Karnataka High Court
Anil Reddy S/O Narasareddy vs The State Of Karnataka on 7 January, 2011
Author: H.S.Kempanna
Bench: H.S.Kempanna
€:§;:;:,§3;%§a:s:;:;%.,4 ' ' ~ ..
{E-'°<z_" 553%;-.§;i:[:;:9g'
' i--§<":e:*a§'%I% ,
" « . " "§"=«::;
5% "§'E§E":;- E-EEQEFE §§' §i§%.§3 $*§f%_'E3.%§i:'/E
%'§;EE§§fU§'§' Eifiifif {§'§LE§E%2%,E§.€f%.§§
»§,5%§'=%
§%EE§**'{}§5?;E';
*:*§~§:: §§£{}§5«3§£§§.¢-E: figégiifi{:%=:'§:;:§'%Ef§:f%.:b€'§%§ 'V
$Z§§:.gé§Ef§'§'§§@;fi§V.Ei~%§$_g§5;§é§%'€13?' géfgafgig "
£§;Ea:§E'§'E5§?E$§§' g? fig;
3%; @§§§g9?§§€@.,@%§»§ 392% V
§§;mLW.W,W h?VEE3:"3
.;::.:%~.:r::a §2.§.2::}z;x§=*;§'v,»*.s;:; 7'
gs;
€{}?afi'E«?;z%C'E'€3'§7£; ' §;:x:':" " .
2-§<::;'%a;;";:§§E§2:;A;T.:z:fg, ;m::::* aigaggs
.P§¥:'ZI§'?§€I}E*%§ZR
.
$333 2- V , §g§;*:::§}§j;. A S???
n. E€§:'}:"Z~§3§"§%.E"'-%'¥f,%E_iE'»é"§' .. 2 33%} E355"?-iii} 'Eff' $53??? - 7' {Z '§§r';'::" '?'§'§§5L ,.?":§;}'°J§}iT75m 7 " _ '"f§';§€§§ "§3}§§'§'§'§'E{}§€E§§?; .§§5'§1{;'?:'§P€{§ E'?--§f'{"§i" '§"§*fi€'_°?% ' =;--.:"?*-S2' Eiifii '§}§§',V°:é§~;§§§§§:3 'Iff{}9 {%"§%§§f%§§'§' 'PEEK §5--??LL}§_2?.:":§é '":m §3,fLE'5,, . _ 3:2; 52:5»: §::-§)T<.2'(.:1'k K} $:§"§'L'a'.§."§{}E'§ E?'~§ {Z'§%1§f2«'§'%3 Mi}. ?'=f};"2{T%E.{}, '%f:FE'~§§{?§*§ E53; §~?iE*§{}E§'§§'"Li"§%ZE4iE._E_:} E9-"€§',}'i§¥?§. 'ET*§~*§)§3 {}E¥"§'E§§'sE£f%ZEE §'3';'§.'J'g' ;'§{}3§~~E3 E'{;'"*éf Siiil 34 {T3-E7 3%'-7C. "
CRE;w?E?1E';@y§E%%:§fE%§,{% E%§;3ffiE?E<E§Zl'X7 SE-§{}§3E*§EE 253%} :'73E%§a.&'a-SE-1* E?;§§E3%Ef§":? "
AGE: 2% ""f§Z§a.RS; {F382 E".i{}E,§rE£E3E€{§_§.E} Rfié %»"§§,g-§,;:{.§Ei E:i®E§\§EE§E.§€:§ TQ 5? E3337': ':8§B;%§?<:
532:" :'»_~;:r~:: 3 *2: §?'z1'fE;éE€:SEEs%'§'§§g fafii/'";'§, 3333:;
'mg: E%'§1i¥.§f§£ ::>§<"* :r§g§;:azA§";a§%:;::
R58?' ABEL. 33-"? {:1§a;€:;m* §§::1%:_:«:;~:_ 'V Géfigfifafififa ' -
