Karnataka High Court
Shriram Gajanan Hegde S/O Gajananan ... vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 September, 2010
Author: C.R.Kumaraswamy
Bench: C.R.Kumaraswamy
SE~¥Ri?:--'§::>T :
M55}?!
IN THE HIGH COURT 0?' KARI\"'AT'AI€..&
CIRCIEIT BENCH AT GULBARGA
BATED THIS THE 2ND gas: or SEPTEMBER. 2014;?» L
BEFORE
THE HONBLE MR; JIJSTICE C.R.KUMAR£;SWA§z§'f"~ '
CRIMINAL PETITION N0. 9'1o3_'_<3r5' 2G1 G~
BETVNEEZN
2. SHRIRAM GAJANAN E-%EG§E: .
Sm GAJANANAN Ramgxriaain-E' «. "
AGE: 40 YEARS ' 5 .
occu: AGR:c.U:;:*U'RE ' "
R/Arr MULIEKERBZ
HONN£*»..VAR'Fg" V
E{ARWAR, mg'; ' ff «
2. Gr&3ANAP%§2§ * . " "
s/0 §?J'aI%./E:E'i1?Zl3*C§E3
AGE;68Y§E§ARS3-- a .
OCCU: AG17{*.ECU_E;E'{ERE:«. - T
R/Air: Ea/§E3LL.£<;:§:'«;RE: ' " "
"fig: E--§C)N;NA\?AR._
mgr: Ksxzaxmaéz '
XS/01 E»;-«%_ Ei~.E{§DE
A{;%::«*; 32? 'YE§2'%,_R;E~§ " .
<}{ZC U ;a<:R:{:.z;:.;':%;';?'§z;§::
E-'~?gz';i'{f' E\A'i§L§.E<ZE{§=§?_E~%'§£
TQ: §-§ic;3.1~»¢1\fJg;\,s1';t;,..1?z...~"
' ':}§s?; §<ga_§2im.:z
' §;;%;r~g;;;s;§5m:
S-g'_{:. {};k;:'f:NzXNA §~§'§§;::}:>'s3:
y_ ._ 'jgazs 42' '{§3§xE*€E§
<}{if{§E_§: E';§§{3"§"L_EREi
.. _ '224»m%:" $;a{;;§§2
6'
r~*
TQ 8;'-X.CvA.R
BEST: s£~§.2M<.';£.:;=,L
<3EL?\E(}AE)}-{AR
8,10 GAJANANA ETEEGEEE
AGE 40 YEARS
OCCU: 'TEACHELR
Rf AT SHEEVEOGA
XHST: E5}-£11':/{{)C::'%;
KRISHNEK
SKCE GAJANANA,NA E-IEEGDE
AGE 39 YEARS
OCCU: 'I'EACHER
R,/AT E'»'IALs\(3«§ '1'AE_,{E§€
SIRSE TALUK
DIST: KARVR/ERR
SUIMA
W/O KRESPINA H1?';G§)E<: V
AGE 34 Y}:ARs~i» .
OCCU: ';'EA{::=£E.:_R_'. .
R;,fA'}:' MU?~,?DEZGgX'E'E . "
K_AR.WAR,' Jngszi '=- ~
<3?-:E~;'1"§-m. V
WfO?'AG;§?§E$EA{ ' . "--
AGE 38 Y'E':AR:"3., ' 4' -.
OCCU; §~Z.Q'{JSE:\7§fEFI3Z "
RfA;'§'8AG}1R _ x
§}§§S'§' SHEMGGA
«, $§i§AS§3i':§§AE._..A
'WT/€3._V1f§Sf*£E\§lf.._
.._T;a<:A;:.«::--5 Eazigrasg
R_;A*:1* 53.23;: g_§KE~EE:E}
A .'_'_§*Q: E*§.53N?€:.%';VA§%
E*>E;€~:@*::' éézzziéxafzaiz
, E¥'1A?€;'s$;=3s1
V ::~zz<> ssi~£R§E>.:a;>
'«..;::€3E; 32 YEfA§'€$
{EC Ci? : §*§{}U SEi':«*J§F§§
E91 ,3 37$? ?'¢E'iIE,,-L£%§{§§§?{§:
-3,
A51.' PREZSE-N'i' E5§'T§£M.{}{}£-1
DESTI SE*§1MOG}\_
SULEKEA
Vv'/' 0 G-AN(}ADE"¥AR;
AGE; 32 Y£§;'\RS
GCCU : E-1G{IS§¥.';EK?I FF;
R1' AT SHIMGGA
DEST: SH1E\«'£GGA
{BY SHE DHARMé§Sf*£'§{E°;-E: AS$OCI.A'i'EZS, $§§}V'S} T A iv
AND
E.
Ex)
{av SR: Suisgggazé E§v€;駧§I;vz§E)UR;_ E-:«;':{:=p}
E'?-HS ::%§+:m> :«*W°:,>--"'zI,z's3. -/38:3; 5}? {:::::§w:.: BY 'E"E€E
_ £?&E}V€}}:3.{A'§'£§A. :~?*r:>§~:f" A.'._§'E;§§»_": §r%:«:*:'§':*:<,>::\;I:-::e E»'RA"{E§*€G 'TE-{;'¥'£' 1%-£15
"E@{>N*:;3.i;E a;3Lr:;:vt;.:;v:*§::' mA&>"":3'§;':>:,z«:;as>s:a::?; "rm A:,,:4.{31xs *1';-as E-'E-"l'F:E'E'§<';sF\,I
".AND'«{§§EJ£S}"E.'?§§§£-- i~1N'E'IRE PROC§3EéiD§N{§S EN CC NO, };.2};E3f2{}€38
'§:§;;ri3sf;2:.:z%:G_ 'v';*§»»i;~:"_j;P::',:; 0;? 'E'H'.E§; EE ,§:E}E}§.,.. ..,:1x...rs:«*<:, <;:::,§sAR<,2A,
'm:~: STATE? 0? K£'%RNA'§'A§{A V'
is? sUB~iNS§>BC'i'<:>R OF' §'O§,§CE€
MAHELA FOLECE 8'i*za*:2'@£x:' = "
GULBARGA
SEEXVEIE-IA @ szwzmg H _ _ V' -- ~
W/G SRIRAMP;'G-{&NzXEiANE¥ Eriflflififi, .
D/O SR: KREStE*§£5§' Rm'; E{mgKA}"?£\3I u
Rzgxgr BEESEBESS :'§r1'~.<1;E.';;:s'~ GP :§1:a::3:.A :~f-f:E:Pc;R*':f3
N0. 3__--;__0;"'1 S:?x§1Eg§,$X&'.¥§'If'}*£I" "
Go:f;AM ,';:x:;«fR@-z~'sfi':* 09 af§?§AZ§ Ié¥;§'§11:A.
GUI;BA}?:'3:A"--" ..
' ' RE1SP{}E'€E)E3?€'£"S
;;.~.£..r
A?€E3A A3,: ::a;;2%;~;.m §>:z:}€;:2z:§}§:\:<:;&§ ;>z§§2$:§mx:*§ ':*z»a§«:§{§:':*<>¢
"-ifizig'€;'Lr§:é'1i.§:z:§ §}&é;£:.i.::~r"; aiamingg an far 21{§m§$$:é0:2, %;'.Ei:;%s
'(fizzy Ehfz gfafirii mzléiifé ihfi §e§§{W.::i.:§g:
fit' ,-=
a
%,j'
#4"
ORDER
'§'§:1is C:'§mima.E §€:t3t:.i0n is; flied ¥.£."fl€§€3E° Sect,;1<m_ of CKRC. pmying :0 aflew this?» pmiiiian ané qliéififi proceédinga in €PC.N@a,E25E/2008 §ending 0:1. 'i3*:eV ' the 3 Am; gLM,E«*1€, @u:baa~ggm »:14:1ci.}.i§ pmc::e<-:<:§ir1gS pm':a;uzm':: :}1@r@€,(x 2, The elder sheet Sf 'i:3ffi:~:_COur: .d::s>:$;(§LE_0s5é:Vs'VV2:T3 Eifidé-31":
O31 30.G'?.2G1@ :E§;e__..:.Fv§.%3;gf»?s:i;rai€ was &irec%te& * :m:. §:e%ce¢g- M tiE§"""$b{,G8.281G. an zm8,2§m; 12fms;iV§2i9éeA'%;m§ 5:; 305682820 there Wag rm re:preser1i:f2:§.io2';3;9:1 Eschaxfi of 'aha pssmiorzers. Ev<~:_r:
"VV"E€}'d21"§3'\~:.£}:f;.E;re... $3 ':*'':.:3- ---- ".'E5t"'§)§'(fSff§11I,&"i{£(3£7i cm. beihafif af }:2§3é:'§é§<§:1.é:**:s;_j .
V. .§ '.?;'éV¥\§'€3 hezéféi {ha Eezzrmsd Caizifi. '~w__€Z'z£;'v::~:°r:_f::¢2%;% ?':€:~z":é@'r far tfzéa Séate. "§'E3.e§*€§::}'ré;: § 1%-*':3.5~,: 7::;,":.7ié3"§;%'§Li'éTi§§"§€{§L €13 psruasé €,E:é: §_§§"{}i§§E{§E§ Ei§"§:§€f{§ in ihéi pei;,ii'.i<m.
under:
{1} {2} {4} _5_ 'E'h€ gromiszis zzrged in €;E:1«:% pe€;i£.i0':": gm: 8.8 Reading of {he cenzpiamt daes -net {§::;<;E1?§:S§f;f' any Offfiiifiifis Avermenm made 1;": ':,he1;C0m5pri..s;1§*:_i, éi0@_;§,":1£:§ 'V fLflE'iE ihfi', §r2gredic1'2i..s Sf flag é:;-ffém:e.;:2E§€:g;s:«d; A readmg cf the er'1'fLi>:::§§%'c 0:"11piE21.i.fAiiT the matgriai 5Vf.";;':::«3»§./*8 \/IV-it"»';3:'I«{3 :9 'Same 1'flél'{,§"I§1'I}C)}'}.§£:1§ betweezz the pe.€.iti0ne;r~-- 1'§0}f§ ::?:€Sfi€}é:§5退r1t No.2. r:50r::§3§ai:1'i" is'r1Q§t 'b'{:--nafid€ GEES, bui fiimg if £0 Eiarass iha pé3?;3§%.'£e:i§19:;; W «V '§'h§é . E9:-s.m'<%_:§ '.z:5°{'E£1§§7i-Siféiié hag faikzd ts u.£:0r1s"1s::f.§:V:V'V €,h§: §a{:i:s and s§r(":u:7";$t2maées sf ?.§§€."CaiS€Vv;;'fi §fl the dczzituments §3:'é:)é:a,2.§:<2d in af 'ihe sééargfisheaéz and "Qif§i'hG'Ei§ 2¥i§;;f§§?i$9~i§{:';§ Q? mmai £2,223 taken <:{}g§":é..:é:a:':{:€ §:«'§'§;he Qffeznce afifi issuefl szsnmmrzs ':1; the ' -- fietitianer, 1'vE<,3s%;'=;; :3? éghéi: pe%,'fi.'§;_§s':»:1s:':'§"&"; §3:%:"s':;Z::": zim: ::'e:?:':sés:7§§:_";g§ Em z"§§.:"§'?::--:'<:::'1"£', §3.E::{':es; :=:'§:2:':;_,§W§z?:'.E': i:'E.":{2駧° fa;-amiigf "~w/ members having theiir Qwrz avasaiion.
Except staging §h€::i':' p1"€S€fl{T{f in Compéaént nathing is: afieged. zigainst {6} in Mg-C. Nazi/Q8 ii; is §3<3t.§%;§(mer :3<;%g--§1<:ci.ed .:;i:":ei§":ie;:;,eri;c:{§" iE';<:é=.} respimgient wfihénli. rea,i~;{}n§~:a.'§<>?§e {%:'s::v1'és::§ 2:.;1:;§"«. he also refu 86:51 _ ' " --~ ._:0 "r§1V;a=L§;,:f}'ie:§gziA vh<~:;;~ Responéeni No. 2 E*:;%;:7s ftaE{é:'1'3 T 'd€ffé:e'nt versian in "E'hiéV; ;:IiVé1tter E1I'iS€S O":3$'{; ' " = . éf : .. §1:.atrimoniaE misurxifiersiafifiirgfii. is sf civil nafixra f§'?£§é ' v.*';n:;i9:§e::§;:é§"~___ {Bf _' the itamplaiiat daiieé
38.§..2.2Gé3.'? « disetvééyges?'~..f:'E:_ai:.--~ {Em marriage betsveem Shriram Ftieggsie '2mc:'.~_S2;:;?'ii%2~£1 iawia 'gfiaa<':€: (:33. §6,fi?.28t'j's€::"'- at Sri R.;§--;naé::E:andf£:§::_r }_'R5€a€;h, H9sa':;ag»;a_r '§"3;1U}i§ accerdizsg %:§§'¥:§f}§:3 E':i%i§i:x:§:VjL':«..._;t'%,1s€£}:"§1sk Khan: 35 éayg Qfifif 'LG the :1~:%;*sg:%;r§:.";§;;e:,"§:'.:};?:;V:§ §';2:f@::i;.s Q? élhés h:.:s_rfB5.né {3€i*§'§E€i§."1§§i'{§ E3 '§;{}}i{:i$ 0? gikéd 3;:_:*1a€.;fE1:§S%1.:'3€af§8S,?~ (:a%&: A9: 33.6 iime sf mszrriaggfe A §';:::;re:'zES £3? §;%"as:: {f{}I'§"£§3i££i§"§£H}?; E22'-2%: gizfégzz 22.22 iheié z:a§E:%{:E.&2$ _ 3 _ and fulfilled the i'€qL1§E'€I}'1€§}tS 2:53 diacmased? For abaui, '§X>i----'O :f1.10m:hs immpiainzmt was Eaokezd xxziéii ané t.h€rez;fir;r husbazzd 'W213 abussin->" and 3211;.-'in F that she éa ., £3 . . .
knmv c:<>{}E~:ir:g; Shift is; £101: E:s€:2:Lzi.é§ui a.:1dM_:éi£1ti:i€s 42.3? campizxinani, rlaméfiy R2-mirav E,::ikfa fir;«i '7uVr:1{:1§%.__"705f _ €:em'p£a§r;a:{1t Radha ~»~ mofizer of'-ACé3mpEa.£:§.aA:§tA' aigc? R3.gh'upati Purohitr uncie sf c<3'§?:;.§'}i;1i:1a:i%*{:éji::1§é aiigé told ':0 the famfly membéfa .E:1'v_,$ba.:1d A "£3? the campiainant net to ilifiéreafi Sirgée' -Vcamgiainani was ssuffermg %.':%€}§':3:fi" fi1f§3i'f:E'1::}£ %:é2:?._i?':':§.:S'?'c>:»3.1?1é {ask hey is} viciizfifi ' fi§:¢.z'€.5IEfftS "f:=7:§;e:2'L1'=%3':€5"' <>r1"""'"2'V'?:EL2GG'? and an i5.J;2i,2{}v!0?'-- 'aéf ':.m*':1¢ {he :t<>mpEa§;na2it.'$ husbzznd, AF:1ré£heI'>--iIi¥Ea€a?."aéfifi sister~ir2~§2::W Came £10 iha V Apamnéégs Exzmse Gffificiirzi amé teéd Eihai ihsy WEE} maize {er éii¥@ 'Jf'{:e, 2%: €3"A§_ at fimé: the sampigimanfg u:":»::E<: Ramrav "§{i%,i'EE»§::$r§:§'--v.»_"2a§i::§TV '=rf:eigh%9:,:}:' $3351': ;§E'1§,€}."V€};"}.€3'%i ihfin c@m;§§*::i§2e:1';%ffsahtzgbzarazi 'm"<>§;.%:a3rw§:'2~E2m-? amé ss§s;'£:€r--§:1--
-- Ezra}; §'§€.':E{§ "$3165 '%.é,:{'é. s:}£°?i:%1e: <t<.::§":pEz;;.§§':::.m, zzami §.§'}{;¥}7 fg3:_:§Ea>£i Eéfirf' " ;i.::;c§T;aT3:as<--~:"ci7 E26? sagzizlg éirzaéi, {:<>§:1pE::i:2§:§:§: 3:225; gm géiace ii: x"
-sf9wv'""
-3-
their house. "fh€r€f0r€ this; {'f(}}C'fl§3§E1i1'1i is iociged. Statmg ihzzt Shri:"am_'$ bmther'én»Eaw ami sisi'€r--in+Eaw :?121V€' i1fi~ t.§'€2::.e€5; her.
5% 3:"; the bagis {>5 {this <:c:mpE:é_..iv1§.'¥:.._Vfifime Nafig/200'? was 'regi$te§°ed againéfti ih@T«g§;é4Cm§§z:'d--. Shriram, A€3C'i,lS€d N02 - .(:}«';1J.§':.?,i,E1E1.i"1';.v_?$_CC{IiS€{i'V .§'§O.3:'§- Shripad, Accused NO.4 --- G3;f:és§3.z Ac5C::VS§e"d $0.53 - Gangadhazu Accused Naif?_5~"._E{:;_§vs§1'a*:;:,,'figcuged $30.?' M Sudha, Accuatxia N0.:,,...,_g- ";.z'%;é::'{:useci No.9 Siéashikaiaw.A9i§~:{:%.z§§::§ :Ef.ff3.fi.;;i7sé1 amd Acitusezi Rodi la-_ S1,§1駧f¥§%«,_.VfQfV§::i€_ :::f§§:3r1{:e punifiiabie :::r1d€:"' Seittieri - 3'»<1"'ELV"7J§':L'§{.z'¥.};'V.'.3§4«9 323? 504, 506 1"'/W S@<:i.§€_§n :~i%~§ fif §'F'§§ @E1 the Qamfiaini of Savifigaa ., HQ . ii ::"«._ ";;7"fis:?::éjgntemtg ef the shargeahaet rexraais that i:0m§:§2m"::::.miij_--'~«.;x:a$ haérassefi in c::";':::§€€:i%9:f: wiéh ::§0w;:*§;' " 'and §';:§'§'.V__"§','a,:fi "§-E-*&}.E:'§ puéiegi by éhés a::t§:us€--:{§. Aiiegaifiam T ::12::i,$,5:z: 'ihaé <t<}'mp§:=;§21é, Esiaias ':5: :;§:3w:"3:* h.2':§"E§;S$EB;€:':§"§§1 211$ «Q g_'E.ié<; {§{>m<::§":i<: v§<§Es:*:":{:€., Eva: "éhé: 21E§§;*g2i2.-fi.m:Z{:'::2 mzaéiéi 1&3": i:%";€;§ ,~»"/' 1;'t'~.x'fr _§@_ p€iiiiianers-~9§cused. it is weii Settiefi 13%? that ghis Cami'? $3131 exercise inherent pewez" under Seciiam. :=;i?:h 6333 cam and Qaufififi and in rareat {sf ~ assess This is :19: a rarest Qf rare .s':94s.e'xx.ri3.'7eréV'thia: Ciczigift V can exerciae inherent pawer undef-Se§:?Aiiij¥21 iii}; {he Qfime.
8. In the reguit, E §é;$S t.he:fQ11QV;iifigA:
This Ci'ri:":;.i;'>:;駧"E?1e:itzi:27§"iS" di'sf:1:§ss&d. interim stay grar:tadi.:Vear1§i:é: g_--:1 {)5 £5; éracaieda . V'