Karnataka High Court
Ashok K S Shivalingappa vs State Of Karnataka on 14 June, 2010
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
H34 TEWEE §iE€3%% CGEER"? Q? §<fi:Q§\§,»5C?A§<,é C§§Ci,§IT §E§'\£C%§ $3' Q§*§§3,R,'é'§A§ EATES "€"§-EES mg 145" my 3? Emma, zmgy---I_.{;. __j 8E?'QRE "EH5 HS§\E"E:LE MMQSTECE ;Ex:%,§;xz;:§;::éTg;::i#§_:§i?; _' "
CRIE'~'?EE\§i%L REVESEQN PETETE:Zj_f\§ gasfig. 3:59 2:':£{8 1' 5E?¥'~§EEN:
ASH@K§§<§S, $H:vAL:.§;"c:Ap;?A .
AGE, 2% vEéRs,@<:C, 'E'i.%S':€%é;E€~?:$; % R50.%<S'?"i"ESQ§'2'§;5;§'~§;5g%iféi.,§§.§';.V V ?QaBE§.ai}R§&§'f::%-i§;§éV'-§M%%£§S4'%'E\\\§;..: .. * A ?E"§:T:@§xsER {gs SR1. gs'; :§$44..§<i§#-:;:;;:AR:$£:_! ':3_\B:?G'§;;fi§§"§} $°m*:fE G? E:<f§_§z>E.\g5é3£Vm'?£%E~{:E'V.'.VV' _ REs®§é;1;:g'£':\:"?:::>' ¥*'§3"?',E"*E."S"-.._ _ yuaaggfizggEV£:_:--*?:"@§;,---«._ meg C6532? a%.,:§:..'%;;'%::§a:s:;'g~;
€:;*2;a;':a§§"§ 8E§x§C%%; @;%:,a§%:§, _ 11111 ?;£S?G§':§@§§x3"€ ,{§'€ $*ié;3:§ %:s:;2;as§A%<,$, E<é.iL§<A§:E\%E} $éf}'=§§£;§§"E} '@513~..'$av:"%¥é:§x;;':: RE\.5E§E§§2§ ?§'m':@:*a: :3 %~"E:.E§ air/3 92:: ;Q\/iz'::';'.sjfi!?~$§ Q? £333 "53 3%" agzwg 3&5; §R$§R '3}§%»S:;S§i§_& E'? ?§*€E 99$; §E§§E€:§E\é§ }i}$C:E; %§L§é%}§"f% $5 "{";§;i;.;2i?_?EE§:L ?2§G, 2§2f2iQ£3? §};§TE%f} 272;j'E{é,f2$€3§; T?€E§ §R§§'*iE§"é§L ?;E'JES§§§\§ §3E"?ETE§§'a§ C$§'5%iT'»3G SE} 38% A§E'¥':ESSEi3§\§ ?§~§E§ §;i"aY§, THE CQGRT EASE T%fi_§ FGLi_C3L'ifE§':EG:
GR§ER Cemségiafi acwged is $5: re\.;is:e:':.:aga.§::siT_j:;:é§é*:ééni§f' gym, 262/238? gags zzgmgzgsg s;?:t4.;:E-;;i%§_T:"~:'J':e :55 W:
§€S$§S%"%$ Ezgégég Beigaumg CQ§}§:§V§#E'?7:§VA:§":'71'£}(§§§éV.j;f§§';~}.{T§%€:E"§§~-Lfiv 21;'1ig'2G@? an ac, fie. 3,.:;:;:;'29;:}-?----VVn§'{r__z--.é;':~:.e_ fife"'e5..):..s?§.a£, Sankesmigayg :':emzi:%:€d mraishabie 2:263?' Seciésrzg am :8?
9f Mater veh:g§%e's<'"%'%£§§;L}AL.:;i_ ': 1,;
2, %€§_aT%§[»L'._--v:§3é'.V;a;::§§§§_a:1_':5': CQSSESQE a:2::§ learned zi':$2f§:"§'::':*ze;%/2% %§fe:~3fie;<._ V geéé%£E._§___.s*>? iéxig Q€§:%'i%8?'! is time mag §:;?'§§§§C hagiéfiiéée-3.-.a?@a2§:§ fi;§§G£§vE $52 §"L£%~=iL.2i8S? am PM %\§§}2=f%3'.§§é'*;?é§v%%2§f'f§"§'i§ §:'ié?%€a cg? i:>%3§"§§2;§ fifigg $239; §'é§%°§~§%'§w aiiagégéégs §:*%2:e;*: $3: E329 §ei%%;i@:*:§:' fmm ?i:§§§'E3§Ei§f' é:éL:a:%r%§é..éBa§Laam: EE: %3 aiémeafi fiaizzg iaréama §:;'e:"E; _ % _ _ W 3 3 *%____"':;?%:'3:£§*:{:':a§: 3'? §%*a€LLgxm% Efihaba sasfferefi imgames £59 fig 5,;
égrwsgt 3? C€}§§§§§@i"E with the \s%h%£§€; £8?'%S%Q§i€§'3§{ ta wééiéh he mg? %:is fife. ?h$ gyogegastien 35? égned ma agggilaszi. ragh arzé neg£%ger*:€: a;imi%n§ argé éf<::r Causing €§_;<3§é'§?%2-«'.,'_*::r;_;%_5 megiégence Ljnéer the wexzésierzg gf $€§€L'{§O§"§S sf EEC" ané Sec. :33; am :8? 3% §v'§<>?:<i:,§' er: the Eegtémeny <3? :3 w%inessesT';5@_é 1:{'<fV_s>f%:!;:'r:a>.:%fi '::;5 £3, Th$ acauged .---2:é;f%:e:2',.V-3a;--r:?3§2*:*%{3°:2_ed fi5?e:"s§e¢:$ ihe marge giéadérég émsceaggi Hi:'::'\3'E:S::}i(%'i:_f§€:-.%'a'§§éE;. S, "§%se_ _ _é:gj fi §%=§'*"'%cCepted ihe graseczsiéaz: 3% %e\.:e!§ed agains:
'ma as:§:t:,:s€:a%i seaiencs ag Sees':
fyern mg é§*s€§:;;i§ €§efi' {$38 ':s'éa§ Céééffi. Assatimg wizich 31$: was $1}: V-'{'::§VL§V\""fi;'V-§\'éG..a 262522383, big: the §aam%é :a_p§%§§E5aii':a* 3i:'%.j:§;%é*~f§:;r2mfi nag zfgzssm :_2a,;:'{%: ihe graamég if? 2319 a;:2§::¢3a§;'_ :z~:a§ 5 §§f§§L§F'%$2 iiagaérfii mag: 33% V ".§%._:é§mé'a:€:s ,_ijié -?:'§"é:r': zezsigiazm Eéze éegmeé aésaageé fa}? ;§%:§%%§;ee:* %?2?§£3§§ ___.f§":;:'%3%é§: aver: §§"'§§L§§§'% gaiéiigmey k aacagseié mg 5:3': fiiggateé $333 iagama Régeri ééed ciéfisaqaserzfi ii: é:'2;§:::*ées sufferaé is: {fie meitsr aiehéagés &§;£%de§':'{ as egiabéigheé prsseautéen thmugh §':'E€d§C§§ exgééenceg $3: ihe §_§:'t§'§:%«?:§VV:2<.é;_E5 was :15): ¥'€S§3§fiS§b§€ few saich aisiéeatg He $;:bm§.t§_:'c%§a1t--.?:?:e wimesseg 3:2 ::*~.zhGs% iestémegzy the §r::2Se::.:§%:§.n"'--:§'§i.