§§§§S{ . Subéa Rag 3; £20,; ;£s5jV§;:} 38 ﬁxﬁiﬁ :

L M} '2 £1 $5;

.__d The Siaie GE Kamaiaka Heugmg Urban Deveiapmest Department, MS' Ezsﬁding Bangalare---S6O G01.

. The Cammissigrzer Kamataka ¥-musing Bcsard Cauvery Bhavan BangaEa:e:=S68 G89' . The Speiéaé Lam A§:;[L:%$é§:§t:zn Qffécegg Kgmataka HQ:,:§%§i§ _ ' Bgard, Cauvery Bhaxsaa ' Ba;':ga!@re~56G g The Asgistant Cc§_:"nfr:'§é:.:3iQ'§'z.§:--=f 8:.._ Sub~B§v%siQ_n !'+'§.$aag--§§i33:§_at:>_'_"V * Bangaiaré Nétxhff. " ' ?h@dEun*i':3§@.£%<,\;'";Vi;";-_f'§'£:.;$%'e§'2 ' ' Ba:3ga§@re?-fSV6€3 . The Taha;3%%§a"i*"

,.."Y€5a§'§?§'«§<5 ?3§i§§< .....

,Yé $3 E33531 §<5€= "L ' 'E:-'j';:a§:gfa"%f;3:%f&::'§s<§f' g:~§':i;gé3za;§;;'i.':é;;T%Ag Pam §~%:${§F.; 53: Rf; '1;--Sr: :.%a3ax;s3?a&:;.. 1f.-Sabarad, zﬁéaszf $3?' R3} .,?;e§§@:2des':t§ _ ._"€§':%.$..S.%\f%%'i: ?§:§ii®:': E3 ﬁeé mﬁer giriégfeg 22% am 22? 3?' Vi?' '£§;3séi§;:;:§@:é 3% §%'"':éi§ Qfaymg m wash i§*:§ a€§:,:%S§%:%Qr: .f'.§£§--*;:'§§é bggsiizg §'€f€¥'§§'EC€ §"é@3<H8/LAQ§8:f8§«§G §SS{§€::§ e;ﬁ'_S:fe£%:%§:: 5;{§_} 3%' im mm Acqgégétisn {SQEE ﬂat} éaigé . '-.,§g5=§§E.§8§ aw gazgéigd Q5: §.S.:.i§9Q iggueﬁ by §I§"':E $%€@s':d BE resmnderzz aside Aséséexayewé ﬁeiifécazéﬁn bearing refg-rsrsce §'~£@.%<arnata5<§ Hgrusmg B@a:é.LAR!93;: Egsgseﬁ i£¥1$€fHS§€{C":.i_{;3!? 6(1) $5 me Lam Asquisiigéan .§§CE {Siate ﬁat} aséd ;;i'::b%§§*!ff:eé an 2531991 gazetted an 114199: sy the first_.é:eS';3é?;*z.(_jj;ef:f%_i", vicée Annexure-*8, IN W.P. NOA8074 2003 BETWEEN:

1. S, Shanmugam Age 55 years 23 $2 Prakash Babs ' ;

Aged abeut 45 years ' Beth sans ef . .. . "" "

Late F2 sr:m<;;as%,%s3e't:;e.«     "
Residing a:_VNe...V8'2§:.3_,AV _ _

E Mam; {Ea:1fe'shf;B§sc7SV<:" "
SeshadsE';;:::.a*n':     
Baﬁga!a=*e~S50      H?eiii:%s%"sar5

(53: 3:; R;'\:;;'g ,,'};ayai'4§;é§<'a?w$"E%g ';xd'§%%,) 1, "ma S'?i':s§7e"-:é:?~«.;§&é?'§':3'i5§<a ' 8;; its 'S'€::€st§:.%;AT'i§ Gsvegnmgzi §.e:s§r: §%.?€§";3?'Ef?§€§'EE f'_j~,..{§;a§é ,&.cq%;,.é§'$%:%i::§:} "'€'*~";,.;;3.~ Sgjiiﬁiéig

-§§&i*5€iAA:,;:a%§_§:%"%~E§§ Sm, '2;"?%i1;e__f--5:Zar:':a§a§<§ %-%§L;$§r:g 833:6 ':§?:.;eg@ is; ?'"§§:i§§§?§ C{}§T%i'"§%f$Sf®§3;€E' Cazjvery Blhaazaéz, §<.{:L Rags Baﬁgaigzné-«S68 G§§% 3; Thg Specéaé Lané Asquésitisrz Qfficer; Kamataka Heusing Bearéf Cauvery Bhavan KEG. Rgad, Baszgaisreﬁéﬁ G89 ._ {By Sri vijayammar A. Patéé, HC{_~E_?,, Sorgéz; Sré Basaxzaraj 'gt Sabazad, Adv,,'§§ '§*=~..R2 &"-R3} ' V. This Writ Petéticre E3 ﬂied %;§;AéeVV{i"';'x.r¥:%~s;_f_es '25'2*6.,.aH::}cE' 22? Qf the Cmstiiutéeﬁ af Enéiav "px%5§g§é§g€;he Empugaed preiiménary rgotificatéen ﬁnder Sectien 54:1) 9? Law A€c§;.;':§"§f::§':3:'2 itgﬁci, i§né" in Kamataka Gazette an 1:8; am the fmai mtéffcazéen ,s:,%--ecf.Aa€':*;év%i::;'i1:*§,V:'}a'§:};éd '2"S;'E;.§§a issaed by R: asrzder Sectien 6(3) 5:? géxct am @:.:bEé§hed ii'? Karmaiaka G§aE:_;é%;:ie':3.:%V xréﬁe Ar:€:ex:;:*e~E aﬁd §§§'?€ mime ﬁatjeéf R3 Lmder Sesiésrss Q and 1% Qﬁfiée éa%f_%§'f§ g§;.i;;gi;:§.s§z:%Q:'%"é'T:f'a'a;;i véﬁe .53J":;F2§}<:§§'E"§<: 3&3 eta'; :2? iézsx§;.%:~%€2Q?5$é;'%-3.239?

V%i;LJéE€f:ai§E§#:<: % _ .?;5~}§és§'%* :_:~': dh3§E 355% ":;;a::.§':;rr§'5€:éa§ i§§§"°§7é%"%§ " '=,§a§e}§.€ a¥'%;e:;%?: 32 years '?ii"a..Vf%§_Q_§S;':; E§g:§ma§';a§ ?«'ia§:':

l -__Rs:;§asd§ Ba;':§52%G?@w§é:'} @535 Rep by his ?@we:r Q? ﬁiigrrééy Maids?

Mamﬁa: Vxfaﬁhxzsa S,/0 LP, Wadhwa aged absut 53 years R,/a Saééani Mansicn _ Laféagh Raad " ._ .

Bas2ga§0:'e~S§O 022 ' ;;~Pé':§Ei:i;:";u<é":*A. *7i {By Sré Narayaza fer Gautam 8: RL;92;§V:é'::+.§;«zariA"',e'\ﬁx;§:;:% AND :

1; State $27': Kamaiaka __ ._ Rep: by its Secretary :0 C-2:3v*_em'me.ﬁt "

Hanging 8: Urba..n~D€veEé3prf::e;'m:-._ ' Authefétyi \fEd4h;3,ne;'}'LS;9u.::i'%7a':._V Ba{1Qa§Q;'e, ' ' We K3 r:j;'ét:éi<a..:§%%§u§'i§'::3 E:§a ré CaL:very'1Sha2=a.n;' '§{';{,E; .R{;«:i::ﬁ"--. ' §anga%§rs:=S§~§E 88.9"

Rm by 95$ §~{a.;;s§.{:g €.:§;%:2':2*zj:§s§§r2e;:

FM} ffgfha ;§»';:€:;:3g§i§'§ §_:ar:$f";:?a::{t:..t1.i;<5%i%@§§ ';_G5f€is::eE:*; Ké%na"§:§§<a H§;;3%r:g '§;%9'a.~;.rG;~ .Cag: $ é": a Va n *§§_._;:%5{;§v§78$::s§'ar§"9r§g§%3% §S§, HR€§§;3{§§'Ei§€§°%§S 3 Sré v';jaya'§<ga;égr A ?at§§; §~§C£§?,§ far 31:

:2 i:;v..§:.:$hp&:§<_§~::th§; ;i%.@v,; 2%? R2 & $3} "'*":%j§:V%_g1 ?§§:§:§§r': Eg ﬁiezj :::r:§§§ ﬁriégieg 22% gm 22? Q? V' é':jE*;.e.?""{.Z'§fssii::§:§9a $5 Egssiéa grayiazg ﬁe éedaae gm: ihg . '-.%€§'{§§$'§f§Gi'E yscggéingg iﬁéﬂiéi' £533 §E'E§§§'E'i§f'E8§'}? :*:§i:§%:"'§€a:i@:*: 34 éated 6349}-g8? §i,§b§§S§'7€d in th& Karnaiaka Qazetteﬁaiéd 1S,i.1§§Q $332,385 by ihe R2 aséée A:me><u;'e==C and .%:5i*::i§:'j4«§§ s=:;afr! nstificatéen ﬁated 25*3,:99$ gwiished in Gazette dateé :L4,19§1 issued by the R1 vEci.«§}§x::?1V;§eT:}§u.re¥_'D in @3935: cf the schedasie Easzd §':ave '§'aA pée:::* %i'>_'y' Eaw unéer Segticfz 3.1% Q? the Lané A €:g{3--§.$§%§0n"'5?x;:t..1~8§--é~"--sa{§'._u the award E3 net made within ?:5;~§€3~...yeaEg franév-v:h~3 "rﬁ'at'é §f" the ﬁna§ ngtiﬁcation at Asme><ure--:;Di:.;"'-..V_ IN w.p, N03-4667 2o11%'L EETWEEN:

3. Smtg Aﬁffa B::a'm;.'*--. """° Die Sheik Daw.Qf'{;2:f£«:_;,,V 3 siiged abfiii{f Z'?.. igrearéi _ N93731: 3*? 5.§<;::§.< ..

§<ar2ai<a§2a§aQ %\§agV3's"s._fa%:a'§~§..§"~ Evéaérz Rem, Eagiga§:::;'e4=3'2V,.._} W3

- :;'§;':3€. é;§-¥.::gva?:':°2:b%§<s " ..... .. e , W353 fx!'ie'eer?e§{;§*:3 §~' _ }ég'€.<j' ';;b§v:.§'t'~Z?V{'§%. yég rs SS3'; 'é"%33'§A¥"<'i?§§3vjEE?V§€s.'%"?& B§£:::%:

:>%;e2§T:;::§'; Ba_:*"fagé_§::E'r€~E5§€%24s; ¢a?§E%£§:§®§y§%f'dS f:€,;'sg §§V€5?~éZ§f§ & A$§<::»s:§a:%3; Adam} V V' EL"~"§f?:»§_§§§x;er:':mer;: sf Kayngtakg *'::%"§d%°:as1a ﬁwéhgf Baizgaiaré §e§ by its Pmzcépai S€C§"€?§E";t 2; Karaaiaka é-éguséng Baaré Cauajgrgz Bhaxxang KG; Read Bar:ga£Qre~=56G 089 Reg by itg Commissémer.

3. The Specéaé Land Acquisiiiers Qfficerg Kamataka ﬁausiﬁg Board; Cauvery Bhgvan K,G. R0351 8ar:ga§Qre=S§G Q09, 4, The ﬁxsséstanft CQmmiss§$§$5e_;"'aé:d."¥"

Subﬁivisisnaé Mag_Estra:;e.. _ ' Bangaiore ?~JQ2't%:;T.3%'s:.E< I Sangafere-E63 ., ' E The Tahsiédar _ garigaicaré"E'£i'§rEEi';*."§'a5i§i5 L . 8anga¥sr€%%5€:G ' ' HR€§§Q§'?%j€é"}§S {By Sré ::;jagza;<k:§g;;:gv A;géa::%,:jj%:::sP,; fa" R; R4 & RS; Sré §'v'%.§'~$. R;mar:}e'::%2y5~VGm§iéag éévgg fa? R2 & R3} A "'"'§'§f:V%:si"*\;%f:*:7"1i:?IeA§;§_:§@:": g ﬂied amer A§'i:§{:1€S 22% am 22? Q?' i?3E --§:O§}§'E-§§L§'Z.§§'§E 'Q?Efééia graying E8 quash the nsiéfégatéea': é§E:T€§§'j6;§~g§;§'§:§._§,i?i.§&??' §§£i%Gr2 $51) %31F'Z§":§ iansj §::'ZQ§§i§§'E§O§""§ :3 S: {S:a§é";éa;:*:)'{.fé:%:*:ex§me~3} iggaieé Sy §"§S§§§?5€§'3'£ §\£<3,2 am '.; nG:§_§%§&t§Q"'s~% =..:§$';.v,;"éd arsées' Sestim 55:} iéﬁdﬁf Lam

-.!'{'E~C€§_a;§$§ii$:é 'ﬁégéiz {§!:a%:€ Act} §::§§%;%§ 2323,2991 §;£%§m§><§g§§~K} _ %.;S5'$-iagsgf %::..§'espi§§aé5m 349,35 "?"--§:§§§§ aswét gatétims §"§a*%:'§f':é:} 58%? §'?§§%":'Z§ sné rgserveéf ESE'-iésféérg, £§m§:'zg $52. fa?' gresamzcamani Q2' Gréeég, {big Say '_j-.:hé'~€:§:.:§": made the §G§§8é!".§§;¥"§§i* 35 QRBER ﬁeiitieeere are :he eweere ef 2.se5%eL;e_'7b§'¥;efz. ef Qeeésjreveeee eéies situated én Aéiaieeeecfze {j'<.zi}L Yeéahenke Hebe, Bangeéere Nerih '§e%q"e§; ' §' g..;e.'§a-m'§.s7;' :.e.x{e':'éee~ eétee beieegérzg :9 the eetézierzezis ee{§--.e'§%2eree.v:e:é*:e i:{§ 'ee"g ecqeiree by {he reeeeedeete. T'§*§ee« §;re§§e?:§ee%yv': eegeéeétéee netiféeetéee eeder Seeiéee? fef Aajqeisééiee Act (fer Sher: hereieafteprefesf;f»ed:'_i:*<:s preeeeing {Q eeqeire Certeie §~.%,Ven;'§§e,_ %ee.ie'e§ng.._'.:§§A~e"§eé'd'e in queetéee wee Eesued en :8,__j;g:'~9,S'8'«:.;for e'::._:'eArea.::v;Q§73:2: acres; The ﬁne; eecieretiee 'er:c:§er.S'ev:j'%;§e'e._S'{_§§~--efthe LA egg was éesuee er: :':2,4,§§9§. §ee'e.s1 es*eVe._Gf_i§;€}_'€; ecree; ﬁevesei esvéé', Qeiéiéeee £i:'%*eef:«_e éeﬁe f§.T§'ef§% ea; A:%'e%'é.e.:A.;e ieifie eweere éeeiedéeg eeyiaée ef '§t%'3é--VeE3'€:§:§"€?%£.'§T§e3.?TfS1'e§'§§:GfTE teée Cam: en gee ereiémieeey gyeeeﬂ ' "».é:%2;e% *:%€e,__":}ee_:;f:*;'i.V_éffee":méseieee§ ée est €ﬁ?§'":§E§€?1f ﬁe éeeue

--f['_f5;.eee%e§:%ee ";:e%%§iee*:§eee. Leemee ﬁéegée Eeﬁge had eiieweé 2 %1i§".§5f§;:%€i§'f%@%""ES eeeéeéeg eeiég fee eeéei eeeeeéeeg E: esee 'eee ieemee Séegée jﬁeege 3:335: tee Qeeezy Qﬁmmigséaner déé as: have gwégdiaiioa re E33:/:€ gcquésitfan gzeisficazémgg £5: Saga': writ §€E§§§G§'éS§ ihg %n:e:**%;*f§*.;":>:'r'e::i'1<é§:*;ii.":<:?;:' SE83' sf d§S§@S§€$S§€;':I"°: was grafted av; §§2W§E"'GS. The interim Qfdéé" was ca::fé:§§b%1'::e:§ 'SEE-::%:.§¢'e:ﬁ_§.$'Q§$§'E« cf the ggéé wrét getitéangz Burjwg thé"--.;}1éndenc'}%.%. :"ﬁe*}.e%}:'%'t"~» geiitésnsg certaig G'? the éa§":d$ "'V.{f:':3::t%eé%s:éd:'T2?; Qua ﬁnal nsiéficatéer: avers de§':a':ife'c;I;?_._";3y ffég.'}f§"r':3:'.§9e$§Q:':dAé%§: $31 and areund 1?,§,:.:§94, Wr§.fi _1-.A;;§piga"§§v._'VA":V'--Ei;:2<;f§:sd§ng WA ;\ie.:485;99 {LA5_?i_:ESé§i"§§%e§é«fiiéeiﬁ E;?.';r':::°;§%€VV:SéﬁCQﬁ§ resp§s'2deﬁt---- KHB befare :_§f2__§ $.i}_}:§':=:EV.s::::;_:V C§£§§"{ qasestionﬁng the Qrder p&SS€ 5f§ is: ¢s'r§:'V~;3E§%':§,:§é*:§:;"~..T§*2e 'x;%.ir%i aggéais aame is ﬁe aiéawed by _S':a:_§§';.%}§s»fgéﬁéah C??? 18.233: arid £«::~:::s§§@ug§*:%:§yL"'E;%:s §%:%<3:___:Q;ft?%e ieamgé Séngfg Ewiga SESSES ii'? 2;é;%'%%:. '§5%f{§'f:.§§'%E§'-.iiééme €29 SE SE? asiée ?§Cr§§§§'?§ ihai ihe ' ~..__§'3e§;§:3.EA C§€r§§§§%§;:%%§}3;:€? $253 gsi ji,§;?'§S§§i;";1:§Q?'% 'EG issae

