Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati
Oce: School Assistant Physical ... vs The Commissioner & Director Of School ... on 2 November, 2020
Author: T. Rajani
Bench: T. Rajani
appounlt 1 | or Zi we / GH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI . " p IN THE Fi (SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISIDICTON) i | MONDAY , THE SECOND DAY OF NOVEMBER. / TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY :PRESE ENT: THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T. RAJANI 1.A No. 1 OF 2020 IN WP NO: 20043 OF 2020 . AN \ |.A No. 1 OF 2020 IN WP NO: 20149 OF 2020 Oce: School Assistant Physical Education, ZPHS, Sreedharagatta, Bommanhal Mandal, Ananthapuram Distr ict. 2 Chitra. Obulesu,S/o.C.Ujjayya, Age:42 years, Occ:School Assistant Phy.Edu, Zphs,Rolla, Rolla Mandal, Anathapuram Dist. V. Ramesh Babu, $/o.V.Venkata Swamy, Age:39 Y ears Occ: School Assistant Phy.Edu. Zphs,Kundurpi, Kundurpi Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist. tad 4. K.Madhu Prasad, S/o.K.Chennaiah, Age:47 years, Oce;School Assistant Phy.Edu.Zphs, Yenumala doddi, Kundurpi Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist. 5 N.Venkata Ramana, S/o.N.Venkatanna, Age:45 Years, Occ:School Assistant Phy.Edu,Zphs Pamudurthi, Bukkapatnam Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist. 6 S VenkataRamana Naik, s/O.Narayana Naik, Age:45 Yesrs, Oce:School Assistant Phy.Edu, Zphs, Kummaranage Palli, Gudibanda Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist. 7 NS.N.V.Hema Devi,D/o.N.V.G.Krishna Rao, Age:42 Years, Occ: School Assistant Phy.Edu,Zphs, Cheemala padu, A.KOnduru mandal, Krishna Dist. | 8 M.Miriyala Sai kumar, S/o.M. Pandu ranga Rao,Age:43 Years Occ: School Assistant Phy.Edu,ZPHS Edara, Agiripalli Mandal,Krishna Dist. 9 K.Geetha D/o.K. Venkateswara Rao Age;44 Years, Occ: S.A. Phy.Edu, Zphs Nandigama, Nandigama Mandal, Krishna Dist. 10 Nan.§.k.Bhsakar, S/o. N.R. Mohan Age:43 Years, Occu:$.A.Phy,Edu,Zphs, Vissanapeta, Vissannapeta Mandal, Krishna Dist. ie é 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 23 K.srinivasa Rao S/o K.Gopala Swamy Age:52 Years, Occu:S.A. Phy. Edu,ZPHS Kammapau, A.Konduru Mandal, Krishna Dist. Sowthani SubbaRao,S/o.S.Sundhara Rao Age:52 Years, Occe:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs Polavaram, Chatarai Mandal, Krishna Dist. Ganta Venkateswara Rao, S/o.G.Bhadraiah, Age:52 Years, Oce:S,.A. phy.Edu,Zphs, Chillakallu, Jaggayyapeta Mandal, Krishna Dist. T.Kondala Rao,S/o.T. Kumara Swamy,Age:43 Years, Oce:$.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs Bramhana palli, Piduguralla mandal, Guntur Dist. C.Rajesh,S/o.Narasimha Rao,Age:43 Years, Occ:S.A.Phy.Edu,ZPhs Julakallu, Piduguralla Mandal, Guntur Dist. R.Subba Rao,S/o.Nagendraiah, Age:48 Years, Occ:8.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs Machavaram, Machavaram Mandal, Guntur Dist. A.Baju,$/o.A.Krishna Rao ,Age:35 Years, Occ:§8.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs, Gummanam padu,Bollapalli Mandal, Guntur Dist. (3.Sailaza,D/o.G.Simon,Age:54 Years, Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs,Epuru, Epuru Mandal] Guntur Dist. K.Ravi Krishna, Age:45 Years, Oce:$.