Madras High Court
Ve.Gneakizhan vs Tamil Nadu State Bhoodan Yagna Board on 25 February, 2019
Equivalent citations: AIRONLINE 2019 MAD 1502
Bench: S.Manikumar, Subramonium Prasad
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 25.02.2019
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.MANIKUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
WP.No.21452 of 2017
Ve.Gneakizhan ... Petitioner
vs.
1. Tamil Nadu State Bhoodan Yagna Board
Rep. by the Principal Secretary and
the Commissioner of Land Reforms,
Ezhilagam, Chepauk,
Chennai - 600 005.
2. The District Collector,
Villupuram District,
Villupuram.
3. The Tahsildar,
Vanur,
Villupuram District.
4. The Registrar General,
High Court of Judicature at Madras,
Chennai - 600 104 ... Respondents
WRIT Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying
for the issuance of a writ of mandamus, directing respondent No.1 Board to
consider and decide the representation of the petitioner dated 1.4.2017
after holding a public hearing at Vanur in respect of the alternative sites
mentioned in the said representation for the purpose of construction of an
integrated court complex at Vanur, on merits in accordance with law within
a reasonable time as may be determined by the Honourable Court.
http://www.judis.nic.in For Petitioner : Mr.M.Radhakrishnan
2
For Respondents : Mr.E.Manoharan (for R1 to R3)
Additional Government Pleader.
Mr.E.K.Kumaresan (for R4)
ORDER
(Order of the Court was made by S.MANIKUMAR, J) Petitioner has sought for a writ of mandamus, directing Tamil Nadu State Bhoodan Yagna Board, Chennai respondent No.1 to consider and decide his representation dated 1.4.2017, after holding a public hearing at Vanur in respect of the alternative sites mentioned in the said representation for the purpose of construction of an integrated court complex at Vanur, on merits in accordance with law, within a reasonable time.
2. Vide proceedings in RC No.B4.4836/2013 dated 18.09.2018, land in S.No.227/5 to an extent of 0.54.5 hectares has already been allotted to judicial department subject to certain conditions. The proceedings dated 18.09.2018 is extracted.
tpGg;g [ [uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fspd; bray;Kiwfs; Kd;dpiy Kidtu; ,y/Rg;gpukzpad;. ,/M/g/. e/f/M4/4836-2013 ehs; 18/09/2018 bghUs; epy khw;wk; ? thD}u; tl;lk; ? g[spr;rg;gs;sk;
fpuhkk; ? xU';fpize;j ePjpkd;w tshfk; ? g[y vz;/227-5. 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F epyj;jpy; 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyk; ? fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[jJ; iwapd; jilapd;ik bgwg;gl;Ls;sJ ? Kd; EiHt[ mDkjp tH';Fjy; ? MizapLjy; bjhlu;ghf/ http://www.judis.nic.in 3 ghu;it 1/ khtl;l Kjd;ik ePjpgjp. tpGg;g[uk;
mtu;fspd; nfl;g[ fojk;. ehs; 26/02/2010/ 2/ tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fsplk; tpGg;gu[ k; khtl;l Kjd;ik ePjpgjp mtu;fspd; nehpyhd nfhhpf;if. ehs;/21/01/2015 3/ thD}u; khtl;l Kd;rg P ; kw;Wk; ePjpj;Jiw eLtu; mtu;fspd; nfl;g[ kD. ehs;
22/09/2017 4/ tpGg;g[uk; tUtha; nfhl;lhl;rpau; mtu;fspd; e/f/m2/780-2018. ehs; 18/02/2018 5/ thD}u; tUtha; tl;lhl;rpau; mtu;fspd; e/f/m1/3966-2017 ehs;/14/02/2018 6/ rhu; epiy mYtyu;fspd; Tl;L g[yj;jzpf;if mwpf;if. ehs;/18/02/2018/ 7/ khtl;l tUtha; mYtyu;. tpGg;g[uk; mtu;fspd; fojk;. ehs; 28/02/2018 8/ tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fspd; e/f/M4/4836-2013 ehs; 24/04/2018 9/ tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fspd; e/f/M4/4836-2013 ehs; 25/05/2018 10/ ,af;Feu;. fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[ (k) kUj;Jtg; gzpfs;. brd;id ? 6 mtu;fspd; e/f/M2/17054-2018. ehs; 22/05/2018/ 11/ tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fspd; e/f/M4/4836-2013 ehs; 02/06/2018 12/ tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fspd; e/f/M4/4836-2013 ehs; 02/07/2018 13/ murhiz vz;/172. fhy;eil. ghy;tsk; kw;Wk; kPdt ; sj;Jiw (V/vr;/2) Jiw. ehs; 14/09/2018/ 14/ murhiz vz;/537. tUtha; (vy;/o/4) Jiw. ehs; 22/06/1998 ??????