--f.T';§E£qa;i,§§:§$:§§ 'a {;f%:§f§caié@2*25 T53 mgiiér rgagéégé the épex Car: §'x$§2§§26%8 zg Eéﬁéjﬁiéé 2 am' Qtéze? maiieﬁg, "7:*T§*':~e.V;_%:;:{e;:< Cgzm: ﬁéamégsad 352$ §§S€§$§ ieavg ggétiiégng fégé by ewe em eeseere er: 3aE,Q;2G@2. Steer Q?e§€Si§§.5~'i_§ ee {eerie were eet eebgeei: matter ef iheee writ ee§éi'%jVeTr2eej'*.e5'e.e Aeeeee. Subeeqeeniiyg the ewerde came {e be 2: in {he ezeeewhiieg eeeerei erdeh:'efee»dee:eféf§%ie:?::'e are eeseee by the State Geee%_f:*ej':eet;'v-Certeii: "e{:§*;Ve.r*'*wr§?;"V' eetitiees eése Came {G be ﬂied b;§----«%:§§Le 'e»ereee'S':ehe'§§'2ed eet aepreeceed the Ceert earx§i'e':_;' '"§,s{':*V§;'%€§f'?S_<;»~:i"'3$8?/2SS?' end W2-K2345/ZGQQ, '_f?'§:§:i$'~_~_ "V§'ﬁhe eceuésitiee netifécatéens En ee $53rie's:?.:ee«.ie'§*e§*§e€e':_eiréx%'e§x:ee in iheee matters ere eerzcesjieef"eeeeiﬁe':f{g;:'re:i»§§& i§%_eVi:"é:he Karnateka Heusieg Beese i':eeEf e;3ée«ed fa?je€;AZ.Ljf*:?1§?e'~~§;e':'2s§"is e eemefreeyehy ieeé eee eat 52?: fQ:i--eeqeé§§i_§,ee~é:e E'-ere": 'gee ieyeeig Receetfy ie éhe §;ee$'2.§ie{§; e"':':eiE<:e? 35 eeree ef Eeeé is eeeeiiféee Er: feeeer e? §%«:;eeeee;ai:e;s%e«.ee§e«:;:eeee Seeéeeg, eeeae 3;? reeee eeree ef' §eeg:'j ee;ee"'---fa;§?.%:'§'éee""eeeeiﬁiee by iee Siete Qeeereeéeeé: eﬁegr Le? tie ieetter ey me eeex Ceeséx "ﬁe reeeeeeeee "V."V..%fée.e'ee*:~{gEeeée deéme te be ée eeeeeeeiee ef eefy eeeeii 3:5 ' '-.._e::':*ee'eV'23 geeiee eeé: ef See Eeief extent ef 30$ eefee eezéee r 'F7-"€'"

39

was acgagireﬁ E,if'E§€i"' ﬁngf ﬁeéiaraiéara '§"h§ug%: the HV::::.:;s§:':g gaarci géairzsg {as be $3: §G§S€S$§G§"% es' :6» acres €:§?§.'.EZ':§:Vj€'3:E"§':7%.E':é:E.S as afsrementésﬁedg, thé recerdg maéntaiyéed i::jV'-fij'r*%he§* V' reveai that 3:}: of Sigch 16 acres 8: 2v3'A 'g':£2rt. a:;g in j:}i3§S€SS§Of'E gf abeast E acrsg 35 guiiéaég §nasrét'.;sg:%i" as ff'-.e"= rest 3? the arsa :3? about 10 acEé:§: £3_in V$e::f:';}pvéE§5:§': sf the thiré aartieg whs §"'i3V€ a§rs3é%:i.y <:7_$é::§§gE é@§::§A'§:he {am and' have Cwstmcteé iihe bui$d§ngs,_...Eif_%--s '§.iAs::> %éEéi%~é{.ﬁ'i its mte iha:

Eng Certain of t§::e7_._§ar:;?€3's_. %1ffi.EC:3 ar;eV §::1':§§3f"'§'§tEgat§eﬁ Ea these wrii §et§€'i§G¥'3S_§E"€'~§§;€i'5«:_;§}§¥i the Hanging Béardi but a<::ua§§y ,_a;"e Qé§iS';:v<%:fS§?e£%:f§"'::s.§{'::§1£e '§et§:%@:ze§"§§ §§S€3:'§.Q§"E i?*:%:- .. §?:L}v§"'9&E1".E t%E'a'E§ﬁE?€{§ 565:3; these wréi §8ti§§Q¥'ES gig §:%<;'%é;"L'* . V 3;v;::#;a:§ gezszmass if: x;::§§:m?§8:/23$? ES iiha:

E19; ;_§§a;%s§iéQ?§:. €'§$§§f:§£§§:§{3§E§ $3? feggesi Sy_?a§@,€:5, mgaguféﬁg 4«a::9$::_'_3'§ gaéséiag Sétaéaissé 5%: éliésiagasszjya Véiiggs §'§§\--:E §§%§'"%§§G§"3 $5 igw ii§'§§$§'" Samar: §_3;«~£?%: :3? 32% 3% iii} ﬁat; §:'%8S?%'"3i,E{:?§ as; ihg awaré is :29: svgadg within twa.--@333 frsm {he cfgie sf fins! naiificatiars, E: S the case 9f the méziétionersgiE}:"¥*'s.é'§ﬁe;3é:Q'6_?i.{:2§VQ2 313% the Scheme is mi: apprevedati: :h:9 :é.me Qf«".%.%:é}S'Lé'ané;é"'e:sf'*~%' §§'€§§E'T3§ﬁaE'§! as Wei? as ﬁﬁa! *L."'1i*}eVVVV§arsds bearing Syg§'\fQ$;35/:2, arigWi.'§3V';?%{§'i_3;:'t@:>a§§g% Angéveasurigsg abeut 2 aareg § guntag mt fit fbr acquésﬁiag: fag' they are at the ism; éymg are marshy Eanés;

the Land hag §§ve;z the ;?'€;;'3§§"E :3 ihs §~isg:$%§2g $:t%es;a:_'_;fV{§ fa qasesiésn is marghy gmié 53$: ;_i:«£§$§Ei_i'bV§eVv':aV.'£<,%.%e;f:_:%é:u::€t ihe §1§:;$§ aver gajah iagzds am :?':é:§{{:.::¥§: j::,é_fv&:g' §'E:%§'"E"§§EfS need 7'{Q be ﬁeieééé frsm 7»..§cg::§§i7%:§.:";§*a§ §a"};';Q%.ii'€ af ihe ggme ﬁne §§3%?E§"§'1_?3"§8?§§ %:a$ .4%_é;é:§.§é:g§y éggageiéj ﬁgégé mzéfigatécargg misgt sf {ﬁe 35mg 3% 7::;§';i~:§f12§';'%'_§"§»:%_fd""A.«r;:s:r* €><e:§a:*d:.%é frag": iééa 5{:Q:,%%§§'§%@5::; ggiéiésmérs 4}, ii"3€§'"€§?E take supgeﬁz G? cgrsiaézs &b$€?"a;'§?:§G§'%$ maﬁa $5: the cmjeg" gf ibis ﬁﬁéifi is: WA£'a§&2§4é§2SQZ?. The petitéanerg in WP2NQ3,95_§3j2QQ.?V;"'V'-§$'?§§'}'2*Q€2Z?i," 148§3;20:3z, 193%/293? am 14.?L"S'6;'2G.€i}8"»{§0~f§}ie':§'§7 --..é:.Eias they are the §w:":ers sf the rev2€.=:}'::§: 3ét1e":::Va;<w.dT'ivhe::f'sas.a€§t EQV Ceﬁsirucé: the hsuseg; theygiga'Vc:,>§:%.%L§&.:2{2*..}_';hét a=:es;;%§ut§@n Es gagged by me Kamai:a%<a 'i§§§ué§.r2.§ 3 reggiarézéag Lmautherésed Qc:e,;::.g3i§§cf%1 sites by émpesing Vj"R:s'.~iG/- per sqﬁ; and sad": :®:':Cef;:§£'_§:":' E§é"§2%:':ied én faaicmr sf the §€t§EEG§"§€§'Sg :bgg;.:;;§:d_f' V;i:<3t,';é*'é:~;s;§iv_;s____vaggearémg er: éghgéf 0? Ehe ;;§§'t;:::;:%::;¥2kie:;<gT%%%;a%%%k*j%%2%wag'?65:g;2:f;:@f;: @359/2&3? am "L..AA__gyg§?%£§'S'§3 a;%%§'i._..%ih§? m"i*:: §3€i§{§Q§'%§ $:,:§m%t 3%? 32% avsarﬂs g:::§sgeé'*i':e}';i$n§ mg gegésﬁ 2:2? am: §f83§'§ ag €G§"s?i€§§§§§?:§§ 4"--.:.£:--sjé%%AA'.S;e:?::i"§@:2 :15: @§' éhe as: am :;?'3€:"%'f@?£g E323 £2 ;'}?'G=i:€€§§§'%§S are az%%:§a':€é' Yhey aéga take gzggpert Qifihg €G§%§€§E'§§C}é'%S maﬁa an behaéf Q? gihar getiiisrzersg 63;, Sr: Bagavaraj Sabarad; Sr: %ﬂ§?.AG>._\fa$a:*;';:%':~§ﬁ<f£;f29:'at"argsjé iihe ieamed Gavemmerst Advasate a3:gjp::=;_a;*~§:r:g5".;e:"': the resgendents sazsméz that i%'3Ei:._§2§'§f%:'ii gét%:_§r:;-n_$T' a%'é.;'§'§*ab§'é ta " L' be dismégsea, Enasmaéh agthe {e--r;?§f:'§t§{:-:}_ Q? échemiie is :23: necegsary fgr ihe 92.:rp<>3e :}%'__'a§:q:§:'%V§'§:':§L'v3:§L;AféV"'grgpertéeg and scheme can be @526 time sf formatien sf They further submit ':hai; 'i ﬁgxzithén me years frgm the Sate sf iihiii' féiéai ihe timg §:ji"§E'§§ which {ﬁe §§":i:e:r'£:"':::--§:§féer ;::§ ;dé§pcrSSe§3§§r: was if: Qgseraiian iééeﬁg :3 b?e _é'§<§%g::3":éjQ:,.,;Qrj'%'Eh.€ §ii;';';$';'€3S€ sf ca§€:,:%at%§§§ €538 iémg iifidﬁé' Ssciim g&¢::

*.f'%"§":eg: ?':,:§*§:~§*;e§* Csntenésaé iiihai garigm Q?" E323 §€?.;§§§{}§'"%E?"S é.:% ':hé'§;e_:§§f'a:ter$ 3% af@§"€me:':§%9:':eC%;, avg ﬁne Gwﬂéfﬁ Q? $38 é*é'\;:€.:3§,;i.:€§ SEEES §@rmecj is vgﬁgssgg $i.3§""af8y ?éi,§§"?b%fS %;"v'§'E§€§"% gig 43 eeeeiree; Aimee? ei! sf eeeh eeiiiieeere ere '?;?'1€ eercheeere ef the ieveeee eézee eebeeeeeei te tee ﬁeeé r2e§%f§::te?;fi'%e;%'e.4; Henge! as Eeniency can be ehexee :5: their feveuif ?%fe.1;e; "%i§*..ve_fe petitieeere argument that the Heee§'hgV Bee§:ge-5' eV§¥:.:_fi.eVaAt'iVene. En respect 0?' eertaie ether eite ee;eerS'..fe'r.. regu,'ie?:'Zi:§g "i:h¥eis?'=, eeautheezed eecepatéen ef the ':9"e:§_"e::::e :3'i:e'§.;5y.':::§epQs§ng Re.11{3/v eer eefi, as de'ag:efepe.§[ee.§A ehaﬁbe made eep§§::ab§e in faves: sf such...re_\.rer*;:,se:._ei'"Ee. eezl»r2e:*e, seem': be aeceptee pasticu:e_.§f¥y;:A1:_::%.§'_?fxe.%§'.i:§':.eJ eeE§:§eéie're have puechaeee the eétee eube%eqe~eei1'V%fe_ fénei §i'e€'§fE_:e at§§3n. §. Tee 'i;<'rf:p'e§"%eef:'ejeee:.§e'e. ﬁe ﬁe ceeeieeree ée efi these wre: §3EE§§§$31$ ﬁe" ee'~E:e .%eh.ethe: ihe echeree e%'éee§e be §7'§.;e;§Ta"s"ee"" .e§é?:E féeeiizee ee%'e§*e éeseeeee 0%' eeeééeeéeeeg eCee%'s:§:%«e_:€::v:'éE§§§:;eV:%ee eeefe? eeeéiee e{:.} e? See émsﬂi Aee ﬁee¥""eei:'§:'{e§ee under Seetéee éii} ef the Le ectf fer' ﬂée §§"QQ€§"{i€$ fee Ef'i'E§§§§'§'%8i'"'§E%§§§ ihe §?§jE€§ "'V."v'..§e;*:?Lr.:e'¥:;§§ e§r the Keeeeieke éieeeéeg Seem eeder the 44 erevisieee Q? the Kiemeieke %éeee§;s':§ Beard Aef: :;fer_..e_he:': hereéeefter eefereee Ee es the 'Ki-£5 Aer') 65 Te decide tee eaie qeeeigenf ."§%:e:t}fe% erevieieee ef the KHB Ac: need :3 be 'x:er:e§::¥ere=:§:"» "Section 1?: Qzsty ef".BV:;ée:fd te.g;§'n;.f?eé9ijari:<;e heusing schemes gndee"'"§e}%i§:f ""-efevefepriéeeif ecﬁemeee Sebjeeé 5:: J s'_:j§':e" 'ef 5,5755 Aer and sabjecé _*£'<:_: f!f3Vs%£°7"":¥:*,:::°%:;'§z':;'ftf;':>.§! .v1ef:"»v':f7e Steée Se veremeet; Beeréf Jmegf. exeeediiezre end c;z2der:::'ek--;e ];@'e.;';%5.i:§e'i.'e_ef?y'--'a:*?e3" far the framing eeé ee:f€ee:2i'§§if3_ve§7'fea'ek§»..V§?ees'§§é§Veeeemes and farm?

e*evefe;:eée_e: es? 5:' may eeeeider neeeeee:"§.._' time, er es megs' be eegreevzeef its §§efe Geveeemeee ' _§: efeéter ﬁe ee greviéeﬁ fee ey .§§--e:§.§5§eV§'7_jee;z?%e;:eeee Rfeeeziehseeedieg eeyéeieg ee:§'€*eie*.ef§f'v§E} ee}; efeer fee: fez" zihe siege eeéeg ﬁe VV"'fe;fee; eeeeieg eeheme may gereeicfe fer es?' 8:? '§;é"'§.}«f' {fee fefieaeéeg ieeféeref eee?e§;g:~ §.0::v€::.g " = V M4; "

mm"

\'''"-«-m\' {3} {SJ (5) (6) O') ;in;::7t§:??gs,'3"§V V ' éfiefr Qz'eg§rv'5s:§£:_3r:s;'%V.__ .. ' 45 5&5 §:z:;a::;"s;'€i@:; by gyréﬁgge, §xC§?3:":ge_--.___ $5 §€f?8FixV?S€ G? any graaerfy necegsasg/.._4' far :35" gffggéaﬁ by She e><e«:::.::"E§:? Qf §Cf7S!'?'}€;

{ﬁe iaying 9;' reiayirsg C);§f 6f §3§?}/" ££_i:f?'{f:

gomgrised in {he sgfyemvé; * ._ the disfributien Qr;'e;disé:*§€:::i%:'a:'; Qf".L:*;f:*e$;:

befangiag to C?éﬂ:i_{?e'3.f$ camprised is'; 317$ sChTe:;27eA:_ ffzg ﬁssure ' ~ ﬁsfﬁqiifiﬁﬁ' » ., é'f, _dweii§r:g5 gaff: fer fzazmam £_'2aéi!:§*éf;'Q:g "

the gsséjgiiiicéé": {:2f%k.m§z~r;;c:~s:;»e5:s Jbaziidings gr ,£2VC{'§ii}f?S' Q.f"§:méii_din§3;v __§f?€ .:;:;',*i$:{:f::C:i§{'§' 'A V :"'éC§F?Sf!'LiC'i'§O{% @f maintenance and §'fi%€_¢ ":~:a!é,_ 43:;%:§i_s§§ or e;:$f2§:?ge Qf gay ~ .. §r§,§e.fiy"§§:?é;3r§5e§ is? $328 §C;"3e:'2'3e; *,_CQ§?Si'"f"é5::'€f§{? aim §!€e:'§§Eas'3 Gs' ._ "v.,S §fjS:;'3f§*--.§fEG' b5::£< E5383; §.;*:§%:sf§:§§Q:? 3%? 53526 girafmng, a:¢a5er»ss.;§,5!y A,,,%§3§"2'<§"§Eg§3i;':'2§: af Efss $93 ézécfzgﬁeei Er: 5&6 " _sT':f§€:?*;e 3:25 éarrymg 5.21;? 52y {ﬁe Saard Eg:: gggcg'? 3568; £55'"§§§'§§§"§; §e:»=;er§ge 55:25 W336? gzsgggfy ;«:@§"{<§;

