Karnataka High Court
H B Rangaiah vs The Divisional Controller K S R T C on 17 November, 2008
Author: A.S.Bopanna
Bench: A.S.Bopanna
3»: 12% Hmfi QCZIURT GE? mmfmm AT BAPIGA1.0R_F;e -
BMW Tim Tim 17%» my GP mvmmm %% jff% _
BEFWE
Em" mwm zsm..Jz.Is'mE A§%Bcax=;aia"mx% Ti"
wmmmzom uoa.1?»257;20cs¢ %
' '- __
WA". E§25?j' C35
Eestwwan: ' _
HE "
SWEE='VIMGfi'DI2v$Wi . 'a '
aaam
Rmmsmfmsmtnmgaz % %
mmm mmmrr * A % L
WWW" " ' _;';'..PE';'§.TI'I0rIER
gm' 53 F+§m¢u;:~1z:%%mvA%Ru, ADV.)
mmmxwa
mm-m, E£s.;"*3i"%ALmE Humnmsmi
E113 STAKE
- swam. .,.REs1=mmN*1*
J SM E mi-mrmam ma M! 3 wsmwsm
gsmmrmsw wvz;
WMT ?E"I'I'FI*'ifXI IS FREE E%ER ARWES
». 4 225 fig 223'? €35' TEE G-ONSTIWMGR GP' HWDIA PRfiY'II§G
fifi Q¥...E,fi;§?5E% 'Rm QRDER EaP:'T{'ED ERBKKS PASSQEB BY
'Wm 'I" HQLQWG THE IJESQYC
ENQUEfiz"&S FAKE MID PRQPER ms L
4.!
E9
WmF".§{}§ Chi EQQS
EETWE-EH:
"mm mmmmzgz, QEGHTRQLLER % %
Kama: mm nmsxafi « ; A
"5112" *"' Eefifififififi EH8 S'I'.A.Nfi 1
ammmm -- am am.
19.,' " V' 1.
:3? am E'; 'W31-fW&NATH - A13v§i«"<3R ;l§.\aIfS A
xmwaimm .assocm*ms3%%%
ma H B wmmmfi
am am x
mam ' %
am ;am'avm:mmaET~%%% A '
m15§K§,:§R%LVm>s.m 1 % RESFMBENT
cm' ma mmmgmax, aw.)
-'2%::-m' 13 mm unmn AR'T'ICLE-
ma &:"2?:.23:}* mwzimv may E Q1? mm mama
. t '§?£3%"é;$%:»§g§,::;H,% .*c:;1%Em mnfimm AND AWARD
%mm»E:":f A~m" 'mm Fmcxvaz mama
:Z:fl*U;F!g"€'°;ifl$%§W3r;fis;§.,aQRE mmn 2556,2594 av :19
%"§Xi}-T..':*";&1,g"'€&;'E'g« WEE Aauxea E DEEMWG fim
T3 REIfiSTfiT'E TEE %?fil%ENT RTFC3
L we max wages.
A x , *"§":%:§m3 'WRIT mfiuaua coma mi ma
mama ms my um mum' mm
% '?:%H%a~%'ai?§a:m..:31a%m:
GREEK
pafifianm in w,1=a5m43,!2m5 is the ssmfl
m" befits the labaur mum TM
}a
p
u gwwuxmznnxm Istxjsa atmnimnta. .
pafi't§m»::mr Em W.P.E@25'7'i.I'€35 is the: fxrat may
befams fiffifi iabmm mart.
-mm mmnm in waP.sm1a;e5ig%jkaggn:em:i
ma mm mm 2Ms.20e4j§:mm£a;~% 3a§:«§u::*'
fimmx" "img fimt me &at party anfi
;":7§%Z.'%'3v*-*9: fimékwagw ha fir: *: . _
hsfmaiiar as the the
may mm mgjmm at' 50% $3'
the party wtarlwn
\ J pasaaad cm the
23%. fiwfifi. dnmmtfic anqwry' .
«$ri..vPrab1'm flevm, learnefi enamel
%a;§pm.g~%% thm amt. may wen-Lmn and Sri
V mw mumal appaarn" "3 far the stwonfi
gimmad 3% Wfit papem.
" *%\,'£%wpa1"aiwar¢mfw*mdtek1t11¢xa11kam7mwc1
ta tfizeassm bawe the Eabaur mum far pixie of
wmtmzianm am clarity ainm twrs wt.-itinzm am fiixed am
fim r& am drifiarmt in the ME pwfitiauna.
la
an 'pwr-r-ux
amcxzrud mrcy s
an
fiw: way mrfii was warl®gaVV_:a$;T~.a
mmim7::m1" in the asamfi party
wag s:>«:'mfiu.«:zv*tim that has Ha,i}.293 _ix;;E0um " " 2
"%M¥}].isL'::1fi «mass; mhmkfl at RES filfrg. % .
