Karnataka High Court
Genu @ Ganu S/O Pemu vs Jalabai W/O Genu @ Ganu on 7 November, 2008
Bench: N.Kumar, Jawad Rahim
EE TEE Efifififi €§$"€3R"'§' $F " " '
E}h'§'E{%"£'ir~HS 'E'HE W _§:m' {;}§m9vE%¢§§xz«:§I§'; ma V
V " 'V
'mm §§@§§'Ffi§;§.a$ a§:§§§;~J§§&'§fE"§@§ E "
A " A'
n 3. 4' §§f_': §.$£ifif2®% mt;
V. V
Sjc»'Pe.=:m:2'~._ »
" Agftd 53553-.V§"£%i%£"f£ W
(L-»:7;x':1ds ;}m;§-ma aQga'%:%1Eh1r'e
3 " u.sham;es;aba:
_W~f 0 (Exam: " """ " 'V
' ymm
" » Ggtzvxggaeatian: Hfl'i.E$€
§<i:%amé,%:;.fim€
.- E73; (fimu
_Age~. 3&3 yemfi
" . iaiicctlgmfian: E-Eaumhsafl
" , Duiiabafi
W} 0 Smzajaa
Di 0 Cfzsrrrnu
Age 3'?) years
ii'>csa"e2z2'g.a»s;m'?e:»n: Eioufiaehaki
.3 §:§}3i*i:a_;73? E
S} 2:) Gena
V "fZ?<x.%i§§Ja$iéi2
Ag: 26 ymm
Gcwcrupmion
Eiammh
S} 0 {f':€:::m.%.
skge "25 ymm
Qccupatésm
Sumfih
S} (3: {Emma
Agar 21% ymm
Qmazpama
Raiméh ._
3,99 «smug; '
Pugs:
q.Zj§*;€;sii'a3Z:b&e:iif:'-~ >
V Eff; Géviml' .. W
?%$;e'%16 yéem. " .
:_;;'€:~'= 0:" "
' 'V z£%.§Jz§.:m§};:~:s,;t. 1'€e3.3.v
rigs: Mn@ Thmxda
~ '*a5mmg¢'«.S $
A' ' ». j*§'§ agm.::zsm..
4.13.333 3' '§:'.3v3
£33' 33% ~''% 3 .: :.:~: '~
§}a;.i'§i.3;}_;A 1
Jammi
Win Emma @ (Exam:
Agar: 4'? yrram
fifiomapamaz Hmzwhafi
Sufihimbai
£3; :3 €}::°:m3 {gig} {Em};
W} is
fige: 2?' ymm *
{3«r:s:;eum£;§<:an,: §§011a=«a:ha:ski
W; 0 Rmlrm
gay: 26 ytram u
€.}«::{:up»~;ae,z:.§u:m: }~Im.13she:m;___
4% Stanitabai
Wjce Kain _
Age: $.24 '_§'€'?:3:1','73 H ' VV
€_}gx:ups:;fi=:,:_n: §%:x:av.st§a=:.}ici_
£P:.24m;1:9:§3z:§;?£L__-.'_ ' _ "
.Ef§=i i£:v {I¥¢»::;:1g'a§':{TgE.. " :
" "'€;1::<_:1};;;&a'3;i€:i::a: -- Eéazafieheyki "
ESE
Aifiviaam *5} ¢} u';§';%3;a;§I; a7¢*§ 'u'ififig@
Shzizxivaa ax §:>r"ea~?;§a:€lm;'E;'
8,! £2 IFE'aua::g0;a_ '§'<;Mf_ gemsri Biat
¢'j;~§:3§>s:1~gaL" _ Raasapcrnflmfiz m
. . x{E'§§»"'fi:3? Vmmah £3 Pafil, Admmm}
:';a:;2--1_.%am., is mm marfirzir Smtimz 3'£3(3;} m' FC Ac: agaixmt
--. 3 and datérd 23v~a@~2€§=E3'? yaswd 7m 6%
'§"~kz=,;Q{F'U11 flat E39: :15 the £}:l::s&g*§cl éutgigey Fmzaiiy {iuux'E,
«.{}a:flmrgaf,.' dmmeing the: smi: flied '&'3%'§df:'r <m"i¢=:r Vii Risk 3 0?'
€':P*{;§'Qr £iac:im'afi<>x1, pamfien am: inggunmimx.
Thin M'§31A. mymng ma fin»: Euvazing this day,
" _ V ?m»mmAR J., éefivemd ma faiibwiaag:
a}§3Q§_%§ET
Thzia is dafmdants apw}. afisi the fiaadgmemt am}
daztrzxsm paasewd 'by 3.2:: Famiiy {E-amt, zimmeing rm wait af 5116'
; E '
1': /"/
'Y.w»"/
._-%f§:aIr«, in we 3% defmdam.
pim5.n.téfi"3 far pmfiiion and 7.
infiuxzgtfimn.
'"§'.he tszemc mi' 'afimt
wazisiafi wifi: of the: ix» 5 mm
tin: chiidmn mm is; has dmarrmd the
piaimaéfis. 3% 423$ p§.ainh?%
$3042 in '§'he 1" pfimimfifi'
is i,n.d¢%Ef3i:fi'::- fiéfendaxai awmd in mkr:
_'::<r diachmga the aaid mm. flaw
he me? faflafi 359 3%}! ma: mxaemmt m
€332 V.
aiefmdamt hag; maxw .' am, Shmmiaflaz". Ska £15:
Ha anéfimi mm smmmé
A iwréthnui Ehc Emszrwfiadgc azmi Gamma: 9%' ma piaéntififi.
Hm? £13313 1" {ix-:faand.a2m is mmpietaigr amém" ma mum} and
" I Lgmgidmam nf his mmmd wifa, Shaxwabai. arm 1*" datfmdami ia
mat pmviding my mmimaam an" gvmg any akaam Im the wit
wzhaéufia pmpamless. The: phamfififi am 3333 mamham ef the
Himiu undivkied fmnfiy easf mm 13' fiefmgdani". 'fix gait
._" 'aha marri-£.wa
~. 's;:m x§%§i @_{3§uVA:$i?§Vdiv§£§:xi fmfm. famiiy .
ymperizim am the anmafiai amd.<j¢::»:§:a:;*£i. famnifi fimé T x
yixirxfifia amfi that $3' é£?f€B1§a€£1%T."" 'E5?{§«?r:"
irzcfiapenssként fight £9 03" :mm,;;a%
pmperbim £9 my athm" fess a mmum"
that, the 1*" fi&fmfl3é;f'::ia _a§émafit¢ the gnnwrtém, €23
rasafeguasrfi thfizigr gyxmnt mm. far
iparfihfoxa am? p»,r:;§.--m3{=.2.?ia:.:§fi 2 ._
fir. T1;Ie% §@tm€§@d written amiamaani
ififi V%'**- piainfifi' Em mm; the kgfi
N92 in 5 am nut. ham hr:-s hm.
V;q§a:;1¢2Afi'£,1?0;5zz?..L%2fi" desmting timm aiifi not fie
wiifla Gflfi Shmmiaahai and having thzm
' " +§i;augh?é:e:.t*.':\. frcmx" sang. The: p§a§m?'ifi"s am nu'; ma memimm mi
The pmysermaa am gimmfimg
néma {If Shzsezmaémi. Wm pafiainfififi am mi at afi
.. , with the suit mhefluk ymyemes any mam. Was
VV '~--j§e§;ir§_i1+'.:*h?fi"a am maiaiing in Pmmgaan viiiaga, taiuk and ziiaufmt,
Guihmga. '§"h@*_§a 33?: net fm m:é3;=.%£::33iwx: af tfim jaamt famfiy
pmgxzmnlas. Thcy am 11% cnfitfim is i£5"~k aham in 'tfifi 53.3%?
N.
.1
Q 'L' /J, .»
M
av"
mhe':€1'uk: pmperty. That 322%: J?/23?? is 7.
amfi dmmmm to he aiifimismd,
3"}, 'firm dafendantfi ?'3'fl.2 "f§ ";Q5 what «same? mm
Smt. Sharmiabai b;-;:':3€*' "fiub3eqs2mmflj§*-'
ixtzpficmmfi R3 pm"fim' ir:u"] & mpmaam wxétmn
smmment ma 3:" defezadani.
Thay imjrc flag wrfim ass mmut.
in the :f : mat the wait 5% not
fiimzri at Qmiizumw $3 ma:
$0 my the amt far mifmf
of 3' 9f the Fmfly Cxzamm fiat, EQSQ, far
k§1uén&§%ez*--------m§bm®d in 33 "the": Act". m, they
' V' " finaughi: fm: %3"i2a;mir§.*;a£ cef the auii.
A mm? fimmefi that f91ky§mg;?asu«&s;
. 'V3
A<{"v
Whethm' me gaiainéjffs prime {hat that}; are zznfifiwd
far mzfihan and segmmia pagmasima af iifith
aimre rack in 'étim suit: ficfizmiufm ymgmrtéea as
csaxziendfid?
Wfmsfiker' Qlfiinfifis pmva that mm}? am mfifiafi $9
dmfiamfinza that they are iha jaémt ssswmsm awed
.\
Ly' //
V.
wgmswm af they '"':m:'§.t& i AV
afiwxzgzxrith zicfendsantvfiffia. 3.; as?m:;¢¢m§é:3?" .. A . 3.]
3* W.?3«:=tthm* piaifitiffifia pmwg fizaat, ihegy. 'an'£§fi.&é.
Ewzpemai i1t3?2;1:c;h_f§irz§_Aa3 §fi*a:z3§a§?_ "
4. W'hef.E:2.€:3',--- gfiafengiafii _:§'%§sw:$; '£9 'Kim tkm
pmimiif :'+.:oI,".§. _ wmaw Wifin mm that':
piaimréfi" E932 £9 in dafandmm §'*§7a..§
% piaiwfi" 1%%%?a?%%em%aéafi¢fi?
5.: 'a.:g2z,-;:::;3a;gf;:v' 3 in 9 pmw fimt the
ag§::;;;g;_m:':x;;;s," ;%.a;;a~¥2 am the kgafiiy waadeiaé mfg
" 7I;safs.n§ V};'gxm%t;ia§.ir;:g§_ mat: of thaizr wmiiuck 'the: éesiendmxt
' 3. ftbv§ ?wg§'g:. bomb; ':9 them aa cxmtendesd?
_ En 'WY.§."§V{{'§.?E;§'_1,&':A'..E'v_ &é§i:fidam.i Run. 2 ':0 '.4? gmssvm Elam? {ha
mm nut that joint. mamem or new in
pqwammimn of the suit ";%z1E1?¢:2s as mzkatndmi?
i.:'§%"5!':}1¢3{,§.i€3I" etizctfizzndam. figs. 1 m 9 pmwm ifimi 'mes;
Apiaémtéfiivz have my ca.a.ma=2 easf aczfizficm ami mes: .§ocu5~
atansrii as ézzgavnienaieé?
fix?'
. f" I
8, Whafimr zieffindant N03. 1 is 9 pmwm that ma caufi;
fizz:-,2 paid £3 mm'. pmgmr and mxnmt am os:am'r:Bd©:i?
91 Whaiiuzm pfiaixafifiiia entifizesi $9 312%. mfiiaf as pmgrefi'?
10. What ccnim' €31' simme? /./"A
{Md}. Emma mg; firamad m.<1»=M::«~;2§m;, f _ V A
Wlmighm" the dafbraflfizgt N;}m,.. "ft;
{:«Ufl1E°i,§.1«flS no fiimadigfign m fly itiaa mEii,§6¥r.¢;h4:§ '«g;:€ %.
gmriiflan umier V'
Qontxaarzdiiid? V' V '
Y. Thczt Fmnfiy $33133 33
grefinainmy .i;;5'n;§:. af this; Clam'? in
the ' _'.§'\§ Smafi S Vimaia anti
anoihmi ~.a§ gum? which ham magnum
v.r;.*aa;tx'_Ai§::,'r,t»-.*L"""34§fl"'#' 5.25 piaadeed btztsmwzx tfiari mrfies in
me-. zyggitaag, ' s:;§"a*=a§ux~: Ems gm. gmmman am $13' the
suit". ihlc': F'ée£xe.i1y Ceurt mzmwaraszd ma mid 3:33:23 in
;f¥fi:°P§§i%_?{iVIE. "§"};e*«::***:~;1§H:ifi mfizzr 'w.as mat chaflgflgwfi. '§'}:w:xm.§Em',;
' é:ir.a;;~wa3 mmmiuad ma; PW .1 aemufi aim: pzwiuomi mix
H '-- wem Ifiarkmi as $2339} in Pfi. '.§'Ez»z+°: 1*'
was-3 axaaxaincd am SW. .3. 'Thy: :2" aiafeadmi Wm
A. , gxamizgxmi as '£"'h&3s" have grmémrrd mevem riemumezzm,
VV '-zgéiich ware marked. as EXSEE; in 3?.
8. The triai szzmzri arm appmciaiiean aasf éhe Mai amfi
émzwmzntmfgz mziéanm an mcsmfi. hem that ihtf pialtzafifia
are rszaiiiied tar: E3595" sham each T. x
and 'ihay am the }m'?3:a§: mrmam gxfiaesfiaséan é&'€4ia32§§§§;i:§h
the 3% fifiiffiifififlfii magi f§§,§$;fh'mj ya£:':'$:¢:;ci *;"m'§'i1nat'E£3':a»
against thus: 1" dafiztndant E': tizéét ih§._§:i§:fei5:31é;ant3~1 'ate
9 mm faiiezi m pmvé._}&m: ma: Eawfiy wmém
Wife af '£115: E9' V§€':','§~€B§a3;.'3§"v..: pmva: that the Em
semi Em? '§'hny have mm
£9 pmwi tfié: jeint Qwrmm. '§'IEi:.e.=:*:mfm*e:,
'Hm p;§aimfifl"3. figmiwvmi by
me3=aaai«;;i gu:i%;,,,'1{§gg.§: of the mag; mm fiw fiefezregdanm
am bafmfag Mfixia v{:$1I3'&14'f§'.." V .
for dam? appsfianw aawéiitxg the
V " jfiiaggnmt am} aiccmr. mntanéed. that Eizm mm is; mm
" A "£31241" mfi mpamta pnaaassaign, which £3 xméi Efi4fiEE
tifig Emmi as ii iitms nut fafl Sficfiznsn '? af {£342
~ : j§aid§ }'§a2t. "'§'_3mmf03*a, ha ngmtmids that the irxtapummi gudmmztzi
VV simztme gmsgassfi by film Famfly {1'm3.1:'$:. ia w:§é'he:m.t jmémiicfinn
azmi nuiiity and recguixma is be mat afliiifit.
qt';;'''''
1/
H}. Pm' mafia, .%«:=:azm3»zi ¢:4:2§32m:§e..'i"'.i°€.x:?. 'ihfij T. 2
4221:: the afcxm.-mid juaiment Tm '
$;§am¢::o1:a«:::a3 in the piaimg, m%mmmagh:p%m
nutwiihfimnerfimg the danéa} at; .i:h.~;~:: Cami gem
§m:§ad.i.e::fian ma my $x:<; i§'::=;:a1Et.l_VAV " cm mmaidetmfiun.
of ma Wézicnce am that {he 33*'
37sf;§';3:;2;:«.;%z,§f§;'é£'e than afher guiaintififi am
thcii' chfififaéxa, cam mm _;7u1'i:3d%cfim§ ta
paS,s:3-- the d¥.%;§r23m5.1::5 =.
H. v §»§a:--ne:%3,' '£3353 giainifi firs: osammiemitfirm in mix
.a?P%.§: 4 4" ~
2 iii} V§;r'V?}:Va?t':v'.?v«--'-'.:*-:;a-*:*:e*"'z';§:;e Faamfiy Cvurt baa jurisdicésian
A 2 in cmxsriraiu the suit. fin" pmrfitieaaia by
._ A xvii}: agailmt hm" hushanvzi, in mspmi
' ' emf ancarasizai ami jam? family ymgmrrty,
{B} Eiaugiatam azgaiflm'. fiiwizz" famarg
Fmm tfitm piesadinga and 'the avidttnm on xmnxfi, it £3 clear
mm: ma siaama Q?' t.'%_m E" pkaintifi" ia than $35 is im: fiat wifa mf
fiifj 1"' a§.¢:fi=:fldam ami glamfifis ¥*§c2:.2. iv 53.1 am the dmaghtam
I ,/ "
;
:4//
ii
barn in them. "E'h«e§,r cunaiitufifiiha 3 T AV
(m~pa"a't.>anm§n As the 3." def:::n€§a;ni-- iia"
pmwrtéezs, ii bmsamw nac*a:3£?§m3r iE's1**-*:h¥m::n_ iirg "Suit :§$a=z§
parfitimn in ymtmi their iniezwéisiv fin aham in
tha smzit achmiulue
33. Titfl §:s'g_;«3;§;:g_f;3m33ifi'3:§fa§Es (Datum AGE, 15384
fmz" £3? The objmi mi" such
aznmmfini ni:<;-: ' Em anti mama agiy
marziagtt and f.axniiy afiaim
with; The flaw. @xcEu.siveiy amnfam
§13fi§dis:§§ieuVVV an €3m1:rm ta mawaésm tha difipimm
.19 xfififirhmanéafl incfiamriing xtulfity mg" mmmm
' , igagfazxmfiufi, divarm, maiimfian {sf mnjzzgai Eights, mr
H '-- 55?. m the valitlity af Hi € G1" am to '$:'§m
afafiztm (pf any per:-sun. Tha §'miEy {10m'§: aim hm
A. , Qvmfenad with fixes: juxiazijcfian ac: dwida the: digpmn
VV in the pmpazéy 03' that symzaam am' af eifiaar cf them;
daciam'i:t?m_: as ta the kfitizaacy of may gamma; gtzmfiéazmhip zssf
3 'gmmon car ihe mmmdy emf any minm'; maiaiflmance, inciwziizsgg
pzwxmaéingfi imdm" Chagitr 114%,: {if the cm: flf Griménait
a /,
525,1
£2
mmacmm. Ekrrcfian $4: 03? me Famiiy'~--6'3@a§'ia _..A§t-» m¢1a¢§mf"--:m5 : '
j1,u*iadis;¢'£:%nn af am: Civii Cieurta {dez*,;<.'=.sA_A}fi.T
exs::i'amiv:E:3y 13;: be triad by tE?i£¢. §*"zae.£;z2§:%,z';vV:'i_k:;;;¥§r;, :{§i:f;§
pnxwsdmga Emfere tibia _§né..9&§3afi:1;§gé§a%gi"§i$'aata: (Seam.
aiwsafii staxxzi. fie: cm mar: flats :3?"
which it is mtah;,mh;;¢,V:'se,.«g駧:nfV:L? ;.:%:§&;~.«:, agxztéficaiiy mm
(ma? tbs hf; 513$;
1:',.mn~ta.=i' V which are wit nut in
, (Smart. an" Magififiaifi fjwuri
" Samaa, 31? & Fmniiy Cam'? ia
esmbfififimd 1:"_§3E: 'a=§2*é*.z»1;..'L' Simfiariy, tha Famiiyg €3'4:;u3'4: W373} have
";§:J;z§'V5};iA3:¥if1};'E§di€3:f;"€13§;k: to tézztmflaizz a midi ax przmmdéng 0%}:-452-32" than
}t§Eée wife agairasi' her imshazcgd, suit mm ivy" fhf:
aiauvgié-énxfi agaéxmt than father ami his mmfld with mud chzlkimn
V' _ V mfigpzmt Qf anccshtafi amt? finiut .%¥a.*m:e?iy pmyeriim am
€."f{"3g'§1'§ZE§;§),§€§ tméer Ssecfian 37 -Cvf tar: fact by me Family; i_"3:m3*%t,
:4. Seating; ?' {sf "éciw ski, deais with fiurimiicfian, Wfiieh mmifi
fix
Eifi hemzmdcrz "
Va /~
_ E;;:;;:.vi¢1n§2tiz:2'aw
P?m:é,=ed2'1r":g:s refamved in in
"F s:'&.£3'"z3¢5€:2r'c31r1.~ {3} QVQEWVV v'
pmm'.=.=;ians esj" Kid; a Fmfgiiy fiawii ~95" ' _ _
fa; have e;mr¢:i.:n%_e E33'? £}m[_jM*:§§;?a%€€3£§o§ij¢
emwisakifi }€.s§g::_ any héiistréii .5?'
.§uba?'tiirm£@.é "e:°i§.$§'§ .:;>m..u'"£ Ema:
fa? 35:3 fizz-we inviwfifim cgf
sui?"i§.;~;'A ' ("vii _ ':3f the namm
ré3j§az's1%c£'«$(; imééw and
fiwmw flzf
7 V_ exatgfising :§:zc:¥é u;3:gr§asfi7c:ié<}n umim' auefia
'visas, siisiwirx mam' 91; 223.3 ifiw:
T3? Lmay Varmfiz gmbaydimfie mg;
V -.€;a:?i£§1"T._ jT3f "aha sigma £4: wizétgh £13m
V af aim: Fanziiy Cauri
éxfzefmia.
3&3 {semi
22:22; Sui;-«ssemima-.
miis
mjfe suits and gyzmaziinm :33' 3,3253 fafiawfing
_ fitamm, z*a*mImr§y:»
{a} :5; Suit QT pra:as:vé:~é3£,iaEng ésemtéwzn flm
"gyayiieas in as fire' at fiewwe 9}'
nufiiigg cf mrmflim 5 fdgdmwhg iim
mwflagm in» be mm? and zamfi er, as me
erase: army Em; mmmiiing me ?2'mrr°:l4:w:}
or reatifagiinn Qf iigéaissg er
{hi
{9}
A. A A ' fig}
{J23}
{Hi
M
jzmzfizzicsi sepamiiaxa-. {pf
mzzmzw;
;
es; mi: mr :pmma€iing*;far as £:§é2:.:§&ru3£ia:r§'g "
as m the mgaggzagg; 4;' 5;
39 the "naaéiiammfiaf s};'£f¢:.:S2;$f'° 5}? may
52 é1z£'i3"' €i"§"._ §3-eiween fim
"'3";c2,r=f§+:v.>:.:-f;:'§aa Qm fiifilffflfiigfifib rmgmm ts:
i§:é__ ";;m§§m*£gg;:"e:~j'= pwiieaz" 63%?" 9f
.. *é§'£§:_.:a:f'£g,f tézsézrifig
ea? '$:,eiA£*fe3s=" far an wider aw"
Ji§*g§i::r:g;éEz':'32r"a; in ».i§'mwmsiaruw:»$ mzkmgtg aui
-~ , £3} m§e:m'0n$§t.ip";
' M {E}. '
is? "$14: "'§@gr£iimm:1y"" ezfgmgg pemam
"£2 $152?!' _c43f2rV for :3, deztfitgmfiaxsara
" « fifififiii mi" przgmeyfizagfcsr "'mm"n£mraanm";
0: suit 01?" pras:x=r~9:(£in.g in mlafiarm. to tfw:
*g§.za.n:i'z'mn$?:;z:p" 0}" me gwman €33?' fire
cu$£m;£y Qfi ms' ax'; €41, any mimzar,
Jfigbjem 30 gm»: Qiher fi3'"{3"c'Ii3i-€?3"£F$ {sf fiw
VV keg m Farrziiy ssimfii mm fimive and e;a:4-:==:rs.:€m£~
fits: Jméadicfiian exermlsahfe by a
fifmgifitmte «rgf £533 jfmz dzzm; mafia?
éiffzgzyfer EX {reiming 3:2 ardar fmr
mmirmznmamr of mifer, :m§n?¢§mn mnfi
3.5
pexmnmj of 33:23" aft
}'z'"&z:ed§m=3, 391%-53%;; cf;gf--,;?;f3%'.}3;§'7;'53}_T'V€a'é?'i%£ .
Q2} mmzah 02559:: juriasgfiééiian
mrfieneé it." by'
erzmxmem. " - _ --.V
355. iiiatzsc {Hz} {ref 3""a;'Iii1V:';-_§a::>t:"f$.i»:g>;t::2'<(V Iv' maiarxm it xttiwar
ihafi the F.*aemji3>'V_.Ck3t.§1*% in mapmsti 9f the:
mziiza V mfeztrmi. in 7m the
Vmxii £3333 wifihén acme vi' the
cat3fi;gn1;ifis" €}{§é"«§fg$piaaaiinn, the Calm gum nu
»{'€:}--.:_E<;§§§°":h~e Expianatéaru éflalis with mm amh
ca_t:=g«a1z'3,?"é::~=f€° -$V'§.1i~'§,GI' hzsriwmxra the: pmfies ta') 5; ammriagt:
._ §ws.-zapsect '£"_&€1: "§I"{)§'.3«€2'{y af film parhicg" 02° 0%' "'s:,-iihm' {sf
A af Exgfianafimn £13 Smtian 'Z?' agmazifémfiiy dfiflifi
Agsmjparty diagyaziesg The aiisputfi shezemfigi be miaténg m
" I Lépmgmrfir 0?" ma: jpmfim" area" :33" "€~:i*!ch:-:1' 433' thtirxa". E°'s:.ar the Famiiy
flan}? ta flxéffifflififi its jsmadicfimn ism: Sfilifiififilifi mum ha
aatiafied. Fimtéy, me said €§:§.§:p1fi£: shank} ha 'izmiweegn €353
gmflfi in the mmmge anliyg ané :'§€€'.3£$1'&&'i:i§',. the désjg:r:.a'§:c xhmflfi.
K /"'
,
be in razspmzt nsf the pmperiy cf flue «r43'sir)
Ewih them: cs;maii'h?an:a Emmi 'E3§§é21}§§
{Emmi cam take: $ fl9E"VVQ§..§§ st§%'vfi1j~ ;{'3V3':%*;=a*/92:?%;i1A2E;i;fz§g_g;4;=;t. .1::itie;;§"
fiat, in msztpamt nf pmyeriy K ifivffifi aim that
fiat': E¥'az1r§.%y Caautfi. :11a§_ amfi by sag 3113?;
Gr §>vrm.tmdix:g; ofi.m:r ficgm fiber:
mriéataa 19 in sizissguiat :ss.?a:s:eu§¢fi.
'b:c:}»;:¢:ng fax' them. if pmmms
ins; tE&"'ma:;:_%.ag$ have SB iaxtamair. in mm
hm arm _§u;a'::i3&ie:;t1?oE in azijtadicatzs
itfwz €;ii$}'3=}1'>fz":%.V Efi'£;§£¢r'w}§;fis, ma parifim ii) ma mamiage nrsannat;
1*§ghi:"'é1,_1E zé' yifijgmrtgr, is: which {him gasmm aissm harm:
" . V i.'F"£'§ie'3.:iz"".i?f§°5'{,v'!ti;?4F;.'§'(ZnI'E3 firm Fzanziiy {imam
ii,'?1 azféiwaents in Sim: piaim. am ma': the pfiamfifia am the
"',izasn;:V§;1~t.3x's ¢:ai' the E-iimfm umiividmi famfiy af that .§.€°* dfifandant,
.. , 312:3': pmpmhim am the: anmasmai and fiexsint faméiy
V' vi" the piajntéfiéa am} the 1" siafexaciant, aaid that we
.1" defendant ham my indefrmxadem right Thereiéztem, gsmpeswévyr
disyzuta is amt: batweam fiat: parfim is that mmztiagez nmy; it 15; a
cijapuie Eseiawsfin me. fififlffififi is tha zrganfwae as wttlfi aw beztwmn
3;'?
thztir ehififimn. Tha sgxxbject maéir-,r"0f--i:he Sm: T. A'
axrtiusivaiy E-akxxafing $22} the parfiéisa av:§5_A_¥ei£§%§e.'1; *§;im_m.,
in fhezz jawizgt famiéy, in whicfi flag: gmmvns sthéxf §.>m*bcé:::§
is 3.3%; maxazffiagc Ezzavc Em iniéft*::;2§;ia, -.f"_£'.h:::z'E:f%.:~*--'3z."c,V 'i}i1§;-:3 pm§.n=::'t}' in
difiyuie daca mm'. fcafigaéiétaisskaiy b§éiaa:3.g:§."~5;;} the jgmxfiem ta": tbs
mazrréagé 62' cf {:tit;h«E=;f_ a1'iti p.e: :f;«;<=r}i1s mhm iimn tim
paraktfi in .3é';':;3;2r.::':V {hes misci gmmgmrtétss,
mam, gumdimm ta agijudiwma
ziisfgiams, 'E9 me nxmaiaga
ma' mm; ¢=:xc§:m*sismi),' hakaxaega '£9 the:
pé§uI1:ie37'--tg; aithm' mi" fbazm
~§~*}:m';*e'.Ma;;é*£: fiimi by the; wifiz agmnfit the: has-shwé
' " fer and mgmmiztz pcsasessiaugz {sf hm" sfimwr in emf
H '-- §§>;ini famiiy pmgmriiy is» was': maimm?n.a§.:iB in firm
ma: adn1i?.t«e:fiiy apart. fmm fimm Qihem Whfi am am;
.. , _§§flfi6;=; in tim marrimga aim have énmmsi in the mid pmperiy,
V' '~«E§ii%xa§Ear;Ey; ma suit filed by fiaughiem agaiam their father far
pafiifian is aim um; mafinmiuahk: as they are: no? mfims in 3;
mmiiggs,
kn,»
/"
I9
ficmugh in e.=:fil:':c*& it wag hcid, 5:125:25: "aF'm2iii$_4ma_a§*¢1}m;as.AT' '5 ; i V
Iewrd m Hm fmzm mf {aha (23% aa 'SEE ._
2&1}. ifimveffimr, in maprexzé'.
uxmiar ézmmse {Ct} fiéxt '"%2«:153ivE::1m a:3§
maflixnaniai Ifiiafiaxigfiifig' £fi?z:€:t Wouki mi
mmicr the {:3 that matrmnaéai
3z*a:3ah7:n»;{;_sIte.i§'§ iii? the "gzwmperiy Qf
the gaff if the gmgmrgr in iiiaespum
dargs in "the: pérrms in the mmtiage ear
r3i€:hT~é;:'¢':e.f.V "::1:$i:§x?§'fi;h5i@2er;déx3g izhaé plaza mgardjng
matfimdicifigiv m;§é'fio£3a§ii§ in than plaim, or men ma mafséiemm nf
;_ma:<;_r:&moniajE'";a'=::§afi<;1>:mhip 'being admitted, 33m suit is mzet.
' " m;ai::qf§3:iI}V3a§i¢:--%.. "Far; ithia exmnt the ma g*§1.dmagx;i:. zia wast 333;
* A 'ribwxi gimme: isew'
21". _ '3~"I'hm=,*e*:£'asm,, the kamead §€mIafij§r Caurét Jufigss: Wfifi in mm:
" _ V Légmr in haifiing that flag: suit for pmfmcm by wife and my
daugghtms Ila maintainabk: against hm" humirmnd, $22373 amxmd
wiih and chiidren in mapmi caf an%€.z*£s3 and }}m7m'i fimiiy
MW"
1.
pmpaxfiirme Henm, WE pass the: fnsiiowéng ardesmw Q" J, L./ *jF@ mama (3% 25} fim ifi aiiaaéxmi ~ fim jmdgrmarzi maé flea 'imuri 36$ srwieie an iigé-.:3飧:£'4j?ar zmrm nsfi ééfgfiaqagafifia, mi? 3339 fmsfisrafi {.5952 «.,i.f.=s fifffii game zmfimmi gaging ;€zz2£,g3~V;'§2;¢a: m§:a§r':'-is 'cf .Hl;§§?.ba§2:e;?:j' « 2732' agwf; gxzrzéw fa appmwa} . m :tfii:$.»*i£«.f}é:r sseekfrw apprnpmie meiiajf AV .=_s:';§?4;.=3: .iz«v3}é;ai:f__:€s» fified, Em»: c.:€'m"£ mam is mwapaieni m 951; ggaxfiiian mar? mmrd §i\'5§ 'V cm; Vim wiihemi in any asmgg beinzg; fyfizmzvwm by mxrvéikfierzaaafifaraex in fink xpwiw. V' ffanfea in ifmir «mum. a::m§£. Séfm Fufige S&fiw Eufige