{ﬁg ;3:"C}¥'f.SfQf? af parkg, pf§yf;?g--f.5€fa?s §;':§ Qﬁaé? @5555 fa" fhe é€s';s:'E§" $3' 35;}; "Sf V pr:3;,;9?e.§*i;:w (K) {5} (52?) 5??) 46 arsg £0:':';§:";'seQ' 5:? me :;cf7eme ans' ffze ae'"2!a;*§ez:=';s:'2i sf' sxésffssg ;:)5ri<s; gfa;/;'z2g7.._ {£8553} Gpzer: §paCe§ and agpraaches; ' Effie gravfsiaz? Q?' saséifary arrar?ge:;*?_;é:?vtS».. L' reqzsired far the area cQ;f;fzpr;'se::'2'":"r2._'§'7e-.

girfveme, inciuding ihe §§§;3sé;*:za-«£;'o-2:» .a__";::_.§ " ' ' . er prevestfez? of aﬁyé. ;'_"fr;=j:.ir;,<'_ . ' Corztamfnafiarz £5 rivers an aiher $Q££f"C€S aged :"2'?E§i'§S sf w§§éf§$:gpp!y; V T' the pm vfsiar? ,.Qf §C¢:3m}%"2.¢:?23;tiGr; " ?)§3v§7. aﬁy 55535 af §r:hab.;jf3;.r;:s'; " "

€338 advance Q.f..%?:@n*g;5 ..»f0;?"vff?fe' i;:':Jr,a0ses 0:' €b;e4:::;;f;-emég; ' ' am faafiitfes far __;Qi?'§r}é':;:*s{§§ t:%:§_r; ézéé . ﬁffgggigpsrz; {3} the s:'e*'§:1§;::*§@;§"*V::§f*...§:s;:!? infaiimafzcré 35%? *3zE'sé§5t£::s'3fs. :*':"?.;:_'§}". 53$ ;3e:'e5s§;*y far the ,aE.a:.ii§5;§es ,@f.:fs"zi§ .;ﬁ§:';

__l3':*::;5 oéféaf .... _'z§?§:"ésr far gﬁgiyfg , £5"; éfzg §,g;i3§::%§§:? Qf ﬁve S3553 §@v€r;"2mes"::, 5': 5'5 "v..SA'§'@Qf§§!?§ :9 make ,sra;»';'s!ss':2 wééh 9 arfgzas 1 "'v§i:..v';3;f§;«fv§§e s'?as,s§s'z?g §€§s;3*%;2::<3G'§§:;'@;? gag' §."Q5 §5:"_".?é imgmasememf 0;" §§%;'€f§,Q!?'?€f?f' Q? »..gs2';,:"'3i*e§ Camprised gr: we ggbsrae @r " _ f§§'E€ g€;?s§r§§ afficisncgf sf {ﬁe sahemé, ;§f$§3§'§§'§§f§ @533' s§:é§§':§§s§§:';% 3? fgaé £25' ..._"'"§:§;§::§i V ' *- _ "=.§é¥e§§§s§§§:*§:"

§2§:,.:3§;:§ §r'9§§*§§3m?§ gas?

pmgfgmmgf gisﬁgai esi:abf§shm§;1t s<:i2ed:siez= {2} §€fG!'§ She firgf dgy Qf Eegembsr is; gacf; year; 52$ ﬁaard 5355! g;f§;::;§;;_*§V._ 3329' forward --~ {E} 5 §rQgr§mma,. -

{ii} 3 budget far £2578 55:?) a scfzedufe G2' i'ii*=.s""s»t3ff c:f53ff;':,=3r§§ aﬁd servants already empiejged 'a:2::5 fa} be empiayeif €T5.€}i*"§§"'E§ .:*f"3'é' §2je)§i*.._;zear,V""f0:i'V the State §Q%fSf§?f?7T?f§!?Ai'§i? :§L;i€;'": 2f%:2;*:*:<: as may be gsrescribed. T ~ "

{2} The ,::as*'o§§i5¥;';?*2;*;??_e .:§§;5§E!'?€9;:}'2'fa;s'r:._-K (3) 1:§:,:Cﬁ_!'_?;_p3f!:i<::fiér$"'af ';é?é'a;si:7g 5cf?eme5, famsi» ._ :f§véi5}p{r:ez':.? SC'f'"§€:"§"?€S and £55323' ,='3eu55r?QvL'v:3::i;éz3:@s "~:»:{?:fc$": {ﬁe Beard prapases 52:23 e':<§eC;1:fé~,:¢:.'§7e!:f?e;f" 5:2 gaff 0;' whefe égriﬁg i'§?€ af§€X§' }fE?§§'ﬁ3.Z§ 33.8? be Qf'€SC'fZ558§;

{:2}. the Vgsgarifwfgarg 9%' sny L£:'?(;5Effa!<f:"Ti§ w.?:r:'C§7 '§f2§ Sgamf §,§;i°"éi};';9G;§€S :3 Gf"§?§§"?iZE $3" exeazfe .. _ §:;;'<€s;g"':é:€ nexi" year far thé pzgsgacsg er' {the ';:3_z*::3§:;:é:L»:%;';:%g.;* (3? bigfiaifgzg maierfafs; arsﬂ {':§~ _%:':;:'f? @5536? f;?§if§'§€i,i§§fS as mg; ﬁe ;i3;*:?.$€r§@ee:;2 V *g.'3} The §£,§:i§Q€§f sfsgff 5§;':§°a£s2 3 sigigmasgf égﬁéékéfng 5325 egéémaésaj' regeégég £526 §§€;i}§§?{,3'§i§,§i'€ 3::

~ "':;*3;'§if§§ £329' i"§if€'f"?£§€ §i:"CQ££§'E§S 5&5" 35:28 nexé y§§::§, 48 ~x \

1.Sa1n£:t§s:2' £9 gragrazajme, age! _ 'establishment schesluiaw _ Thgé? _ f_: V' V» G@--vemmer.=:' ms;/1san::t;':3n tf2 e_ »»»» H§;*ag;°2a:;::éf:§-é,_""'w.fS*:§ _ ﬁzzdget a;f;%c? the schedule af z'he';__5taff ;;~f'Qf}€?';*erS'I: 7 I servants fafmzardad {Cr it with _s::ci§'«.:1_ék:2cfi:'§C;a§?:%7£2§?s" "as'1;.:'i*' H deems 5:; ' U F "'§ _\\-~'.\z~z~z~$\_ 3»:3§&\§.§.3§\3\\\3\\\x\\§\ iixw psmsh Ik . ~ I. . % H sazzcfimzed Sectiaz?

s.c;b;%nf£*-- :2' sgiﬁﬁfementafy 1» as M'a.a§?a5'?f£&i3a£.% fS3€f?2%6_f@Tf::ia % tr?-§ ffég §z"§gr3mr?2e ganiréiarseg' by we Séaife G0 vemmemé, Prozsideﬁ {£255 {:3 Saab varzsfian shafi $8 '%2i§a;ﬁ€V.:Ef 35- ' f}"??a'Gf'£€S 3:2 expendfézjre En €,><'€'§S.S"'£3f..§V€E§4}'?i";;g%"£;F'é'§" §i'€f§'f Qf {he amaamé as G€ig;'na!iy "5ar:'::;é:>n;3»:f f50':' §f!:.g.§'*1.j_' gxecaifas? sf any Fvgasgfng ssfjzéme a'eve!Q§ms:2€ scheme §:';:iLzdeuc:2"»..{§é' §a2§£7V"pré'g;9'5rEz;33€ Gr gffgcfg its sceﬁg Gr ,3u:i;:%.;_ose,.~*V""" * Section 24,: San.gfiQne5-Q schemes and iand deyéfsggémént%scf?1é2é§éS'VtQ.fbe executeds {E} Affer zfzé E::ss~;§ sangtzaneci Sﬁd 'subf£she:5:*'**'Ti?.;§'i§S:f*§€::é§ *f§e é;er;<2.,r;%e;:!: under Secﬁans 23 33:99:22; 'sgbjeaé :23 the ;:3r@:z;'§;'a:3s as' 5ec€§é:2. '33; exacagre She izgusiﬁg S:"§'?€?7_;'§{3, _f§;?;:§ s;:' e:s;a%;'a,¢:"z?é:?:° schsme Gr Egégssr baggéag 'V V' ":4.€"f?:+§§f§8i,.A§fT?§i:'¥;§C?§§ E:?"'i'?:'€ §:'@g;*a;;%":;::';e£ 252,} "?§f"::§_ Sgésérﬁ $525255 rzgi" 32355553 3523;; %§§z:§;':§§ sgfée-:;?s,v_.g'g3§%€§ Qevgfagmersi' saheme $5" §§;'::§:;;" f}§£.i§§§'?§ *3::f3e§??é:vv;:;~?§e3§ 3528 33:36 IE5 bags: S§§Cf§$§?€§ 33;' me »E§§:a1£ié?».§9 %"€§"§?fE'?€§? :1 55 Sectfarz 32" Schemes 8£?ff§.f§€'€é £3 Bsgrééy Gaverrzmeni} star {1} "E325 pm:.»":'3z'9:?s $2' 5e_e::§:I_V'-353-..v 18 is .24 {bar}? frsdgggivej shah' rzgz' be appéfiééiévi-«$4 any ﬁwsiﬁg scheme, Eaad deve!0pmenf...s{§E?.§n§é Qf Iabaagr bagging SCi?€f'}'?€ entr:1s€e§§'fé"t§';e; _"::.;,_; ffgie State Sszzemmergz' except {'0 .§a:C?%Q;e>:<*A§ifé§ét *s::b]'é§;?;'z*_.A VV"

ta saicff: maciiﬁcaéions as 2:f2é}<'._be ::ge{:.€ﬁec2*"'5.§::v--VV.5:§y genera! gr specs??? arder :}Si'a€e G9:xerrsmen:, 35:36 e:.;?"g.§--ry sggs.-:f;*«..V_ »¢'r"s::ie:' giaraif be pubfishea' 5;'; éfge afﬁcfai G.::9§2'1Vef5€fé.f'V {2} Notwfthétaézfgfgg 3n}s§:i:j§§j;':é;'§tfa's'%}e::;f in frhis Act; the Beard b:e?"::f_0.éﬁpefé§nVf :9 Carry an any €r5di:2g: éé9VTfi:*;;;§;7_Cf:%§:"V f§§'%"jj}'off:, whether 5? the e;<5C:z:.zési§ "' Qf §j§?§€!"f§i{'8i? by, gr eﬁfragsiea' 29.4 _E:;,_ Q?' . Q§7_§'ry§:§:;e, P§*sL&€e: fa §£§§'€'§?8S& gr ieasse by V..;22gs¥§es§;29v2.§;:¥;-a) ?"Zé'?e Segre' may Eﬂfﬁf ;';"2:"§ an §g;«~:fe.1::>s*:'3a::>§%;;%4'."%;/;éi'i?f? easy §¢§r;9iQz2 far f.5F§ §€§}'ii§S§€f§§? frzjm V . §?§m "si3y=--T§:;';':?f25se,, !éa§§ as' 8Xe;Z;"§§f?§§, 3%" §f?fy" iaaé .£::=":?§ea'€cf E3? the gawgésgg Q? 3 fsggggiag A ;é:i;:§:=sé>,;_:?!s gr f§i?§ §e*:e'ef§;2:2?e§"2: .E2€f"§€§'§'§€ $5 55?}: §§'§i'€5"€S§7 .. f§': §§é£:'f?'i 3335 G!" far s:,z::mpe=:2sa£:';':§ §:§?§ QWf'?€*§"S $5 53%;; 53 3535!? right is resggcf sf any afe;>r!:z§€;"Q:*? :'f?sr&@f...§r fﬁésrferénae :"f"E€f§WE€f?:

Pmvféed that the previagss aggravgi af GO:/'€i'!'?:'7'E€_§?Z' ghali be §béa;'r:ed £r;:::~a::e $5 p:_3;9:'§%.;2sV1eLsv::: éxchange invefviség ié33"?C?' wasfb :2*;:§rs:_":}fg;?TT»:::;:"§ée55' %'%er".?"~I.' fakhs as" 58858 for mere §f?a:3';i€_:;e }/§:23,;i§;. {2} The B§am' may 5533 V: ':'a!<ie_. stéfgas-_.f9;§' the gamgufgory acqaisifiairi-V{2Tf_ 3:fE;é%j;?3"i2::§j any faterssé {herein regzzfred fo:f_.i'§.2:é; :=.€;%%€&(L?;!§.i;f}fE}VA":;:2§*C " 3 itvsuging gcheme Q1" !a;*:_;='a"'giézgefbgzﬁehé"s§fAzé:*2:ée.5Er; She manger gmvided :13 ":§*5i§€3'--.iT'j'.-3éV£:'é'§é:-é§S%;ffg'<;sE A5: 2894, 35 msdiﬁeé' 5{fVs:% ':?§:;e"2:v;:;;;z;i.§it£Grs sf any iarsd Gr a;2y:'.§;3§e:%;"e:Sf'V'§'S?ér%e§é*?%*--[:f:;:* ffée g;C?i.i:'"_,Q§SSS sf tffsfs AC: sﬁzsii ﬁe" . :'i:«;é4 .5§gé::§5§t!@;? 2%? 5 Qgbzfc g:>ur;3:%5a:? _m':f%§;<: "zf§;ré ;%2'.»§a}3§;2g af ff?€ i§!?§ ,£:cg:.;§§i§§§2;? M " ~';§sf,%-4[;:M'8§:s::, Ah """

:5';'EESRE_'§'§'é.V_Z*§::§:%;§§'€§'¥'?€?'E*i§Q§"i€d §§'Q¥§S§§§"E$§ %: $3 ﬂags" 'aha:

~«.T.%j'i§.-é,g'é:i'2§ Gu':#»; i~:.i:§ 22:23 %é@g§§§§:g Bsaré $3 %.§§'Ef:§%?'E&§£% ézgaggirzg ".. '*§:§*:ge:§:':§V$,_3:35} iézea E5526 §fev§§@m*2e§2:: §<:§':§me§§ The ﬁsugimg E';%3:'§:'{j_.«:*ia:: framg grid gxgtigig §%:§ gwn hQ1..§S§§'§§ S{Z%"%€E§?§€$ am «aw sf' 8 'W 52 éarzsrj deazelegmeni SC§"E€§'°ﬁ€S Gr it may exacazte gay ;3r:;_jec:

gairusied :3 it by the §iate C3Qii€§"?'s§"E":§ﬁ§. $€€§§@ﬁ 1? cf 'me KHB Act: C§a¥'_'_§ﬁ.;€»fS E§}§:'§"{§'1.:E';':.§;§'§§E':;§§§7£.°E" Beam may incur expendétggre am uE:.§&e:§ta~§{e%s;§~rkg A§:?'*--a.§%;sj ages fm' framiszg and e><e€ut§e:*é._ Q"f»..V_suéh' §fz<;~:;sfé:z_g"~. SC§1&'%1"2es " ' gnd iarzd deveiepment V,s.§henf;€*3R " aS'~-.__§: 5:33;. .-ésyésider §%§C€§§3§"\; ffam iémé ﬁg that any prajest entrugted §e :§ _-bx,' &§SG may be execateé. that the §~=EeL:s§ng Beard wéié itg QWB housing S£§'§E§T§€ Q? me: aisg 8X€€i§'i§ the gmjegt er';f;m§€:e<;'i"a:::,%g §i"by tE':€z'Sé:5':e Gsveramerig %'$é::%§a:r}as:%'%:8:§:+;@ 18% SEC iﬁg EH3 £3: giémzéatg Ehs :i '*»..<::§€%a§Es"%:__§% b;% "'§;.;3%€§%%Ed $2 hmjséag gcheme gag Earsé "-- é5:§}'E7:'%:?5€'§'»%fZ¥§§"§"%€_§;§?: _§<~i~¢%*:§:"'ae5 ..«"'"

S3 S€C§§Q%'E 1% ::::f éghe KHB ACE staieg $75: tbs ggard 'ghaii prepgs am fmaééze 3 musing grggsamms a::a:_:"'-.:'%_§2.nEii_ €§8':fE3GQF}'E€ﬁ'{ pregramme amuaéiyg The " shaié a§§s ;3r§pare a budge: and eS5%éb'§'éshr::es:f '$:%;héé.Qié*- §nnuaHy§ SECUOS 28 Q? the K58 §g:.i:--VVV:A's€f_a":s3_s 1.:'7E':"af:___th%,§ State {3Q\/'E§"'E3§TiEi"§§ may sanctéeig'fifié'L.§.§%%;vgré%%;An%$,V budge': and schedule f0rward§.§..@::. s:;;:<£.E;;:.._Vrhczﬁvévfications ag it deems ﬁt;

