K Narayan Ips vs Smt. Annapurna on 28 October, 2009

[Cites 4, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

K Narayan Ips vs Smt. Annapurna on 28 October, 2009

p;V.1z'1i5:sEt1:;1'iM.>11£~: E,1I1{'§f3§'" Sections; 14.7, 145% 302 read with ;':'5a~":<;:é':a'€..m EQQ <";fI15'€ZL 53%. LE%:i:i_tT.i<):i1_¢::1* is a<;:(tz...issc:d 1:>e2f0re £11163 }.t§éi'm1.eLi §iT%€;?s5:1:;§m31.5s ehzcéggﬁz. He has C11;E€f&§§i'i()IKj'£€3Ci the: i111;>L:.§;z-1€:d.'_§:s'1'd¢'t'._ &'..§li'1 'E"1":m:: §;§;::"c.;mm;'i i:}12&:f:. the orcler Em' ;f"ra1'11.i§M1§§ _g:I_i1;_£1*g'ge3 _1;;:_€~r.§f-;'ca i_l?;a3:g;§.21.1. zmd Wi'i.h(}ut j§.1risd_i(%tj<m' K;-. 'Rc>s;;)<>31<:ient, NQ,rE_ 13e'{'m'_e.:"- tE*1is+s_. Cc31'.I3.1'.t E:

(:¥;")II"§."2_}')lEl'E1.'I£M'1E"M She filed :2 gariﬁfaiéi'CQmg§}2;i%1;f{If.'é>I"2 1235-10--85 e..;z:<:£m"' E§%e<\%ﬁ;.i<'.)1'1 §,;()€') 0f7_4_("ir.P.-';C.,:. .v§r1*:.i¢c:.ijx"'«z:v.2-us} :1'e:g_i$t:&21"ed P'.{'3.§§%f' Ii..E{-$859 §1.i2_t:6%;"a1ia.,. ..gi_E}.egi1"1g.b 'i':1*.1';€:T,. E*1.<V*;{:*:""' i"3L1.$3f:Ja»3.:r1<:1, the €§V<::'rw::*.:;=J:.:;§;e%e,:%i f§'S;ic3:v*:»gr'n c;%:'~:1%f; 'xn;f;13_2.11'11. §:::cii1:.0.1" of 2:1 {tiiaily rie:ws_pz1}3e::' "'Z'{rr:;zI's.£.?'5z:i'f §;;+:_.1.'::31.isaiii.tr.:§§v.fz*i:rri"G:-'uE1:)aiu'g£«1 I)i::at:.;'ic"t_ I---ie z.n1se:d to \rm'1'i'iEa.i.e:: E }"x:.:'e g:;;f;'fi<~":v"7_z:1:f1~.<:<3'ss~~--"of t"I?m public: zag;%1i'x:'1s:.t. '(fie p().1i(:€:

'§:i"{.iL€:é-A. "E"I1€:--» .v;;;_;_<;;_:_i¢l1'vz:€: had d€'3Vf3IQ{;)€3(3 an :+i'r1i.Vr}1()s_i%t:y .m;._,fj;z%,1,§_§V::.¢::._'Vi:" i.1{_'1aﬁx?-:c::t:21:ase:£l. On 268" 1.5.3183. whczéal the: deceassed '-.'w;:2,_:%: iT§';v..fvE'*:«i§g,;' -E:...)Vi'€:}§';E§l'f$ﬁ tEi1;<*2 'then 81123 I11:~3pectt.()1' of Po!1'.<::t:".~. ifrom ¥:"§:1:";1:I:'1n'};3.:.:rL"-§:3i.i»Ii<'?€3 €3i:.a.t:§o:r1, \v.h<3 '\>\rass e;:h:5x:'ger shesziieci in mzi1n_@~.=a:::i:301": with Hiéfl m'L11'd<3z" ($215363, c.:2=.m.1<-'.2 {:0 the p1'€S€T-S =ﬁ@Ce.

1mg?g * %:im_:;;V::

a':21;i<mg;§; with 03113631" prilice (,)ffi(',t:'?3I'S~':i«, mak "the ciecixezxssed 11:0 the F*{;}1§<.:<% ;'.%':€:21'£';1?s_?>:'"i aI'1«;:£ as:3e1.u1te<?E. TIIEE said 2'1s3s:3au1t was at fr..§w m:»s:Vr:..i.g_3E;?:.i'.ic')r'§ of t'l'1_(:- ac:<;tus<3d--K.Nzazrayem, ':':h€: ' " tI;1e3;'1 ;?§§%...s,permm,em.i@r1t, of Poliztct. Gu]ba.rg.:§a.. ()1; ae:<;:c>,:;1;=f1.i: 'I;1f:v€~,._

4.

L §m:§efi<;%.m 0:': ,26.€ii._1983, {The i'€'1&iL'i.iO.f1§§§".1.§}l}V_ Eé$é:%1i:\A?{i§§3"1 m:<i:%a,2:;s:§;a':*.<;'i "KN a.1"z:~1y';-1m. and t}:1<?: e:iec:ea,As3'cs«§1*_Tbé§;::2;u_n'e.V '..;:ji§t:;rjc~:A' 56:' K V s_:a£:::"2:ai1MM:mi aimﬁ in (T)£"d<:?i' to ba.r::1_:3s tile:_(:?'c?<:j:&3z1s§t:?i51; .1j 1'1é3 'r1}1Ii'1c:

{if ('if?(.T{?é11ELi%1¥{'§; \ma.s~:a ii:r':ét.£:d in 'i'.}i*x=?:.A_ i*o\_2v'e::1_;:Z aixid m.a.11y £.§f'I§.XfTE.1§i'"§&:-'J (izwséaa WE'3i"E;": fi1_t:V(:'i~ E'1.."fa_1?:.";_."'«."E'hc--3 ::1c:c::L1se:cI had ;<2..§.5§;€:> Esmtsqété 21 Ef).Ag("_;l iéirt£:e;é3'._1:'()'-.ti'1.::'_< A::iﬁ€i1'V1§S'iI:;'--::{t£>.1*, Municipal C-(_.}i'"}lI){l}§TiIi'€"i'£.?1'%71:A.'£3 miii: gé;..;1S.ki11;_;§" if:-2:191 to cjtvittt: tilde dmreasstzcl i§w_:>rI'}. i",E*j3e.: §;3I*€iZE'7i"}.ia'€-4': ».t:.h ciezceamci was :"u1:11'1jz'M1g hiss pJrf¢::*.:4as;<~;«,L Elm'*--_p1...a:*s;;1.iV:;:":'1§Et§ 0f"';t+L.1<:.%"a demzemci by {Line aTc:<;iru£se.d, ﬁh i..f:371i(Lti}1}€:."il' ..Ci10i.'mn?.s$01.16;" }'1ad i8SI,.1(f{"1 2.1c)i:ic.:e to the 't1c'j:sya:-1c:aLt:t§"'ii'E§_e pI."E:II1iE%€;fS. for which the ciecetased 3 V;;:a,"V«s§§M:iiiT., E:"2v<2':1 b€:f<')re=: 14.2.1984. 2-m£?1V1sseci K N'2'§.ré;aya-m' 1:'*g:2u:f}§= e1'ti:m'11ptc:d to (;:<.)mmit mu_rcic£:r of the €i£€ffT(_",f{;":'.'e'E\}3,f%.%'»{.'f'\7VZ:Z§,{fE:§€?? hL'1s?:.>2sz11d of the C<3n.1pEaM§11a1'1_t). In this 'm;é.;§2:::1""<:i, ""<"§";.t:?: GEE->.<;:(2:21sae(?i had pL,1§:)}i$hc:?:d. é:¥. 1"ep<::art; in his " '~ _{:§(:%<'.

E1€:E¥R'S§}2éEi})<i?.§i" ;;3..1iu':i E'12?15a also iI"1.f{'}.1."'.IE}.E5d i;:l'1e 5~sz;'m"1e to the mt-:11 MM? E*Z'Em<:i:;fE E§ha1.m1a1111e1, Cx(.)V(;'1.'II"l£)1.' of K.aLr"r12:ttak¢:::,_ ";;1j{1_ci %?..)I'§T'§'"l.€?:}.";'.L-9;. ifﬁecretazisészci has also wﬁtten 2: £c53;'t':e1' 1r;;')""::IFr2 <::

E-"i'0':"2'h'}<:: {3ﬁ'1"i<-3}? Mjraisatax' i.1.1i'0rmi11g; 't:1V1a.i 3.'}"1_er:;:,. h:JE.ire: M5: by Exhe Ei(.'f('1'1..4EE5i£id and 0'[h€:*:1'L~.sj.

5:3" aim M._2«1984 23%,u_;3?}f3L§i.'.V_']£V{} V_p.;::§';y§:;Ven%:\::--h'e Cim11p.§22ir."12:m'i W515; 2:1 3: her }'101.;%§:€r.,§;ics.1:'xg; :§ﬁ:et..1": faV'm.i_Iy ;"m=%21Ta1bmfs_~x x.v':5.a.iti:'M:;g" abmn, 10/LO @3711. f:?»Ei"i('i §"(:*(1T(j?iVfiTd 5-: ctgﬁi"f.'a'§1ni r3:§;§; E3211'Hie1'\vz:1d, W539; €I§.oE%Li§§'§;i':.)"i.e?§\:',g7 'VV:i;';:if<':>z?111£:cE 111131; Tihe (:E<:t<?:;t2;::s:;:<:i:"vf-5%;/§'5f%§1;§;E?:i%r;%':1.J" .hE£S " bEfCv§'1'}StE1b§3€d. am} Am"1211'z;1c> E'125'iE"§ ' lmspiml. I1:'1tn'11edi:'a€'.<e}y, €"§Ifa::.>.§':°":p§z2:.£mam" ::m<iE '.%_:1.a:-":1: sari 1'ea(:t}_1<::~<i1 th.<-3 §"ms;3i1:a1_, 2111c? the wz3:.,5§; :$'{'.1}§-------:::i'ive: a11'1<::i mi». was in (TéjiES1EE1}i'1i_V', (.119 LKf§_a::.r<'{<:%'a%3A;3é:-viii "E:7i'§7<;2i*:"nc:%€%. the C()n1pIe?:i:1.az1"i: 1i'i.ha.t: "'f.he 21<.:<':us<=:d xvqm iw=;m1:jz<;:§%;Té§g;AT"§i)t;%t"(3.r*&: the (L1€?C',(i'.:jif:§€'{I1 axfid _ir'1st:3gg2:1teci of:_hers *._1it.0 <i:<">z"§';m iE't: mL::*cie:rr zmd asked {hes C()mp§&1i1"12;1I1t: t.<;i) 'dent. 'E,¢~3::z1_w§%="A_' §:"§§m\" 'i"E":<:?re:a.f'"ter, the ac:<%'use:d, when visitied the VA V' ?_:'€m~s»§..}§t:;;:ai;. E",%'1.,:*<:2z:=z.'z;e2r1e<:i i']f:1' iI"£tE'3}'£:1EiE'.1 ;;1E1<:;gji.3:'1g that: if sht: 6;"

W;é3?~7- :-»%:*;:f%:;i nr '<'t§=?3z::";'j,;§§j:é '~w';~1ae4 fiieci a1§.§2;~1ix'1.s3t 11 act<:us:s:<;i=:d. E';

:m.§;:<;»z~""ij m' fikir <::0m_p1a.int, Shit zsmci Ea er f::m1i1y' 111en113€:1.2<i.~;- Wm faz::<:% ﬁi§"§.f::T". e+;«;:a1:"m;Tt i:.1"1i'11g wi"1.2e1.t: her 11'L,:s::E:>213;":cI 1"121:%; fatcted. E§§:ia.<% z;a§ss<'} aiiegtizii f:E':1e:1't she has given. s3t:2?1.t:e-um?-::"1't. h€f@;r"é:--,t11<:: {T.iiO§'iT3 g~.3..;":1.<;'E {Iii-3%". H_<.3weve1f ffZ}£riE-iﬁfd on Ei}"Ié'.*. (3€.)1'}l"1.p1{:1i:fi'f:f(5f An.rm.;::s.mz.;>, 2:1 <:<m1.piai1'1ij. urzexsaes .1*egi$t'..<:é:'*<3(§.V__;,igai11§§'t é Vti}:iee--« U E'1_;k1imm\-v'z'a §]T)€ii1":?:'>(}I'E.€E~3 and f1(I}f, ::é?}§g&1.§_§"T'k§§?-fv -__::i«.;:c1,_:é2§é:Vg:jlj. j "E"'ﬁ:'}.ai>:..rzg;E'.: f%%'$.1;§fi£:%Ti'}€Ii}'1§1 of th e C(Ji"11'f.[)EEfiE'A1"}£i'?'1i"j v\f2:ufaA .'l;;i'3€;.1(L)1T€§€£';.C'§, £33.31 {:§1?<% ,z";1:iL>t :fi.1.<-3 '€;}m Charge $é§311.§{ée:<f_a:'1g2ii:~V1$:iT'E'}1e :ac:c:useci K.§\l'a=1':";«a..3?;~:1Mm.a It £3 £1 E.ia%:g"€-:Aci 'r. 1ﬂa_f1i. i.i":=.<;3:.1__g'1*1% W16'; dc)c:1..1meI:1t.s; K>Wf:*.'£"€'T %"u.;_*m.Ea;E"1<;r{.§Awai. tb<:3.._'t:1ji_a~E.. 'r1150, (;1f11'é'?}.I.'§€3-. E?€$i;1€E€?'fi was filed &fE§3,§£1.§§"I.E3§L',v"'§1§1EF5?i_ §;r<:&§§' §_:z;'M:"i' i%1C§€ft£SCCi"' 'E*£.'i\I211"e1y'a"1:%1 2111ci s5i%1<*: xvaas eVam:.£m*V1.1.i'1<;:;:"i::'§'1}.§;*?:%:;:é3is;111"--f;}'1'a.t' K.Narayzm wili be céharge :$~:«_E:"ac:;*:<:%<'E;s3:<M'£. '*--"}'<j>* imfif' s&si",..,:j;Jri55;3 on 16}. 1.0. "E 985, c::;~:zme 130 E»<;r:'1<m;;'E;'§'n;:"m,2gi'a-. f£h'<:3=fueivspeapeti" t.'§1at. no cthairgezz s3If'1<itc:t _1f1a.s3 "-7?.?vti?<ii.¥t*3 §i§.€%:€5i "":':Lgz1.i'i1.s:3:'€MK.Naraye2'I.'1 by 'éflméé {EB}, 1' I0weve.1', Sm:

{'.WL'r'£]f%%"";.iE'€'V{?:€'i ii§1i§"%' Eawyagéx" and :~:aE'1c% w2§1s ::1ci'vise(i to ﬁle 21 gi;>'E'"iV"é;g'$:.@ <§c:{..)mj:>.E.e::..i.":'1ti. Slat: alleged é.I:"1ai: her" }i1.'L%f:s3b:.»111d was; V.'§)E="}.'E..4EE"(I§€'?§"{§{i .221 {E19 .i;"1$'i:a12"a(:<~: of KIN 2:1 fay':&m--acC::;1_se<:I in that. L'§%'":;11'%[3;j ; gggz"

L€i?£;M".I.'N;3€'.'§ S<':s.sssi<3I1&;~: JL1cig'e 11e2'+u'(;E the: p21r"€:..i_ess b<:tt'()m ch a.rge ésimi "bf/" £::he=: img.):,zgg;'I'1ed ()Fd(§IT {'}21't.<:d I999, 1.ea_.rI'1ed 2f'$<;t&;$i<?n'1&; {E 1.: dge 21.513 di_1"ec1ied fan' f1"2m'1.i1"1,g§ CI"; 2.11*ge7%: V' 'f"'c.>_.i*v1:'i1.¢ ni'i'%3.2'1<:(:: §3'1.4EI1§.5~?f1&1§').E€3 1.II1C1€',E" Ss:c:t:.ic)m'a I47, '1 41.8; Wm ;'Zi?%<;7<:i.i<m 1.49 of {PC. It ise; 't.I"nf'~.<:;"'G_1*.:7£<;:s.* m..[i.1e:<f§ £11 qa1€:&§fii<3.;'1 by the 23£cc:.z::sec.i'bei'1<';r€: €.his..C0».:11.*t..x 1 <1 sjam: A H Eshzai';

iiiﬁzrl, f Cc_ra,11'1:s--;eI za:.pgk3eT"ézx"§?fir15g§ f<i.>1f me: _peii"ti~Q:r'1er' s;'1--b'_z_if;ifj:.f::6aiE. i:i1a.t: {icy pasrgs («H1 <_}:m::§<:tz"* Em" ﬁ"z*;m':_it1§,§ c?:If12311'gé&i, ?}:§2:z:f'r1c§:'<:i. '3~;3<§:;i_:,s3--;%_c)1'1:5s J1V1(.ige ',4.

