Ganapathi Dattatraya Bhat vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secretary on 14 March, 2012

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Ganapathi Dattatraya Bhat vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secretary on 14 March, 2012

Bench: B.S.Patil

' M

Efaé "?'%-§E HEGFE C§i}RT G? §<§xPi?§ﬁJ'§és§<£x
QRCSET 8§?x§€i% 1%? §§"i£\R§5=i§\E

SATED "mg T%~%E :47" my g? mag;-; 23:2 

BEEQRE

THE HUMBLE MRJUSTICE 3gs.MpgFr:.L   %

WeP:No.14?15/200? cjw wﬁi': ?1;QS--;_29e§%_" {1§_.V;Q._}'7'h IN W.P.14-715 200?:

BETWEEN:

Sanapathi Qa%::atra3:s:;.'E:.%'}ai,_«" , Aged abaut 58 years;'-- ~ ;

Rig Neelekeré, Kumta "'§"a%'L:§_<; 2 __ :..u<. 9§st:°°%:*:B " " "PE:T»ITIQNER {By Sri G§.avr§§a4p§:§:hi 3,sh,3§ty;;E.Adg.;E 1; ':._"?%2<:3':'?;t:a:§:'ja.f%<§%:*:;€a.§<2:; :3»; Trig §E£f§'?€::£3"¥;'~._' géygﬁzgvg §:§*}E§§:i?§'?;§Tf§§§%wfE'E, _ iv: 3; §i,§§§'§.§§'i§§"~.

§§nga§$§s:,_ _ .,%i'§*;.$'«i,,%§'--:3é T!"§§iEﬁ§§§ éiumia * §i;§'é:%?§.§§§§:ﬁa;2;

;%<:;?:f:?i§§A'T:7?§i:;§<§ i..§e§{a ms: 33 " . EP;,a§?:ag%:§:':§?§ §8€E§§"§§"§'§ ih£%§§§E;

' ééﬁggisfz Rm Naiieigsfg Kgmia T§§Li%;, L%§<f;. §%$%§'§£§;a 'V ﬁshaa Qgmakrégémg Edgy;

?4§3*§::

§:::j:;: 5L§§§§;§E éérigma 'aﬁiigsaf EN)

3. 9. Raaé, ﬁaimmgag Mamﬁaée S; Mangafabaé Achghgth Harikantrag Maggi RXO Neiiekerig Karate Taiuk;

UK, Bistrictg 5, Nagesh Manjayya Acharg Majerz R/0 Nellekerig Kumta Taiuk; __ V ._ {Mi Béstrici, ,,REs_PlG.NQENTS (By Smt:..K. Vidyava ti;a_ AGA f¢Lr._R;:i..& Ru-2; Sri V. F. Kumbar! Adar". fai'-'_R;~+3;§ _ R-4 & R-:5 served) '- _ i This ::%e'i:i':"';):€:itEC:.ré is 'féfeé :.sV:"e--§€§'emi%;rt§£§es 226 & 227 sf the Co:z::sii§t%,:iili_azfc sf..:r}:3ia, gzrayéng 2:9 quash ihe order dated 2§,6.:?;_GQ? "ipa$Se5};:£. 'E33;-' tﬁe"'respQndent N02 in §rQce,etj.%n_g"é\:§;:1.Z_36Q.-éé :_§§§§.<%:3§;4:S iﬁnrzexgreaéj, am em " . .

IN W..P.i"1;Q_5V "2'gg:;A_ QETWEEQ: _ . ' " .