$e:',tE@:f: 213? {$9313 with the gubiécatian sf $a§2€ic%sa2eé pr§§':,;r4Ea5%::f2:"r2é.§ " . t%:v§Wi{%~§§ ﬁg: digéagég 37%: the Saagé mg? e.§:"-3_:'s.g;"'::§*;;§ Vé;%e:§'%3x §s':§; §§"@g%'a:':%,§":%§ $3 am gas? thaws? '7 _E:?"i€Z*~:vi.%§€d '§§"%'* :i.§'3'§E' ; Qyagramma by ihe Eiate G@¥$fﬁm%§E§ ,:*~sé:::i,js3£?é;'%.:§ €§%'"i§§f% §X€$§®E§®mS5 ﬁaftﬁ' ihs i'"1§iiS§E"1§ S€§"2€%"'i'E€ ' V_'j~a;§*:€§~' 'tiexzeiggmeni §€!:em§S aw 85¥"':€§E%§"%S§ $3! 'ﬁg Siaéé §é::§:°r::'r:%z%: i,E%'§§%§" the grgazégimg sf §e::'£§Q:":§ 2%} agzﬁf 21 sf E4 339 KHE ﬁat, iiée éﬁwséﬁg gaasﬁ sézaii gmséeé EC: exe-sjsyze '$29 émusirzg saﬁemef iarzaﬁ éeveiepmeni Scheme;

musing schgme Enciuded in the gmgramme :.:n:':':4.;i~'=*._,:':**vSei<':7E§ QT:'*:"'_4' 24 G1: the KHB Act The pravésimés af SeC€ien§ §"fV..V_t§ 2'11§;f i&%:_éA'7._§}<Zi-£3*'}%s<:': * L' make if: gima fade c%ea;f----_§;ha€: V-:~§;§é"_ .H"@g;$E;;:§'*3.::2a--;€é ghaii §><e:ut€ Qniy ifﬁe ihﬁ Staie Gavernmemt. scheme is sgrsctéaned by Hsusmg Beard cannot execgéte":h§Lv5»sChé.§'f':g;'»._ ' Eecﬁw <::f ﬁg? dsag with safzeme e§2::2;fs:§:§ 5¥%;§__ i?%§ Bféﬁfzé .... .é:::y ihg Séaie §G¥'E§"%'§%'§'§€§'§3§., "ﬁe g:*::€:=%:g%<;3:§";i:§';*:.:**%§é'%é§*- :,::':§§2' $§:f;"£§§%} 32 a? :he Kéég Act $3 :T "§?f£€§'{§§;T§ '€Q Eeéﬁééﬁiés E18 Ea 2% 3? mg KHE ﬁat S§C§§§§'E 32 %<Z%%%"§%§i': mgkeg E? gmgéy C§§§§' iha: the §§"$'~é'§S§§§'%§ G? .J'¥i_8_:u.--'m 2% $5 iifée ﬁg: %:%§*{§'2 §§"%{i§ij§§':iE:l shgi mi; ha :::;f:}};;§V§a:a.éEe is 5&3;

§"2§:,2§é§:§ §C?§E??'%€; éaﬁﬁ dgveézggrnént gaizeme gr' éabgur imaging scheme eairzsgied :3 {he S-tigarﬁ by the State GQ'\,r'€i'ﬂ§'E§"§"1€E"':§.2 Whégh m%aras, if the entmgieé is the Beard by the State G@ve'§?%§:rr;;eiT:::{iL"'"fe:2%? ' execgtéoséf then the pmvésisng 9? Se§:f:A§A»VGb§':S5' .333; 251:; KHB éci §'eiai:Eng ﬁg ssheme are gist:4a--g;Vpé.%<:ab%é-;.L 3;n"

wﬁrdg, the framéség am f§§2a%izéngv"LZi%1_'e%' S<:he'me_"':;T:' gefzjsgect of ma grajectg eatmwsted b3:'A---. §%1;e5_:Sta.§é"~.._§§x;tgrnme:€: is Ehg Heusmg Beard fer e><e3suti§v:1V,~«§.§3j*::0t.;j*;ec'éssV§'%y."' The c©m§éin§§; 'V"§5;--.s':.:'%§é'gé:'zé§;>{:us;,_ and harmamaass seading Q2' E3Véc:§:c":2§§»V_:? :i::£§ 2é«..§r:d §Vé<;::Vtio:': 32 3f the KHB Ad makes ii £Eea§'§j:¥sa_:: tE:;e5'%%i<?;:'3-%._%ég« Bﬁarﬁ Cﬁiliféﬁt QS aheaé with the €XE€£i:§=:3§"E Q%C i%g'sé%§"u$§'Vé:g.$C§3em5 €§f%£§§'xf€@ 553$ fsrmeé ﬁézétg sénams $3 §a:a§i%@§3§d Q!' ég apprgxgéé ﬁéé._$T:.§ié"G';.3a.:5eé;:*2§*é@&:":%:s $52 ifhe {.15iZ§":%?" §'°:a§2d,. if the ;;€}§"Qj%£§ "".'j~:'?Q:*'§"%:ai"§§@:é am fémaiézéag Em 7?',§§ t§":§;% '§1ia*:V;e 'f§§2;§*:'§r::§:7*l: is €€:%:":,;si:§@ by Eéze Eiaié .1 -iT%Vi@2:5§.§'§'::":Q---3?}:Ea Ema §"'%G%.jS§§'%§ 83556 far" €}{8§:§§"§§§'E ; iéﬁéré tie Sﬁhémé §;.:s§fe:'e sagh "-%i%§§"£§'7%§Si§?1€§ﬂ§{: aszd §><€€é,%§E§f§ i3 ma: §"%E?'C€§§&§'y":

eeeee:.e"J'.._g:eee'_~vv..__eet" teeett eeee§eeteeet et teeﬁ eee 3% §eet§ee 33(2) ef the Ktte eat deeés with the $Qté£f:?§__§" ef ttte Heueieg Beete te eeteheee er ﬁeeee by egteem.eattt; Seetiee 33(2) ef the KHB Aet e_meewet'e"t*e'e_~.;%%'e1.,§e.t:";gi eeate te take etees, it steed be, fer e.Qrt:'_eee'%'eetee;"e_§iqLi'E§i't§et,z_: et any Eeed or aey interest ttterei.2j"";=.equiAred §ert'exe__C'e~tE.ee Q!' = L' the tzeesteg scheme er Eveed c§ee~efe§_;"3rr:~~e{zt seeeme Ee the meeeer as erevidee eedet' %;'»iC¥E"§§g eeiese the tend cetmet be executed scheme at Eaee eeveiepmetfttt ttetetvte be acquéreeg which tteettee tt2atRA'"t%}:e fer' exeeetiee ef tee ttetteteg et:'§iet;ee"4'ée-ivtes'eee':;tt:e the Eands Witheet the Eeee; tee §fiee_ete§"1e€:§§':e_me eeeeet be %X€€i,»E:§y:e{:%9 Exeeettee ex? A 7?'_et%e:t:et:t§ee eff ettee eetgz, Exeeutiee ea' eeheete eteeeeeeeee 4:*~tté'e"..jte>é§et-eeee ef feit tteegee eatttetfee wttiett te eeeetteeee. ué;~'tt8 et KHB eat meetteee ee te eseet eye te ee .p,gif'é:;~e::dec§ by the tteeeiee eeheree; The Eeheree ghee eteeiee M?

w ihe Qarticaﬁars ;*e§a%§:':g i§ gaquigéiim <32? Eassdg aiscu Se_§:__%:ég:3 :8(a} ef K?-£8 Em: sieaﬁy maadategthat the asquisétiea ahaii aisa be agecifiedg Scheme"-«.§a::j;'2~9Vf acecuted anéesg the same £3 sa:*':<?;'tEAé§'é'le'd4. iigy-:'%_<Fjé«_VSt'aV*:e;".

Hence there cams: be &CC}LiiS§?:V§§7§i} Q?'gaéégzeyty 2;%s,;§i;E:s:i;éat'.€E':e"F.L scheme és Sremreé and sa'}é%'s:Vtéi'§n§d State Gavemmeni: ag per Sectio':%$"':2§ Thus, far executioa Q? the? vsch:em é5. rsecessary. ﬁectéan 33(2) gs}? :%L;§'_%:Vv%9:"V.€§:V%':""*s;:§ecifies tha: fer executioﬁ iand has :3 be aiquéred §n: '-.';h£=;" E3: the p:'Qx:%$§Q:':§V Q? seams 4(1) mr Q5 :§';.%é§*.:hé_".A;A mt §":é' : af§§igm&ni%m§d §%"%\f§$i{';%§S gf 3% E668 fag:

:'::a%<:é"%:%*ea:' §:§"i§§'E gmuié S5 §:'€§a:§€;%@5: §?ii'§ i:'_.f§n§Ei:aiéé'§% 'si;f"i'§7§ %:§::,:s%::g ggheme aracé gagah §"§§Li$§§"'§§ 41-§C'§%gLm%*§2_§ Eaéaé £§%.='€§§§§'Z"18i'E§ ggézemé %.f€§§%£?'E as ﬁnaéézga by Sigig Gsyemmésig gray wiié %:a:;% :3 *§§ Elzéﬁijiftéﬁg "*-i:ii:§%2;.:ex!er,, mg £?>'{C€§iCI§S§"'E '%;_:@ E§?§ gm wig ég {he ﬁﬁﬁéeciﬁ S5 V ihe"Sta»t"e £3§¥_er:2m'ent eﬁtméted by it :3 the ,i~--:eLss%:':g 8.5:,-*.x§:'*§_,' ' _"{h}e 'sreparatim 'iaxzd f§:"2a'£§i'za;t%--::2'2 3.fé%2ei 3cﬁ--e'--m'a és . . Ha:wev.er, the f£na%iz--ai:%ar; <3? we sfc%:e:f%3'eV»"§$':t;::i:é:

' E;a.'s3a::;i;%%:'3--t§;j§k spetific ' f;3r5az--isi*Q'r; ta? 3 the ages: my :5 mt mssary.

_§:%_§a ;mL%r 52$ %k;%§:skes:§%¢:2% éf {éaiﬁh grsviséea in tke' T§ ;f§;:§=§_ in raspeéi cf -{fie pryajeat, whim is ésateived M respect 03' the £3?-Gjeﬁtg wh'i_%:h' é$,_4_csn4:--a_§§:e=d" Gswtnment am entrz.':.s'--te d by it é':;ar_d fssﬁ EXE CL¥ti§:§"} Q A¥=m;z3st:. the Séivfifééi as ip%:i%§v§s%§i:-as :§%%%;;s, ' in the Ta miii M M ";a.:*a'r_§§ is 5% ?V'!0HAMME9 YGEESEF AND QTHERS reeereee %eV.--AER 1992 SC 132?; which reed thus:

"' 6. xxx xxx We have a:%eseifgi....e_>_<ere_--%;§':'?ei,§--:'?;hVe= eetise Ac: wéth the eesis:ence=___of-~§§i~e"'*eeEee.f'eee'if-.,,__ ceunseé fer the parties eegj irﬂeer v§es;;*...:'he cententiee en behaif of the f'e.e'peederzEe"eié2i:tt§f;VeVV' proceeding fer acquiring §ae;d"':e'V§i-- ﬁee._eemé*eeee'ee eniy after the seheexe "Eire§:fs_éﬁ}ie"'%:'e.§»§V'{bendedg 1 As heeeeen :;g:a té.d e.er §.:je::_ _§ih apter v::

eenteieing the ﬂaming ef ihe ;SC§'f$V€fFTf}€§:';"V._'_ " dawn separate ereeede res . I typee ef schemes;

eceerein g:VVV_:eee€:e'e.éA%3:%}{§;g'Qi""eeétabééétyg Seme ef the sefgeeaee _d*e~.e'e'€ ':'e':;'e%re eeeeieétiee e?' ieeﬁ; ﬁe; ,%:ewe':re«.§;...«eseeetéeé fer eeneireefeeg ¥?;$?'%€.T§_;ej§';tf%~§ '%.:se"é§;e§ege eeeer iee eeeeéng scheme:

See[§:_e«eV"' iiee eeé, §:EEﬁ:#%f®§ﬂ€;: eméfe . ﬂ eee§'%f:ere:§:§;i~"§;§:e meiiese ﬁe be ezeieeed in the 7-~. 'eehemeaeeeeeéfieeéiy eeeeiieee eeeeéeéeee ef ieee '*«Eé:.Ve§7ei;.:ee {e}: if {he eeeeéeétéee ée eeeieezeieéee e' eeejee: matte: ef ewe eeheme éteeéﬁ ii:

5% feiiezes ihei if meet azsveii ihe preeeretien ef' the.--__ seheme %xvhe?e%m ii: wiii be Eecfgidee, The act requires the gregased echeﬁgie be pubiéshed permitting ebjectEQr:'s»«.te Eye and if they are feumd te be va§id;':4Am:.,'§fe{' 3153', gcheme {Q be mediﬁed er-.._ebee:i;e%:e;d§:' "'i>fu.E3_§ secfgien {1} ef 8,49 eérecte t§éV"eV..:;Viet_§Ce Ve'E.::_§1ee':dEef'E heeséeg scheme te."'~§ﬁCEu_::§e""e'{';:§V'*"e'-specie)" the feféewieg inferreeiiéen ee_e_ce'r:-%%:e'%§1e§eev§%.:f;»..{;"%e;.2Se {£3} fer the purpese_'ef__ §u%3'E'§é'a*tE§;*r:"efr?:i évefgﬁhatien te the genera? ., 2' V V '" 'V ""(eeb~§*~et?3e'g§§éee=er§E--a:es"*e%;-- aéshich eeftécuiars ef zhe evehereegiv:53-aféaeé"e§"§i«%1e agree; aed deteiés ef the iaeﬁegééich 'iii i"e."e'a.;%.*:i~,'"eS;ee {G e: ﬂuke eee ef the §;;~ed_ énkegeerﬁ §:z3 iA;hi£h ii is ﬁreﬁeseé ie ' "@iece§.2e:':,._«-Le V-,.eei:Ee:*'e*:'e::%: fee, may be seen et ~ :**e.e Se 5; iﬁe %<'§é;,: re T?3e'--.a;eev§e:?%::§i'eAé 1r'*éO;f§S ebeve yeeffifm tee esétiee '-..._'5:%°2e: She' ea geeéiéee 9? %;he me bee ﬁe ee e ere A e.I:_;.§:'::'e. eeheme, weéeiz cee be exeeeied eeé efter «f[.--§:;_f§%ée%%:ei§eeQ xxx xxx {emehesie eeeeﬁeeﬁ $Es?bS€qL§€f'§§§§f; ifée épex Cgagﬂ: Er: Eng matte? Q?' Sgtfafe sf ?'3m§'£ £35365; 8: G{'§?€f'S £13., £,Krish:*:a:2 & reparfed in AIR 1996 SC 497 inzergreteé thé:_?§rc:¥%:EV§§é3E%é_4' «:3? Taméé Psadzs HQLESEGQ Bsaré Act; iijéi '§a?'sz=:i judgment in ihe casa @f A. MQHAIWISQEB SUQF3 am abgervéd th:,is:~ "Far 3;'; she abmze ré5sa§';§{."i'v};e ﬁ:2c%V§:'.,a';'ff?c:zi{* 50 read {he hQ_!dingA.f:2. §~i!ai3.a:';f2i7"2'£--:2a'"~2%%§rz;;isef as saying 333:, 5:; 'n0 ea;/e;%i;=£' -,:'§a:*;'V._V:%'zé%~ 'fa:3d be accguirea' fcaff 555% pizrpiose 3:25ff7é"""Act/Board zmfess a =i$ﬁFna:f*~.;3'r§:%..effej€t}":/é:_sébeme is framed by fi';e__;{ife:;si1:g:.,Boa;f:2'_i;é:3z:ie;f {ﬁe provisions 0:' Secf§§:{?s"3;?.i:fo 51:3; _}*"}':?. e sagﬁffmftation a fies @521' Sahara .:h:»'j"-53%""£§";::a:::a!'2:' :0 be ac aired 5va:4ze:ﬁ!V *far' .siff:ég:3;a';~:%_"'a':>.<:?e sf execgztieg? 9? a hﬁssiﬁ "%;;'s.:*.f:f2'2 'ravsmefnt schémé re greé B f§7»*e§-giaggsiré' 5'G3i'd '§,!i".?Gf€§" Chg :'e;*-VIE Q!' the "'F3z":~i%ifv__£'€3Vda; %%';3ssgi:3 8§ar::f Act, In eifser :fyaéL:":f§;' ':;:fés'e§s She :'?Qf'ffiC§ffGf? zgrgsigs" Secfiag": 4 ' sf" *V:?€:ev.._;!;%.a:;*2§f' :%C§£.§fS§§§§§? 535:' sxpregsiy siafes ifzaéjé. £§v:'3'1<;:?v,_;>:f;{;;:3'}:%§£G' :25: be &€Q§é£§s""€<j is £"§Q§.§ff"'EC5 fQ;_*' 8X§§:;I2fs';*§§ 5 haasgfrsg as" §s'??pf§%f€§'??§§?f . §a:§;e:r;g §';";'e,,, g fisgaf gag' sffecééye SCf'?€f%'?€§ :'}"§;'2/:ré-:r<:2"i~ ﬁg ésée ﬁazggisg Egazg' gs;/?:2'er {ﬁe g:;T<3;i§s:"i:®;?s $2" éhg ?"3:*:2if E':£§d:,; éiaugiﬁg 593;?

