Karnataka High Court
Divisional Manager National Insurance ... vs Ashok Mallayya Kambi on 13 January, 2009
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
AND} ..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD 5 if "
DATED THIS THE 13th DAY ()9 -'I.I4&'NI.'_J'1.V5L'E§"J(':V'§3,?I) (")'€*.4_'_:»'V
PRESENT".
THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE V.'{}(3PAIA V
THE HON'BLE MR. JQSTICE *i}_;'N}iRAYANA*~SWAMY 1 DIVISIONAL 1v£.A3szAG_ER,' NA'I'I.ONAL1?J.SUVR?_NGE Co LTD DIVISHQNAL O}?Fi'-T3E',,1?'?39, . '1"{*vAMDEVV.GALLI BELGUAM .» NOW RERB'? «ITS REGIORAL MANAGER, 'NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. I:r13.,
- , 3m;Q1s:AL OFFICE SUBHARAM, _ TceM'§>1;Ex,"-:44, M.G.RoAD, ._ B'AE?~3C3,ALf.§?;E --550 901. APPELLANT ' (B9r sR1.LAX1vzAN.'B.MANNoD1:>AR, ADV.) 4_ ASHOK MALLAYYA KAMEESE . _ TAGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, " OCC: SERVICE, R/AT 305/7, ROY ROAD, TILAKWADI, BELGUAM. bk/, Cimgiderizfzg the faci that the ciaiiziazit Efiag iailed to examine the dacters Wm} a !;.}_:é4:'E.,"V;{3'é4§{"§. A. him in mg-: iwo h0::pita1$ in 255110}: Efasé @6313 'Q3 " ' ir1pa:§€nti:}u11e&iat€3§: afié§*t}";«¢:_ acciaisrfifizfrf V {ii} Whaihar the <\:0111pe21sa§ti:}f1i'.V_<iei§§4;g:i%5;;€&:'§ n V' the eiaims tribumal z§n:%._éf."$& $3 the facts a:1:::i{ cése'? if 219%.," what is; $ :=e:as§r;.ab§e €::§;z3p@'::;%'s§fi{i{§::':;;? ' V €323" .§'§:'3é.i2'1gs the zgsgaiivé ansé iha ae§§ii_2":;':§fiVi; 5 '.E$§i§§;;a1:<:€{§ €{>:":2p€:1$a"{;?.Q:":
(2? RS. E,8f{:?:*f3'"i / «» fig?"fEf::é £'€'§%;:z?::':g reasarss. $}.i{§?\:;§3*'? §$.'?f:1§§§gf_ g:._in{i. safiificats issued by '€316 K L E} *Ti~<§:§::f$§3;%*:i;<.2:§g'.%3<::§ga._§§;33. 334?'? iiiscriaaag §%*a::*€1;;"e 9:" shafii _ V £:ihi.;2z_,«. '§§%'ef<§':'ifi'i€;:j5A'Ti=%' crapiiznas as upyer E/'3r{1 <5?' right Zieg, ' ;?:;w&EE:;z§gi §t'iii1§éZ'I'1€SS 31% avg? {ha 'zmdy, biaséizig p:'6s€::::, " :zméc§£::.A«d€:e;3 £;1<3xz&:.:1€:1"fE rastxictrazig sugperiicéak abmgion, kw W4.
)"'W'>'* '28%- 'Ffisrsfzrsre, Ehiri appeal GE' {E16 é_:1sLn"31zc<=: c{>I:3 ;::é:2:"§§-'--44§;:;V'vv., £:i"1a£' €:X'€',€E}t s1.i$€:€:e:<§S.
18. §?'£.:rtE'as:;* it is igim C0I1t.<:::r1*{:i:}fi"{:;€' £13116 .;%:1;éé_:';:*:§12:<:A<f; L. (T:s:>mpa;:1};' that E"{iiII'i%3'i_1i'S€"iIE€'f3"1E'§3f£.:.;;}7§€?§i{i.?fi'Eifiiéf :;'3;§«;§{.i%V Egg?
the <§epart:3}€::1i is mat V§i2.:;:§ néamsidfifééia:1 by $318 ciaixaxs tribuna}. of R$fi»3,€'3'?'E%,,{}{'§ iijmmé EE4/1999 :0 '?/6;' 3;€%39$'}. €}0:m:r1fi:':fiz:§ an swag' in not {Tam ram fif the iaétai a_z1'2<)uz}%, {Ef C§€'.é;..'?'5>,{?3{"3fE;"~ _ é£:s§%€:%ase{i '£:<}&%;9;r£i$ {E16 zizsiiigtézé exgjezzsgea To i§§{'§ifi§if. 333:} the 8:;;pé~:a1 3%' 13%:
"V.¢'§:'::é;:_::fgé:::;é f;::::;;i;;}a:1j;r has :3 suecaefi. "i"E':;€: siafizxazzz; is s3'i:":i;i"§E§€g"i§.1 E.i.){} midzir me: hazad 3{§'EiEC§§.Ca§ V V _expe:i'ses»:j§::s:.égd {}§"§Qs.,'?:"3,(}§}i},/«. V' {Tf.aI1:§i&<=::*§::g fzhage two aggsactg f}}{*3 ::::91§.Epa11sa'€iar: has is ha Caisuiaiazi HE wiiisiz €313 Eiiiaimazai is éntitifid. The cEa?:m$ tri§:2una§ has iairifiii 332$ kw c;:%.§>1a<:i4:;i = ....,.
