Acc Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Acc Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath

W1."

EN"%E%ﬁG%%£GURT{M:K&RNATAKA£ﬁ"EﬁN6&LORE

§ATE$ THIS THE 237" my GP auaugi" 1:32: 

?RE§EN?

mg %%§¥\é'B§.mE svimaggrzci ;r~»s.i»<a,%:-r§gg  1%

AME

WE §~E@E's§'BLE' :v:§"3:.:§T§;C§ ?;ﬁ:;*.€E;E%E_$.LEF~'§:£§;f§fEw§' - = V' 

amp rx:0.:24 @F=;: '@~:§ ":§§>:----3 '   
4'3'4E'§«-Q    h' "
gm? §'éQ.S§,~1_45~ES6*§§;2Q.3;.1

ssrwem:
ACC LTD,, _      

383%; GRGUF§£vE1€Fi,¥£}V{}R,, "mg: Egzwa' 
magi,§:CKE;x:5::Q"r=s':f<=9,;,a;gi3;._,L"~~. '-- * 

BANGALGRE ~»..56--{}:"';§;42T  '

REi>9.Es:~:r~;s"§"E;fs   
§A"{:§§~é:;:é'C:v~wéf:::rv::A.se:;,:*xs«V%  . ; ..@Em":@§\:ER.

{BY 32; ﬂ'['a;*7.E4f'\1§KA'"E"§S E'4..§' :i§'%;:Q7ifﬁ;?E}

  "§f§¢E §'m"%9é ::§%~.§;g;:mATAm
?'%é% CQ§'*f1'§'3»f?§;'i"i,S~EC'é:"«%.ER Q? cagvzgx/§§§.£z&;.«,

?!£iX'€£§_2_ :.::3€'§=~ﬂ:.§9sE»%1§}<.afm;. 3:&>< $E§£%R"§"E*~'EE§xE'§"
§;2.§a§§§%-2: §%§,&§§éé"~€§ K;:5§VE:":;5aL§§§:.;§ﬁ: mgzg,

 E%E%§{;-:£»aL€j%__§-?;E-.~"§§S 59% .,R§S?@§'€B§§'*s§"§°

 SR: :+:;:%%§.gas:vgav:;%@:gyx;;a:4?s', %*~E:{§§?'j

* mwmw



""1." , 

i
2
2

M 9 M
nazezsre 92" 553 {i"$!'2i?"3r:fE' 3:70' fr; View 52' the fag"?
55735 the freigfzt cfiargeg were csiiectad by faim 
far f!'§ﬂS§3Qf'f3{"?Q?? G?' She gmdg fram i"f?7S '.. ' _V
facfary 3553 is the piacra G9' iifze §§,i3«°'€:"',  'V
Cfearfgx :f}g3;';";e 02;: siren': the r:a£n::r§   
aonfrasi sniered Eats bezygagfs 4ff2.;é"";3;.é§i{:%'é;=;: 
§§:"§:'{::;i3:'£y :37 V5834! sf me c:3}:;a'5€{;34;§ jj:";f§:;,47:  AV
aarszjn:-3c:t and :35 a z:0:'z§e;3uen<fé:..f}?s}eo2i Eéf3"i?a>&:.f V'
aim caiﬁecma' me 2§F€f>§,?§vA§:€:"~.§,ff'?8f;Qt?§; '3.§i3~5r§ fé'fy~w 
;i*"«:>m the buyer as per §f:r_¢T:%?f;:<3 :>i:ﬁV aaéé i:s5;§ QeafVf%$r

pregaareo' ségaaraéhégevg m'%£cf2'VAf%:g.¢%e.e;': exiféévted

5;': the aggésjszneniif 555$," sz:Vé:§?¢_~~ féé assegging
a:ia"f?o_;.r:~:'y'__ 5Alj:;':.?3';*f>e;:'€.%.2_";%;%§_:.V*:e:*.:1... £"--f2a'5] vfribgighai baa' i<3§i°
gsghiﬁsf :3%;g:§ Vf§§ff'Ef§éf'£§?Vé",%:2e§§z$§*2e:' here has 3
{:f:;;}£§§Vfin;§.vgfg  :3?" §§e§iie;" ans? 0{"f2e;' 3:' a
Cérjrief __}3;*§cf if 55 in big Giﬁer
5a@3*.:?;='_:";' §§"§ . é'.*§{i'§é§.f~ 62' we geads, he {é€Z§?%,/Qﬁ
 :'§:w3 gz3.éa'..§_%":::9 53%?'  behaﬁf 52? {ha basyegg, @323