" £533 g2r;'s?§§§:€ §;*':c::f rafria as' fvfQf:§5??me:'5 'ifaazsef £5 £9: §ff'f"§€§€§, Merg Si'3§."€é"?'%§??§° is? {ﬁe ...,r§§i';'i"E<:a§§@;? £255' Easisa' 53 regajiregi far {he §E.£5j§Q;§€ Q? 532% §~§§z::5§;2§ gﬁﬁfﬁ ':é;@::faF f?Gi' by ifsaif' 'a£"t;:ac:i< the said primzfpfe. am' testis, in

-2:*i3e__ iﬁﬁéant sgaaeaisf $32.3. ;3atiﬁ'cat§an$ Q23 n::z_it, * -. agar: 1:S£a:'._"e ma: Z:??€' faﬁd' graposed" ts _ "

ﬂagging Baas" ; "' _ .

(emphasis sumf§ed2%% " % 3:.-:;::ra' e§<};§3i;a~iiré~S§:§'ze 3;.;dg'm--erét_ in *i%%Ai:>@< Gear?

' j '§.: , * gzvmt if: LM¢hs;mn§ed 'acqziffes' is mew: fer {ﬁe gzurgscsé §f?_._*f2é':

1'%;h::2_ '§':s§I'g=:31:e"'::t _%n the cassiof 1992 f§;1a£iza:-im sf id ' the ..

*'%m~ Chagter 4:: 0? {he Tsméi Nada: ﬂessging Bsaré ACE. V.--2%: £3 fagrthgr ebsérveé therein ihai zméesg 'zhs Eané §s§.;2";SVé7e§5i*.T.%:;s be acquired E3 E9? executing a bagging er' §:"::g;{'rC:'{§<.3;:x2';é:T:i;u'_"T scheme framed by the Heuséng Baargi :,:é'é{§e.s*'Vt_h{2' -;3 _:"::syi.g'§"e>"r:s"'« af ?am%£ Nada; %~%a:,:sEng Beard A§£:,._'§he4'g3:€§"2Vs:§p§e[,'a;.:2é'ré§é"€} €:f '= Mghammed Yezsgef is as: a:t§'ac:e§';=.:_ _ E In thé matter an h$4'h%§_'a§s;>;:"V::s4:%?§'§%§v%§._sntianed; the Eéauséng Beard viz; ﬁrstiy executim sf itg hes; the housing and Heasérzg Baard, seaeaéiyg €><v'é?£j £:i'?;§QVT'i' fwgzseﬁ am §{2§i"i.,i§§€§ by $36 Statéi{3r3ye4§;%:a;2§:zi'§ EV§ .'a:%:e %am :3 b9 gaqasiyefg E3 a£z:;V:své:;%E.§zVL" féf' %i:%°%.$ garage as' execagiém sf hsagséng §ch@r§%$§;".§;:.:::§T"";§g::.é%::%;g§*:3%:':i:§ gﬁrzamég C§§'E€:%E%%g'€@ by é:%*:e 41§*§QL:si§"%g {:i7':éaav%'i@; 'r:::':%'1§:; Eizera §TZ§"i§ §%:*:a§ arid effes:::%v§ Sghame E3 .: 'E2':-.§§$é Q? the §€qL§%3i:§e?2 :2? 2% §3§"§d $3: we %-éauségzg

- '_Eg§_a«;r*--:;t§ 'f§% the Qazsgass $2' §E'€E§§§f'§'1€§':E§E§§ ihg §m}j§€i :fL'*--V{;A§5§5;s;;e:'§ir§§ by the §i§§€ G€?}Ef§¥'{é§§;'§€E"%f:, {hag the €f§a$Eiva am 64 fmai hauséizg sahamg ES mi aacesgary is View ef §p;.é3.:%fEc gérgvisisa 5°: $23': regard Le, Sec€%§r:~32 9*? me Having regard is £325 eatire s<:he,;:25e Qf_.%:'?é"ej*~§%:$.E:*:a:'3k{3 Heuging Board Act: ésé generai and h@§no§§'e:*séeE.;;.s":'éadVi;§é"g_5fj Se€:§Qn$ 1? {<3 24 afw Sectéang 32_ 'a:"_;d 33 §_r1V;::>xa:'§=:;EC':;§'f';a:r; E? $3 " V ﬂea? that the gffeciiazé a:'§d,.. finai a§.;QE'GV€§ arsd S8§'Z€:§§G§°E€@ by {he 3, very i'T'z§i{:§'E §€CESS8i'fg' fgr %nj;gé: e;;':§*:e:::§_§A§;§LG_Q'_:'V:¢su:§:?;]j_~.pv:%g:§:;éme$,r's::hemeS Canceéved am V":j'H:%§L:'3§ng Board. The 3€QUi5§t§9f'? reveai that Eands ﬁre ;:?>;*G5Ss$edvx":§: be' {E38 ?%.3§'§§S€ sf axegagiisn :3? the hQ§.,§S§§'§f*--v§£§"":€E:?E% %:3? ':%: £é Eéaasiié Saasﬁg E: E3 §§$:3 :33? sj§:$pi;i'€€§V %'i:=*;E'3E:§%é"*~«§f%s:.és§§ég Bsard :53: the agqaigétisa Es:

mgée 5%? 35:6 §i,i:"'§QS€ Q?

"aémgéémeizéi%"";g§é><'é:z.:€%:2§ thé pr§g?5£%: f::G§'%C€§Ei€@ 333% 2% 'j§{§s"%é'V;::.:§§<:a.._§~°§§i3s%:*2§ Eggréf $33: ms: £Qi'éC€%§'2!€§ by We Stata ."."%&'®$§;§\:§"§"f~%'V§')§E§'"§ﬁ§:2;%§:2 Ea @325': 3% mg gamﬁ, ting framézegg féréaiizmg VIf-5m'»§an£§§as':§:2§ sf {E33 sghgmg $3 é gaadizisgm §i§"EC€5€§Y{ €35 E5 geing ahsaé wiifs 31% atquisitéeﬁ, Bu: iéwe re_::§rds maémiaéned by {$36 %%e:ss%r:g Beard {K} :30: am: 2g«:%e§réV:'r'é'$;:é&.§ that the musing gcheme is ﬁnaiized and sanc:i<3«'%f§:'e:§ h$;"iiﬁéj State Gevernmem: as required i,,i[':e"_.§JéA»§V' "E,§"'?._€"<.SFQX{:E"S§§}§§V§'V'VQf'. Sectéang 38 ¥:@ 24 cf ibe KHB AC::._ A §'F§C'8€dEI§§7.[?,E':F"§d€E;"i;;§§.v, Agt r/van §€CE§Gi"§ 33(2) af KHB G:'1%3;

after framing and sanctiorﬁg; Qhich the Eand is ta be a«::f.:,ui:*ed:._... cf KHB Act sarticuiariy Seci::&r;[a%:¥ 24 ciarify that ihe acquisétien lthe scheme by the Hgagsészg Baééséfd ﬁfe Sihémé framad am WEEE Start 353$'; 8f"C€§':V'§.§.4?.'% 5::E§§Zé§§§§'} "s>§ '§:%1e§':3e€ :"{@>€;_i._f%{:a¥:§§%é méder Seciiaséﬁ» 3% LA; Act, E? %g§;,s€?ii._;i';ii%§:*"v*;é~.,§%;§.§§%'§§'i%@sé Q?" 3338 gaiwgme wszgizé §% xiagzss 5' b€€".--5i,éS€ hf ::a b$'e'%2€e $1" dgtgéig raéaiéng :§ §§§'E€f'§"%€ therem .1--3V§é§;»:::$§:g.§azéégéiiy, {he gm Qazxiizerg wauia ﬁe éggrévaﬁ Q? A'- f::he«T«'--i3é'ij:e'fE% :3? fééizég §f§eC§%:ia Qbéectémg wider 3E€i§{}§'1 55% Q? 55%.; W39 5?§é.%§":??€§':i G?' 35% 8§§3varaA3 §§§§§'§§ iééaét 25$: c§'§ie?;::§%:é§v7§";%f£.s%§"§?;'é§%§§é esgeéaiéyf 5:2? i:§§"$@ﬁ§§"s§ 3% E5'; 5% exégutéon {>5 sgbeme §TE85E"%S ésxgeéoping :3? ianﬁ am fQEF""-'*'__'§§3'E§ {he giiegg cams: ée acceﬁteé' §::CQE"éE§}g :21: §'i§¥:i.'.;_5 '§§'§'§ 4:§Z§7%€.V §€ZEiLi3§ deveéepment of Eand, it Cannot be gaiéﬁ ssheme Es bewg impiementeﬁ, Ir: a:§'ées%xé:e..rd.§;-I§':e:_"s:.V;§;V§r's'§§:sV"« that tiéi the meject %'E'3€h€S the s tia_ge ofﬁéésuaé :i'«:,%'v:évE'<::'§Qrr§';e §1: sf éaads, ting Eaads %"':§€d me: be 'hvéugféjsiéssian desensag is be r$:;@CEEdz vv}éi§.__gj§;e_me v§;té;rts wéth the inétéatisn Q? {nasmuch as acquigitisn Q1" scheme as is dear fmm 5% fa) Q? %<%iB AG;

ii, 8:'; E*a;s1§%za:'a.,§'Sa<b§:rié:::.i;"'Eeamgé csamgeé 3§§%§i'§{§§ €91' KS8 ;ga:i:§:%§i§§V- §?3'§'i: {m%e3;3 {ﬁg S§ard gas §c§::.,ga% @§':.'é.§Sé§$i.Q%*: G'?' %;: §é.§ *§«§€:d, ﬁts @%€f:§C€§%'S atanmt ga ave? the gamé W) 4':s%":é~:m& "§"%::g~--f§§ '5é€::§*é§§'%g ﬁg him; it $3 whgiiy §mgra€E§:§b§e .5629?':iZ»§f7§§'*-§§§?8iiZ§§§§§% as' the gsheme bxefwe Qaéaémgg A'-';$:.;:':_s:+3 ?e§35'ia§2 3%' Em %§:'z<:3i The 53% guﬁmésgéam :::§§'§§"'1Q'E ﬁg : 5gCf€' £%§EE€§. 32% Q§'ﬁV§§§$i'"2S Q?' We §<i%~§B éaf é?

iwééiah is akin tg grexzigiaag af Ssciésn 14? 3%' Tamiémgéss Hwsimg Baayé ACE, 1951) fzsméshes § mmiwéeie this argumeni. The Sa%d provésien empswers tiié %.~i_e.;isi"n§_"'_4'T M Cammisgiener Q?' any parser: eEther:v'fgbér§'ei*a¥%~3: «:i>r. Sp_e:'§'aViIy"'. auizhsrized by him 9:' the Board in am'-sleézaza wétfsaut assistants Gr wsrkmen, er%,'9§E'e'3,r_"is':}tQ s:%~.:;;§::§i am' éandg in yder :9 make am; §r:3 §§c:E--§n!§. . fsu._r*:.zv}e*y_ iT3€3SLE!"§¥T§€f"i*i, valuatiea értquiry, is take r;7.ea,S;:.resg 3;0' §§gV;§:;:""b©re mtg ihe sub~=S0§§, {(3 set §§:':{3vnd;§%§_e§ 'anjizi;én:ési§--tjédE'i'ries ef §?Agﬁ£#§<§ etc. The East: dauvsejgf?fhé«:.;§_a§;'§.,_':'§<é3;':;At;'::*€{_gééées wide gamer {G ﬁe am; thing; a.z%;hic:.%':' §3'} a 3{"-5 ;3"pe'3r«."533E#' 'a£§'2%&x;§:':g ting paarmse Q? ihe ACE S2,:bjSC?:x1:£}_ {:%§"'ﬁa§§;27§f'é£3§9{}ﬂ§b%€ rggiréciiaaga §%:'€0ve§ Sg*::~::é;§§2~2:.§:.Q§__i K§-§_B A%:':«p.r.{2:s%ﬁes 3:': Qggortwéty ':3 the Sﬁayd ta even afté? étg Sa§'iC§i§E'%, ﬁse gaié 'i "-ps<*av%§%:>1§":,__ %ak;8,:$f"9:f_a§"e Q'? C§?"'§?;§§"Eg§%'EC§' $2? a giiasatimi zsamigh '~ %.?§:-va43,{g:"§§% ::*;._§['fA'%5;;;é::,;:'*e§, S%..§C§'E ag gvaiigbééiiy sf §€$$€%' gseaf Md Q?" iamjf §§"&§$§'§£§ af marsizy Eamj; :3?" gasaéiabiéééy §';F :3%"§.f§§:§§%?G5 fer immagz habétaiisa ac. Er; ggsch a Sitiigtéﬁﬁf 58 the Bsafd hag g::>'£ ﬁght ig msdéfy éig gariier §rGgra:f:f::.§r:s§ thszggh saactésrsedg 3:,s§}*eci is aeriaira exceptiengs Umder séméiar sétaaiigss, the Agex»QQL;:"*:§,.'E':':"'a:~§§€§,éa.sé3_:;:f' State sf' Tamil Nadu & asxothefy Yousef & atizers (cited su;§%;-fa; §'2a'gV_rs_:_EVe1d Ehe * L' natéfiaatéars under §ect§Qn Q1? the~~--§;$;L_:~A't*:LA_sté'tEn*g._.:hvv;§ pubiic puépasef if issued grim' ta wgwﬁ be vague because§:3«:T::A§:§;2se15§_gé%»cf 'tea gcheme therein and Q§A?f1€§"S wsuid be deprived @f: §§9€éV Qbjectians under Eectim Six if? 2% Said matter; ii: is hgéﬁ iCE"1%E j'§;'§'?S §¥€i'g:.§:§$v§{i§§E §$.%.§§§{Z3'C§G§§ is Qrémgture am is §§é3§9 §9 E7'e1&3;-§§«§€§§ """ is age heﬁ f§E€§"%§§'; £33: the ¢ g <;>Ke€:é%;%.g@':i.__%.%§v:"':~§}$V.Ti;'::':§z&:?;e giartg *~:%::h {$23 émigéaiémz Q?

"v?' ;2:'§:':Eed§:*é'?g3 G?' §:}7Q;!.,§§S§iEQ§'% Q5 §§i"'%§; aaqzgégéiém bsésg 5 35;':

; '§:;~<§§:;€:T§ﬂ gf sahéma Ag §f@s"es'€:§::*;%$:":e§*§ éihe gaéé ";j;.:: cz"§':2,'éé§'2§: Ei? ﬁéhsmmsﬁ 'i'§z:§§f's ﬂgge ﬁg égarzsééaeﬁ gm? 'Vff--~d§$i'éw:z§§§§3%:e$ §:,:7§3e§::e§"2f%i; by {he jaidgmem: Q? 3536 ﬁ%§§x §§ C323': if'? £.J{ris§21':a:?"s Case {cited S%,£§§'3) ta Ceﬁain exfiﬁeni. 3-isweverg in i;.Kr§sEma:1r"s Cage; ﬁg Apex Caurfg disagree with the aferemeatééned Qbservatiang t;'1jg:?.:kixx§i:e.:%i'_<'? Ceuri: madé Er: Mohammad Yoz:sef5,;§bACése_;;«._Qn §'%'s€~; hand; the Agex Cam: Er: £.§KrEshnan'$"£::é--se; %"::a.S.§'e$':%§{*:€év<i"H. the Cgmtizzsieng/obgervatémg E§*:~ .

Yeusef"s Sass my én §¢héme;§a;:d de\.ze§opmEm: scher:":e._fverm:e:éV--.%é_rjwd the Heusing Board; AS '*5 Case; Ehe Apex Csuﬁ: musing wages:

as £<3n€e%vef£*:§ by' ﬁg animated :0 the i""§Qi§S§§'E§ E@ardé"?<_>; s*" f@mé§1:§G:*: amﬁ firsaiizaiéos g§*'t§i':§ is ::% c:':'«:w:9:i:«e$$ar%§' mar iii': §€ii§ié§§§§i{3§'§ $2? we §a:éﬁ.__' "':7"h':2v§;*'-..§§fe€:§ 33% £:bs€§*\:§ié§ag made ﬁg": :7'. "--~§s£ai2a;§i:§éed_Y$r§:,§ef"s Sagg bséﬁ geeé is the £3383 whécé': '" -§§:"§'§«$f€é"»§i§i: §§*T___%E~%":€ ?2£%é,§S§¥E§ §<:%;%m§s Qéféﬁéiiféﬁg §a:"§:*:s§a."% am 7»._"*§%;%e3.%'%':e{§.if;.%§ iééé %*é§:gg%r:§ Eaarég IFS :2, ijméésgutedgg in the mgtiers Qﬁ hand? iéze HSLESEFXQ gmjegi in quesiiar: is camaeévéé by the féaasaégig 5Q§%'é §2;%"é.¢ as: by the State Gexzemmentg Yherefgre, in judgments ef the Agjex Cauré; in ﬁfféha'm:%2_ed:A?V}'Q_£§$é'f*'§: Case and £..Krishnan's Case, @ L:p§e:ﬁ.:ak--!.ih ':%§e*1;§rva*;g§s'é;§'r:S"--. cf KHB A3, it gar} be Safew éand acguésétim prggeedings @f the KHB Act shaﬁ bs-*-; framing and finaiézing the are is be acquired.

