Kerala High Court
Palakkad Municipality vs Girija on 16 September, 2020
Author: P.V.Asha
Bench: P.V.Asha
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE P.V.ASHA
WEDNESDAY, THE 16TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020 / 25TH BHADRA, 1942
RP.No.306 OF 2020 IN WP(C). 42501/2018
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) 42501/2018 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/2nd RESPONDENT:
PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MUNICIPAL OFFICE, PALAKKAD-678001.
BY ADV. SRI.BINOY VASUDEVAN
RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 & 3-4:
1 GIRIJA
AGED 47 YEARS, D/O. RAMANKUTTY,
MAHAJI VEEDU, MUTTIKULANGARA,PALAKKAD -678007.
2 SOBHANA K.,
AGED 54 YEARS, D/O. RAMACHANDRAN,
KALLINGATH HOUSE, VADAKKETHARA ,
MARUTHA ROAD, PALAKKAD-678007.
3 JAYPRAKASAN,
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O.KUTTAMANI, MANGATTUPURA HOUSE, PULLODE
THENNUR P.O, PALAKKAD-678006.
4 GOMATHY K,
AGED 49 YEARS
D/O.KUNJANI, CHANDAMKANAM, MANJAKKARA,
MANKARA P.O, PALAKKAD-678007.
5 SOUDAMINI T.G.,
AGED 47 YEARS, W/O. RAGHUKUMAR,
PUNJAPPADAM HOUSE, VENGAZHI P.O.
ELAPPULLY, PALAKKAD-678622.
6 VANITHA K,
AGED 44 YEARS
KANIYAMKUNNAM HOUSE, KINASSERI PO, PALAKKAD-678007.
7 ANIL KUMAR V,
AGED 44 YEARS, S/O. VASU NAIR,
DHONI P.O, PALAKKAD-678009.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 2
8 BINDU K,
AGED 46 YEARS
D/O. KRISHNANKUTTY, REVATHI NIVAS,
ATHANIPARAMBU, ELAVAKKAD PO, PALAKKAD-678002.
9 SUDHA V,
AGED 44 YEARS
D/O. VELAYUDHAN, MUNNIKUUDAM HOUSE,
VENNAKKARA ,PALAKKAD-678001.
10 THANKAMANI C,
AGED 44 YEARS
D/O. AMMALU, MINI BHAVANAM, ERATTKULAM P.O,
ELAPULLY, PALAKKAD.
11 VANAJA C,
D/O. CHAMI, THAYAMURALI, INDUSTRIAL
ESTATE,PALAKKAD-678731.
12 REMADEVI R.,
D/O. RAJAN, ERAPPAKOD HOUSE, ERAPPAKAD,
PIRAYIRI, PALAKKAD-678704.
13 SUCHITHRA P.V,
D/O. P.C. VISWANATHAN,
MANAKKAD HOUSE, KIVALLUR P.O,
PARALY, PALAKKAD-678612.
14 SHERIN CHRISTIANA,
LORD SWAMY, MARTHAKKARA HOUSE, PAMBAM,
PALLAM P.O, KANJIKKODE, PALAKKAD-678621.
15 REJANIDEVI M,
D/O. MANIKYAN, PUTHUKUZHI HOUSE,
KODUNTHIRAPALLY P.O, PALAKKAD-678004.
16 GOPI K.K,
S/O. MEENAKSHI , KOONAM MOOCHIKKAL,
CHERAYA PO, KONGAD, PALAKKAD -678631.
17 SANTHA K,
D/O. KUPPAN, KAVUKAPPADAM HOUSE,
RAMASSERI P.O, ELAPPULLY,PALAKKAD-678612.
18 RAJAN T.V,
S/O.VELLAEKKAN, THRAVOD HOUSE,
PARALY P.O, PALAKKAD-678612.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 3
19 NERINA P.H,
D/O. HUSSAINAR, PARAKKAN HOUSE,
VALLIKOD P.O, PALAKKAD-678594
20 RUGMINI P,
D/O.R. PONNAN, PANGAL HOUSE,
PUTHUPARIYARAM P.O, PALAKKAD-678731.
21 PRIYA D,
D/O.DAMODARAN, MANTHAKKAD HOUSE,
MALAMPUZHA P.O, PALAKKAD-678651.
22 USHA P.S,
PUTHODE HOUSE ,KONGAD P.O, PALAKKAD-678631.
23 KRISHNAMOORTHY K.C,
KUNNIL HOUSE, KAIYARA, NOCHIPULLY P.O,
MUNDUR-678592.
24 RASHEEDA A.H,
D/O. NABEESA, PUTHIYARKULAM,
KINAVALLUR P.O, PALAKKAD-678612.
25 RAJAMANI A,
D/O. AANDI, KATTIRAMKUNNAM HOUSE,
OLASSERI P.O, KODUMBU, PALAKAKD-678551.
26 GEETHA K,
D/O. KUMARAN, KORAMKOD HOUSE,
KODUMBU P.O, PALAKKAD-678551.
27 SUSHEELA M,
D/O. MUTHU, VALAPPU HOUSE, OLASSERI P.O,
KODUMBU, PALAKKAD-678551.
