Karnataka High Court
M/S Vivek Enterprises vs The State Of Karnataka on 2 February, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
{B33 3 :~w;§:;a gas: 3%-%.Li%»£§ P;i'J%"EL .m:<:£;a?a$;
. "mfg ;§:".::?£ Q? §<.AR%'s%A'€§i=§A
TEE EEE=G1§ C='.f}'J§."§ £32? 52:." g"~i_'§'~Z§;"§'.~'1..'e§.i%€':. XE &:1.:é<3s!.¥;€}§?<E 2:2 }3n"§2'£52€}€§'£?
oézéza cm:-mam; §'iIm"£§:"»"E":§
3
-1"
3% THE HSGH CGQR? SF KARNA Efiéffi ;€ '3' 8;fif\?GAL=GR§
Bé.'§'ED THI8 THE 2&9 BAY 65' FEEREEARY. 299?
SE.-:"F$f:'E
$35 5-§$$é"8LE 938. 333 3385 fi?.K.Pfi Tfi.
2%*.p.m3_ 330*; TS 2393 GE' 2309 iT»;«:;a?:'%
.212'; %
w.p»:~:<:>¢ 22243 OF' 2%'Z.1*{18*"f3'\~:-K£'i'I'§
A?€B
'«§i.P.i\§C.14-*%£E?' GE2GQ8._fT'~~.B:ST}' _«. » = % L
'a%'.P.NG3. :39? T6 2393 <::s§2:é§3
BE"sWE5%~é _ _
~: rg1;3w:.:'»:s< §z¥;¢f§;=*{T%§R'§.r:3£.':§_'.
:~e03:@A;2eT:;:"cR:2,<s5s.
£32:-: gwasa. Vgaa'-as_f~;A E?-éQU.§'§§?%.«*¥.,, 23%
afi;?%Gfi.%;€24:'%E1$~B
RES 3*: :'5s'§v-V§.::%:2.9m'.:=.:":*;--:2:,:>,'\
3 s+:.a3;é;mLA; E5-*;§;ags%'
3-4:3 gag;4;:5.:::f€2~%*~:'va§::%A:;:;:%;%ea§%T;£9
9 233, smgz . ,
2:55-;;i:=z"~:g sz~;§:£,s:;:=:.:,A.':_ gazmzrztr.
a.;%.%a;2.Leaa.3a. ..
;;:::2:-.223 as' as ?§zs§2:g::<.:a;::
_ 3-: 'a.\:,»:s;§=.:s-fa $%.,§§'-«E-{'}AR.é.§e.1%; :2? ':5;-2&3
EH'
PE''§'§"§'2Q§'éE§:'Ei
% §E?&%'~§.?§v'§E§'sé'§' GE: ?L3§.§i sf'-£*e'Q E§'éE?'%fZ5':'
"»:'§?§;§S§*2 EQBQHQ
3fis%~éG13%£,§QE
REP '"''£' 553 S£$RE"§'e%R':" §§'éER€s'a'
T:
aazéaa §.'£a'7?a33i3££s'?é§ §¥§.?szZ§$§§€
V m
we;
TEE §.§E*iIi§§ €f€}§§§%,"§ Ce? Ei:'~£{E'§?s3'A§<Z.1k 3:5? §fi§£'5C5 .~"~.L£.'R§.':;. 'a?§'.Pf3~3é:»s,%3€}'§' :5 i3»{§€§€2fi€}'3' $25:
ezfiza smmeszeé zraasiags
«Ex
53% $2, SHEB !\%Q 2, RMQALEPSRA ¥§LL§"-'$5
§&Sé'&R£3e P831 SARJe§§?'L2R §{}:'%L2
Ei§%»éi'3é'sLQF{E-3%
REP' 33' $3?-.R"§"E"4ER
2% '?a%?é$L§?'A%éG5§§§'«%~%
IN'!
$58 %¥.=*3AF{Lé"?}%2 ?R§%?~ES?QR?e'¥ER$
§'%{l* SQ, 5'-:E'e%B$'s§_§PURA 'J%%.%.fi:€3E _
£23:-'ERA ?QS'?, $!5:Rdé'v%?%JR R{}§%$ V
§§'~3'a%{'x,5'L€'.}§'~i%'::'--3-4
QEP B'! ?':§R'E"NER
'£3 L§'~§{fi%§'~$§'»é§
em
§'z:"'%.%'S VAQQQDRA ELE*C?R%€$xL E":§.§?5F"%§,%§f~7€;$
E'-£9 33 2'-sifiéifi %A§..'u%§'~€E}{3R {3.¢{§'E N _
SA?.$R?':.3R$i RGAB
85'-QGRLQRE
RE? 8'? §3'§RT2'éEP;
3 31?? 3., %~%%R§s%Ai.A .
