Central Administrative Tribunal - Hyderabad
G Shiva Shankar vs E.S.I.C. on 16 August, 2017
IN THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
HYDERABAD BENCH: HYDERABAD
"* Noa, O2 6742017
dated TOOS8 2017
BETWEEN:
1. Gr. Siva Shankar
So. Narayan Rao,
cs ~ Hospital Sanathr
abad--~ LS. By. Plot No aT
% iL HME! Nagar,
Nacharam, Hyderabad ~ 78.
{3
Soran ancy Rao,
a. Venkata Ramanaiah,
Pek VEEPS,
Oco: Radiographer. sore Medical
a
Sed lege Hospital, Sunatiiagar,
Nydere bad--- 18 8, Rio. HH. No.) Pag,
Na aL. ake \ row Ag
AY runddava Road No. Olt
Hyderabad ~ 68
. k.. Rarunakar Reddy,
0. Joseph Red ay, :
aged about 32 wears,
adiog rap sher, ESIC Medical
ABA ane "Hospital, Sanathrager
Hyderabad ~ TS, Ro HUN. 466,
Wacharam Village,
Nacharam, Hyderabad ~ 76
Apt
a Soabhan Babu,
famedas,
= Radiourapher,, e8i0
< 7
; Hospital, So Far,
Hyd lerabad ~ - 18, Ryo Flat No SO? F
"SIC St att Hues
Apmicants
The Union of India rep. by
The Principal Seoretary,
linistry of Labour and Employment
Shram Shakti Bhavan,
Rajeev Mall, New Delhi.
= Phe Director General,
Employees State Insurance Carporations
He read oe HIE,
Lad
. the Medical Cornmigsioner.
Mew, Branch Head Quarters Office,
EAT Corporation, Panchd sep Bhavan,
CG Road, New De this 170002.
Ss
for the Applicants > Air, PLS. Ramachandra Murthy, Advocate
Counse
|
Counse
forthe Respondents --; 8 gat eee
Hon'ble Mrs. Minnie Mathew, Member (Adma,)
OR AL ORDER
(Per Hon'ble Mrs, Minnie Mathew, Member (Admin):
Heard Mr, PLS. Ramachandra Murthy, learned counsel for the applicants. Nore for the respondents even in the revised call.
2 MA.SAM2017 for ling single OA is allowed,
3. The applicants submit thet they are presently working as with Grade Pay of Re 2400. mer they were sppointed as Junior Radiographers in the scale of pay of Rs.3200-4800. They contend that the i leak si Ly oe aforesaid pay scale has been enhanced and thai they are entitled to the revised pay scale of Rs.d600 ts Re 6000 CV CPC) whic Rs. 5200-20200 with Grade Pay Rs2d00 in the VI CPC.
agerieved by the non implementation of revised scales of pay.
similarly placed employees bad approached the Central Adminisirative Tribunal, Poncipal Bench , New Delhi in OA2908 & 2996 of 2014. The BY said OAs were allowed with a direction to fix the pay af the applicants e therein as per the recommendation of the VICPC in pey band Rs S200- S0200/- with GP. Rs. 2400s. subject te oulcame of the Writ Petition pending A before the Hon"ble High Court, New Delhi.
Sve antes pea bees PES z oeetetes ee oy kt eb Hceuyis submits that the order of the £s Principal the Jaipur, Bench of the Contral dated Q6.12. 2016. He alsa Administratere Tribunal im GAM submits that the applicants have already given a Tepresentatien on O24 2017 ta the respondents to extend the reliet ihe Jaipur Bench as they were simuarly situated and that the matter is sul pending consideration before the respondents.
| have considered the materia! on record and Annesure-AV tudgment Aft OLS dated of the esordinate Bench af this Tribunal at Jaipur in O4.0¢ O56. 12 2016 which is extracted below:
so The contraversy is covered SQUA the Tribenal in Jaipw & ab in OANo.2 291 10068 FRAQLE SOT QOS LOT Teas also isputed that the claim of the apple:
alse covered by the judgment af Pe CAT. 3 19.04.2016. This Tribunal in the al forementioned Jue pe aged in OA.No "91/0009 1/2014 an the issue, Directions in QA.No Sole as "under.
ef "and x whee HES Bre ew Delhi order dated ments particularly OL& have settled an 27.1} 20S Ee Ly oe * > rr, nen, tise ite Ext} ed Capemet at ewes ns 'a wee oe oe rae cI 'gaa Ax pe a 'pak Soy pe fee gr ved wen pone) . "et ees " peed yen poor ine , " ws pe too peo nt Speed So. aes "heed ' on " ay a pay Nm a ae Prat ee rs 4 the " Poon oe ty ORL cA as that a mee " " ge qened st 'ale Po pe 44 ar he ge pa "adh fox me : we ht Lows Pr, whe 4 G coe Sy lo ye oe mS ' eas tae Ps anes Paes Fal : rn rs et "dood Set cond oS CE: 'chane a ; pees ae par re, wae Pon nee , ca] 45 Dood at pa) "ae Pood or ea ae oe eed heed 2 ate om. ey aan ty . Cer hee, bias Pre era, ee yas faa "eee 43 fear mes co "reap fot ee, ene Ay an . 'ad aie "hess = eA fa "-- Sd ra le + vo.