28 KRISHNAKUMARI V,
D/O. VELAYUDHAN, CHOORIKKAD HOUSE, KALLIMUTTAM,
PONPULLY P.O, PALAKKAD-678552.
29 GOPALAN V,
S/O.VELAYUDHAN, PALIYAMPADI HOUSE,
THIRUVALATHUR P.O, KODUMBU ,PALAKKAD-678551.
30 SHYAMALA K,
D/O. KOTTAN, 8/256, NERUKAKKAD HOUSE,
KALLEPPULLY P.O, MARUTHAROAD, PALAKKAD-678551.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 4
31 LEELA P.M,
W/O. VENUGOPAL, PATTIPUDI HOUSE, KINAVALLUR P.O,
PARALY, PALAKKAD-678612.
32 CHANDRA PRAKASH M,
VARAMPALLAM HOUSE, KALLEKKAD P.O, PALAKKAD-678006.
33 SUMATHY V.K,
D/O. KRISHNAN, VALLURTHODI HOUSE,
MANKURISSI P.O, PALAKKAD-678613.
34 PRANCHINA A,
D/O. APPUKUTTAN, MALAYAMPURATH HOUSE,
CHIRAPPADAM, OLASSERI P.O, PALAKKAD-678551.
35 RADHA P.A,
D/O. APPUNNI, DEVASWOM PARAMB HOUSE, ODANNUR,
PARALY P.O, PALAKKAD-678613.
36 DEVAYANI,
D/O. VELAYUDHAN, CHANDEKKAD HOUSE,
MANKARA P.O, PALAKKAD-678613.
37 GEETHA A,
D/O.AARU, CHEMBORD HOUSE, PONPULLY P.O,
PALAKKAD-678552.
38 STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, LOCAL SELF
GOVERNMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
39 EMPLOYMENT OFFICER,
FORT ROAD, KENATHU PARAMBU, KUNATHURMEDU,
PALAKKAD,KERALA-678001.
40 DIRECTOR,
DIRECTORATE OF EMPLOYMENT, EMPLOYMENT DIRECTORATE,
6TH FLOOR, THOZHIL BAHVAN, VIKAS BHAVAN P.O.
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695033.
SRI.R.KISHORE, SC
SMT.VINITHA.B., GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
16.09.2020, ALONG WITH RP.538/2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 5
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE P.V.ASHA
WEDNESDAY, THE 16TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2020 / 25TH BHADRA, 1942
RP.No.538 OF 2020 IN WP(C). 25812/2018
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) 25812/2018(B) OF HIGH COURT OF
KERALA
REVIEW PETITIONER/2nd RESPONDENT:
PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
MUNICIPAL OFFICE, PALAKKAD -678 001.
BY ADV. SRI.BINOY VASUDEVAN
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:
1 ARUMUGHAN,
S/O.KARUPPAN, AGED 48 YEARS
RESIDING AT MATHAPARAMB, PANAYUR P.O,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT-678 552.
2 JAYANTHI L.,
AGED 45 YEARS, W/O. VISWANATHAN,
KOTTAPALLA VEEDU, KINAVALLUR P.O,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT- 678 612.
3 MURALIDHARAN D.,
AGED 48 YEARS, S/O. DORAI K,
HOUSE 20/88, MANKAVU, EDAVAR STREET,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT- 678 001.
4 SASIDHARAN K.K.,
AGED 49 YEARS, S/O. KOMBI,
KODAKKAD POTTA, KINAVALLUR P.O, PARLI PALAKKAD,
PALAKKAD DISTRICT-PIN -678 611.
5 USHA C.T.,
D/O.THIMOTHI, CHITTIPARAMBU,
SELVAPALAYAM, PALAKKAD.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 6
6 STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY,
LOCAL SELF GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695001.
7 EMPLOYMENT OFFICER,
FORT ROAD, KENATHUPARAMBU, KUNATHURMEDU,
PALAKKAD, KERALA -678 003.
8 DIRECTOR,
DIRECTORATE OF EMPLOYMENT,
EMPLOYMENT DIRECTORATE, 6TH FLOOR,
THOZHIL BHAVAN, VIKAS BHAVAN P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM -695 033.
9 SHAJAHAN,
AGED 50 YEARS, S/O. M ALI KHAN, MURIKAVU,
WEST YAKKARA, PALAKKAD-678001.
10 MANIKANDAN T.,
AGED 39 YEARS, S/O. KRISHNAN, KALPATHY,
THOTTUPALAM, PALAKKAD-678001.
11 GANESH,
AGED 39 YEARS, S/O. KRISHNAN, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHUR MEDU, PALAKKAD-678001.
12 MOHAMMED RAFEEQ,
S/O. M. MOIDEEN, AGED 41 YEARS, 4/447,
SANKUVARATHODU, KALPPATHY, PALAKKAD-678001.
13 KANNADAS C .,
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O.K.S CHELLAN, KALIYAMKUNNAM HOUSE,
KINASSERI P.O., PALAKKAD 678 701.
14 HASSAN,
S/O. HANEEFA, KUNNUMPURAM,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
15 USMAN,
S/O. HANEEFA, KUNNUMPURAM, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
16 AYYAPPAN D.,
S/O. DHARMARAJ K., 3/121, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 7
17 SHAHUL HAMEED,
S/O. NAGOOR VEERAN, KUNNUMPURAM,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
18 MANIKANDAN D.,
S/O. DHARMARAJ, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
19 MANIKANDAN,
S/O. MARIDAS, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
20 KANNAN D.,
S/O. DHARMARAJ,
3/212, SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
21 MALLIK,
D/O. AANDAVAN KAZHIPARAMBU,
VADAKKANTHARA P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
22 KANTHOON,
W/O. ASHKAR, 4/286, SANKUVARATHODU P.O.,
KALPATHY POST, PALAKKAD-678701.
23 PAZHANIYAMMAL,
W/O.S.SELVARAJ, AGED 46 YEARS,
KUNNUMPURAM, PALAKKAD-678701.
24 KAALIYAMMA,
W/O.MARIDAS, AGED 46 YEARS,
KUNNUMPURAM P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
25 AARUMUGHAN,
S/O. KRISHNAN,
SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
26 PECHI MUTHU,
S/O.MUTHAPPAN, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
27 KANNAN,
S/O.KUTTIKRISHNAN, OOTTUTHERA P.O.,
KALLEPULLI-678701.
28 SANTHI,
W/O.SELVARAJ, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 8
29 RAMASWAMI,
S/O. PAZHINISWAMI, AGED 41, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
30 RAMAN,
S/O. KRISHNAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
31 MURUKAN,
S/O.KUMARAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
32 VINOD,
S/O. RAJU, OTTOTHARA, KALLEPPULLI P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
33 MOHANAN,
S/O. KUTTIKRISHNAN, OOTOTHARA,
KALLEPPULLI P.O., PALAKKAD - 678 701.
34 RADHAKRISHNAN,
S/O.PARAMESWARAN, KALARICKAL HOUSE,
AMBIKAPURAM P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
35 VISHNU,
S/O.RAJU, OTTUTHARA, KALLEPPULLI P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
36 VASANTHA,
W/O.KANNAN, SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
37 GANESHAN,
S/O.BALAKRISHNAN, AMBIKAPURAM, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
38 B.SEMINA,
W/O. AMANULLA, DIARA STREET P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
39 NASEENA,
W/O. LATHEEPKHAN, DIARA STREET P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
40 JANAKI,
W/O. BHASKARAN, AVINJIPADAM,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 9
41 MUMTHAJ,
W/O. ABUTHAYIR, SUNDARAM COLONY,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD.
42 MANIKANTAN,
S/O. SAKTHIVEL, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD.
43 PRABHU,
S/O. MUTHU, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
44 KANNAYYAN,
S/O.APPUKUTTAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
45 RAJI,
W/O. KUMARAN, SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
46 ARUMUGHAN,
S/O. CHELLAN
AANANCHIRA COLONY, SEKHARIPURAM P.O, PALAKKAD.
47 CHITRA DEVI,
W/O.MURUKESAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
48 JEEVA,
W/O. KUMARAN, SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
49 LAKSHMI,
W/O.MURUKESAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
50 RANI,
W/O.SEKHAR, SANKUVARATHODU, KALPATHY P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
51 GEETHA,
W/O.ARUMUGAN, SUNDARAM COLONY,
PALAKKAD-678732.
52 PYARIJAN,
W/O. MUBARAK, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678732.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 10
53 SARASU,
D/O.APPUKUTTAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
KALPATHY P.O., PALAKKAD-678732.
54 SUNILKUMAR,
S/O. AKSHMANAN, N.K PALAYAM, CN PURAM P.O,
PALAKKAD-678701.
55 GOPI,
S/O. MURUKAN, NOORANI P.O.,
PALLITHERUVU, PALAKKAD-678701.
56 SETHUMADHAVAN,
S/O. THANKAPPPAN, 5/86, KALLINGAL, PEDUMKADU,
KODUMBU, THIRUVALATHOOR-678701.
57 SURESH,
S/O. KUTTIKRISHNAN, PADINJAREVEEDU,
VENNAKKARA,NOORANI P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
58 SATHYANANDAN,
S/O. PAZHANIYAPPAN, 222(20/517), KALMANDAPAM,
PALAKKAD.-678701.
59 VIJAYAKUMAR,
S/O. THIRUMOORTHY, PEZHUMKADU, KALLINGAL,
THIRUVALATHOOR P.O, PALAKKAD 678701.
60 PRADEEP,
S/O. SELVARAJ, MUNICIPAL QUARTERS,
KALMANDAPAM, PALAKKAD-678701.
61 RAJESH,
S/O. BALAN, NEAR EAST FORT,KANALVARAMBU,
CHITTOOR ROAD, PALAKKAD-678701.
62 PRABHAKARAN,
S/O. CHAMIYAR, 15/167, PRATHIBHA NIVAS,
KALLEPPULLI, MARUTHA ROAD, PALAKKAD-678701.