§;d-. ie:::z;:é§ f net have 383?': éthe §C£ifiE{3'3C a:'2é,T"{ii_:_e:: x:'e>:s§'er2 \r»sa$= 1<::;é!§' ti: ' faégeiy énaici ihe fieizitiamezz 1?: E": €935 regaré ';§r?s;3%§ainsrzi ~Si.::°es§3 %v%ar;;th§_.V§;<=%§§:§% Sgsgégser sf La><:m§ Shaba zmfier V\g=:@ ::§<ér:g, H5 3253 §<:<:i§%§§ 3 In w%i%c%: ése a%§6§€é %t§é.'§aa@r"'rw33 'a*&s1'?én;s!§*§t:2,i éT'[.__is: we aii£§fi%§"¥i mi: we §€5£§§§Q§§E§' haéfigrsggsgééi é:_;%'§.¥~§m his ::ass~§xsm%r:at§§§: £22 .-';:~<;§u§§ Séé5%§v..__?i3€ &€CE{§§€€%f. :5: this yegam ihg §é:EAE§%'°i'?§€ {§v.§£;i$§;'E§'§.§€.;E--3T géiiiésner fifaifxfifi my giieniéerz {:3 %he éggéggéiéi 32 é:§ j;;}%§:'<:€ Q'? siaagwegica E: gimws égxmi Bhaéa ?,§f%3Z'?§'"i§"1§ is is'; 3:9 Sagfiméia :m 52% fémmegg VV"'V.___";3::t%:s;%i;z was QXSEQEQQ 3% '$33: aariésf izam" E5: :?'":e §'E"'E§§'¥"%§¥"%§ Q11 anii there ES fif} €'J§§€?EC%3 Ea shew éhaé: W51 gajyéséz §v'§§:z:i:%§ 861523; égwner G5 Lgxmi Shem hag' fZQm§"f¥€?"i{ZEé baxsigééfigf. Thergfege, his exzifiegzce 6933 mi mfuse £as:zfié;€;§i'::ef,j_~:<;§5;, ' acéegi 313 has seen the acsééerszg
8. "me S€€ZQ;'"§§ c%rgumsianceéii'.?°sé¥;§.A§é§';'§%zié:f§, éiy Eaamed C®iifiS€§ $3 $3 '£373 a:c§§§rzt._$e::_:u:'*ré:i._$2???
eihe: emgieyeeg zsshe are_géted.V-"§:rg'L_"%f§"::>:»__§:'@§é<;'zs.t%@%: as wétnesgeg, zagazgig? mi: have a7%§:7;:ra;é5{i.§'%:»:e a{§i :E;:§é -is §®a "§§'2€ ¥;'E§"'E§C§€ waasid §':a2.{e- {b:3§;': ;§d:e:;'a'§%;.:ed3 %;3';::i%éer rgéers ics §i'OS€CLiiI§€}§": §a@'ér %g;._:r§'52-§'%;VEf2.'3-§}§__é$\:'s Vti$_a:._':§1_a:.agh the acciéem':
£3 aéiegeé .Vvta':"vTv?:,a}§5::> £§:.i§f::if'§*i>{§'*--.§f3 ':%"iVV;-';}"%i,2§§? vehisée W33 ssézeé an :E.{§3:3SE2333?;~,.T§'}é"'--if::§§1':§.2§fi§?:§§"§i':€S B{}%2"i'§:E{§ 91.3% $3 §'--J§§'§ if it %s %h:é*«r_: a3e :35 ?'ié': ram téke mtszsgseg Ceuié mi'; V..~§";V3§;§ $;r~_:2é.~§'~:": §?%:sé:';' «é._a_§E;Ey; ha amagié szgbméi gegecgziian %é'a.;<;' §?é§'%;»es*1:_§§;;§%fhé:,i_ iésai me §€§§§{}:"§€":'§' wag $76 dféiffif' 3? faéwa §f§é';éé§:{§ %;f_é§é%%;.*§§ 352$ age ia Sis 3C? cs? szggéigezésg §C£§fi%§"'s'E :1,-..