-""?'€-i'"i1%"i"*<?3- NJ {Y I%'2--.i1I1€:s-6:111" "£:',E."3.;:'i*,-- 'é:E3.é:>--:"€: :-3:.r:e 5sL:ffi(:1'_e3fz'11. g.n'"(31.':m:ﬁ €:.0 _;'5:"%¢;:'s;--:{':t¢:j<'i'=.;3.gs;:Vii'1;$i. .t..E;:e E€l(?CfLI;E':Et3:(j1." if Im sa£:Esﬁe':3 €,E";..2;z'{: ti:';2.<%3§w:*:_ 2;-weir 3"'1~.r:'2 :%ij-;w:,ﬁ_'?"»_1'£'M'T?i'1'--:=%,}V1"1'_i"V g§s'e31.1it1.c§ to p1'<3cte3€:dM, E<:3ar1A1c:ci ;'"§35<;:s:;.€.:;4.i;m'":2:~:;..J'u%3.<:'Igg;:: _ iV.rivc)k":111g file pr0vi:s;io:.3s of Secticm 227 'L }(."1T§".'C§.§",P:C;.5., rc=.q:..1irc3d to CiiEE(?h{"3.I"§;E? thtiz ac;:c:1..1ssecl. He .s,:§_E.:>_:*z'rﬁt{id meat i'}'211ni.r1g§ of a:%1a1:*g;<2 m:1<:ier Sc::Ct.i(;>i1 2;f25i:§"'*-mg? v€:.'f§r.'E?A"'.'ViT§_, £33 bzxsed on the: pre3sst%.1:'r1ptio:"1 that t:.h<::

,;::.(;%c':T;1:t5€:s;:.EV"' E"mW:~, {:0:z";r.1_mit.t.e<:.i an off:-::"1<7:e z.L1Ieg;ed agairlssii .' ﬁr R<:qm,imnM1.m:':t 0f Se:(:ti()m:a 227 82;. 228 of C1'.P'.C., is; ,,.. * " v _§E:'M~.":f E':.E"1zaE mziéreii n'ms:3;i: Ei';><3 s'uffi(éie11Mé'. gg;mLm<:I_ to p1'<)cte:ec:3 agaVi:n:3t §Ih.<3 E;{€'ft("1§fifE-3€3{¥. E'z.:1«:'i £11211. :I'1a1te1"1?a1, if "am; <:<.)1f1t.1":;»1.Ver"£:é3d"HmEst:

:'"<:.=::2~;'a..:ﬁ_'£:.£;td in €r.0m,zi<:'t..'i_o11 of an ::ic:£':t,:::;ercL 'i"'i:'1is>:. mi: 5: 1.11% 113.32%; rmt: i.f>c:2m'1 c:c>1'1sid<::1_'€~.c'1 by t..fE.'1 (-3 J 1..2<'§,;<;;%;"é2 amii :+;ubz'r1.i1;te<:i that 'the n1e<::.h.2:a.nirjaﬂy "E12152; p.:~0c:e<%2d¢d _§.0 (.")%{4"'(','1€?:'!."'"~§";*()I" am. iT:h<: ;s:~;§)ka-*2 ;;'r"0L.s.a"1d that PW. ';)121..i::i':r;rV:.1'j£V*{.,:.VPW;§2~;;§o31 of 'aha: €730mp§a'i_2"1..2m'tr, PW have p§"f.§r12:a~ii;r2.c§c2 ::31:4a?AiV§,e::ci. i1'1__ ti.h.e'. allleged zgmﬁksigréxcicit .:~:1s.m::i "E§"1a;1f;;.i.':s§ sLir1'fiC=iéi1E:. %3;':?.(_):L;1:i'i<M1~~i;'<:> %m€:£3e?:c:i a fa.i1"1.s'!; Min (-2 acrms agaé j.

M1,, " ' 'E~f<:_:VV:32.{f':;AE')miﬁti;:g1''Jf:hz1ti the _Ee3;-Mncici JL..1dg;e 1121.3 <>mi€:.i',e::'e(:i i.:..H=1<..>§'is;:c: i:"i'3t{:~«,impV(31"T:am:. m1c1is_};..mt:ec'1 factt: 'é:h;~11;: for ﬁt-?n;1':1;;: .s:;>ffm:%1€i'<:é;v--~-éhét triai W215: <:o1V1<t1méted 'c'.¥.g{:".1i}1STi '11 '£tm1;*<;f'zV§aeégﬁ,'W:§_m_V;:<r;rr<: <rhe1.1'g<=: s:sh<::<~;zt:<3:d by t.E"::¢: (TB! emcfi in the s:s;§s:;€.<j§' m"'§a1;E,"§31'?W?:»ES {En mise; C8136} was 11%'. {Earn {3i:+.1ir12::1.1"1.t and <._E"a(3 'w:5:.':;:v <f::".:'.s:::»;m'11?t31t:t<:1 are; 'PW~ 1. "Th:-.:*, Dc_><;tt:<:>r }:7*'W«m'7 was PW» z;-he szszid mm. I-9W~ 1. is; W253, ;>w--2 E4?'W~E52.

V "E".E?3<-;%i1" €3?Vi(I'{(3E"3(Lf€f.5 W'I:'if~fa' §t=:::.d by tihe }}I"O$€3(7L"if..EC)I1 and bzisattd z?e,g§;:§.i3'"&s:~3'i', me <:c:3mr2"1()r1 J11 dg§.gT:m{:":r:i; of ﬁlis Court:, the

g)'§:"€:.$<:-r;"2i. (::{').I7!"3§;)i€1.i}7'1£i1.}T1tC has filziéii :1 Spe<?iz+1.1 Lc-rave to A._ppea.l ((f31*'E) I\§<_.)s1§.3'?r"(')(.)~:3'7O} /2009 and '{".]'"I€:', ffﬁélid is ;_i>é;t1";_d.i£1§_§ '§:;.>€::f<.m5:? ii§1";:€:*: Apex Conn,

39.. L,<-3aVrm:<;'§ Counsel fear 1211152. _p<:i.iii"iMc)11 .§;:.r§:3"11"2"i{t5f:.c§'c1 "é_E'".aa'éi m re:-:sa;.3e<t3; <;>.f the Very se1_1.Tz1é:2 €i>ffc€3f:Ct"<:%, 21 t:1f;' a--.E 1'1;1:+3 fl':x<=:€§1*1.

m.1'1tim_itELmi9§. ;~m<:i_ é-3i:'1<:§<~:(:} in e1C<:;§v_é§1'i~Vt':t;23\E of 1.1' z:;Cqu in so "

my saw: the: p.:'s;>.;a~:;er1.t: ace. -%--::e"r;§. ' 15;» c:c3'2"1<:--:2%1':z:":.V€:~ei, 1;:1.1€=:

{Liam pi 221311;;-mi: X?U"h(') iae: eé:5<'::1_1'1A1ij'1.eé?E,as_';€?X5r'.::i3E3 anti her s:»'0:1, w"'E'1<i: $35 <=2.xa.rm.;'n;§<;:i V:-1;::; m 't£'i.i_ca._:s2i1%i(:':A $31.2"-1} 'E"1z»:7s.\/62 sstaiieci. me v'<3ig"yT faa:ti:.Ee% %3{3.§f"g§;i*:=§ i.'})€:"1£:'Za.l"f'i€3€§. Sessi<iu"1ss J[1€i§§€% mld the E.5:;5ai'2'f§z~3%a:.§ ':f:x;_c '"?s5-xioriss; ;;;%__1mt,ge..% _<%t')1V1:i~;§dc:.:'i1:1,%s,{ '§.h€;.':.i.r e3vic:ie1".1.(:e h 21:51 §:'§.{'fC'§§,.gI§{'§Gad 1:}w"' z%;<:E{ia.1::;<3.«:i. T1"1€3}'€3§1£ifi€'.E', E:%'1is~; Cﬁourt on "é'§i'}C3{_.E;3§"{Z'('"fi'i%i,fLi('§}i';i'2.VOf the en'tiire:% c;:\r'ic?1e3r1(::3 im:i'L1<:iing t:If'1e "'e;txr:'(§_§:;:r2<€:5a:%«"i§i:aaf§~ 'E:}":<%+ Coznplama-H11, hex?" f%${l}I'TE e:m<:i a1.~:3o .PW~» L x?{?2'":<V:» 'E3'W~€':3 zexmjii PW~3-4;, Wm) PWP? in tiflis cease, «_w'3"J;a1.;1:;ae.?: (f{vi<;ﬁ<:%1'1{:e w;».'1.i~2 alsso {3C)I'1S»iC1Ef5i"(Ed by the trig-12M] C0L1.rt $53; \§.v§«::£§ ﬁaisi; (Ti<'>'m:*i: and tilde é.1€:.',C fLlS€Ci i"1aVvi1%%zg a»:.u?c;_11it.1:c':d £5 :%*<t:.¢ 1:" %§'a<i;im;~:i.i'z'1g a-m<;»i:_her sep;22..r2:1t£: triai in E"('ES}"}f;??€ff of the E"'li'1('7'? {TH §'§}if:". .

M», Ap::1Z':"i", f§"c)n'1. thté m<::'rii:s;, he :;;~.,:1_j5;,_(:)5suE§miI.Mte2t:i "i::h:a€,. ﬁ':§'1c:': a..i.§<:,g§23Lt:._i<":»m 21ge1i31s1' "Ems 2i:g::<.%a:;:,s»*'<;:;::1': 'jfliﬁflfn 11],"; ex' (%w31.}>§:;z§mi, s;:awc:.>,m st.z,11',<;éxz1<2v:M"a_i: a1'ic'i_ "she. ,V€§'f':'23;'{"-€T:';3;'!I"l'}.€;°.f1'1'_I Vo-15 W:§ti'"m:és~;:'~ga:?ss :'"ee:::'>1f<:ie:(;i in this guzlly *i}I'1a.t this; mf:<:°ms=;::i-taii p:*<;'2s3e2I:ij_ Wit .'j1ihef:>:. §;i'1i;;.r::""A:>i" .i1V1Ci.ci-writ, this, a1«._:<'%mss;<::';£i fE.2"1:4;€;.i§_§z=1'{:<i:<:E '%}1aV,Q1jh-61"' :5.2(f.§:L:S'6:.(i "'z:-zgrxtfi if t}'"1is is the 5,} <miy 21$EE<:§g:;;;-:'E.iz3j§1n A (.}1'.T_1..vv\K,?'I"'}VI'€j.?3\'}!' ;i""{%}':I;:e1.1"g;e h::«1M&s "£10 be §:":a:°z=2sm<3€'¥{Vv "§1T'i§'E7" .jt'}f'i1"<*:~. cz.%i;7?;:=:--<tre':a.,}3.11nié§E"1'a1--1;;i'Ie umdear Sec':tic>;1:3s 147, _]i__43;& Z1562 "§:3's:r;'i<;¥_ i1»~iif'L:~.':'1 "3(_';"(fEA';§(")V1:f1 .149 af {PC}, hr-3 sas1,.2i:m1i't:tc:d £.i'm€. £~szw:fi'1}'é-1 <:i:_§'12;1z'";;c2A~., <:é1~:iI1<3t. be ffra1rn_¢:t<f?3; as no (')ff€:1"l(Tt(;' eﬁ€t4E'.t::§:€'.g=r a31._mEe::;* ;'3et'{§t:Ex?:--:~'--:V.147, 148, 302 rt':t:e:c£ with S(?f(T1".iOI"i 1 mm .:%f:::>::.i1';:T: "be alleged ag{;zs1irA1s.a;t. tLh.§s5:s pe:t.i_t£()1iu':-.r, when f:§"m éii.c.%(':z._N;s§:i3ai?il_ Ahg.-_§21.i.:%2Sé. whom. z2a.Ii€;s._§21t,ic31'3 <15 Sr:3c:'t:1'.<m I302 "v.,}f°E3§3?i£T§ w"i_1g"§"::. ;'?3<=3;c7éii£}r1.s3 147, 148" 149 of H-'(.2 'was z.a1.H€ged " ' Em é%.'%ff§ 4' Tm3:<.::n zgazmg :,.:_.it:i:e<:i~ (iii *'{"°'?'"»mi5--*"3'""' w--v-X"

w"';_ <;%<:»_m:'::1<;>;:'1. c.)b_}?e:~::ct. of the pc?:.rs<:>n$ <;.:<')n1pc>si.1"1gj t.ji"1;:it. as-:sm:'I1biy §:~'s--

i:"~'*"'zT?".;<.4;E; --

iE3;€?C*(.)Ir1€i., '."§"§1.i:"'dm Ei7:'zjmzfI.§"i:.3 V » " A m;;;;:.

<:>:§"§'e;r11c:<»3; 01f To overawe by (::;f:i.m.ir:ai f(>rce§ or ::"sh{:a\2V of c:z"im1'_n211. i"<:>r€:<~*:, {1;h.<--:- ..

tiiamtrai or a11.y Smie: (}'»ovr::nM1;:11c':'x:1%tj ear Pa1'Iian1en.t: or 'tile: I,x3;5§isIe;;fL}';;*:Tc:"* ' (if any' S'I:2«:1.M£:£=:=_], 01' a.:':nAy §33V1__..z.§:'ai'J'L:;V*_'Vj' :e;erve1.r1i: in 1:'h<:*: e:_xe'r<:is:3e: ("3.f__' L" % §a;.:_wf'11£ p()\rae.z"

Eii€:'.1'"VE.1II1T,.; or "To '1'€sissi: ,t.1'1§:: {i:><ié:--r:m':£(>I1 ,»<J}':"f filly Qf s~;m::§'1" v'p{..1VbIVEct " .

izgmr, or of 2113:-yi~eg21_} f:.)jr'{}(2ii?ﬁ'~3ASj'v:€}.f" " S "E70 .ﬁ:(.:mm_1"€; KE3;;'E",i:.\/" 'ji:J"{EEE%3<L311i(iTAtAf H 01' (',fi"§I':"£iI"3'ZI_iV -. $3" §jf;aa:§§:.>;,;:A 4:131" cinthfaié' _ rmf:é11}s.<)f <t3:1?mi1:1a§ f(>r<7:c%:. 01.' ' 7&sV'é'i.{'>w'.'_ iiri': k;rin*3ir1a11 f0r'<::(:, to amy' "V.}T;€:fé:3<i1.Ii",'--«. 4' to vgilk'-;)&5»§°.L~;-.{;'.E':*,;*f%§"(;>r1 of any p1'(:>pe:r'i:y, or ta .. _ €fiV<.tpri've i;:.«1.k€:t 431" <;1biia.i.n.

any pe1:=3«:.m <31" ffhc":

t%'§*;§~:>y1nc:I1t. 9f 21 "rigE'ai:: af way, or of 'the: use of Wain" or €ﬂ',.hE.§I"

V 'm.e0r13c)1"eai righté of \Ar}V1_i.<::I"3 he: in ' 1;;<":s::€5e:ssi(3r'1 01" €I];}()y1T§'°£f:"fI1iL, or £10 cmf<i>r(.:c3 any" right, or $1...a;3p<:>sed ri§;.E'3..t,; or By l"I1G€if1S of <.:1"i1'mina} fQ'1"(;:e, 01"

sshraw 0f<:r1'm1inaI E'()1*c"r&. #1:) C(T)f"I"1}f)f;'.1 ramy person '11:) do what he. is not iieggally 330{.iI"1C§ U) do, or 11(7) omit 'L0 do what "he £ega.}1_y £:z"1.t§t.I<:'-td Hi) dc)?

f€;.9<{)E€;zn.a£:£oi'L An ass<:%:mi:>}y W1'zi.c:h xvas :1 cat m1'E.a.W'§:':.x.1. when it as:.$<"::*.m 11336:}, m.;-1-gyj' E§E'fi"§f}E§§@€}E,1(3.I"1t'Iy bectcinme an a..11'11z£=..w*Ij':_;1i3. L- g2s~a£ea<;:z1'1bfiy. "