63 ARJUNAN K.,
S/O. KRISHNAN, ERADU HOUSE,
THIRUNELLAI P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
64 PRADEEPKUMAR,
S/O. SUBRAMANIAN, CHALUVARAMBU,
THIRUNELLAI, PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 11
65 OMASUNDARAN,
S/O. SUBRAMANIAN,CHALUVARAMBU,
THIRUVELLAI, PALAKKAD-678701.
66 HARIDAS,
S/O. KANTHASWAMI, 537(1/324), APPUPILLAYOOR,
NALLEPPILLY GRAMA PANCHAYATH-670732.
67 PRAKASAN,
S/O.MURUKESAN,THUDUKAD CHENTHAMARA NAGAR,
PALAKKAD-670732.
68 GUBENDRAN,
S/O.KRISHNAMOORTHY, MUNICIPAL LANE,
KANMANDAPAM, PALAKKAD-670732.
69 BABU,
S/O.SUNDARAN, 268(20/260),
PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY-678701.
70 ANWAR,
S/O.HUSSAIN, 33/83 SIVANI, VENNAKKARA,
THIRUNELLAI P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
71 RAVI M.,
14/248, MUNICIPAL LANE, KANMANDAPAM,
PALAKKAD-678701.
72 M.VIJAYAKUMAR,
S/O.MURUKESAN, KANALVARAMBU, THIRUNELLAI P.O,
PALAKKAD-678701.
73 KRISHNANKUTTY V.,
S/O.VELAYUDHAN, 25/348, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
74 RAJEESH B.,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN, MILARUDHEEN NAGAR,
VENNAKKARA, PALAKKAD-678701.
75 SASI L.,
S/O.LAKSHMANAN, OTHUKODE, THIRUNELLAI,
PALAKKAD.-678701.
76 MOHANDAS K.,
AGED 48 YEARS, S/O.KOPPUNNI, MALAKKAD,
NATTUKAL, KOZHINJANPARA, PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 12
77 SATHEESH B.,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN, MILARUDHEEN NAGAR,
PALAKKAD-678701.
78 KANNAN L.,
S/O. LAKSHMANAN, OTHUKODE,THIRUNELLAVU,
PALAKKAD-678701.
79 HARIS V.,
S/O. VAHAB, CHALUVARAVU, VENNAKKARA,
PALAKKAD-678701.
80 VELAYUDHAN M.,
KAIKUTHUPARAMBU, NOORANI, PALAKKAD-678701.
81 PARAMAN C.,
S/O. CHAMI, THIRUNELLAI, PALAKKAD-678701.
82 VIJAYAN P.,
S/O.PAZHANISWAMI, KALPATHY, THOTTUPALAM-678701.
83 MANIKANDAN C .,
S/O.CHANDRAN, KALLIYAMKANDATH HOUSE,
EZHANTHISEKHARATHODU, PALAKKAD-678701.
84 GOPALAKRISHNAN,
S/O. KITTU, NELLIKKUNNAM HOUSE, KINASSERY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
85 SANTHI,
W/O.LATE RAJU, PATTANITHERUVU, PALAKKAD-678701.
86 MANIKANDAN R.,
S/O. RAJU, AANACHIRA, SEKHARIPURAM,
PALAKKAD-678701.
87 SARAVANAN T.,
S/O. THANKAPPAN, THOTTUPALAM, KALPATHY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
88 VINEETH C.,
S/O. CHANDARAN, THOTTUPALAM, KALPATHY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
89 KARTHIKEYAN C.,
S/O. CHINNASWAMI,THOTTUPALAM, KALPATHY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 13
90 SEKHAR C.,
S/O. CHANNASWAMI, THOTTUPALAM, KALPATHY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
91 SIVAKUMAR R.,
S/O. RAMCHANDRAN,THOTTUPALAM,
KALPATHY, PALAKKAD-678701.
92 MURALI P.,
S/O. PAZHANISWAMI, THOTTUPALAM,
KALPATHY, PALAKKAD-678701.
93 RAJAN P.,
S/O. PAZHZNISWAMI,THOTTUPALAM, KALPATHY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
94 VISWANATHAN V.,
S/O. VELU, KOTTAMAITHANAM, CHITTOOR ROAD,
PALAKKAD.-678701.
95 JAYAKRISHNAN,
S/O.VELAYUDHAN, ELANTHIYANGODE HOUSE,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
96 KRISHNANKUTTY,
S/O. PANGAN, KENATH HOUSE,CHITTOOR ROAD,
PALAKKAD-678701.
97 RAVEENDRAN V.,
S/O. VELAN, KENATH HOUSE,CHITTOOR ROAD,
PALAKKAD.-678701.
98 GURUVAYOORAPPAN,
S/O. RAMAKRISHNAN, KANNAMBARIYAM,
WEST YAKKARA, PALAKKAD-678701.
99 SURESH BABU,
S/O. PRABHAKARAN, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHOORMEDU, PALAKKAD-678701.
100 MANIKANDAN K.,
S/O. KUMARAN, KUNDANATTU HOUSE, SELVAPALAYAM,
PALAKKAD-678701.