Ra<:%;fza§?':ar%§;3$"§:%$ia:i;§::°°: ﬁagﬁeg A{'g~=éd isésisii' $3 yééfsa ' , ";5;GV £e.§,:ara4zi::"'?é_sgée; A REG '§'.§§*E-§.;e§'<;:%§*%.,.vV.'... '*%<a'z~%'*§*2ia,; ééftgzmééaf Qigiﬁii. H§§§:?:$§§ER {gag ,,s!:~.: %i R Eéismgga g%§:;§§ H 'iFE*:€ Siaig sf §<a?§":a?i§E<a§ Sag: $5 Rexgsszaigf 52%, 3 Suiiéingg ﬁaméééiigr '@3652; §§§'1§§§$f"%E --«-igéﬂ G3:

Rea Ea; its S§:reta?§{Cam§:%§$s§§m§:

Km) 2, fine §§°'1§§f;"§":§%"§, Lam TI"§bL§¥"'1§§, Kgmiag Kayway SE51;

3, Sr? Ganagaﬁzé Eattaireya Shaé, Ageﬁ abcut 55 years;

S/G Saitatreya Bhat, R/9 Ne3E§3<erEg Kgmta Taéukfg ' i<arwar Bistréciﬁ 42 Sr% Mghaﬁ Ramakr§sh':%§"'E.};Gia5;'~ . Aged abmét 40 years; " _ "

S/0 Ramakzisma SQ§3i" ,,__._ ' Cfo Udugi K?ESg}'?R.é§"%fE§{iAEag A BE Pg Rsad; §*s'iat%iz:=:1§.a,;- _ ;

Mzimbai '- 1

5. Smt %«'Ea'r:ig:«;fa§,s§fa§%a:§._ .5xﬁ;?*::;?§fLi%§§ %i§:?§§éa;%3:a,; §«ge;sﬁ"'avE3;6i§:..é??"';z_g§:*§.; " . W/is _z5;C:§Rl.~Z.3r'Li'€§': »i-i4a5's<ij§<a?r°:*:~a; V _.:Rg'.Q'§'i:e,ii'eié-;V3';:?§..,_ --. _ % "

§<um}iaf,'§fa§u'E:<:; .4 .

'-.%£a<:*a2«:§;:" $~¥'.§~::_2%§:eﬁ:»; --- ' ' §§ Er?§f%§§§e$%2_§v3;3r:j;§§%:h Rchggi,

-- ., Ageﬁ' a_§§s:;§c' SE"-'gas 5% Efa §V%a§?5:%"§if8f_ﬁ ,§»;.:h§?§§, 3-.§<';;'$"'§'?:i%§EeE<e:*§;;"

' ~ _ V .. §<;m:as 7'§_'§§::E<§ ' ...§%;;a_;§*%;":a;i:Vf{;§§:r%£: A ﬁ§E§§§Ei§E§'é*§$ %{§3%g Sr:*§§'§§§* ¥§§ya¥3%§; Aw; far as»: & Raﬁ; $?% ?;§;$$ §%:a§::*§; gay; 3%? $93;

53% aggifé Q: Saﬁhaﬁétg Aﬁga 2%? $5 3: ﬁwﬁg LL %§?§;:Esg té R4 iémssgh Asa;

'ﬁnés zasrii §§¥Z§'{.E§§? Es féieé Lmﬁer éﬁiséas 226 8: 22? is? the Caasiitgﬁiafz Q? Erzéigg §%""'§'*g'§i"E§ ié a;.:a$§°: 32$ aéﬁer zjaéeﬁ 2§3§§2§§? §&§§5@f $3' ism f"§S§%?":§€fE§ 3&5: $5; gmgeeﬁirag ?\§Q.§23§§~%«15§§§E==%-§.8é§=§S {A::n$;<:§:*e~§}§ am as' The %:"»;'§'§i §§'€§E§G§"%S ceming as %e? 1§E.,,§i"i§3€§' i%eajr'":;:§; mg Say, the Cmr: mgée iéze §'aE%ew§ﬁ§:~ .V QRDER in bath these writ §et§t§eng§,>AAb§%§}e'zsésy -:$a:j§e_;:3:§"i?¢§ §&§SEC§ by the Lam T:*'ibu%7;a%_; K:,}}::1té,. 3::

chaﬂenged.