W. By" .I"e%'€%i:rri1'1g to 'the: .p1'<3*J4i;~3ic:4_nsV¢ﬁii%' I. E$éCt§.Q'I'1is.. NH. M63 14$? & "148, he s1:1'i3rnif'ii§;=.<}'-.§hat:. €152.53 ';ix1i;%*1i'1:ji"L=1.1fh;'. ithegm: "ire; :"<::<:g_'a.1.i.:¢::::<i£ far e3.c_>1"1s;t;itu1;»:2VL'§%;:::> c)ffe.%x'1z:.:ef u1"£'<_:ie§*< vi???-'é%c.§ti01%1 M~"7E"' $.93; 'i:'i'1a'§. 'i'.}'1{f3'}.'€f ::;a.hQ1;:.1.ci b€;.<':a£:'1.;;Vfg1::1§é:;W'ﬁ..x1 21E;'ser1ii.i31y zimci i..I'".:2;z"%'. in §:.}'1<:: same} uniawful .;§1's.<§é::;i§2<'§1y,i}1<€?*' n 31"1:E£11Eﬁ:ﬁ;'" ._a:«'Ii{§'mc:f1'1--'l;)c:;"$ 0f til': ssaici tmiexxvfui 21;?-;s=m:&1"1"1'E'::>}j::rV §":z.».:<f£' i.}71<;{fVc:c51nfI10i'1 ()}.T)j€§(?{", of c:c>mmis$io.:1 of c*_%:'*i;"mf; E'§{':'f Ei:i:§S€§ fEf{VﬁE.v?(ff.l;'1'€T!I:f..t() Secticm. £437} eiamcl s:submitte(;;i i;'%'1.e:2.'>{"«?.f§0» §'.>'z:':3.§e::;_h ":13v_;g.;.§:(%:1,1sed t.1§1<:1t2r .'5e:ct§e:>:';1 "E49 of IPC. he ::'3m_:$iL. §i:)éi':; gag. _1m;~_r1"r113<:é1* of an u11_Eawf'u1 easssﬁxxibly and 171 ad :9. V' -£::€."V;z«i_f3;yT1 2:'¢:x.ri=._<'1séh;§V%;§::j.:V'Ei.; F017 the: c>{"i'e:'1(><:s ;:>m"1.is;h21b1£3 undé-tr {fZm§€;f?(f.5ii','if'.').E"]1§i'§_ "M8 .:e1.r1<f1 1.49 of HDC, {1"1{:: reqL.1ire31"ne':1t:. _§'iE;.2;£.4 E.~3;'"11_<:=::'*i:r:;r .sa;h<;>uI;d be E11'! 1m'E:&1\.%.r:f'LM:E. azVss;&zr1abiy ar.:(;1 the 2'») C':

0'? '§".h<=.: m ma1..wi'z1i. 2?-wstémbiy EZ:.1'"id they "had '$3516 (:c,}rn.z.110r:1_ <;»%3j€2:%<*:'£: mi" <L':(;)"R".ﬁ_£'}TTi§.f§3L'§iOI1 of an Oﬁ'E"tY1C?(5'., The c':_E'1arge: {car <;.>'§7§'"et:';<:-eats ;:>Lar1%s3}";:;1%;)'i<--: under ii§ec:V£:i0I1:2: E43, "148, 3Q2.___an(:f ME) <::>f YP€fi c2m'1'1<;>i: be fr21meci as e1.ga1ms3t: '{:h<;: p(%.t:jE:.VE<§j3~:g€:i1f., am §'1<i: :.g:._.ic:1:m;?: ::ra:1.1'3:'?:0i, form an '1..m1aw'fu1 21:23ss<e1':.1.._b1y,'-Itfzvtaf h ' a:2;x.'rz;'m"f. ¥;)s:t<:<:m;1e:% :31 memtxzzf of u:r;1':iivf1,::§ 2.t'\t:3sﬁ:.z::.1_biy r}c)*1"7:he.*;

m;:z...:.§d E:><::: may <;tc;>r1amo:r1 0E3_je<.:i:., u£'1..E__<;:é5-5:»; €11': €:?.' 1{_1jc:>:'"mp51z1V1~::1§r~:1t' ~. p€;..>i'm:. m.;:1:, that: ff.§"1(:':1"€:', are Ot'%jé.1*", 22.(rc:a..1'.:%s~:§?§(.i.'V. Tg;_ﬁ3:::1's¥31;)11VVV;:1I<31"1g \'%*'i'{i§"} '£11m: pm'i'ti.i<;>I'i1_c:1* .¥:5e.;'_ng .':.-{H £'1LV1%-<"3{j1"2'1I:f.;l*k"%?.I" Orf §iiI"1. L1I1121WfL-I1 z«:1.<.e=;:'~'-;s2é?r§};:E1::}Wxr. if 'i:.1?'1:? 211.lega1;i<3;:éfiii v%;§e':-zji?i.p'iaim'. do Imt §*@:v<':::21§,.»'W1';zi;_ é§.jré;2 '{35;i;<::--0"'i'.;ii1<?":'r 2:Lci€::i;1::;(~3(i. Ewen if it rc~:v<3a.Is, '§1m_'§t' €'..i'".§{":A:J' §..>;a:.i;'": éﬂ§.':"":3;1{1yV'a.g:q}§1_ﬁ:t:eci by the M12111 Court 2.1"1d. <?:rmt';"iz"§m:+<:?E 't'._hi':s_5 €,'.()'u.-ft, they cta11:"1::;i; be: arrelyced. or __.22:§§¢vm:?;%;_,-;*,f1~::<"$;»'.,a:~;a ax': ;=,1(':i<;rx.;;;:;;--ed oniy ta} j:}:"<3sec%m:,e:: thsa _1;>e;:t,it.ionc31'.

"J§i,E.1;i'v.§f.i:€§f.;T" '€3'{.!'ii}}"E"1§ﬁ€d tlmt. '€':_h.e aiI.e:gz:m;0n agz:ti:"1st% iiiixe:

};$<E"ii_i§'£f;i_<:.x'm..é:'E"' ' L'fi--§:; 11.:')Mt %:ha:t: htiit a.::§¢3211.1.1te3c'E e:.:>:* (:<:":m'm'it.it.e(:.i a 'n,m:1'a.4z_r<:*i£:;rf['1- -Z'w2é:'3. a:;~:&»;a4'n11i1":g_g i".h.ati he has i1'1StigE¥.t£?t(Ii by thx-3-r. _:(:x'iE_:i_.i:f!;§f' m'%<"V*;':.Va.s5:;a:>:(:§, who e<f)I11I11iH_im.i!. {'..I'1€*3 c:::f;7f'e:%'1'1(t(-3 U/5 302 of VA u 'E__E§§"(."E i"1.;.::m% b€";'?€'.f£'}. amt g;1..1ilt:y ('pf the $E1id <'i)'f§'4:2r1e:'.£:3 emzji. if t'l.1(~: .' M €'"WW""

,.m ' V' .m';:£; E:

x§<;:::»};s:,.1f:"1;,>: 'i'"z;'<:'m:'} zmy eimgle, {he cor11p1a:im: s;1"1(.)1T.1_E('i not hzwcs ":'.ri2;':_.§ €ji<1'n,.:;:'"t. :+m<;:§ t.:h.iS Comft. .§"1.2::vir:._W:;.; h 61:1 that the gi).1"<'.)s:';<::(':mﬁcim ,E":a::':: ilzixiied to preve. the 0f'fe.=:_};'1<::<:-3. punisljable

2.m(:im° SF§¢3<:i;:i<:>:1 1302 of WC agz.1i3"1st1 U'1(:?i}"k, no <th21,_rg§{é'Vzftmiiivci "be f"'m>:z'1<;é(.§ ag.§a..ir'1si;. this pe't:if._i(:me1*. 'I.'hcm,ggh '£.._Et: e:i' aVI'ieg§z1f.£a";i._i_'T M in 'iI}.".':&"3 »:::t0t"m_;3ia.i_;'1't t"e'v€:a.1s that 1;.k1{j;:}:'ééi' <';ée1:*_ir'(:::t*"t.';'_ia.l.;~itffxéig .'§€'32';'iI"J'1'1,€?.',(Ii Sz::5a:&:.i<:>1A1:3 Jucige in "£11355 c:a $».§: i:*.f§'i'..'§{{1c>1.1.f; _-iic3()k1<1;1g».if':aT:A(}'~ £.}.'1<:*# ;;3:1.*<t_>v.i.:%;icms:; 0? Sz;:ct;_i011S 48, 1&9 bf IPC E'1a3:; <i>r"'de';"ed_ :f<:>'af f>:"23_:miri'g..V_s311a.1*géi ffof iii (.>._:32:1ic:1 €.5£'?£'"r3:'i'f1.cite. W, "E."';f1e=: p::1:'"1:)0:ae-l()i" <i_}_.f Cr.§P.C. is to Emefi m1.,:i': "in~vw*'?'i;..§§VF.--i'1e:f=_th$2113: eazwr'£311/£f§"i§§§:i:':"1t g§r<:)L11'":(i, in the s~%m'§::'ses: .V"%..'§:Ia{:-. _f:§{;;e::?: V1it*;.;.:1:%'Vt:;'t';i;;1l*- p:'erﬁ'<;ia;.:c:é:<i by Ei..h_<2 pr£)se3c:utic)1":

E.<3~h€';¥W:':$ &i~s'i:.zi';fi<:t1?e§i1'ij'-Vgr0'i:T1f;E.i's' "1f:.€:> p1"<)t*:<'::mi 21g;;aVi12stM the peEiaiti<"}z'1.€:'7;:.z;:{i.S:.;1_{:_§"'; :1iat;_€?1"iaL i§1"1c)t; c0.mimverted :~';~:»};':1.(>:_.:11_d :"§2:+s§1'%iE §.;_§. <:'tm'W'jc_'{.iV<i)n. When £".h<~:: &}.(,T€3L£8£%iI..Ii()!1 its<'31f Coulci. ;ETEi£':E§:§.€;7f z1ggé;':'.::'1S'$. the _p€:t:Et:ion<-?.2* 501' Tjhéf 2;111(:ég<~3d _€.}f§:ﬁ§_1;E.{l&;€E§'«,._'Q?iETfA=S:§Ii.:i'Q§'1 of franling <31?" <:*I":z«.1rg<: by £3153: Strassions z}i,:<'§§,;*e: E.s;~,: 'E'i?E;3j'?TiEy €r§*<')r1.r::c>uS arfad t.0't1::11.Iy' C0z1tr.2'11"y to fflfﬂ e:z1I1€-2g;§;z;:§,i< §:':1. : 1:1::3.dc:: in {I'm <;:<)1np'iaim:. He: :i~:;'L:bm.ii:1:e;=:s:.i £11:-at ' " _.Ahi:e+:.;%:'§A%::<:E_'~-L , 0.2"':

'i;w;3m": m1it<i¢:r€:;.-aimed, even if <:%1':1i;c:rte1.i31i'r":g;§ the <::01"np1.2:a.%'m'i:, <.§z:<3&:sfi§<_.m :ﬁ'".'rzV>:.m"1i:T'3g_g 0? charge {E06-3:3 not aris~;(--;:

20. in Vé:h_i:'-3 case, it bc:i.;"3Mg 21 pr.iv:5ﬁ:r2 c:<.m1p12;1:i_::":t, the ;%wma";z1 si>:'E:a11i",<?:rm*.:M1L the st.ate:11e1"at. of 'w.i€',1'1.e3s.°3<=:$ 21.g:§I.(§.L4;1'L?§;tc:I by t:.hé-3 {f';<m'1p}aim:1_m: do not 1'<;tv€3a1 'éi'"1a..1: thi59:3:"f$e'f;i_i;;'i-(ah .

aea.§m'm: mt) s.,.1.'1_ei:.E be-2 })1"£3&':2é',CLl1i€'d {cw thc: g1'fc:::'1:':s:%.21110»; 5,,' mm amt? if '§:'}-E-é'-3 p1"<>.ea€:CL1t:.i01'1 Qf }?;'<f:'£,E.§.:'ic).3§*;.g31*~E533' }.")'O'.':'::.'V":;*~'-..i}:5"i1*;:.f' am Eﬁmfsfr §:.>21..s3is; of a11.Iegat:i()r1; _i'é--.._Vrr1ea.r1ss. €;§f1z>11J: _tiiigiérer. rm 2 L s§:a,.2f'fi4:im'3'{: g;§rc:)z%1.z"1c:i to p::'c)ce2ed the? 21<:;'::_x..1s§*§{'1 zemczi. if €':E2<:%:m :-;xr<.;: .I'£(I§ sm'ffi<%ieri"£ g;,§f1".c3L.'at")?{:.i'.:. 1i'1=i{1:§i"A --..Se;%c:t:i0n 227 of "" ""'§V-:".«~;--1"%m1<;*('3 E5c::~3s"i.oI1.5.-3 J1.1cig€:

fmm 'l':1:'t€=: 2:2..1Iegc'3cI <)f:'fe:;r1C<-3:8.

ﬁicavs/ae:vm €'iE'a':;é 1a§z:L.1V?:.'3 ..._§L1dg<3 E1215 ﬁtiierci 1.10 invoI:;.<;:

€1E"M: 4;§>'r1'r._;»'a,Ar.é.<:'~;;'.<').V:M1;'é3:.: ;S<€_2(v€'='.:ic)r'2 227 of C:'.F.C3.3, fact that t,}2e ﬁi:'E:i,:<._u_§c: in S.C1.2/E363 ham 3101. <3i1",11.<:~?r €j_3'*.ET"{:Ti'é;L?v§L'§f:*('§?v._ R'.l3:i"=. A:i':,2rt:h¢32" i'E1V€ST..i§;§21.'{i()I} 01' for" 2':}.ddin amy' :as.'ai?:€::1'.:a:~;%:Lmf£ '<:Rf;':--a:14zf1iy &3s§s't:c"1b1iss}1 1.'ih.£%1t tiI"1<-3 niajitrrizli which was as/a1:n.i.,%.z::.+E:)}5<?:..Was; m:>%t: 551,1 E;'ﬁ(:it:n"t. to pmcéeed '(L-1.§§ai1"£S'ii way' other "V.VL'~,ﬁ\::)'%%:-;Q'3fE}ﬂ€%-,E.'3.W if "me E€:a;."'1";ed S(ESSi(')11S J1V:d.§j;e. in E116: 'lirial in E:'aE' ﬂjfisgr V'J11a;9§ ia:__ E%35.€3[Nz_;:n.2/1986 I:V;:as fm.1_31d thaif. ithearci: is no 'mat:.€:ria1 to _pM><":wC£ aexggggairssst this a(:eus5<:;ed, §:<31'z(:1'1..2C't;1?.1'3g,§ trial a.ga.i1.1st "€:h1Z:~;»; 2es\<'re":'1..a;ss.:e<:E in 21 p1"ivat:e cr.}.m.pL21ir3f xveuicl. only means; .¢:»:3§t;"i:_i11;;; {w¢:*.r ihms jI.3€§.§._,§1"1"3(i'i'11'; of a;rxr:3th<-31" ;s;smss3ic>_;;1 m,1E:3:':"nié_:f'<%:<L§ t',I'm'i". théi <_)rd&:1' 13E."I1p'L1gI1(:EC1 ;:1_<;)1; (.x%j:I.y 3 {mm %T§.Ee:':g§z?s1§t,y b'2...:t: 221130 from ir'reg:.;;.1_a12*.it}1"éiIid'_"it "iS".<>mjt m.rjVi'.E10ui. "j u_:1f:i.s%;c;iicE1301':.