=i<i:;._r:'€§g R&?€§"2'§€:§ is ezsééerace :3? ?:F¥8--La%<§h:é:a§2a t §E:*:&*;,:f:§*:':&§§i":sa %;§§§§ am ?':2';i:$»5:§?§%<a::f%': Razzajgé §:::"§&3:i, E35 <5 mints 93?; ia §F3C§§":§ESi*:'EfE£'; wiih E523 exsiégnsa G? ?'v'VE~ Si§f'§$h §\%ami:?:% Eeymé. PiE§9~§<e$5:§afi:':a Géddgggsa 8en:'*:': :.E"§ aiga an €i'T*%§§O'3!€€ :3?' SW}, "E%2e:"efe3§'€, 3%: 25:3 ésicefi by the §§"QSeC:駧C%f% €§§§§'E'§S to be €m§§§y_9.§%,§4_:'Q§'§?3;§'f;, T Ga thég basis §':e SE,ibfl'1%iS rm: itmsfe :%_.3 é;2@'._ énarimifiatiyzg maizériai €Vi§€§1CEéC% _§¥'Ed§C§; §€Ci,§fS€§§§'; Eufi tiie ma? £925: has a;§':ju$i%f%ab§$; :e%*:a,:i{'i'§:g5:% E_1irr:."'-hféT'%ihé§*{3§e:e; $€€i<s acgzgéttgie E3, 9e?' §{)§f%"'§_§ iffée Eéséar::4é'::§.f--%:';e:;ie~::§m&:'2': @8569:
has Si£§:r§)C:E"'C€€§g' §"%'é;f:;««..e;1<::vs*r;;%_§_c%é::é_a___é'§ii":-é ;:%§i:%f:§»afier' 115, gétii 33:' {ha @a:%ii@:*:er"s gaignsaé W:?;,_¥% F5u%'z§_3V%:--«.'§«Ea§:::_i§é§'Semi fig C%§€d 52 3% S%"§§293§" :2? ?.§'%;;=-'3, 24;.-::;::::'2% 31%:-:§§a""zs*¢%2§'1e ?¥*§1§'-Sr%%<5:2¥:%z Rafi}; $:sr§.:3:é ,aéjg;..?'*;'15%¥" ':<§é":§a:*2r':a Géddagga 83% me $53 emQ§@'ge%s5 3 ":3 .¥j'-.;{~':%a%%:§ éaggma Pugari is gags 3%:{:::rm 33 _e;":":§Eé';:e§:,.__'7e§f'éwz "§i*§@ ggééence Q'? Wzéig § $33 3% warsuéé éézay ?%€§§'é éiszgé mice aéézti 23%;: §®§§<§fi iés _' T{f§§f%::§;§;3":: zsasifage géamé wégg %§"¥"E3§"%§i§£ "€%:e§,2 aéiegefi éhai .."':g-iv:*?:§m was SC§'8a%"?"':%§é ¢ Q33 amine ézig S' %:%'29« §"%€:':€§"hffi§ J :5' is 'me g>%a<::§ 8%' 3§<::,2:':"e:':ce am §ea.as3{j he haé gzfieraé %§'§};i§%'"§€S¢ Tfiis azxssuéé Shaw iééai they had :39: 33%;"; ;s2%:._a éi, %r3§:§§§:'e§ Efifiiéf is h§armg SGEESEG;
12,, W'as'i-Sa:;'e$h §'='?a:'L::E"i% Be{1;"§%'" »§-sf':%?_'é {"..£"'GSS~€><3§'£"ii!'E3'{iG§': aémétg he mg né§'.Vsé.éf: 32$-_gf<:<:§§..e::i:L;;*._. Theaggh aiher :='*--J§§:?'§€SS€S Ciaim i<3..__&'zs_:/e §e9;_::'%§:é.:a?§C§'€§e:'%£ 'iheir eviéence reéating 'EG;.§C§ii3v.3~"§i.;fiE'€'§éF3§: is §:':'~x;iarv§'§:anC€g Sn ma"t:e:§a% §§f"£§€¥._J§§¥"S €§'2"s'§r'e"i:siL..V§?