Karnataka High Court
Arjun S/O Ranappa Atgundi vs Sushilabai D/O Gurupadappa Yenkanchi on 20 July, 2010
::~: THE HIGZH €0URT G}? mxzwxrgzm, CIRCUIT BE§ECH 25;'? GXILBARGA ' » EATER THIS mm 20%: my 31? JIJL"f$',:'2.;G mg» % BEFORE THE gozmng MR, J1'}_STICI*'.5_E--V pgmg ° ' CRL. RP. NO. 259643;?' 23170» % §3Ei'i."%.?if'EiE§'§=J V' V K ' V z%.§%;§'I.}N 5%/O Eifafixwf-'A A::1::«§5N§§:_ I A<:t;2::.4r;> Ymgass {§{1€f:E3{}{ifEA1... s§:«:;«:v':<:::. _ Z. _.
Fifi} m\:<>. 1.83::1.;24§:;iLé;gg4 ; '
:}£§'II."§'£f'; E\EA{}A::E.-'i
<.;§.::J:';;:.'§z<;A.
~~~~ '.,P?{€:'E7£'.§'E<i)E*£E£E%E
{BY 3:53.: :5: ;x§>;'>g::%:s:;_§>.,_Agasggzzpg'
I-'«.§\J§} V' ' ' V '
2. SZ}SEAi§E,,;¥%E5z;.§ :2 ,:"{1E £1':-{EE3flj.§}:%§}§:.P§};§ '2"E;:~»:§§a.r€<:§TA§:' ;%_£:.,{£'; 5% ':r'::g<;§'a>:%:VV " ' ..{:§<::{::~:»a<}:.zss§a::-;:1;:,§.> ,
- .J_:é?<.%;-N E;.:?;R E--§;3;§'«E€J"§%é'E'33;?s3 '§*:i:'s,/:'E>::,E«_.i A ' . 3 §§:§3::A§>:":'§£._ <:s::>:,.<;>:\::»:Y ' T{::.§':;§3A§2<§;;
J 2.<i§£>;<> E}E,3§E"'§EL:'*;§if:§' ;gz::§; 'ms;
<13.' E*»§E{:fiiE5<E §:§.gx.:~:'i"§?vig1§éN 'E"§§?a:EE?§...E%2 §3"§';i>'i'}7;;*:E73{.ER {if€7}i;€.'f,}§"E":' .. , :1; §i§';E:iAE%_.{Z}E:
_ W .n . _ E;??§E%"§4§'§{§ E};""{i} f€%E..§3}?:E'§§E;£%§f§:§I " 5:€'Zi§-§§- E2 §§"§§:%§iiE§ E'¥.,:'{} .%"'-;'§€z%E:€ E"§.;:'a§§E..§' "§V§§?zfI§3§iE7l K143 <.>§°€is3r F€f;t'~§$j.F£1iI'§.i§1§§ $4216: §'J§.:'?:"§ii"§.'..i.{'H'1Ei'i" §:*::,>'m 2a;4ii€:123_t.1§:3;g; me h{}'i,§:'€i€',': 1>a-*iE:%1{3u.'i: piZ'.?'E".i"§i£~3S§{}I': {Ef €:E':{~': Cifzurf.
2. '§7'E":€:. fEié'.i§'S§ sf {ha {ifé:':S€.'. E-E...I'® 21$ E%>'1§(}zvs§;_ "E.'h:;:€, the: r:%3p<::1<ie:'1.£,$ h_;;::ve fi§f;°';'€.£ file: {if;*'§;"i;:,,-gji "3-;m"::
in {}.$.§'€<}.2:2:€}f2=-I}Gi% b€:E'"<}r€ 3-'r'~f=~.§;<i§i§,§j§.Er:7§::i'::sE"é§i.§_v%} Jzzciggé {&r.Dr:.} {}:,:_§bar;__-_§a "é::':..rj <)bi;2::_i':_:<::i :i.2.;s;H--<7;u<3 :i;~rd<:r. {:1 tihaéi s;--;1.f:i'é. t.§n<:: peE:ii:,:{;_;1Vé'r:§s 'fig;-u.?<-3 fiiéfii umfiszr SSe<::é;:i0n 25(2) :f,:"w S::%<éE.}:<:>i";.}i3={iffipi"P1f'<>f£.és;:t.:<H: {sf X?-V{}r11r:£1 i':°'<)m §><}mes%;.i<: '£f:1c:'£§3':'2::%e?';33;'{§¥;;"¢?fiG§L._seé?'§«:§,.:f:§ ixeréain {}§'€§€-3:1 'Fix: §€arf;:1<_:é€i ..C1-.*sz.i:fz;'. "<}._{;:§§§'f:-13;? --._'§J'Vi£';}T):'1.} €}u.§b:;z"§§22. has»; az_:'z§.:::'i.2a;§z:e:{i_ ..__é5;%:i:i ',,,;;3;pg§E§'£?.21%:.:«:3:3. ;2i:'22:.:§ ztgzflé-Ed far a:}?E3;§e<:t,i{§ri'::: :3?" '§%1£*.V;és:'%_Lf;:iV':€::':<':w:3_T£-*%:"?. a;m§ she ps3i'.