2 E» 'Per <.:<>m.ra, Sri Sa(i'ai:. ££:1V1$asaiiii_§;""is::;1f11edM "

C0 a%.'1;u:=3@."Z ::1p;3eé:2a:"i1:'1gg: :f01_f iihe Cl.(.>:1fi}31eii1f1L2~:.Mr1E. ééuh1n.E..i£7m.d tilmt €:..h.¢:t ixuticie:-%'g1iT h.a<::i. 'E:-.'»;':kué:1 [ $984 at 1.0.30 gjmn. ?7f%'§'§"s;~:;E:_ ii'1'7ETr>Vr::i:_:éaiéiicm "H-;e1Vc.t1"§::2ci 1:116 p<'Jsi.§.<:<:t zaﬁ 1.15 a..m. (.33; EEM/:_.v}.E}§34,' V;:;KI§i'1--211'j "':3i*'u-:<=:1". was; fE.i<:?:(:i, in W1%1e:r1 the :{"xa?a.x%:m*:_ _ oi" E.:If'}.i:'f_ ;.>é~?:".:-"*r;;0*;1 "éT.i(?(3LI!&;'€$('§'.(i (K.Na.myar1.} was 110%':

'V " _ia;'1<._:.I§¥§5i:;zi6% £15} f;hc;: 'ﬁts-i--'.-----0'f a(:CuS.::<;§ and trxrimxl t:E"1<3 ;.<3a:Ec':3 fa,{:t »r;_{2;m19:i': 11.0 '§..1"1'a;%v %:;.n_{)w1s%cf!ge: of the (Tompi:;1ir1_:3:,.n.T. 011 the kuasiss '2:,?1§€.i*£ri:=:3c': giveil to }:1e'*3I3 she has %'"i1<:~3<:1 pI'iV£€tii€3 mmr'ﬂg;,>ie;1if_':_".:i, 25.E2L.1985 itself. "He :'~;:nbr:':it;.1:e*:C§ t:.3"1at. the

-.,§TJE'"1i'=.-"a"<4?:€1§<§...V _é%:<)3:I1p§:ai11é" £1§_;{8.i}'}55'[4 {fie {€'1{3C§1..I.E."~3(i%d, who is not:

<">1':1a1_.;"g;&é s~shc:3c::'i;m:L 355 111z1i111:ai:;"1.a&:»;§<¢;: m1<i§€1" f'3€:'C1Li()1"l 208 of €f31".E3,{;1 "I"h€;1;;"<v: is; no error in f1'_}171:2.g of the (:cu;11pi%a.i.11t. Hf: fs.a:""t.hm" :1+subm1€t.i:e£Ii tihaii the matter C{L>'E'I1tI:? up before t1'1i_s €f1m:z.:§.*1" i'W§.£f€?2 ssmd e1_;u:"1c:e beforsg the Apm: €jIc)urt. rim. (Z?cm"1p'}.2:?e..ina.r3I fee c():nc:eI'1"1<:3:ii, <':o111p}:;1.i.1'1ar1t; _ EV§'z<;;: :%;f.:<;':}'.?;sa im:'I':€diaMiieiy :;1fte§' V;A:A1:'1»:e>.x*g.§<:é in fi¥§.€Liv.N<"},Ql{198i'¢$ and the p1'i'.:rig 1tt:;*;

;;T1gjaaV.i_1'1:a;i: Théi". €:E€3£iiL1§§%€I:¥€'L who *'.}§F{:?}.'_§? If: amﬂy 2:53-§,;1i'1."1 $1; Th G 2-*u.c:c:u'_sec;1 _;1()'£:

213%; €°5'ai..,3.(fh E,.;E"z_€;?: (73<}_:V1V1p1a1i;1';:1'I<itT_Wa:.€s i;i)<;?s:*f7e:: c§t'*gEA3§fM in aC<:0rcize1r'3C(:: 'w:§'i':§':. 3éj;:§:'*' ' A "

Hta: €i}:}.<;r <j)1*<1.¢::.r of €t.i'1is;~: Court in ("TimRf§3'.Nﬁ:.,"«%68fV ddfeéd 9.4.}S38€§ arid St1b:I1.i't;t.ec;'i ~._AfiE'12;é:'é;"'WEjj2.if1<;*: we(_)1r'::=53id.<iri';;':g as re3g;e11*c:is {:0 iﬁ-'5SL'Eff.'. GI" :=;;1..1r1313"3(3n:%s, _ i;hir:_3"*Ii;"§i?:su,%*"zi;. 'Em"~§%1.a¥:><";_2'ai:e (:0n:~:si<iierati.0:1 of the: Iataateriai pn"k;>__<iE'1.w:<i:r:'§.. 3f}3T'§fj}'1<if €jj30:np}za..im11'H. has f<.)u.1'*sd that the-3113 is; a. V'-».§A:)Jr"1€:m{?---- ﬁ;%::%_.:i{r (.:a1:-Mi: to p1'c)cre':ed £1gTe1i11st. tﬁfééi z&1<:<:L1seCi and ;(A.:)';;V"¢;,L"i_«:-:_;i?1'<:?:e:§ fm' 3';sa;ss1.:<--3 <.:>f S1i1'1"11'1"l01"§§$. Even, thougla ESLP was; .. §'3i}§a::<i§ zvnssainsgﬁ; E1230, ;$;ai<:1 o1'de:3 the sazmnzz <::a1'1.1e to he «,2?

Kai' §:i'3_aI"g;g;c:: 'ha.:=:+s M-:E'°<52:'a'*c:d to thff :'sta.1:e3n'1e:ém.s 0.1 PW.1--w1'f€ <':§is;:'zV:i_::ss%_-;<:<:§.. This €3(.;>1.1rti h21Vi.1%1g been fcamnci t..112;1{:. f'.hf€:'i'E3 E}3'".'§I'1'§Z;£.~§ﬁ3£.C3i€T m2%2f;e::1?1Ea_1 to pI"€)()'.€',€:Cf E-.1g€E..iE1Si", $;1"1c: actc::+.1sec:i .:'m<:&3rsae3a:-u"'iIy H362 material whi.<i:h was p};'(;)C1'L.i€:€(?l also s3aL1ﬁ'°i'§<i:%£:z'1'i: itm :fmM1T:": E? t:'E"1e L?h.a11fg§€<%, Pie f"1V.:'rt.._E":@:r s51..1.b1"1"1itt<:1r 7_i"that '$1113 m2}.3p<..>2"'$: H16: czcisse of C0m'1.;.)'iai11a':":E', ape).r't~~~%f?x?g):;'I3__" hcaji" 21«i«.wm m s::3'€'V2a1'i¢€:m<:-zmW--&;f;at:.€.I1ae11tM "being E.""f:7f(;i(j)_}.".fI'i _ .hai~?;' <.'iXé3,.E.'}Z§.§'".K"ff€i 0,!" QPWMS to PW3? ésmci 3:}. i}f" ,1"'1.m 2*11 ::=snTVnpp<,m'.;:":%<fi éiiw (tame of vC»<}1np1a_i:'}.a'..i'3ii. 5~;z1E>'mE:é,*::£:d i:h:~;.:.i: mi. the :s;t:age wf i?sfg12"zi:i1'1.g; <;':'E'--V1;;":Au1'§__M>",'e i:1?;is;; c.:o1,1rit wifii i'}€'}i'. am; in M1 e::;ppé;s1,l_.":0r i:§f1 £3;j3_§j$.f'é%(E'§.&1Ti€311 of EL'.V'.id<i*,1"lC€':, it mﬂy' '§¥;;)a€.}l§<i'f%}1-._E:T1Ef.(f) '5£f.i.§'}'€'? "'p1"i'111a¥fé.-igctiev maf:€3rie1.1 to find c>ut: W}.'"s.&:é?t;E"1é:xf r§l;f1<;'t 'I';.§_"§ﬁ£z]§.L " t':d'1;11¥:ii'---- 'i::.«é:% p.r<)ce:£:<;'i<;--t:<::i agz;1i1"xst. the ;:»m::<;'w,.~é_«';=ai:r(.'§ s31v%f1<:'i-21:: i;'hi_£%§ 'the: Ee:a1*1'1€.c1 86255310113 J'ucig€: 3'm£:: z;'@<:;g;,3§1"c%<'%. t":a::, v_ai;€5sem-?séTs ﬂ'1(? (~:V€d£~?.nC<»: to find mat, wheaiilel'

-1:hs3?n-mt:(:i«i;av§;;c:'::§..Ar?.(}:;11c§""b£3 <it0I1\ri(:%ij.ed or 1:1<i:ri.'? He: 1"<%fer1'e<:i to '1t:'%m?;-:" ~.};:m'"€1v:sVEf:¢;Eﬁ.s;t'r,é»;---of ;'?5ecti()11s 22"?" 65¢ 228 of C1".P.C.. and i*.§l-.3§L§j§f}7§.§.§.,{.f:?ii§§:""fé.E;§7é?§.'f 't:fhe }<=:a1'11ec1 Se:$sic>11€»t Jt1C1g(': for" the §:.:m4'E2'"1';i3<ma:: 6:? :':1Vv<)kTi1"ag-; Sec1i.i0n 228 0f C§_r.P.{Z., for fra111i;;'1g fL11':§;I71.€§1" _ mi' Ehgsi Cic§:<.:<§a.sese£.i e:?:v:1de'r1c<:>, sé:az..1':<~::111ent. etzi' PW.2--son of the: {;?'.(?;mpEa.i1"3.:;2's.,;:1.E:., si:e1i:en.1ent of PW.€3AC<7)mp1a.i112m.t in e:.«.u"h{':1" c?ase;ec:3g E3'W,7»iT)<)ct<>r and 0th€:';r' wi1:r1e::;a;e2:s, 'iVhi(l}'1'_ $'h.OVV ':',E"1z:-:1. '€:}_1a~: :1>ffm1 (76: Was; corrtm:":.it,te:<f£ 2.1% E" i"1_e:% i.;'=:~5;Ifar1__<1_>t:'.j' gtif, a..a::<:1a:~aé;2(.§ zmci if this I13aie1"ia.1 is ;+1va1.iI;::-:bI.;C., t}:'}.g:é --fL€5:z1r11e(i §§@5a:ai<:>x'2ss Ja...zc;i.§g<:= t..2::1i<.iz'ag into <::<")1'£:j:.sidt:1i2{ii.}§.(§f:.; iIj'1i;+j§_4t"na.§e1*:ia"1!f ha.:'»:s i::".ig';§'E1ﬂy <'_'>;1'cierr:%c:i fez: :[}';'1§_:§1i:3g" ;'»3.<:a":m;9i<::<:iﬂ ' H _

253.. §°uzf"€.1'2 f:A{')1i:1pE21_i11e1r1t 3';L&<3;f?5§ zcmt: ﬁiza:<:i :cj.:'()1'§":;3I2A1"11f1_.ﬁ %»1.f'i:L{%_§*VA» jv'v"--('::"€f)L11'i'. ac":c';1.:ii".'£ed '1:§'m.:~:¢ EEi;.j{T".L"i§3fE?€.§.' E3_€.:i.f:é .ss«1i';c5ié'-.,."_f1:;tsis._' "taken :'%:'»§§.€;'p.'.3 ear1.y 'g1m:+a;sai%:3ie-,t~ Vvi'D€>::/}:'v'i' .i_n3.;I1"<§(iig1i?'<::1y'Va.f?;.<::r t:.TE1(: c%_h2'e1rg_;§'e;: :1:.»%h<.=.:et was §'E§i<:-<:§;'.¥%i:i;xw:tV::+':sx, V_jiiti§ciz1A1 p1"0c:€:eciing_§s '€:m)i< comsicierelble :"§':.§E'7E"]:;'€T,"ﬁ z-;1;:3f;€'§ hézz.i'"a;1'z"t'_E1.€v:' ssL1?3rI1if,fi€-sci 'that. s5.i_nc<:3 Elms rzV1.2ztt<~;:r 'Wa;{:si§._§.i;€e:"i":<:?'1;;:";.gu%§;;='.1? <;1'L2iit:* S301"i'1t3 {$1731.63 21.116. (in :*i.1"1g* which t1'..m<::% "ihi.r.ﬁ;:=V2_Ai 'w1;9z;1&;s: ('5.(I!I'"§C7.11.lC1€d. The: cc;)n.1pia1inamt: did {mt

-.V3.%:.¢2:;}:,,§g,:§}'n'f"H. fit: in niaiie an 2}.pp'Eic.::1t:.i<:>11, thsré S€'FS§$iC111$ C836 TE §.}€~:3€%3;. Ht-3+ fzT.1'rth<:=r1* subn'1.it':'t:ed 1:ha'z. if {there 21 nsst: 11%;: L <:'"

E '-='\ §:}<ia.§E<':<;: <:a:'~;~3<3 anti p:"§va.'L€ mampiairat, NC: cimibt, in {".€..¥1.'II1S 0f E%a:<":ﬁe:;m1%2 iZ;'i.€f} of C;z':P.C., both 'E118 <:a.sas€:s coulci bc..___t:rie<:tl 'EV{;r;_;g;'::=;t"tha"2;1 N€':V€?1"1'l"1€5I€SS, leameci Sesseamrla JL1dg€:V"}J1é:.rTi.i2g "rum: 1§m_v(:;ke<ii *z}1<=: §;)I'UViS§OII1S of Se.<:1i1'_or1. 819 0:--): '(ih£3Agfi)€A1nV<_f_i'T Wﬁééﬁl %i;§':t:. p.rivai'.<=: c:<>n"1.pl2:1.i1'2t E55 p§:i1'i'(iingg';. I_1:'1_..i:_i51'<:$._ ;')res§€:1'itV« mm, 1]€r;2'm;1<::cE Serswlons Jxzdgez I[1a1i\ri11:;§_ <::ei3z1f:.e:~si'<.ji::1f'<=:.c'i'. 211;'; 'Ii-h<~f:'~. m.;-1m:::m1¥ M155 §7c>m":<:i th.a.t t13€:.:<iC*"'--is sL.a£'§iig::ic:v1'1f"_=1'ri&tr::i?i.21i to ;im;>C.e<:r<:E ag.§a.i1"1si". the-':~ 23;:i?}x:1.VL_'1sr::c.':A."'" *

24. He a1:;':';<:} s.:;L1bn1'i1_vA1f.cC:1"_ of film otl"'1e:r 2:M.':<it.as'~:ew;fﬁ w'<)u3;éc.i ':j:g;§':; &1"1".'21:1y*V\}vaiy ;ii*fe<i:%....t:her pI.'()S€:':€ILiIiiOl'1 0f"

€:ﬂ"w: EJi:v{f§%€T'K'iI' }:i{%'g*'1.2; Pie '>F;?"€?Lt;~3 not 'tlhéi? acc:z.1:es<~::d in the {';>i.h<>:Jr' 3%:-3;}; ':a'm:'i' §:f '?.?1iLf§QvE3.Qf'"]'i'€iV€f any <3ff'<'-mt. or bcaa.1"ing,g on 'ilhfji g.v);*§_::*.s<:=:_:";{' *t:m°a1,_ -hi": "v;*,iV1i';é. 1'ega.r'd, he 21153:) su};>rz1iT.1i€d that '"; feaiigﬁivag; 0:5' "Em:-....2%:{3qL1§ital of the 0'¥;1'1€:r £?£('.f(i1,ES€3d, Vé:l'1e 'm«ia;1» ~c'§21é1:.1 A§;>«:%"~ci?:1":1du(':i',ed against ﬂit: press-;:m'1t E-.1C?.CE1Sti3d. He ;%§$ft;a;£'7.rg;jy ';2é"rg:"1f':'§:V{:i on the que:a;t:_i.<')'z1 of_jm"i_s3d.i(étic)1"1 of this (3-(}I'Iiu§'"§i a'=m<:f§' " the .r'€;;":v1?sione1I powei' ::m<'i% :»§ub1'r1itted th.at §%s:;re._>§;:;{£é bi" I"€\FiE:¥.i.<'j}ﬂ be-iing Iimiimti, the Cmirf; neeci r1r:>t. gt:

mm €:.§"m a;:)p4:"c3ci:a.t,ion of the 1:fx1at'eriaI ;;x1"(>:it:1Cet-rci by $116 (}3<:'3mpEa_§_n_ar11:. in fm(Ii_ out wha:€..1A1m", at this ssmgc: the Said ,;1"1;-ji€Zff§"§£i§§ :ﬂ.:e;s s:3:ut?I'ic:i<:%;TA:t to (YOHVECEQ; 01' 1"1<3§:-,_ 'iI"I:1_ia~3 "£10 §'i;m:E mzyi: w'%"1et:her" the txial C€j)E,1I"f. jus:at.ifiet}:i;'_:i"i'1 _ iihti mrﬁeézr mi' fra:'1M:§n'g;{ Léharggcsr e_>:";1Wi:he:

E:i3<:-E%b2"<;:~. §-mm? egvvcm. if 'there: zgure zi=1}y §:.::3v1'1'1'A;;fC_ & mm: m 3.11%: <::{)r1s5icier€:d on1y.»éii_:;.::1"i:ig--' 1-,.},'1é:5..*. trxis-if"':2md._H1j}.(:§t: aqit _ L E,.E".':.i;-'-a s5sm;;<;;<:%.

25$. ;'::§:§_:'1ce=: 1,13%? ri1a it.f.e:r1*--. -§:_)¢f<:§;1:fr;2 iilrae Apex {LZfm.m; am sag,-;fz%,*eViVt<;;:'~:;§. 1;.h_<:i" "(ta-.*.,T:.*':k:>.,:*" A.§:L,:;:<:1,r,Is;;<::§::E'. it <':z=mi:'1<:)t' be c:m'1:e;t§:";§;ir"1.é;%<.?§ %i:7::;1.t...V_é:§«.c1'1a,1*;;§;: my the c)1"fc3.1"iu;:e':s pL..1'm'si121bIe. amciim" E*f3s§<ft:::_ti}1§'<:+;n:s:;' }'€'3€E1.d with Secticnra 149 of Wifi 4§:;:1'2'm<.>'ii. V1:-ge;.j:~:a::~;;%ae'::1. If Eh est 2i11eg;a'ti',§0I1.s a=iga1in$t; the :.»éms";;V:'s:;~séd',. i¢is_3f'ire;2Vz2.~;*';1(::_ﬁ.e":»: dis(:'1os@s; me af.£"c:?:1"::ce and if the E11'?;2'E.:E:f.;"«iseii «ifs»...§9;u§:E'i£::.Eet:"3t, the law-aimed Se:as;i<>;1'1s Judge was _ juss;i:;§1i?e3{tZ'---VAim"'{'§r'{.%(:;af.i.s"1ég§ for frar11i1'1g_§ c?1121I"§ge and s:s1.1bI1"3;i't.t;eci 7¥f;%(-rcéza1L,:&3asé tin: .inte1'pre't:a:t.i<)'n <)fS6:<:iii@'r'1:~3 E47, 148

-- a':'--"%.V<:i MS} of 1%)' I'€3(}E..I1§I'€S an unlawful a.s;s;embiy' does ricst i;§3s<;>i'm:€Ma3 vi{.'ia1t'e3; the': };>'1*c3se(:uf.im'1 Cas.<;~<';:. S'u.{:.h a1",gL:1_112er%1t. <::m;:iz:"3 Em mzide: wily after 1ih€'?: <;é\ride;n<i?:¢:': Ieaci by £1.11:-:*r pmssm:2.:.t§.a.;v1'"1 ..

£135. in the jI_%g§hf; of the ;smbm.issi<;ms .1n_;;§d€'35y-- _ 'm<5~.* .§e":rz:1.rm%<it£ Cmmssel, rm: ;.:>(>i121:.sg t.;*":a~i2t . f R31? (:a;}3:1.55zid<:%:*e::t'.ic'>n an: 215:. u'r1c1r:é1':-

{I} 'W!":e3I:h.e::*r the orrie>.*?__ Q/" i'F'e..e' 3.£3CTi1 'Sg:a§;.<;3i<)ns . } Judge j1:2r framir€:F1argeV f%)fT '£7"1.<::% }q[[I€r'1cre2S pu,:"1f:4;f1a.blg3' ~.}_.£.I'I.d€:?"W £3'<3§,:f:i§§r"ag<; 24-I'/"'V,° 3748, 302 n~3.az:i miiih SéC:;io!'i' .3 Qf'..fP€.: Es-51.53 {;c:u'J"2..::2:bZ.e3?"

--. 'é:'§'1c:? c.1(:c?;L.:.iZ:m,.Z Qf all ot,i'u»;>r 'A éfiiczrz tfw <;zc¢.;:u.s;(3(;l i.n.. :f.}"z.e-'9 p;"iua.!:e :éfeV:I'§:1pZci.i:'23;'S521 a §:'z'ia,Z <;'oz..dd !wZ.ci agaizmt £11115 1 V.V_c:Az<:><i%zV%L;§§"§<;12~i:;2":'";.3r"Or the ojf'%,>rM1c:e?s pzm2'sh.cz.b$e z.md<«2r"

r2:*,ic:>n:;<; .3427, I48, 302 I"(i'Cl€i with. Section 149 3 §7?(fO})6? Qf e;>n.qm'.rg,j m"zd€r Secztirm 226 and 228 zfgfw {Z'i".P. 6;)'. , '.9 W}1eaiI'ae;* mrder :'e;~?vi.€~:zZb£e?

{4} <?:;;

3 0 1317..

%;:h..%.e':"~; m;;ri,.z._3f'f Lamierr Se:cti.<)r1 1397*" 0E'"thc:~: Cr..I%'.C. it is; j'L1.§'-;<..1_;_ zamd £*3E:£'(':>1*e: co1"1_si.dering the :;~:.cc);i)r:% Bf fillfj power of §'E€;%€;j?iiff€if:§€:§.Z'y E0 x'1z:11*1'"z1AiTe t._}.": e fa1(:'i;;~'es which &1i"'f:E not m ft is»; not in ciis~3pa...11:e !f1'T1.£:1t :1""1::~.,g'1.'r1'j.IA_1"~:;'-1.',-3; ITET acr<tt..:1_:5§2d m:.£3_e1f mail the 21c:c:'L.:.$¢d. 1'i'(£t;;<:2i':vf:

f$§"1.€?{"';i,£'f(T1. by the C.§r3.I. CELL _Po1iﬁ:'e, NeW :.i"()f'; 9 <V1:ff<:11<:@5e2; ;t)'L'mJ§ss11;»1E3¥€;*: under E~3<:_:§t':§.{'21M1.s 'i~i?Z.(L)?E3':, .148 53923. am. ':"<-:2':=u:i \Ar'§_i,h Sé§c7:'tic)11 t,h.<«?: 2;u:(:.u&;~;e<:i '§;\Im..1 €§;)s;£i.<i§aQpa) zémd dead before »;1~.m"nrme;:rVa(:m1'1§£m:3:3"? '§:ri::;;1{ t1"1c.: i.'r.1_7aji'"'w--:;":§§ C.'{)I'}€I1L1€3'L'(*'f€'f only' ;<1g;,'3§miz'1s:Vj§. :1{;é(t1£.$€?d..,N'e>s.'«.2}-.3, 7, Q, 10 zmcl. 11 in E?§«{;X Ef\Ie":.i33;./ 863 1f)<':%§()1*t:*AVT..héS'--?',%r4i2ii {"...'.0i..13'i2. 4; '"J2;1é€:%, in N0.';2/ fhc: p1"<)se301[.tt._i.<)1"_1. to prove its é §::jéi% %"Juéii.<3; s_:f>3$';.<g.3_.v1"1.1:71"1cé<::§. as many as 64 VVii§I1€.'T:SSE.?53 n.a.;mc:1y' marked Ex. E11 to R1865 auici 211.550 §}'E"{?% <.ff£'£..§¢j7&:--§i::§. '1?$?i.€).--§ '£0 I\/{.O.~i2;"":3. On ﬂm: d.<~:ft:3::1.Ce sidcz, x'E':4é";a.»z.'3:g%':n_ Vim m*:=;z1 eaxrieiiéénttts was led, 'h.ew<::=,v<3:t* Ex. I"§1-1 to D~ §§~'f§"W€23*e;?: m2.1.r'}~:¢:~:cfi, Leamced Pri1.'1c:ipaI $€}S$S.:':i(')I18 J1V1<:i§2,"t), " '~ _,i'"§§<-zznfiii; °°%:7y_ ﬁ:T;_.€,ji €}{E(T€..1Es * €i.§-1...:EE)rc2M%z»}g2::. on a:ppre:cti21tic>n (>ff.:}'1e c=3vici<i:=::i1ci6:, ac:qL11Ttf;ed. all ﬁ':§"1e:-=: :~:'L<im".:.s3e;-d 11.63. amused N053" 2, 3, 4:, 6 to 11 for the :;1s£_"f(=:3;1<17e;-7-x=;a-3 pt.m.:?s}'123b_Ee umier Sc-xéti<;:'1s 14?, 1.48, 130?,-.._1"£,~aci Wiiﬂx ;'§*§e<.%'i4i_0z1 149 afszf" I.P.C. Emwevczlf, 'i';f1e3y ~ Em' 'i;.£"3..e'3*. 0E'£€%1';a<:«;~;s; p':..m.is.hab1e L:111c_1t:*.1: .S€::€:.t:f.t)"f:é§" 'Al:.',2O?' I3 a1*1'dV 'A u 20 E. zarf 3132(1) it 1:73 also not in (iisf;m;(-§_'_tﬁE'ﬁ1t :if{i1_§%' in :':.%§.(fi. _1\m.:2/5:363 dated. ' 0;;4~..Q15*>.20'c12ﬂ Vv%.g;;:;1~:~,-% an"

q:ms~;~;'ii§0 :11 by €11.39 :e:<:<;?1.1 sad in $3.9 aé1'5~:._'%':ha=:i1;'Cv:.>.';'wijé:!:i01"1 for €._£"3¢';'%r zf;f"f&2;1c%t%3&; pvu1"1.is3.halaitf 1,1n.ti§-sf» ;';3'e<§ti <")nV;é; 1120-8 and 201 "

0%' E.,P.€Z"§. W§"}€¢l7¢2£.v8 f;h3%:i (7 oI';§.;.}i42:i§f};2mt" 21}«:.:»§() ﬁled Criminai ;R€V§S&§i(_?%:"1"

fE=3'<;=*:éj11fV'{1jf¢.c>.:'1'i"{f<> 3'3.i?i'/2001-i"' it is 2235513 not in ciislmte H"u;'§,ii ii'§="1_.i&§ _ <f~.'m_..:I§"I'*.\.,jgy-_ it:5" c:<7smm_Q.1"1 judg111en.t (ﬂamed i.'Ea;>'§2§J¢if:c'E 'f._Is3.Ve)<'~* ":(L'1'i11t1ina1 Appcaai Nfj;).823/2002 :11 z:a.<)4,rg0{§&§-« ..;-1 ~*--*'*Vt11e:'ei.1'1 and a.c:quit.£:(*:d them. .fm.n:1 {gt u <i:;f:":ﬁ£>:2;3§ie:§:§"~§§é;1_'::;iahablét Ulldﬁl." Sccticm 120-3 amd 201 of L'E~';.£Z',-.5 '-.W"I"1Aé:+1"c3:&15:; the-: C1*_i.ménai }?%:-3.visic)1"1. Petit'i.(:>n

-- _N<:ﬁ:'E-$33 ,1°'Vf,;Zf()'iT}5f§'f» fife-?:<7I by the pI'€i':ES€?§§Y". cQ11";§3122i11aI'1t: seekizig w..éi".€.f;: ::;::..§:i: §:i}ssric1:2?: {E39 jusﬁgrnenti of aciquiﬁak p€<"iS;-362d by' the <:1--:V:.I5I'1Ae;f+<::£ ;':'3~€25:;&3i<3,x'j:s»5 Ju.<:1g'c3, acqt.ai€;tir1g the ;a<éct1,1s6.:ci for the ' 'E f"

'V " :j:<:.23V1-:¢§§{:E ::;%§m;;._ -am a:::V a*:aﬁ7f5e?:1'H'%<%:;sea pu.r:issjhz,1bir:*> undcer Se0ti()n "147, L148, 302 mad wiéh §;:.'§€;'f('T'i.§{f}'}'3 E49 :3ﬂ.P.C Wag dis5a"!1iss<~:%c§b rm Ef)'u._1"i.1"1g.§ the trial 0;? SCK2/88$ PW'~.1 {._t~mnp§;;2%AE.:'12a,m. :'1a.mja:%iy Anna. Rem E3/0 Ma.di'v23.;1é1pp}£ ~ 'ijZ:f.i.§'~', 1 ' 133%-___,.:f%«<§. "EM. TM} N2-1ga[mj_. PW~52».+;_4K2fa;iiii"Q 5$ia':irza.n'1<i;rsa}';}., PW~5ii§ --- A'nI1ap:,1:*:1é:.&W!.{<:)* (£':"':91Kd'1«";': ]A I"I7}.(fi:f'1:}i"£ " %fVe3 1'té.. t".':X£?SI'T"l.§II"Ni*{'fi iii"; the: ﬁéiﬁd c:a.s€r.' 0017'}1p.£a.i:1:1:-zrjrtf"r.§ié're1h in "

:w_g;:>g__3<.m {Bf ii§j'1(;*. prf.v;51t.e,<:3o1np}z3;£_1'1.t,;--. 'E331? &3w(>1*z1. ;<.;{.i;1Vt.c2*I1"1<:::M11:

'wiiiﬁi E'"&'}('.(f}§"(Ji€3{.§. am» PW? ;sm.¢:.¢%1--1;:en'i; ojf Km1':rt:i K111'1.1ar M:e3m3rx_:1:.e3:m wém.::'*¢;>s.t;c.3.1f<j1'e:d21;; E?'{7\i?'.2?i, Sf£{ii @H1C?I'1t of Arms:

Ricliijh fﬁﬂiiV'l'v'E-z1<iiE\ra.§é"if:3":wei'Pa-1:11 \I{fé?:;&s"i"e<':01'dz%:(?i as PWHES zazlfxci mes: £'¥5'i1;Ei€Vi'£ii?'§"1"'i'<3\¥ﬁ' :31' E;'.i .. ZN;;«,.t2z.ra} was rerejtclrdeci as PW--'7. Em ;'?5.(i_T:» E\'i<jé';':2,,/"i9§3:i*5. -t,h&:" i€3.1'ﬁ€?d Sess&;.ic.>11s Juclge had

-..1 1C1'tifI1VC€ of 21.1% thesse wimessses and r12<:2;_'e 1i_:§'3'<3 '§<i':--*».§,i.<%i»:;%:*;.:;Ar<;€'guf ¥3'W'~EI$2 2711161 PW---58 $1.6. 'f.i"1e :;-'::vi<;is::1"1c:6: of €.T{'}:{ia"ﬁ._§i)iE2:J11.:}.:51£;ﬂf_--;:i;1'f§C3: Iwr scar} anti h.z.-:15: 2:Vcq_1.1i'%'.1;c%€} the a(:cL1.sed

-<._ '1§i"€J1'1{'{E365<ei5}ff§:€i'1€;3€?8 pu':V1£s;hab1e: Lmder Se<:t:_i.<;m 143?, I48, 302 "EM 149 of 1.9.0. N0 d()£1bf.', whiie E5?€:<%€£:i<;1":.

2 _<g:_<;§"1s:;§d€:;r;E_r'1g H"1(:E <:*;v1?c.k«:1"1c:e of I%"W«52 zzlnci PW63 i(c:«;11*n<~3d 33 J%..:<:1gg&r. at Pena---'?E3 of the jud;_._{}:}:1e11i: renderecl in SC. N0.f2;' Efﬁéfiétfr %":1z::.s; <)i:}:<;w33'ved 1:11.:-at SP, N'amy2u1, t._1"a.e present z:1<':<?a%.me;:cf§ £3 iwti: armyeci a1<:<?:u:5€<:i in the: Sizlid €.'.&:"iS€ amd €wE"a§%>. }:1>.r§v;~2i:<:: (f{f)1"I'ip§Ei.i3"£i'. has i:>€:3e:1'1 filed by E13 r"<::¥:<:':«;<¢;z.1£: ('kwmplaim2;:.1;1.t. H()we>\rez*, iEe:+1rr1<:c.£ . gm <.:{}1"asa§<ia:21m'~:(i "i'}'f2.<::se: €3Vid(:'fI'l€3€E§Wf(}1' (";.ii <%%5:~:s;:}<:>&5i::;1g§ (hf 'She <'ta:~3<*: as zagaimsfj. ::1";}4T'1€', €'f§i{:":*§t3.

3 1. B<1:§':"§g;{ 21§_.§gg":1*ieVe5ci'T' j of za.cqu_itt1a1.%E, 'éifm <;::;»;?;1p1;?:Vi_r'1iem"§ itgeértsseif 1"-e1_(:i -iﬁé-:r(:i 1'evisE.0z1 p€'}'iiifi€}1'.1 bef'ore tjhés s:7€._n.i_i*%.:._. 'ass; in Cz'i.R.P¥ N().335/2003.

Thﬁrgeé;¥?:{{>a:<";'1<:)E<:: &i::<;.);'V1V3"Vi Orin re~ap§;)re<:iat:.ic'>11 of i:}"1€>. eV1'.demi:c:

% m;?fi_:..éeifé'rég :7 '.§:j1s}.: ~.;ef::vi£f§e.;'1M<::r5: of c:Qr.np1a1i13.a.z1t .2m<fi %"1c§~:r :~30n 113$ €i%:>:%§'{%1*f'u%:-:V%<i'E _L1'E':§ €§€ifI.'I "'f1'»/E.e;rv;.?<:3:. _gfas:'§;<*;§." of motive to the {~;=.ffe:<':f' mat t':h<~?;*e was; <=>£'"k..:"z'*;.:.E.':.::}/' i.')I;?'£W€:?t:"n Sidda1"a.z2"1<3:;h :1-md 'flat: Polices. §fJi§'i<'*<;?%r':¢s 2:1:-'5 he? E1215; _pL1b1iss}3e:d <:e.1"é21.i1'1 a:1"f;§<:I<3:s ';§i:+z*'E.z1_i.;'a.i:'1g 'Er; Efhési (,':0£'1€I'1'1.iC.i. of P011*<::=c;=. 0ffi('?®I."S zmd had :c"3~;.i.<.ssa.;> f1"i1é:-551 <;:()1+:A:p.i z:z:§n1;: 2-;1g2:zi11s3M£. the '¥'c>1i(:c% (§';PI"£ic?e:'ss V' ~ ,4<.:«;;.>:g.1£s~:3ii«v.V of }mvi:'1g {to§1"1.1'11.i1:"E';e(.§ i.}'i1:':

W6 u.n<t1£:2" Scéctior: '1(*l~4 C1".E7'.C..

34 'wou.Ed mu by" itself" ctr)z'1.c.I1.1:=sive?Iy ;:;31"0w? {.1"::<:~. ggtxilt, of :}V1.§:": :.-:mr::a._:2:-3<:;'.c.1 ass; no .21x31():..1n':'. 01' :21:zs:;g';)1?c:;i()1'1 ctazft. take gm-.1(:<§ c>§"p1"0<>£" zmd .f.'z11"the:r. .}":1a'ving .1'eg;a1t'<if to that iélgf. f§:":.z3.i'i E-"W-~53 who the: wife: of Si.(f£<f1a1ra1'11esshéiiizﬁ? 7. <'§a:%£:{.:;:1se;m:3 mad .;':'3i.dd;5m':..r'::<:*:::=;h .F;1.ave .s3t;z:d.ec;{ 2'3': t1"1<:~ir t?\7'§C§€f;"i.€;E3 thé-if. 'K.-'V§'E€i'}. {hey '1"r;ad<=i-r e11quir"y' Wﬁihy>S'i.§f€1£.1E"zEiifii€{€511 iVI':iE:'t'1"A. A I:"W»«52 who (hie: S.t;;'£'i¥.

}'}€'.'E Wm; in E.'1"w .h0spit.a.1 £'z1ki1':}g TL 1'_j£'_?5'j-'1i..:.*.""I'1.'i'.?;_I'1.{ _.f'<1;--.z" 1:3*:e__ A' i1n}?2;.:1"ie;=::%1s ::~;us~;§.z1i2'1e(§ by him, ms ii":t_'<>.i'"::'zjm£1 't1.1 z.;s_:€': 31ﬁ;~wzclg ' 8.333.. Narzayzeztx wE"1<.) C1Z1E,Egh§'.'_E"'i~§I'I1, £1$'§':;'é1E.i.HEtﬁl31.I'if3:7ﬁi.ig§.'J.' s=ae:%v<:::'V1m¢-%§;g;E2.'t. 1.1):-zcmans anti E§",;f?".1ﬁ&EIIv1€ c>1:"i':§:V:.i'?? éacrcriised in Efh.i::~'; <72-3.sv::~ bass .'1§f()1£:«_ be:¢:9'1'H':n:'i€:.::.J;_éi(§i'1!?i:§ £.i.I1("i }.1Vé1\7'§I"1'§:;§ £"€::Ef_,._§"E'iI"("§ 3,0 flhﬁif §11a..<.:t1; ':;1€.%aiI*sjf:».:i7'c:¥:'§1'1g §.LEi'e:..asi.:;Li.<:ri'1_'nEe1'1.t.

§.§§xr:;::1':1 by ;%:(.t{:.t;5§<<~':(.i C;:'.E3'.CT., §:><:r§'<m:: W§i'--6'i;;....ii_ é1c:'té'a,:5s<%écEV_ Nb'; 1--~~w't-1:» ElSS&1t.EH.@d .'i%S'£.g§§<:§a.i:"ra3'1=;£fr3.1"3 :.£'.v;'¢:t:1 zgziasseﬁd Eiixizxl injury" zmd EECf(ffL..E.f3€'2Cf Nziﬁ'-E :7é~.:~f_d<3:.:1;ci. =Tp§"'.E3£3'£'.Lfi.é:--3,. 4c§,m.11'E. $322122'; 1'"1.c-zid 'E:'h;211 t:h¢:2r<~:'.

3'35"": z'i1:;;'€.é3:*ia.§VV' _t':€)'. 'szljijxv fCJ1"?i"1"l.€.-':tI.i("..'>2'.E oi' UI'}.}€¥£W'E'L1I :$:.;311§3£:§z,'-»€tj§iéélrizil (:0m"1 "hex:-3 13r<3(':e3e':{;E@cE to hold .§_§';:.<?:-p1"c):s:::tEi;;'U;O:"3 haw .f£~.'i.]3.1Et(ii to ;;)1'c)xre g:.1i1'{i of t.I"1e>, <.)I"fbr':e7es V" .__'p.'z..z§";;.s~s.§_1.;:§e.b'%~é§"i..i:1d<;:;' Sec1;:i()m~:; I47'. 148. 53:02 IPC zamcgi ._m *=-..»<:*§::'3:~.x._,2"j'r.;,».f7" {"2363 §."'i1'1di.1'1g on p<.m"1t: Na} arid ho1c1ir1g i..i'"x_m. §'ss.:* m.2.1.1i:::;r11(;3sm. given} by 2?1c:<.:us;e<:i No.8 peer is; ssctlf :.;>Xc.:-uEpm.(.;'z"y am}. not c::<')i1I@$.s1;i()11 2:1ci:'1'1i:i~':+s3i'E;_3Ie L":1'1<;1e3"

f::'m<i:£.ie:;m. 30 of ('mt Eilvidemtc AC1. 21ggai:'153t. U'1.€.', 0(7)"

61. . 36 <_>:ffe:2"1<_:a*x mm 'f.Ih(:', {'f{).II}plEii1}£1§'NZ I1"12;f~zcie3 then': pariy &i.<,i€.1.','I..;i:~":§€?.*€.i§ in her p:"ivat:e Co1'1":piainL. In th.e Eight of the ?<:'3..bQV€;"iy zemlci a._Es30 in the Eight 015" thecr .21cqL1§tta.'i of _'(i:tl"':'s:;;' z:§.<:{?u:'~a'm';:<:E 1L:ﬁ'1<::m: is: £10 ;g1'<_>L1.1"1(:i [O f1"aI11e'3: ithcz e*;'i"i'e1If§;§_ <:%i:"~:;<f:us3§am.2":x. of '!;.Em c:V'iden.<:e <:.:':'.'*"' =£'}i1§s:. 7_4ufii1'V}.é5;s:=:S~[£»21'itE (Em2f1.3'%.§€§€3t'X""{;'E."§i'.i{H1 of t.§1c2 SE-IIIIE? Wouid °z1Vc:)i1<1Ts_ia..E{r3"e).":,1'1:~Su.fI3:;f'fe::xit.'._ gg,_§?§"<'}u:1'm":§:»'3 UL} pE"()€'f<;fE.*(i agamst 1"§t1;é"~~;)ree3e.§:rt £.i(?§.',yLiS(3fd. A.

33. N0 da'1..4:E;w%; «_c:ox:';.:".11_(:ﬁ' ._§._1.3.d;g'meIM1t: rc:~31cir::red. by i§'m?:+:: £jfa§'r'E...H""§ . Es; mmx pe'3:r1d'1'I1_g i_i:1SE;X3"P'~:._k:€?£'€3.I"@ the-r Apex C.'imu"'i". E-§ww€E?'{ré:z*'1;#:P'i<3 p"c:nci1c'1':<%:y"('1f<;té.";'*::3%-wi1'1 SI.ipF6}}11€i' Cicmrt mam mzgjii 'E;'>a=:~ a "gL:+.<-:a1_mz::£% t(;.._fi"ea._1'1'1e .:u:h2:'rge:. Eiven if the m.atii<~:r is; W-?~.z": <;fi£af1.g.;§ b<%::i_'7cm:% 'é:.fn.€é ,.S'1--.«1LpTrem.e:2 C0L11"'t, H":<:: smici E1€3CE.1.S€3d zmér '41;'?:€;3'E'L ?.§;,3;2a.a"§ic:*?::-12..V_=;i*£ $,%1:i's:s cased pi{'§'i/2;11'.€ <..*mz1p1ai13t. fi1c:(;I_ '5<'m.'§.75/'u ;2':gé§g3_:3gVa_s;Ai«.._vatumf E1C(i'LiS(:'d. r1_a1m<:%Iy K. N:-.u"ay.:»:m, tflta", Lpaa-:_:~tVi's'T'€'_'i;i3:"§'is:::*'_~»'E'1'<irr§%i.%:1. In {the p1"iv2u'.&t C€.Jr1;1p§ai'r2't; ass :at;.ai:<::c}_ zj.1J'§;txc_>W:, V&:;;',m»;: :;aE:3.E:§;a1ti(3:':: t:l1at, when 316-: ai%:mn.pla.mant Smt. v.,,§/i3§§.7;£}.&'}.}I>E.i1:33.21 W/0. S5jd1"21::r1ee'sl2 visiiicécii the h(.sspi.ta.i, t.1'1e*:

<'.i«;%V¢;__ré5:z:5mc.é<:?. \JVé:§;*T53 aalivsa 2111c}. he Enformacf her that th E?

" =5' 'r1a§.; ' 37 ;;1<:(:'zj'1:'~:m%. K" N'araya.r1 ir'1$tigfatM.ecI the <J'i:}"1c:I' a.<':cu$ed tzc) <%wz:'z'm11%§: .n%3z..1J;r§c3r 2:mCE do not'. {save hirn. it aim} ailegeci 'ﬁ':haii iihisaa Ei.(f'.Cl'1&§€iT{'§ t:I11'e21tened her and her V%£':{1§11,i}y' rn.€;?.£;:'1?E.>€;32"s5 a.1§€:§;{i1"1g;§ that will 10:1': n1_c'-:=te<i'£ wﬁh V. <:<'s1'1:5;£;re_1g_z1<33%1(ﬁes if €ih(;.: c:on'1p£ai1"1'%. is fiieci {Iifa..:>:Vz%rp}.a.marat: in tihcé-3 SC. Ne}.

£1a.'1*.t:"z;2'm:mi {E16 <:%v<e3£'1?:: mat t.1'a11_:5 ati.t;v<:¢3a:::'«;§-rcii. E31311!) '€:1':1e Ses$ic>r'i alga VC{s)'L1rtA dici c:<;7m&a%.§.de;sr<:e<i_ the": t%v.ii7I*::n(ée«'"c§E" ..Ai:};"1<:>. c(.':':m_pIai.n::mt., <51?' 'V F*W--+i:3'4T-' he we:re=: also PW--»E§2 i"}€If.§" s3c3x'L PWJ 'j~a;1 tr:-:2<;.:¢mf;_in:::a:E---;;%.lmfggg; '\i§::i::i"; 't}r1;?:"--<;t()Ii":'{§§'.21i_i:1ant in this creme 211.1550. {En a;;:s;:f';:f<::{i:i;:1'{:'£<)rrbi?'thg3"'--..e§t4(r§_£'.Ec:.2'1<:<:t, iihe iri2':1fI Ci€)ll3"i". has m;tq:V.:§i:'€.ed. 't:1E":<.'.w.<.:~«:~. vz:1<:ttca;i~5seCE~-- " anci it. is ncui; the (12136 of the: ,_cm'1;':;§}i;1%§;:1a.z.":,it, "£.11z.1:£*."u':;E=1:;=::" zzccuserrci E1E§S5£"1.U}"i'.€3€f§. the cicacezased féuiwff ".i*<;éS2,5§?l:t","pf 'w'E:3ich the <?fc::*:<;é<-3=a.<:3.c:r;i <fiie::c'i C)!" acta::u5ed ei:a<inx_§§:<<érs::§ a_r.1'y" '1-%:'};'}1..11'y Kiri} t:he de3<:':<i:a,$e<:i. A.iI.e:,ge:1'tic)r'1 iin the 'g.)3"§va:at;%-3" <'j:<51.a1'1;;3§2a§'r'1i: zamd in her @.vide1'1¢:%(~3, azmly reve:z~1£s t.he1t. A V"é:'§;":1is~s'_ é?i.:V~:«;r:..:5:3€:?<§; fI'IS{I.i§{£i.'i'.€C1 the e.3't.}"z.er e1c:c'm.~..$e3d m ctomxniii V' I§.'1_§§ z'<:i€«:r <%3§ Eih as: (§€3(?€EE1M€éi?(i. ff'§;~p%}w I34, '.i"'his {$5186 arise out of the private <::e:)mpIai'r1t.., 'E'..%_m }€i*E:i'E"§1(iTf€§ Ses3s1'_<'31'1s Judge: "E3215; coI1ss.i.:':Ie1'eci the SWC31'1.1 :sa:'{.;2:"§;<2:'°:A1e:<'1iT. Qf ihe (If€)£'}.'1p1E1iI1&1E'i€.. who is €:2<;::1_:1.1i1'"M:eci 8%§€'.i%i'§i.iEfI'I."§EEHE of her s~;50I1 PW--2§ s--:.tat',c2m€:m: of . E->W--3, 1:»*w%w4 m+ M3,, PW-w5 ¥>:~a.;:-:;:g:}:;%1g; g-1<:i%v.:%§{§;%;1%e&%;: Eh <:)r*1ig;:fm::1i <t(:m;'1.pEame1n.t in the.-: ~ ";F'*u.,,¢T7I'";1r: « ci<:2c"£m"A vv}";:':3 \?'J2":1S L-%;s«;z:«z..r111'n<--::d 'éf%ii§:3 w L 2~'m<"§_ 3E);:1s&;s;rci gm 'i;i'1<;%aa€: ;r_r:&1teri§€%.}.; Jlfldgﬁ Em'-154»; g}r§_§<::<3£3€}e:{i to §j)&lEV%E§"-..*;i1E§ .:'§:>.2*.r:_1V<-:r1* F01" f1'2.11'I]iI"}g <;r§'1a*s':"gge E703" i;.h<: ' §n'3'f;;~§:11<:<f::é§" S€(:t.i<:>1'1 147.. .148, :3.#.T}--2'-V '1f?<;:ei4ij-CT} \Rr%;:,::?;%1 ':'3¢t:t,i01'i_""'i~4:£3 of ERG a:ga.i1'1s1: t:.h€< 'p<;%'E',§t.i<):31'*::;' " %:'1erz=3_if1~: 'w}'m__WaS_.1:"1c>i actcizzsaeci in the raariier i%§@.&s:::i¢.:)z'159. Cé§x.«'.:=3f;?'. "N033 / 'i.V98~6.