V  °£§,.A'-3 :rgf}g:i§;§ §7ié:""§:3 E1353 €3§€£{,. far éha pa,::;s::::5e sf
  j:;*§?:=::;;4::§*:1§_§£@;§ 02*' E135 gmafs is 53% ba;ye;"s
__  ?'"§§ér§f@re,, we f3'";°'s$s,;:*§af $3 3&5 mrrgzjz" 21:2:
  5&5: iése gzwafg were ﬁefizzgzeé g5 51%
::';$:;' 3;' {F25 basygr, Tﬁe §€f§i"§§!'?€§' fag'

AA  "4--. §.'f"§?'P§,§s:§§'§"§{.":'§ {ﬁe gmﬁs :@ 55$ gﬁaaﬁ 9?"
 wf:a§e§5!E §3::zye:' 3;; Erfse vaéysaﬁgé si3ei'§::§s';*;g 5:3 55%:

i
: ' .
 /t

 ':\';nf..',.L7\V_.:>s.»-«ms/zx»'»~»¢n\ma.-1"-m Iv 



 

mzzfséars peifiéigner, But ihizz; doeg nix" maar:

that {he gaeds wefe ééfiveraa' by $528 58558:" at.  
3.539 page 02' $523 buyazj, wsauge in tfsig  
As we have afready grated éhe re;%f§5c:;*s[:VV: 
gyatéégcmer fsaé 3339 zjnafériaken. gncf _-§c;i:31'i!%e;£ﬁ?:";?(':§**"'~ 

the freigfzi Cf"§'&!'§€S fmrr: fi§?€:'.._b£}i:'€:'j3

ffée gwds $5 {he pﬁam 92? the §::..7,.,{é'r._a*r:::.>' i;'i;a:g§f:'ré~

his <;'aﬁ::.*a:;'f§,r 351 3 carri@;"'--5;}""~§ff¢e g :;:'_:_§'§,,_??§ 'Vf:{5é"ir:?~~~ 

undertaken Ea zzrarggpart :"_f}_;é' §Qc1;cj$ £::%'$h¢  553:5
Sf we bays: aim?  Er; -hési. §:i7a?;*3.¢'=;f§f'*yia$ 5 'iééffer
Qf' me gaaaia Tf2z2l~T-'"§"r.;?3§a}ré! . ;f£;é5§_ as the
a§5eg$;"ng . 3f;;:2'_ tfwggém V5§'§§;;ir:.'§§é':e§L»--_§:§.%*f'2«§%;§";r fzrawng
§faZ?£"§'Q§§'§:':$ 4   xjjcgifg;  :'::f "7{*}'?@ mvigfsn
§efi{fé:;§es5,._"'§;zé'"s$ fE%}§'£" :§'f-As ﬁefier 9? mg goaﬁs
:3;?é'1a'Vi"E';e :g'2;"f":V:¢¥:}%V ';:2§"'s*:;%3é;:-E of°'5"::'a"}*r:er cf éhé gaads
f*{'a_zri;ég ::r3:?§::4::;t$7:;-'»T,$f:--:%:':'.s+g;'g?hi chargeg separatefy

f}*Qrr;~--_i:»'*2@ bf{:~;zé;', §3$§--:éfés!§en 55359 a S@!"§eC3::1§ errar

;'§;*:_£s':c1'££,sz.:?}!s7;:};,;~v'§;'2é'- féésfgizi aﬁargeg 5:; E525 safeg
 ';;.:i;2s;3.:;;5r éf=:;"i_--=r'*:--§' gggassfea z2:s§2:'::f% is gaaéénzfy
  ;;;§m"s*&::}:if 5% View 9% the naéggre as' the €Gz"?§;"5C£"

 V. e"s§;%'*"f1:<:;%;i_ez_:?.T'V;£§<2'§"a 5€~3'{'%«"'sf§§;"'§ $23 pariieg ma? :5: vigw :3?'

  $53 §"§'E§ gﬁﬁgffiﬁfiéf $239' cgiﬁegéaﬁ am

~~;";'é;fgE?3 aﬁarggﬁ $533615";-3E'@§}f.

ffféé rm? iggi :3 ﬁg aggsfﬁﬁ £3 §r"'£fi?€§??@§" €325

gﬁgﬁsz: Eggya Qéﬁﬁééf 55 553%?' $5" 55% fggiarjg cf

    

 aA x x §§g Wé &\s&



M12"

axcfaﬂed fmm 5% mrmver af {ﬁg aggegsee far

campufing fhe gaigs ia><:."'

