Karnataka High Court
Mass Traders Pvt Ltd vs The Appropriate Authority Income-Tax ... on 9 June, 2009
Author: Ravi Malimath
Bench: Ravi Malimath
we *5";-2% agaa saga? G? KARNATAKA AT aA?4GA;},§RE aA':Ea THIS "ms 9?" war or RENE; 2.-fig; : "
?R7ESEN"E"
THE §-§G?*§'BLE MR.3us?zc§*:v.$c§;a.z_A%§é%$¥f§si.'"%%j~--. f1L ma HoM'3;.E%%MR.3usfi}c§; ta/3v: .f§%§%.§,'i.f%f3§§'%% wax'? AP?EAi. ix:%Q..2é%:j: <:.é"éc_r:}¥S%{?«:'?} 8ETWEEf*-§__:.. 4' 3:.-*. * "
ii. ?e%§V;.%sVss"~~"§f:*?¢:r:i«s:s§;f2*.V Wt' Ltd " W £ce::str:s.c:§o7rj;'Hausg-A, 24%" Read V'--,Kh;;~z:',' ;Be3':*;':b1»a'§* gag '$.52, 8.39.53:
§%'3{.R_aj A ?2%e*jr':r.',3é',4..?T;';:'.$.4.i.r.--~¥e2§e:' S,z'<3firjun"M 'i'»'IAIe:2c1§7r;2», aged about 43 years _; " V APPELLANT {;3;gr~ §;;*--r;t. VT%.fa:":§ %-%;'v;i'e:hzecate at i$:f§ G. i:3.a:'a:3g:an, Seniar Afiszecata} 1';-« ";*T1%7":?a-v.t~'§{§ps"cp§'§at$ Auéémrity Encame-'%"a:< ~ fiepartment '%;f"F%c=ais", Centraé Revenge Suiicééag AA Annexe, Queezfis Reaé, ?.8.f2§o$§§G§ " Sangaéere-61, yreserafiy at $"' Sfiear :5. Wing; Kendriya Sadat;
Kayamangaéa, 8angaEa§"e-%6 {:i3£ '\ \R//
2.' Aimai N Irani E Representeé fly 22$?" censtitazieé § Qeéaisfi xséfie.--_,_ Atterzrzey i"v3r,§0é2*az K Eimrii 9 Cam': <':3s'd;;eé<._ 539.243, 3 33%;; Reaé §t.2,§.§a Eembay 488 G6? , 3* Daréug N Eran:
§.e§re5e§zteé by his €oms%%€::st'€a*<é~. Atterney Gedraz K Iran; "
Kara Estate, Eséfifizég, 3 fiafiaji Raaé Bafiébay 4% 8%?
4. §.§?"3§{fs£'§ af Erzéia _ _ Remasasztefi b§r._§_f1s«. Sa-:s"e:§:"'"'=g..,_ fvéifiéstry of fi:':a§2cIeT ' Bepartment cf Rag;:e:':.;;e ._ .V flerztrai ;,'-1';}r.=.i<:vzfeta;*§ai:"'~; _ ' §'v*a§'t§'2 4_f§5§e¢jie:;, f'=;%§2éL's.{ £%;e§§f'sé i':1.§ E, *;£e::i*ra:i 1t"}.~;s'*:.a*..e's'%r3Té'2*s%a-f»;:*é~§';--.. ' §e:a§2sr'?ase':"::*;:'sc%'j_L'§;f:,? 'i".§T_?§&~ g€1.5~:§e? ismméssésrser :$f'*Er:<:<2mé* Yang, »--é<,3'::1ata§<a;, Gea and _ éieraka, 'Ca:i§i%:ra%=_Re**s.é%e:':a.;é Eaziéfiéfig "Q.ueen'?s Rsafl; Eiangafcrefli °'§"§§e Erémme Tax Gffécer "V _ "s:§a:b§":'a_ iieéatéanafi . 1f;T;¢;:z:r2~2§VV'§?i?even:.:e fiuiidiitg Q_:£§%aaT.:_';s" Raaé, $a§'%§§§G§'$*€*§ . §;§$F§?s$BE§sé1"S ifiy Sr§~;_?¥L 1.3} $&$?3a£§3a§a;, fifivecaie fer R}; S: 4%} ., V. 35; gg;. Bhagwan; Aaveca W3";
'fééis 'é'\:':"§€: égpeaé is féiefi %..§,»'S 4 9? $38 Ka§"na$a§<a E'-éégh Com: fiat graying is get aside the srfier passed in t--he writ $e§§$£§§%'§ ;?*§ss.3%2S8 & 3§2S§;'1@93 éatefi 25;'§§,?2<;E;{é[$_:'[._V "?%*;§$ asfieaé aaméfig gr: 2%? férsaé diggaezféé«'--.%E_*:.§$ 5é:§é3;; _ §§P&LAQGWQ;& 3., éeéivered the foiiowéngz-= ' L- _ fiaréag iéza §enVéer2c'»§§;__ «.