M}
-.-- ,2.
:m:»z"2€;;E1}§; Saéazfv 0? {E15 ciaiiixamt at .E'V'A'"3.$.49{}{_}f'"..;'"";§3X};fT?'.§.«Z,§;__"
{E16 saiazy <:e:*%,§;fiz:aE:e f-'<31' the z:1z::n?{i'1 «sf 1%/%§z1};,_¢%é:'a:f1;g iazsiicates fiifi S3Eaa"'§.r' <";f.' €:he ciainaafii. 51;:.E€A$f;84'.l5E,ifj%€},' 'TEf'§1<-:.:.; .' Claims '€.I:%¥3L2:1ai has 'i:a'§<:€:::1 i:h€:* ,?f'z?_fii€ S.-:3E:s;f§:*VVé.:f;V$§:€:;;§{i VA of gags saiaijgz to £3.§3SfiSS the f72_1 %:f:2:f€: k;Ss~:._ é§f €é:z'r1§;2g aapaciéjgs. 'i'a§§.:'1'1g E%s.8'§..§'fg;»«« -316: V;§i';::1Lt2.éE~Ai§1{:§;::1e wmes is R$.97,§32.§£3<.::,,%i3§%'%s :Rs,2"?,4£2€}.€36 '?§£hi{3§"11 is; 1:3 Séiiijifi has :9 B5 zxgziiiiifiiifiéfifl the ciaizgzam; was E1": 'the ag$'«g;fa312v;p'i§f"%1€ :°e$ui:am: figure xsméézizé ha Rs¢3.,-§6,46fiE§'€}:{} 'faz$';{Eé:' fie heaéi fazture 3933 $3" f38i*3'3i;iZg' f}?1_2%: 4i'<:}a;in1ar1£ has z::1<:i€§*g0;.':<: 23 @p{~:r23;:§m":s " T$1<:3'..:{;.v..--A:'§'a§':i::s.g is aisa fiifiéfi. '£'h€:r€f{:r€, the '«;%£§m ;;>€:::%5atiaz1 Qf Rs.50,€}GC§/-- "1,22"::<ie:* the head pair: 31151 njjgwizffsirizig §"8i"i?.7.€€§ by {he Czlaims {3'ib"u::"1ai is an the $035353? 386% W6: erzilaficfi {ha Séflfif: :0 Rs. },0€},{)OO/-. T516 My r-m L') aiaimant was in the hasgita} far 3 peréaii of £92 €i2;3%§a{§zi"'vv., the Claims mfminal has anify awardezi M uncier the head have salary. This c1:37i1m3.::i'.._§s _¢::fit1€;d*i¥3 tmal c{3111§er1sai;ian urzdar the héa_d"-_1%:avs" .f§ai.a1*y V' R$.i2,5,{f3QO,«'»~ {Rs.816{} x,----.3 camesijgc 'R-s,24,48£E.f~.V§%3h§c}:
ig reminded sf :0 Rs.:25,€}{i'()';?_T§;, "
13, PW-£i has. "(ié§--:::'s;<=:& that he is gzirgicaily a;3é3ja'é:%=.>€:?g a11%i' ;)ii'§: '§i.s§;'t::i1'e§; I11 order 'ac: E'fiHi{3¥€: the i:11p§3;11i_s, t3i.::.&i;:ia:%in19i1t__ has to undergo one mere eperation 'a_;tid, he.' f;§:f:§_ " éperzé 3111011121 9:: §:.§1a§. T'}f1€T€f(';1'I:'€,_ i7'i'é'V E.~;iS.'%£3§GO(}/~ wwarda the fzztazm " I::é>';{§iC?aJ iiéatiiigni.
"E-.4. Eiéiéxzfé the aypssai af the ciaimaigfi, is {;'I'}£E§$'}.€€§ 'L0 .. _. '; ~ ahiiawéé partiy arzhaliciiig the CG§}[}p€fi$3.iiG}1 by 5%' ~_ $';..V};,"§"T::i{,98 1.{}Cé 33 fofiews, whicjh shafi C8}E'I'ji 5% ir2f;er'e3€ iéxcépt E3.4{},G£f}{E,I'» vakzécix is gramecé tawards §'z3:1_1:'e /iw