13, E: '§s:_:*:§§V€2;23V§é::AI/LjV':*E§"*~:i§é%.:&%" iha: 'E§1€ juégmeni sf ':h€ épgx £Gii£f§;-.§ﬁ ihé :ivaj3rs '@f V£. '§'(RfSHNA£¥ is ;'§ferreS by %:%":%$ aiaw: ;s:% '%::'%e:"%'%:ar:"g,s§ §%§§éMA?§A mag- 3% ?A§_AW§R {ELR §§§?' 33$ ggiﬁ Eagﬁgmentg $3313 sbgarkgaiésgag V'v:--_m:a'::f;*e §§'"'§ §i§§';:3V}g;.?'§:§?§'§"33 by 'i§§S Sugremg Saar: £32 iigisimagfs g»€:$:~:§~.,és*'E::-._§"'8§§€§ i§§G§'E ta €I';G:"EC§é§§E thgi ggﬁstigsé $3 533% fer mg mrpasé 3? gang ahéaé 1!\.fE'E§"s ihg: VJ?"~~.g§%::£;s:§@ﬁ Q? a §'%_@i§S§i'?§ G? %:i":§r5::§r:2§:%t gcézemg fsamfsé %:;:y Sine H§ug%::g Bsam améer the prevésims §f Ehe Hmgsing Beard fact. was: greatesi §"€S§SC?: is my est%emeé E am Qf the comzéctian tha: E am mt bmsnd by ihe Smgie Bench ia Dyamappa's m:§3€Ee§':*"b_e;::a:;::::é "i:r_;é Said: deiisien is :13: fazmded an :he_z::_Qnc§u3Eéa rea:.?:§'d '3y'a?;'E*:é"--. épex Csurt in pa;ragra;3h~33 s'f 'VL'£.V;_"§{:ishViiafi"$'j:§':§gE§2ent. in pa;"agraph~«33 Q? the jfQ<:;--i,4_§'j;>r:e;.'_jé _gV>:f "ft::4§.1__:'§_3Su_§:'enéé Ce:.:r: in Krishnarfs sage, the. S:sp:e«r:<i.ej*w.C:§.§;s;,: i'*é'i'a.g '<u.€:,<::if'Er2g:;§sir2ed EYES principie and ra1_::%g>i.i.i¢a;%§: ;§i%ea»é';:1§}a %hex::«a%s§é;c§'A; MOHAMMED YOUSEF (,%£R__.T}_9"9 ;2' csnaiudeé that méy wﬁere :59 iaﬁfi ésrsguired aaseweééy fsr tbs §L£¥'§@S€ $2': §><é"{;«a;fi:§a:;r% $f'V£1'§*:§.:;;as§§*:§ 3:' émprozgemeni sghemg §;:**§~;;2v3;rer,i: '3'%9'£_~.T§§*ae H${;§E.§fi:.g«8@§r§ é§§%ﬁ€§" Chagierévii 3? the °§'a:V'§r':%L_§&:Vs"w:[d';:;,;_%%::_é;z%:%':%§' ﬁsaraé égtg firzai and effsciiafe ssheme E2 7 '--~;z»ec&§§§:j;'; '"§?:s::'3--_.:2§5ans; me Agex Saw? mg aiaréféed that ii} 7»._"'v%:§é'§%é:--r¥:g;.%.:3.§;§{2g tie §:%%"Gj€€§' agf if %;%z;é._ E6535 $3 {:3 $53 &£Qé,E§f€E*é fgé' {he §i,3:'§:33e Q?

A iha §%:&:€ §Q2s€§'a§";':§§:i :~:5%é_::§':,:2:«iﬁeé E332' it is ?.:§":e §'"%Q§.§§§%E§ Bgafﬁg we ﬁsaé am affgciéve j"'>.,, %»:7'' / A' wk ?2 sceeme is net eecessarys Ea ethet WO?'d§, ﬁeeé...__er:d effeetiee eeheme sheeéd be neeeeeettiy frames Heuséeg Beard meet the previeéeee ef the Act if the teed %e te be acqeireé avev\i:e§€f§»§3%'E'e«;f".zhe' the ereject/eeheme framee by the_ Heeeitégs Beats: .ee<ievr=--..t't:e"~..L etevéséeee ef the Hoeeieg Beaté ;':.;'t'§ _ Bet."ee§'er't;tmateiy; the said eeservetieee G?-.L§§-'§€-1'St:§§}V§"e:'..!f§'Eé'*.C€3i.f?E fauna in eeragraph-«33 at Krishtianfsvéajse't{feye e._et':--'t§eVe:1 seeeiﬁeaéiy advetted te by ue"ie*'c§éEng the matter it: Dyamappa,"'~7'§':§é't§§3;___V§_r{.,_j'nf§:i,;?'"e.§f§V§t;§v:§e, the juegment in gyamappaf rune eentrary te tee ebeeteetéees éeeee. V%:e;§.%;:e>< Ceett is peregraete33 Gt t:%2'e~..v_§ee.§'%ee.%étﬁe "§{eE.;<::,imee'e eseeet téeeee the we jeéeteeeetté:é--»§yett;§e.§§e is eet meeriem. Eev.t%ée taee ef ﬁtiigtiﬁetéﬁééééé weew §"€§§§"E Q? V =«.tj'-~_ '*§(ﬁ:§;§§i';T§i§{A gee eeeees feeettee ée §..§§§{?§ eestt:

t€.%§}ée§.~.eée§§§at' eeeetéee erese fer €S%'ESi§€?é?:§Q§'§ taefete teée "NJ LA.) Cami; After i:€}!'iS§€:iEF§E"ig vaiéwg 9s°§:I§3i§:'2s $5.-.__:he ?<am&ta§<a Haasigg Bgard ;%ci mcégdéng Sgciiens sf the Said Act; this Cmzs': Canciudéd tha: the aC'{L'g_:%;£§:Téj§viwi:§':""'é' $5 landg fer Hanging Schemeg has {Q be;?§§{:E'a'tevd*«.srigigf. ?afE€_f'é§1eV".

aheme is sarictimeﬁ by the GQ.x;_Erni'%';e:§t 'f'u:V'%:jI?i5e:' "~~ heid thérein thaiz the Board %3 frairzé the scheme whim is net and therefcre iniﬂatisn Of befgre the ssheme is jjg§,E;<3;:'%'?é:eref0re iéabie is be quashed,' ....

352 Q? :V§'*3%«g_j stage;'é*:. }"'§$ raexzaﬁt :0 mte Céfiéifi $:%ﬁ;§:%..§'_x:e:.§'1Q?::¢§§E.§j?ﬁa_§e b32~i--?3:.%«;%§ex {:§iE¥"§ E32 iig I"e<:€ﬁ§ @§C§S§{§§'E m ﬁfe £:.a'::;é=.§f '*§:3':;§3§§§'§ §§§y CQ§§6§'§i'§¥$ 5'f§i§S§:"?g '_ '*;;'~?;;';§Eei3§* .__;§;§§2:§:?ie§g%.;?*T:;:€§g 3:333 sf K3§'??§i'§i{§ & Qffgersi %T«g>gg Ier:§s: ggégizggzgg 35$ 332. agashééh regs mg: -

" H '"f?'";§ .:£:%?5 §s:i* GQQS gmvzde fa: f;'§:';?s"s';§:r :3?' '"'§23;";'§:;s :§a:§?;€m§$ s'z"§{:*§a;§'§ng §";€3:§.§f;':§ sgﬁsmeg "F4 5€€§fGs'Z% :5 92' ffzs Ag: amgcwsrg Sﬁé :0 L1f}{j§§"{'§§<€ warkg §:"?G' f}'?Ci§;" §:<pen0':'i1::*e fairs devefapmenz. In éerms af Seczfian .Z5(.Z_.};'(}i~3)g..'_' ' A' BEA is erzéitied :9 draw up afeéaiied 3:*i7e_:2?,és'~..f"e:§:f::' she deveiapment sf éhe Bangaféfé"I¥?svfz*Qp::3i§:fé$«,r5 Area and in terms sf ciawse C3:'2., wi€f?. "

ébe grevfous appravai 23$'-...:f!3e '-:T§0;fef;'3Vmé-ﬁvé... underéake any work far the__¢§'e2§e5Q§mé22.é_§f fféie Bangafc:-re Me:rapC§..fftan Shﬁfazr expencfftagre therefor ;§.%"_si:éf f<--;«;.9 "iﬁ_é>__'_fr5mfng and e><ec:;€£;:.;3 ' ﬁeé§%eI§§f:z?r2e:é'i*»v sgfgeffiésg Sub- .sections (2) )%é.:;:;§awa'5:5:>;s» to make arm' Sake ;:p_,TVa':?;%"' »e:;:§:' aeveleymenf sci?er2'?_e __ _:;mi;'? 9;" am {he resomfﬁ§;*:'d5:§ce§i:::.LiV'€iTf' "§.,:7€5f .é:::f§39r§:y :35' as gas" {he §'f?$<":_f;'Q.::: ',-«if ':f2é=""Sfa§& Gaaierﬁmgnf, wﬁfcﬁ 5§s';€a:';?s 5 f?Oz"ii* 333535333 :;§.:;:%eA%;.;;s:;a:3:es farmfrég $5 SEW §;><ée:"2_§;'§;':§ as"

f§;{§ :/35.3. ';§rs's;a§'§ ;Z}§§'§SE?§; §"f2a;;gE?, 55;? §€£*:':::%;'% {ZE§ éﬁeregf 5% C§§,§€§?€§ 5;'; :%eg§€;'2:e fgrm, 5:1 '=-.§:'f§aV§:"§§; grgaaféeg far ?§2'"!??§f§§§? $2' gm! ';,.%;€§s§§§§r2 $3" Egyéggi' by 5 §§'f§:'§§"§ pez<§s;:>r: aézéff:

u Wffifﬁf? $ar:3€:':'::2s3 Q3' BSA 3:33' gsjﬁgeci is 552% fermg 552$ caﬁdiéims zrzzhfah E: may sgecify, Subwgecfisn 2 9f Secifan 32 roaxfdeg ma/<§r3 sf written a !icat{@;'; afar; wit}? .§_gf%:?:s§..'_';---.. ". --I- and sectians showin various m§:é'§:.éf.:".

emjmerated 22:'; éjlaasses 5} iii *im.{ aravisiamg are gerstairtes' in Seﬁfiénf E8 jg? me; "

Karnataka Hagisén Beard ~ éfihgugh, {ﬁe §;:a;§e.{{ar2 if j' ha 2% V Vlbefgér; Eequfred fa frame 3 scfféggrné-..;7}2§'s€§:§:f"_»:;;§;*2fGr;??i€y with me ;3r9vs°sTi.<;9;':s 'v;«fx:;zf a'nd ifike Hausing 8 o;.a}}¢' 54;: jE?:§5!:':}éa"":"9 frame a ssheme 2';7Ot}:gi mrmber of ;ﬁz'zemI:;é;99.§ of sfies, £25228 reqyérémééé' :2? *}i§3g«";§£'v4V_:V.i§§}§g§iﬁg She Size as' :29 $5955 a;"25a7L«._$,:*:35:23'._ 4§:::d5§<:€é':ff3:3 92' the maﬁs 33$ m§::f§é§;.§f §é'v»§%.;§,Qs3?§3;?§ :32' {%;'':§ §§§'§if 5:; 3 fgysué:

i3:?¥€f!?!T?€i"'§§ magfé thezé §;':}Q§}/ mama' zékfg-é:"§:éV:*«..ét§3:"%';%§§:~ {ﬁe hsusfzzg .§€f?e:?::e éramga' égi é;§§$ §§§ei§é3{_:§; gfseagid be §§,Q?§¥€ﬁ. "

.. {§@ﬁé§S§S 3::s§§;'£e;:{} Egg 5'%"§;'emeﬁ:§@z§$§ ;¥E'"15§'t%f', ihe {ma}: Cgagri has VJ}"~V<:_§%'*:'~:.;§a:*ed iﬁée §%"§'2!§$§G§E§ sf §§%"§§§§{}%'€ §€X.«'€§G$§°¥'1§f'%E ﬁct:

with the Kamataka HQGSESQ Baard AC: wiih rggard €{::.___'£he feméatégn sad fiméézaiiam Q? tﬁe haugmg scheme the initéaiiaré er acquésétéaa graceedings. After'*§:§§:.sA§:jéf'§%r'2»§_"T the gzroviséerés cf bsth the e€:a€t§"nen%;é;N€?1<: A;>e->2:

CQ¥1C§:§d€d that the provéséans goyztaineii.:%:».Se<:i:?§§:s"sf':.T18" aft Kamataka Hanging Beard Ac: Vi:i<sV.e; ;:¥%*Q{;§;;i:9.§Vns Qf Seetiss': 32 cf the Bangagﬁii-§_ an§ has Qmciudeé that aitjhaaugih may :33: be required tg §;§5rj§A;:£'V.'§§d':é:form§iy with the msvésions G_f_ Vifxatherity Act; 19% am the gécéf it was bsund ﬁg framé & s£he:z'%--.:4--.4.g:§i,;rs::éV§::$.'§4V:';§i.;"fﬁééperssns Wm} am aégibié fa? §%«§'{;:<*;.;f2j'2$r':_'E;_"3%:3f_§::§§ b§%"i:$..::reaé ::r;§§<:aii@:§ Qf mg msdé am :*:'zaV:'2.f_:e';* §'fA£%§'<;%%;'e§'i;g::::':e::: sf ihe 531$ 33 5 Eaysaét. The Siaie 7 "A--.5\3:3:;g§'§é::}_é§:t :;e5::§«5f*%?:éré a9;::%y is mmé? 'v'%£§'3%'§'¥€E" 332$ mugiag "-- §§;:j.:§%_§§m€ §%':$?e:g§éé ég wgawgvgd Q?' zéaé;

"F3?

16. Er: eéew ef {he eeeveg the petétiemere ere 3?ue*;_§fEed ie C§§"i'{€?'E€Z§§ﬁ§ thee freméeg eed fieeiizing the ee%:e%'e:'eL'4.VT'§'e"

preeeeuiséte fee geieg eheee with the aequisitéen "

ender Sectéee 33(2) ef ehe KHB Aet reeé" with "the;';§§9e§*EVeie'eeL"'; ef the as Aet, Heweverg, in the n3a:terV4e.:j é*%._end,ﬁfze is neither fremeé ner ﬁeeiized ieee game %e eaeetienee befere geing ahead with ihe p§f.e§;.:e_et under the erevieéeexe ef Aet. Heneef.

the eeqasésité[email protected]'§'ce:§§_QES,_'eifeeEieeivie be quashed' 17, §"~'Ee§'eV3'ee{.e°e",,v if §.e4V:<e§'e>{§.eeE te eete et {hie siege ieseii ee;~":'~'i":_:v§eei§e_=?;§3'§A:%.e§Gf_fV'£2'; e%2e""s:fée.e_§eiee Q? the ﬁxséeiee Beeeh 9% this Cee'e:_' ireftEf£§;--.?§e:,'Z§4--§;'2§@§ ieieiee eeeee} em ee ée eieee feee,__'4'Ee::e.eé'e'1..V_z:§eieeeéeee by tee Eieeeieg Eeere; §@% ef *4-T7;fﬁ;e.__'§eee ;e%eg€~eeeé eeeier Seeiéee eilfs ef Ehe ee, ea: fee W_"ee'e;:é3é'e§§.--' ie eéeeez' mi: eeeeeeed eeeeeiﬁee Veiéjeeeeezeeeiyx Else reeeeje meéeeeieed by ewe Heeeéeg ?$ Egam cieariy :ev€a§ ihai mage than aha}: 56 aareg af.-.§_ a:1é is demiiféeé ever: afier aiiégediy iakiﬁg gcassessigriV:{:s§"L:'f§§'€ Sand, Learned advecateg appearing an befﬁif. ::¥f "€r3»é_<'T ﬂagging Bearé are 3%"':SWé§"§ESS when y\;ée%é':§:;é4s;t§-s3n{e%a:E._b;k"ii'he"'. Cam': as :3 under what grgvisiorzthe "S-afédg a:fe--".%.d'é':1ét§ﬁét§%;W. that tag after taking passesséom "facts;

it is aiready mentégned éérés of the éand which was no:é.f"Eved '?§e'f§.'ci§:»é::§¥:f{::'i:ier1, aniy an extent sf abeu::¢..i§§' § é§.;v,,2'é'§u §{£>ssessiC>:: G? the Reusing Q' the and ihaugh £5 stated in %'::Vé,2A§:e'« ihe Hgaging Bearéi is aizeadgz 5§exze§Qf'::«e;{V§ garties am Qzséidiszgs are :::§3':a~s_i_r;.;§.:{e5»:3f Ea}V':";s:§;%_ §§€:G §f;'§E.....?§'r'€ regééiag therein.) Ejnﬁfgr fngse £i:'C'a;_*r;~5*{T§":*:_€%\:~s_;'%§é:*%§§~:s is 5% had gm: me gurmsa fa; arash%§§":

V7 '---%§*":e %az::E$4"ga;§:T4%:'§é--§*:§§Q3§d :6 %§ ggqzgireé hag :"@?§§e:*'e§ itgaif '~T..E;*:f5r_;:§a:::;s:3::s;..i_:%~a§:':%2§£%§ §§ mam, ihasz §§% :3? the %a:':d ég mi

-»_'§:":"'§§.2s'::a%§3§Q§": $26 332 %é@:;§i¥2g Ems? iZ§"%$ii§§'E ihg aaqggigéiigra §:§§::%€.%.£::3;é§;':$ W€i"§ isgaggé 33 far §::a£E~«: as ii"? {he yaar E98, WW .