§%:is:3:1@r$ ears: fiied :3§":>}€{?:§.i§;:"zs; "%:<:_ 3?:}_":i.--».::=. A'--._s:s1:§?:.}Eéi gié-*:i::§i:.i.<}:'3 :32": E§.€}'?.§2iG{}"1?C ._3a?h€.,%;{3:¢a_§1i:§§§ ?;:_.ha §z$§f:2:fi.:?s§:i éiimii Lfiitfiiggéf {L.§f.§}§~E.} has §}é}.SS§€':d E:£: €:T":f"{i.:3r.§f ';.::;:{;§é%:i_ §f}£>'r:zssi;§{': '*J2:'}%_e.z":{t:§:* zém. "E'h::':~ sgaisi «;:':sr::§{::" '?;2e':%':é:{*i'«.__:::§.f4§;'fi?§::'~:§;::%§§ %3§; 5:35: §)~i?f?l§'i'.i€}¥§€:EE' E§s:§'<;':*i»': ihfiz Ef*}e;%$§;<.i__<§:'::§1> 'LE {}:.:'EE}22:';g2s in {i3*3;5;'%§}§3{=,zs§ N{3.S?;_ ;'2QG§ "~e:::':é:'E i;Eéx:=:é $21353 ;'>:§3§3<:2;:§ :35; <'§.i5;§z:2§s:~;a§a%<:%; zzmgé {T{'3E'E§?§§"E'§'§'§.E,'}f§, %;.h{?: C}f€I§E?.E' §3ZiE§S€*,sZi by i.'.Eae §<;:<az';'a&::§ E-Si Acfidi, iiiarfi fizziigge §L§é",§.}n.,.} in ZZ%:'EiSC.N{}. BKEGG? {iaE.&é€.i '.29§{35,2G€}'E}4.,v~~ _ "7§f'§a.€: g:«e.::;§i.i{;:;":€='r ha-1:~:; 47:31:': :5 2:1 p b:'i'.fiZ)E"ff.' this-3 {i{:~1.m;: eh21:}-3::§§§.%§.g'fE?:€%i . m"{E{:=.:*:~:; in t'§2é;% C{'.Z%u£"'i".S5§ 'i3<:z-§::>w. ._
3. Hr-3~::1:"{.': Sr}: K. §>¥E3I3EZ.4E{£i{}§"§.§?.2&I°I'Ef3{i.»{§.!1ff=EI'§ES€':}':'.f{§2* V thé": ps£3ti€;.%Q'r1«:%r and Sr; B B §€'fE1§"T1-"2.£',¢Vfi"C{§U;§:l-SET} far '§'}'1€3 ré;éé;p{;:":£%é3,m., 2%, 'Fh_§?~gie-;1:'2'1i:§€§ V ';'ig1;1.:.:1;é:~;~é%§--.._ f'<3:':« Fighe p£:i.i§.i0:'::3r $u':§mi's:se S<;3<:"t.§{m Efiéfi GE' Pr€;"%:€:~;:%jV:i€'3:9i'<s§f':';?{3:"§§§fé;+11 E:"£:§§':3 .'E3*:§f§:z::e;éét:i.:: Vrioieszlce Aait 2885 $;'i::a?;e::;<s i:.§:.21t.«fi:he:3 ii, s:}i:ij; §z;%:£i<:i2:§ m;3ggi$'§z.21t,@ {>5 fimfi, :::E22.s3s;:
V2-*hc:> %."a._:;2.e'§§ géjé, :5fi',aa:5V§~12:*':»s::{§i{%'*{.3Z<>'r: w'i§:}1§:3 W'h{}8€f ju:*"i${ii:":'{.§:>§} "'5.3§§§'5;i?'-'i:€V;';E'%?*éf,*l'£§L ';3§:%:':§0:é'V"'°g§£:':"n::am€:m:}}; :"e:§icE.<3:&;«:, gmii the said " é:s§::§1 ;§.E $36 $116: {?:>r1:":p<;*:€,2:':_";*;. {§<is'u:"'i. ?é;=:§ ggrzam. ;>:°<';-%;.;<-é2":'§;4§.§:e;'2_L'<;:--:'{i€r zu'°::§ §§e;::;:&2 E29 ssz.:§%>im3E1:.s%; "::E_'1a':; 'aha? :>r<§€:.r "pa~1§;ss§:€§;,__?}§ ':.h€*: Szmgfi: 'i}eEz}*a,:: E; .:':{f;':: 2-2 :}:"{7E::'%r* ;3ass,~se:~:£§ in ':g%(:--<%:'iz:*<iiamfz? 2%-*'i§.§'§. Ems, E~£::=::1<':z:> iféiif {:=r%:§.:;%§' Ea; '%i?"i*§'fE'§€Bi§.i, " = ....§--1:;.z Z'§5§{§§§{'."§"§.{}§"§n E--Es: §*:.§§"'§'%'.:%;"::" §~;u§:s:":'":%':é~; %;:'§'2;u:. £.';'*:%:: E'{f&:5§}€f}§":{§€?§'1%,$ {Es} 9/?"