tpGg;g[uk; khtl;lk; thD}u; tl;lk; g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkk;. g[y vz;/227-5. 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F g[ydpy; 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; g[yid kw;Wk; xU';fpize;j ePjpkd;w tshfk; mikj;jpLk; bghUl;L ePjpj;Jiwf;F epy khw;wk; bra;jpl thD}u;
khtl;l Kd;rg
P ; kw;Wk; ePjpj;Jiw eLtu; mtu;fs; nfhhpajd;
nghpy; bgwg;gl;l Kd;bkhHpt[fspd; mog;gilapy; tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l
tUtha; mYtyu; mtu;fshy; fle;j 28/02/2018 md;W
g[yj;jzpf;if bra;ag;gl;L epy khw;wk; bra;jpl ghpe;Jiu
bra;jpl;ljpd; mog;gilapYk; tpGg;g[uk; khtl;l fhy;eilj;Jiw
Jiz kw;Wk; ,iz ,af;Feu;fs; tUtha;jJ ; iwapd; rhu; epiy mYtyu;fSld; Tl;Lg; g[yj;jzpf;if nkw;bfhz;L rku;g;gpj;Js;s mwpf;ifapd; mog;gilapYk; thD}u; tl;lk; g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhk g[y vz;/227-5. 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F epyj;jpy; 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpid Vw;W nka;f;fhy; epykhf epy khw;wk; bra;jplt[k; njitahd Ml;nrgidapd;ikapid tH';fp MizapLkhW ntz;o Kd;bkhHpt[fs; ,af;Feu;. fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[jJ ; iw mtu;fSf;F mDg;gp itf;fg;gl;lJ/ mjd; tptuk; http://www.judis.nic.in 4 gpd;tUkhW/ cj;njr epy khw;w epyj;jpd; tptu';fs;
tpHg;gu[ k; khtl;lk;. thD}u; tl;lk; g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkk; g[y vz;/227-5 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ,lkhdJ fpuhk fzf;Ffspy; ke;ijbtsp muR g[wk;nghf;F vd tifghL bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ/ g[yd; ke;ijbtsp vd;gjw;F Mjhukhf g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhk m gjpntl;od; efy; ,izf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ/ ,e;j epykhw;wk; Fwpj;J g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkj;jpy; fpuhk epu;thf mYtyuhy; bghJ tpsk;guk; kw;Wk; m1 nehl;O!; 22/09/2017 md;W tpsk;guk; bra;agl;ljpy; Ml;nrgizfs; VJk; tug;bgwtpy;iy/ nkYk; g[yj;jzpf;ifapd; nghJ Ml;nrgid VJk; bgw;gltpy;iy vdt[k; bjhptpj;Js;shu;/ g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhk Cuhl;rpapd; rhu;gpy; nkw;go epy khw;wj;jpw;F Mjuthf jPu;khdk; ,aw;wg;gl;Ls;sJ/ cj;njr g[yDf;F nghjpa mQqF ghij trjp cs;sJ/ cj;njr g[ydpy; fpzW. Fsk; cs;spl;l ePu; epiyfnsh. g[uhjhdr; rpd;d';fnsh. kahdnkh my;yJ ntW Ml;nrgidfukhd fl;Lkhd';fnsh VJkpy;iy/ cj;njr g[ydpy; xU Xuj;jpd tHpna jhH;kpd;dGj;j fk;g';fs; bry;fpd;wd/ mtw;iw nfl;g[jJ ; iwapdu; j';fsJ brhe;j brytpy; mfw;wpf; bfhs;s ntz;Lk; vd;w epge;jida[ld; epy khw;wk; bra;J bfhs;s mDkjpf;fyhk; vd khtl;l tUtha; mYtyu; jdJ g[yj;jzpf;if mwpf;ifapy; bjhptpj;Js;shu;/ cj;njr g[ydpy; tpiy kjpg;g[ss ; ku';fs; VJk; ,y;iy/ cj;njr epy khw;w g[ydpd; tptuk;
khWjYf;F Kd;
t/vz; g[y vz; tp!;jPuzk; tifghL
1 227-5 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F
khWjYf;F Kd;
t/vz; g[y vz; tp!;jPuzk; tifghL
1 227-5 0/09/00 xU';fpize;j ePjpkd;w
tshfk; kw;Wk; FoapUg;g[
2 227-6 0/05/50 epYit ke;ijbtsp
g[wk;nghf;F
3 227-7 0/45/50 xU';fpize;j ePjpkd;w
tshfk; kw;Wk; FoapUg;g[
4 227-8 0/05/00 epYit ke;ijbtsp
g[wk;nghf;F
epy kjpg;g[
cj;njr g[ydpw;F tpiy kjpg;g[ epu;zak; bra;jpLk;bghUl;L http://www.judis.nic.in 5 g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkj;jpy; fle;j 01/09/2016 Kjy; 22/09-2017 tiuapy; thD}u; rhu;gjpthsu; mYtyfj;jpy; eilbgw;w fpiua tpw;gid gjpt[fs; bgwg;gl;lJ nkw;go bgw;gl;l tpw;gid gl;oay;fs; Tuha;t[ bra;ag;gl;ljpy; Tuha;tpy; tPl;Lkidfs;. cj;njr g[ydpypUe;J J}u tpw;gid. cj;njr g[ydpd; kz;tadk; kw;Wk; juk; Mfpatw;iw Ma;t[f;F cl;gLj;jg;gl;lJ mjdog;gilapy; khjphp g[ydhf g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkj;jpy; thpir vz;/7?y; cs;s fpuhk g[y vz;/310-1?d; kz;tadk;. juk; Mfpait cj;njr g[ydpd; kz; tadk; juj;jpid xj;jjhf cs;sJ vd;Wk;. ,g;g[yd; Kd;bkhHpt[ld; ,izf;fg;gl;Ls;s g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkj;jpy; 0/48 brz;l; kl;Lk; Mtz vz;/4956. ehs; 05/10/2016?d;go U:/144000-? f;F tpw;gid bra;ag;gl;L thD}u; rhu;gjpthsu; mYtyj;jpd; gjpt[ bra;ag;gl;L ,jd;go 1 brz;l; kjpg;g[ U:/3000-? MFk;/ nkYk; tHpfhl;o kjpg;gpd; mog;gilapYk; brz;l; U:/3000-? MFk;/ tpw;gid kjpg;g[ kw;Wk; tHpfhl;o kjpg;gpd; mog;gilapYk;. tpw;gid kjpg;gpd; mog;gilapYk; 01 bcwf;nlu;
kjpg;g[ U:/7.41.000-? MfpwJ vd;Wk;. ,jdog;gilapy; cj;njr
g[ydhd 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpd; kjpg;g[ U:/403845-? MfpwJ
vd;Wk;. khjphpg;gy
[ dpd; re;ij kjpg;g[ tHpfhl;o kjpg;g[ Mfpait
,uz;Lk; xnu kjpg;gpidf; bfhz;nl cs;sJ vdt[k;. khjphp
g[ydpd; r;eij kjpg;g[ kw;Wk; tHpfhl;o kjpg;gpd; mog;gilapy;
cj;njr g[ydpd; epykjpg;g[ U:/403845-? vd epu;zak;
bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ vd tpGg;g[uk; tUtha; nfhl;lhl;rpau; jdJ
mwpf;ifpay; bjhptpj;Js;shu;/ nkw;go epy kjpg;gpidna epu;zak;
bra;jplyhk; vd khtl;l tUtha; mYtyUk; jdJ g[yj;jpz;fif mwpf;ifapy; ghpe;Jiu bra;Js;shu;/ ,Ug;gpDk;. murhiz vz;/633. tUtha; (vy;/o/4(1) Jiw. ehs; 31/10/2007y; muR JiwfSf;F epy khw;wk; bra;jpLk; neu;tpy; tHpfhl;o kjpg;gpidna fzf;fpy; bfhz;L epy khw;wk; bra;jpl Mizaplg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;gJ Fwpg;gplj;jf;fJ/ murhiz (epiy) vz;/186. fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[ kw;Wk; kPdt ; sj;Jiw. ehs; 11/12/2001 kw;Wk; murhiz (epiy) vz;/75. fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[. ghy;tsk; kw;Wk; kPdt ; sj;Jiw. ehs; 28/05/2007 Mfpatw;wpd;go cj;njr epy khw;w g[yd; Ml;nrgidf;Fhpa epy khw;wk; bra;a jil tpjpf;fg;gl;l ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F vd;gjhy; mtw;wpy; Fwpg;glg;gl;thW ntW muR JiwfSf;F epy khw;wk; bra;a ntz;oa mtrpak; Vw;god; mnj khtl;lj;jpy; rkkhd gug;gs [ s ; khw;W epy';fis nka;rr ; y; epykhf gad;gLj;jpf;
bfhs;s bjhpt[ bra;ag;gl ntz;Lk; vdt[k; mg;g[yid rPug ; Lj;jp nka;rr ; y; epykhf cUthf;f brytpdkhf Vf;fu; xd;Wf;F U/6000-? http://www.judis.nic.in I nka;rr ; y; epyk; njitg;gLk; Jiwfs; Vw;Wf; bfhs;s ntz;Lk;
6
vdt[k; mwpt[Wj;jg;gl;Ls;sJ/
mjd;go nfl;g[jJ
; iwapduhd ePjpj;Jiwapdu; khw;W
epyj;jpw;fhd kW rPuikg;g[ bjhifahf U:/8075-? (U:gha;
vl;lhapuj;J vGgj;jp Ie;J kl;oy;) (ryhd; vz;/3 ehs; 22/05/2018) ghuj t';fpapy chpa muR fzf;F jiyg;gpy; brYj;jpaikf;fhd mry; ryhid rku;g;gpj;Js;sdu;/ nkw;Twg;gl;l tpjpfSf;fpz';f thD}u; tl;lk;. g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhkk; g[y vz;/227-5?y; 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F vd tifghL bra;ag;gl;Ls;s ,lj;jpypUe;J tpyf;fg;gLk; bkhj;jk; 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpw;F khw;W epykhf mnj thD}u; tl;lj;jpd; mWtil fpuhk g[y vz;/173-3. 1/22/0 g[";ir jhpR g[ydpypUe;J 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpid nka;fhy; g[wk;nghf;fhf epy khw;wk; bra;jpl Kd;bkhHpt[ rhu; epiy mYtyu;fshy; rku;g;gpf;fg;gl;lJ/ bjhlu;eJ ; ghu;it 8. 9 kw;Wk; 11d; thapyhf jilapd;ikr; rhd;W nfhhp Kd;bkhHpt[fs; ,af;Feu;. fhy;eil guhkhpg;g[jJ ; iw mtu;fSf;F mDg;gp itf;fg;gl;lJ/ nkw;go Kd;bkhHpt[fspd; nghpy; thD}u; tl;lk; g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhk g[y vz;/227-5?y; 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F epyj;jpypUe;J 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpid ePjpj;Jiwf;F epy khw;wk; bra;jpl jilapd;ik bjhptpj;J Mizaplg;gl;Ls;sJ/ ghu;it 14y; fhQqk; murhizfspy; nfl;g[jJ ; iwapdUk;
epyj;jpid mspj;jpLk; JiwapdUk; chpa ,irtpid mspj;jpLk; neu;tpy; jpl;lg;gzpapy; Vw;gLk; ghyjhkjj;jpid jtpu;jj ; pLk;
nehf;fpy; khtl;l Ml;rpj; jiytu; mtu;fns Kd; EiHt[ mDkjp tH';fpl tHptif bra;ag;gl;Ls;J/ nfl;g[j;Jiwapduhd ePjpj;Jiwapdu; ePjpkd;w fl;Lkhd gzpapid cld; Jt';fpl ntz;oa[s;sjhy; bjhlu;g[ila g[yd;fis cld; xg;gilj;jpl nfhhp tUtijf; fUj;jpy; bfhz;Lk; ,t;tpdj;jpy; muR xJf;fPL bra;Js;s epjpapid KGikahf gad;gLj;jp ePjpkd;w tshfj;jpid cld; fl;lilj;jpl njitahd ,lj;jpid cld; xJf;fPL bra;jpl ntz;oa[ss ; ijf; fUj;jpy;
bfhz;Lk; tpGg;gu[ k; khtl;lk; thD}u; tl;lk; g[spr;rg;gs;sk; fpuhk g[y vz;/ fpuhkk; g[y vz;/227-5?y; 0/65/0 bcwf;nlu; ke;ijbtsp g[wk;nghf;F g[ydpy; 0/54/5 bcwf;nlu; epyj;jpy; kl;Lk; xU';fpize;j ePjpkd;w tshfk; mikj;jpLk; bghUl;L ePjpj;Jiwf;F gpd;tUk; epge;jidfSf;Fl;gl;L Kd; EiHt[ mDkjp tH';fp Mizaplg;gLfpd;wJ/ epge;jidfs;
1/ g[yd; ve;j nehf;fj;jpw;fhf tH';fg;gLfpwnjh me;j http://www.judis.nic.in nehf;fj;jpw;fhf kl;Lnk gad;gLj;jg;gl ntz;Lk;/ 7 2/ ve;j R{H;epiyapYk; nkw;fz;l g[yj;jpd; tifg;ghl;oid khw;wk; bra;af; TlhJ/ 3/ MWkhjj;jpw;Fs; g[yd; gad;ghl;ow;F bfhz;Ltug;gltpy;iybadpy; Kd;EiHt[ jd;dpr;irahf ,uj;J bra;ag;gLk;/ 4/ gpw;fhyj;jpy; cgnahfg;gLj;jg;glhj ,lk; murpw;F njitbadpy; rk;ke;jg;gl;l Jiwapd; ,irtpd;wp tUtha;Jiwapduhy; kPs vLj;Jf; bfhs;sg;gLk;/ 5/ cj;njr g[yj;jpy; cs;s kpd; fk;g';fis Vw;fdnt g[yj;jzpf;ifapd;nghJ Fwpg;glg;gl;lthW khw;wp mikj;jpa ntz;oaJ/ 6/ ,e;neu;tpyhd Kd; EiHt[ mDkjpapd; mog;gilapy; tl;l kw;Wk; fpuhk fzf;Ffspy; jpUj;jk; vjida[k; bra;jpl TlhJ/ Xk;-?,y/Rg;gpukzpad;
khtl;l Ml;rpau;
tpGg;g[uk;
--c/e/c/g--
khtl;l Ml;rpaUf;fhf.
tpGg;g[uk;
3. That apart, Mr.M.Radhakrishnan, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that proposal to obtain Gramdan Land in Vanur District has been dropped and therefore, the writ petition has become infructuous.
4. Placing on record the above, writ petition is dismissed as infructuous. No Costs.
(S.M.K., J.) (S.P., J.) 25.02.2019 Index: Yes/No Internet: Yes Speaking/Non speaking ars http://www.judis.nic.in 8 S.MANIKUMAR,J.
AND SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J.
ars
1. Tamil Nadu State Bhoodan Yagna Board Rep. by the Principal Secretary and the Commissioner of Land Reforms, Ezhilagam, Chepauk, Chennai - 600 005.
2. The District Collector, Villupuram District, Villupuram.
3. The Tahsildar, Vanur, Villupuram District.
4. The Registrar General, High Court of Judicature at Madras, Chennai - 600 104.
WP.No.21452 of 201725.02.2019 http://www.judis.nic.in