~ {ray SR: 53;;-m3V;a;;:%a;'E;§TT;*~;;::g>;%z%;«:3; azazg .1:-{£35232 '§f'£~§%§E§:» a*:.:aj«:';a;~_:é;__;,$ ~ _%;:>;8 £3? {:R§a:.r: B 9 ":*§~i§::
}'aE;?%fQ{7E%TEi * «T2'%'f€_7Zs'R 33%: "§?Ef§E'EEi}Ef€'EZE§4 §3§,;m§»:a- w1"§»aa;:* E*£{3?%'£§L5E: _§;=mf;£ 'PLE;.§';S;i?:§} E23 §:_?£:;g§§;:§: mg:
P§"ff§'T§EG3f'£TEZE€;- @:i«;' 'S§§I%'._{ :23 §§~:'a;;§:{1a::é* me' EEES ;a:9g2;E§*2* ER? €§€§EéTZ?:"I;
:a3<3:!?::sgga3é;'a: ¥'i§¢Q,E*°=i{}'a2'€1%Ef"'E.§ £32? ?e;':%E;.E€E $*§:;ra'§i,@;%: , :3 'V '§'VE*:'§;':§:;=%_ <%z}mi§2g fits: ."§%f:=_?:° zérfiiefg 3:25;; "ihi:
'§'§"::é: ?::s§:§:§§;ie;;}§;%::§5; 3:3; "§;.§':z=§3s:: ':zs;*;°é,3ii:;§Za:s=m::§ 632%: . E ,. 2:9 . ' :3§§%:":v*%:?:iié::~"ér~J§_:§$:. v if_;::§:m3: ?%§<'>,§'§,§2{EE€§ {:5 J2;:;1a's.r:>'21::E§: ?€,}§i;a;:a:: $§2:§é§a'1q wiziaéia 9:": <:@m§;:Ea:%.%;:3:'2 {>5 §Zmré3§%:§g;%;;ai,é;z}:é ':?r:2;;::s:""'-éiégézzi §r?;tS@;if:°é.§§r §*§:€%§$%;a::"€::; gas»; {§££'%§a,§:':{':§'§ 2%E{}..{:é--=: ' &§%«§E"€:«»E§ S9223: Eiziiégg :"€g:is;i€§"@§.f<;::'»..<}%§'§%:%::;<::':é';%ufi'§;3§f:aE§E.§ "%;?§§E§g€E:E"' §fL'{ifi€}§E*'~§§§%§~§£§§ uaéer ffiafiifian LE 3:? .§{§17%§;3%g§,,? §3;':;_;f%:~§.?}§§%a:::";; .&€:?,_E; EZ%%§?ViE.-.,f;%;':":' :ér§;":§,a':§';: ' figé E6;:_:E'%@:E{:'g.?:Es;(é4§Ej:_'§;'t %:':;'«:a;":;.~::V £33? fp§'*'a:é}%c::E§,:3§3 ihaig figs» aiifiaééaaaaf Eéianj " ,a £3939 §%.»2 ES ihs Eziigfiézazé" G? 5%» Ea-3 3% £4', am}. fémié» £52 @1333 'wiiie if}? E53, '='Q§?€E"§ .:'~;;5%;fl%\A'53;;-i:3i§:%'é;:%.;(4ggjj éiha fi€€f€&S%3¢§ E9 aézé ::'2§§,t%.";%:,:&T§E§' zméé ;;::E3}?S§a::aE§}f 52:; gmmfad 4":
' ~'..::§';£::if:_':,;a:1§:--§ V €§€,}iEf}.f§?', 9 W 'WG 3' F xi ' ma km 3";
5W\W* M?
i:';"'' {WW #3?
\<~.J my 90- A8»-
5'""°<"""
'"'i #32 aw') $73.3 2' M9..-
g) C?' ?"*Q ma Tm?
kmm » 'M \ M :
$4?