H ».'.'§f'§eV.":._"_:"iT~£"2Q%'dEQS
{E'e;" 524: § 2 Rfiééi 3. 35:2; '?_S'_;§A$é%--.§:$%%_é;§¥i3€,;!¥?E$ }
fiéséfi :
'E "T2-§E $'§é'€E"i?F'"%%§%NN.'3%?éA " _ Vs
SE?.:*-'-9R3'§%§ET; ":1"; SF §=;3":§$'§§'4E§%3'a"" "
'J§i<.fx3k $QL§$!~,3;E M --
aarseaggafis. v _ ' -
RE? 8'? 8'3 SECR"7.%"§se'-2'? VE?-éER£§?'{
$5 $?é€'2:§§:. :<;$;a:«4é;*:_£:-:~;:g_"..'%*
Re.-*=s av '£2; '&§*JE%a2%.§E sacasaéeazi
2&3' ?E-:~"%.§%L§%€'=éS ag:;sa;:»R£
N5
« V Ezéa aesamagszeésaa H39 £Qfv'e§=£ER£%éL'
."'f'¢:"Z*'-3-"'1%'§§£'«E<.'.';«"'='E I "'53.:
' V .aA?:%;£;%§Ef§z%f%§§:¥: gm
._ "$§éES%~§£E%R.:§?{;:Rs%%¥€
A §;:a:«saA;.:.:~:;a;;::
'é:;~:E gm "Ca?a:w::ss:@:»:ER <:>§ aagaeagaszaz TAXES
. §??~'?£.fi§;$3
A. , Lggeéggaaaz:
' --,_T,§:'E {Z§--%.i':§%'.;§s'li3:§'»§ Aéé €'v'%:'%€*~i£GE§'é$ $ER§'£3TQR
£Q§%a~'7'@?u%TE %'.'}%"3¥§%".'.';E
§ES$Q§'21'§
3%; R :'Z:%R€.';§.E
-"£31." 'I '
'"'§§§§Z iifiiléié £i3=i§§?,T =:i's':£=' ¥..i'£'{,§«L'ATf 9% é'=Ji' $»§'*&'~E{'} 3~.£.i.}REZ E¥._;'?'..'3»§;:s:;'§3;:}? as 1i*i€L%~a'-3'=52%Z%€T!:2? 2%; '
9&5 sZ'§3§i§§é:';§':'-aft EE%$£=.:"?fa
§"';'-EYEEI1§k3E§ijTi}E,?§{"£'€3¥K_.%Rb3A?AE~Z;'a5§T fi§i}E'{i?J..€2R§;, '$2 f:'--Ea3='§,13=€}?ia3= ';3é§$£Z€,'2§9 Eh':
mafia szxmeffafi §I?J¢§CiE§":2
ta qtsssh §§'3€ arfier ;3a$$eé by £"éS;fiflfiQ'E?"i'f§- 5 ans? 8
mafia? S%8'i§§¥"§ $2-A cf {fie Karfieiaka Saks Tax Ac: '$5?
vifia fi.me2<ufa$~F ané F? ciaieé 5.8.68 arsfi égzfzagd
33 7.88.