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, POeda Kadamagunda, Karampudi Mandal, Guntur Dist. K. Srinivasa Rao,S/o.K.Uma Maheswara Rao, Age:39 Years, | Oce:$.A.Phy. Edu, Zphs Tangeda, Dachepalli mandal, Guntur Dist. D.Syamala Devi,D/o.D.Madava Rao,Age;51 Years, Occe:§.A. Phy.Edu, Zphs Vempuram, Machavaram Mandal, Guntur Dist. K. Vijaya Lakshmi D/O.Dhanunjaya Rao, Age;44 Years, Oce:$.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs Mor} ampadu, Machavaram Mandal, Guntur Dist. M.Ch.Prasada Rao, S/o . Ramu Naidu, Age;46Years, Occ:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs D.Yerravarm, Nathavaram mandal, Visakhapatnam Dist. 24. U.Lakshmi,D/o.U.Tata Rao, Age; 40Years, 4 Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs, Nakkapalli, co Nakkapalli Mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 25. K.Ravi,S/o.K.A.Rama murthy,Age;44Years, Occ:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs 8. Rayavaram, S.Rayavaram Mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 26 B.Varalakshmi,D/o.B.Akku Naidu,Age; 40 Years, Occ:S$.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs Burugupalem, Burugupalem Mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 27 P.Ramachandra Reddy, S/o. Satya narayana Reddy, Age:39 Years, Occ:$.APhy.Edu, Zphs, Kothakota, Ravi kamatam Mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 28 P.Srinivasa Rao, S/o. Lakshmanna late, Age:50 Years, Occ:S.A.phy.edu, Zphs, Dorlapudi, : S.Rayavaram Mandal, Visakapatnam. Dist 29 G.Lavanya, D/o.G.Venkata Ramana,Age:3 | Years, Oce:S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs, J.Naidupalem, Rolugunta, Visakapatnam Dist. 30 M.Koteswara Rao,S/O.Yeri naidu, Age;40 Ys, Occ:S.a.PHY.Edu,Zphs Nathavaram, Nathavara m Mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 31 Ch.Babu rattan, S/o. Ch.Rayappa, Age;52 Years, Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs Pudimadaka, Atchutapuram mandal, Visakapatnam Dist. 32 B. Appala Raju, S/o. B.Appa Rao, Age:39 Years, Oce: §.A. Phy.Edu, Zphs, Etikoppaka, Yelamanchali 'Mandal, Visakapatnam, Dist. 33--C iD. Balaramaiah,S/o.Kondaiah,Age:41 Years, Occ:8.A.phy.edu, Zphs, Tellapadu, Donakonda. Mandal, Prakasam, Dist. 34 C.Veera Narayanamma, S/o.Ch.Sarabhaiah, Age:47 Years, Occ:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, Gotlagattu, Konakametla Mandal, Prakasam, Dist. 35 P.Vijaya Kumar,S/o, Satyanarayana, Age:43 Years, Occ:S.A Phy.Edu,Zphs Mallampeta, Donakonda mandal, Prakasam Dist 36 §.Peeran Saheb »S/o.S.Hussain Peera,Age;42 Years, Occ:$.A.Phy.edu, Zphs, Galizerugulla, Bestavaripeta. mandal, Prakasam Dist. 37 38 40 41 42 43 44 | 45 46 AT 48 49 -U.Hanumantha Rao, S/o.U.Punnaiah, Age:44 Years, Occ: §.A. Phy.Edu, Zphs, Pullalacherevu, Pullalacheruvu mandal, prakasam Dist. S.Suseela Pasam, D/o.Guntaiah, Age;41 Years, Oce:S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs Tripuranthakam, Thripuranthakam mandal, prakasam Dist. T. Yakobu,S/oVokkaiah, Age:48 Years, Occ:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, Veerabhadrapuram, Yerragondapalem. Mandal, Prakasam Dist. P.Kousalya,D/o.P.Malakondaiah, Age:43 Years, Occ;S.A.Phy.edu, Zphs Venuguladinnepadu, Peddaraveedu Mandal,Prakasm, Dist. B.Lalithamba, D/o.B.RamaDasu,Age:3 6Y ears, Oce;$.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, Eedara, Mundlamaru Mandal,Prakasam, Dist. N.T Prasad,S/o.Venkateswarlu,Age:44 Years, Oce:8.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs,Mogallur, Veligondla Mandal, Prakasam, Dist. K.Narasimha Rao,S/o. Chenchaiah,Age:40 Years, Occ: §.APhy Edu, Zphs DonaKonda, Donakonda manda! ,Prakasam, Dist. Y Srinivasa ,$/o.Krishna Murthy,Age:43 Years, Oce:$.APhy.Edu,Zphs, Velicheru, Atreyapuram Mandal, East Godavari, Dist. D.Prasanna Kumar , S/o. Narayana, Age:41 years. Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs, Burugupudi, Krilampudi Mandal, EastGodavari, Dist. C.Pradeep Kumar, S/o. G.Deya Arpimani, Age:42 Years, oce:S.A Phy.Edu, Zphs, Mallisala, Jaggampeta mandal, East Godavari Dist. P.Srinivasa Rao,S/o.Padmanabham, Age:42 Years, Occ:S.A Phy.Edu, Zphs , Lampakalova, prathipadu mandal, East Godavari Dist. kK Ramanna Dora, S/o.Gangaraju dora,Age:40 Years, Occ:S.A.phy.Edu,Zphs, Bhimavarapukota, Kotananduru Mandal, East Godavari, Dist. D.Dharma Sekhar , S/o. Mohana rao, Age: 43 Years, Occ:8.A. Phy Edu, Zphs Kandikuppa, Katrenikona, Mandal, East Godavari, Dist. 50 53 54 55 57 59 60 61 62 M.srinivasaRao, S/o.MohanRao, Age:43 Years, Occ: S.A Phy.Edu, Zphs, Pallam, Katrenikona Mandal, East Godavari, Dist. G.Srinivasa Rao, S/o.Satya Narayana Age;42 Years, Occ; S.A.phy.edu, Zphs P.kottam, Kotanandur, mandal, East Godavari, Dist. M.Ravi Bhushan Rao, S/o. M.V.V. S.N.Murthi, Age:48 Years, Occ: $.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs Katrenikona, Katrenikona Mandal, East Godavari, Dist. K.Raj Kumar,S/o. K.Tata Rao, Age:38 Years, Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, Machara , Kapileswarapuram. Mandal, East Godavari Dist. A. Rama Krishna S/o.Satyanarayana, Age:41 Years, Oce:S.A PhyEdu, ZphsTurputallu,Narasapuram. Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. G.Divakar,S/o.Musalaiah,Age:45 Years, Oce:$.A.Phy.Edu,Zphs,Perupalem. Mogalthuru, Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. N. Vijaya Santhi, D/o. Narayana Reddy, Age:35 Years, Occ:$.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs KallaKalla, Kallakalla. Mandal. West Godavari, Dist. C.Suresh Kumar ,S/o.Aseerwadam, Age:40Years, Oce:S.A.Phy.Edu, Zphs, Siddantam, Penugonda. Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. A.Venkateswara Rao,S/o.Krishna Murthy, Age:38 Years, Oce:$.A-Phy.Edu,Zphs,Chinnayagudem, Devarapalli Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. B.N.Venkata pradeep, S/o.Mallikarjuna Rao, Age:35 Years, : Oce:S.A.Phyedu, Zphs Haparru , penugunda mandal, west Godavari, Dist. B.Durga Rani,D/o. Veerabhadra Rao, Age:43 Years, Occ:$.A.PhyEdu,Zphs Parimpudi, Koyyalagudem Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. K. Vara Lakshmi,D/o.Prasad Babu,Age:33 Years, Oce:SA PhyEdu, Zphs, Seesali, Kalla Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. V.D.Sivaji devarapu,S/ o.Nuka Raju, Age:40 Years, Oce:S.A.PhyEdu, Zphs Elurupadu, Kalla Mandal, West Godavari, Dist. 