Gama: ms. amm which 313 ajjgmga A %
it :35» mflfied fimt the igaue hen
fickatfs. :32" EH50 N1Mté§;%T :3!' mac:
mm [email protected]:.':e&€- flrmmn. In trim
ta him and am
the mt party mm
&Tmm"?igme&V §Z~n;§m elf téw maswnd mrty by czrdw
famt wrtggr called in qumtian tkm
mi. an
$m.1fi~--M---~A} at' the mduamaw fiispuhas
% Ms wirucmm rzwzma as m Emma.
Tim {kw aafifi pmseeadirxw, the imam mlamg tn
the *m"%iiui.§;t3r mr n af the dmmmfixz enquiry wag
mmifimmd aa a fmxma and the lab-mur wart
by fig wrgfim" dastafi 133.21% Emld tha same in Eawur cf
L
'or
was mmifimufi an im mmim anfi 135' the awmmi ~
:25.mm»%, um mmm mm was mi'
am thmmfam tkn labmzr
flaififl ma mmsmaa swim"
" ;- yeah: as» oaxrfiuctcmfizfiitia
am ;%3%- hamkwaggwg firs! 1
party gm wall am Cam: 2
amanaziiiifig am naatu:::ed'
abazsw firms fiat 'rim aréiam' clatw
mfimas an %é;;ma.
nf writ papers; can hm:-rug' the
inéicaate that iz1sa&x as me
mung-el far the firm; party with
,¢:;;;§ wfidity af ths dameatizn amquixy, a
mg gnaw mm and the finziinga» maem.-1
amumr mfiimm" wauw ixicfiicate tlmt as 'mm' 1:
; Iemfi £ the peti't.ia:nae.ex', the
fifiwz" ma Emma to the: mnmiusiun that eharga ma.1,2,4-
am ffi am mrfly yrmmd, wlfiie the firs»: party wor1%n
L
mama' t tine fiat mm
Wm mm W113; mi' ma chmm 3,5,7 and 3. In
am zfimm tn tba order
inslimém that am dam ' hum' = authnrityilxagéhnifi' u
the mhwgw Ems he.-m pz-awed axtfi the
hm jgmmwfi. In thfia
mrdw gmmmi by tim '
imuwza wmamki infiimm the: rwtiwd
this as-fit aff tn tk
wmlmilwmi. was: fair and
. = avwrvfxufiaad the pcrooe&J.re
asinm apportumty hm
it was mm mi fair and
ms am iabmr mutt mmm tn» the
_ mmfi tn the apporturfity baen
I-wwwlw su
Q the firm: mrty wearlmnm tha Iabaur eourt
'}i'%ugh,,thiaa;gm1:asft11emafiaBrhaahea:1
v tax in dam} by the Raarmfi: mammal fiat the first
mrty" wmrrlwan, aumidmm the fact. timt the ultimte
is
-4
{fin mt firzd it -
¢:1:,a-a mzaga itmf. it im a§n'te;gt,
.1 %% before the Igtmm
firm gmaaing ef' me in bus
mfiaad.
Efi; :3? the award gaassati
my rim :ia5§;~c:;i;3f::5i}i';§:1i'rua;t»3 mat the labecmr mm
mm mmzema. and :1» rival
- gag. ;£m~.»:~.3:.=.. mm mm tn the chaxgm mam
party workmm 13% naulcm fm
b,» firm mt mg» mrzmn wit}: mm
M' cahargae mm} ttm jusfifirsmtzimn far the
lahcxur mart baa 1'efe:m'efi tn the {eat that rim
flaxmm: he bald '£9 ha pmwad far :11: rmmz that
the mf fim mkmrge 'W:1'3';§7i zmarti. 'ca nszmwimue nf
fifikfim $3 -4: J': _
-mum indicate am: it 3w hégm smpmaam. whm
in
o
W
2 Wm psamwi in fawmr emf mm {mat mrty w»ork';n#l$_~-.
at 'fifi may ta .
1: ma rzumhwer of' gasamzgam in the bus,
mm rim. aspmt af the
.-_..m...;n..o=;..= =4». ;..s..«.g....m...... -
as
I uwrirunu vars
axmrsixmag the awmfi paswci Evy' labmur
Wrira. yafiifimm. mdw Arfim-la $7 af the
Ixfiim, aim-cm the: mega mi' "' 2
amwt?" , $fi~&p ' tiara af evxfle"
paws-mfi. :?m @1113 mam. WQEQQ
mm'? {Emu minim xmmfiaf the
amfi Ema» m;_m'éL§% at' fast.