2; ?€€§i§QF}€!"§é'*}_ §é: 't:hCé Gwnez"

Q? the ma bexirgg Syi_E§§;éE?LS;%fVéA'»%¥r§i'V_~:%j'easarirég in aii 1? Qmtas §E_*€:35'?§§:% ai3--_§<2%?"§'éa'%':?: i§1i'iar.§V.§Kamaﬁa Eistrici am the is daiming is he a te:@a:;,:$v:éVféid1T'Eé'_§g§:A%§'ev.i§d:.:'_b*g :?.éte gEra::E Q? §C<::s§an£*; eaéy in ?'€S§€3C§ 25% iifé' éf'<:.§fE'é;§.§@%:"s:§:*a:'§ hwge axciaaéiﬁg iieé sihe? Qsriisg ¥~;?§4§?g%2_ §$~a£§eg's;-zéév m his Gacamaéim §§ a iengnig F 3; '"._?:*7s 'vviéfévé Tfibgaaé %%'§'2§§€ ?'§j§*f;'i§%"3;§ the ,.

VEgg;%:éi;:%§::§V'=-%F§:§_é:s§ ﬁg! §'€S§Q§'"i§@§'%§§ M 3; £5, 3 am 5 Es':

%ii---%.4§,§%~?E'_§§;='2V@G?§ hag graniaé saszjgaaaas régﬁis A;ie§§§§::;%:éf E313 §"'%€:i§,§§€$ if: whégh %*'€§§§§%€:§§§??.Z$"3; § gag § é.é:f:6;%é3 resiéigégg $5: 2% grémé 3&5: iiéa §§%§5:%Q§E§§"£ V. ._..§a:*:ag3a%:§*é§ $§::air§'~;§ aha: ééaé §§§2§E;E?':§%§ far gffamg 33$: Eémiieé §'§§§"'%§§ 22%? gzaiéiéag §CCi,§§§§§"EC'§ %"'%§%'§i§ 3:':

sir' gag; MM» , w:""?:'"

«pv'"""€ 3%;

?'§§g§€€'?C gf {he §"'§S§§§§'2§§$§ i,§§'%§iT§ if': iéiaér agaaggaiisa, "ﬁzig Sfﬁﬁi' :3? $33 Lass Trébigégi Qasseé gr: E%£ﬁ1!g$®@_' ﬁg wgézgceé at .§§§f3€}<%.,i%"%~C*

4. Reggméenés 3 iﬁ 5 %:&re§;f:. ';--

mcugansy yightg $3 :'es§ec:*: ®f %:§2§..§r_;s4§erf':§,%"'§%é=§i§::é§f?§,ssii asniendirag ihai they are the e><%:iA:2s:§'§§e'TV€é:2a:éi;9 sf entire exétant af :3 Qantas s%" §i§ 'a-~':..g; '§;§?:v:;':=. aii they aggiicaiiezzs $3 ihe}(_...%};%:§::}_e"V%:§f§e :9%:2a:¥:.'_AC%;ai§?maﬁts am hag gassed ihe §V:':i'§V:e;igk¥*'*:%;«:§vf~}::;fdé2{f_ ﬁéaém made by ihe 4?" res§3;3r:__den§:""§éa<;:Z'::;:s§e.:§';..gféjvecééﬁiﬂs wﬁereas éa respect ®f§§:§:_§i§T§? §'r{;ay.;i e._g;:y--..":*éfgp§_n§ént$ 3,. S and 5; the T§V§vb:_s.s:a"'§'w._§és,%%%é-Egg:?:.ai»%he faﬂﬁ wag mat a ienaréiefd ie wafer Em ecsugamy righis Er: "';f§s§eci' _g ':'..*§'%"2:é_.'%~§'2:§:gse gremisag W§'§C?? §§ Ea _ $:§.:2§f:a ':§i:f: Sfv.§f"€:¥;i3V§ §'f§'§i§§?'C$ 3; S 5% $5 aiéggeﬁéy gm ihe »b;a*::i§ ::§i?:%e.§7§;:1_s€§§€ gizsan ms ihe éaréﬁ swag". $5 2% reasmg §S$§§§':$§ éfé iﬁﬁ «V §§@§§;:§.§2é::§ §§'"§E%'} §§"%% Eeamesj éééétégééai éawgefszmsszéz "..:L»..;&;a§:éVa::§;§:é wag Qéggsteé :3 gecagra :*§::$rd§ grzé Ea Swami:

§é;§2§e}:%x$? gay $Li€:?"E gigtemgéi was maﬁa $3; $3 E3536 m§}§zr?2§§ aarzgaﬁrzg ﬁe ;€§%2§§ cf yegpaaégaig 3; § 352$ 5 5% /is $4-5"»'3"'"2 «gw §;g§és$a?y sréerg :3": mafia €33" g€a;r1%:§r:§ sacaggaacy ﬁgﬁig in §'"€S§§§3§ 3? we ﬁsugé §?€€'i'¥§S%S Q§§§'g2 "%'E§E ieamgﬁ ﬁéé ﬁgs fféaﬁé aazaéiaéie the resaﬁsa ii gamgaé sf the yagarés as mi: é.%$:§:i{:,::§T&:-_ éhat am: gush siatemeﬁi was mags by {ﬁg §§§:£--.m%5%%é;'* ~ §e:§i:%®:*2:er: Gr: tine aiééer h5F2§;__.?3.€__§"£§§§' §é?§é;:§ %:?1}_&:€:' iesaanssy Ea resgeﬁ ef ihé eyzisre :'§:a;n=:;§_';T~'T?hé%%efr:§%€Q' very ﬁear 315% $18 Trémaai '2€§:s~..§as$é:{§' basis af the aéiegeé sagsené §_%%+£é:;:::.;b;a._7:A£1e..pQ:i§:'§_;3:3:%-iand ﬁvifﬁﬁiﬁ, which ES :23: 3"rV.'>1r"*i::§;a«'c€*s:w;:§_2f§;sj.";%' §r§%2§' %g§9je.. grfemrés, "Fine 'fribuizaf GiigE'ii i'G,__ éiayé' gr: meféts based an made aasaéiable §efar*ev_.;%:?.af5.S'E'a*7:<:::;"' %Vt¥sé:fg,_c§«r§<:{§' §:':«'.:%}ﬁ§.»E:":'*:a*:te:", As gush ar: exeréige 'ES 'ﬁe §??'E§i§§!%€§ aria:

Qaservgé .§~?_ 4' V zfl:'5c::::~é§_;:_§§%g, £213 writ §€§1§§§§$ 5% disggssaé »$};f;--» _f§"%f*sVe'«.§s":*%Vj§:.:§?2e§ arse? Eg §&: 533%, 'Fm matiar is rs;%r:§.'¥:':§§'%:::§..i:f;=éE,.a?:§ Tgitxzeséaig Kgmza; :§':':$:*5 Kaarzaégg g 53:' §;*s;sV'i"1;V:€e%:;s%:de:*§:§:::'2; 'a::%:%: 5 §§;r§:%:§§:"2 1:3 ;§§"§'2;'§é§ §%'€§§'% "..j»..§Tg,;:ig;-%:;€::zV§:§i'§; E3 égih gaﬁéeg am %:%":%§*eaf§§§° §a§$ wxwmwwamwmmwmwmmm.mw...W..m.m..m.w~. ' _ _ . "mg BS 3 21f3392§}2 B"

awe: as Saga 3 aim E3 3:; WE F~§%'$. m::%;2s@?A¥{;f;§';* ~ H Cfw '§sé".R :;\3& EEEQSEZQQ7 These wrii petiziezgs hays 'a€<--:::1 <:iiSf§§:~s~:.6é $5 0:n"'§}--§,é'}53;§;_?i{§§EZ._V 2 remiiiélzég 313 matter is ':he 13:16 '§§§§;;:*;.2§:.:,_T A' --.f<:: cmzsideratiaﬁ by gsreéséciizzg 9ppsriz:niiV§'%:a¥:}V:'i>Qih Wrii Eﬁeiiiisxs same $6 be b}r'%f:éfe5V'. '¢§:*a;iE'fe :::g§::g Q16 sréer @3355 53' fhs Lang': 3:: respect 9?