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 74 75 Y .Devendra, S/o.Ankanna, Age:38 Years, Oce:S A Phy edu, Zphs Perusomala, Sanjamala, Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. C.Nagendra, S/o C.c.narasimhulu, Age:40 Years, Occ:S A Phy EDu, Zphs, Chinna Vangali, Chagalamarri. Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. D.Swamanna, S/o. D.Narasimhulu, Age:39 Years, Occ:S A Phy Edu, Zphs, Srisailam, Thudicherla, villege, Jupadu Bunglow Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. J. Bala Krishna ,S/o. J.Pamulatey, Age:43 Years, Occ: S A Phy,edu, Zphs Kamavaram, Kowthalam Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. M.Suresh Naidu, M. Nagasanjeevarayudu,Age:37 Years, Occ:S A Phy,edu, ZPHs Velugodu, Velugodu Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. M Shaiksha Valli, S/o. Jainullabdin, Age:34 Years, Occ: S$ A Phy. Edu, Zphs, Kolimigundla, Chagalamarri mandal, Kurnool, Dist. V Ranga swamy, s/o Ranganna Age :40 Years, Occ: SA phy Edu, Zphs, Ankireddypalli, Kolimigundla. Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. C.Suvamamma, D/o.C.Pedda Balaiah Age:37 Years, Occ:$ A Phy Edu,Zphs Koilakuntla, koilakuntla mandal, Kurnool, Dist. N. Venkata Suresh, S/0.Pedda Sunkanna, Age:39 Years, Oce:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Girls Athmakur, Athmakur Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. K.Chandra ,S/o. Maddilety, Age:40 Years, Oce:$ A phy Edu, Zphs Nossam, Sanjamala. mandal, Kurnool, Dist. K.Vishnu Vardhan Reddy, S/o.Jarami Reddy, Age; 43 Years, | Occ: $ A phy edu, Zphs Halaharvi, Halaharvi Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. G. Sreedhar Kumar, S/o.G. Subramanyam, Age:49 Years, Occ:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Pedda Harivanam, Adoni Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. B.Maheswari Bai, D/o.B.Brama Naik,Age:34 Years, Oce:$ A Phy Edu, Govt.High School, Sunnipenta, Erraguduru Villege, Pamulapadu Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. 76 77 78 79 80 | 383 84 85 86 87 88 C.Sumalatha,D/o. Praveen Kumar , Age 37 Years, - Oce:S a Phy edu, Zphs Owk, Owk Mandal, Kurnool, Dist. S.Vinod, $/o. Subramanyam Naidu, Age:43 Years. Occe:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Gonugur, Kuppam mandal, Chittoor, Dist. M. Hari Krishna, S/o. Sankarachari, Age: 49 Years, Occ:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Vasanadu, Kuppam Mandal. Chittoor, Dist. L.Suneetha .D/o. Chinnabba Naidu, Age:39 Years, Occ: S A Phy edu, Zphs Girls Kuppam, Kuppam Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. P.T.Prakasam, S/o. Thyagarajan, Age: 41 Years, Occ: S A Phy Edu, Zphs, T.Sadumur, Kuppam. Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. C.Maha Rani, D/O. Chengalarayachari, Age:55 Years, Oce:S A Phy Edu, Zphs , Matlayaripalli, Ramasamudram. Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. S.P.Sreenivasulu, S/o.S.Padmanabhan, Age; 49 Years, Oce:S A Phy Education, Zphs Rama Samudram, Ramasamudram mandal, chittoor, Dist. M.Lokanadham,S/o. Venkatesaiah, Age: 41 Years, Occ: § A Phy Edu, Zphs Chandam, Kuppam Mandal, Chittoor Dist. P.Udaya kumar, S/o.Govinda Swamy, Age:43 Years, Oce:S a phy edu, Zphs, Gonumakulapalli, V kota Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. V.Durga Devi,D/o.PattabhiRami Reddy, Age:39 Years, Occ;S A phy Edu, Zphs V.Kota, V.Kota Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. J Hari S/o. Narayana Mandadi, Age;4l Years, Occ: § A Phy edu, Zphs Yamaganipalli, Gudupalli. mandal, chittoor, Dist. | M.Chengalrayalu,S/o.M.naraiah, Age:44 Years, Oce:S A Phy edu, zphs, gudupalli, gudupalli mandal, chittoor, Dist. P.Ramesh Babu, S/o.Ragavaiah, Age;41 Years, Oce:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Kalicherla, Peddamandyam mandal, chittor, Dist. 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 | 98 99 100 101 P.Chandra Sekhar, S/o. Venkata Ramana Reddy, Age:42 Years, Oce;S A Phy Edu, ZPHS chembakusu , Ramasamudram mandal, Chittoor, Dist. Ch.Mahesh babu, S/o. Sadanandham, Age:53 Years, Oce:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Ponnangur, kuppam, mandal, Chittoor, Dist. N.Sateesh Babu, S/o. haron, Age :41 Years, Occ; S A Phy Edu, Zphs Adavibuduguru, KUppam mandal, chittoor, Dist. P.S.Siva Kumar, S/o.Sambandam, Age:41 Years, Occ; S A phy edu, Zphs, N idigunta, Peddapanjani mandal, chittoor, Dist. G.Lokeswar,S/o.Nataraja, age;44 Years, Oce;S A Phy Edu, Zphs, Rallabhudugur, Santhipuram mandal, chittoor, Dist. D.Sasikala, D/o Lakshmi Narayana Age:37 Years, Oce;S A Phy Edu, Zphs Girls B.Kothakota, B.Kothakota mandal ,Chittoor, Dist. K.m Adarsha sathesh,S/o. Munikrishna pillai, Age :44 Years, Occ:S A phy Edu, Zphs Settipalli, Gudupalli mandal, Chittor, Dist. N.Hemadri, S/o Narayana Swamy, Age:40 Years, Occ:S A Phy Edu, Zphs Lakkanapalle, Bairddypalle Mandal, Chittoor, Dist. C.Vani, D/o. Ramachandraiah, Age: 38 Years, Occ; S A Phy du, Zphs, CTM, Madanapalli mandal, Chittoor, Dist. R.Lali Praveena, D/o. Joseph Rufus Xavier, Age:40 Years, Oce: S A Phy Edu, Zphs, Mettu, Chittamur Mandal, Nellore, Dist. B.Udaya bhaskar, S/o. Brahmaiah, Age: 43 Years, Occ; § A Phy Edu, Zphs, kondapuram, Kondapuram mandal, Nellore, Dist. G.Arjuna Rao, S/o. Pichaiah, age;56 Years, Oce; S A Phy edu, Zphs, Varagali, Chillakur mandal, Nellore, Dist. R. Anjaiah,S/o. Penchelaiah, Age;48 Years, Occ; S A phy edu, Zphs, Ananthasagaram, Ananthasagaram Mandal, Nellore, Dist. 105 106 107 108 109 110 11 112 113 114 J.sateesh, s/o.Janaki Ramaiah, Age:46 Years, Oce: $ a phy edu, Zphs marripadu, Marripadu mandal, Nellore, Dist. P. Ravi Babu, s/o. Eliya, Age;42 Years, Oce; S a phy edu, Zphs, Chamadala, Jaladanki mandal. Nellore, Dist. S Venkata Ramana, S/o.Raminiadu, Age: 41 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Battali, Battali mandal, Srikakulam Dist. K. Beenargi Kumar, S/o.Swamy Naidu Age: 39 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs, P L Puram, Meliaputti_ mandal, Srikakukam Dist. R. Hareesh Naidu, S/o. Durga Varaprasad, Age: 40Years, Oce;8.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Koligam, Ichapuram. Mandal , Srikakulam Dist M. Ramesh, S/o. Ramurthy, Age: 37 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs, Manikyapuram, Kaviti mandal, Srikakulam Dist. P. Eswara Rao, S/o. Suryanarayana, Age: 43 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs, Karaj ada, Meliaputti mandal, Srikakulam Dist. P. Phalguna Rao, S/o.Latsanna, Age: 47 Years, Occ;8.