(:3 fzsmui '» n W:
?'\N fig;
Y E K '»»m we 'wt Xvusi fiéfi T .. J , ,, ., , :'§i§::vf§: '§;%f::;§: 3;:
a;"2€:§. 3?; 2';;3{>:2 am 3339: sézéééi 5&5; z'3':~§ 2':aa:i' 33%;": is}
-.*£=:5£:§m3 aggzzrzgr 32:8 Taargfis: {}"£E*1:€E° aitczzsafiaé "j'§é§,.;'3:Z§mi§:'_ £32 '£33 g'%,~z«'i§ %%:a:""%;i>':e§ $::'§§€{%%:§';:2g§ 'aha ;"3.€s:'%€ia$€§i * E":&r§,§s§::€:n: Tfiaégggj ':}_z::é5a;5'z§,ii:E<i .%?'i';;1& u 1 fifififiafififi sxpréiggsé ihafi; $336 é§r<é'::;E§L__§i%5; :s:§:«:jE§ fuf"'¥;:5:"a§2€€: air" ::Ez::~i:* £:{';:':3:-:--;';{§f:'V~.Vzizziszéiigézzg;_§t{;2E{§'~Eé€'r @233 iii?"
she wimié figém ,---an »:>é§.";.-e32*--..§:§§.::fi3 i§2ej§"v,'=@::§Ed fiiéifiéh Ear? Sa gajgéiagég ihegi f%'§s;::f'L?f:f:::;%:--.EE§.& yiai £3? $316 hfiiéfifi fig '§'£€i'_ E::§é§@a:3:"§;é. a_:»::as§s Céiaéid $336 fit:-*3a::ea,s€é$ £§Z2a."'3 Zfiérfiiggééé: :§I:----§"{3:§;§é,':__a:<'§s:§i~.?;§€£_ :'2€<":§»; :3?' séézfiézagafi;
fiféé aivésffiéfigzéiégwg ::;«::;§§;s:« 'éhéi '§%::§'@%§E§::g 'éh@E€&3;€;e::
Efigafg '§{:g.:3;;é.g€d§ firm €:%3§7§:E3.Z_§ fags. €52: maéis ii:
aggsagr it ii»; aV'§;:;i%;?;%§{: é::;§z"§ 33;; ifizaé .8;§§€EE"§j3§ éfiihszté E'}{E@:':.f' éfééé T fag"; 5:3, Eha fEa'}{;;i* E':§':@§g haézaézzéi iihéé Eégféfg émfi 8§§«€:"3{§: 2i'%J%»'"&.}.? §:é;"{;;,s: 3.31%: ii":
A " 3 {§:{E1,EiEE~i%€5§. &§§§}%3£§.'E"1§§E;_'§ fag" ifigzia " 4. «V , H, « ~.«,.'*i ~,.~ 9* é ,~.-£r 2; < ~€':« ' » ~ «:-- 4» ,-~ " ("in '*9'?
:3m::}a§::E.,E,%=:s§; 23.33;? §'»:;,§2a;:: 5:, §§'i§:%,a, fiat-;é:;;; in *3 ~ , ':2 %'»'--? 3 W} A /k W93; .7.
E':-rfizészzi éiifzafi, éifizésr §}f§f%3§E€E&?§% gaiéziggaé. agaiziat '::'f:':$E=:.é:: '£;z§a:'; §:;w::'§§;i%:§§§:,%e.:*$ zssha ésggz égwé and §y~§i- 2:3 fézaé, ésammiéfieté flfaaca azzéif $€€§§"§EE ~ £3? azzzd: ififffiééfifi %_'§_'EE%:'§€§° Eacéigiz. 4% fif 1% £533? §§;%@§h ';§'E2§:;= €'£";§,§,§"'€;f §':3:;":'é,a'3:r°§§:E %33'z:'1 T§§":&V%i Aw} zfiid .§%~»£§i 'é.;%J$:"€ EH} Ezfggiiffifiif ;§§é.::%3;_::° i.-:rh¥:1::"
Ehis aéiéégafia mafia? "majgég ,:~':'z:.rji'~-éfiizafg §$*f§b'§""§;§;'§f3€£E fmm é.>a?§:3.E; hag hwy: r€fle*;€::é:%:iSi §:"€§§$jé2"f_"§"»1§3E £E§ '£33; '£13 §:s:£::i€:s3:, "'E'1f;&§fi§%:§& séiriagéé»:-._ Egg; ;:3{,;;;& §§"_--.._m'a£;§<:' aggagimgé; iighaga §a%;§fi:i@:':er§;;§a§»:*-.§h&3'..g::§§%§;-€355"z;::§%f§* :?.=;:":~€:%;.§§sm 3&2 §?€.'f";; $25: §a'e:*iS --A::s;§:.;d 'éf?=:;:g"'s::izi';:";%r7;é>:£;::/3;::=$§s"'fiézfiys E3 2% 'i"fi§£§:f}§2£ Ea §§{':§fi§f?1$' 5£§2$:§E"; ;"@§_'2:é%;:=Sf€;; V . 3 %:}%%f;A ::2"§:L§::a§a;f E::a:'2;§:E_§ 'i:'§::.€ IE2:3:gam::a=::."i é3."%3§§1§,'§ie€3d: E;E:.a*§:; iibfimzgh Eézeffi iziaésfiaé gig __:2::{éa3:°é :5; ::a?:m2;az i;[¥::;3z§, §j?§f§f§§1f§€%'EE€§§°§ at jg2:z"{:é.=;:>::;": ?,Z§§'§§fi?: §f§"§.§"i E2213; §1"2§.$iiz:":%f ., $E.;é;:§:_ gag €,§"§aEE§"'€3 §}%'€,§§i;§.£Té'i'§.i':§"E§ :a£::m;;; wéih €f}"§1§7":€3E" §,E?--f{§r é me.:?:€8iE§f zméi §§':;}£§%§{f&E§é' am §:E1§?: grmiizé {sf a;'*§$;:mja:1§: €25 {i%%;2?§: iiirzfiy age i'§€3'5{ <~:m':E§%:E<":§ 31:2» bi? :%3§é3a_Ee€:a:£ 3;:
"E'§:é: {;f§€'z2;:":ea 21%; aaééiéggaaé. E"3":§'3%'§."€3' *-2 sgzgggaizizaé '§§1€ESf3 §&3:€.i?;::§{2§:e:=:"5§a §:%§:}:f° Siilfimiééiefi. £3 83% 2,::1{§<--::" ;i%}s::::f:fe:,;;@'?: :1:?"s;>::'%€é,x i§»i§:':s§ 'L. E??? éifié m?;e:§é::r fiasiisséz 5; {f EERQE; ihauggh fiééfi §€§E.§s::§-:- E"§§§%§"§ Ear "éim effiaflcesg YEW 3% Q? EES and :%f€:ga.*§a§ '£3 {ha §fii§E'Z:3;G§E€E'% i.?:«"€,Ef'%": ma? :"°"s:_;:s;§:§%3:" :52? me: §€{i€3éEE:§i':€§5 3 dz: 31$? 35% ihs: :f°%:{§a,s;:.%:§?z =35 *i{}'i';:e .1 -2..
§3€§".'§j;§§§§~€??§ §<.i%:'" 3'1T§3§%3§§.iE駧3gf;§ $329233 @;i"; bag? 315 ®E"""?$§ :23: Té;%::5::§:"' N} ew»:
M4 M fa-twain.7
Q3"
W?
W {*5 \ 5?
W"
aw §~Mm-M W 3"-
csz' ' g::a,s%§§% Efésia §?::z'§§<;:%;.:i'§:
figfifig ; ':n!nM:
W;
W 'C?