'=;~,r>::<e 1??! ébem: 22 353353 havé %apsed after acqaségéiésn af the %arsc_'é,___ Er: cl ihég View 3?' 'mg géattéij, :39; zssefsﬁ gajrpege wﬁé ﬁe sa§:r€;é'§ %';<:. mmiémgéng the acqasisitien §3i'GC€€dE?'§QS ix: resggﬁtt. *af""iihaé"_f grspeztées in questima

18. I53 additiaré te thé afQre %';2.:ef£i§@né':§._§n:$'§,,mz€:§ ef mm fiaalisatéan ef srjleme as re.q'{;««%re<-if b;; §'E2x(y'p':«*§_Q;{ is agquisitiesz gmceedéngsg this Csurt f%n<i2:V.:ﬁ§zVe ads:i*:'i€>ng"%--'i.'g'E@und each in faxmur sf .__..4V$§_'--3;'§'?'VS8i£2GG7 & 'W.P. 3486?/2GO2;,v %%%% 7 1?. In x;*¢f':r2é_;:§<,>§?5+S%k1%,;2:%§?; {E35 Cam': féfzés mat the ajarasaéfé %§ :}.ag§ 'erj_ be\ ;'%:;.:ﬁs:f%.._..ér;*':e geréw sf ivgﬁ 3/earg fmm izize éaiéa the féﬁai mtificatiera Ceiiam datss §*€§__eé.:*§§2.?i"L"1«.V.§:é:* dégéding i§3§'; said :3<}és':"§ Er:

"-- ¥:S??_.__§'V§»sr;;?§8:,f?£3§?, :;2;h%£%"%: am ag uré§er:« mmw.vr"'( 80 ?AR"E'ICULARS DATE DQYS REMARKS §i,Eb§§§8t§0?Z ef fine? §:o:§f%::a'::§<::e 124$: ~ ~ Lest Pubéécetierz ef ;F§r:e% .f\:e*:%f:<:e:§er2 @168: ~« « interim Greer ea' stay ef diseessessien 206.93. ~ ~ in W.P.Ne.:35e5~e8/§:

No of days between fine? netificetien 25.2; 1% +_ and date ef interim ersjer where were __ was me impedémerzt fer the :

reeeendenis 'Ice take ectieﬁ to page the aware V 1 Fina? erder in WJ:'.f\§C>:13454-48f§1 1312298 -- ~ _ -. Féeeé Greer in W;.e:Ne.?2S-28%? 2"?;'i7?_,G=1, ~ ~T?E_e etitire eeréed '- .fr'em 2§$§;91 ﬁe

-- 212".~:?;2QQ: gets . excieded fer the eereose of H ' V' " --.--"caE<:uEet%ng the _ peried within 2: A " .... .. which the award is gequireé ﬁe be V --- made.

interim weer of s€e_::_gs~:g:;:5'b\;;.é.,He:?5b'%e_ ~ -- Eu reme Ceurt ﬁe "Si_P7 i'€e§V§€G8'%f§_;f§;; _ Ne ef days bet?-gees: --r"%n'e5§,~e;*;Cier"«.§;g'~...}e§=@4 :89 ~ ¥jlﬁ!2N@9?2§&28j{g§V".' ané _ ﬁefe _e;s§=3: Esteem ereer be £~i_er1'?3%e "§e'g3;°e;~:me--. V See~3@ ijoeré znshefe there wesﬁe émee.d§mer::.~' 0Ci:-3: fer the reeeenéjeets te teé'e'e<:*:%en' ie ?€e\=.s-»3Q gees the ee2esie.~:*., ' ...... .. Eee-33.

Fe%»~i'}:

"%"ete§~« 18$ 3,:;SkQ2 « 'ihe eeiire eerieaﬁ :::.s[g{ees;e:.e§ gee ::.:e;:eee~::;'2ee2 ffem §f:HZ,2§{32 ﬁe 3;::i':L2::%§2 geis excieﬁed fer' the eereeee sf eeéeeieiimg the eréee' esiiézée I & M 'véfééch -1???' $3 §$:;u§r's§a ﬁn be m..ada;_' .. :__'~ e.

¥\§a,2j*6;Q8%-~11/'52':' aging ~ date 9%' gassing t?sje%aé:=:ardI % ':;':;'?.f*~x3@§:?§8E.!/'EGG? award gamé ta be $§$S€§ segarateé-§;_ gr: 153.2864 with Ehe dgiay sf 1% 653:3; in 'xf§€1i!\f Q?

it has ta be hefd that the acquéséticrz :':etif§Cat%@r":':§._:%r':vj§Téé'g§'écvﬁ %<V' 0? tfze Eaﬁd beariﬁg S'y1No,6S sétjJé€e §:§'..va5*:r_T viélage, Yeiahanka §-sﬁabiéi measuiéﬁg 2 ai---::_:9€w;9 39TV:«;:".=;;.§f':i:a"s §apsed by Gperaiém czf iaw under uSe:_'C%:ée_n thé LA Ac:

as the awaré is 52$: made ?;e_ja3»:;S"f%fGm the date af fiaai deciaratmz. Tb_€?efQrT{5:,--v _".f'.~'P}v~§\§i§_._7.53:}':i'3:Q7 succeeds, aésg 0:: the afGr2:T§*en§1§ji n_ed':aédV§t§Q_n§A~év§r;§:i%°:d. Hawexgérg"§§:*~:éspéé:f3: :3f'»:§;':i3er .§$;'E§t getétéans, thgugh the similar §Q§?téf'§iV§G7':'3 i$i..;tfla%S«§s:.::"":.§":"§*ée §f:'§§£§ thai ihe swagd ﬁg QaSS€ﬁ b§;s<:n_d *€?'}:<":5:'-.§?'3i€§§"§':Q§ 2:2? iwa yeara, {ha sgmé camwt bé ':C:'Z§Q :iE,?€Z§_\§%'E§'E;§:§%'3{§é:?§'} 33, ihg gzasarég $2 ihagg maiiefs are as$€:}§_%._%;:¥<3::%2§":'::"':~éée'.§:;é'r§§:2:j 3% ms» vearg afier é$é::£i%§é" 32% . V __ __ 'f' 9 4gperis@é §:é%'§ng--«V:;v§'.i7£%7 {ha irzigrém Q%"§€E'" wag ia Gﬁéfﬁiiﬂﬁg E3: $3 ; §EE€{i3§'§»€S§ §I;§ Gésgéwg that the iéme §£§?"i§°%§ whiaéz 32$ éaiezim A'-"_:::§§«é--;' was $3 sgeragar: §7§€§$ 13 be %}£C§L§§E§ :5s'§"§i§8 CL"--v::.a!E:.:.Vzi:§'i:%r";§ ihe '§ii"§%§ égrzéer' 3%€'i§§:'": gm Q? the 3% £2: Tézug, 83 E iéﬁig éghai: ihe §W§%"§S is: 3% Qihgr' matters are gagged :5:_.§:h§n {he geriad }§3f€§C§'§§€C§ unégr Secééer: 11% Q'? 'mg éﬁ. therefare the a€C;€.,E§S§i'.§Q?§ netifécatians Came: be :?g}}aS§ﬁ.V e"c§ that graund, m ether Wfit petitiansé 2:. The Eand$ %m;Q§ved Era w¢'%.':\:@J e.3%:;@é;:;2e§3&2;;;::.zk€gzhe lands béasirég Sy;i'ai§s.36/1,. me;a.gaVV§f'§~:2g"~.._:L ;a €f'r'e._}""_ §gu;:':as; 3&3; measaréﬁg é §L.:s":':a§;' 36 gamtasg situated at Ai%a§a3::.1§f:<j.raﬁgAV;§%ef§'§€} 'AA.q$;fg:_§§vh&r§v'§<a Habié, are marshy Sands w=ii'1 §V:i}"«$'%é'3!:,:§1f§f;j .?§r.._fémggisag §Z}%.£E"'§QS€S. Urgder simiiar 5irc:;':*ﬁéian§§eVS,'é:i§;2'§S: {f§é'::i'€ § %*§"ié*QP§?~§@'3;?68T?f2§Q7 has ceizgmﬁed i§é'aV:'*:%2e._§:iQ:§'E'§E_§§'s%*:*' mtiﬁcatiiang aeed 'Ce :§§ qasagheﬁs fsixg WE? ggzésgéaﬁ éé '»f2;'P,§'=30=1?58?;"EGG? is :.2p%'3e§d 33,»; E" ;£:%%§%~3_§_@:: %%%%% 'Se§":€?i 0%' ms gem ﬁg':

zﬁg;:.%:af2T€;;:§§g2k:%§§%k§%;;:~;«:§«s$j;; :Ag§''s&:'s3%:'2 :: :3 fgigsgevwaé _ 'i;%s" _;é%;:€ 525% smégé £39.59; ms §f"}ff!'8 223 " é§;'I"}f"é$~ . §!'£§QQ§§§ is 538 agqsjirsg' E!?;'€§'"8 ésgajgﬁé éizmzﬁ 55:'; ECE5 acéss ans? §g3;ir? 5: was érsagﬁf ﬁawgsé T EQT 3% §<':;"s3s 5;! 31526 iime gaaggrﬁ §§m€ €52 be $4 eeeeed, ﬂee ieereee' eeeesef eeeeerieg fez §°f2e_...__ aepefiaefs wee fair eeeuge Se ea}; She? even ef thie 8? eeres, 55 ecree eupeeeeef :0 z'7eve__£§éee§:é_'V:---.: resumed by She 8£ji':'70§"i£'f€S end cut Of..i',f"_§'fE?u _ eeree 3823 acres is She eL.sbjee:'« ._me:§:e%f:"'«ef_":7' Eitigetien. 'fherefere, berdfy .V.2}"' eacres ef iene' an which e7g:3_fe"'e{{e;3fs v§§£'}é;§i:§ f'§e»*e.. impiemeeied {he scheme foV§f_:e'<;e --;:2_ebf;*c,.T_ Ae en éeday, §,e,, eeerfy afeee ;;.e'e':fS,V.:"ee§ ezéeéé 3 single site fer the as' she appefieef is e.i;'e;fte.o'. 'vbfe.:'V.:ﬁ<:«.e»eij:. enywhere faczuei/y thge"e:epe!%5;et jfzjeﬁng---":e'i<ee;2» eessessiee 0f 55 acres. ::3_f_ Estgffj «a:i"_{e.§asig Whers ':fz§z;g.§=."'e:ee§*--.,_:if:es, eeeeeee ef the Iieeréy Vee}"§'§e%*ﬁiéﬁgeiieef the epeefieie e:;i'§:%::%:r§€y'~ eeeeeiife maze reeemmeeeed fee Ieee' §e'.g7£;ee:'§e§§"«.eJeeg ezftﬁ eeeieer feed Sy:.:"\:'e.3§ 1ee§ee.eVe;§}?,QV"e%je§.;~§ 4 eefee eed ee'«::r' fer eeeufeféfee, €e"..%%?e1ee§e3:?§ me SC§?8:"?'E§. fee eeesfiee is "._;:vf3ea'f?e;?*'«;.f:'f§ie eeéfee ef {ﬁe a,eeefSee§:e ,ﬂE"{'3§Q§*S§}"?§ V' '..je'ffeee.'eeeefe§§%ee efjeeé 4 ecree ef' Eeee' ie jeeéiffeef eeir Qeez: £23 fee Erzeéeeee ef {ﬁe Ceeré, éhe

-»e;'}ee!feeée eeve eredecee' e eeegf? eeeéee 85 indicaiing affié ﬁamfg whfcb mmg is be acquirecf by.--«.._ grsiiminary amrd f;'n5§ {?QZ'fffC§i"§O£'? f.r2CE:.:di;::g.::'f«._ '=_ Syg§ves,32 8: 33; #28 sgbjeai matter QFESGSE acqufsiéiagzz IE is :0 be rzated e_w3i?4_ ;c3f:e§.éf .

S3./J'\[email protected] orziy 3 acre E 93. {£5 '§:'§;§;:j:<2Tsé:§ §Cqé!§Si€'5Qf1 'i""f?e fanci gbave VS;y2!'§§..__33V_§s S}~"._ﬂ<:s,.,33 K and the fand be/aw Syg{V3,33_fS..VSy.Na,__34., aof faazxe gay maierfa!__ to sf7Q_:s3.}'j':'f2af:_» thé's:f2 ;fa'{;Ligd pubfis pagrpage of h€s:s§i:;é'j%'*s c!7?fen§e" §s_"i}%2;3{emen:éd, On the @f!';er V f2anci,__ &'i§:e" --'.i'V_::C%.1izrse cf arguments, ag§L%§§j:e tigfyazf» 54/3, 54/4, 54/2; .V,£mf.;;:gr':'e__ " Cé{'!Sff'{:'C§'iQf?S have @me :,;;2.A.__ in Qﬁfy 2 hguses are shéyvzzg 2 hause Seems E3 fgave 536:; ":fjeié§é:.?*Lj.'A'3>f€'e} "«:é%';qs;.;!;";i unaisr Se€£'§a§§ 5(3), _ .%,{%z'e ;[2{:s{*.§2';'2c2i';Ia€:?a}?f23i' 53 522% jagéiﬁgaéiars in

-'"~gfigi..f§e:§§i;"§y£§gA""c:;....58a:zi;?g Gigi' 553$ f&:'ss's §}'§:'E"§ ":_V5:§§*'::';f3é§i§';7% 'i5i;'}'§z;";{€ azagz' C{3*§'iSi'T£!Cf§§FES f7'§'v'S :':'Gf'F?€ 535:2 §'{§f:_,:%2€?E;'é§;i..§:;%§*:%éy ;?:,;s<2':be:*.§: :?'§§§:r§;"; Eﬂe gfaﬁd $5 V V' _ 5:29 €§';§§<'?';ffE:7f?«§f'3 E3 5&3? éecaazgg 02' ms C§5'"%SZ"f"§,§C{'5G%? 35 3 f2<f:;.;_§§@ ihgy émve :"s5s;??;:r:€;3§£§ fag" @'sz'£§§:"zg !§§"E§ in §}*'1f3iQ, 6%/3,: iéféﬁﬁ {ﬁe 3§§§§§§f?fS '~5g:4::; 5:293' @2135? séfe 5:? impégmsgisé iﬁssfr gcbeme $9' T :3 ES §::;*§s $25 farsaé fr: {ﬁe ,{£g§7: @f 38 §€;'§'"§S Se arse' 9,53' befrzg the sgbjsér azatferr $25 iitigafiaié, gihaé is m jystiﬁcatiani zafzéy 535%: :"2§w'prspss§_ﬁ§:j the a::;q:.:§sit§e';? sf 2 zjéits of land 52*; Sy. ' A 3?. 2 Fiawéveir' gays 'om' .::9ﬁ'cée rne.i::'_j S .ﬁJe,33. Wfﬁeirr thervmarshv :{f"éa?»}92M%:¥§1.§::7ai§rfzfse. denafiaiied as they were 329: $22:

scfheme thge nresen: .!ané §j>e;§9g Aknéfshj' -5 here. is no ' *a}.3t§'§¢;a:ion'* f1c;§;j: Km. . swim 23335 y£ffh--in. 23.