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Amalapadu, Vejrapu Kotturu, mandal, Srikakulam,Dist. Y. Dhanalaxmi, D/o. Venkatanaidu, Age: 36 Years, Occ;S.A-phy.Edu, Zphs,Donkuru, Ichapuram mandal, Srikakula Dist. T. Laksjmana Rao, S/o.Parasaram, Age:48 Years, Occ;S.A.phy. Edu, Zphs,Gonakapadu, Sompete mandal, Srikakula Dist. R. Srinivas Rao, $/o.Appala Swami, Age:35 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Baruva, Sompate mandal, Srikakulam,Dist. M. Vamaravelli, S/o.Mrutyunjayam, Age:49 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Mamidipalli, | Mandasa, mandal, Srikakulam,Dist. K. Maheswara Rao, S/o.Surappadu, Age:39 Years, Oce;S.A.phy-Edu, Zphs,Rangol, Palasa, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. 115 116 117 118 119 120 122 123 And S. Rambabu, S/o.Sankara Rao, A ge:36 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Rajapuram, Kaviti, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. P. Venkata Ramana, S/o:Chinna Ramanna,Age:5 1 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Silagam, Kaviti, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. P. Surupunaidu, S/o.Appayya, Age:39 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Baluru, Palakonda, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. K. Suryanarayana, S/o.Ramaguruvulu, Age:46 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Borivanka, Kaviti, mandal ,Srikakulam, Dist. S. Venkataramana, S/o.Harinarayana, Age:42 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Kaviti, Kaviti, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. B. Tirupathi Venkateswara Rao, S/o.Ramanayya, Age:46 Years, Occ;S.A-phy.Edu, Zphs,R. Belagam, Kaviti, mandal, Srikakulam, Dist. Ch. Vasudevarao, S/o.Papayya, Age:50 Years, Occ;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Edupuram, Ichapuram, mandal, Srikkulam, Dist. D. Yasoda, D/o.Jaganadham, Age:45 Years, Oce;S8.A.phy.Edu, Zphs, Veeraghattamm, Veeraghattamm, mandal, Srikakulam,Dist. B. Syamaleswari Patnaik, S/o.Satyanarayana, Age:36 Years, Oce;S.A.phy.Edu, Zphs,Hukumpeta, Vajrapukotturu, mandal, SrikakulamDist. ___ Petitioners The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Department of School Education, Room No:267, 1"Floor, 4" Block, A.P Secretariat Office, V elagapudi Guntur District - 522237 The Commissioner & Director of School Education, Government of Andhra Pradesh, Sri Anjaneya Towers, Road No. 7-104, B-Block, 4'" Floor, N.T.T.P.S. Road, Ibrahimpatnam, Vijayawada --521456 ___ Respondents Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings in pursuance of G.O.Ms.No.54 School Edn (Services. Il) Dept dt.12.10.2020 and consequential orders bearing Rc.No.13029/11/2020 EST 3 dt.14.10.2020 issued by the 2"¢ Respondent, pending disposal of WP No. 20043 of 2020, on the file of the High Court. 1.A No. 1 OF 2020 IN WP NO: 20149 OF 2020 Between: 4. MHemalatha, S/o. MSiva Sankar, aged about 43 yeas, Rio. ZPHS, Godasalapalli. D.Hirehal Mandal, Ananthapuram, District. 2. G. Anitha,, S/o. Anjaneyulu, aged about 45 years,R/o. ZPHS, Godasalapalli , D,Herehal Mandal,Ananthapuram Dist M.Mohammad Ikram Hussain, ,S/o. M.A.Majeed,aged about 46 years,R/o. ZPHS, Gudibanda, Gudibanda Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist S.Gohar Jahan, S/o. S.Abdul Khadar,aged about 42 years,R/o. Bommanhal, Bommanhal Mandal,Ananthapuram Dist. S Karimunnisa, S/o. S.Mohiuddin aged about 48 years,R/o. Zphs Madhudi , Agali Mandal,Ananthapuram Dist . K Muralidhar, S/o. K.Muthyalo Rao,aged about 46 years,R/o. Zphs Neekantapuram, Madakasira Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist Y Sreedhar Reddy, S/o. Y.Adinarayana Reddy,aged about 51 years,R/o. Zphs,Uddehal, Bommanahal Mandal ,Ananthapuram Dist A Aruna Kumari, ,S/o. A.V.Raghava Reddy, aged about 46 years,R/o. Zphs Inagaluru, Agali Mandal, Ananthapuram Dist Matla Narasinga Rao, S/o. M.Kannayya,aged about 58 years,R/o. ZPHS, Pedabodu Gallam, Nakkapalli Mandal, Visakhapatnam District 10.Chawakula Chandrakala, S/o. Thavudu, aged about 42 years,R/o. ZPHS, Rambilli, Visakhapatnam District 41. Jeeru Bala Raju Reddy, S/o. Rama Rao Reddy,aged about 43 years,R/o. ZPHS, Gudivada, S.Rayavaram Mandal, Visakhapatnam District 42.Tamatapu Arasavalli, Suryanarayana, S/o. . Kondbabu,aged about 47 years,R/o. ZPHS, Dimili, Rambilli Mandal, Visakhapatnam District oon one & _..Petitioners (Petitioner in WP 20149 OF 2020 on the file of High Court) AND 4. The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Department of School Education, Room No267, 1stFloor, 4th Block, A.P Secretariat Office, Velagapudi Guntur District - 522237 2. The Commissioner AND Director of School Education,, Government of Andhra Pradesh, Sri Anjaneya Towers, Road No. 7-104, B-Block, 4th Floor, N.T.T.P.S. Road, Ibrahimpatnam, Vijayawada 521456 ...Respondent(s) (Respondents in-do-) Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings in pursuance of G.O.Ms.No.54 School Edn (Services. Il) Dept dt.12.10.2020 and consequential orders bearing Rc.No.13029/11/2020 EST 3 dt.14.10.2020 issued by the 24 Respondent, pending disposal of WP No. 20149 of 2020, on the file of the High Court. The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of Sri Srinivas Bobbili, Advocate for the Petitioners in both petitions and of GP for Education for the Respondents in both petitions, the Court made the following ORDER:
By filing these petitions, writ petitioners seek this court to stay of all further proceedings in pursuance of G.O.Ms.No.54, School Edn (Services.II) Department, dated 12.10.2020, and consequential orders bearing Rce.No.13029/11/2020 EST-3, dated 14.10.2020, issued by the 2™ respondent, pending disposal of the above writ petitions.
At the hearing, the petitioners' counsel, however, seeks this court to make an interim order directing the respondents to show all the posts created under G.O.Ms.No.144, Finance (HR.ID Department, dated 02.08.2016 (GO-144), and G.O.Ms.No.91, School Education (Services.I1) Department, dated 17.12.2016 (GO-
91), in the ensuing teachers' transfer counseling.
Heard the counsel for the petitioners and the Government Pleader for School Education.