§' £§§*é?£:»%i:@'z<aiiG:':. Tiaeér preggnce '€§'E€§'€f§§'§.!..:§§.gjG%,%?§A§fi:»§',' ; :39 E313:..§f€§3§':GS' '%§%'§§§§ %';%i§§Z}'§§ ?:g:§ ganchanama anfi sketch cf pi_é5<':'é._-- _Q§e_ ::;<;::'s;;:ij_:*e€:<_:é is cerzwmeéf the Emsestéggti:"2é;;;.,V_€}§?fé::é:._$233 ::9é:«:;{J7:¢§}eé Laxmi Qaaba £3 2% ft away "s:_ih§.V;;-%.§C:e"'e§ V'r;a:Fa:s*renr;a§ écciéfini ég saéé is ._%*za'{é;e:%_éé:{:u:§9%§:rjVV" the sgaég Tins digiance fiaimreaa tam 3§s:;:%:§«.é;~: §::.;%a?, '§§%.§;%"5§:é %:%§€§e§®§;;€3; %3?'§§%S§ it ig giiewrs $335: V §§'%€%"€ 2&5 :;:;'§i§%¢~§er:i Eighét am as §§Si§"%.iC'€".§é§§3 $3 the axigésn it ....j/' §§.§§§§::u%§'~€;%::: baiigézsa am: 32% ;:::%:'§@§2a :a:?:® aasare %:2 {ha swig have §a'?E§E'% éhe §c£u:*:'a§z§e; 3%: megs: f:,:§':%':e{' $9 : ;§3ii-s::Veé igééai aggiééaé: is §:*;s:a;§":'e§ ai :»§z{§f}zé£v§ am :?*~§a:%::ma§ ééégh way, "':"§";€ grasegutésn hag mi ghswzz ihera wag am: mdésiriars csessmg or gagmigsibééééag sf geéesmasa Cr§g:._;§€g flee mad, 3%, Eu ems? is; deséde whei§;:3?"::f€e§::%_4er_§4é'"é*;é%;eVEv€i§:§ Ea act 3% f3€§!§§E§ECE:':' &%I aéigndmg 2::*r::%L;:.msi:_aA'n:€s'*¥'f:sa;§ :0' taken %:*:i:;:: :::ans§<;i€:*arié::;:2E "'§"he ?'£':§é'2€§i"Ei :C%?f_C§}$7EffES"iT,§f?§jVé§"'a §"€ $23 §§§::e G? G€Ci,E§"F'€f'*§C€§ fame a.§'"w.T _%':"!'%"-a_C<:§éé%é':-eaiuWed, iraffiz afié mavemgaé: @:; %'%?_§'e? 8§(§€C§%§;
Asmézteégy the Véa§a':V%§:%§§2a£ High Way;
Theyefsre, usgeé 3% expeaied ta §>x:§€s:§ Q?' §f€S€f?C€ sf %:2§%:z§$'z2a§'$_7 ég': Siiéh an avemtuaéééy %:§3%§3 it may 'g;*§.3;§-r§%:~:;e i.%j:é'?5.<E7'?ti@:'g§§%e §"é%§§§§§%"'%C$ Ea": C§a:E§ fan: '"~§:jut i%:':'«:.£s}§:§:'§:: a far ggrieags affgmaa éika §&C':i§:'% "3{:n4.~';x-Vqf"E.?'C;:V"$s§%§é_ea:€ magi: §S'i3§§iS§'§ izigabie aegéigaaga '"§%2éé:%'%;j$§:A::~,f?i'j;*ai:.?§g: egtgbéigfi tééai aegfigsnge wag gf h%§;§*:e:* €i_egs'€e §:"§§3_;r2<>: 5:'::§$?:*:a$§e §'E€§§%€§§:'"E£T:$; 3:3 'E:§':%s vim; 32%;'; iZ§'§®L%§?% wéifzeggeg éaxzg . _"t::-2:52-i:§é; ii wag agisgagzgeizt ii; §'E§§§%§%3§'EC€ 3? the §€'§Z§§§§?§€§é", xi?