2. 'me getgtésners in v¢.P.%¢a.s2243{2Ga$ §m
sfiught far 3 éeciaraiiéfi ta dac:§3ré%
éateé 38.3.'%9%% and fiateti' %3e.3f2eas2 5% A
Arme3:ures--B ané C are s+pf:z5ic2H§':;:i'eV',V}§::». arid
saippéiers <3? eiaetfic di§z2;§§€:;fi%:;:3 2.:i§"§§§£i'5fg$§f§*r2r_2§'s, fin Hi_&., :9
agsmrw, MESC§';=%§, Hszsfxqm as they
are :§{:'3TCLf%(E8 M and
wnsequezfigr pracxeedings iniiiated
by the Cammisaizmer cf
C$mr:*:&§fc§3i 'T33'r:@;s ,', feagaénifig tine assfismeni: afifi
rdaréééé fa? :Je§3nvéry""uf'Vfhe amauhis made? sesééers 'E2-A
kx3%'tjk%«g¢tk%kL% 5;; case %'é@@. $3 mi 29843; m?ea4a
éaiefi--.. waéuaed as Anneasures-$2' RC;
§5??';&'1a:%5?3 fiat 25.2.2ea3 pmucea as
V' . ' A :5: mi: EEESEE ~;:*az;:~:3* <3" gsx2;<2£a.T:1KA 2;? E£A3€{3:§L€'>%{E :3 :}:sg:'2:2<252 mzfi
assiéafi wimeaiafi mmesss
Tim Efifiii COEJRT OF K.s*s.I«':'}=E.%"§,¢.§<Z.,;v*; £1' .I%i,OP..£ 'ér=i?I,?¢»:35' 13$}? 3:: §3%}S.:"'£-:£3i}§ 232:5
zpaéaer sazmeséafl maierg
-3-
Annexum-J, and RC} No. '§G'M268 éséed 29_2_2§'}G8
profiuced 3$ Anne.»xur*%~--J*§ are bad in iaw, as a%$a.«".~";--.«r;*;_":fc§'_$ i*':'4:'q_,:V"
fiassaé by the 4th rapendenifthe Jain? Cor:1;n§sf;'s2iVvG1§é[e%:f}'._¢f' >
Csmmerciai 'faxes in Afipeaé
daiad 29.4. 20% praéuced V a*.:+. _V An}*:a3€uf§e--%;¥£f,f v%
$93-39 dated 2942933 pr®ii{i:¢:e_€§Vw }f&:3%s:e :;»;:;;fv$as-K1,
%{ST:AP:'§8:G8-89 d3':ve€:;"V:%":;r_:>§uceé as
Annexure»-~K~2 a;:1;3:A"%%3e i@'£3§%§:%j:s:§§igv1: 3§L':*§;;5v;s§*fi}"fioceadingg
bafore the in $339 Nths.
Cir}.?zi§is.?%i€;8- ;f;f:§$iii;;'€~d:"é.§ §\%§fi'éxiii:es~M; amiss. was
pmumas Cr.1'}'£.G8 pméuceé 33
Anfie3:z§f¢%;-%v%2."" V. A
_ 'rag ;m§:safiers'sn W.P.%\§<3. 4444? 6'? 2&3 have
S1€:%.%V#§'v,;v§T§"1'Vfi5¥{ '§.Vv{'§é;{3§§»§'f*371£§fi¥? in fiéfiéfé €12: ifie nztsiéficsfiens
fia%e§"««..3Gf£j€'@' %:%,%@cs: 29% and mad 393.2052 aside
' fiénaxgfaég. am C are afspéicabée ta manufzeiufafg and
._$~%_:.:§;§f:,~%'§-*e'%'$ af éiéffifiti éisirébsiféafi trafisfarmars in 5.6.,
y%}§%§scs:s.5: macaw; HES sax: am sascmzs as {shay
EEJ fig Eéiifiii 'C'i3*7é,f§T €232' Pi? B;»'a3'~3i;"3é'i.'§,éL'-{%';i'E '$5 23%}? 9:3 i3éI%Es"3%}€}'§ 3:153
:}?3§.$'é' e:mi:;::a:z% mam
£1I'<':Z§<Z'if.>E,"*':"-2.'? *5)?' K.-'a§?1Z€§aTA§;?x 9:1' ALZEREZ. 'Js:*.E3.':\Ea3a. :39? at: i3:';$'.Zs':{%§ ma;
a}§£';£{ :s;m::e«:.te¢? mam?
-4}.