§/ rm: €fi{}§"£1€? xz.,-'Main '§§'1€.* z12:é;2..:'1i:'z§; i'h::% cie3§i:1i£.ir;'m Gf zzggriiave/(3; pez';<.s:>:':a 2353 sgiae was-§; £:§':e xsvifsé 5;? BE:a.g;2u==;2:z.:'1i'.E':arziyzz1,_2§.f:.i;§§ r:'2.iaf:}§'<':sz3s::i in éhé? f§;'{?2:§E' 2-G88 *{.}":€:K%.§'<?::*€ :-;%I:1§;% {72::":_2j":'k:'3-i.« .f§;22_:£.§:§";__ ' 'be:":%:*.£'§':,::-2 mf £319: Aci; in View <72? 33:? w<}:?§Ei..'g':i'gx i:h€=: ' "
<is%i'§::i€.i{:§:: eagggriewsci p{=:;*:~g.<::3 2&1} {if €:h;2:Af%%é1i{3~.A.<:fi{."--- E?£<%"~.Ei:z1:e?;.T .' fu:"'ih€32' $u'm11i%:€:c:d that if "E..E?i:a..__2*e1_i駣7._ié§ {:12;.£i:'1i;':§_ur":§;i&:f S€*.€.'.¥:.%(§I'3 2% of {he A{f:t:E 'éhe iriawia
3.mezf:<:i€d E:h<:~.."ipEa}1::%. 2%»r19:*L<:§"; EA:-e"--V_m:::g' ._{:E':§.._cs: §:z19,;t;-'3; Far 83} i:E1é:=:s€: §:':<a:--3{>:j.;~.: :.s3':;.:'::;mf:1§A*¥::s§v'* "<f:§a.£.m ;}€ié'Uo:':
umdézr EIEV. '-'L54!-$§i--(;:\..:i <1? mmpéaigzi; as: per S€::;éii:§ii_ ihe <:>:"&€:" .1§E"i iiieszg-.§'a_I 21:15? "
}'§.._ 'E"Ev":§' Eé.1'f:ié;":m.'£%<":§ "'"<t{}u:1s§ei fez' Eihfi :'a'::-;;pm1::is;*.:1€:
."':§"i.E=§}'EE7'1if£i3§.._"§ETEE§;1; an Ei"§:'1éi"'{:%:':::é h.a.:'1i,% S<:%<;:§é<>:1 21$ :7:E€::5:.:'E}; §L§i'«Ji'ES
3.:.:é'":§.3{E§C§i@§:* {'i§fv*'§.§ €iz::u:'t. £23" {fz*i::*:§':1_2:E {"2'e::2r*':: is E§{.'.ii*}i 'ihé =.;f<*:E§¢*:V*§?.'-.:- é;;:':{§ E;~'S3.3;{'§"E i"{:'f§.i€;* f:.::'f;.'£*:a:* ':35 s*s<>ug?§_§', fez" in V:e:_;£§§.E.E_.§<i%:'2v".3190 9:' ;?:.i<:2:1;;§ w'i_*:'.E':: gm}? <>"i'é'1€:' 2.'£f:§i€%f éiiizzst. :;%V€%:i ET}&':§:§ "E2: s:a:.::'*E': $3,332, $3" 3;é'T';é§;§'§ji §}:*§:{.*:a"-:e:{§§:§':§;§:§ /5:2 /' fix beieiféé fizz'; €f.'i'E"1§ gr <:2*:mm.;'-1.: C;:3:;.::*t. :E';e<:<::"2a§1§; 'mg: 5e~;u':3m:%.:e;
i,E121'f{. i:'h€r <£€<f}.:":ii'i<;>:: <3? :;é:;_gg:"im*<:2<:§ p:;::*s:so:': m:.<é2?1z7;s;; "
w<>:'::r:%:: %.-=*«sh2::» _";2:w<:.% §Z}€ft';'.*§'} in d{>m&;2s;£:i€*: 2::%E2:1i:<;:*:é:;E2.:§§"--€%;*i--éTE§7 the :*<a%s:«:p<}'I1<§e:1i. icmzi wh<,:s aI§.e:=;;;;€&; '£';:;:~5h:?:._.'<.;:-gt E:'§<:2::>':'V:" ':é:..{_a? j:::«:%_jI:~a::::iJ-._V V Etés 31:35' aétt. <3? {'i<}m::%s:§i,i_<;: x-"ia3E€:m':e E3},-§*"g'£.§1ké_ :"<}:Ss;:£:'s§1.