101 SANTHA,
29/1369, SREENAGAR COLONY, WEST YAKKARA,
NOORANI, PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 14
102 AYYAPPANKUTTY B.,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN, HARIPRIYA NIVAS,
MUTUKULAM, NOORANI P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
103 RAJEEV,
S/O. MANI, YAKKARA RAILWAY GATE,
AANGARAPARAMBU, PALAKKAD-678701.
104 MANOJKUMAR,
S/O. CHANDRAN, CHIRAKKAD, KUNNATHOORMEDU,
PALAKKAD-678701.
105 SHANMUGHAN,
S/O. SUBRAMANIYAM, CHITTOOR, PALAKKAD-678701.
106 PARVATHY,
D/O. KURUPPAN, KENATHPARAMBU, CHITTOOR ROAD,
PALAKKAD-678701.
107 RAJESH KUMAR,
S/O. RAJAN, MANKAVU, NEW COLONY,
PALAKKAD-678701.
108 SULAIMAN,
S/O. MOHAMMED RAWTHER,
METTUPALAYAM STREET, PALAKKAD-678701.
109 PRADEESH B,
S/O. BABYKUTTAN, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNITHIMADU, PALAKKAD-678701.
110 SUBASH C.,
S/O. CHANDRAN, KENATHAPRAMBU, KUNATHURMEDU P.O,
CHITTUR ROAD, PALAKKAD-678701.
111 RAHMATH M.,
D/O. MUHAMMAD, KALLEKKAD,
BEHIND CIVIL STATION, PALAKKAD-678701.
112 R.RAJAKUMARI,
W/O.CHANDRAN, KENATHUPARAMBU HOUSE,
NEAR CIVIL STATION, 39, PALAKKAD- 678 001.
113 PARAMASIVAN
S/O. CHEKKAN, CHIRAKAD, KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O,
PALAKKAD -678 013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 15
114 UDAYAKUMAR,
S/O. SANTHAKUMAR, 12/105,
CHETTITHERUVU, NEW COLONY, SULTHAN PETTA,
PALAKKAD- 678 001.
115 MURALI,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN,18/112, CHETTITHERUVU,
NEW COLONY, SULTHAN PETTA, PALAKKAD -678 001.
116 BINU,
S/O. APPUKUTTAN,
AMBALAKKAD KALLEPPULLI, PALAKKAD 678 001.
117 AANANDAN,
S/O.CHAMI, AMBALAKKAD HOUSE,
KALLEPPULLI, PALAKKAD-678701.
118 UMMER FAROOK,
S/O. AHAMMED, PATTANI HOUSE,CHERAKKAPARAMBU,
ANGADIPURAM, PERINTHALMANNA, MALAPPURAM-678001.
119 SREENIVASAN,
S/O. VASU, KENATHUPARAMBU,CHITTUR ROAD,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O,PALAKKAD 678 013.
120 ANISHKUMAR,
S/O. VISHWANATHAN, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNTHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD.-678013.
121 PRASANNA,
W/O. RAMAKRISHNAN, THOTTIL ENGAPURA, C.N PURAM,
MATTUMANTHA, PALAKKAD-678013.
122 RATHEESH,
S/O. CHAMIKUYTTY, NEW COLONY, CHEETY THERUVU,
SULTHAN PETTA, PALAKKAD-678013.
123 SATHEESH,
S/O. CHAMIKUTTY, NEW COLONY, CHEETY THERUVU,
SULTHAN PETTA, PALAKKAD-678013.
124 GOPI,
S/O. KRISHNANKUTTY, KENATHU PARAMBU,
KUNNATHUR MEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
125 SIDHARTHAN,
S/O. RAMAN, PLAKKOTTU HOUSE,
KANNADI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 16
126 MARIMUTH,
S/O.GOODALINGAM, KALLEPPULLI, PALAKKAD-678013.
127 KRISHNANKUTTY,
S/O. KARUMAN, PANDARAKKAVU,
KIZHAKKEYAKKARA, PALAKKAD 678 013.
128 RADHAKRISHNAN V.,
S/O. VELAYUDHAN M., 22/354,
SELVAPALAYAM, PALAKKAD-678013.
129 ARUNPRASAD,
S/O. MANIKYAN, AMBALAKKAD POST,
KALLEPULLI-678103.
130 RAJAN,
S/O. MANIAMBALAKKAD HOUSE, KALLEPULLI-581204.
131 SANTHOSH,
S/O. CHITHAMBARAM, DURGANILAYAM, CHIRAKKAD-678013.
132 VINODKUMAR,
S/O. PAZHANIAPPAN, RAILWAY QUARTERS 284/A,
NORTH COLONY, KALLEKULANGARA P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
133 MALLIKA,
W/O. VISWAMBARAN, CHITRA NIVAS,
MANAL MANNA, PALAKKAD-678013.
134 GANESAN,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN, SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE , KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
135 SABARI,
S/O. BALAKRISHNAN, SANKUVARATHODU,
NEAR NEW KERALA THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
136 MANIKANDAN,
S/O. VEMBOOLAN, SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
137 MANIKANDAN,
S/O. SAKTHIVEL, SANKUVARATHODU,
NEAR NEW KERALA THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 17
138 BALAKRISHNAN,
S/O. PAZHANISWAMI, SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
139 ANJANA,
S/O. ARUMUGHAN, SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
140 LAKSHMI NARAYANAN,
S/O. VELUCHAMI, SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
141 GIRI,
S/O.DURAISWAMI, SANKUVARATHODU,NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O., PALAKKAD-678013.
142 SURENDRAN,
S/O. PAZHANISWAMI SANKUVARATHODU, NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
143 KANNAYYAN,
S/O. APPUKUTTAN, SANKUVARATHODU,NEAR NEW KERALA
THEATRE, KALPPATHI P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
144 USHA,
W/O. BALAKRISHNAN, AALANGATTU THARA,
MANAPPULLIKKAVU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
145 GOPI,
S/O. NATARAJAN, MUNICIPAL LANE, KALMANDAPAM,
PALAKKAD-678013.
146 BABU,
S/O. SUNDARAN (JOSEPH), PRATHIBHA NAGAR ,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
147 NATARAJAN,
S/O. JAGANATHAN, GOPALA NAGAR, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHURMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
148 PARTHIPAN,
S/O. PACHALINGAM, KUMARI BHAVANAM,
EDATHEERUVU, MANKAVU, PALAKKAD-678013.
149 PRABHAKARAN,
S/O. CHAMIYAPPAN, PRATHIBA NIVAS, MANALI ROAD,
TAGOOR NAGAR, PALAKKAD-678013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 18
150 SUJITH,
S/O. MAHALINGAM, MUNICIPAL QUARTERS,
MANNARKADPARAMBU, KADANGODE,
PALAKKAD-678013.
151 UNNIKRISHNAN,
S/O. CHANDRAN(MUTHU), C.B ROAD,
SELVAPALAYAM, PALAKKAD-678013.
152 VIJAYA,
W/O.PAZHANISWAMI, MADHURAVEERAN COLONY,
KALAPATHY P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
153 SUNIL,
S/O. MANIKKAN, CHIRAKKAD KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
154 SEKHARAN,
S/O. AARUKUTTY, VANNACHALA,
MANGAVU, PALAKKAD-678013.
155 GANESH,
S/O. PATTAPPAN, KAIPPALAM HOUSE,
MUNICIPAL COMPLEX, EDATHERUVU, PALAKKAD-678013.
156 PANDYARAJ,
S/O. P. RAJU, AANACHIRA, SEKHARAPURAM P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
157 SIVARAJ,
S/O. RAJU, C B ROAD, SELVAPALAYAM,
PALAKKAD-678013.
158 MANIKANDAN,
S/O. SANKARAN, 7/458, KANNAMBARIYATHKALAM,
KODUMBU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
159 UMESH,
S/O. SAMPATH MUNICIPAL LANE
KALMANDAPAM, PALAKKAD-678013.
160 KANNAN,
S/O. SWAMINATHAN, VALLINILAYAM, DATHERUVU,
MANGAVU, PALAKKAD-678013..
161 RAJESH,
S/O. RAJENDRAN, MUNICIPAL LANE,
KALMANDAPAM, PALAKKAD-678013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 19
162 JAYADEVAN,
S/O. KUTTAPPAN, PONPARAMBU-3,
KANNADI PANCHAYAT, PALAKKAD-678013.
163 PASUPATHY,
S/O.P.RAJU, AANACHIRA, SEKHARIPURAM,
PALAKKAD-678013.
164 YUNUS,
S/O.A BDUL SAMAD, 12/367, PONPARAMBU-4,
KANNADI PANCHAYAT, PALAKKAD-678013.
165 VELMURUKAN,
S/O. PONNUCHAMI, 9/533, KALLAMKULAM,
MARUTHA ROAD, PALAKKAD-678013.
166 RAJESHKUMAR,
S/O. RAJAN, NEW COLONY, MANGAVU, PALAKKAD-678013.
167 VIPIN,
S/O.PAZHANIMALA, C.B ROAD,
SELVAPALAYAM, PALAKKAD-678013.
168 MANOJ KUMAR,
S/O.CHANDRAN, 24/206, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
169 SHANMUGHAN,
S/O. SUBRAMANIAN, KULAPPULLY HOUSE, MAMBILI
CHUNGAM, NALLEPPULLI P.O, CHITTOOR TALUK,
PALAKKAD-678013.
170 SEKHARAN,
S/O. RAJU, C.B ROAD, SELVAPALAYAM,
PALAKKAD-678013.
171 SUNITHA,
W/O. UNNIKRISHNAN, NEELIKKODU HOUSE,
RAMASSERY ROAD, PUTHUSSERY P.O,
PALAKKAD-678013.
172 JAYANTHI,
W/O. MANOHARAN, SANYASI PARAMBU, NEELIKODE,
AKATHETHARA, PALAKKAD-678013.