are fiacaegsars if': ififerest sf fiée ersfiwhééa ?iPTCUit{'EB
and in S6 far as patifésners are carzaarz}.e§' é*:%éé ~_
amsequegrtiy. fa deaiare that 3%? the pra»<:eedf§;7;<;:$...iVn§'§§fa9c 2e%$J'
by ?:he: 3" respandent-Dt=3puty:;_
Cammerciai Taxes. reepefii--5é_g'4--..__ti"ee"-.aé.<:*$;*;§'%::é.j;:2..._$r§d%
arderirég far reaévary cu? the 3fiT!Q¥#§i:§$$,"'1§§"i%fifé? '?éé<%:i§:;2.:r§ 12-A
sf the 24:3? Act in %j&3.é?3234 fixated
28.63.2688. ?.:;;:r..j;; : §ata 32aae, RC
2339635? ?Q駧8%'VVda%ed 25.3.2353
RC '§§38?'§"§4 dated
24_3_2GGé.3§#i aéfézfie Ar2n&>:s.1res--F tic: F8 are
bad inAV¥,.x/W. a:§$£;.t3r§ '5e.>:rV$f"'..;:2asse<r$ by the 4?' respondent
}"'fi':eV;§fi$fif»*."fifi'h3miss§ééééf 6% Cemmerciai Taxes in Afipeai aside Afififixfifé-G, dated 2? 5.2688 yéée 'i3s:'s:'ee:j=;:yéz3:§.~=;s --%-%. 633356 25.81.2668 vifie A¥"!I"¥8I3{i.§£"é-J f§':%3g §§:}:1c:h§:";g £3? sacamry véda rsaiiea daies' 28.8.88 fiséézé'kfiénexureg---?a$F,Q GE'? éiie fiée as? $3 sfiéae cxf tha 'V ' A "~,§é 'i:sasfy Cémmifiéarrsr af Cflgjjmerciai '$222593 sfievcavefy}. SEE $5.311 =::'€}'§,:'3'"§ E")? E§;"a§%_?L§;'§."?aI'{.?: AT §%§££'%i§ ;='z.§,€".§?}iE 's5s'.?.1'~§i',«3.i}{%?££:; i3{3$z"2%3$9 2.m<:3 2.21:5 ::s:s;1.z1e££$§ amen E3»: TEE §EE{21§2:?QE_§Rf£' =13?" §<LéR3*~E,%T.§\K.a AT 33§\.?€G§'~£,:,'JR§;. £352'? :9 13£éSé'§%}i}§= mi e}¥£§$fii" €s'1EE3ée£$&§ mazam N19,-
4. 3 fiave heard éeafneé mange; sppearéfig far pefiiémars and %e3mefi ccszmsei agpearézrsg --fgr respefiéefifs.
£2. iearrsed ccrsmseé apgearing fer b«::t*::__'f£'§':§§ ;':'af.:**£'§}e:.; at iha wigei, sufiméfiaé that the§:'s§y'T::;§.:'s2*e$*%'éfis"s:_':
t;':fi%¥°'§S§§E%'&6 in ifie hasten? wrii V;r:se$;_$'€i::3:is;._§é'-thai,,é3;§$vi§? Safe Gavarnment has éssued :%'£'x3i%":f;5§¢e3t%!ani:s"e{§ _:3§7Gt%.§}?\i§3rch ?€sQ6 am 3&5"? ?v"z3%*ci1 VL is the maimfacturers am $'u'p§::%"ié§'?S: Sisifébuticm 7¥'"3f"§$§&t'?'?"§€F$ %§;§:é%;f" a%%*§é"8%s:chér§ir3g their §'%p&cié%.{e. thus, in View 3f the '.'T»*ifi£"i;::'.é':'§§££"Ti'¥_"§"§§"V§v five wfiipsnies fififififléyg agscam kkk%%;§.z:ex*a*»k{::;:>§42;%%véésascamg HESCGM Am gsgéfiséng Auiherfiy has érsééisted thé graimd' iézai, éfieré is as ngiifécsfiéfi as _ suraéfi %s_$s;:e "<:i}Z« find hfififié, 'éiwesa fifififififieffi are Eéabée '£3 " jihééggéé and firdereé fa? §"€fi§€~':¥""i§F°'§§ fifié $$SE$$i?"§'?€?T§¢ §€2'¥::_V%"t"':§--"sé $$i«$@§$§fi'§ auéhafit as weéé as éfifiéfifiifi gasfémréfy .. 353$ §§§.Q§% {"Ii}i,3;C§" €335 Ea'? S,=Ei'5i3s"%§;,£"}§¥§ £23: T:3z€,%%;":%}€,3'§ '.-fiéé gszéaa" Eéfifilfifléiég mazzazzg Eiézfééé =:}'J zen 333$ ezsihas sc'a:zzs=.t:;:e.<,"§ .F _
-31"
'nave asassefi the fifdéffi. ifisteaé sf msvifig the :f:fsar?:f%fi?a:fV fiéffiré the jaréséésiéanaé comfieéerfi euihaiéty _ igsuéng :3$z::é$$ar3s f¥'e$%'s :":<3*i%f¥s¢§i_i_ga;fi__ Er: _.'xi§'%e*w:'_';s:3f"'V the cansiétutian mi §'v-'é fififfifififiiéfi a:°*s{:'§, tz3_'_'T:%%ét $§'§e.«:¢:i, éhemaéivag haves igsaed 'ahé.. §§rfir:':{s":§§§a*%%§§*§. ~Vi§'i=:e mafia? E3 mnfiéfig fiefmja i%*:e""JV§Vf:.§:f§;:;§"s<';§'%a:§é§"earséfieierzt 3i.§?§'i5¥"i'§§i. Raving r& g ééfi " V §;:qavc§<grsu§*;d§, §E'5'€§?§0i"'E€FS are, ' Es '§%e§? §i"§é"é3f§C§?: §efar'e ffiifi 'fi3:'re§':fies$ 3? the §"é*fi§'f'.¥Ei"ti?':,:gr Autharéty 2:16 fits C§fiS:é€7jfij€]§"§§13:fi§"{';§§F'-: m§T}é5§S€d by the Agpeiiafa :§fi'ffiG§§?§', as :%fer;{_&'§"' abiéve.