they are net 5:§%£ifi£, Evsn if we %€{Z€§i: §F'GSECi§§iZ§®§'% €§;':§§ that ihe v§r:t%2':': éigé gage is émgaai 3:' 33:8 :;eh§:%e?.._ §9._V qmstign érivesé 33}: 'give geiitiener zmiess ii is sh$%3'fé''%'%'.,§~s..§é ;. ' fiase 50 $3233: negiégefice and rgikéessaess i_::~V-~i%{5€$'~,Vd:'ré.§!i;fs§ anfi Egwminafui sf ?;?E€ safety 3% :*Ga€E__ ass&.r3;,;} he "{:,;a¥'m*:'{;Vfj=--L%gEu:,1Tf vigitsé with the fémfiirzg <32' gsjiitg :6' £351' sai§3fying--...as '::';"'--v{;jE'*:etti'§'s.;e§ i§éé"-Aasééence §§':€::;§§ai$$ iize §€i§§%Ci§EEE" Q? Viaéhi':¥*::~3.:€:E9's§:f§é:§.§».§ kgeééed agains: him beyeng reasx;%§§a:.;Sie§:Afie'§:'5f§: §4"%€¢;--x;e'rs:-éfigzaiseé the evééeaae; E a:?r%"'S;%:;*:fié"§7-i"e:?é:;?_ {E131-..g;?:'c§:*s駧fe§:r:y in the iestimaszgz £2? ?i£v'§.f Z "e;?3§--._§?'j;,3;'%'€§1§:.; 1-Q"'%f:§:< §,3é'€'%:""§§3€§§i';i §g;n,<3f§r;i $32 the §eame{*é iéiai '3L§§V§€3vV§:§.§§SQ §3;733$ ieameé Segsésns Liuégé. The evidesécéé*§ve3%s~?:zi:'<} s'x§€~'?§;S§Q?3Ss Pizfifi mg ééméiteééy in "'a_sf": 2,::f'::5e5'::yt;:,;§;{a:';<:V_a§ té%::<~..§.....E§ea: $78 has mi: ages: ihe agmaé é;3g'Qi:.;:%';%é:,7:";A:::_*"e4Q" "?§3§7u-§%2 ?'%§'af?; 8 mad § say i§"i§';,? saw agaééenég §u%; %i§92e%r 2«*%%Sj_§::;:': £3 flééfereaié Er: ifiig view ?"§i'aSQ§€a§§e;§ _ é§.§u§% %$..g"s:;=f:€:"ai§£§ ihg §}€§E€§%'i 3:? w%:§s:%°: S§"§0:§§{§ Q5} $3 the _ :.:&:£€:*='i;%,:?:%§;**;~~i:*>;: E am %:%';§§&f:3:*e, ggiggfiesé '@232 331% zomzéctiam Q?" .__ %:,'%:€§3€:%':§{me:' fa? '{:"2§ ef2'&§é<:e gaénigéeaéie gage? §e::%:i<;m 2?% aséé 3@é«~% <3? §§C $3 éafiaii 9;? iagaffécéeni maieréai gm réqgzéyeg §_f'&'i3¥'§€i"€?"!CEg 1?, The Csrzvigiian fgr 'zhe effeme §:.;n§sha'fb §§uT:§€§Lé%M' V' Sectéan 13% ané 18? af the Evéetsr 'gfiéfiécié A~%fi€ fa'§§;§"m§;ii egiabiéshefi by the grssesutign 1%, En 'abs regain the §3iéi:é:;:i'<;%"3VV %s"'f.:ii--§§.é%s::':eé.VVf§ The imsugfieé 3i§§§fT'%€§"§i cf i§sAé §;-riai7_VA£<:g-:35%"dgfiéati _Z2.§_L2GG? én CC Nséfifi/28$? a:Q_m:i§t§:2.§...:_%':--e p 8:i:§'€§C'1.'§":§;?":§§§}-E';'E§'§€ gffence gurzighaéée sjsééééf a:_%駧_V sf 15921 38% 33$. 353% Exit; afe set asééeg ' L C§:fiS€C§{§E{_§§:§'{;_%ZA§'i;€3."V3.i_}?§«gfi'i«$?'i'-___fi'?_ afggsal, 'fie getiiisaer is abgaéxxefi G9? 33% me is:i':g%j§:%_é"é§%;:'é'i§e§ agaéagi him; $35 wads §><e£:;';aj»:§";'::;,2 392;???'-»aV§éi:§"s::v?a§::;€; am Q§"§€E'€§ :3 E3 sanceiiesi ,V;§"%%:s:ia.'5":":%z:>%I:L:rf2's::_ E§__a;ny; fiwagéted mi mm ig :::s:'éa2"§§ 5:3 $3 réfig V '*§"§&%°'%°%,¢<%%m 3 "x;-§:; '-