93:63: the area wheg ssnsirzscigé whicia ware aiiegeﬁiy E21 Eespeci aaf the mks:

arm, 15:26 T:*%'bi;v2§:1aj._ gﬁg-i'§$E:E%ﬁ:}a $531; $5: mspes: Q? the M3336 §E6i'E3§S€S €£§:.:=:_ '§;':°ifb:;:;*:f:a;§' :§:a::_§;f<:c:%$deé is gym? @C*;:%.:1§3EECjJ zéghis %a;;,.:;£é ea %;'Ei:é:; aﬁegsé Q@5§;$§§_;§;__A$€%:aEeé :3 image 566;': giveﬁ E}? ma awrze: §-:;2f'g:g:":':§§';g. sgagéw §§¢é;2§g§§:; righigg §2:1 3% far 33 33% iegeséiezz Q? $13 ' V' '--._;:3g§ié;2 ﬁg yﬁéfgegg ":_;%¥1§%e§ §G§§3:G1E $5 Eaaé, ﬂiers $3 EEQ ghaﬁsﬁge by Eézs ~ . 'f{;;?~Z";§_.§'§"~§$ sxgsgivvéy 3% SEE Raggaghanéra $$§i§,'E3;Ei'%§'§f%$. Esgéﬁ aﬁka E135 '":.:§3§é$ﬁ"§.§% g:::::a3 if: 33 Ea. i§§%§:£Eu%+£B. ?h€?€§§?§ ii Eaag 'Se E56 www gééégﬁ 1323.: {is <3§és:* Qf ?$§1§§§ gaagsé 79:! zbéa Qguzé E3 Ea '£36 <;3€§3?

mzzﬁzzeé :9; ﬁgs €§IES§5:.€§"3§€}3TE 35 $36 éaém if GEES? "éazzamg aﬁgsz' 1513:; $313 §e*:%*ti5::e:£Sr% Ramasha:::§:°a Sseiharama Eéegés 2:1 EEE@§52{}§? @323 E3: §'§S}:'}€C'£ $1? 'S16 arsg where {E16 E39336 ;§u:>é5§1%,$:5é'$'L:'%;*e<e%a~::-T * €:GEESEE'E;iC§€§ wherein ihﬁjg' are aﬁegeé is haa€::"c'0n:§§V:2}$d _§§"t{cc§§a:§¢0:é;.. E3': 3% far as Rarrzachaizéra Sesihaiama Hggée. is §e}:2$3§E:eéi~;;_' *i:i;:é'._ agpiisatisrz ﬁe: £36 :::'::i::e exéierzi GE 19 'g::.:::::**i£3%s has'-ﬁg %;:Ae_"::s::::§%c!ef:*e:é as he has cgaiéengeé the E@§es:§g;§;'~~Q§ his $3923-:23; §;§~._;:;es§es:"A03£' £313 ®§'i$f €§C£€§Y{. V in ihe fsgufé é';i§a'1<',=":*:;§$:f ;3.:[;35s!e$:§,__ '7i"éj;'iii*:§.s C3125: SE1 §4%a{);ga.!2$12 S§&§1§S fl'§Qéi§$5' i{} §;T'1&'.§:téf reméiieﬁ Ea '£16 iazzé "§:°Ea1,i::g§ Kamiia E-££ia:';1 i¥<. §::§:ae:~";a:"'£3%'s:r§c£$ fa" f§f§S§'%, £§:z;3§d€ra%:§@:: £3? 3' ? ~, 4. '.

'me {shim :}§--é'ij:€ g3Qé%§.§§0£::e;::* 3:: 'EXP. Nag E?'i§;§§Z?:§§§'? far £335 €§Ti'§',féfE $}<;%:§::€ iaaé. yagarﬁs €323 Gihﬁif' teaaﬁég Wiis have £385 ;§.§_§'EE§;;°5:::;««..V;_~».f§a2:°:§:"'"ééaisﬁ $?§:§ £33 fasgsaié $5 'aha ﬁﬁiiﬁiéi sf éheéf 71T§:::;:;§a*:£,2:£"<3€::§§$ ééaagé ggrsmigss SE33 '$3 gagséderﬁé. ' -.'%>:'T¥v';'.V wmammmmmmw»mmmw.mmMm.m.'M..WW'._ .. ,

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court