"ack "ak o Foes can ar rr aa Bs poe bas ty aad a hate paced ar tad 5 3% . om a teed, - : vee (aes ater ro ? ee ay oe > pened, ate goad sheet od as 'ait my ~ ORS ran fete Hee : "i; Goa . 'ef oe wi ge = M0 ps Ane sre ny or ay a " a, pam nes bs a wit gases " eet bop, SS nh, d Ag tee ps ice wes a age oad fe nae Paced ; pet ed bed ene pans ao ane OSG peso oS eee bse ete, F, pees Poa Be Se ' oe ¢ o a set os 5 & "pe i "ent "et "e oly ro ma we od A . nee oe ad ' Eee aS * 4 ; tad ee < ioe ae et ty AS & F ~ & bk as oS a ya Kaa ace, ted nw . 4 ew | tad oe £ fener paers = ™ : ay - on aS eB Ne canes ° et teen 2 ea . Sot Peed e of, ty on veaears mad zy ors, gh od hod G&G Fac oe oe erg oa nd Stn haan Sat , Bes 5 62 son UA te ye 9 eoc' A 'spine evel , cd "y bre pewnel Set ae on ih s Pu aaa é pe 43 a Spocey teed a. TSS an % Oe tg oe ae a ca open, ead eet oe Ay : 2. "led 4 pe boss ed get Eo oe we Ww «i aoe 'od 4 ah re ocd spe 65 TP Sees ot eo "Ta av) wey a card spee Le an att pas B3 haces ay rer os, nah or os 4 ha a3 . a i es ne ' ieee bes oat et s ey ae. ros re me wt, tm fe ee Be & we 4, a a eee ee . ps _ B Sabet ile is "ee age, : paar er; - ns m e Aly Slot OO ; ooh} fo fat he :
- " ah ps "3 . sera je eee gv.
toad Sy he ~ bee 'eg wn om weed song an 49 Be : oe . # dees"
set da ae on of os a oan peek ied week vs te a4 ey anaeel aoa as we hi a ing re hay oo z trons oS we ot pa we bend a we be an Peter fr i 'ct wh Me : 2 pay We tod wf coe, 5 * net toa é dot pperey ed vee Fes oe no BY 2 mt nn a ee os a ey t ap Ft Laas . ee od ne ScD MY an os Ze ity @ ent Toa "tne od at vt, an : $e Pa sot 2 ioe om Fak eed eet aed & bar re wee a, -- = po ea ene a faa pn pet a) we pad Pe Bat es 4 3 S nA y bags * a3 Cae 23 ated ngpent, oe tk tr ba epek gets od mks ben 'ol tes See, a vee eas ae aa ee os rd Ry gn Fe co] coe re OC f. pas pay om ' ae ° eae] Pagel % re, Feed "head. z one a baer = , Sony : ;
oe ee ne TS up ceag of ede att AY on ~ co er aed - get nai bese LPS we na F ae a Ot fe & Fi Be a 2 7 tk" Soot oa fee, a yee sing -- wee Bp 5 2 kes Soe hea eee "he. fot es " Shes et wee int hos hood + bee phy Sk iy Ye ; 4k vee poets ' os Bp MAE stn, "at ay SS ' pas a mm thd par be on cms par ; fe "a mae on fg aa eee wa Fs = ae gk Be tee ™ i port "ade "
pe So a3 tet in ws, as 3 val i ae a ewe Bs tag oa Px 3 , Cy spook ore os ciack ies 2 a oF &, © s * os G % ting Ce a ae " ih 2 pany Si ' g tai) ; Mr as aes * pea Bs vere he a) A ; ty Ty te oe os at es oe "a cop ee : nf ns + "< a sone or ee Eoseal ped & a f Leos. wees pass] Pawns Kor roo fond pn aoe . cal bar : ey ea bared ipce! z Ese " omg fo pea £3 og oS 2 ~~ vege . pees cont cA vee e per oe Boy Tagg reine ree Eee a rar % fae oe; ee veo a Pe ne oe 4% ey £ 4 oe:
4 wt fered BA . Sed "ee A = ' ed eae"
yD teag E . Cs, the poo os oben et pal fo, a aie ken , <u a YE ae eed hot ae y ce, oe OD a oa