Karnataka High Court
Dr B K Karigowda vs State Of Karnataka on 28 July, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
E2 E3 SEN {EC}-E. E{3.{3A.E:'U R. L,€Z}KI'EiZSI'--E 'J ,sXGf,§If} 54 Y1s:,:m$._ S/'O \.:'£a:1:§RAEa32~;Ar;)§2ALa;1«-4:.
N0. :1 :19, £51' zvmm, 2333 {:§€(_:«S5S.
SI~ZI§%AM§3UR;"£., 2N1) S'.F'AG.£i..
;M"{'SG§€Z%: M 580 023' 'M:M:\»mr2m';x2>'P;x R AGEI} AE3GLI'£' 49 YEARSQ S/O L;'m«: mNG;x1,;x.}>-L N09 L429, Em»-E CROSS, A UN§V£iRSE'§'Y QUAI{"§.'E3;E%Z:3_._ ;
.E'~A''.z'S<i}I%';E m 5?:3 06. "
13R. NAGARAJA, * we Lgmz: SRE?;'E§R';%§NC?xE?P£%f, '' _ -
R/1¥£'NG. I;*"i;2:'Z%',.._23*lE};7€fE~?;«£;i--§S~»., V ' sAN:):»«£1NAGg;;;:,:,'g, » V BREE LgxK.sHf':<,i1:R.#s;:§;C¢a:sIA<:'£{i:_zi. :2.1.ILs: .':;<z:z.' EaE-mg)mvA*:f;§.:,;V'SH:'§xz:O_§mj_'£3:_sf§i;a:€'£'. .. . E3§€'§"E'I"TOE'"'§E%Z§€f% {By SR; gs E1?1j2A;';%E-»EEi71\?'f§4'E,.g1;D\f;v£5é3.e'R RA.:r1\:;s;,§gr»,»j:;*a K3..§MA.R";%.$SO{i§fi.'E'§Li8. A§f}'v'fi'~3H} ;§éf&.§::> § ~ .
< ')«»ww}.
S':':é;:"§%: 5}? Er§:'NA'§';aK;:1 :rz.§2::I%a>:§a:$_:§:I\;fE';:::;> By' §'.£.'E-3 :~3E:':<",:i-Ta:T«.:V:f;z?*~},i§*z:
E'f}§iE1';'3;4E?fi'T%'§§:iE"«§'£' {E7 .E%iE_§U{3§'i'§'§{}Ng "'§E:;£E;C}E'~~EE%:3%?;-- :§:;}{I{',;'a"§'§G?*~§}§ '=51/E.E%, E3{EiLEi}§'{\§€;}§ V ' f »5":"'§~:" E:'L€}{}R, . '?駧%r'E.E{E,§ T E?E§{Z153'E'€EiE§§i§%§'.%.."E€L§} 3?? E%E*=Z€fIE*~Z§€'.§}7?:.§€7::i'9 ' _ 'E,'}f¥é.,. :T'%_=§:EE:§E§§}§§§:R VEEZ§§§f}§*§.§4 ' }I':3;{%.T'§{}f%.§Mz€}E€.E§- --m 5&9 {X} E , if ?'x§EE»-"'§f*.'E§-EEi:§E'§":"', "Z w5_ §GRDER E-{cam {he Et:2m.'1e:::i ::<m11ss&%§ $2}: the pé::t.i€;i<>:.1e:* and 't.he E<:,=::;1rn€-:<"i Senier Am-*<>cat'.<% Sri P.S.Ra}ag_§0paE appearizzgg for Elhfi cemiésézi for this §*&ts3p<J:r1d::3:ni'.-{}m§ve:*sii;3I.
2. En i;h€: wake 91' the I)i.vis;i<>z1 Bemith_ ciir«3::t*::e:ci 'shat, E',h€? p€<iit.ie:3:1_s3 be {',€}1.15§'gi€ii€I°_ £Tf{"',§jfC}I" _{§Ef:E§,E .,' r:i§sp{}s21} :22": "3£<:r*rn$ <3? ité; <>rdx:=.';;' g:i'.2:'§ed ."VE"5fT_I~«E8'220}1G"--%.»;az:':c::5 "
having z*eg";a':'d to '':.h::-: u1*g_{e:n{:3.2 Ether %*<:s;;Q:1d£3i':-€:<3 Tfgavizgg mavad am 21 E'§<ie?zt.i::):2 for <?:2"§z1.fV"?}e.2f_r§n--"f1::E:a>_ 5e:éi.§<):":s .':1II.'f:3 ~- ~ _ _ -1.55 -- ~ .
i',&§%i€;':fi up £132' €T{}§1Sid€FE1f,i(}I§H _ 3, 'i'E1<3 f21_<:E'.ss§ br1§é§"§j;*'E§?sa.t.§%d'j-aé' f{§Ef§<§v=;s*.- ' E: iéfiv "f{{ii3;1':.~.:§.§'1e: §§é'i::>§i::§ §'<:$pG:";d€-::'2.€,-- L'n;i_ve;:'5~:-:i*;,:~; is; tzéiéwiy &$i.:::?E_33.:§é§h.§§ti»..E;E::i*».r'::%:*s;i%.y wh.?1<i:Z<1 {tame §z":%;.:1§ exi.$é€:':fw_e §r{}§*:'; %;E";:3.§;s3;1:'v. 2;'{1$:C%i§§ WEEECE": §'1a::§ a2{i'm:'E..£§€{i i'.§'i§*: :1:€::§":):é'§.§":'1£%;;i*:.': <3? <:e2"iié%:f§I;%é. i'.s;=,23,<t'E:":i§1,g>; 2*-,:%;:::if£ Pr<}'§"eé$$:3:';<:L §{€£i{§€',.E"S ._£:'E§':C1.. §;»§§f{7iéfi.fii§Tfif€~'S. "§'hs% 'v"€;EE"}=' s_%am<": p:2si,$ 2m5:r€: mt- §'i:3':.ifif:c§ E3}? 2:_v'§"i;:ii%;§§::;i'§" :1{::'é§f§{':a"£,§;<;::':': {ézzzmzéi §}--E §~2..{§{}?" E3".
.4 "§':§i::;"z.i." %.:§':,:3 gléiif§.§§.1§.€.i%E'"§§2E§'E% E"; 2:215 :2s_'g:>§§i§§<fs:i $9? ééizsz? §;}~::5e;%;s~':; 6 « 3~Y2C~$®'2 '§&¥%'%$£'L Pmfesgzssuzfs E:U;"§Ci R.<;"-ra::ic?z*-:=.'-s w1.1<3$e §§:';;'.E8{'?'{.§E3I'*': vszis; {£111}; é1ppI'{)K-«'€ffd by S§mcEi::21i:%, by 2»-*.i.ri;11<:: of t4h€ §.'fi'EE's{flE.1"§§{}E_f*»:%f pz1:~.;.se€i, t,}3ay were _p"1a,<::;%é in "(E36-2 $e§<:%<?§. §1':~:;L A<%{::3z'{§'i--:%§§Ejg*,''.' ' i;'.ht3y 's,=;,:=€§<3: e:i.i§_;;ib£e {:3 be £3.pp0iI7if€.'€i in t}.:;r:...<}:fder_~'€"J¥§:":}:3%:*§*§f* W-"§*1e3;:"; the: p<%E.i1'.i:>:::3{$ m:::'<;% 553:1} 6*ag;;<;:riy"'a3.x¥:%;ii_€iii_1g"~w?iiii 2'-1 fond hope ihai; their <':,2"1:;<;*::-3 w«:>uIci 3:3é§%~».;:<>r1s5'ié;€rz'::<:i; vii, in Ehafi. {:§:"<?L::mstan<:€ i'.§:3j;. "H'1_,é3.fi§'}i§i§§1'S7%éAff§,'.E1833 t}.1{<i'£;':;g;?.1f._. git:
1:9 :r'e/advs3ri.is;e the very 212?.
Anns3.x'u.réi~£\. and it #1515;.«V'g§%:iii.i<3ners are befmra U128 C=€)t;§:z:fi_:--.V " A it <:fi:m§3.-s_;eE fez" E3625 §3€'{.:?;.im1erz'$ i.éi'2:i." in :%€::;s£}'E:fi:i<>n €§8.§',€;'fd 3'i--'?~« 2669 wh<;'::§_§.E1€V§'§;§1§iEa:%a;3;:;.eA;E;_§§{i*"";§ég3§3:'{}%:<:%§i ihs s;:3Ees;:i'.:£:§:§ <3? f§'1r:2a*At. V }1E'}.'c1C§€ by fizz? i§§«::»a1r~s:§ sf Appé>i'§1%,::§:%'1(2fig:-.V_§:§':éAqé:;.:>:S;i.2E<>:": af réégaézzéizigm b€3'ii'i§_§ §'€f'x?'€f'E°:E"§€{§ An:::§;>:1:..:"s:éa{} A§K§'E"1§"}'iE1"°E'I"ElDf%§E:E§?!.}§€:? in Ergzw 215% in §,é3}"E'§EE~:§ {>5 ""s§i:i:i.E:e_¢$§e:§;::i.§{:s:'zt 5?} <3? S€3*.{T?'i',§.€}'§1 $23 0? €',§'3€ Eaaéii, i:E":<::;'£3 is 2.15} ._ °€:.<*%€:z;3{: -ffgr. éjééaé S§;2':c§ia::£_'€§}, ii} zwzééréaér §'€fS{I}E'§.§§.§{}E'L {i§§"i.{?§",". ii", ~:%;§.é--_;§':'<:s:»-vsgécf éiizis £7:E2}§}{}§EE§1:3'§{i%§E'fIfE§ 2.~'s..i':{§ E2. E5: E2': %'.§2z;§.'E: {Iféi}§"§.§.{?'fX§.a 6 {$16 E<321:":':€c1 cm,1.ns<:%i €21)? {E16 pt2'5{,i'é'.§{}.m=*::'sés wiyuld S£;',£3i{ iii} piéléféff :'é%}ii21:.'1<:.:~t 0:2 i;:h.e '£:1c:>1'§a:m.2*i:'::§ 2m%.}m.rii:_iess:
.3} 2} 3} 4} 5,}
5.
of }§x$';;:e:Oz*a'r az'zoi.i1€r' €.fr1z've:'siz':y c,z3,<;a:::nda Rae & An0£.Ez€r {AIR £955 352;;-2 zgf ' B.C,}'vfyEaz'app::a azm DR. €§§1ii§_§s;,g; ;a.:z;;z.;>;4a;pp§:;%V %' V fjiR.R9 1='e1'zR:aZas:zbbaiai2. ii: O:!j:f2e;j5:i 223% ' « , T f SCC 306) S}'zan§car Rae (Z7f"z;1«:I1;I"'€c:r;ZZar.v. Km":'1ai£:;:,E€::"' S Uzu've*:*sa'iy {IL}? I
f)RgA.V.V€r1kaia V f2;fif£'£'::ci:7": ; ffitfzers vs:
Chartgreiian Ugziversifig'z:'%'s::<§€'§1e:" {IL}?
298} % "
S 'i/'"z'm:pg);5£i:$§'§<3{;iA§s:1fé;:_ ..:{V;3*?{,:'£_.V:'1§j£?5_f(V34f"'5:f'3' £53 T516 C§iaa;r1:::e2.§.0r. E3c;::§;a,§;9fz'e3.Vi;f;'ié'.:;¢;"s§.§.;; §§»:i;§§§;§Q§'e'3 Arzoimsz' {SLR 293;
Em i,i1§=:..LiErsi; '*r3f"' 'éizisézs in Urziyersiigj of gifggsgrze pg_mi:,a<;w::*:+;§g'Raa' {$2522 3955 SC 419;; §E1E>i?aS 22 {i?é"iS€§ .*?a;:E?3§<::E";v V..{is::;}i§:f; ¥2§2'i"§§?.'§ 2: s;i'?{.1.:a?é,i<>11 w%:e:s"<3.§'::_ a :"e<:<%::11::1£§€:~a2;:i21§ie::%';»--__{§§}i;E";€: §:;a:*{§ cf §f}§.:"23a?:'s,@:*:a§ W.-22$ .s§e%. at '7,§:a:..:gE%:'i', E}? ':',E*:s:: §"'§§;;gh C{,>';,.:§"é: ;?:z:':ii éiiass Sé:H"§E{i §":2§%;ri.:":.g§ be';<:%:':
.1 «§?;31:'.;*:§:::s§ i'ié'£~..;Ti§,}§%f;EEi:§.§ $332;-'_: S9;z.:;3:"{%:";'}{;% €",i:.>:,m1 §'1£'i?§{§ z':%sz:'£" if §'.E'"§€;?§"{? <a {WM zi:»i. "--
aware: .:a-:E'1egz:.t:i<:2.:15_~; <3? E"i1&1iE1fid€;?S 0:"; t:E':<;~: pm': (3? <i<3«::.i$3':'>:": cf thee: Syxiciiczztze, EE1~f;',I"€ wzase; {ii} s5(:c:::pe fen' i:;3.'i'.s§:"§'<:%re:1«::<:: by i:§";::% C::}1::r"L '§'h.i$ w<>z,:1<:i neryi: bi', §e:i<2rm.i<%:s1i is iihgé p:'é::s::;€i§1;?£;L». ._ (3215:: Gr: h21m:i' Sinéiszé E2' is E'§€3i', iihe: :"6:»;:<3m::1e:::1{i21tj(>§%§§"Ejfff Izhe. B(;:51:*d of App<>i:1i.r:1em.$ ii,§1:>3.t; ES} MmS§§:.:gE:.'éf'"'E.§§::"_V: {§E.I€'.Sii(}1"iE3C£, but the i1're§;11Ea1r§i:.ie%s :'E;:3.A'i:. when 'Effie 'm:;1E:'£er was p1a{:a-d bei'0r*é_ $ 2;1§>, Syf:vdi{:::Vi:¢3; _WE?:.ic-hm wa.rrar1ted gush extrenze z1£:i._i{}n <:aLiiri:g._£b'£:_» the i'ssS,::21::{ée 9f 3. fresh n.0t:£f:i<:.ati()11, .£::f :23; rs;g{::z %'ap.p;§:: 322,33
8. in {he <?;;1s%'::§ Ven,kai'@$ubE:2a§r::§: 386}, the: faci §§ii'.u:;1%i.§.G:": Ezadi ssaughég is in%.€rf<%re: v§,r'iE1'?f;'.V§:§"3€: by tint: B0a_.r°d (3?
A§3p{}im€:m'1§§;:?.s:LA. $1.? '$1211. 119 reasazag: E?'J€:E"§'3 e1§:»p::=:EEa:':§"'s; é3}£§,}°i"':IE°'§€?§"E{?€ as 2:
§¥{€3{:>:;:1§':*;t.E"r! §3:"§{";r ?;.<:= his a§}p{§in':,mé-:::":2'. as ?_r:3§;%:§s&-;€;s:9;"---- 315:;-g{§ E?2«;%.'vé.z':g.;§ be:;3:=%:_"; iaisz-:22': Ema} {-Y{mr¥3:-§.E'§£€§fi:EfE:%4-E:-E.{§:1"E1; 32:": .é;.E'"s.:;-T: V::'.%3§s;<33'}<.%s:: :72? :;'-::':j; r:1:;*£;"1E"i_{§.é:es33 i;%:§*: Eiiggh {_i«:}:::§*E; Eéiéi. §;'%£T§§2%§§.f%{E§'§ 3.1;; i:":?:';::::°§%-:=:*:*,: {LE2 éiéési {§sZ;':{fi§§§.§€'}§.'5. £23?" '§:%":::;% xi ,., _§g$ BQ2:;2*::i Qf .A.p;><3i::i;:1"m1':is. Asa; ap;;:t2';:1'e-:'1i: £'r::sm i:E:e If::1{Eij.S and ci:"<:11r11:si:2m{:é:$ E:"i§1{i ass :'§g»;§1i,E'y p(:sin:?::%<:% (mi. by Eh:-3: k%21rn:>,d S€fE"i'§{}'I° Adv{§:::21i=:': in Sat) "far" 21:55; i:h,s=: ;3re:..sa:€=r:t. fact? $é.'?c.:_1a'€:is:1V in iihe p§"€'ffS€;',I"£'[. <::2":s'~3e «cm hzmd is; ::?:<>:":<::<:mer:i, it is m:«'s: '*- is Elf}? am a di£'ferens:;¢:': sf Opiltiifiil w*:ii'.1'1_'é;.h:% :seI.:€:%f,i<>:Eij ,(> fV. <%a':1didaE',ess by Boazrcl sf Appc3£11i.m<-3:1t',:*--3 '~.w}1i{T:T32" iS'»s_3{:nV: §g3*1"{I' to be the: rezéasgcm for £116 <iir<--::3t.i§;r_:"'--*E;§> reééo iT.h£-:é'»..eér;i;'i';reH §Jr0:::€:*:«s$5 bui: it is {.115 léifgfijf.p}'7f3S§i_I3.¢;{{3'.0?.._vEAf.Ff$3;§;¥,{1'3E%!.%i"§iA§;%§, which §'2£~§§.;§jt bfféifi hig;£1'Iigh{:;ic:i\.,§§f;§.f§;: '4V:*£§,fnC1i::21%;a:, whicirz has axrarramiefgzi V ' 271 in aha Cha;*:ce;'ZZo§«9 Kamaia§«:a 3;§§'LR"- .V>§--§8S' 2.432; *{}m r&(:{>mn1e§1{i2fii_;}:i of " V__'<>i." Ap§3{>i'r:im&:2tss W213 §§e§§a.%:i'g-wéd {'33%;%;,§:_%f::TE_§{éz;": mad §':%1<3 iimzrf: E::_ax.-iszgg E1i7§V?3V'%35'v?;3_3"€3?{§':...Q1???'---.§7}13».€if%}€.i{}Eé"§'§'§"'fl'§€3 :1:-i':§:,>f2.§iiw;%., zafzmiii hzwe EEC} z'<3§e%J--:1_§1'{:s:_Earsfigié.,g§'r§:Vs§::2i. fa<:%i,ss {sf "ii:h€~; attaé-3% zmd *::§1€: E€g;2i'E "g3;~.<>asi:§'§:2:f:.$V §:1v_.s§{; .far S:::s=::r:i;E:i;:': 5:3 <3'? files z~";<::'t: is "-§r1?:;s:3;':i":<:§:??7€r"2{;':<'§., "iii, 3;;>§'e*:5;{:r:"£%§::2és éhai. §"€',{E{}§'3;1§.E"i&';'§"}€§22'{.§{3§'E :3?" §;§':<::
"--§%<§2:'-::*é;'?._ 'v:'.iL?§ };£%;}g:§5:§;'":'£:2':':eém::%s; seiméé §>E;;::::%<><i %::éé§'E:3:"%:% E:.E':&? ! ,/ §_ .
,«;3- H9 w<>t.1§c': fghxassé {.'.€.)Ij}f.f3:1d "ii,h2';=.t. iihé-3: Efrziversagity has-3 <:21.i4{§g<3ri<:a11iy 2;:1{E:":1iI;:€:e<i ihzli, "£3116 pef:€t.£:§:1€3,r$ had '§:}€:é:17_ seEe:?i;<3»;.i and app2'<:rvs3<:i by the Sy':'::.1i<:a'{:c?, 'E'if1i:-is I{'€:'.£iCii.E§"' .Ei(Tf{?€3fp§Z:E:1b3€;? si.r3<:e tile; very .s3f:a1'£t{--:r11.e.':1:: fi;~éit1e€'.' ithereirz ine:ii<:at".<2s that; appmvzzi was_~: "{t{:§I":._€ii{.i(>ri2i1" -as-m:;'i "
sLz'b}c::*:. to a legal c>p§.1":ir:>:2_ being ()bi{;§i'1'¥.fi?€1, if<;.__fé.a1<_;:: :1 fi'~=:i%i'i'" 'V df3CiE:'-i{)§"1. This; 21130, a.c<:0rdirag t;0"'t'.h_é;:-- §é;%21,":':1ee1_A';i%<::2;i.m* Adv<3ce1t:e. Was; brozlght £10 fiche' ;:f;i.<::g::.fi(?;r1::hé§1--.§3ivisi:)::
Bemth which cai'.ego;'*ig:a*£1}? iffljfifitéiéi-,;§i.i1j,{*~.S'£1(i§'iVS'ia.I1d an the pexrii <35 the ;)a€:'t:'iv{'.1'§_;;7é':1;}:'1%'$5;._ ' Q. iearzzssrci Seziiar ;%€Ev<;::?:.';2.i;€% aviic} €.hz"<;ug§'; iihié very ;*ese:}iu£',i{m gwiigzsig {:;>{_3{:3":t:f;* tTf:'s::V§g§{Té'i:§_1;i<>z}.<:~.:'s.'; U3 {:%0m:{-snzi "éfiai:
§'*:::§2c}};t;tii{§§i"Amniid rmfé, be icmiesi as; an {.1E1if{}1?E,.{§.§.'¥I;§%€}.i"i'E3_E: 'v._ :;s§;;:$fg;:f:3f.s;23E sf '{'.i*E€;% s~;-2as:i€e£:t:i<m; <35 éhe V.__E%'éi:::di:iz1§;@$_ byi~A$y"::1€§:Z:E2:i:€' 'é'.£*:&3: i°<>§§<322v§§2;;;; izzfirmiiéss-3 "'2i%"€%"--$€§::ggh§: %".<:;;...'Tz§€3 E:§gE:§§gg§1i;<:{§ :%:§=::h f"€Ef{f,"E°€i§}{i?E? E19 IE1:-;-3 gzzigi " ._ %'::?s;':_;E1: E-t§f.V<f:1r"--: .:':2.::"m<;*:§}n_ 522} 'E_'%é;;:s§. fizz: §E'E"§iE'?§°i-?§.£%§%?E% §'§£3;.{.'§ §'}i'}§', §3i;.=:§5;': E2:::'=§=:§ w§i:Er:i:'2 $3 §§2a:}r":§'.§:&s 5% if) .\ ,"}5v.
t:::3r'{4ifi«:.?z1§,e55 and markss C?21I'dS ami €V€'I} L0 «::2.:r1<1icia.t.e=.::~; 'WI'I{) had ;'--_3<3:E1.1re>c1 less: 'E.ha.1'2 55% mar1~:s in t'.h«:~*: €p_1&EI§f:._;'§.£1§;
€%XE1.1"11iI1€i'£,§C}I} 2.1316 396:1': to '£'}';:>ss§?""'*-- wI:m did 1'":<>i. p(7S.'?§'€;':§§fE% Ezfr-'Aézé I"€':q1.EiSiT.€ <;a.'1z11ificat;i<m.
C21:1cii<;121t;esea wizég Eiizjhzfi. ri:,:et--.. 4' itlairzaeci 1"tE'.S§€fI"\f{3..'{.i(3'E'1 'aemgi v.1~'h<:»-. _ _ had 110:; £=;nCk)S'e_(i ' {';21£%>i,f; . _ c:erf;_:fi{:at<~3s / casi::3_ % ' and ii:_1r_:{:i3*.zie <:€rt'.ifi<:2ii;§%s 21$" "i:1':»r3{_' 's-?a;<9:§t: In 213:' V had 1f)(}i(:«'.I'i:"€f{}'f"§E§i{§€f€ifi_'>E§f1d_ §§'I\-"GT1 benefit. 01' :f_€r'.~5(-éL**;ré1t;';1c)I_1,"-. "
.£--3¢':)mp0i;¥3ti1:ig:>1fiV..: .C:Af°~ '_--..8<§.2i:":.iS of
3 A§37"pQi1f;ifl1éf,fif,S §%r23$" :§{§r1é:rar'y is n h';:*:' {E _C}€Z?.v§%1€"gL; '£'ai:E'c}{:.1s5s ;
"j;?§VI€é7§:ribé'§*S"- Of §<}a;:"'cis; {:25 V' SE§3pt:i23'i::i:'ée.::1i,$ f Elafi ségmed bVi:2..%1%«k .§éi§:gé:;j9 \>E?'h..i(Eh {Sid moi".
<::i\mi',i;1§r:,. "i'E?:_e=,' mariis zfmvzzrcieii 11¢:
V'z';',7c'i7{fl:'"E E-:>_§'"§é§1e, «:::&.:":dic:i:::1§€:s.»* u;z1::§{:1"
f;';;'<_?.(,';§1 «:3? i'}}(:'f ;>ar;:m€:i.é3r&s. Wiléks flhéif p§<§c€:€cE.i1'1g§.<5 {Ef *r.E1:> ' ;:s.ee:%:i::g 0%' ihfi Efiazarii 0:"
'3%.;:2p<>i;'3I:r:'2€:1E. s~31':<>wg-:6 :::<-?r€,222,i:§ Kliliffiibfii" sf :2.'2<5m":?3<:*:'é3s €10 "bet? §3r{3:_s-:;e}:";£,, fizz": pr<2z:é:&%{i§:':.gs W'€i'€:
Her}? ::;i§;;:':<;Eai by' 2-21} 0f éE1:é:;":.
".§'i%':<;-"tr? w€:%:*&% <':e:ér':'.2..2i:': .::1$<:*::'E"..é{f:i'2§s £2": $53 p:*<j3{ts:<:§.%iz1g;§:: :3? '$16:
§:§{T§§:1.§'{,§S {zsf fig}§§{}§E'§§E§'i§jf§2'§ZE§3 3 _1g-
se;2.:rn.e zitixd t:}':<3y hz;1.v<:: E-E15-3-(3 ;;";21:'£':?4:7ipa'z.t:=;<i; at £'.he::t iI1E'.:>:'vi<:1>v5s \1?I'}.i{'.}'"1 w<3:ré3 pe;::"mi't.t.é;>:r;i :*suE3}eci: :0 ihe r<rs;1.:E% 0:? *f::E':c*: '~§.?§ET:i"'€ .V §):3§;.it:i<}:.'1s;., §1'}tE%€)§§-1E' 23:3; "(ha p<%?i_i:i{):'1€r §'€c:s:3§.1.§5 and '7' 2111 f21ii"'E"1€Si-3, ajehamlii é?..}~S{> H) be pef;'.1I."I3.1iT.'ff';:'.A{§..1"Z(j3é €;',\z€.1.'1 i',k3{>1T:ggh 15.1% ;:»:'c)ci:<-.-'usage; mig._ghi; hawés <tié'?;z1é».'€:€}( 2:1 z;:s;,:s:; 2-1;. "
this p{}iiT1iI sf izimca 3%, Hence, iiim E3I1ia:c;2rés§i~*;g isT:.:e:_>; p:£fi§:'i"£. 'figs? §3e:iit,i0m2;'s NGSVL5 arid 30 t;':># .AAg'f.§V',,*> 1§3_:iiC21.i.§<§r";$
33.,-'hi{?}": :':-sizezii be 31011;;
with 0'§h<;*.r he V6 b<3e-":z:1 $0 p:"()<?€ss:5€§ . 211351 30 "being §:v§3,:"n:*:é1::t,<3:i _:.z:'12f::§«:{: amé i;E§<;%§r app1ic:2zi:i<}zf;;:s--v §V;;*v£(}:;:.'s§é,*:sss,A«_§'é5:*.{f'..;.&?{)2,z.'Eci s*€.:e:E': the s€E£3<::t:i<}I} T::£?:_'§'I1"$c%«ésw%{%€=: ::«:>n<':€m.€:{£, it 35:3 matigzr azieszar 'fL§"1éE'ii Eih:*':'«.$:3E?€zé.§:.:"éiégé, LS-E':.-21%} ':39; preéparesi in 2-:{:<t:}:'{i:a-3.:'sc€ 2%-*'§.fi:E§_ Elhfi:_§;}E"(}~"~fi§~s§.{}7i'T£f§§ {;:'§°f '§§'§€;¥ Am and 3.31:3 &i§3'§§{}i§3.i',E§'1€?E'"}§'.S siraaii be é :f;:;*£é;3:£.'::' A.£':%>i;<';i2%§:::'.'*' iE'::'~f§{}fa.§"' 22:3 'iihfi ;j3c}§;i,:s; GE §}§"€}i§".SS{";!§' 5.1":
I' ",E.';é%.§'fiif'3Z.:§i§é§§; "§'€{%2.2{E{é:* in i{.a.n§'2a.e:§2?§ amai §%;<%;:<i§s:&r in €{}:z:.:"::§'::':::e":
V 212:3 :{"f€_::I5E"':i'.€'f'§"§E{',?{f§:, §'j§'2€;'? ff:i=2§§"§"i€t :éE";2:1;EE bass Ee§<':;>§: :2': ;;,2".§3a=:~__§,.-T*22:..2":«:T:*s';% ;T:§':::.E .» K, iL.»°' <.
a s;ha1E bt? p1"<3::fe$&seci a1E€;1-3;; with i;.ha=? ;.:pp1i<:a.i::i.<::'1s of théir p:;=:t.it,i<3m:2's:: N<};1.§ and 10 K,-X.»-*11i<:}'1 Shéifl 13:2 filfid. by $16111 withiii {me xIs£%:%k frzma tiz:>{.1z-13;. E-i€::3«::e<:: the <t<}'1ms-t;§:1.V_V a.pp<:%a1"'ir1g fazist' the pet:ii:im1e3r$ is; dirs:%<?.i.€:<i {:0 i1"¥i','i1'I1E}$.€f';fhé". pei.it:i<m€rs 0f this r€e:;1,1ireme11i. $0 t;E'3.a.'i'. they may with this <>rcE::=.r "r101: waiEi1'1g for 221 (:eri'i'fi.:-32d <):*cier. ' The arder of se;{.a:~_,r g_,§r2m:::eci €f§1'"§i(;'.T the pef,£'::i0n£»; st:z1z1::§ Clisnaisssstéd,