é:§x:;%:.3*:." ~ ';1'2"'Ef;%.-*? mat'.er:£z1.§s bc:£'<>;"€: the 'l';r§aE C{)L1._f§,~~V%1Ei%'{% 2:n1§3§y~._§3':'r.§§i;;°'2::*+~EjE*:at. {E16 t'::sp<3:1{££tm'. «::<>m<:>,:~3- _w'i£;hEr':'" ":;i}.€z1z}i::g;.f;iaggri§2ve{§ pg-:I:°s3<}:"3;' and E1336: learzaed "Ff_i2a_1'€?é%z:'ri. _h£i$.;"§g§I'1€.E}* iiézafid that, {he pse3.i%:it:i:>:1€r_§£;~e:":f.i'é:k:i§ci {,0 _i}.§1@._;'é§i::fs'z.*iz';.CEe::',t' igihéi' a<f:i:. Si} far ease '{.§"}:'3 i'z§p§'i-E:{:£{E'i'{_;::: _ "';j_:1}é:.e::':;c:.. £55; <:{:e:1<?crr1€:<:i {H1 2;. pé:r:,:5z?}."ééfigéié§:;?;.'{i::3:*§*i §:"i.'§{=%'{'§~fi>'=ea§ 53:6 ::E1€3. "Rial Czmrtg it is seer:
21332115, E,§":{é-.$22.«:%i,<i 2s--§3g_3i§i'}<T:::;:€;,E:}_:11i"~ffrgzgg bmn fiifirii E,3§}{§€'*;I" S&::i'.i::>i': 28:2} rjw '{§';;{§3 r;>%f.'§;)$:§v:"2":€%1:i';*:.§s;: "J315:E<:m:€: ;5°a<:€. zmii £:;E::3:*aef£3r:~*. }§}'f;(§%5'i;€%i€EZ;$ 21re §}:*i§p@:'E§; fr>51E0Ws;%d. Eierzce, ha': ééubmiiss Li€:§':;T.;i; v<}:'i:§:é:;»:f g;:;:;:é*<;£d E23' {'::::»s:z2'i::<s; beizm-* mag; be éizmifirmssii, gzmzgj {'9 §';':':::*: :m=:E:5;"§aE:s; 3:": s."é3s:i:<}:.':i§, 7% am T;éE'2€*«§§2§.:':;i§>z1 i.h;;§€. ii}:-3:' :»:ppE§:iz1%:.§;§3:: iikzzsi. in Eviiseax " . :§<is;'§}%-;''2-€}€}'? E}€;%:"1<:;§*<:< iéw 3% [%_{§d§i.i:.;:'22::E {TZEVEE &§':.::i;g:;: {J:',§}':':.} \V _ $§2;'§§ " -
at iizzébzzrgzz .i.E'Ti €}.S.N<:>,2:?:{},f2{}Gi3 WE-ti} wii:.E2_§.z1 ihzg pmVisi::»ns.--; <35 Sea/:t..i:>r'z 26 of "::.h<<= Zi}{}m8:--é:.i..:<: "ifi<}i&:*2<t¢%'T,E$;a;%jt.. "E'h€-? games? :15; zs§§:~<'; §;:";<;%o;af<i2r:*:1§i:.§: 1&'§fi.1 S€:<:ii<m _;i£"2' « .{§€. ' .sXs::.%:,& E7'14zri,E*:{:1" '§§'1€: 's<3sp<>§'1{§€::':i:::-:2 1i"i£ii'u"€3' ;>r§>a$--s:{i» .. _'_%§=2?i;£2;é:7.{: théf "
T:"§a.§ ifimzri. %3'12?.ii:. '€'h{%j,z gamz fhéif. 21.gg§;"'i:%?-<:§»"§3p%3§:aé::}:*:at: %:é.*'i'é§:§7£:f: .' 'éihe Ema.-'rexzaing 0:? {3£€§ii"1§'U€}§1'" (}'f '{'.1"i#{;;."-v_§V§fi.':§'§. E3{}§§};€S?'.i€T 'E?' §{}§€*.:'1{E€:'3 A:7:'§:. _ E Ezggéé' L9 212::
merit in €:1r:<:% S.-'5'{fi§',\§I1§E:§5.~:*V3%{)E.."V*:.".§._§'§%£j£{i:C§{i*€',§'&L§€}'E'1€i° and fL:h€refm"€ 81$ r<:f$;§;s;§{>:z T_"h:2 <:a:°d€r;s~;
of i'.h<~3 ::<>z:r§:.