1?, En @133 Case, adméiieéiy :ran$@artat_E_c%%..'éﬁ§*:é§;;j;§s;é~:____" _

B

are inciagded if? the cast wigs. Tberefareg"iE*:'kea.:5§::':'es§%{;.L_ 

Eagﬁgmerai: hag :29 aﬁgiiécatégn m we :i?§§'£?'5 <;§:'t%%[E~S 'r::~ﬁ:§eu*=."'V::"%%~«..  'A

8, in Kurkunta and  St§.r2;e§A[§'.;5)«V"1.; fé*.ES.
Siam af kfarnaéaka :*§::~~§r:e'ﬁ.""_§%%%-I';{f S$§«2]  STE 333

exgiammg me meaning "fa?¥:.ij»e:L'.'%.%x}s$;*@_.~.§é§AA§~.ﬁsjéce, thés Caurt

Eweiéi ag :_§r1éas": ? 

1 '.?wTf--:j_je'f:;:.5é.f@?:?;,.  €379 frangacéfss?
ej:V1f°§{*f*2§J.;§;§:¢ie  ié-.V»j:>fIa=':"eé:'s§g:5::"§/'ea? wiéb reference
§:;:_ éizcé ?'§r§':1*':;:~:§?5.T :%'fT:é!;ecféﬁnﬁiicrz §f' 'safg préce'
En iS€?§L"i§€}f1%  éfmtrai ﬁat, 5:': £859 £29

.~»::<::§§" $3" féeﬁgéf is: 'ﬁéfivery Es ff?%»'§f5§bf§»' gas? of
  Séfé 'saagéﬁeraééaa, €Ti'"§€§'% rm f:..rr:!':@r
  z:;_:;a§£"i§",é';: ___:#m;§Ed arégeg Hawever; gr: 5 sage

« i;r%:'§i'i£_:a=rf{e V5532? mgé 532*" freight as cfaiézxery £3 irzaﬁggﬁad

53;: €f:f*;j::§ ;?e3§e:" ms: Er': 5:55 cagasiégr ag €535 SEf§€2'j,

'~  gs g maféer" sf camvenigsae 55:9' 5;? Eﬁefmff
 §."f'?€ gswghaser, am? if is; .ir;:f9;:?§r:§€r?: sf {Em
:z;>5~:§: Efﬁméﬁf Sf §'§'?& gaaﬁg £5: aggsegizan far §"§"?€
gaffer, 532% 33% §eg:*§s:a' gar: 5;?' Sim ﬁgfiséiéan

E

1.

/' ..,...13...

wmxfa' ﬁe gfirgcfm', 5;: wf:s'¢f? case, §,a,§i§aab§§££*;x :3? am exgiuggrgs wercis fzas m ﬁe ex§m§::ad, "

§, Er: its i¥3§i8i"'%?; cage; Sesiéam 34:35::

éafirsgs Turmver as z_méer:~ ""?"a;:'rsa%ver" meang me a;':;§fs'f;"§'§:f€ '.3?;i'?{§ili-F§f'~"=.__' ., $3: which gyms are §:;f§' @E"*,a?§$ir§!3u§%a%.:.:% :3? V deifzxerea' 9:' aiﬁerwige d§§;:{§Sed 9? :';? 3;'*:;:j';i}fV'i*f§§é' ways ra@fe3§*:*@a' ta :"§fj§ C§§';:s€--..'Z('2§;E..Lb:.z 3' -dsiaféir, either directs? 5:" 'ff?~%s+:.gg;.f> ;s;:%;@z'3€':*:'§fv.r} *£>:;? big awn atwunf §§'".»{Z}E'? arc;:r;'=.n}'f:£:., of C;fCi?¥*§§'§;,V'>~}§?§f.f"'_?'?Efi"§?€f fgr $33!'; 9;' :_fé:9"};;{%é'ferEe§ gpé:~§zm«é§ﬁ%.j_§f s§j,~*'zé :" vafuabie c@§3£:§ér§§'§§$ﬁ',"?V1.__ é:?:§f«.__ :'~r_;§::':";d€-23 M {Em aggregate §;r:--":Q2.;;§'é~.g%§'1~I:gs{f}_éa:"£f::"g§:,é<:§.s§_::§:'§:§p:2r:;'*2a$eaf from 3 gsaerse-F: '§§~i:?:..,_:f9§~3g:§€é§*$Q' _:;;2§ér the Act am' {he ::a%;€:gef-- 82"' _ g}'z:§}§::»ai?.%'§s'~.._:i'r2§::~sfers*ea' gr éeggafcheé _ §é£§S§€f§ 'vzhge- _S€ai*e.. ~~§£"§2erwis& fhgrz $3; wagz 5:? sfféga 5}:2:;'.. iygaﬁﬁest ta such Cﬁﬁﬁfffﬁﬁﬁ ar;§ _ _:%%§§:'{§§:§¢a$ may be wegcribea' S23 amasgni"