V _e3r:.s7 of tin-air _'§;=.='af.:.«!iaé}if' c3 #13 ~. A Sr 1;») ' :

5%'? % ' ¢ ' ;.»,\f?:,.s\_ .- . "

» . x w . . x C' 1 ko §-.-{X : .. . '«. 5 ..§.§-3&j€ii5%f?tss[ I' ' I Céurz. g3.'%:,§.3g.§ {$33.8 <~:?:5f$ 8?

ma gﬁaaf gregmcig {Q slnferferg wﬁéf'; $573 Qrders af.----.._ {ﬁg fearned gfngie Jadgeg "' V' {Emmasis supgiéed) 22% In this CQE'!§€X'Z; it §§ reievafégfé _§§C;:ve§'«.;h-:9; 31' the Apex Court in the case «:>_f HOUSE BUILDING co«oPERAT:\€=.é=,' s;QciE*:'§'(1;:m:;'rEn -« ysm STATE 0:: KARNATAi{_;§f--ANV:D regsrteé is: IT 2904(2) SC 398 wher,e§:: it éasbseragggj A pe_rfu$'a.§: '4;3:§.:;_::§je;§.,_:'j:.§:§iiAg"::é§§_:.}0? the Egamed singie 13uQgé vé":?c7§_§:éate$ "-that.' the chauenge ta §<:qi:§s%i§<;«+} " _p:*Q.§é;§€§§'§:§E§"'«'baaed aa gexsera gramég za:é"s<'§_"me:jaf%x:é:§ am; iﬁzés, six wt 9? 2-"v%_§e:i€3L:'i'«:.:!a§:f§: §e':§éE'"§?§;"':§...§5s;i§§d, ﬂag fa: 33 tbs §re§§:§t %'f;°;é$°§€§;';%'§s'f7§i[:E'%"£§f:'«§T;'§«§k§i ég {:§§€e;*neﬁ, ihe iaamed s§::g§s ::%2a§§en§e aa 326 faagaé ihai: the Etaiie §:}_ *:zg:si9:é'?ﬁ§a:i 323$ accggiéé §??{f§ 3:535 wag; §a:":':;iV__§:lé£§a:i3%%;%§§: sff%r:§§"§ §"€§Q%"iZ aéaéé? S§{?i§§i'§ ' §§:'%, §~§ 51$ égt far" §§'GQQi¥"§§ the §€{§é§§S§'E§S§"% = «'--;s§*:';$s€§E:':g$ $3": {$33525 0? §§:fEI'§§ séméiariy ééiuateé {:;§3§£§, bait: 9%; €338 §&S$ 95 im fifth S8 reeeeedeee, eeepite e seeemmeedetéee ta eree_...__ iiwe eequisitiee ereeeeeéegef the gevemmeet gene ahead witéw the ecquisétien ereceedéngs;_:"§"'--e_'V---..: piausibie reesene for such e§scrim§native.,eetiee é against the fifth :*eepeeeer::'s §é'ﬁ§"'e:e§=e -:e§.fa ic'e_dV '*7" em feeerd.

6; 1: ﬁe the ease ef the fifth t::*e..$pende:1:.V:teatveil the eases where aeqs.,gV.ievE':*%:;_n; "efficer had recemmended zjreeei-neg vAA--'.j'V_~e _efquis§t%en ereceedéngs s§i;?niE§a'zf§éy s5§::;a:ee'e «am there was :23 zje'e"sf<;gﬁ§ee-Ei--_§_e' «.jg;3.e_:fe~:;m1,:--«'v_'w§fra:eeever, for making. e?» [d'*Ee%ei:*i1:?~a_,_i':fV:&1*»:_i'eff:re ease :0 eentinue with me 'giife-§::_eed_':ngsg It was urged befare ieV;e'* See:-teeAew.e§e:§ieV~"j::ege that Efee state Gevesgfzrraeéﬁ ﬁes;[--.ee«%;e'<;%"»LVerb%e*ar%§3i ey feééwe ie "'.e_v_a??7':e'j"§*'. {ﬁe Veere'e"ee_:<ie:§ei< §e reeeeci ef the féfizh eeS--;:Vee.éem:f:s2'*~--.ieneg '"§%ze §%vis%ee Beeee eee "e.eee,eie»e7""_..,::f§":ée;-ékeeeeeme ef see ieeeeee eiegie 3i,§é'§€; .

5f"?Q§%:~«_.:zeee eeged by See Eeemee eeeeeei fee {he ' eggeeééeei: thee veeeievee be ﬁne reeemmeeeeiieee V' "e? the Eeed aeeeieitiee effieee ﬁe %'z%e reeeri: eraeer eectéet: EA, they were mereitg reeemmeeeetéeee.--.__ and the State gevemmeet was met eeued eceeet them. The State government hee..:§%:'i':te_'V1-~.:J discretéen te accept er rejeet the seE_d__,'v_éfeeV::::é.*;t: . meet section SA ef the fAc't"'t.e'n_e-:'--t§%:_¢._IV" independent decéeier: te cont:m,{ieV_e--:f "dEscE:>:§ti~eL:e" n the acquisétéen eteceed§ng3sv:""%.§f; re'e:)_ea:t_T'et"':e't1;<.. pertécuiet teed Qtepoeed te ﬁe-..ecq_uire:£«--g.Ttﬁzvittief the discretiee may be;.;_._"t>L:t--'_Vee§t.A exetciee Gt statutety' discretiett f--'.ﬁ'V_~tf§__e'.eed Ge reasenebie t3§e;t:'zj.dei;_'eg§'di.«t <::etij:}~et_' féavpee trite erbitterineee Ci:_tf_tie::_VtE'ee_V.st;g't:..i_;E5teeijathema to the Ruie ef 14 of the Ceestizititiettf'T5'v7t"heA9fa<:«te"'-e§e.<:ed ee teeere dc: not %ed§eeteA'ttzet_tt:e_.:e§%eeV'e.t:"t'E%'e ﬁfth tee enﬁeet was etm§§e_r_ it e"etVéztetztée-e§"~'tVe that Q? the ether me

--._ewee:2%e;,:'e:t:eee""ieeee were éreepeé teem the ee'e.e;e§tAie::~.?t*e__ceed§e eg téeéttzet the e eettaet L§;etT'_tt3Ae"v§teteV.T'§'eeetee%eet ttee been eete te eeew es en ::et_teea: eéstieetéee betweee the eeee et t%t't.t1__A'1~tee eneeet eee the Ceee ef the eteet '~:LfteVe'e?"'~«_eweere zeeeee teede wete exeieciee ttem ' eigeéeitteeg Ween ttzie ie get it eeeeets te LES "ttiet tee wee et" tteetite eieerietteetéee iefeete eed 9S véizietee eee deeéeiee takes': ey ihe S'£eEe..___ geverereeei te eentime gee: the aeq::§e§t_Ee.:f§'-«._4b_T*~..V egamst éhe ﬁfth reseerzdenﬁe éend, 9 {Emphasis suppiieé} 23; The Aeex Ceeré: in the recerééj:}§jgé5ne§*:%V §:*s',Vi:§2VeV{_L§ie:ee:._ ef HAR: RAM «--xzs~ STATE OF eAe§§ie.§4A :%le;.:Q':-:_e{::, ée:, '{'2ea'ia}3 " Sifiii 521 was ceee§derE§1gV:'?t~?}_e nf:a5't:e%f¥§'§"e~:z§:hEc§é'§'E'ae' ee:*e0é':e eiteateé eéméfariy were net the State Sevemment in they reeifiiergzsf <:Ee'€%et§f§'cfa"iwE0_:§..70f éendeg in that eeetext, the Q{§eesﬁ4§k':;: €§ef'§:e the Apex Ceurt are reéevantg vséjéeh j%'e'.«::ij? thee:

$49311? ége ireeﬁféet eke: eetiee er eréer eeazeery °':£::5 §'av;: e§'::2e?S~:j_:o: ee}é?ee emf rigid: egee any pereee e_f{§ife_S§eﬁé'v§e'r»vi:'s<ee_:meet it ie eqeeiiy tree em: a §el'eée'a:gs:eeV'ei'j_§.?x$%';eee ieeé eee beee eceeieeﬁ fer * iibiée" "'§:2eé5eeee e' feiéeeen tee ereecrieeé _ , M T 3; 3*' .p:*e;ee:ee eeeeei: eieee es e {heifer ef ;'%g%2t fer e.§ie'§ee.ee e:f héefher Eaed free: aeqeéeéiéee be: _f@§2eee tee State Geveremeei exereéeee its geese? iéﬁdé!' Sgatéasz 48 Q?' 'ﬁzé Ag: far zssithérawai frQm__.__ aaqgaéatécsn in respect @f a mrt§::a,:§ar Eandg éarzdgwnes who are séméiaﬂ situated h_ag:i'e«..'a.._.: ri ht of simﬁar 'treatment E: the__ S ta:t:e Gmiernmentg Equaiit 3f cEt§ze:1"s'f§' h§:s§.'Es.;§é*:'€'. the fundamenta! iiiarg an wager; easf;::eT the rule of Eaw rests ;a::T%%a~1;:ian;g%e§a=:h*ei have :0 be fair and far iegitéhﬁaié ::jeasof';*::~3}T " 413 The Gavemmenfﬁg:L'v'v<§b'VI§g$i:'i:$§% Q? acting with aubstarttséi-._faigﬁééggi: : :'§d['_--.._:Qr:$§V'Stency m cansideréng 'V §fe_g§1':%_e1se:*nﬁ;at'is:;:'éV 0%' the §andow;j§rvs*'V.V.V":*§'§%%___ acquésétion wheseﬁianﬁé'Ea25év'3v.$e--év§ _§_:qLgéréé under the same acCgL:Esivvi:i:;>%:.§;":3§é§i%§§i_%:g.§;"~ 7E*¥*:e State §3GV€i"f'Em€ﬁ'£:

iamet 3:3»: azréd-.éh.r.:.%::$é samé Easzdewnezs and §e%i€:<%;se é;%'1e§f §5a€éé§___f:em as Tuéséiim am sea ihﬁ $amé 'vi§t"AE3.§\:-i§Jf%'§: %:G Qthey Eanéewners b creaién A*5§%.:'f%§E§-3'e:€§§;A§';2s:";£r;§§§:, 9&S;§§;f"E éiffezasi iﬁféﬁfg Ea eX§:.§_C%s_9- ~::';f".-ie2;':' s awe? ¥.3§':@EE" $€C§§$I"i 48 Q?' the Act gén reS~*§§;%C: sf €§°SQ§'§$ simiiaii géiaaiéé reigién '?;':<':;e ggmé as zséséziaa mageaiéégmﬁ am far we 3$:3;:%2é asééic as? age ég defiaieij azéaéaiéage sf §2 Arfticie 14 Q?' the CC:{'2§i§'{u':§Q§'2 aséd magi: be he%é__.__ ta be discriménatsr B (Emphasis supgiied}

24. in thig matier E3}S©; ;1either:'é:i*éie"'HQL§--sir3;§ the State Gavernmergt has been Tabke :5t£> é§w ow ratégnaé distinctian DEEWEEF': the"::L\aTV:$e 'Q1; Er;

WP, Na.34G67;2a§2 éané awnerg, whcse éandsgwere '%;l;ﬁi1isition. The facts maced an Eha case cf the petétieners %:f_:_ net simééarf if ms:

Eﬁentéaaé, @:A.z§":ers M2933 §&ﬁdS are dmpgéé frasfé " Ehe i""€€Qﬁ"'§f'I'i€:*"%S§'£§Q§"'§ te éireg ihtiff'~:§t;2é(§AL§§§'§i§§§§""Vg£'§V§i}_{:éE§iﬁgﬁ by the Land éaquigitieﬁ @fVfé--;feJ;:,.. "%:'.E§€:..,'V"'i9§::>.2§"€:f§:::':€§":it ézaé gems gézead wéiéz {he "*--.._§.:qa:is§t§§i'é p;%§:Véj;£_:2ii%:2§g an {Es graamd iihﬁt '§§E% sgbseqgeai :3? :§":;e ':_w§;'1«:§ §«.CQé,,E§E§§:§$§'"§ %3§f%£e:* ?'éii"2§ CZS§1t?'ﬁi'"'g' :0 'am *~.é§--§%§é'§"?§§§'s:;:i made E33: {hag Lam ﬁcguﬁgéiésré Sfficéé: §§:§"§§§S§ 'éf?%'§. V'sj::§§Esf{§§eS gm atzﬁiézéd $2' fyaagd is a%§§§ed agaiasi 'ahe 93 eeréée? eeeert ef the Lead Aeeeigétéee §3ff§CE§' eetee 3é~ 1:L1§§Gf eecb reeeri came: ee eeeeeeiee. It ie fer tee Sitete Gevemment to take fecteei repertgfeggeeeé'e%d:.¥y* H frem the ceeeemed efﬁzféais i:E§E:"feai:;:%§"é1.bEe«e f'e_;:e§'t7«'is submitted by the Land Acquiseitiee 14'eC)*§f§:.e:' Govemment. There ﬁe eethéﬁg 'ee'e:V:%'ecerd"':.e"s§%ev€;:thVe: the earéier eepert ef {he LeadJfivee:.:_%"e§:§e;*{.§§'.3ff§--f;e:* detee 3.€w11~ 199$ brésees with mazafgaeseeereeeﬁiefgaegejeeeeigkpiayes by the eetﬁiionere ﬁe e'e§._§vue'}i:;'e3 itéwee':3:!*{e':1"""'Laed éxequésitiee Gffieer, En ;*eee'e:§:~ef ée WE Faieg34@§?;"2GG2;

the éeeie,%e.eL ieéieéi :§.§;:.E99§ egz the ieee gate ::'§':::%EiVe:'é S?:F%Z%:'e§_ es weer: --~ " 'M-Rik: , V3? 'W ' 2 \ A ' - ' , vewe'-\ ' . $73' L ./9 22%?

Eié®<E® §$§;$a€€§§& €385 m>@'s3aﬁ32€;:§ e:§c:f>5"c2§ci;""e:€§.§§?:3, = L, "

msﬁifwsai §i;2>é3g aﬁﬁﬁzégi 2:3i;:2:@?\;, T ' _ .

{€§T§Qh3S§S'SEiQ§1§€Vd):_ ' ' Such a fei'§ é;;;f'---.§%:'a'3t__q.uesi:§Q:3 is a marshy Sand was mTa5é'i=e% :§'fj:j':§::i3§§€3. §ﬁ"'V$pite $6' thé same, the ﬁané :3 maiv <i:éi@:é:§~ VVV?f~«§_L}:'?:»J"e§:;a§%~sit§§:2 ihsugh certam sighs? marsﬁy §aj.§"-3{§$ s:{i':;%§ a§'v"S3:'-_§iE§ s,38j1 8; 35 aﬁjsiniszg these p*§'§§§?:§éL::3'-%€ {§$§8EE{§ a "" Bgwezzgrg if geema, 3'28 §"§§é,§$§§§§ Béazﬁé .§'z§:'_:_"3 marg gragczsi: §?s:.>m she Lam ﬁasgagégétézws Sf'?%_Cer 9 'r:--- §E3.$;:§;v§:°§9§f~ Ea §;?:% 85585? §";§"iE%*£ {ﬁg §a:%d if? Qajgsiim §€{};'"+§4_€Q§E §§§§%«'",(:'s%"§. §%..%C§"2 a saaésséﬁ :"£§@:"i mi: be of m agga '=.%:f0--.§§*:é' §¥%§:;§§:":g 895:6, §§"%aS€'%'§E3fj§"3 3% 3323 game is an afier 3;"%2€:'€ E3 §%i'}i§E§§E§ am zegaré :2; shgw m: :;?:E: 5&3: §S %'e§er: égiéd :§§:1.:9§{} iS§LE€§ by {ESE Laraé §C=;§:i§S__§€:%G%"': Sffiger was frauéagéeméy Gbtaéned at wag faise. there was ma Gccasian for the Hmising BQar::i"f§é: mare remrif $3 afgrementéamei, asndéfmsimiéf'~.V_§'f:*;f:ur::%f3%éVnQes, acquésitéaré wag quashed marshy Eargd by thég Caurt came is be canfirmed in The §and {S§%'é@.3?:-3 was a marshy iand am was a%s3:;:}' a:--ssf%§§ V§}'é;*'j':-5%::;féaE§ '§*1..abi-'iatiaré ans Csnsitmctiaﬁ af §'%O§§§§§. "§'%:€€éf;_o;:*s'3_; %S aésa emiéiied is b§:---a«%§ma:§:{§i.a::::§ the a:::§.::_§_s;i:%0r": Qoiifécaiieng én reggeﬁ: Q?' ihé §a5':€:E..S'b.é5s'i§f:*§4'S=gg;.?§§i':':--.Sg36,32; 3&3; 3?,z':§ meagurégig 1 awe ? ."V"L»...§.;;;":ta§.;Aéﬁiié am} S235 gméfzas f"€S§€*C'{:E'£€§§/5 sétazaiaéﬁ

-- . _§f:'7'%444_3%§§§§5S8§§€§§§ Wiage; 'feiaéégséiég i-égbié aw Eiabia is @§ éawrdérzgéyg 'igifgéi ?&:é:§::::": §\«§§33éi':s{'f§§"?,f2§S2 ég "::§'§e;i;=%:*2€§:".§ 5Eg§ an ihe éfaramenzémeé aﬁéétégsﬁ gs'®a2:1§§ 25; in view 3? ihe 330%; ihé fééiawifﬁ made:--

Writ' petféiaag are ai!awéaF"--~.§:2d "iize §(::;::;';si_§?fé'é::'>.:?--' graseeaiings in respest Q!' the §a,n§:t_ :;2_;{0fzze:i--zT:2 gtfiese wr;'€ peéfficzng sigma' qaxaéféégi 1

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court