%'¥?§"';e:éi,ii£%:r"~"i--ra'V the 1i;___§ht; of the ac:q:.1it:taE of the QEi'i'a.('::§'* _:s:»2'i;.?:!.,:i.j::.~.::&e:.:1;_V 3.1;}. §:3.C.No.2/1988, 131%: 1<3:a._rm2ci Se:s.$i<)1'1$ g}'n..u:';i gg{: (j*€I:"i'...E§{IE;"V :E'fr;5.m'1r3 1:116: dzargc-3 55);." i:%'1<:2-. c)f'fe:n<::es .«, 'V.p'Li2'1.§saE"iz:1fi§<:r :..mC1€::* Satztionss, I47. .148, 302 read with M:-'£3 mi' £.P.,Cl? agairzst; '£171.63 pe:1:.:i€:i0r'1er the 143 zj)i"}..§-'.(;'.. which mt-.:::m.$:;

39 (.i§{..£§'?$§[i€.)1'} .;i*e_:q1%,aircsi»t {:0 be (:m";sid€:'1't:cE in this revision §;>€:"€;E'£'i<?>r31» If 18 'Lzs5'at?:ful 11.0 1'{?f€:".*.F to Vibe Eaaici p;fc)v1's.siOI'1s. ;':%§e<':éE<m 1.4;'? of E,P..C. dez-11$ w.i'iL.h t'.l1<:'>: }I}L'l.I1i$.}"'i.I1}E1111. for _:*§a:>Vi;.i:'1gg; in 2~;1.:~:-s :"m1c:h as 2'36. '"£.£.3f"£.<)é?U£i*!' is guilty Qf rz'.c;2:"ing, s;f'za.EI wit}: m'fapré5;on.:"r'1£2mt' Qf' ¢z3it.f"z.ez' de>5<:ripI;éor1j%:2r' ._i£:f!'I'?'f.'v.i«U'?liC}f_iu z"n.aiz.g,.y €:z.x7i"<a-721:2! iii") Iww g.,:r3ars, or wi1i2'z_V,?'A_'z'r1e'<&.-~<;%;"fi':.1.§E;t}"i,. -b(:'>'{.h.""'V ;~ 3 1?. Iii_im't',i:1g;§ ﬁes (L1{'3ﬁII€"Cv'i'<§,U"£(Z1€f'-._Sv§i':€TfIi.(}'ﬁu'};,}*1F'5_Vy§,r']T;1§'("3l"i §"3"§€;':EjtI§f'E?E%§ "z,z.:E'u:3r'1e2*L>e2;* h_ﬁT)I"C(3 or :}'ioZ_e%:M1g':e is ~ . u.s:ec'i.F by all £.:z'1:E.c;2:;u..gf1.:.f €l£:§;':§€{?f'I'2}J§§.j, (;>r.T'17_g--_ g::::":.g,Iums-:%;*'?'~;fE3e?r* I.}"te3reQ/", in _;;W"n§;<52<:m:f"im"a.,qffifué':é;r;:m1§*;?z.Q'r=2 O}2:f€¥€T'ZE'QfS1,.L(I??'?4 <iu3s<3r'I1bZ_;.;, every z?'T2ez'raim<.:s+%:'~:_ {;3§'{'4 :s:'uc;'?":.4~. é3:.$s«:é;ﬁ}3Z;)_. gz.:z',l£'y qf" the qfférlcre Qf ri¢:'»iir"zg;® "

f{.Z)<:3:ﬁé 01" rim:ir1g I:'1ec:s:és:~3ész;11'§I.y 1"tE3(;;Ui1'€3S "if:-i,fi'i. " '&i.£ "£".,I.;1'ijV¥1Vé3ZfWfE.:1} zmsseznbly or a _1f1_1emE3re:1" 01'" u.1i:Iz1wfui a;3_s%;@s;§:"i:;:1.!i3Ey."gj-§°:Sse(it1,1.t..i;'%3g the {T:{)fI1E'}"1011 €u').§l\)¥'j€-4::f2tV of smczh 'v.z;a:€~;5«3¢:31*:i:'§.':a,§3»*'; "U :'1ia1w{i}:2} z1ss<-érrlbly 211530 dcifilxed ulntler :39 K. 40 "Km a:=s;se:r"r'1b?y C1]/Vfivti.' or more g:7e3r'sor1s is <:£w,;igz'@.aie?c§ am. "az.n1Lcz.z.Lg_Ii1.Z cz.e:s'£3:'2'1blg,r",§/' £.f":e:3 c:c:m1.r"n.c)n oi:gjec:fi'. zggj' {.316 _g;w:"s0r':.$ composirtg {Thai ass<a*r'r1.blg;1 is iféﬁl 'R3 <;>ve::*awe by (.?I"iJ?"?.f,I'"I.(il.lN/E)?'C€i', or sf-"Lou..a c.*z'zT:'r1i:'2,c1.5. _jbr<:e_. the: C'¢:ez"zt'I*(1Z or (1f'ly Sisziizjer. ' ..§-()L!é31"i1f'Z"¥.k"3f"if or :'7a..1*£z'arA:"1er2£ 'a':ije;c:3 % VZ,e3;{}f:;ic:zz'z%sre Q1' cling Si'<:':f,€,».0z" at-ir%a;;V Pz..::k2? . ' Servcznt in the exemise :_'0;f. --3ihi-:5 £c'2z11k:g[i.t'£ pm..z.2e=r Qf8l.£(?h Pu§.3E{<: Sef:..1_ar':f.:': er A . 'V .

32} 1'esi._<3é: the execé;:;*£'.zfc">'r2 Q)" arm {<:z:.:f:=. <.i:{ of am; leegai. pfQ(?€SS;'O'i'"-. '-

ZW} €?OI'1*'?ﬂI31if 'i/i.Il;{:,' .Af"I'3§i;"§£:f}":i'f{f_f_ €;.nff <::rmzir1(1E mzrspass, orﬁ.oi:iu33z* Q[z'é;:.:'zc?"é: .<:;§'\..,_ __2.§§g1;L'v_~:72gaf(i?:zs'Q)'cjrffm;--zcli f2:2r*ce?, OI' Show Qf' '--(i'3'"i.§'I'1iJ'iiXA{:;f§5I"£'§?;'"1(:;" <:m.g,; f36;'i'S€.')I'E, to tales": or "o;§9§;.o:¢.:jz'1~p0'::s€i§>:éion e:3f"(1I"I.g7} p'r<;}{.9e3r£y, G?" to (i€?fJ?'iI)'§? <::2,1'fzy perscm Qf their e*r;jo;;n'1m-1:. <3/"

_'€::e._;*Ig!-1i Qi"1,1.2ay. or Qf' {he z..:..'s€;..> Q1' a.z.)czte2r or "<%s:;.':e,g.%_{:.r incrorporeczl :V'igi'1t: Qt" zVz,2§-jaic::?'1 I19 in '>j<_;.r;»§;scssi(}r'2A or ergiog_;I'r'2£3mf, CW :0 e:'7fc>r'c:e3 Vcxm; righfi or supposed rigf'1I,; 0:"

53;; me2*(,m,s of (:rirm"r'1a.ljbr*(:re2, 01" :;«;}'"t€i)z.,u Q/"

crz"nI.i:"1aifarce, to <:<3r'rzpe1 Clfly p<e"zI"sort. to do u:?'r,a,i. he is not ieggaligg boz,md to do, or 3"':

3

MW 4 E. E0 orrzii to do w}1-xzzgt: fie; is Eeggaxiigfg <~;mt'iI:'led.

I0 520, "

4%") If E.E1Wff. mz;:.}:s:<:ésa ii. :a.i:}L.z:':da1'1tly (':k;==21r £11216 in 0rd_s;:::' to :51.-fii:.1'ac71':

me;-' p'mvi.&si(>::%:s; caf Sc~x:ti()11 14? 2111. tmlerwfui it)': 2:' z'£":€:z'1"'3.b<::r mi" 5:11 1.} ;:'i}zwrf"1.1I as5semb1y' in ;:>1"<':>.ss<~:Ci:z .Li0v1f1ﬁ€.)f ' {TU.i1¥"k.1"i'}¢iT'JE"} <'.xi:>1§:;=:<:%t; oi" the assemblyC(:c>1ii'rx';.§t:é;. an -<.;) ff:---.=:_1".=.Vc;L<?:L*.','V 1"c:q_'11i:m $0 11.0151 l"1iI'1"i g_g1.1ii{.y. of an t};f7f<:1"1c;:<e:..".+.g:>§A:I"1";.i:3E"1:a.iii Ev:-:1 V' u,..m'1<'§m"" Seci.iwn 147 {if I.I:'.C. 1%" E§5@<:.:ti<:.>m de_éi}s;V_'ﬁviétjz. :*E<?}f'i.t'3g ei1*.fi3eci with €'i§;'r£;%.{Ti§y w.m::=a: 't2v:'1iz.:f\Ni'L1E a5sse'1'nb§y with 2:1 (4*(}1'{""t'}§ik(V..'V?i:'§"_,i' }i§I:>ﬁ}§' tlie ab} 6.61:. of s5uc:h 2:%.:4m:=:'g"z-31%;)EyVxéa:?;':':.z::»~<<'%V}?a{_%.;{}.',.v_Eie;iLt.i1y' \V{:\':1p(l)I"1 iss ';:>r..1r1iss}%1a.bEc:. 49 <:1<::a1sis wViti'M1 (_)ff€31'}(iff:} <:<>m_mit:'u::d by _e-3@"€';":_i"§2' ?.§i'::":??}§1'1»?'*51%<;:;sTT Q5" m"1.EawfL3I_ as3s5<ia[1_1biy' ,§.,§ui.§ty of an off"e%'I1ce mnj:£ni€:'m(i " p1"0s:se~,<:L1.ti(3_1.1 of (',€}f1'Tl.I1"1("H'"} 0bj<:'>cr'i.. O:ﬁ"em.<;:<~:

W.ﬁ'im.t' i:%s_efi)H:1mit:'i.:<:>c:i by me.1nbe§* of 1.mIz;;..w§'1.1i as5sa<~3mb1y in m"<:i_<-3_;:*i.' in ;.m")s3€:<::1m), E119 c:c)1nmm.'1 0b_§c3c:'£: of 'the: u'I11aw1'.'u]. A rcavacling of Se«:é1::ion E41, "E46 zemd 147 of 44 a.;;_§a?u'.:"1:~:a§': a.<:c?z.1ss&:(.i NOS. 2 "tie 42 zgmcgi ix') .1. 1 trial was heid. and f:.h.."i.<:=s <":<"m.r"t' 1"1:;'1.<:;§. :1] ready a.<:qE.1.i{it.@:ci 22!}. tile 2.-2.<':<:'1.zsed 1101'. e:m.iy f§'"<)3'n. :,'m2 0f'fc>r'3ces p1.1.1f1.issh.a.bEe L11"1<£.<;:I" Se:r€:t:ic)zMM1.$" 147. 146%, :".*3i{.}i?: wand Wiih Sc:ct:i<:)n 149 0f1.P.(7L'. but 21'.4E:»'.<v):'-<f.':if(>1f}:':

1i'..§'B.€.': <;1i"ft?:3.m<:s.%s:a pL11'.1i:~ska21b1e 1.Ir1(.'%c:r S<:%c:ti<:m.sss '1 ~ 0? §.P.{iI:. (iun-1p1ai.m: has 110i: ;».1:':"e1)_{(5:..d_c_'>'r ;"I3..:ei('3'€%" €.:m"i'.}::v;2r ihan i:?':1<~: p£"E3S(3I'31i a<:t<:a.1s:;e.§I~I$;'. ~ N §:>::i'v;:.m:3 <.fit:u'13pi:a>1i11*i. In iglfzcé '§.iC:.r';V};.zE£1tgﬂ..V'€'§fA:._'f"i,'e.-€..cﬁher * L 2.1<.?:€:*::..w.:*.<f fI"t;:a:'1:': 't:.he zézllgzgeci '"sy.1"1e£.'?1'cér":._t,hg::i§ }ea1"nt3<fI f:"%i€:se;:':»;i:.;m:1~.a g;'z.:u:ig<;* was "_};;:st.ifi§;:<ji;--. Jr':"a§;1.<::§é:r':'i:1_g§ to fra.'1"m:

<:éi"1a-.n";.;t;~>;. "&f'§L'gZ'§iJ1€E:'3f 3ftL:iii3,;r;~*.. pyfgaeeni.' "}3€t.i"€.i<>1"1e:1'* Em" t.hc=: 0f"'fe':"1(:<:2s.~:. gmz1§&aE"§.'a.'Et>Ee;;: :i:1fz£;ié I" ". :5\':','4(.".V1'..'.§.',.'}'f"'J.C""_% 1.47, 148, 302 :r1-"rad with .E§@€.::ViT.i<;.):3'}. 14e€:3..<.":§f'T. . P;;_(L'3'.?'~., Vv Z\;Ci:11j_U;ec11y, a.11cg.,fat.ic)1": in the priV'at.<~:

'qigéigytggﬁizezEm; 'a..zi{:i.._t:1*1n=e f;*§l',a.1"..(:3}.'1T1.€BZ1 i. gixren by i':1.1e <::0r11pE21i1'1a.nt. <?§'s..3.:'"i1:"ég; *i".}w3§'.ifi_.'1"':.i.*'(:1.1 of the (:a.s(~: in SCI. N0.i?;/ .1986 are m.01"e ma" Ee:=sss.; '.iE*2§>_ {.119 ;s'sam<--:~:. .A._pz1rt. fI"(')I'33. the. fa..<r:f. 1:ha{: ttim :s::1.n1e: "1I}é§1§:.'€%',F£7J<i.§. "was 2.-1v:¢.1.i}::d),£<:: be*f<.):*<-;: "£112? §c::z.;1;1"z1etci Sessions «_.§z.2£:igg,£-t mad the Ieamed SE'.SSi()]'"1S JL1€i_gcé ha%1viI'1g_._{ mat: founcl t_i'1a;t. {jh<::3:'e: is any gfustifi<:::1'tio2"1 to iss:~:.u.<:, s:mmn1(.)ns. to t.1"1e }:m;:xs:z~mi. z;w<.:us~:;e€;i '§'1a«'1S <;tc)11cIu<:'t,<»3<,:i 1:116-3 meal c)3;1'iy' a.ga.i1:'1s1i i%,§'m:&:>;<:-;*. :ss;2Vc<':'L;sss€:d ;;11;1ci passed 'ihf.'.:'; juc1g'1m::1%1i.. a._':<.)w""'E., :;ii'i,<-:71" E'V3a1vir1g;f 'r1otice<:E in the e-.:r\2*ic:ie:'1..€s:£;*. L- <;:¢.:'>::%V:V:.;:>4B.a2;mamE, 1V1:».1:~?g amt. f0Lmc;i tit; issuer. §%§'[..lII'1:1"}{i'('}i'1S'fit?)' 11hié;~5 %iii(3€?LiE§é€i'.d.. §%Z';\rc:'n <;>£.§'1e.r\Vis.se ::«1I.s.3<:>g I':0_ I*'<;r1':":_ ';':'%:1_'1-__t1:';1!.v;g1iis2;'1ffL_J.j1A' e1.s'ss'~;E-:n':z'E31y 221$; E"'€i%qI',1§.}."f3C1 u1'1de317: F;3t::<i:t:i(i:1_ 1;/1% 'L13 ﬁr; 33.22 mEa"}:in'1am:*; E3 };>em:~s0'1"::% or iTi(.)1.'(i'?: '%fe?2_':%:.1Tt_._rar1<;t'{' 'é...?"1 c1.%:j }:)51~()\V/§si()I'1&s of ;€'§@:<:::*;,i<;:'1 .I4i-?'.. 'I';h<:: a(:.gr:i:as;<-éd .1_';}u,¢}4;'f«" 1"m".~.:"I"1 bar of V£:.I"1e s:e;::,2.£<% '1%,v'"iié%2;'{ﬁI"fi.E;§ 2:. ';ss;.n1'¥:v1y=--. &1'l'1.C§""Stl be-:2 p1"t3sec:'1M:t.i11g the £:<>v111.;"m<31f:. i:>b}(:zi:é' afijé"-_ }i:'r1F: .s4s.,21i'C?'. "t..mE2;1'wf"u.I 21.:':;e3cé131b1y zmd {~30 2:1Jl:E;0 EH}(i€319*'f5£:?{'iTi.§.€}1£7i.&% ' a.1M1(iE 14-9, if '1:1.1e:2-"re, mi) mat.e'1"iz11 Mu-.1. '-':i::""2.€I?'i'.,§3L3ﬁ1}C}1€i'E'i:1"{'"~~~£E3aI'V in tile S\7V()£'I} s~:»$21t:e:n"1e%r1t: of 1:116: L'<_e0m";?xiea§;iv;f;:m'3% <.>;r in the SfT2}'{.f:f}TIEE*l1i wf the wi'{:ness<:2s:3 %j_:}§£1:§_'i.1.EZ.Bi'1§f§€;§ E::Sy if}'1e <:ton1p}a.i1'1am' to show "t[1_"1z':1t t:h<3:re: ::1re 'v._;~.m.;\/* c.";E':§j 1¢f:;" 21.cc1.1s<1:c§. zﬂcmg wﬁh pr<*:.§.se1'1i: a1.cui:t..1s<=:d who Céiilii 'j£T<;v§j"ni"A_' ﬁ..'§i'1,§£:fWtfi§'""i..t.1 £5185-u5:mAE)1y, 1111 my \/§€3'W the questi().n of _ﬁ.f;<%2..§.1:1E1'}.g;{ <t§12«11"§_.g<;2 'f<._:)I'" H343 (')ff(:.1'1c:<:s }:m':1.i$ha1%bI<2 u11:::1eI* wow WW...» g w..4'I'W' vr ciﬁé E:%§m':i:i<>:"'3;:s§ "1147 5. 1,45%, 302 reacgi W'i.€.h Scsxsrtiarl 149 of E.P.C3. €:%0<;>:s:+; £101: 2:2._sti'&:§s@, 426%. A3 :i':e1.r the a1'1e;:gg,'z1tL.i<:>:.'1$ of c:ausiz1g_v:1@@%t:1.(;fr 135% <;><:>m;ré-::*:m(é.£§ <ic):"npEai:11e121t, }V1z».2:as not .