;_::;;~; szmmm taf3 t.'P__1ea 13%
mt mm tbx: finding
charge Hm. 1,2,4»
Nas.,3,5,,7 anal &
mrma mm T aimsnez thfm mgr:
v X3? uf the -
E:3?@fl*iww ma firm mmm cuf mm cnrde.-r
authcxrity aim xmtfim in be
A mew"
M. M. nmtéced, ms lahzzur mutt afwr ap
me mvizsfienmma imam cftzaxgm .915 must mm, whiie
rim :;:mm at fim firm: imefi' Im new
thmtiiseaeafimrfi 1§2,%a11d&wem@t1yprovedan&the
L
4
$
Nlwwsv
had mt E §I"v1'.'.I"9.®. Q16 fifflt
W-:3» wmimnarz. mm the mfifact, the j %
mmmzry ma tic; paw 'flu mm-¢;§'[%%% % A k
tha amszmmpfian fitmt. afi the chmw
wifimmt
datfimfint M 13:13 " _E:'Il':jfV2§m, the
§:ECi§3 ' Eveazrz ;
. -thaé-aaingge law Iafi down me'
tin §~%L:::z'1'hk~. S*n.;a';:.:x~esmVVV'L mm vi" SE 3.33
K rwm in am; mg 1
F32 flag ctwhichrmtfl 't::::hannt:n:ne&'
i.fi*?.V'%A:§:2:.%fA% =th§s« :
wax mt jumzifiw in cnnfilmg tar tbs it
vsirzm am am: mfg" we aim ' %
mafia afizmjfiar mfimndmt eammlis-ar.
J)
c
0':
myymrtufiiy
3 «.933: 9! I*u'|I|II:1Ir'|Ita-I uuuinruu virtue»: -urn air'-IInII'1II'"IIIIr"I I''
2.2:;
hmm "mm": mmfit." 'bad by rm fimt wxty " .
lamm mm has apspnm fm
rmtficing fine namm cf ting » -
hm afxw mm as am
* v pmmt
nzzawk fin cnly' three
am as not
wmfi "gnu-31-3» 1:9 fiw
mm w'§.;1§fi* The lahcmxzr wurt. has
to thsa mm' xmennduet 1
aka he-ML ism: pmarvfiaxmd 3
%§;"_zsfl af mum'. has the
mam-xi§aa:e;§:1L3§.aw.%%§j:*.;=;Vif"'r2z:;a§f&'u'1"§.tfa.'£» pvarsy Werlmrz rmufixm taa be
mgm which ha mm with mz'1tnm' n:y* of
. 1 e:1«w~~fifs:.t Sm}. my awmr in tha amrd paaaml by
Vfiw 1é'%W'W*m
». £4, The mt qumtian aim ' mad mum' fiat
'szifimfiaratimn $5: with ward is me gmt. csf backmm
fi;="§*'m fimvm; wrty wasrkmm baa E that
l
r
n
M. in this 'mum cam,
:1 $5122" fimfi. may ®z--'z'.qr_ §
mgarti tn me order
" ':':+-.=.~=a_-an in amaiffi the $6.111: tzyf 'A .
-- 'fsgfi 'awn
mwwfissfl; E sf the
mxattaar $im§::.z3,:f£7;§' Ja mmmmt that tha firm;
an 3.31 fiaum bafire the
apex: thy tkw Imbam: wart tn
izzzznk am memztfime ita cliacrafinn with
in tha mttant tn be daciéed by
. shim it, is WM} azsmhfiiahefi that grmt. at"
Em amt aufiomatzim awn. if the dismiaaal urdar
---.§§3§.::§.;e %:%:aai:i£s, Em am view, a pm-uml esaftlw award pmw
V that Im.§wux' mutt wnmfifi irldicate that tiw lflmur caurt
hm mgayfiéd £95 minfi in thfim aamt fif" the: matter aka:
axfihsm tfimaamrmciaus fiec:'?miu3::*m mm5G%n§the
i
"an
u qgupgpuuu was 3':-juuuurnvr-Inn-I II -uwvrupu uwwuuuwuu-no
'kmkwagmw amfi. trmafomg M the staid wzmnt. X 91:1"
mart my mat. ta caiifcvr mt m
ma Thertmm, Impm fiogfsac
v§mr§ 2" mm. of the mpzfixzim
%.fi.:%vi.;'-%I3% wlfim ism _i'n*at party'
" ' ' 3&5 K ."
mt far :_V5f:§€§'3!$h%"';_1:$:££11§,"§.3', bath 1:113 Writ
dirspcmed of; 2%
mrfimraa 'V
aamjy mm 7m the a3c:a% mf sfiscmfion by .
.....
Iudgs