§§:.%%§?é;§<§§2<%'r $13'; iirizmfirizif; §"aE{:gE?%--'i%¥_"%éE~§2{EEs; :::}:*{E%:é:'@:"E 31:":
%3X{':€3%2§§,§},§,_; a §::€;%§i:€-;a:z»:w2E '%:;:m:i§ %5;"1?i£:§r; :s3::§*r:-:€:~:; fa}: éhaé §§;'%::
€§3:::";2.:":§;Z§i::aE Ii'e§2;g§§aira€ia:': ;':T~E:"é},7i:§é;';€:'f3'§:V"._ E30 ' A '§£}§§§:é':ax,ri:':§j_"'L. C{}E1§}§fi§£};'1E.S:
3., Eiflar: 'gig;-é:.":2:m§3@;r wifig aha §}fé}8§:§:a2t:Z{3z:,»:,I;€§,':§:es:§:§$:?;, " "
sfisgjzsfi :5§:£%,;é3 hfi:";:3:a:=§3§E° LN} s}3a;}::%, »_ ~g:s;§'§13Z$e:§ 3.3 airafi ':FJ.%";_€n
7.:r€fi5;":N*::%.>;;'éa§;';.V _» 4"
3&3 §'ZZ"3aL'§_§. ?Ga§{:_§"§ C§:2m;"§.34;%Z?2:*{aj'§ éjszssmg §;§.}:€-Eifi '{;@§;:j':'s: €316 €»:i;s'2a§'§; af féegaiagg xy-
:::a:':. a3'; §:§2§{&$ £2? §§fi3,.E°§§'3;~fE 2, . " ' ~ in may %3::-:- a.:*2>;~ ff§_%:";:'i:':i;iE€{§ E10 €33: mséi 3:":
5':_§::' f;":§£é:'{':?;LE;'£f.§E"1§3;" 27; _*§;fi:5~;:'3E:;§?. E::=s3:2.:E; in 3. 5221222: if ~ ;<;:§§"%i§£ fitafi Eiéazi $13222 égzé 5'*""E*"
has éCf€Z'§§EC:EE§"§'T,§":§ §€§Ei{3£ mi: :.§:,::°;élf¢ai';:7i.§e;i€*..,§a:%§"§;2:E sséiaéiaizfi é3S§;:02r»::: s§:z§3§é3s::§. is 'aha f€:§§§2§'§gr§g1.€:=i:':§;éfi:§§i:a2v: «. E, 332$ Ségaféi 8E3ff$é?§§%? hgféx-:_e as-J§3Mi?*aa"2,V:*=;'%.;s*.;a£é3%.1z:*;é S 'E' '§:2a;§@m-- as}?
éifififeffi 3:$,%2¢?;%I.E."§;é :3? Egg? 3;:°:r'%:s§*z, agflai' raésaigés, , 1») r;s*:* % % V3 .
,2 3"
'3%%3i§"--{'j--é:.%é;€f__ V. iéa::»m.~p€§* %'i?§C§.§Zi "mg:
"§f3E°é§?&*>'fi{§:E;§i§i€33"i§:'1 €;.r~;?"aZ%ii§:;§;9;'I-s:<§%¢ ' V V fWx5'W\l§" '.
V5'.
2;
Em si~:;E:'§g§E :§5*%.E§§i3.§.?:fE?;E"' baliérg 5E;'E$ aifizzzzfiéiigfi _ §%I'§ag§;%;?,a"}a7:';s:V €i;é€:z'%3ia§i:3:* ?:?,»§3§?::s:"'£ '?£E'§€:': €::§m"'%:.
§a=:~}a27;@32:;";ifE:ér é:€33:"§;:¥§:i%;i§%E mg €i:«2;§é3&~;
5 ' aw .- " ' $5»! . ' .
§w»N ' '< ' Mi