Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Service Tax vs M/S Bimal Auto Agency on 21 April, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
§iTH§?§£%éCQG§?§E'KARN%T§K£§¥§§é§S§LQR% ggmga "mag "§"HE 3:9' :35? GE APRE:
?RE$ENT TEE H®§\§'§LE §'*v"§R;. §a;§"§;*;:::§'. §x§;;§<:}T§2E§:a.'_ %, "mi §~iQ§\§"8E.,.E s%é§;«:'._T;f;.I3Sf§f§'§:ijE f?§;;%;'A:;§a:;;:§\f%gax'§%~:
% C;E:;:%>,, Eaégsgé §:},§*3 *:{::§:<35 (ZQM :»%':%$s--:@£~sE;<; .'{'3E' 'g.E';2;:gf:'i:E SEEK §§aag:§§::':3VV':"%;€2>< <:=:3%:;§sE:§$1;eI's:§Rm"E, gsgfiiég, SIV'::'):'a'§%::€E.?V¥§E'§:§§..;--'E:>{'.f ":..§;,!;§%§§~é RSAQ, gA§as::s:;,@R§i v. 356:3 32:: W§§;?E;:M.::@1:T % {§g%-- "sRI%§%%A:ig§":::%§;§Ha;S:"<%;:fé; gagasmgggg mg a::nai«sau-bogauexs . §v'%,5S;3;;§§*§;'3aL &:,:":'§ ;;§g§s<:'v §2§€;lé@§2; fvififiéfifivfixfififiég ':?:f'%%~%'§T%'"§;'" 51$ gags;
r,g;:%s§.a;ga;@§;§ -~ §§§ gag; ..,R§§?§§%§§E§K%'§' § ~' §§,w'K/I {EV 3%? SEQ? §<ii§N§%R,, fi:§'2§€3C§{?E} T§'i%S CEA éiecé zmées" S€€'£§Q§": 35$ :35 Excige AC3. 3944 Erising mg: :3? Qréa" éatz,-26._1:'§<g;;§?';'::3:i'5 gasses iié Fina? Graig; f'£ag8:Qj2i$Q8;, .53:5y.§":§§ és;;.-VI;§e.駧_§:_i§:g Sasbsiaatéai quegiiers Q? Eaw staiieé §fr'*:3..r:ei?:,,_a;§%" a7s1§§e '%::,i:_e CL?ESTéT§, S@a1i:%z Zeae §e;:::Ei}_; Sa":'3_g'§aE'%:7a':*a :.fV§:r2:§£ mgzggzgeg daieé 39§§:%{,:s§s a:;sga%% V%'%f: '§§§ea§ §\E3.§'"%"/:S8§2GQ? ancé. rests-réA""Lv~.%%':--§ ::>réi§e:<.,. fiésseé $2 gmam mzzam éateé 3§;';Q}2;2£;_a::V?;' This §7:E';'i._' _'-C§r%_2%:3_g %":€a§**'§n§ ihés flay; as E Kéj MAR ; 4; 'F é:.*.§§:g?,z-£.:%:é_fe.é .%:_::_é 1v%;?;:;;%:*:i: é£\;;§f:§;' .% 3:": 3. §a%:g::§"--:_ é:§§"~~r:§§€g aezzékerg ihe gazage? G? ?:%1€ a:,:':f:§:~9;;§.::§@:~,: ifi §§?s--;,>--3$$ ;;§§':&§§:§es am we géweg" :3? $913 Ea afihaags ggnaéiéeg aszé SC§§E {sf §'33,¥§%:§§§§§S.":?:§:1'g7:: 2E8 55$ 8% a? $26 §:§%'E§¥'%€i% fiat; 39% zasgg %§w<::%:!§5%:§.§ EEESE; aaggre fiéggsasefi sf? $3' the 3228;: 53:59:? éaieé w'°''X /# I 2§.éI~.2G::§ in CEf~%.§'\§£é,if2{}§§ am asaaézigé §&$§S wherg Ea: wag ézeié 53 ur:§er:» {E} 3&8 :'mp:::si§/52:52 £35" pe:2a.E§§; am::§€:' 533:' ' €:u§'0ma:;:'c. '§'§'z€ i:zgr€_§~§€.:3{$ i:?%_;2u VV $685503? $§Ze:'}iiE§ €)<Z§3§; §:;:':.re;§;--.§é!e/*:c;§V starsd E78 of {$26 A52V:§§;~i....§}:2V§g'::;?2}§f Q,-'5:§:{§se~': L' §e?C::'o::5; $f?AV.__o:¢:ia7 » _£_::2;.e':i;;_ a,§é.é "§;?::Vie.2_;'eVAV é?5/zaaid be flbS€§'E€'€ Q}; saidjéiiiazsa {Z} Seciiiszgs esssizzszseg 5}"
. _ :§s 'Siéééxiaszz ?8§ 39551031 2?5 is """ H 3252 ;2e::§-=;L{g; mm E35 .A :?€1§'22€ 'j'3::éEzzre £,i?7£d€I" 533%: 3328 ' 2E§;.gr€<§Vz'V€;"2§;s s§§;:zV:§@:{>,a§ in Ségiéarésg '?§ :':;_z::§ ?8v"%é%§;V%2€ EECE ma €35/§§,>§§.§;§:Ved§ $1,?' §§2€ assesszse f§£}§"é{?;§'?§€ {fag ' .::zé§:§2::;ri§:g Ems 2'25; Vygaser :9 §§'§%§')€§%S€ ;:§e::a:§§,;/5 :32 35822:? 53,?" §€€§§,{}7€E 863% (,3? 51529 5352;, ./ {5} "jiICZ§ .V Ejyen z:"§§§'J€F E2s:}§5:'::2g Ehaé 353:3 §23gr€die:'z5s $§:'§:.»:§&€;€§ in §€C§§i€}§'ES ?§ ané 278 escigi. and 21!/2:e:'é_ Es»; :32: ?"i3@S0?"E{E§5€ Cause S3§GLU?'%j"{)Fjf&i§{£?'€ §:e..~53zf:;:?§§j é€i.:%§§§<; :i}1e:> said g:::"@y§s:'@n3; {he <:::zV:V§;,_(g;'3€£},: éh<:5_ ' dissreiéen :'ega:'s§z'ng £5155 q:ga%2is:i.§g;'«_Q§7 'z;E--:::_? iii $6 impasssai. Efawgwerg 53:9 §s3z2§.E§_z5;é'.«;:% A§€"§m;i2§;§<?fi' €'CEfE§?;G§T fig iess §:§zr;éi':,€fzs€ n:i:2€';'%;u:';:,.?<:>r ;f,?"::f,'i?'€ éfzzrin 3&9 ::r:a.X€:2%:V:%32..V};ar€3:%€§5€s:? gégétigzr the sviéfiiiiig. The minimum gzzészazivigf ¥:&:2_..Ef/>é .AA{mbp:§_s€§ :3 {$3, $33,?» zjzzzsi V ";ig:ng:§:g és mat iess ihar: 3329 ~ ..:;fai%;2iz?":if:.;:':-- §reS{%réE3é':i""*:{:}:€§er Eaw, {$23 revzsienai " a:z:§s{:;.~£;;;;. §?i,>:z5 T';:3;;::" ;__::a:>wgr {:3 §z:%za;n€e {he f::?T£GZL§,§'é§ ef 'L'--gg§:<::3:E§/gag_a:2,:§?;a.grfizzizé éfsaé :3 Eggs. V éifiéfz' :E2_e___{:5s€$3i;z§g ;:az::§:§r*:':g, $5: $233 d§SC?'i3§.i§3"?; 32:23 "33,sE§di 532$; :20 qezzaéig, is Sevégbés, by séglwjjzge 5:" _ A . éi j «Z >~ ' S逧/58:2 88 Q? me 5:55;? 55:53 re:;:°si0:':<.;:§ §;:::;§:@§'i:y Vsgzérzai' §§'§€}G§€€ £313 kjzzzégfiicéésgz ::m$f zimpags? gseézaéigi 32:2; :*:;'1§2j'£::<;z: Efme, 2, 2?': 2.:%e::v sf iéze a§::§r%sa§é §€€§&E'8§§O%"E Sf Eaw, we So :25: gee any :°::er§i is 'ms §§1§:;=Eai am the §::bJ§3§ 駧éti§% QL,i€Si§G§"% Q? §a:r~; fsgmeai £3 3fi$%s'%;€§'€fi in 2"}:r:'a:'a'::2:%._:;o'?i'35$? 5§S§SS€§ am agaérsst me revemgg _.~.§2.CV€:fl€:%§§;§'§;%:;g§';g'; i:%§'::._ §§p§a§ £3 éégméggeés