'A _v'§_§e.a.rfie;d Govemmafif Pieaée? appearérwg far fééspfééxdévfifégv».h:'§é§z::§r%%ed sari am sufimifiefi thgé, skeady
--':?s& cc§1r:;3én#te¥1i.Vauihar§t3s hag issaed the cammunéasiééfi ta %;%";§e?f%é:¢f fir3at she mafia? ifi wade? csngfieraiim am i? :;s;%¥% .___'%:;s& :?;mrsSééere§ fired apsregfiréaie §$#f;:§$§§¥§'3 wiéfi be takers, in , ;§fi§:§§'§8f%%.;';?8 aesééh Ema éf ting? ég $3, there is rm érfigeéimefif ...------«-----"""""""""""
E}: EEEQEE <;'€":«§R*'E' E' T "S :"s;a:a::}A£:}a%§; 2.3:}? %3€z$;';%}£.>9 aw'; azeziaa aggzziaszszafi asaiats TEE3 Eéifiil C'€}§§§%.'%' E<A§{}Eé%.Z£" 31$ 55?' A§.QE-13:'; '%:"P:1'~E<:ss\ ifs}? ae; §.'3sé}§2i2€1',1£ mad 23:31:: :?:f3fi'ii§é:ifi§ z::mse?s:-3 '3 g'_
--i':'n far 2228 iurésdictimaé campeieni 3£}?§"1€3i"§'E3f 6% the Etate Gaverfimamt ?i"3 take 3p;:zr'op;*%a':e €'.§€C§$§§fi éfifi §mt%f§cai§<:3rs aria £i§§ %$suir:§ such naiificafian, '€?1e_.A£§ssé;§s§i"fi§:T:'"' * Authority and Appefiate Authariiy-""are%'.mit 'V weaver ffza Ci§'?féi'éf'?f¥3¥ fax a5mo:'a:_r1t " fhé:~§*é 1' pefifimers. Therefcre, E hereb1'j;}»;-§?;;a;¢t. tfié "g§_Vi§s£:%':<3£'f.'§:'fc;'£}fi'V;:1aI campefefit authorities' tax armurrt fmm fhggeh fieiéiiéfiigfi:fig?§*;i:'$Vfi:".:§$t§ficat%an $2' arder is %f rm?
aireaéy " 3 Wévfh fiéesé ihé writ peffiifins fiiéd 5 fiy the:.§.%etA%t%éfiaafss€a:é€i aiépesed afi A~.$§2xe§}§:;nent P§e:3fi7e:' és pemzéfied to fife far rmpafiéefits-?;2,5,8 and 7 (E23 W.P.fi'a5.€'3G?;§308}2GG§}; fat" resfisanéattts-1 ta 4 (in %j"%%%;*g%j.":2.%:a§g12é«z3;2gm} and far respanéents--z ta 4 gm 325J;A'§?*{V.:¥'§%é.?:'$4-¢?!2§{'fi) , W; 1?? {was weeks ffam tedaja ____J__,_,,,,w_.,.»..--«----r ":3: 3% 232,22: £'O¥;¥:"£ 2}? §<€5as'2;3~2;i..'F.*~'..E~:,«'a arr m;r»:<:si§,<;>:2£ '-§.*".Pf-$35.. 23:12'; ii} ma:
ayéaa cwmaasa IN "SEE? §§'}€-'SSE: *{1'£:E,}T£§E' Q?' ?~.'§~E€;3?;1,€131-';;*i' "}.i?3v§a;:«;§3€;'? as; l3€;&'2€}{?9 €}§§i€E" maaaaai §1";§{1s'Ei';?
..'?E3..
3:; zsm Gupta % fsérmifieé ':3 féie va;:ezs:k§¢T@mk Résgfisfifiefits 8 and ? ii": \f"\§P.§'s§$.14447/08 weeks fram taday. _ :uaqe EEEGEE <?£¥§EE:"f' €33? 9:5 T$§«;:*';f'£3 "*$a=T}'Ci'»2:>2;.. 33$'? 3:: §.?%é?:'$«r'M'.-',i.',?é::'§ axis; aaziaea" §z'1%':§';£iJ§€:i'§§%5:§Z§?'$