The petitioners are working as School Assistants in languages. They were initially appointed as SGTs and language pandits under DSCs and later they were promoted as School Assistants in the month of July, 2019. The petitioners are eligible for promotion to the post of School Assistants (Languages), as per G.O.Ms.No.11, dated 23.01.2009, and G.O.Ms.No.12, dated 23.01.2009. While so, the Government issued G.O.Ms.No.15, dated 05.02.2017, amending the rules by declaring that SGTs are not eligible for promotion to the post of School Assistant (Languages). The petitioners then approached the Administrative Tribunal by way of O.A.No.317 of 2017, which was allowed by directing the respondents to fill up all the vacancies available prior to the date of the amendment i.e.,G.0.Ms.No.15, dated 05.02.2017. The said judgment was upheld by the High Court by judgments, dated 03.10.2017 and 11.12.2018, which was confirmed by the Supreme Court by its order, dated 08.04.2019, while dismissing the SLP preferred by the respondents. The respondents promoted the petitioners as School Assistants in July, 2019. But as per the Rules 'in force, they should be promoted in the month of August, 2017 along with other similarly situated SGTs/Language Pandits Gr.II, who were promoted in the month of August, 2017. It is due to the fault of the respondents that the petitioners were promoted in the month of July, 2019 and the petitioners lost more than two years of service. By issuing GO-91, the respondents created 10224 posts of School Assistants (Languages). Even then respondents did not consider their case for promotion to the post of School Assistants (Languages). In fact, they were promoted in the month of July, 2019 against the posts created under GO-
144. But due to the fault of the respondents, the petitioners lost more than two years service. By issuing G.O.Ms:No.91, School Education (Services.1]) Department, dated 17.12.2018, respondents created 10224 posts of School Assistants (Languages). Even then, respondents did not consider their case for promotion to the post of School Assistant (Languages). In fact, they were promoted in the month of July, 2019 against the posts created under G.O.Ms.No.144 though by that time, further 10224 posts were created under G.O.Ms.No.91, dated 17.12.2018. By this action of the respondents, the petitioners were posted in the left over vacancies under GO-144, and they were not given the benefit of choosing the vacancies created under GO-91. The petitioners are entitled to be promoted in the month of August, 2017, along with their contemporaries. Due to their non- consideration, they lost the benefits of opting the places of their transfer The Government Pleader does not deny the fact that the petitioners approached the Tribunal and were successful in getting a direction to the respondents, as stated above, and that the writ petition preferred by the respondents was dismissed confirming the order of the Administrative Tribunal and the Supreme Court dismissed the SLP, which was preferred by the respondents confirming the order of the Administrative Tribunal.
It can be understood from the above admitted fact that the delay was only due to the respondents not acting in accordance with law. Hence, the petitioners cannot be deprived of the opportunity that they are entitled for with regard to the opting of the place of posting.
The Government Pleader submits that until the petitioners complete two years service, as required by the guidelines for transfer of teachers, they cannot be included in the counseling, which is scheduled on 20.11.2020. But it is evident that the petitioners could not complete the two years service, only because they were being driven to court by the action of the respondents, which is found to be not in accordance with law.
Hence, this court opines that ends of justice would be met if the respondents are directed to show all the posts created under GO-144 and GO-91 in the ensuing transfer counseling. | In view of the above, these petitions are accordingly ordered.
'Sd/- K. JAGANMOH N DEPUTY REGISTRAR ITTRUE COPYI// | C4 SECTION 'OFFICER, To -
4. The Principal Secretary, Department of School Education, State of Andhra Pradesh, Room No267, 1stFloor, 4th Block, A.P Secretariat Office, Velagapudi Guntur District - 522237
2. The Commissioner AND Director of School Education|, Government of Andhra Pradesh, Sri Anjaneya Towers, Road No. 7-104, B-Block, 4th Floor, N.T.T.P.S. Road, lbrahimpatnam, Vijayawada 521456 (1 & 2 by RPAD) One CC to Sri Srinivas Bobbili, Advocate [OPUC] Two CCs to GP for Education,High Court of Andhra Pradesh. [OUT] One spare copy Rw tvr e Zé HIGH COURT TRJ DATED:02/11/2020 ORDER |.A No. 1 OF 2020 IN WP NO: 20043 OF 2020 AND |.A No. 1 OF 2020 IN WP NO: 20149 OF 2020 ORDERED