?¥%§§.£.%fs?.?sés,é323;'2G§§ ézas V§s:é'e:§*s..%f%ise<§%V. %*gq'L:e§sf?.f;§ié§ é%'s'i's €3asri' ta permiiz me prapcseri. 3?" aV:':€§--..i$?§'i fe$p0r:'§é:*2€: if; coma an yeserci as me ;3rwertg}'é:*t_T_lq:z'e5*:ff§{:V'n famfiy pramezty 332$ theér Eégéfifs..gig'AV§fi§&§§:é1e§};««.t'VL'jg}V'sa;§$§r%:; sf iée fight c§a§5'1r§:g§,_ --§:e'-'¥fif"':V'%jfi€.i_ '"i"g$'£i.£§$'€~':_§ 'fa' the Sféfififififi %§$%§€3§'§'E$ p§acedA';;e;'£%ancé-- §§.£§§§'}""f&f§'§ af €§"%§S flaw: is': &.'Sg.'A.€s§0i§f$C:£;V_§§S¥? fi ?$§fi$$fi fir': 2%" 3:353: 28%. ciaim of thé fig" mspanfieszi 55 $&E'"§€C§i.i$§"g 1"._£'é~.z§;%i:éé'§:%'::,;%%.___%;§§""é?:e fiagartmesxi. iaarfiafi zmasrései 5&3" me §§'g:se§§;.a£:§*é:*:*éq:.:$§tefi as regieai me? §fi$§iC§E§$%'?, 'fie Eearzéeé A~$3_§§:s§%..fa:' 232% a§§e£§a:2t aise submétg that we §E"$§&?'§"5«' ""._é%éa§éss¥§ in the year 3,§§3 and ma same has been vestefi \/ ~11"
$3: the appeéiant §§ beisw thé mrmai {ate 3:36 t?:e:*e;?i:z.;:fe the impugned arder was met caii fer any Enterfa:°$.;2;éé';'-%?j§g¢;%é'ae, me éearnea s§n§§$ }'a.:é§e E135 hem that ::ze%%sf'e2§s::§V;gFéei% pmperty $2": faveiés' as? the Centra-3"{§5~z!e;'§irr2e&Vz§£['V§s_ fierfeciéy ' éegai am vaiéd. Fuyther having to:"*;*§§'av.