gﬁaﬁs: am sofa' gbaff §:""'§£§i,§ﬁ€* ass}! 4 5f;:§;*%iy;§§%_ égéarggﬁ far §:'7§§a'£'2'"?§i?g ﬁagrég $3; §:'%2§ gieafer " x $53; §ie5§§&§§f sf 55$ ggmés mfg' 5:? t§"§€ ifme 9%" gr §:éfs%;»§ gag §?*§?§i2..ﬁ§f§: érféégfﬁgiﬁ M34."

:8' Yherefaye fmm me afaresﬁé ﬁefénéiésng it :3 Sear that Seiiign 4 0%?' the Act whéﬁ: aéaaig with the §%E;t'§§E:§€;:»5V :3 tax aésé ratés 'i§'§€¥'€i;'=§ 9i"Ei§C;%"%b€S that every §,a§:éZ:&%.V'_~zwjfij?é;__VA4 is 0:' Ea regagiraié {Q be ragigtfereej ag sQe£Ef%€§7_-2-s':~E%.§a:t%§s:f}§::._2',zZ* and 2%, sshaﬁ be Bahia ta pay iax, 35%;": h:§'*s.:Tf;9j><3§3.§e"{u':*:2:2xg_'éé:,?1' Theréfare, fast émpasing tax ii:"§T_$":-f2 e::e§5s;~;§:r'y ta fTi':*:é:i_A:3V;_;t 2*~sj'3§i is the turrzgvan As Ea ﬂea? Q"-¥"}§;'E'+i'».§I§'a'?i§ ﬁEf§'i'.i."x:i{'3i'r's, 'i:}_:r:2cvs;e;* means aggregate ameﬂ-r2%iT.fcnf r~.;a:*mt%:'L'v.%g?c%r:sg are gala 0:"

dégiributed G?' ®c--,*"«__.».§&"*=.»f;;ered'1é':*"c{ii¥"sém;'§Lsé .éi$§'é.sé§ 9*? in any 5%"

{E28 xésays :'$€ef';*§§é3l;ig_'_ Er': §;%3é;»:$e {_2;;@ --'}V '5b3}"a"§ea%a:" am mbjact ta gue:§%:~~+r;:>:§%V§::i'o%:-s3__§::z"§"rié'$iri§§i3n§; as may bé p:*es<:ré§e@ the a:%*%.@e.§--s*i*{ .f95 r='j::~;A§é'é:§'-~.<;¥é3~3:§*s5are soézé séﬁaéi énciude any $235215 cha}g;4eé:%_f:§% a:§*:3é:hVé:'ﬁ.;g diam by thg deaiw m wggect Q? ihV{:*'~'.,g;e§§a:%s; §a'§':.:*;.. §: me 'Esme sf £2? ﬁe? re {ha éﬁiazergi ' V5a:V;%é's.»*3:§fe<::f;*.% "?%*':&:*s;%'es"e; aii &;':<i$€%'ES€§ §E"%€é§E"?€§ $2; :;%s*e aissasaée at 'me iime gf éeiévery cw §ef<3:*e ibé é&§§%!€§"§' fE%":@;ra<#;f ':3 §§"%C§%.é§%§ ii": %;%:e zmsaaaser. Ag Ewiﬁf by $22 of 'aim matter; we ﬁé ms: $E% any merit in {mg apgsgeaé, §~€em:e, we 9333 the fmiewing:

QRBER We Q£%i:'EE§Gf"tS aw a£c§ré§r'_:g.%>;.__4dEs_;%é§é$'€;{§;, '_'%7.%1é2-V_ imgugrzed Qréer §a$3e§ by thé; '§f_§*éé:;:;;::é'§~_"'is"

mnfézmeﬁ.

§k$}¥3$§?§$ \ 4;.

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Acc Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 August, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath