Karnataka High Court
Kuthbuddin S/O Peersab Achammanavar vs The State Of Karnataka Rep By Spp on 24 September, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
IE3" *r§m HEGH cmmir Q?' KARE\EA'1"A§-L5; ~j' § €§RC¥J£T EEECH A? D§L%RWA§ 3 1' 335539 THIS THE 24% mass? o1§f.:sE:2-:'1'AE;«z:'fi§E";1:ii:; 3311033 A' A' V V Q THE §i0I'>I'BLE MR. Jr3s3*:'é.Ef"~:,fN4§R;x§g*;:z~§A'.és£%_g;:2qY CR. ~IMEI'€A3;, REVESIQN 1:Ef:%ii'j:<§:xfVV§§0. m:2§,2; g'2 ;:§oé Beixweza: V ' H §{m:'§1budc§i.r:, V 1 , S/cs. P€;'f3I"aSab Acj~h21':nr%*2am%ar,;
Aged about 35 ;re:;.1:"s;2',,: {}_:_::c: §3riv¢r§ . -- T .
R/':>, MaiapmiDhéi':m%'éi€§~.L b " "
?e*'£11ti<}>:2{-Jr {By Sm Suresb P.' vE§1.zd'&€i21ga.éfi-iii, A<3;v<><:a£;€} And ' ' 2 The Siaéle <:>f Kaiffgzxiaxéqgz, "
Repregsmied E'3j~;,/*é;Y::'@ ' V. ' Efifalic P:"G$e<:é;--,1.i<}?, A. High :r;:.a'ur.:-~Bu-igémg, ' """ "
Ri-3::é;';2;'3r1c§.<:r:'i'.
5:33?' §#'§.:%4é;f,:f§§K.Av.§%v..--KL1}.1<:a.1":iig Ir§{3{}?)
7.f§ms,s:::<';};'_;eé3.;§> is: {mi 397' 40; gm <;:::9<;1 23:; {ha ';§.{iV{}*CE§:L€ f%:>:'j fizz': }Z?E3E'.i'E§{}D€3§' pr21§;ing_{ '$123.3'. iihés E§<>:2'%3£€ {3<}u_:r'{ may '~'~_E';€:=. $6; 2§:§i;(§§: {E36 j1§£ig_{I:f;£:1':E'. éi. E.§{}.{}?,12{}€}f% pzigiéed bf; {ha Pr}. *§$:'.§'}'1':'}§ {,Z§f\/§, BE}:-1z°v;2'-xcé in C'{3¢?€<;2.2E%2,f2{}{§1 azzé EEK:
jt;rig;_';r:;s::;t. sit 2E§¢{}2.2{}C2€.is paazgégsizi bf; {E23 §3:"LE':--.J( §}'n2:r*-azad ii';
--_}€§rE;--{§n§"~E<}.3f">/2{}€,}:"3.
xx
-..} '.§'%:.i:»:; pe:~§it:%<>'r: is Coming 0:1 ébr {Ema}. §}€ai:"§:f}§; 'V C(}1E1"'{ maids 'ihfc %' §i{}'éJi1"}§§: 7 " " "
L"
The p€~t.§§ii2:'1.@r E1213 <:}1a.He:r:g;€c§V_E.§h:: oféirizri '§,>a:ss:éT:--:i~..Vifi'._ (3q{3.N(>'282;'i2{){}f§. 0:1 Ehf: {E353 if'i'§%i€~_?I:'§.. .C§,Vi§-.;}:T;Li_{3i%§;€3vv'{E$'3"»':3§1.}, 'V .D%1a1§Wad and aié;:> m'd<:r .»'pg1ss<iC§"'i:1. C.r§Jz%,.Nz>.35;"2U{Zi5 by {ha Pr}; E§<:ssi{m:s ajilfigfi, §h«:~1.rvé:a_c§' 0:'d€::' d§':2::::d; 28.O2.12{}€}§3, ~::<)nfi:°mi1";.g ihfi <)r;:§T€:v..p21S§§ed 'b'3:: L§;if«..i'ri3§§'C;.::;é§E against Whmh the appeaé is §'2§'"'€::.§1":'..¥__f'1""£:::3§Z3;-LIV' .' «A
2. Théé V}C':.--::n%:'c§ '<:4:>_ii1<:.§;::E fer the peiitioner sL2."Urr:é%;?;ed {E12333 {be 1:23.: 'Cs:3ufrf.._§:a;S.e€3::jif::E'€ts::<5i the €Z"I'{}§° in convicting; the appeiéegna :h<;{;~;3:h' :h§:'V--.pf£:_:§éCi2:i{>:3 xvétnesses :2 E0 10 amd E?' dié '".§f_:{3'€'. s_2,r;3;3:;_r: ihfi p3i"<>s:§»:_<i;_'¢:,:V:i<m aria thegf hairs bfififi treaiezd as V.'.h{'}S:{L§§3'V £z:§£i%'«fL2;'tI'~:.<:§ ihéz m<}%;<;r veéraéclz-3 i:1:~3pec'::';r Whifi has grass":
r':#%;:~£)Ar%;-.§}i;--2V;; ;::E$s:;" mtrt 3063:} @§«:ami'nc5d. He f'ur%:5r:am' submééicd tha: 13:26 a§;~§3é:§§'.;éra.E fig vezy rinnecrsm 21:15'; 331:: E215; mm aésgmméiied §:'z'{'i}-' at: t%§{%«:r:.€; "§'§7<: EiC{ti§<:'1":i' <2<:c1z:*r<':s:i wiiiiéz m3:g:;<3:.£a{§::§; ';:=r:1:':3:e:::3 :~§;:*i{}'{,E":$«--:f 2-*{~:f%:=ée::I€: which r:~3s:1,1Et<:=a:§ E2": 21% aagéésgi Em' v:E'2§.{:E2 ¥:.}:::.-3 I £;':§_.}p{i§Ei.I1i. {T{,)L3§{§ m1}? hzavér: @3611 Exam 3iz:2b§:':%. Théié {3{}E§'1§}§£3"fiI;}I§i.£'fif~V$3' per E§«:.P?2 22:25} :':E":<t c<311.':;;>i:£§:3za11i Wim E1:-:5; §3€.:'7_:":? a-'%;>;:é*2V'::<{':":°--:a:'5:*--'--T himself as; mix: :;:¥:a*:.<:d %;ha{ the ez§:2p:~:l}»;§:":i W2z%3."i':'1' ané while (>21-er 'E':~1§§£:2g a:r10%:.I*.2<3: w3E}i{t§:':: i?;"£iE}%~i-*3hf;';C§ Azzggie-2i19:':;}s:=..__1;I*:::-;' :~st<}z2{9 in that middie of {£253. r:>2ic:§-.___e:mi "
ez2'z<}éh.<2r 1:"12'~::»:1§ ca-1%; anaé in {he {<3 22 iI"§I"fEE1§'€S :<;us;\:2':1'r:e<:i ézzjuricrs i;:~::;§€z <}'1r";VV€fi'1'1c*"L.%pz:>1:. E31 his cross; €3§<:.2:I'§}iI'";£--1"£'.i(}§'": be ';~fim§3<:s Came in frqmi of Kiss €ipp€fiE:f:3 E'.§. Ehe same, as;
Sue}: he sudd€§:.13':"z1'p§§i:;t§. '§ifh.i¢l§;@Su1t€d in cezusirzg {F26 3::1:id 2§:<v;<:iLc_§§¥%Awf1x§"j';%;3«£3_Ftih¢'«V;:§{}-;:1:;;;i21.ina:1t himseif has deposed {heat the 2ap:A§é:E_iLéi:1t ctausge fur {ha ace-idem:.. Tha CG*a,:::"?;.$' iuésimar i€§}'_§,{)'t;,":§__d§';1'8;'s»-'{3" E36512 acqI.,:.%.m'.€d him for the e:>ff€r1<:e agckiéiirggazi'; {'*u':{'E.$n£T€ of PEVE a.r::§ mhczr ;::z{>:3<3€u'é;i<}2": WiE§"i€&%8€iS ?iFé'L;%.2...;§r3 TE-i§ '2:2.;5;<;§<§£::E mast' 5;1::;;3p0§'t the p:"<)$::<::_:i:.§<m. Efrzdéér ':'h.r3.<;;c &3§'§§i7Li§:z'i'E§EZ233T}f{f€S§ H763 Eippfilléfiféi iés &ém.i'£E<ic§ far a<:<;1,2i'E:m}. " {Era ti/:55 {Ether hzmaé, t'h<3: éeamed <:r:;'Lm_<;€i fez' me
2."_:;j:3;3é.::a:§<éAn:. :~_;u1}::1:%'i:?.<3:i 31313.6, $115 widsézncés <2? PW.E.3 13: is .14, E573:
-§§::'V:é<'."§;'"E§:.% %'2;i2z-1% ::;:_2p;1_::«:T:s:"€'a'-',<:i Zhfif p§"(',}§§fi§{?¥.2'?_'i{'}§3. 'E'E2::*, ;:2:'<3s.;<é<:Lz.'E§:'m V 's I}+'L;l 3-*'§£:2€ss§z':s de§;><':s;<:é '::r<3§a>r& me C<>'L:.2'1 'thaé; this 2':§;p€i?V-3::-f_ 'w'é:5; iiriving {he zrehiaéifi' in 2: high spead ax: éhe §3"1éé;.ia§ agaimsé; ihiz :;*f;<>n€ $.31 the middle cf the F0316?..a1%1§;'=.§?:é%§*s2:f2:s--é:*"
:§.a1sE'2€3d {<3 .a§:{>1;§:<5r maxi cab whi<:h itséif g§§:'>:-3:: ';:€:' sgftmézafg4ii}i%;aVi"the'. ap;::26}.123::E Ems ct{)1f:'::r1";3Z%:f;8e:i iha :>ff&:'r:{:r:. if: r€*:~3p5eCt {if :§9:<*._<:*giCi¢'iz*1<:%;*-'V Of PW.} 'NBC? is the <:omp§ainem':j;__ 'i'£72_.E§'1f3 {3:§1V'§{:f. he has éepmged tézai the appellant's fazgvaginast me Same in the middfie cf r<}a2:'i§"'éi;=i}§i jthgrsaaftévrvf" d.é23%'1i:d fie another temps and thereafi£'fT{.@f1§§3Vi§ i;Fv'&%VS':i1,1ff1€C§ mrtié, PW3 though he hag beenV%;r<:=ate§1wa3._§:;C>s§%é1¢v._ir£.«hv.i:§:'$%:{)éswexaminaEi0:; he has <:§.€:p0sr-3:? Vt'h'z;t..V_t21.e e:r;<f3<A_St:r:i_'ca11'1<3 in a. high speed {mm I}harwad ssirfleg and &a$hgs&b_fi0._béi':éi:)nc and 2':he:'e3a§'t<::r dashed Es ;11:1a>'£§':.<:r;'§:*1f:1p<>.V =.T%:is §e§:)$iti(>:: goes to provée that the i;<};m1:%"2:;':t:e;~:d tihéi {jfffifitfir AEE the pr:>8&:{;:;zti©:3 2A}i€.:1::=vs§-S65';..§:a_}=J%: fiurézzzd h0:§E:i1@ 'am' they hgzwi depsseti ti} {E6 ifauyt '~-'§.}T1€i5(1.~E..1";_f'3':'.~' zicatazésed was in high Spméd. H£:>*ai;€'<,--*E:'g it :3 'A "'~_.§%;z%>:::é%;t:€;§é.V_§:§:a1§ an :3arfi::§;€' p<:»§:1i: 05 iima ?W.1 mzidii it "-c{33"::p§ba?i¢:i {EH E.3:€}§.2{§G': zinc} sstatéiai that EEK: 22_<:<':z,,:8:'-3:3 W213 313?:
E/§:iCh5 spew; am} :§{)m.mi%;{€:§ iihezé §3£{'.'C?:iC§€i'I§'£. and them'-23§%::::r daE§2"1{€£i MW...
'% E X. x,_ u LC; zm(3?:'.§%1<3r *2:<;=E':é§:Is:: ';F'§f;i$ {'.{}f1f}§Z)§'c1§f}"i was :r:2fn:§€~:< 9;'; az":"{é.e;é*--E_ié:§%; 311$, it 33.:-11$; '§"€;"V€EE-'§}€';'C§ Ehe 12:5-:éL§:'aE {:<3L::'s;c :12? 'me 21C<,r..%¥;_i<t:':'€::.'f'-T'?I%'1§'f§_ wag ths h.<>S§i§<~: part {Ff §}1"i)8€£'{fL3fi;i{}I'1 w§£r:é=:$S_é%s::,,__"=TE'}:V§'p:>ur;"
hag aisa sxeiznimed {hes maieqrsr 1,-'<3E';iCZ€3:,'éi::éi{E?}::i;, §::;§:.»<fs2j%azz:€f;{§"€E1€".
evédence of mam: zrehick §§1Sp€iC'§(}f" wix) §~S5SA.L§€*3(§ i§T1€'~i:{i1f'[§f§' marked as 'E?_s«:.P.§3 WEEQ <>§in@d'%h'2;.: the ar:{:%:i<:n'i _w:?%.sv«-v%3Qé<>{%.L:@ --. L 1:9 am}; mechanicai dszébait of t§1€L4'w¢:AE*1ir;E:3a E?7"rj{§m" {big Sketch p;:°:)duz:€<:3; ai E><:.P.£-38, whi<:?:'~.{Qr€§fiC$ ~C.'.§::f3'€'"_§' of £E;é'§3:*€}s6£uii<}:"; that figs accidemfs; Spat is if}'Ehe..Vr§1i:id§é".{}'§.V {E16 mad and {ha- vehécfie cams:-zd the_;£cz;id<:1rs{€f;'3.%f§<>1€ia{>f_rn<}v'é;i:§; on the iefég Sidiii a::<:<:>rding;; in $316'v:**;:a%_é".re'g;'ifl121.?;i<.:.:3; The appeiiarzt Ch"iv<::': the vehécie ii": néfigiiggsni .;Ii::; i{:.::€§*..;:iri;':§""§,r1t{9r1$EE§; 0:" the accident <:{>uE<:§, EEC 8€er1_t?za§ EM: 3;':-3fVfV1i:<:'ki'~._{1ir?;1ec§ arzfi further :'z1c:>v§:é fzxsm ighs __pI.=,-1<::';% £iCC'i€'}€'ris'£v';'w._T§'1{f1'€f W<~:r6: 2®~2';"§ §€§"s<3r1$ including @155 ._cis§"&::aSé:€i iafavééiézzg 2123. §;h2: gaéd wihicéssi '?§';<3 2zp_§3:=:§§;-.m€; 's22:-'a.:.§ =i1?:jT.1_i:fg3<§ 'inmE:%:.€:~3 ever and 23;E";<3*;{2 {ha giégtmg €23.§:2:<:iij;*, 2-=2,»'h:C:§:: Es £:<:sm::r21:°§:' fa) .m§}i:0r vehi«::§:'3's; AC? 2922353 £1386 p:'e>:ri&3i<é;:::«:."*~::=;§"iézzr, E? ::{:=z:§€§ bc: «:23; {E39 bazsség 2*}? E313 'A '}'1'f:_E.;'£"é.'f".E?§_;i--i1 p%:>C%2,a<:€<:§ tézai E31638 W212; ?;{_;'i2;£ ncgiigascé ms 3:33': g::«:e;3;r?; cf § 3 §3<3:':~;:>n:: inducziing P'i.Fv'IE§¥ W $2.:-i§,i aad P'i§€I2€3 w}:':jV"'vé:§"--_i'§1;:3 Eziwsstéggzaiizagg ififficeir aarhgg Erzéiss :'m;es;é:Egai::<i Em': :r:;;:}§€<»:s~ .23,:':a,:§":;TE,::'é; examincci the E>;P.38--t%ze Siieicéz, E.'.;';p.3? ~f {i1s;¥ E7'--§§?, VVW§_}{*','1T1x'C_§V {'.€';'T£"€§f§C€3f€€$ £153 pm' EXPJ4 11:1: 35? @0731; %3:G':9t;€:r:i~.rétg;<m§; EZXP. 12 221151 3333432 <*.>:22n3i21edju<i§g:?r§é1qis «:>:"'%;h;e ?2¥"i£iV.';v.v{:i§§';§E"'£'S3; 3 find"
%:h<-ms 32:3 gemd ground is int<5rf<::§":%.::§;.._Va§s<} 5z;}_:_1A(>i_'3 find any Eapsess in {E15 order b{§*t§j _Accc3rc§§;3g§y§ {he p€iiE;ii{)n des€:°v€s3 di$r1'§i'S;.%fi{:i.V " . " V .
37. appeiiatmi is take his. of (32:96 S5Z&1t€31'Z}€E'}*{., Hr:
ceuld ha'i'/€:_'é,'€:;:§éd: V.tT.#3f haéé the Wim.€s$€S and taken a dfifeizcfs {ha}. is Vir1":1<}c§:r:t.-"€,vlr:ic§': he has :10': $636. On Em: géyéiiiabiéi %i':a::?2"§al ans? §3¥'i{§.€}T1C€3, ti/1:515; C<3L:.I'E. can :19: t;;3;:«::i*£:::}'**'.:§éff{§r:@f:t._ <>p§:",1i0r3, étxcapi. affirming f;§'§{3 ardétr (3? {he {3<>U:"§s§'*Eaéiiéfixféy :5A<t£:{;rc§:%:"1g§y, aha 2'ig:>peaE its d§&sr;:1'§:=_«:s<£:§.= Thfi 'g:ppe1E2::V:;: ?:eaéé §}i5'€1'§ puniahsd fez' 3-: psrityd :3? {EH95 mzsntha :§§:zip'§::~ .i£'IEpf?§E3(}F§§1'E€3F1?I fa: {E15 offerzcfi punishzibifi é,1nC§6:" S€C{i{)fiS w{ir_">3?':emd «:31? {EEC emd fmzz" I"§'£{}1'1'£E'2fE§ 0?? émp:"§:';<;:§m<3:n: R}? %;.E2€ "4.V<>§f€::::€. :.ms:%€.:° E§{'f{i'Ei.{}E3 57;? EEK; in '€:<:>'%.aE S§€;"i-TEE": mamthss E:-ass , ...««~*""'"z';'W"".m.,'