State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Lilabha N Gohil vs Sbi on 27 July, 2011
tn'-J:
.'§vi;:'. KAs\§.S§':a.'n~, Em" 1's~.'Er. 3L3:.I§?:¥...P?.ma:1:E., Lid, SEi§_§'s'(3$Z3£'i's§£3 fiias' 'ihe ;s;;:;ne~§§a::t ~.
3... ;fi:r':i2§g E11;-' s.m..<§ =13. 'wéiii ii';-E by 3£<'ian:m,_ ,<é:.;:s.:m:i' €3:mr;;:sz;::::2:r (3§§£2};;sE;1is:.=;_ .No.«.;'§»3 :11»? E§3i}8 zfissiafi .§:§¢3.ai?r{}'{.%'£§ 'v.--*I:.1».::Aé§>:»~ Ihrazm s:.ams= .19 £3322 sttxnwgzimkzséig §ir:s§$ pz=z:_fmi;-xii ha: appmlissmt cm. t§1.<:-- _g:*+3~t:21<is 5:32:66
-3 ilhv'-'=' >:2§es?t::«:.=--,. 'Him 32:': '.>£%E.EaJ.":t ES i)£'§§""i§7§':!.} 9-mn'::i2=s§.:mui . x. fe-
::e'a'*e arigtsxssl s:s;:§a£I3:=*: anfi :¥s:_x.<* im in vurigimii :1-»;\::»1::.::m§~smx:*e; Emreinafiar fax? the: at' if-2;. -am 13.'? flzéz L'»£i3". ':mt=;: -fim E;~t:;?35,s':'1=f'.'»'=f.,'-.'1i3'\'u'rZt££3'i:'=i. Emzsfiasmfl SW3 3\F'a:'a°::: §i§:.t2.T:z. ":5<-3-i.s1:E3§'1:s. .:i',~'.é<,:«i':'2"'§. was .}2;~:.>i:§:iz.1g: }%:;is::m. iiiarzi and «i3~h§fi;iS'£{3~, .n3§..{§§§s: £'m;n§ £)';}p:,:s:I1'*-xiii. E. whsizsi IE7§.i:--:3: i3s::<§1'ai. iiiaixii. e:*«;._;:r.i:~--:<.>.<i. -an £3.$,:2:{§£}i§» £i--2?.t1€3§:~::sr i"i,\"§«§.i3§f. ii mote: {:gc.§:e:; 'Ska cs}:3§§§;i§;§'s1ai2:zi: 22:13? Ivgisgvssisfié-t$E (§&_'¥€3Li,t1}§£1i $9 izfizamnts, i:'f§§.}&:.==;§.§;n.*; Pm: 'M;::~::g;3;«; '§'fl§:,}«Z' §'*i:sie:..E.t:1s:sm.e, xE.§:3i:~§§-tg mi.' ;{*'*m1»;'..I'::=V2;j»-*:a:: .i*;:::£i Eiibf basin '«;3;Ea§:im iifiii as snzszlh 'w:;;s eazsszsiraiimm' is:
fitkaizgflziiazi in :}12*i:s?az:'a"::=t i§'>';:mn1 fer "Size sTs;:§?«I;1§'§$m'$ 'E1;'§a:§ s3sI';p§§:§fl§ in Tisr. §2+:s*«a.r.~'m='s::' maxi Eshri €3ni't:i_§ x=.«.-39 £3 '§'~.;»;sa:>:= s:.3;s'c§ '§1:>.h:i.t:§ 331:2? he 'h--=.:.ai }?2:iisi R.s.f?if«fi3r .~ acaidexiiai ;§§§--ti§?§iI§€§$ m1i2"§f..1..:3~£3s{I~'3. .IEt'£xizw§:i¢.<z.a% zzsmxim 4' _Tf<m:: vmss tm. .suE::2:§z":-eazzi. "Sag: »a§;:«em:easms mats: Eiabia ts} itéze i?nst2:'am.:<e= '»'.«'1.
~.-
_a:::>m;::zt ta» 2%: e:»:t»i::t:;:s';a?é':1ja;::z'. "=.:":-$2: .a::;:;x:z~:«.a:;:: um up.' 3. A 3-{mam-'ctr cskgygeaza-:1\+s§3§:u? N{)€>E 3131:? iii iE'°i§':(§ "£13"-.'1»:'*.§2'." repéy 3: 'kl'-§:h.53 staiitsg, fifsat' 311:1:
:';t'm'ai;;:=§§£.§I3zE§.i3:i."'--Ei a?£k:§:§1':s is: u--;_:s_;:m2£ent ZNc.«._i E3s:::fi»: S=i:s:§x':: 4:33" '§:_2;ti;£.a; ,+"x:1.imd--. 'iE5£e2<sa;i:' mi: xa~ii'§§1::s',:':£ §a:n:e.... 's};:;>{sn:s.r;.: Yb£?u.L3 hat"? :re:q2m5*;m*§ ';h::$ sra;ts;30:is§:.:?'f £9 e§§;§;2§i§'.ta= fiha: 'p.:z;;=:1";=«m'i {sf §;3:z§: %:§--éi'§:t1':t :ami-m_u';,- F1'-!.'W»'~:':'&~':'._*e", a;;_:<§3&:zn;':tni:. I:1:a..3 s1:.tts.+;='; 5% '£3.-{xi :'£ss=;;:sa?«:3.$ii:s¥£e ;'%:'.«r the §e:;1:§ Ld,L¥~'n_m=m gamma {:1 e;;:'s{:'§.--.:§,S::s
4.;
's';m:s §;§3:;iEi'E§§:«:'. §;t':1.1s"{:'s"a:2.a*.*'-. aw '£2 an fitsze dais s:»:1'§'.~:=.=«:::-t:_:i3_rSI»:\1?&:-iii egfisiaith ~r:_3'."" G:1§1:t§ van.+;¥.2;s..s§1:a::Ez._--_:;Em .210:
13 it *¥§:I:-851- 2'2':s~:s- '::§-'.».e= 'x",(§{¥}§_'E§.éiiE}§i£T:i§I i?i::':a:--§%s's>>fr husibzzzmi'. ;'§}}:;ri S-aahéi w::§:2-
flmtzfig .§m§<.ir:::f 2a::.:3.:s.:.i ;.?:s§$;a .i§:1:sa.:.:r¢»;i.. 'Yhe: i:iai:>i.ii1:y' w:u £.§.~:3<iu»':.E flm ;>xs*ss:::3:Em:.:s isismi in ismsuaizxszssss -wzxzgurany' m=g:::3:2.:r¥;s was' ihm: -<31' 'iim £3 ;3_§_:w:.:_m:;':1[t'.§<:»,--1 wixicia :1 Lists sgzrssauasv'. »:3:i' i§:2;12mf_2:t:s:;e~ !'$£:§.{i§.§~§t!~"§}r'. £.E:nie-32$; Ectcma. ;ve§;§:fi .'L£_pg.'¥h£.'-.&i§:.%3Li.:'§1m:£1~s§0"'n'§:i' maze 23::
2.
Sizxii €,§~a:«E1i?L
-$5; fm: aha:
€I.'?sa~.*.£'§§t: Card hoifiar zxf €}j_§§§3{3r3'.'€i:'-Iii Nogi umisgfi £e:sh::sris«§:= »::--f RF31. '}I'h:: £i{}}'fL£§§§lt.§r:3§§ .,s:.n..£3 in in a>:.sre:_:;§.i.£am the S't3:§§§s:m§%§§5(?§.$ 'in ;f:m:ni';:=.=zt1 Em' me: £1e;x:i'_
--'c *§:€.3-- ¥£s:.~::§:= §?i(}.§f{i'.~}«' <:.*sr3:i:::mus7.;= ikmzz airsizas' 12::
a*:onIi--:1s§i£;<;i' 0->5' iiiars: g}e§.§:_§~?. ?~:h:i.:: fixtzai tizez mgsgmsrsmg s;1_o.,:%: ba.=n§< Ezméi mfi. »:i§L;ss:;h;:;*gm3 r"ea;_s<5m;=:_:h§Ei a §,3;;-é' ;ia1§~"i:sI:gf i§i1=£ ;'§;~:'s:m':11;::s fifliti étiaazs <:::ts--:a:Ei1i; s:m"x3'--z'sa':-rj:m:\'r's_:: .<;js:§'--'t.=
-. §:.uii;i.i:.' Eu tiw 'i.3'3.$L§I"£'§=!'&'3«. it w;<~:2_ the :e;ia1-£3' tiie «:'eA;::;§<3:.m:x!c ksaxisk to gszi.n<rsni.na£im1aiemii-s fiusxz iihm .H.(3.§siasr Ezznii. them :6 'fin: ii'£':2~m'&'C'. En 'ihis. i§1§."
-r 1 < .»_ \.
K"-'.§'f\E?«<'::¥:3tSI":'l nix. b::a=n's: :?::a:E::.:§'1s: +a§.;:cs3a:rge 3&5 2s:§:z:m:+¢;&i.e3 d3.3§.§fi;% .u.nd;a:r' i1'E£3;'§.is:'4§f _;»:2i:i{m_;g-, Tifgha i:s.3:s*:::§::§'$iiI:.31§1£ wial-mv flrszélit {T:ism;i ?m.§.:§a:~* a*:ma10"t7 in-:; zzsiim-a=:e4-3 .&¥13:f7i7»%)L€"§Gr'E§§.-*: diefiiagifzs r:s:".tr2~'w hzmii'. 'éfivinrmx-war, '§.§':t.:: Qg}§§i§s3£&'$£. am-.1 jfmis .1::E§a--a;s:mu:zt :31?' ;:~3:'§'sa'1?:i:1s1':1 am :;>,:?.1:I.::::i3:T}:E4 eimi Eh§:--a:zsz:_*s:_§ §?=a1i;"3§:.* am .€;f".§§ was an 3&3'.-'awe: --'1-'*'33'~'1'~§? i'm1:\:'-{§'.§'- ;:mE_§c=_}g iize. a>';':};sa:e:2:%:za:: usmizxlzitimi .t-1.'-Efiiif in nix': prxztmiustvsi £39. 2: gm g3n~:.z3:.i':m':a1. .9-;f' agcilaims, 'ijihe €§§)»§s$3*I§€:?!'§:§? ':E1e=a&~:-fare s:a's2:«aria:::;ss§':;«' .::s::~::::mim:t§ a its ,,":=w;-':i*;:' 3%-zit i.i'§E2{§1"§£E§~'Z:?~>';'l g>;1*:*.._z:1i}.z:e's§ was 110 §:¥»:'~§'-.9$*3$=;';.€1 i;;em'éa:~::,: ~c»;s:1'~»: zsreizi-22.2%' in mtimt. sf 32:}: . .=R%i::s:s:§§%§§;v' gsmszxksm. arsi' was {iéxiisztszximi fmana ?:§.~u%:. czzmiii. s3.c'=c~5¢s1.:m. £1?' 3.0-'1 in 113 §:'e;s* {its 2I.:jr.<§ igtizzi 2:1t:1m_.zm:_ R_s,;\i.§,-"- Wm; in .E:1sm'er _;:s::x:::2Ti.=mz~.. izainiar.
§:',~:::~:--.:w:.§.>2e;:a«..%f;:e::§.:msm-- ta_i'pr:*<2a1;¢.§um was in ¥f1e_i?$i}::§= -'E33: mm in 2a=civ>s§:s.ma~.:. hi tlilmrt in amifis is RseV.i£_3a"« am:
.§§t'§;1:".'I{2'1«'.t"».'.£?H..§}%.'}5 irzaazdaimgg-* ;m3'e':s::::::n: n.§'pr<smi=un1.\ Siasii §3t§%1.. Ravszi, hi. '.f£'.'é:l' the ;ac;>~'g:»:-riéaxié: mi' m:~:aw.: ;'3s:n&<t; 1:3:-' ..I.:3s:§i§s '%...?*:af ...»mm vassmzse.-_yg Tm £?{:{f,-*} «aim :3:is3:é.:"%>.§t2 €;?s:2«:r:':;:s.i:«::ai.m2- has 5§1:2:?ti;: x2.~*§.as;>;w.. b-ss:::'§:
i'<s3i;3s:era:;\*i$j§§s "ta gtsaa}-' %E;§h:'_: ;:::i:;*:2iL::2::"€:::s :.i.a1$.=;,r::'z:r.\_;':,« én Elias: :3-'i"<':'~z§§. mt) _§§§'ty.sm:~.rs§ fisf .¥3-'3"ei*i¥i3ém1-15%? 3¥tSi8r~'$?=5 Wis-'3='ut%£i it :<;ist*.:'>fc~i*'-232233,? in mi: ;._n~:u"£' :31' t}r1«;+. 'bzm;%:;. in rzzasjras 33-3-as .--msps>:3si¥f:§E?:3t:.~* :3: ;mys2':::Em. 12°32: s'.s_;)§.\::me§1£ am»? I1'-é ifezzaié I'.-0 -deduct §§=és>,.:3.3'»« :;£E's3m the iPI&i:¢j:{3L£.:!E .t}ft§§:<':..1'tiiL.{?.{3. .}--:.»s.:3;':c.?,+:'..,:~ amt s:::«.::::i.zfi'E3a.s§e mi 3? $:._I;::'a inf a=z?fs=:.:i seiifi m$,ai z1'a.e:s.:::-ti..3';s;i3-"'_;i1*amium. §sf§w1S;.¥§:'«'10§;§1§f aE'i@':'.n-g su iihe £§p§3v23£';i%:3'_ ' i-.:»o»;§ ifhr a *'i2:~i's;viit§?:3§f;§:3§;i. 3.9.. --si&§'i?»:;§e;s3a:ax' $.21 '3'ha i:::.p1:»ga3ss3l aria: <::f<..w:m;='n '.':§?t$ 1éi<§¥'§'3=€:Ei¥ ifi a'-'%H£fm»"-$9I§_.» _i§:22;31i,g_11:%:c3I izsfdér .£?'f .i73?i.sL{1°'§<:t' F£3?££I¥} is»: §%mmi>;y qmssizs:-ti md ;ss:ia;i<s'. "3'§3k&~. ;::;3;3{:r:a:§:§':t na«.;.3 311$ ears: vtiirezciati me ;:a-:ei:_~_s' R; v-'e*I3,_;§_§i3*£3;='?- ti .¥T€.az§;&és T§'.%£3i1si2£2.'£a:_§} ii? aim ::;e::1.:p§s:§:1;%$i{ with "f'-I'?zi1;~ 315::-2t'=ams§: frezzm 9;.§5,é'fii3€}§3 '£i§.E':2*:2£3l'ize1£i<a:i;, '\~'3_§'.i¢._§I5&§n';3s:E'}E"'-1)'; 223123 E aim- fifimciafi Xi} )':7€s,3{}$l}:3_g; {jg .~ g _'TE_m:2<': "i'-i1:§:-v.ss2:._>.:_::a:r3'fja :1':«;_we:>:u°_<_§s ssgtmzzjg zismi i:3::u::x=s:zi<m;::e e=ts=. '=snrju'i 0~.fi:?é.5£}éI§i-'~ {Rupaas {7.);és»2s -- T37'i:m;:st:gs£m-{ii F.i\-"a §~"Iun:§m»;§Tj} Aim of {:}'3'd:¥:J;'.' :.:s:;m:r;i:i;::g;%?_aa égvdzzg? _t,.->_f."3'1_3§:a>'_. 32$ .1. .
. a 'i .2' 3 I x' ;,-*1 ' (ii? ',3 ' {If}-' ' €.'(.kfli-'.'~33.." f' {S .; .. s :i3.§<hij2g_:, {'Smt_ - §-'art-iTi3:;';:s 1-'... im} M.§Em'§3s§' .:'e"£s'335§3':' >3:
';:%..%';a"§<".2r£~f:':§ "_i'f§}:I'§';§ $.11»: ;
GU §'3:e.§§,i,V .s§siuf¥§ fiL}i:s;: §§§3u:s«:a=:E:faa * 5-' ;*'2t= Tiilzaéa' 'iT3i.";2s: 3-s;.zm::
'«z"'<;\2:-mzé . ,?'vLm§3gz*:r 333$;£L§§ cu" in-sfiia AS'-':%i1£§§$< , .i§§a;a::::i;:§-1::'2 '§'_}§s:§..
£'3$s1a:t»*z;§'§§as:<2;;er t"12ss§<~; --BaatsE§ (1i'"ffI§;§i5Ei was .
:t.%«.:ag;.:s--;s1 «~23
51% 1f§.='.}{;'~§.', . - "
'
3.. ?'%¥;<$33A§R'E.3v
i=*:?~, l~3.asi.g:u* 13;:
"£z:r_\.*.=3;z:a Sisaia Vii
.§'>;§: ami figinséi, fixsiazad;
AJ
=$~. E237 *-'ii."'§.::~';t
Eiémii ] i'}3m'{sd:s.
133$ £3;%'fi-§:§$. ?§E.:'1e2.s1= Fitmsr
tr:
;<'..?§'}%*.%a'i13. . .
.B§§$*'('}E §%'=L::sii.t'.a: l:3§§.L§§3§§i§33
Sixri. T. '2, E&.»"i+e;mi:»;°.r--
:3z1fsfiL R =;'.é1*x»'i?m:t.1i:zz2zr"