173 SANTHOSH KUMAR,
S/O. NACHIMUTHU, GAUTHAM NIVAS, 14/1308,
NERIKAKKAD, CHANDRANAGAR P.O, PALAKKAD-678013.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 20
174 RAJAN (SATHYANARAYANAN),
S/O. KUTTAN KALLATTUKULAMBU PANAGATTIRI
KOLLAMGODE, PALAKKAD-678701.
175 RADHAKRISHNAN,
S/O. THANKAPPAN, KUNDUMARIYALPURAM,
KOTTEKKAD KUNNU, THENUR P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
176 DEVADAS,
S/O. RICHARD, 4/300, VARIYAMPARAMBU,
KALLAKKAD P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
177 CHANDRASEKHAR,
S/O. MARIYAPPAN, EDATHERUVU, MANGAVU,
PALAKKAD-678701.
178 RANJITH,
S/O. NARAYANAN, KURUPPATH HOUSE, AALAMBALAM,
KALLEPPULLI P.O, PALAKKAD678701.
179 REKHA,
W/O.SATHEESH, KRISHNA NIVAS, 4/212, OORAPPADAM,
KODUMBU P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
180 LEELA,
W/O. SUNILKUMAR,1/766, KANAL ROAD, ALAMGODE,
OLAVAKKODE P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
181 VIJAYALAKSHMI,
W/O. UNNIKRISHNAN, 28/879, RAMANCHENNATH HOUSE,
WEST YAKKARA, PALAKKAD-678701.
182 VASANTHA,
W/O. SIVAN, PANATHODI, PALAYALAM,THIRUNELLAI P.O,
PALAKKAD-678701.
183 JAYALAKSHMI,
W/O. UNNIKRISHNAN, 13/146, AYYAPPANKAVU,
SEKHARIPURAM, PALAKKAD-678701.
184 GIRIJA,
W/O. PRADEEPKUMAR, 22/209,
MANIYANKADU, CHIRAKKAD, KUNNATHOORMEDU,
PALAKKAD-678701.
185 SOUMYA,
W/O. GOPI, KENATHPARAMBU, CHITTOOR ROAD,
KUNNATHORMEDU, PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 21
186 SINDU,
W/O. SUNDARAN, VALIYAPADAM,
PUTHUPPALAYM P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
187 SOBHA,
D/O. BALAN, 18/777, KOMBANKUZHI, KOPPAM,
PALAKKAD-678701.
188 PARIMALAM,
W/O. KESAVAN, JAYA NIVAS, ALAMKODE THARA,
EAST YAKKARA, PALAKKAD-678701.
189 RAJANI,
W/O. RAMADAS, 26/161, MANGAL HOUSE, PANDARAKKAVU,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
190 DEEPA,
W/O. MANI,
10, 292 ARCHANA COLONY, KALLEPPULLI,
PALAKKAD-678701.
191 SUMITHRA,
W/O. PRAMESWARAN, 33/13, PARAKKALAM, VENNAKKARA,
THIRUNELLAI P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
192 SHAKKEENA,
S/O. MOHAMMED, PADATHU COLONY,
KALLELLAD NEAR CIVIL STATION, PALAKKAD.-678701.
193 NIRMALA,
W/O. SAVRANAN, 24/229, CHIRAKKAD,
KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O., PALAKKAD-678701.
194 MERABHAI,
W/O.RAMADAS, VELLOTTU HOUSE, THAMARAKKULAM,
VANDAKKANTHARA P.O, PALAKKAD-678701.
195 SENTHILKUMAR,
S/O. MURUKAYYAN, 16/25, NEW COLONY, KALMANDAPAM,
PALAKKAD-678701.
196 MANOHARAN,
S/O. KANDAMUTHAN, EDATHERUVU,
MANGAVU, PALAKKAD-678701.
197 GUNASEKHARAN,
CHIRAKKAD, KUNNATHOORMEDU P.O.,
PALAKKAD-678701.
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 22
198 DEVIDASAN,
M/O. KAMALAKSHIYAMMA, REVATHI HOUSE,
THONIPALAYAM, AMBIKAPURAM, PALAKKAD-678701.
199 CITU SANITATION WORKERS UNION,
TO BE REPRESENTED BY ITS CONVENER, PALAKKAD
MUNICIPALITY 18/832, ABUDHABI COMPLEX, PUTHUR RD,
SHESHADRI NAGAR, KOPPAM, PALAKKAD - 678 001.
200 BMS SANITATION WORKERS UNION,
TO BY REPRESENTED BY ITS CONVENER, BMS OFFICE NEAR
LAW COLLEGE JUNCTION, KUNNUKUZHI P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM-695035.
R BY ADV. SRI.R.KISHORE (KALLUMTHAZHAM)
SMT.VINITHA.B, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
THIS REVIEW PETITION HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
16.09.2020, ALONG WITH RP.306/2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY
PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 23
ORDER
Dated this the 16th day of September 2020 The Municipality has filed Review Petitions against the judgments in W.P.(C) No.42501 of 2018 as well as Writ Petition No.25812 of 2018. An additional affidavit dated 14.9.2020 has been filed along with I.A.No.3 of 2020 stating as follows in paragraphs 4 to 9.