2:m:'*:<':'u.:s;;¢:%<:i z3..é:3s:;a1.:.Iii<::<:§ nor the 0v<:r:*t; c:_tj:' _-- E";.§m.. 'I"%'M:*. mﬁy pi::.z:e 0f €3\rici<i:1T'[email protected] ew e_32j1*E %:h§s'~ia a,<::e;;~;i,1.:e;<::c§ theta c:c>1"1f1r»:V§.f§;':~:;>V:1:1 .91'; 2?<11"1" ;;:a."£E<;?;;;§a%:sf.i ciymgg, d<:%<::'Ea.r2;_1.§(>1'Ma bt::f01'e ithczé <;:()'%;a1p.1axm.z:I'3"E: in '£.1"1<-5' vf:'>V:<afj;*1_;sz1I of the s3e1.ic1 s.;"mf;.e'1%1';z::ar1i":. ii' ".z.'§:i{f t-:.::-1_§.53 ' v{i'1'L:s'E)2111(i <i>.f tzhe m;'np'i;::,_E'i'1zemfi} V'._-vi:'1§}:i>:7:1Ic3d'"-___1:'E"1a:~_' <:<_nn.p1a..iz:a1.:"1f'. maii tlliss €cﬁi.C€i'.L'it%'-.'e£'.'?(IE' amzas 1;3re=*s::;é%';!f;i1._\§Gh_:éh 'inc,Ede:'1.t: wok pizlzéﬁi mad he i.§"n.:+ési'.i%f:(i-*iTé4s;§(i 'i:h_<;%» .,<_>f:}'i_e::1" §1(:(:us€<:i Eta kijii H16: cIe2<jre2;1sc:c1_ zzmd. &}'&:m:;;si"&: .m?(:;A.._ a1k;s,§211;..i(>I1_ 't'h.2;1t this; a<*:c,.~uss<-35!~;:>e"t;iMf,i<)ne1" "':.gas;§a}¢2~;:é:a_ :.:1§€.1::=;a7i"_~v??'_i1"; (3 .;':';i7<:.:.*.<i:<-:r;~:1.i4seC1. If t:h.(:: <')1;'he1' ;>:2V<':eV':use<:'i 1:1::1v<=: beam ::z<:%c§ui'§;M§'.c§E '€'f<.:zm i:}":€> of'fe1'1(':e a1_'Ie>g"e2c1 zéiggaiixlsst them. and ¢.§"€.._:»§;E:-?;y if iihery 22121:: zzmt the e1cc:1,:sse(:i a1"1_c:i if the: p:resc:1'1{: .%§.t-f:c;ti.€Sc;:é£§ cmiy {(3 be p':.'c:>ssec:ui:::c:'i, it is i"1€,)'E. 1§1:'1c)wr1 as to iv"

47 §'3<'.}'W me: 'iz;%a._1f;t'*:e;?c?'i Smsiorxs J'u.c1ge (ran fmi-:V:r31<:: the-3 «::i'1.arg»;e$ $02? "n:§"tm <.>f°i'zs,~:r:<3,€::es pm;1.ishe1bEe :.1.1"1ci€%: .'§Sec:'t1'i(>;r"1 147, 148, 1302 mziizﬂ Wriﬁa ;'3@<::ti(m 149 of LPG. "'1"'h.e JE1:'1g1"6:diemis of E:§s;%<':'t.§<Am "E4i»';7', 1485 149 not pre:s;--;(;%m i;1_1 the 1i:rﬁ1--*\ra.t.<-2 <:c;m'1;;>£zzaizm §"i.3e<:i by the <;:<am}:'}}.a1iI1_a1:~1*£:R "R3 ea-;.3i}i.1"';1t;§t'I§§E'M1't<:V. _;:>;"<:sv.§_sa.§<;)§153 of S('3(3'tT§€f)'i'1 302 :5e].~.;:~;«:> t1"1<e'r<: no a'iIé:,ga1%t:.i.f€;11L't.}1éé11:f_ ' '€:'"EV1_§_.€»'s g;')e:;:'€:it'§<ma*>z" i'm,&:1V3t;.i0I1.a_1}y ci:0n1:3:ii't:t€:é:izmy V 43?'. 'E"1'1e 1.6:;-iLr:;:'1ed S€SSi{)E'1S J':.1éig&: 'E1a\f.E_:f1g if1<:>t:i<i(€:€1 ' m.:;.n. Wu: pa:.1.1"a11e} gtzmtreediI1g$' 'Q;;"i'ﬁle i;;§&;i;s-s§.'i's§;*ai{f" ':;.§';c. poiice m:g:3<:3z"i wesami on %;)e»:~J;7::i__1*e:- A_ this.~. S€]'.'Cf-,$.$E.€C'):I"ku':'§ (I2c)u£*tV in SC. N€:3.2/é%'*?e€'}V'*=vwi1:[E":C>iiE.::5 c'-:v.e n. (LT{)'}"";'i'~;.'}.(ifi:¥I?if"i§,:,§; them by T.hf;'2 §:'"mgu>;.,zgV;;jﬁ"'aA;§t<I:' 4a..:e3'::i._<;§:§ "da'i:t:d--._ 1999 has;; passmgi the %n":_g'3:%:s.g;1"§e:?c.i. g::~<::m: to fltetiizé citlmzfge, aVge1i§':$f. £1715": pe3'{.s'.t:1'c)I1<=:1' ' »-/«'i~'§:?§.V"E{i«.<f:':xs§e: if there}: is 2:1 policrza 1'€3pc):fi, ar1c'1 t.i"z<~:re: is e:i§'::»m ";a, _;:>£*EV3é;1jﬁ@5' mmpiaim, t:}:1c': p:'ef>vi.siai<):'1:a; of S<.=:ct1<;)1~1 210 <;>f V1"&'.C{iIiI'"€i8 t.h.e3.t:. "';'_/" Eixzer police rezpori does not ":'<::§s:zI£fe::a £0 €7lI'"éy a'2.::<>r.§.:sea>ci in t'h,(:.> coI'n;:2lcLin: c:c::.s;c:* or the 48 R/§czgi5:Z.r<:z£e oloeg; not take cogm"z(1n<:e cgf any Qﬂw/(~é'I'IC(«Z' on {:?:.<;* }'){)§iL,'i€;' fw€'%§.(3<:)J"t,§ he sh.c;LU. pmceecrf, Luizgfa I;h.e;a inquiry or §ir'£.<:1L aiJ;.?§'E,i<.f§'l wxzas :s;t'a.yed by hirrt in a<:corc1a.r[1c>e? l,UfU1 E'i'1-3 pr'"(;>mTs;a7c}r's.:a: qj'ﬁ1.is <;7<:ac:i(-:»r." If'1':he're are. tvvu pI.'€)€':{i'€diVi:lg%3:C¥fl(3 mm m: b:5.1ss;.i.:<;; oi' p0ii(:tc~: 1*e:port and 8;I1()ﬂ"1ﬁi??E' 0.1"}. _ a _p1f"§vz~:x.t:€:? <:<mT2pEa:Em'{:, Sec1:ic>r1 230V t':}f;a*z¥tj;q in <::e:-15%: ifi:'§"1<=:: .if}.\f€;':E*I+"€,i§._§éHiOI1 is;

;*:::T&.2.1y i'.§:m=:?r er';quiry, pz'c)(:ec2cii11;j§a'0;: tliii: <::m1"in:3.g.}§aim; a.m€fE <;=:a;1.E_§. .f"(?r the __vr:§\\\ N0 da'm.bt:, in "f:fh§:'~3 (raw, :;1S"1i){; tAhf: cigpfe "0'fKf§E'img of 't1;':c-'3 p.a"ivat€: «;:<.m1p§2§.=i'2;1t:;, .3} _..-.u"g{% 7é}"1€'a::t,"1vz3.sa' "f'i1€:<i and. miss 2»;2.c:<:'L.:sec;1 WEIS m;.:*£: £é.:.£"E.*.g::ym'i 212%:;t§1'::;:A:j:a§i<i}jﬁ-.the <:.ha1'ge3, if-3}'1€.'.€tt :f'i_.1e:d by 1'.h('3 {.){')}§('7€'3v E*£0'vsr<::v<':tf';'e'i"1d.:--s- (5fi'=jL1ssi.iciéc%: w0u.1€£ }"ié?e.V€3 be<;:;'1 met" if V§'.I?'faE5%s §31*iwja.i;.c: €;:<:>t'n§1}1'é1i 111 was; 'brc.>ugh1;1 '(:0 me": 1'1(T)UC:<3 <.>_f1:11e ."-§.t%.zi._i'm3+<:i§i."E§£:::i~%a$i_<_3':1.:=s {..V':"": ,:'dge who \»\r.:1:e; [email protected] with '$116: tiraiai w'; f:i%;.ixii:..

V 521$. :3";'..:'sa-S5"

'=.74~@§ -".'[A;:;jT::1f1: fz"<;m1 thiss, g:)r0\rEs1'_(;u.':1s:: 0f Se.Cti.cm. 319

--V t;w....:z3'%2.:fé.:1'".:s:~;; "';V)&;.)'iVé3:' (3:11 t:_E'1e trial j11(;ige. eitmar c§'L,:1'i1f}g <-:1:"1qui1y or Ar"; i.?;_j:<;% e;:€.,?§<:Ee:t~1:1m, if Eiie iea.rn<~3(:1i jt_.'1.<;'ige fix'1.<:iss's 1112:-:1: 't:hc==:1"e: are 61" K"

63'} :w_<:t1"2 0Tf.}§,§'.1£;?&" ;.:1>«;:rs<'>1'T1ss who a1re not arra.yez:*r(.i 2.15; z.1ctc::..1:3eci, he mm iS$1E?xE..1{if S5i,E1TITi1"}1€'}l']f¥3 to such per:-:.(m if he fi.nd:~f-a prima §7¢'m§:.~'.*. m'm."i:<:%a"§2e:E 21g5;::Vi_1'i1s1' s31.1(:I1 p€»:1'so1'1_. Ermxxrevctx", the Very m;~.1_Vi"a:23":£;;1i 'e..re.r}'"aic,:h Wéifﬁ b(~'e1'.'c3re: '£116 }€3jI"I"§§;".'.C§. Jt1cig<%: ;:g1'1z£"f..}f}.e '§'f,E"'iEiI ....§':V.x.<;ig;,§a:: .§'::;wing r101". :f0L1nc:i it Fit to i.sas5uc_-3§"i:§t..11'z*:;11§);<;~V5§ _ z:m<"i i"'§&:.1.Vi.I'agg 'm1"1Ci<:.:*zi?ci 1.:h<;=. ju (:1_;§1"neI1t':. 23:,g§ziti:1'::~,;t.:: i't:1'(--'3.., (T)§}1\¢;E'.§i" ;.;1<;rz::'ra,z5s;c'-it'? emci tilde E1H€'g£:H'.i()I1 11"}'».:'{,}'1€:E:"'--§3§"i\fE3}i€3'-.ffi'&">I§}'}f§L}.?;3.i'f3Vf' v;.rhi<':'h (£0 mm Liam;-;tiI;utc:* <;~'ff<'-':-,vz';c?.c'»3 :.:1~;3<;:imj .71 4317, -. L 24.19%. :3€)2 rmcil WM}: 5'3(:?Cfi()I1___:: ¥§.§3 if-.*}sf:Ti.T_ §:.!:%1::i*€: no p<:>:e;:e~;iE3§_1itiy of <:,mT':vic:ti1"rgVV"t:}3c:.L;ﬁ;:€3§%.e'f';ij" g.5é::$i.itLi<'J;"1<::r ew:=,11 01:1 ﬁ"§m=:=: 112;-:.ii;«::::*rTE23,__§_ 3\:r3:*3"1ii3f§i%;z3 ";:r.:1f<>ci"L.1c£§'e;*}~%f::j? the <.:(f)1'npi2e1.i.r12111t c:v<::1'1_ if 1%': .1254; :V":o'§","<;<'t>:1iT.1"é§:x%'{i:;fiaV» "

5%)" V'L<-.._V"j£T"i'=21's-i; isAi;1i<::«.._1';€2visi<')n p(:?iii'{i'i.(')};'1 1...11"acf1e:" Sectican ._ iL?;§:E-W '.3-ZEIFEV:'E-'§:i{:.)'VV'€:::}T'w:§§V;'{|:::V05"..-ﬁ§E;{:}d t.his:s {3i')Lii""{ h.::.1s p<)wE31" to Call for kc-m:'s'cT; -V 6:39.,3":"2.;§.'{1:3:xﬂiEm r€:::o1."dsi_~?. of may ;)1'<>c:s:€:€,ii_r1g bef(.)1"<: zmy i_n{e;2%3'*§i<'m" (3:LLi:3i:V%:i-'}_e'1_E. (3m:1"£; situa-1t:e Within its; <31" his Ioczzti a~nris:%<;i§«'_?'€,_§m"2 far" {he p'urpos:.se <')£';ss21t:isiyi:1g;,§ .it:sc:é1f' 01" I"1.i_rr1ei;eI.f f.(ﬂ§"_3..§"1€:? ('TO!"1"€:i:?(":tI"'itE*:S:5f:%%, 1e3ga.1ity or p:'c)pric3't:y' of any f§1'1d.i11g, _ €:'.§;~.m'<i0m*i:r{ﬁ '§'.h€ 1":'22 r:E:1i<i:r was :1_1ci}"t. disapnaseaci oi' by this C0u1't i dfim.

x:,:.w pm<;:€~:<;>:r;ﬁ "£10 f"rz:m1€: 'the chzirge. A3 o1:>se1.'vé:d zﬁnove, e>z.'1tim. 1'1'V:ze1'{;<%%r"m.1 <%>v¢-m if it considesimézi, T',1"'IO'E1§§I'1 ssLz<::_h .ma_§c~:1'i21i 'Wz=.:s.+:; <::m'1sai.€'§r:%:*ecii by the Ieelmeci Sezssicms J'L.1dggé;j"iz"1f"--«f;.Ifi€:' E:.y'T:zz.E z;%.§..;{:z;92.§:x"3;:2;"E: me: <3"€.;%".1..@r £1CC.'.L.lS£?3d, c-zverx. cm saeéaﬁfzd :;i§7 V' '§".E:'§@ €;3ER"NI§.¥"(i:': m:£:§E:c'~:ri:c"1M'i, them is I1(>v-p"O:;~::;iE)§.'Eity_.()f'-;*;Q{ vc.)i11yr. fammxzin <'thfc1:"§,{e3, ever} afi1e::r ;{kE"£<HI1iI1:'£«g ?(-:I;"1é11;rgr3," .'I§h;i?f1"t3 i;3_ j§;3m3&§§.b:§i.i.'£",y' 01*" <;:(:>rw§c%t'.i0:"1. Ii}"--v.._ﬂ1w21t. 59¢}; V"::(§ii1'T. £11 <i%xm"<::§.5~:;&';: of m\,r.is;~;%i.<):'1.<<::..1p:)wer,<:%éi:1 .301; "a..:;ai<;i€3 i'I*:*'<:-:5t;"':'.11_a-"1M1" and E¥_§.€.r§g;z:1_E (31"cis-3r1*;€e;.

2;; ff5:1":m:.:i_1":2%L1_R}<::é1*§§s_i§i§i?2_Psettitign in the ycim' 1.999 a.1:1c:i this z'x"§%;:;i'.€:.:::* E'Ti'&:i:_E%3 '§f.T1€3E:'3ffi'~. ;_:3é:%:"3'(i»if§gg §sir2c?e 1999., L<3a1_'m~.ci C3(.)'i_E..Ii1S€';'1 :\::;t;)_pa;r§:Z.:*§;3;g§ far "t.'E'},_€:' (:cmip1an'na'm. ssL1I*3mi't.i:c:<i'.1 t:.E"1at., b€:('§E1LES€ :¢'i:_§".gt:::E52;e: p};:.é;V1<:fie1';,(.éy' of this r11a1i;i;er com ;3Ia:i_n:;:1.:_1i: did :"1<.)i:. t:ake~;=. ::'.».;..__r__i2§i=}'zjfgisp§'i.é-£115 Er}. the': triai which vvz:-1..s5s p(=:'rz<:1i:'1g t.1"1(":én.. }E.:'"§"u..i:::a-=--.mé.:;€i7i'.<21" we'-ass 'pem1i1"}gg }:><:£7<:;;f<;": Vf;h.i:%:z <.:cmrfi amtl she ;\rar;,1;3_.;;mré;€i?(_§3'}g;§ zfm" 'the: order, h0'w€ve:1', the F€3E:iSOI'1E:S beyand war?' *gi<M W,"

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court