Sri Noor Mohammed Panali vs The Deputy Superintendent Of Police on 5 August, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 2]

Karnataka High Court

Sri Noor Mohammed Panali vs The Deputy Superintendent Of Police on 5 August, 2011

Author: N.Kumar

Bench: N.Kumar

_ :'§.z"~.i§}.:'  '

r-s'-

35%" THE 3163 CQEIRT Q?'  &?AI% 1%.? Bﬁﬁﬁﬁiﬂﬁﬁ
§.}21£5%d é':.Ez§§:s: {his 5% {Ezra}; <:=f,.f"»'::.:_\:_§u:--=;i.,5 28} E

E3 E33-E' O R 1%)

THE H0N*BL.z: MR. J'QS'7{'ICE 1% K§IV£é"2R_      "'

2%:-5; E5}e'£,1??i§<>'§": N€}.385E> of 2 <3a:;*;"»--<e::1fs/:9.:i>Qi.i'{:':%*,: V' 
BE';'E"WE:E$.N: I I A

Sm'. N003" M{>I1a:'z'1I:'1;€{'§ E3:g:.n2:§§

S/0 Bah? IVE H E-¥a.:'12,1}i

Ages? abmzi. 50 §,f€&1:"E:3

DiT€',{,"E'i€3§" O.,§.'E'_'\I"1'I'E':{)I'1'i§€E?:'» __ _ _ _ V

203-" F' 3001'. \fi.::;v{::9u;g1r:»13r;,/3'"E'1:3m;::'§  }
Dr. A:";1':)6:d§«:2::r Véfﬁdhi " '

E5:a1'1gg2:;E<li:'€ --_--     - .' .'.I~"e3£,i£.fa<):1<;*::'

* {By £5317;?;3..§;?.E§i:~§;éi':"§"€§. E'3e.:'1i0§° *C{>m'::=:',-{:23 for
  E;  {TE:E:§a§1.:an'1s:§:1}r}ra%.§ z&{§_2.2<x:2:1E'6}

& " T§"§xf§"§'}€?''g_}U.f}-* $1,:p§%rE:'1€:<:%:'1{§.€:1E. :2?

" ~ _V §>:::E;'<',::3  :1iE'E'y'<??¥§§.§gE-.E§"'.iHg {}£}fE<:{%2"
 --.P<3§§{i'*?'  YT W

-- A ' . ' ' ':}'iT*:?:Ei;;;:: VEJ{§k;21j;:.2k:'.21

 M S F%;,:4§,§c§.§§g._>;s

'EI%z?:":"3.§.;2:2Em':> - 5{%{) {E03 i.,§~Z:3s-;§}<>:T1:§_€:'1£$

  

  'A ;  '§'§"ié:--"%" ;.»*T%d;::T§§é1:T.<.}:T22?:.§ §}é:*€é:.tE.i.;:' €[}@::t*:"2.:L§

V €35 §3':_">§i(:{=%
' ".%.£a_:":':2?:§a:.E<'a: 2,<'}§<;2%gs:2.:%«;:.;%.



 ¢_:::f §f§§};§3:«3.1E"2:1__(§§i:?§§ E10 ﬁ3é;?./.§.}§?§;ii',i{}.i1{:?§' by §;..E1€ XEEE

 - , 8%-*r%:<iiz:};1:--:._ Q3' 'L(ii1'::g'~.§_,€':;.';

 €;";;-:f<>;.zp«--;'~'§v..--C§§fE:.?sé:' 3:7: éh.:3 }T"€;'i{'f{}E31§'§"1ﬁE'§E{I§Eiii{}:"§E§ 0E 3.32%: 1r<Z2?;:"':::.2:.E:z1}-:27:

M" 55 §Z%1,1.i§{:iiI.'1;_§

E§21:':g§ai(>:'é% -- 5§{$G€} 3 ...§§€5§§}{}YE{i€?§}§§

{iii}? 5:31"; B A E3c11'iap[:>z.w;. A<§'s.-"<):7a1i€;% 1'0"? RE:
Gax:'tr:';z§:jw:?1I Ac§v<:;<:2:aI.::> far R2}

'1'héss ikfrif: ¥'e;%§:iii<}:T: is filed ;,m::ie:r {¥E"{.ir:T:§€fS 12126 2i.¥'">:V{i-.i/E:-'f'3,f';;"'v.'{)i4A
the C€}"$1SiIﬁ.{.i'§.i(§i'1 of Igééiia. §}1'ziyi:1gg,_{ £5) (32111 fez' 'éhﬁ _:_"§:%<:'€::':<?t:'15;<,; _wE'.:.§{:'i)

Lﬂi';imateEy E'€ES£EH'.€fCI in §'3:11ir1g sf (%}121:'ge s;h€:e--«i:'.._ "21ga§ :i53%;" 

"£1;-,x

p<5:'i'.1'i:%0'1f:1er in Especial CC I\E<).42/2007 on {he §m.. _ V
XE}! ACidi{.:i{§r121} City Ci.Vi1 a.1'J.d S€?:?>'.Ei'i'{}'f1.S'Jﬁgiﬁigvtf z;L.¥}d V-EE_p,e<?'i.-3E
Jmrrlgag E3e1:'1g§ai<3r6 Ciéiy irlgihléing ] t:aki§1g_; :.<'.é:}g:éi2;2'::_'1C:e'vpf,§;.hi:é

{>§'f€:I1<:e£«3 zliiésgﬁd e1ge1i.:1Si the §}e£,ii,i<>13.e1""ss. '

This; Wféi Pe§i1_iG2'; a:£.)1T1§:;g..;
C0'::r'é, ::r1ad<:*. i.E'1«:-3 ibiizjwixig: "

"§"'2'2f"€§ }:}'€';'4f§'.,}Y.3.:§<'.'§'1i1.Vi;".E':"if:"i'§E§8. Xi-"Zf§§. §j)@i.i.1.:'<m  Se3eKi.I'2g _§1:31' a wriég

I-M-ww

<):"(i€3:I' €32' :if£J:'é3é:;:"§,§<}.:7; .£;r.:~_'LE1f€§ :'é:a§{.i.':':fs;? <3 ' <.:erE§{;3'a'r§ qu.2?asss.E2.£.:.1;.§ i£~3S€«'i2;'-3.:'s{I€?

A{§C§. City Cisvii &

';:2_z':{i E3;:}a=:a>§a:E &:_.g{i§_§:;7--,_ %;32*;::gaE{:;°€ CH1}-* in Specéai
;é'::;é';*;%f:;"

CC i."~E<}L»<§?;£'
'  ' .f -3725;? pE<£.1?.:.i{1}m*,z" W2-'as;

2» :-:;e.§.t'::::.t%::§_ E-§_.§'.'£d. a;3§§a}§:":é.ed 353

2

%

,{_'J7'E7. ;;:h;s;: ' 1e,.2u'_r1é:d .V

Hg} f°<)1"""E1ea:'§:':§§  the V

1/",



'§3{2} of %;.h@ 11:71. "E31:-T: <.t:h2:i:"g§e S:"eh.E%(3EI. wars fiﬁeci {}'i'"i {}2,€}2.20€3'? and

  

-am--r 3'=5é3:.IE1=:E 'W'£:if~% 1'€;?§.-§;§Sé'é'§.&'.§"!';"?{i 01:1 E:'§,{}2.;2€?€}? z1gg21éi'1$§: t'}";<-?* ;:' '."i.i<}2':{%3'

Em.' the zzfmesszizicl {)I"i7e:'1c:c;:. Thezé E€a"::"m=%d J 1.1éi§;;<;% e:}.:"c:§e:'e:::;%-§bf2*.§_::3"t;2,§%' {sf

s&sL2.::'1m{>:1..s; $0 tbs? g:u;*;1:§:..i(3:1e:t£' an 15,02,290';-"__.A:'c:%:'§.1,:.:7:ia,%31c"E33; '

23AQ3(2GO'}7.

4}. E1, Jise; ::01fn.e11c1ed 'Eh€11..'1.'<E1t§"S§}€(§i£i§.JE.§d§j§4:? §:$Ljf<=:;1*e what}:
éhe <:h21;ﬁ§§e sE1€:~€i'. was-t»; f'i1€{si',..V_1£7aS.'1i;é§ﬁiftftfil "z::.>_ 21p1.3§.y"h1§VI::i::c£ as; in

the m'1*:';im m.ai.«:2ri211 pkmeci 0;; i"€:i'L'>;f{§5bgzfdﬁi'=£';i§»%;_§r1g (T:()§_.§£}§ZéiE1{T:€;'; <3?

§1>u:T1i::<:;hé::';:)E€-_ 'r_,E§§V{V',§'::;?."lf ;':fe';%i:;:.%'_i;«:>'1:ie_?"~...._%3{_'I}{{3} :'°::'*.ac.§ v»Jii'i: S¢;=;:::E.i<.}:': 13{2} {:4
{E16 fa<:€L., '5m:i'"{>:fA<>; i$sz.zing,_,; _éa"m;i§:3i'1<}2'3:; E19 §.E"2<:& pei,i.i.ior.1er. It was:

i§2§?z:z:r;'r;:é:d:;.§ an 'a.'Ei's§3  §}:i:"E' (ff {ha Ec2;*.2;1:"'m%{i «.}LiC§§_,{€' iii) insési-ts: azpszé '£.ha':

'V§'éfff:3p{3E':{§$:§'i_i_F1; ~.§t_:.<} §";:"'€.>dL1{.=e féae :»'5a:3{?€'i{::1'1 §.'2's:;::1L2 {E13 8131.5,-.

AQ(}'%J§;'f_?'§'"§1I;3§?'}f3§'InE}é§:€}§'E7 'E,21k.é.§.':.g; {f{}§§'I'}'iZE-}§'§{?{? if {'23: £>§'f<:?:':{:é;=.s+; z:.ﬁ<;=:g;§:;';<§' if

'%'.E§:3:"'s;-%.__wa§~;' :3;:>]se;;?:.:';{:'é.:<T2sT:, 2: 5:-s'ia.:'§u.'£.«:}:°3; duiy £59 <,*asf~.:!;: {>51 £.f%::€- Eaanzed

 VL'_"3I.'}&'.(.':}T..'c':3.E J§_:"<:§_;_,_>;<:% 2:: :"<3'£'z,%.r°r1 Em: <':%.:a.1r;_.;:é: ;&§h<:~t::%€' "w'§E':h 2: CEiE'"€{_?E.§.{>§.§. Est} {£23

 j  §§'35ti%.§;;E§';E§E{? w£'§:E': 2.11:2 ;:§z"é3'ar'§<}:,2s; €%3EiZE{':'Ei{.}X'1. {Bf %i..E3e:;? {'.':si}E"i'"; ;:}{%i.s?':'1'E', 2iii'E.§Ei}§'§i',§?

.V H'aa:2{i:z:"£c>:'§.Ey H-?q11i':'€{%. 1.2z'1c€:%r S<%(%é.£{'>:'1 §..9§f ijiaii 0? §é":{;t z7i<:L '£'he:

1?://,,4_....



 §3<'i§' 1? i:i':.>n «  "L '

..Fia'i£..E';{>:..;'s, E%Ei§'1.{L'E§€}£'TE :1:'2{'i<2:* 5'3€"fféi€;.>§I'£ §§%{i} <2?" i'I§'§£,', ;%:f%;.. #1311 ':E':<:

{'5

'é§"1:::: ii is; (3:23;-' e;-if: £173" ("£1.16 E:':*~.;e:'s-;%:.ig§2-1'£.§{H2 £2-":1'1C'§ a,»m*i§'Et%2*aié{;sr1., me;-'r
2m£.h;<3:°ii4i@§a Euwcé 5:E£{.§L2f_..§;}.'1E §:><:r:'°:'"::§s~%;:«;17t:'m 0%' E236 {L}:)v%;?r'r1;=i:<jr1t '€53

g3r<>.s';e{":z.:i.e i§':{%~ pet.ii.i=:mm: E[£<}\&:<::m-:3'. in vi:%w quf.1:;??:{%"L::*£%=:7'e'z'2':,

pm1'?1::3:.I:'}:?€:mer1i8 :1}? mi? E"£<}:'25Ei)i{* ;'?§:.z§.>;"m;1<:: C<}1.':.'~'.."'_i' rf<:'§;.{3:"€'s§s';§  V'

2003??) KL} 13%.??? {'PE€Af{;<'§S§I  EEAEJFLL _:'E,..='.s_~_;°

PEf!'L?JA.E§} anti 2{}0'7{!,3 KEQJ 565:3

s'§;;s:;;,z:;*--'. _T§>2a;<a;£§;s:§ - :«;-'a. 

; -V :;';%;m::  '

ST.'/»Y;'1'£ GE? £'3II"fAR,?. :~;21:3{':11§{';:T1a. V%L.i11_:CiiL'21"' E§e< §'%'j§_m'   

Ei'Lii,{)§1'Eé.1f,'li{"f sand i"21<?t.:,z21'i a;s§;p<%§%é:s:~';;~:Fa:'&? {3i'ﬁg) reie-*2:z;'2<f€:~in View ()3?
iiizés §€.>g,_,:-ii p<>$ii.i<>;31 Tilér' V'{,\:'{';':";<"€:i--_I{j'}_'%:Z'2'}";f{TE}ii ff~a¢:'-;s:35'* .E3()'m:1.::§ £0 zztraitiwti

5-,:am{':é.'im1. in vi:fﬁ:.__{>£' :*i;'}i'c%V'1a;:;%_j35;2z1'§)'«:3s5ii.:i311_ ém:r1.<::'a:{,ed by the

E~§0:§'b£@f; §3::z_;3.I"éi":iwr:: .5(_k;2.;_z'¥L'.._ii:1-.,__§..§?.ef;.1Eb:'es321id (iii;-E(jf§Si{)I'1E:%' 33:} pi'§f,)f"

E'SE1I1C'i.i.()§'i $5 '$316 {,}'<:}v{%':i:*::1;_3.éi:'.1§.E3 :"i:<;i.1i1*:=>{i Hg; p§'{':S¥i3€;."1.1El(".f a }§%,i§3§I§{'_?

..<3;{:21r2i:=:'£ : _ Tﬁfie. *:;*.§A"<§:"1r;,4*" ¥;h's'i:3>' $<}::g.E2i, f{3'£"' (ii-s5§":1§55§=:=:::.i :12? me w:"EE':

'" m.':3'";1";3<%:" <2? <:a$€35.~;

.v.»-4 -
Am

 is};---. i '3 §'§'":§7;'5 E:221<*%«;g3;;'<:>:.s:'z{:E', :12:

§>»2:?::».{i.:1;«;':.§_'§ §i}::.s§7é}_'§.'<:¥' ibis"-S €i<.>u:'é.. 'a.E'2e<3 c§:.:@&si.z?z.2;'i WEEECEE &'£Z°{'3Sf5 iii}?

'.V=:'?<>':"1§;££i::::.°e:i,§<;::': 1.-'1-*éEi5,~S ii-'§'§E?'§,h{fE" 2-,: ;:.>:1.?<>E§:'% ;<';{'::"°:»*2;:;3%;'. 0912:: §;:»e pr:'>:-:s<:t:":z,:§.::%:E

s



ma

;
rz,%:';:,ze%::;'£. <3"? '£.he ieazrmsezi €fimm:=;eE 2-.:;:>p<:;2:'i;':;_; in :':§*;§s 5:-;;:s.§ci

p:"ai>:7c?<;é<ii:1_g_3;&s, EE':€? ;::r'€:1.1'r:3zT:::;1.;j'g,-7 _§'>=:>i:1'i ':..E'?:g1é" z'm:;:a::'. 50:' {>zj2:';5«;1¥»:E<:%;*z:'{'.i=:>§';
was answezrscé iizzy miss €<3L1r§. by <;2:.'{i<%:* ::iz'1é.c:{i 29"? Juiy  in
the 3-':.E1:31*c?5_~;a2'd <i:r::§€::.1 £i?:<%% p:°:>§%m£:1;3z2°y p<}§:2'E, §'<;m'2
u 3'1<.§€:*: V .

"E.-i~'E2e£E'zei" 5: Co:.:s"{' (>513? :':Ezi<;'er. 3r_r§,§.gr'2§;+:'é£.;1:'<5e_ :53}?
(ggffégrzcg puni3§":ab§e u:r1{iz-3?'   
arld I5 (1§.le?g£;-'d 2:152 ?;2g:Iza,,-'=3 §)<3:}}A:.V_ £'.4rJz'rt:?:£:T:§é:T§: v,f:§; 
pzzbliaé S€;'F"ZﬁCU'2f,' 2,:;iIi'm1.:.é'"'?;ij%é§~.;;r"€> ,vz'é)':;.:s  5§£:.4;--?c>z.ﬁ€:z;::r'2. off
2':?'2e Cen z*,mZ   'ufgfjéﬁeI'?£};?i£:'f?.§I;?"'$EIC€£6

GaverzzrrterzE'/Az.1"&E2<}r*i§.;;--_ {;:c,%{:'?;:)é:e}:{ Ea» !'€?F?"i()1/'E him

, V ; ;"?1*; m_ €J§ffic£5--

 fE"E'1~re% p':*;;'%E1€1"1':A;":";»:1;;"j§,:"'-. p<;».}?..:1E 25:: a;'}5sw<2:"<?cé 22$; :.::'";€£€:°:w
-ii}  """ " "§'E'za:?re2;f%:I'£* {'§'EC' Cé_,?7s>:1:e5;a.§{f
..V::i£>s£;t;':5;3V:s'<>z'2. 53;" §[?'é.€ Apex C(}u.?"§. has {:3 be
 fr': 532:3 £?{}§Zi&',?:7?. in :,:éi1i(.%f'"z. 5.5'? ﬁg m:a(Ea
Cf'f=3{_,§g..-- i,a.:2e-Era §}{}§i'E.§.{§'?§g 535:: :.f'iz.é> {§§g}%%;"{'§'%<',€g> 2'32. 532%:

~. £'c:§._rzgz.::zg€ €?"§Z_g')5{}§jé.'{f gin. -fﬁeaiiizferm. E9'? :35" z'f'f'2eg% £0529
wzzxf Sg%<?E.z':}:2 2.4} :3?' She z'icz'; in E~§e:){r§:é{>r'z 559??' Q)' me

{T525351 :'.§':s3 zs_s:;:n'.€s z.:s.~:g>(§, 5/gm "is; €i{f{3£,s'S{3{'.:§ Q3" {2.:2;§;;

:;j,{}'E?:'2<:e ézifaéggegf 3.9 §':a:.:e }2e3'.>e%2'3 <f(}??2f?'Ei§f'{3(T§. E33: }'2.z'm. ,

E

?g,/"'''



"éfzg Céf}'{}§:3'.v_{}'§" 5§€€f§iO¥"E £5} 52;" 3516 £475,

;;::'<3z,*€':.;z'<m.S <'.'={)r2§"{:ir2e:i in Sa.>c?{":'<m .3 E} (gf z"?'2.e ﬁcfé, is

is uéeif :e:s3i:zEcd ?f:+:';zi" :2 i:Tf€?{?ESi:f}!'2  an 5sz.zI§'z<}:"i:y%j'?:;:'

E.{.?:i'i.(»Z£ 2°: e:z::§z.:{zZE§,; {§é:'{..'f€fé£'l'S. Iw2e;§}'I£>re:'2<:a;' §.'0;"'«:fz

;3c:r"Z":'c:.:Zczr s~e>:'2tmz.<>e-é in the i:r,>r':.:'e/5 Qf Vf'1:z{:{':.:£.'5:.£ 

:.<.~:c?e::<:z.r:'<:» :*{m:'z:.}£ be-* mczai e:.}:.£:. Qf C:f;r1.i"'<;%2<_'a'.; " 1f"73/§'":{:" :_.

<2;f'%m,>s:zi{I z.:.:<;~re:7.?::;° are mszzi. 5:': zfze <.'z;:'2E.He,x:i"'§z'z :,:§?2~i{:}2

if :3 :z5;<-5:3, is is (".°ZeZ'C£I' {has 9-;'2fz'fzc."§i":'r>¢rz. :75}; if'_3'2AZ3'i}£§£'(§V{)%'.'i ~

{flea C{}z.1.:"£, z'ca§s:z':'1g {T'(}gF'Ei.?§:{T{?'"&.€ftf"' 53?' §:,'.2_€"~ _€§{}'&§i 7./ 

:%{m2mi:.£.ec2 :.m.d.€'z" €1'f"ze.*/égrg §Jg '£;. p'zz}3Zi<;»s€IfUCa.:'2I5 

{he <;fE)r'€:>said z.mrd "c'a:aVzf?(2.=.';*'1czf.i{?"'-is 'r<9r;:ci 2i)z:.i: Qf
mr1:'.exz; £2'? z,£,!(3;,:.ECE zifsgjkas-:3_"'£.§'zé"~~»:3}§je<tI  :;z;r:'..f}':..z:>}"2,éc?':
S<:>c£_:<m 29 Q2" if:-x;':;'--'&;::zI  <;j_:'z:z<§:5sé<'i. am m3r1€ier$ {he

s;@cz',ior'z 0f,i(;s;z: " ._

2.6;  >"",'.§'\§:'?4§';?~7f£"i_'ji1{':f.3¥'¥'<'-3'; in 5:0 f;::,:" as ;;>uE)£§{?

"5j<»,>z*";:a.;'::':3_ €i$--'i£?-- {§é§;--'z§é:'i'é.e:f§ {fag-2 <:,'{)g}"'EfZCmCé? Qf ang;

<3;f}'€§?;<%'c §__z;' .5::*:g; {L':.i:,z.z'§. £5; §}e:'::*r'es:Z. 53;; i%a;>a:'.fc2§'2 .3 54?? Q5'

1?" $2.53

 V?';::;4z'z:(3f.{:§a§z§; €?f'?,€£?"i'E{?§,:'ff' 53;' §.?'2,z;.> f}f":.'.'}E'I§3{'.'§,§€I}?'E ::,§_,{}%,:»s"{;:'.5*e:i". 33:";

 _ f,}'E.i'§;*§ZE?_ :,-f::%:":.%e::z':{,;<; is E}mzTz§;?'2.§ Gigi! Esy Em'? m:;T?'e,>.§;:sf<;--;'2

":*:<§j_ €?%;2zr:" simié §.5z:'«:a.> <:<}g:':s';:5z.z'z.<:re €;;"'" ;<.:;:s<.':?'z ogfflmgre

 Ae,>}./}i>é;;z"' E'£"?§.E-E'? zfw ;3r'm2i<3z..{:; :§am::2i<m Ease Qf £1525

' é,:.=:m'.§:=; "*ri<.>" {iﬁff "5s;>f'2:i:£E°' §E'E£?:§€E.' 5:" :f2:E;:.:z'2§£{m.§£§; irfeézr

55%;: 5252:' 3:': z'§'1.2.:,= s::xar;'<:z'5;g:= <35" g;c;s4:.:zs:' ::.g:;"' ifzee sf.?<';m': :9

z"a§c«:'% {"e:::g;z'z,zf;ze:z.z':<75 <"g__g"' s:2.z'2.g,; :.;gf}'&:':':<i:a? is a%§2s.';<;ia.:£.<3 <:"z§'"z.{/1':



ff". Es: 60??{'£1€':'F'Ef)g€£{(?C§. fr'; ;2r":25;e><:*:.:I:e'? ;;>z:E3lz'<i sari,'-(mE,'
u:i'2.:> has»; mn2m.zTzi:e(z". 5:3'£.iC}3 c3;j}£>:'2.{.*e.,<;. miter: éE*2.e~

C(>z.:.:*'z. £3 {?{l§§éf{i :.zp{>rfz ac; Zcakie <%<'>gmz'zo:;'2:7a>r Qf {ﬁfe

Q,{]Z:>:'":<:7e3. a ss=w':<>:'z'<';z'2 {mgfzi {<3 E353 zz£.:c;:fiV55"i§;>_£éT._

:'}i?%erz,;:z'se*. {.333 67am': :,:.>:>:.:E(§ Ezazzm-.> rigor; 5;':.ér§:::.zf27;'<:{i{}:-'3:j;  '

£0 E e:1E€z3 cf(;§c;rzi2:{2:'z.:fe Qf {rise {3ﬁ'?;?*}'"§.{?£?., A 1'.xiii.":.:.:Vi§f::3:£f'A

:2 ziaiisi s5z.:':.<?!i:'>rz. z.uff:er'e <)r'2eW§5 :'2e(7ci'5;';€:é:£s1;;;_'v%:,z,%"z:ie'rj

:Se>»c2'1:'<22'2 .39 is a trim? wz'.{f:§'_3u.§ 'j::;,:4és;{»i°i;*i£'&>;z"«}3§;«..:i§1c  f

Cozm'. A 2f"r2'aZ Z.iJi.E.'}1£f}{:§?.' :1 ;<éa__2*'z.£?f;z"()rz !"&"Z§+'ir3."'I"&%"~f1'}?1=é3 "

[3F'=f§C(3€(i€F?gS 51.?) z'nz'i,z'o; zzégﬁfaf.
28' V '£7,318 €}_~:-,5%z'r:':z'é'z'a.i:>j ,{2V.{;z.ze:2 for ca zscziici

sanc2'.i<m. is ziize ' Z.i§;'z'e 'fa.i:?:ac>r1 _:&.';"L1'.::5"»:',/",'<"3;..r2r'Z is called.

 z[:1T:3o:"2ff,i<:3  '<.:::§§r'1ize'z;'1€:£~r qf Ema <;}{}%-mega, {fl

 I?;l€;%F"{;f'f;'.>E"V€:..V:'"L§,?E?.E'?:2'V'§;'f;é' _Q;f}'ézz{:*e is giziigggesd 5.0 f'z.a:,:(3

E::a%s3:T'2~ a:c§r?'2z%5::T:fz'e:?c§.f* iiic 5.zc:':?azs.::;>d zvas (2 ggzxbiicr

s€:"L%:;.z::i'. 33:31 Egg} §'§'z.:3 :"'2i.mg 522,9 C<:ur:"  {.'£j£.§§€'€§ zzgmzz.

is 3:35-zz-3 :}0§;--;--T:-:2e§(;z:'z:7€: <25" ifze :',}_f]}S;'2'2Cé? <.*:>:':2z:'2.f§:z.ed 525.;
  ;;s;.z§;:=§z':i sgerzscmig E25 Ems ::f£:'{;£5-T€{§ so 23 ea 5;:
 A;'*;"1¥';.§§_}5Eav»'.:':"5§¥é7?'i,?€E.EE.§, no ;-,xt;{:;'fzs:7:_fz'T(.:«2*'z m<>::.E5E be .r:z;><:?es;;<§::r§;
z' ,'.";._,':A,v. .,. ,3 _ V '(:51 , " ..,. E, 'W ,' '. v.,
V_;{.:r_; §;;,}.§aEIZ§j £.{}§}?§Eg:{ﬁ2{.€3' 2:}; "he: éggffezms cggtzzgzsé ;'z_z.m.,
22.5. 5.525 ::z'ma (2 €iZ'<>z.z:"z" is; 5::-s¥<s:{£ is} mics: (?{}§}F1§.Z€i.?'i{T€

"':z<:~{ {}?'T:§§j {Em Q)f}%z'zc%e mzzsz f":z:2.z:a,> 539mg. ::?0rs'2r?'z€{§:ed

by :2. })£4i§3§i{.? .5;g.>r":,:{;:§':.i E3543' rm: gge-2z';<e:m'2 {Z{ff{Z'¥_if§s'_~.'{f Es»;

;;:":'§§ 52 ;;m§3E:'5: s';ez'z.=<::;':§ re;'22..r.;=a:ab§a,>j}":3:n 522$ e:3,f'}?T2'<?e Psi;



 ;2i§%f<?:;?._5'2.:;? Eujsiziis is;

V ' ._ ;&f§{3z%:?é,"T<§;'f}~Ehe E"?Ef'éf£-.'

1'2

52: «::'sm1pe>E.<3;*'s ai,:.Z§'ze:m'.i'g;, bé§_]3:}?'e* 2'§':s2 _g3r{):2z'..$i.<}r'is Qf

S, i :4} can zzgggsfgg. '§"'§':.e.= z'€§c?z>aI'2£: c'i;a.z"'s,--é- E..£4?ii}"'E. 2"efj%;?mr'z__c:g>

:15) u:?'zi{7I'2 5: i.%cT£.§2'€f .<-.;ar'2.<?{:'§0n is ;:<»;zfr2e qua 220;'; jTé;>%;_

zia§<z'.sI.g C{J§r'1;z'zc:r'1.{re <3)" an :3;f}'7c»*z'2ce? (f€}?'¥'E,I}'?ff.§,{;f{L'f _'E;g;°5  '

p::,bEi<? SC'1"2f.-'Cii'EE'." as recgz.zimc'i. 5);;  E5} is z.?t:,jé"{i::z.t'.;>'cf?"

:.a,>Z'h".c:ifz 273:? Cami"  a:?(2Z»Z§>::z'. E£{}{5VF'1?'.'""§}C;'1"b'E35563'

{?{)gr1zT2:c1r'1.:f@ Q1" :.E'1.e Q[j};>n.Ce Q1"i,L.?f2_{{3ziE.':§Z4£ii_féé'C1iCCE,:£':I§:'£_,. [_T f

3' 57-3. 'I'i'2e? .?'%c;§a_,_'£<3r  '?:"f;»af cg;{'fEE:¢{:: xz;!}cfVjVf"£;4;,'
z.::0uZ::Z have <3g3;)<)r":2.:r:fi§}» (1?3z.zs é~.of'z";'ifsz,éS;ge~ ihr-3
<g;f}'¥c:ez '1'he3..%f .~:s¢<:z.z'oaj2=:::"';:..:;»§fg;,f';}""5; :,z.:ei§.!re'€<>g}vf'1iseci.
£.?"Lii£5F"I2 £:i'z.a.i: po:4:5'5**«'?1r4s.  :.i'€;Z;f=~':i':V€{:*Iil:ix:.j\L;. :10 ::7oz'rz.:p2'Z. fl;

is the ?1<)Zd.i:'1gA.._Qf =Z.}'u3~._ <g{7'E£i€. ﬂ£l'«?if'£l';1 gives (an

" {V};/;3_E.');G*Vf:::Z.{?V?,ﬁ.§?  :<";--_ ":--.£.;=:e "'Ez1~v--_'f<)r Cormpi. rnoi.z"L:.r33.
 'I"§:€z°qf3:§3<(;*;-_»  {:::é::.?"r'a.:;3IZ <:<me:i.:,:{:£. is dz're:.?€;£y

"agzié'€b::£a§';ie. @::2<"iigféiziésf%0:'r2 £1323 piimrer {?(}I'§j£'I'?'E?C€

an-V s:}'2,.~;=. _ ' .a;3;f'f';';:7e>;}"". Thzis :':"'2ze%rr<:Ec1z1z'{:»:'2 cznci

'Afi?i82"€g€i"33?€f'i{§§€f_§f'E,:i.'€? £}£:?£"z.{..re%<;>;'2. 2'r:d:'z,%fz}z.:::zE (zfifi {ﬁe

s:.:§2s§'5z:'2§:c:§ arid F1{}f.' :*.§s:%:,2€I'€;i§:)§::'.,
:;'§az.:$s3:; £53,!'3z:i%9--s:;>c:ré.é«:>s[: {I} 53;" Sn

2 i9}'j."z,;.=;ﬁ*;<; 2-he =1-'X'p§"£fSSf.{3?"i "(;}ff;'%'c;c=' 5"/zzzci iflfze goauéer {Q

 gz5{:%'i{; s(gz'3.§tz':fw2 is <:(;3'g.f%;>r?e»:i 0?: gm czzz£?'z{;r::.;;

"~::r;z':2;2e:.€;'z§ 37:} rz;>:'2'":.az;s.> size ;3z,:!:>Ei{? :;er:2az:f. jz*'<;m §'::';<~:

<3;;§f7"E(.'es e:"m.{E ES, .3 E3 :'e,*{;:4z.:'.re::; 5:. :;:_3.:':<.'zz}f)§'2 §;r{;§,f%;r&* €:>:icz°:'z§;

{f(,'}§}?'2§Z€1?E.{f(5 cg?" Qﬁ%;'f"z.{?€?:%; <?<>r:'2m.i:zr2:"i

53;; ;}:,.:§:zEi::?E

 ...

" V£"f*z,:?;,§A V 1:; :.;j?f'--1zfc':'i'.z.

E3 Ss;'§"z.:a.I'2.§". 27'}"1;s <§_,f'}%.>z'2<re'> 3?Tz.s.2:.z§€.i be a:f:im2I'3'2z"z':.:3a' 23;; £528 §)::E2{z'<? se3n2(,::'2Z'. 32;; mz'sz.1.S2"ng:; or (/:£m5:Er2g {fie ;)<:u>gi?r Qf <;,§}"z".<?e.> and if. is f:"c>:?'2. zii'z.cz£' <.§§j}'%<>e. {he gz:.si?2orz'i'§,:

mz,.z:;~;z. be (7{3:2'2;:»e{c?r'z.: in rgn2<}z::;.> E21' W1 so as :10 _f)§3 e?z'zI":Ti'."£'.e=.>c2' {:3 g;;:z*a;z.§. :»';ar[ac:ff<'m.¢

20. T"Z':.5 e:<g2z'essi<i>2'2 °cg,?j}'""z'..::r.:%:;»* in_ VV:.§'i'€'*~ "

Sims-;>.@ :=;z:§3»4<>Z(z:.:.se%$ Q)" Se?<?£"i{}s"2 IS} 5 E ,2 {;:'i:i§{.éE.é»§'(?§=§'£Z!'§§/j a'.g.>noE.s3 zhozzi <;»[}'E}:t(;s z::i'zz'.::;'§ é §"E'2.é ' gj}Z,i«5'_,)§{E5 «:-7€:':":gs:m {I 'V zniszwed Q3' abusedjlrrr {?€}F'?°:I'éw2;?{:i'?'l45Eii,?€$'jb?* .;,z;!ffii§i...?j£'~.. V' fie is :0 be pz"ose>c;':a£.cff_. émd. i2'zAmsg;r3<7::1f,:fz3;Evai:I31 .3: sm'2«:?§,ion £1; p?"(?5§E:'{f'uZ6-3 f%:7.3_7*:' is: rzezzxstgéafg ﬁg; {he cornpei.e>22:' c1z.{L~"'2,e;'.;ij1€1g_; e%: z'f:iz,;&»;:&{ z.(§*zi_<3s7':()a>e V}?"i:1'z*F2'_f'r'c>r1rz This §<£e:>'" ' "E2613 aE):z:se:d..

z'm"'g;?i'zfa1=E§::z'.Ea%é'~E?«éE'u:§é:3i'2.' §'}'2.e:> (,>__}'}"z'.c:e 5232527 £51.'; czbaisaz if ':f§i)é'i;°e?d.V.._ §£;!f}:.F§(£7."«.__2':é£:'§.de;?E' 8. ES} (i5:,>::»z1:;§. sf am; 'z.e7:;:rfi§§"zg;.._ 1"E'%:{s; 'fz::E'é:?:*:"eZ<1f.i::;2 :.:'Eaec_z::'Eg; _;3::"{3:.:§{,f.{35 5: xf::s'm3 31> E3323V:_,::T_:§fv::e.r°§éa.r2»:£m.;,: :.;;"§.f':s2 ;2:'<>:.>z°s£o:'2 in S5 55%} b' §;'<;:§%:.(.:'.§;'zg; f<:;:' s:::£z:.4.:§i<;z':. E25; :5; <.?:>r';'2;}%fe2'z£ :z.§..z§i§'z<:2£°§i'g,; . :,.:;%%:r:,% "s.::2gfm:£.(i 55$" ozf%;£&.> Ski; _j:.za'ge file? zszcmm {;f {"3253 ;3:.a§<é_§_Eé."; $em:2:rTz£ E3e:fg"%::::"&? 2"€:?'z{}:,:in;:; {fie fizrzr. Egg; griiésfizzg $5/m,:7£.£<>;'2., :10 f§'?.€? £'.a£~::'r'1g Qf" §§'?.<'-3' <:og=:':.i2:*r:3zfs{:e '~:.;=f' <;,2f]%;=:'::;'e%:; fag; z'.§'za> {,?<3::.r:'. {1§§{1fI2S§ Em: ;2:,:?,>E:'§ s;e:'z.:a§z:fs.E.. "§'§T2e-?:'agf":;>:"{;: E£?"§£§i€.<;'$§.f{}?'Z{;f§}§.§.; jir>€E<}:.:::; :}:5z:z" {fie §,§'€2f'?€?§"§<'_P?E Z0 ;2:"<25;va<:::.:.£,c% <:c:.:'2 25:3» g§:,>gez'2. fag; {zrg £1 /1,"

' .. ::

" _§:f(é§~ :"a.>g;zTs£.€;' am. FIEE, £4 az:;f.f'z.or*iz;.; g:?{;:2z§3a;>:,ez'2€ in :"er'?2<):..*-9 z".§:e §;:.z§;Ea'e;.:' :5>erz..:5;_z':§:

from z'I?E.&' (}]ﬁzZ.'é1' Z4£3}'E.f{7?2. its? Ems mz's;z.:5:;€d. er cz.h:.z3x£;>.'z"£...V_ f3ec:5zz.zse:> ??'z:2,!:' m.z.£i'z:::r':z.;; 5:20:29 :mz.zZd §3¢-:~«~;:?;>_i:;%_ {'o.f , A' §c:'20w u:Ew:.}'z.er' {flare figs' 3366?'? 52 r';r'zfs1.z.s8_:'}?" ::aAI:2;i;«';:éA T :3" mar} 0 '":'<?er I9: E.f'1.e )zzE'}if<:" S5:z"L'(m.i ;'fz.f'2'¥:'.":'.' "?'%--f;§'§.» §§{;=?%€<5% rszmic omf'.sz'.dc,-?r» 2}. "SW2 '§}_r*iz;rTg.£. <3}: ':;.::.:V%z.a;>:,z'c;1'z 'ié{._r2<J.iVVV{z§'2 iciie f0rma;{z'i:g, 'File s;f§£catfﬁ2*': _and" 's;r;§i:r(éE;czrigt*£' ac: Z.{.?h.I'€,'3'? I*ern<3tJ;3'$~ the 5é.Zf7éi;§é;¢§2:§.=pg?" pf<5V{I€CI.€0I1 53/"

sC§0z)€mmen£. ' ' ';§%3r:As5 z;:__: V » a f.' f2"§v<;l(>r;£s pf{}S€C{.£ffi£)I'1S gar'-xiii... :'§:'h<;> - " %écg:.a£rer?zez1I:s muslg" '%>ré._ be'? 3'iri€:':".5;jV ':§€:m_r).Zied. wz'.Z.i1 bzgfore "ﬂZ'?'l.g;V"j:IK§F€i§§;fi'£T{.!.IIf'€)?f1V'~. g:0i{Z(.'E.V~-- be iaurlcfzcd agains:

317;::'§3f£:?' £:£'-:j:i(;§:§s;__ ""'~Tf:(:i is :,:2%1.§; {.323 Paz'Ef€m':«5?z'zE.

".:;ze'm:zg _p,ré):.:'i.icEs:>:(E'*«._{?iaE' the r:/z.::.:'h<:»z"i:;; zzizmzs wauéd §;;%s.-3°'a:=«;}%'?: g;,2g§",--..3; z.I"=_f"z3§§:*<1:':§. :~;::;2;'z<*£iw"s z,::-u%€.:*?[:. £5 e2'z§i:°.:'.Zs3z:E ':,r> :'€r3é(;::z;.%______§}'2;e ;}z.s})fi<: S£:??"E..?{):f"i.§ s:zg;a.€:'232': :.z,2f'2.c2m b' .:.;:.2_.;é.:'.:.§_.::;>r': is é§{}i£§j?"£§f?"{3f?E f:'§"ze r:2f'}"7:'£c' 'I"%'2e:"z;f;tm:__;'%az'?: she e:;g}%;rs;>sa£d <"fz'$<:=:,z.<5;s£zm :?§e3a.r iﬁaé no sa.r'2c!,E<>r2 is recgzzirgegi €.of:.£e Fffii 0:' SW} san:ff.z':3:'2 is ;'é:q:.:f:"{e{1'. 5::

€:2z:g;<;:.T:Eg;(z.:'.a? 5:1' 7&9? :'ega'sf:%?"§:'2§; an F3}? izrzii (2559 213 :'<;e::m.:;°§.2'.{>:'z 5;; recgziired. £:>j'f£e <::§':(zz'§;e $f'1s3a%: §;;ajfE>:'<3 53529: i £6 25 aiissggerz' £9 ?'152z.:.:% 563$"??? <.'<.2rza:.2*':'2.:'I::e«:§. 5);; :1 gszebiiegi sm'::a,nz'. w2'!.i'z<::z..zz'. z';fzs>. ;3r'e?t;iaz.zs :{=;w'2<;°I'z'<,>z':. <§__f"T,_z'f':»: Ca>z'2{;ra2 G-z,)z;%:m°':r1'2€z':.E;'§}'Z"e:E"e% €.§:)z.%e:":'2:'2z:';>r2:',r';'§;._§_z:éF'z:%:é 4' <?<;r'rzpe:>.{e%r2!. 5.0 z'@r?tc'::.>e} h.:'m.j'}"<>m <;§_,{}?'2'c:=:a.

9. in ':..h:: Ei;_>;,'m «sf xyzﬂiaxé ESV$3"Eif,ﬁ?-3A.éiE}{}1;?€.;,i§{3 iff§'t:_§*é:*a3:ha.1.i . {aka {30§L§Z1.i.ZE£E'1{'1§i of 2:':fz'1z:;=. ::>f.'.E'e:":<:e' erg;1':T11'1§.iE.Ai.:3t?£ $3}; 'i;1.1'€2' jg.::':14';3§§{:_sseW2a1{ﬁ» whiie in <)fE3;ce in §'€:5§p€C.'L (2? {he 4<f}';§";E:'(«"':13£f£*.E%i &:':"::1;2'ié":i*aA,a%:;i Lmdesz" the Ami. "§.'.hs:% Grciez" i:1'1}3z:g1':§:€i'«.i:3 .2.h.:.s;: .u}'x*i.%_ ;3éS'§,iié{;'I'1. xA;E'1em she Czmri. "Ems issueid sur:1m{m5.-:. cta1;_:;n7(>!::VV 3:5 :.~:§:s5%jéIai::'1{%§i; --. ~"i'h€: p<;%T£§é.i<mer is 8. Embiic :5e:x"var1;([ '<3Afi£,.V-';?r;£:: :3f§E:1,U:? "he: $a.i(E--..i.<> hax,»-*6: e::a.)1m1'1ii1:<éd the :>f§e;':(:::j 1.2.:1{i_e§*'v§§vi*2Vé;°:.g"§e;:'£.; _':;i:2:%?.e:: {has-,> C<;Lm'. ':':0('3§«1 a:{>;,;?1'1iz2::"u:€ G? Eh»:-': é;L21;f_<i' '{§ff1Z'§i1{?ﬁ'i'E%A;' §'17€.«.._bi%.;é::; x>mr§<;ing;§ as 2:: §2a:?3Ei;: zservanig '"E'§':&.;'i:'§"£>:";3 .2:-:»:41i'1<::.i'.:E'€§:":"w221$~'«V: 2%; 2'1'::.zs:a'£» Wié.§:<5z.:i'. :?3£i}".":{_'l'.§{)E'1_, Ehz-3 Caéuri. " "::z:n.'1E<i ':'ié;'iﬁ. Ezzgve 'izligtréa {.::>ggm';«'::7w':<~<=%. '}'%::r';*--:'€:§':'>,:"€: E..h:": <%m:§:'e I ~..§f3z":;:<::3é;;%.§:;.§;{&g: 3:1{<:é.§%}.2;'€: :.E'§e {3<3u;°E, :.:'<>2f.{§,, {:33 z°:":€i:'.a;' iéiagsggzi ezmd 3i22':3k: V ' <):"é:§£é.§': "

is E=:>;:: q:.§.5z§::E{";;§%e:'§} in '§.E':.:».1£: v§::%w 0%' éiize? :'2m£,'a.4::%::'. E _§i;:2:2.se;3 this? §1>EEm Wig

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court