"4. I respectfully submit that there are 52 Wards in Palakkad Municipality. There are altogether 182 permanent sanitation workers who are distributed in 6 divisions. 54 of them are engaged or allotted work to clean public roads, parks, bus stands, markets and the Municipal office. 30 employees are engaged for removing waste through vehicles specified for the same. 59 of them are engaged for cleaning the public drainage. 21 of them are engaged for cutting the weeds and other plants that are growing in the main roads. They are using bush cutters for doing the work. They also disinfect by using power spray. Apart from this 9 sanitation workers are engaged in the Thumburmozhi waste treatment plant. 9 of them are engaged as drivers of the vehicles which are used for removing the waste.
5. I respectfully submit that at present the Municipality is able to satisfactorily do the sanitation works by employing the aforesaid 182 employees. Their man power is being used in an effective manner so as to avoid engaging temporary hands considering the acute financial R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 24 crisis being faced by the Municipality.
6. I respectfully submit that apart from this, waste from the houses and other institutions are being collected by volunteers, 151 in number who are popularly known as Haritha Karmasena. The 3 members from each ward constitute the above force. They are recruited through Kudumbasree units. They are collecting waste from houses, shops and other institution. Once they started to function, the sanitation workers were relieved from the duty of primary collection of waste. These persons are being paid by the respective houses/shops/institutions. The Municipality is only providing them glouses, masks, uniforms and a trolli for removing the waste. They are being employed pursuant to an order issued by the Government in this regard. The burden of sanitation workers had been relieved much.
7. I respectfully submit that there are ward level committees engaged in cleaning works. The funds are provided by NHM and Suchitwa Mission. The employees who are undertaking the work are being engaged by the ward level committees on local basis. They are engaged in cutting and removing bushes, and for cleaning of drainage. They are being paid wages on daily basis. It is relevant to note that funds are being provided by the aforesaid missions and the funds of the Municipality are not being used at all.
8. I respectfully submit that various projects are being implemented in the Municipality. The eradication of mosquitoes and the cleaning activities before the monsoon seasons and various clearing activities in consonance with the festivals in the Municipality persons are being employed on temporary basis on being find out and are being employed on daily basis.R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 25
9. I respectfully submit that after the judgment in both the cases were rendered the review petitioner Municipality had not made any appointments of sanitation workers. The stand taken by the Municipality that they are not in a position to make regular appointments was taken on a bonafide manner. There is no malafide intention or even a remotest attempt to overreach the judgment rendered by this Hon'ble Court."
2. The learned counsel for the writ petitioners submit that the Municipality is denying appointment to persons like petitioners who were sponsored by the Employment Exchange whereas the DLR workers are given employment regularly even if it is through National Health Mission (NHM) or Suchitwa Mission. According to the learned counsel for the writ petitioners, when there is sufficient work and vacancies in sanctioned posts, there is no reason to keep the writ petitioners away from employment.
3. From the affidavit dated 14.9.2020, it is seen that the Municipality is not engaging any fresh contingent workers. However, it is seen that the persons are engaged for cleaning either through NHM or through Suchitwa Mission Funds. In this process, it is only appropriate that the Municipality engages the R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 26 writ petitioners giving them preference. However, as and when the appointments are made against the sanctioned posts either against the existing or against future vacancies, no appointment other than from among the petitioners shall be made. In the meanwhile, the writ petitioners would be free to approach the Municipality for engagement as in the case of other workers who are being paid from the funds of Suchitwa Mission/NHM. In the event of any deviation from what is stated in the affidavit, as incorporated in this order. The respondent Municipality would ave to face the consequences.
The review petitions are disposed of accordingly.
Sd/-
P.V.ASHA, JUDGE csl R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 27 APPENDIX OF RP 306/2020 IN W.P.(C) NO.42501/2018 PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS:
ANNEXURE A TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE MUNICIPALITY DATED 07.03.2019 IN DECISION NO.1957.
ANNEXURE B TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION OF THE PALAKKAD MUNICIPAL COUNCIL DATED 08.08.2019.R.P.Nos.306 & 538/2020 28
APPENDIX OF R.P.538/2020 IN W.P.(C) NO.25812/2018 PETITIONER'S DOCUMENTS:
ANNEXURE A : TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION OF THE COUNCIL OF THE MUNICIPALITY DATED 7.3.2019 IN DECISION NO.1957.
ANNEXURE B : TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION OF THE PALAKKAD MUNICIPAL COUNCIL DATED 8.8.2019.
ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS :
ANNEXURE R1(d) : COPY OF THE RTI QUESTIONNAIRE DATED 20.5.2020 AND RTI OBTAINED FROM THE PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY DATED 18.6.2020 NUMBERED AS H6-15047/2020 (RTI).
ANNEXURE R1(e) : COPY OF THE MINUTES OF THE MEETING HELD BY THE PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY NUMBERED AS H2-1608/04 DATED 9.1.2020.
ANNEXURE R1(f) : COPY OF THE RTI QUESTIONNAIRE DATED 17.1.2020 AND RTI OBTAINED FROM THE PALAKKAD MUNICIPALITY DATED 10.2.2020.