t%':§ case cf c.e.Go:maM v. :.g;»%:m dz?.:§:%V:A._mVVS%'a%}é§a§ 'A reparied is 199 ITR 5,339 thgV%'e$f§':é5"-»S§fig§é 'jéaédgé hag éaeéé that there Es as §%éié3g'%a_[_§§':3s-L_.3§{fs§¥iL[éVh*:.3::'sf the gromréy. Fartécuiariy %:a;_s3in.§ re_?g15é:rf§ %;e i§i":'.'V-E-,%~.;:;*:éé§:=:;,=,"'.,Vé:ted fact Etéiaé: ma ésgrapréaie )i'2.;;€As9§»o':j§t'y :;?j:.§1$~._s:,.g.;'g;iffghggzreperty $9 fa%zc;az:" ii? the ia=§ntra% afiegeé mrsésasez even hag receEved"*,i;§°%&V Vé:::;a*.é'9s%'5£%e.::':Eé_.£%ie:3 afte: acceating téxa gamg ag.%<'§eV£*s':e:'~2~§"s'£ }é:2§.d§;er _w$i,:id 2:9: Eiave may grievance. VH§?'«§'".3;EV§é'jfF:;{?:;'7;&,,*.4vA."iZ~§"'T£§ firming :3? ma feameé $§§':§§é Easéga Es ~,aV飧fa;£7t%'~§*_'v_v§a%g1~@35§' 3:3é yam. Eésrtézer w§t§'% s"e§e§"&::€e {as im 3a2'3d"gm"§s>;;:é€'""§§ the §é§$'%'"é§"i"'%$ fisagri' is: fiza sage $35' " ;%§?R{§?§§#;?E A%;.§"§'%~§§§;£'?%' §;?a§§Z's §§§':§§"§"?-EER as: §m':.$z.2§§--;;a ""§P§'15EA'E., man $f'*§fi"§"%--%E§ rfigmriéé in 235 rm :33 aséfi am $2 "'"§':$ aasé S? E..§%'*€E®f'é €13? I?*%$§fi. §'%§§ fi;{'=§Q"§"?réER Ea $§"§TAB§§ :a§;§a«:%s_ _. ..
"§"?;A$E%'s§@ §5;?\E% E§'&§'\,é'ES"%'?'»'3E§'ss§'%" ?.§..T§ fiféfi §_"}"HE§£ RE?GF%."§"E% 1%: 25: E"%"'R §3{5c) the Eeanéad S§2':§f'§é*e{'f"3§}"iii§e heéd that $52 View 3? {fie Afiex Cami §e£§§%<§':§V---- ma: the Csurt shafi @333; max §n:;s...%:%;_$ r2*:faE¥t'é':;:"a*§:,'.';V;»s'%;'al§ég;:%Aa:*§£$} fif' iiéegafitgs wfiiée e>:e§c§s§:%g §@=}:§e%:'_'§;::?$§e%"~§s'§"€j§§t§éé 22'? 9%' ma Cofistétutécm 2%€?:_e§%'*a=;..§s :%é:3~ éiiie-£;_ai'§§§%:é:%~$$%E--§n§ 9-§. the gregefiy. ?'%:e:"efs>_?e, t§:e__j§9':§%::'§ %:";«g:v_ sf $2-.'§_:§ ;e§;f;5;eé Emgée Sasége that raw %s:tes*§e€'€§'i¢;e'é._%Ls;_;;§§E€:é - if} the émmigiéecé order §$ perfestiy Egg-s;s.§:..jj*75§':'é._~<,;§aé'§§;_. :'E';%3"é%ef$ra the wréi petéiioré %2g;1s3._.:vr§g駀:'E%ig.' 5689.1. _§¥s;:~;:$§%;e.ts le;*f$"';ee5':f'*%§ doeg :39: 53% fer any :§1z§%e--:"fes'.é?%V:$?-..j:§L'§":.[»f§%2.§_§"'a;sfiaa§ in exestéae sf asgeééaté QQWEE' a'r:g§_f4 ;égzfézg2€"ti'§i's.; _.'LVwe am is yespeaéfué aggeameat th,af?§ 'vEL@w ta§'%e'z*2.;§ VV§§zAvt?%e ieameé Smgia Easége "mat the § A acsarééngw it Es éisméssefi.
Sd/-
JUDGE Sd/-
JUDGE Rsi<;'ci<: