Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Punam Kumari vs M/O Defence on 7 November, 2019
i OA No. 764/2018, 2435/2019 to Z50/2019, 3235/2019, 326/2019, " 366/2019, 4346/2019 to 439/2019, 4497/2019 to 4354/2019, CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAT ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos. 7164/2018, 2458/2019 246/2019, 247/2019, 248/2019, 249/2019, 250/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 366/2019, 436/2019, 437/2019, 438/2019, 439/2019, 449/2019, 450/2019, 451/2019, 452/2019, 453/2019, 454/2019 Date of decision: O7,11.2013 CORAM:~ R. VIGAYRUMAR, MEMBER (A). R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (0).
Mes. Punam Kumari Ex-MTS, PA No. 63771-G, widow of Late Rai Koshore Singh, age-32 years, Occ. Service, Presently residing at SMO P-134/3, Air Force Station, Devlali Camp, Nashik 422401, Mahareshtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.764/2018.
t Suxdso Kalu, Age-44 years, Occ. Service, presently - residing at H.No.305, Shingwe Bahula, Deviali Camp, Nashik-422401, Maharasntra.
...-Applicant in OA No.2465/2019. Santosh Digambar Kshirsagar Ex-MTS, PA No. 63 758-A, Son of Shri Digambar Kahirsagar, Age-28 years, Occ.Service, presently residing at A/6é, NE, Panchjyoti Society, lali Camp, Nashik-4d22401, Maharashtra.
3 OANO. 7684/2018, 2459/2019 to."2502019, 3253/2019, 3262019, ' " 366/2019, 4536/2019 to 4359/2019, 449/2019 to 4549019.
.. Applicant in OA No.246/2019.
PS, Oce, Service Presently residing at Village Shingawe Bahula, Deviali Camp, Nashil-~422401, Maharashtra.
-. Applicant in OA No.247/2019.
bas pe ry as $y rr to ry $B wo fu rs fi tha Ty bo yt be f 2 oA ~~ hs © wi 3 i ea ry ft op rs y $63 tp
143) r ta + «ky Crt ty OO. ret a alde, Age~-40 vears, Occ, service, Presently residing at H.No.279, Ambad Ganvathan, Village-Lahavit, PO-Lahavit, Nashik-422502, Maharashtra,
-. Applicant in OA No.248/2019.
Pravin Shivaii Gawali EX MTs, PA No. 63760-S, Son of Shir Shivaji Gawali, Age 29 years, Occ. service, Presently residing at jailyv Market, Shivaji Chowk, Lahavit, Dist. Nashik-422502, Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 249/2019. Vined Kumar, EX-MTS (PH}, PA No. 63770-5, eon of Shri Late Hazari Lal, Age~39 years, Gcc.Service, Resident of 145, Idra Colony, Ratnada, AF Area, PO-Reasidency Defence Lab, Dist-dJodhpur, Rajasthan-342011.
.. Applicant in OA No.250/2019.
Sachin Govind Adka WT IF Ten * Ex-NTs, PA No, 63759-Pr, 3 OA No. 764/2018, 2453/2019 to : S30/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, * 366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019, 4490/2079 to 4542619 Son of Shri Govind Adke, Age~28 years, Occ, Service, Presently residing at H. No.703, Rarkhana Road, Post-Nanegaon, Nashik~422502, Maharashtra.
Namdevy Bhausaheb Jaras Cook, PA No. 45824-N, a Ee S of Shri Bhausaheb Jaras, Age028 years, Occ. Sarvice, Presentiy residing at H. N.19 I. it, Malwadi, District-Na 422502, Maharashtra.
... Applicant in OA No.326/2019.
54Shik Yogesh Panchurang Chavanks EX-MTS, PA No. 63764-L, S/o Panduranhg Chavanke, Age-24 years, Occ. Service Presently residing Village & BO Shivade, Taluka-Sin » Mandir Gali Nashik, Dist. Nashik~-422502, Maharashtra.
mp rs .. Applicant in GA No.366/2019.
Rajesh Bhikarsi Pardhe Ex-MTS, PA No. 63761~-A, Son of Shri Bhikari Fardhe, Age-31l years, Occ. Service, Presentiy residing at NP-~95/01 Six Chawal, 25 ED AF Station, Devieali {8}, Nashik-422501, Maharasntra.
.. Applicant in OA No.436/2013 Mano t Prabhakar Shinde Ex-MTS, PA No. 63763-H, son of Prabhakar Shinde, Age-25 years, Gce. Labourer, presently residing at 124, Maruti Gali Lahvit, Nashik, Bistrict-Nashik-42250¢2, 45/2019 to 2019, 3236/2019, 2019 to 439,2019, n O18, f t 642 OA No. 437/2019, 2019, 32 (2019, 436, e DA No?
S0F 2
366. an 4 .« Applicant a a Ch vt et rt ca om o iy m Oy in ny wa, fs] oy he % Fy sit <i se =} © 83 oO ms @ ma el ra Ka wD Q 6 G 3 G Oy nw Me A eT A oo A G4 otk 43 eo hd © sed rg Ad » rt th c Bo th g ss i @ i . i] ry esd a at = Sd a t} ma TQ kd iu 4 oO wm SL org " Oo "nd ad "rd wf » OD Gone vl ~ ES Ob ut a3 ~ % wd wm, Bed LOE Ey r a ONE Sa TE rf bl th RE gs ha "it G, OD 2 Ob -ed ie Dy boo] i 2; $k S$ ky FS OY y MOM EG § woe a, OO GD Day pw em OOS OO Ay ~ TS « bs} a 430 oo ved re MN et on oy eh SJ orf a Cb et ta oh ' W 42-45 fn ha vey Dp * Ty TH LI O yd > EI ow ow Wh os iO S66 mw . ' EO xf $3 sp a uy ft Oy cy . ur £5 42h ae a Af may ° ee my a * "i oy gy m7 . ay J SO oe 4d Some ot Oy DM UP wy Me SS RE re tt ty ct ivy 44) O Ma hb wo OO ed gy Tp ame rE Om O MM TG Ub ed a mp O 8 Gd BE Gh wed EF ey ed Be th ha a ft BO ved 1 tA OT fy md oa DB (ee Os ccd by Py ap M4 iD Eos » s "ef 1G SP WO « 6 0m O 4 xf PM ted ns! set +O OP 2 wo tm y MH LE MG a Mer O Of oy 6 a cet AG RM wom | meee MM O a > 'Op | og ay * 3 @ S32 wy + in Wm aw Mee og 43 ot 43 Oy Dy be ay ~ G6 Of 8 w Qo ard ba Sy el be ray Ro Core 6 OH ab 4 Wh ned eed fm hog fue Dey eed ct Kor OO WG a St mre yp Ch ae jo ke OP yy © 4 So) gb tp, UO} Part po Ca oct fbb st ee ct ot at WE se 4 es Me GY ea ed a 43 3) Ot Dart OCR vr TH ai BD wo @ Um we 43 7 4400 Oe ok ag Sy My hg ee rt 1 Be Med OR ed a MSW bb ed cs E41 OO OG Oo sed gy td OF Os SO ha BE sed Od (by $4 eho OO ory 3 { 0% 0 34 AGUS hs be wm ed eet Ess tr4f DD os AD fi foow £5 @ ky te xt QO 4 WO fF ryt ict OP me be oy ic GP Smog 4 O tr & a ow OM eh oO Br ay id MOO se og 1G MOK OF oR $y Aa] 2 eG On oy A st Wht Oa 03 © TD te oe 2 Bho) >. be oy et Pe tel toe oO, .. Applicant in OA No.450/2019.
ir eh Ry £ 3 OA No.764/2018, 2458/2019 to SoO/2OTS, 3223/2019, 326/2019, 3646/2019, 4356/2019 to 4349/2019, 4490/2019 to 4354/2019.
inkar Ashok Patole IX-MTS, PA No. 63765-R, Sen of Ashok K Patole, ¢ + a 2H years, Occ. Service, Lot ishingve, Dost 'Shanit, District Nashik 422502, fahnarashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.451/2019.
Shubham Laxman meee Ex-MTS, PA No. 63857-F, Son of Shri Laxman y Haghehure, Age 22 years, Occ. Service, presently residing at Qtr. No. 94/05, Driver Otr. 25 ED, AF Station Devlali {Seuth}, Nashik 422 501, Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 452/2019.
Bhausaheb Kacharu dundre Rx-Fireman, BPA No. 45826-A, Son of Shri Kaecharu dundre, Age-38 years, Occ Farmer, presentiy residing at Shraddha Apartment, Bshind Suman Hospital, Jai Bhaveni Road, Nashik, District-Nashik 422401, Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 453/2019.
Suphash Sonawa Mayur ne Ex-MTS, PA No.63757-8, Son of Shri Subhash Sonawane, Age-24 years, Occ. Service, Presently residign at 96, Subhash Road, Bhagur, Nashik 422502, Maharashtra.
...Applicant in OA Ne. 454/2019.
(By Advocate Shri Yogendra Pratap Singh) O19.
?
za en 2019 to ASD/2019 to 454 W019, 3235/2019, 3326/2019, 2019, 436/2019 to 4309/2019, pared 2018, :
64:
QANo.
36672 Versus cs) iD Te by oy 4 a i 3 qd ce 43 Q Q Sa ma ra i } 3 Be @ cs ~¢ & 4 Qh o & oon 4 i is oi @ ey " a3 "gS D , serg weed nd @ 4 a td "i mm i vs, . ' we & XS wy w Sa oN g ; os A yet ~~ y oO . ~ 4 G6 @g@ 3a Yn "4 i ° he 4 oy Oo go wy a rf cy Se 4 os atm) : ca r Dy a] t3 Mt - KS § ~ . an fy iD f 3 POD NH i ie bos " w P "rf O Ey bp Be op oh C7 ye 44 wy eG e 4 + : " rv ged " j wd G Ct ' Ad e 3 "i @ Gt fe SP 2 ane mt Qs . & eS cio Oe Deh "4 oy $3 5 em a e a f « mb u) nA @ ae Boe OM 3 0 Oo wt in ef @ a Me :
ay : an ed 3 G bt ed seh YY a ah be mS a cs © q O » vat om A © - 5 i end mG wh " / a wo 2 OY
5 3 " By bate i bd gp { *, 2 re »§ 2285 $e Foose . MR 2 g Ba S 8 Ge o i fs Qo & | A Don © ng a sf aw e 0 Oe 3 OM ad , 3 «68 ® rn cs ae ree to i. ft 6%, Cy et E @ QD ' at we oh ogo aH. M " ug © ; md O on "i Hoag PRs CoH GO - m4 og) 6 fg 2 - OU a oh uy G B oO B ioe wef we 64 . Sa DW gf 3 Eb wi tr tn vet BS OD hi ol ot @ wy % 0 wm OF ae 8 Mi OG hd to as a 4 Bory ne og Bee EE GR Ba tA w 3 rot : go 8 O& cme gag 2 OM 8 8 EB wea Bs - ge © Gg 2 TA gg eC 4 4 8S fle 43 mgt a - 2 4 aw Spo Cope BE EM Sod oD p Beh tL Ono aa ehh GG nef SEs sg ete ky ved 4 ms TG OO be KEES od ge be oa wy ae cs oe $4 od Sy oo id Oo G Se srt ny tw é 4 Sy no is gt Bese OD i C8 Route 4 ia BA B~ am Bie BAS g Gj @ 2 eg Q 0 a % oer od ce . 43 jd bo oF ; . a ae bay by "3 ry <3 at . a on 3 o 6 rl Qu ee mM 5 M af my S f2019.
2019,
39) ay, 4 2019 to 2 2019 to 4 y ?
Y Ye 019, 323/2019, 3246/2019, 449 2019, 436 f y 3 366 @ ne ba oS tf anf OO oD my "SS soot hy fx) 3 Ty ef ep ee ITE ht et 4 ri) ra) 2 Oi Ac DO fod hi By gS 8 Go rt G "a fe FEE ED OD py ho Ge Re Sy 4 cs ony mosey db ch A Gy bs m ty cy iT seg Th e OY 1 be Sek hh et 4S CEE ey ) vd isd . Oy as ref AS cs oS yas a ay Peinatets ay a By > a + a, by on Diy Sg ha ty EE Pe oY 4 2 Ms 4 oak wt D WO, > oy G "Ae wo Oy tH Om, STN 2, 0 EMG Gy, Pe '8 "wy > QO fe Fy BS yn O og 8 DE Wort 8 3 oe 6 by Og OG o Mm fe OS 4 i is Si nyt cs os my TE mw 2S cm a 4 tS bh. a 4 4 ct as +P 6) » 43 ee ee & kG Me £5 Kgs f ¥ ; OS FS Ad Ty Mie 43 43 bt arn 4 ip! 80 Oo ~~ Be. : gt ' Ess See fh ie mw oS Ghts 9B, He : aoe 3 Cap ee LG we Ds W $3 py we em tn, , fey ES by " Oo tS bay MY 4 Cho ag fey 4 4 g i 5 wy GB © A os by 13 GS 4.4 ey wh ty g rion > gts hg gee ty 4 tes 5 i 4 yo a 3 " iss OM iB Wy Boe me TSO eG ad pet a Qh cred My ae ky on agp rg ha fy $5 Ch DM & r 5 4 cy ay ow Ty ' "4 4 ~ ec 8 8k 8 MBA Eo y ga Ss oa "4 ® Poy ee pM, ny Mem GO & 3 0 43" Dae Sea + gy BS gy fo oo 5 Cy 89 ty 2, @ os em Oo sm Sey wm a, WO cH ow i ag @ ay . Séony 8 z om OG Eg 9 Moa ONL a? ot SS iy AE oy Wet th hs 43 Gs ati . on o tT. LS oi ay nm we 4 "rf ~sg GY ee A ON gy OG bes oO ie; 5) rs re 7 tS B a Py, TE eg KS ee 4 oe os, o rg ss ct a No $3 gr oy MON oo EY OS ES on mM Do os & a UG ed ™ oa, Ger SU me Go wo Baw TB "} aed cs " tn & ma a So oath fou te Pky By <o, 4 al v S43 c ms 8 ig oe] & £3, o mm Oem Oo x ve] © Boos wry a ty 2 tt i % in HOM ord do tH ts en te LD OS vf y "ef OS ty ny a tet 4 % oO ees ® omg rb my Gof hy BS tS ae «oy :
by CY oH o& penef fet gay '. om, Ek Bin Ry mek gett + ty 3] a @ 3 a3 s i ay ®o« kp apts op tp a; "e a ty ;
" bon & Yo om Ke ye 4 ge G pa w MD srt apd CH Bp EAD ren A AN O ao ye Gy cs icy fe e vet - BU Ey sed org "ed * 3 Ep bye ory se} O43 OO set + ord @o a red a see END OES tf S44 UG Ord Bape @ £4, sp Ch Oy bs e tt md % Db Gs TSO eee ep HOH fa aa ky, try a Suet Xs $y 'hg jo @ 0, 4 ed GS ae ty ty Ge Co ca so ky OS gy DG : BH re = Uy ad og a 6S O % EO te te cy op % BO EAH mM ty my fd a w rf 4 a oO + i aed + ef, fed 2019 to 2435/2 O18, a OA No. 764) i i » 386 2019 3 f2 449 2580/2019, 3 2019, O19 to 4399/2019, ss i we 3 4 619 te 4$4/2019, a A 4.3 4 ce oO od wy hy & be % <3 4s bs ss ty, { a ey on 43 GY 3 wo ¥ weg rf tt my hee fet ct 14 8 87 ve 44 of
a) ar} ref ws uy a a atte u bee G oh @ eek ot Oh vt "4 ced tenef anf "rd is] o a 3 8} gt eka be AS 5 1 Urner aced 5 rd ¥ was were @ V3 G ha Q Oo:
4, ed OQ ord 5a ei ae Ad a ca chek we Ch a +f 3-3 "sd ot fea.
oO s term Nee Re ee ro Ad @ £ § ah 6S ita) a 43 O19, O19.
f2 3 i O19 to 454;
f 2019, :
2019 to 23/2019, 326 & 439:
f j 2019 to 439 z 3 aa 2 B4/20T8, 245 f « O19 é B th & OA No. 2 66/2019, 4 _% 2 We, OD wy wm A GS UE seb Lob EI ay HID 4! G ke @ G& TH ab @ in tl 3% KE DB we t @ D tn SPO & w ® i "4 CHO BOs @ Sct G sO & a wy le O Got RPO) A EO Lee 3 ACE YD ESE or aL Word 43 Gece cy a ty AB ory 43 44 Qoob fh 4b 0g wry net ny 3 St Gy HG 4 Bit 2, 43 = OQ, <4
a) Pont by Ny, Sab eal ved ttf] wy oy Mor se ey i By 43 MPD wm 4 By i ee DE OG tals a Oy Ml Gi 2 ba oy ee O, O BD Gj OF ao a) | * 43} vel 5} ord G % tne aS 0, red] Ul et Hd HEE dQ) SL yh ch Sal cs rd hes a he WR, A oy & ar yg abet eH Sab oh al egb ed rl "C5 & He a 2 & wWiS Ba gs ea) go © try Ps Oh aE OE GE SEE ay ma oy % Be ay BY 2 og Tk oo OM dy , ' KB FA fy es thee t ° A KE rd 6 ULE « rs ns e n wy 5 aS "e Ger 4 4 s Bloc a TL A) be C 3 5 % Q Uy dy Ry fA os 7 as a3 thred a A ty Cy 4 o Mt a a % a fr ey % Ps ey Yon o & Of ot of a Bole Go Aes 24 mf ye EO Wm Doe a ed pp AP ped 4 4 "ton YS "AS Ge hp te @ a PB at Ob aak SE sgh Oh ad 42 3) a us Ya "oa g fe ke & o a & 0 ify G De $5 Q iS "4 a 2 "Cs ore 4 f s "CS w at Cie thy 2 -s "Fw ie 43 o 4 a ca MTS epee - } Me, A a OS y 4 3 OG hy tb ia"
rg Q hy fe Tay AS wy ay , pe Oe a a bk ema BS Op ch Layo. % = 5 , a3 eS Ee aa" Sag opal | ola a = b ou BS 4G, o ah, # aepote Ay UE SA seq] GE af HY OF yy 4d ® m4 AG ai" os - Ay A mp O GO wy al EA ~ | 3) BE yh Gh o ye go HBP Been cl ol GL af Che ah cad Bi 3 low ae S Oa ooo of spol ef ol Gl siry GTi Be gO & 8 HOP OS ce ged Sho") Gier ah GL 4 ge Bi et i mt ia | Ty r co oy "ry i rte 4} eat ¢ y br eI i 4 Ps cs S 4 ha ced ho G hy ml ah kd Gy 4 wg a. BEG so és i Maes ay G3 Oy sap] Ol gy a oI DL oe Gi a ny Le Wok yd @ ~ f Sab tok 4 ty Rey i Re 3 ; RE dy eae GB OH [Se BG AS 8 Ls @ 8 MOS B yee SD «| Uy MH ee OP Spree yp oey Oh eg * ay a AY, 28 [Seed le ogao | wa suey . Bea ga Be ® BE & fe ad Jf Sh ah Bp nd Si wh yl ty 5 eb oo Gh" by s My at a UES mort Op ky Gh rd OF Ea OF OF Os) Wil aad pO Meri | om * BE sel uy bt v4 © a oS Ot tet a wf @ edt 49) A Bl dian my OG 4b ba A @ Raped ed Sa cet DO CO Cy i OH cet OO O, A & & Ad a % 23 om PER OU ky EA Mp A) Oo) til dor Fah a ay tap yy = OF GO Goa om @ kG, Pa -~ ) © J3 Ds 3 GO Sh a Gl ool mh sl GH Ge ch Gh ast gp GH mo 4) 2 Oe wy as Gm. My mos "Sa ae ~~ RG 8G OY Gh inp Op fp eedp = Pap Of Oo} eg ay "fel GO OO, fh my og eG, : we fg Oe Sap a dy EG Ce ts m z O wd rj o 4 SA/2019.
O18, 2435/2019 to 2919 to 4 Fast fk 4 & f 'f 449 OA No. 764 19 ) Bt & bel a wi id ht ica ry O i iH Oy aD fe B38 Es em D 2 6 tei y : By o tha Ou G oy 4 eh 4 oY S& a ep cf ct ry S gag o mie GP Aa MO 45 43 de ge cay ot da ky gt gy ey og Me i ao oy 3 YR eS De rH ES rd eg cee 02 Cy arg ced EG eb oe fe Ape oe 44 43 j 2 :
yds haus i ry eH Ml 43 Oy kp adored md £e GE RE fy trey o é Q ay as o Ad Ob 3 a re Ww ; : 5 Mf. voed ® ty ey th 43 ¢ by oy 44 oh 43 (y Ea: "4 OED mt yy a 3 Oo £ , Ue a 0 oo Ges Ga 7 rd a a oS 3 @ se iQ ty bs bmg 5 ma on 3 oy a Tha Gy & ty ee DO . ae Oo 4 i a 2 a ts 3 mH at O oR ot G " i wee] ra a sf &.. 2 . ' wy ES as BOO Py oy w © x 3 wa ab is 3 b Q Tie & & BG! EG aa tgs any QO o % © 4 Se a OS seg US - + * 43 cpt YOURE Ss vos ( Gg ty 84 Booed og bg rth gi aa aS og BOM ay ® Oy a a O Sy } ret % hg re ' ve SA hei a 4 ba hors > M sad PAS OG 4d gy 43 Bom gs 3 sin wed 3 4 Sted oo BO Moye 2AM e UMN OUS oa at hoay gy 8 Gag o BO GG , + is rh od i vp e o q pe " , hi a p @ e cm gS G Sy ' a fe 4d ey 8 tis "to Bes & a uh KS i m2 24 4 2 44 sed 9 3 wp wf dd hy S Re a a Og vy ae iM ai a 42 * . f O a aa cs ago AM Og st gy WoT EO om yw me og & Oo G Sy eu GOL" BRA Yao Bw Bt GR ae wt dy ® MEG & " Bon cd ss i. s eee BE gen, 7 ¢ ey ey C oa 4 Ad ey 9 % "Ue a 9 i Mi ae rae 3 1 2 am 4 4G 5 4 cc ys at e Saad a oy Ag HO wm ODA So Ese a 64 "rd ae "oO gu | H Bam ogy OO BPE BG | nn So © bom Atos Uy > | uy A al & pte LS ee a) 3 "In ie ry ES oy > oO AG SS GQ Le gs =) Oo oe Ge " o erg Pap gy Ws G Hw g se 3 vt 4a * "ef ° 4 4 : . , Ch ee ERS 3 $) ay at oO 43 5 ry 2 O > o oo THR. 2 a 2 a et OM cee 2 Q ts i rn ih % re Vo % 4 PE or By G i YE Gb ry OS oa 4 Pa ad 3 Kh r et % 3 ay g C3 Gh ie Fs go 4 DP é o i ry & 8 g@ & mS 4 G eg Hh Bs g bs a} 3 i G3 0 cs i a OG Ret Bet a S27 woe @ 2B oo gj 8 HB 9 as mE ay 1B 7B gy Mg OE a) me , "OR bi oie egnoeglS duSus eo gessuk oe onse § go gf 8 & ' a ema i oa ty ry 33 5 , mr 4 ' 2 5 nied ee ern Ru gaa Pe bee 6 BP 8 B 2g Boe i gy O Q a hey Ga e Gop i i D4 wv % m OR iS ® ei CF vet ry carn me Cots og @ a ti ad a3 os chs Wy & ty ea eed ted 43 Si rt fy 6 yt gy QS D a t) 45 4 ha : Cy +4 GSES GyeR of Flee eHe Bos ne ; 2 8 ee OE tg OT hy ' con BL 3 t ms, a See ee vs 43 4a sry ee 4 hy a v? ry ; - nt ; so x ' oe OE EY ef TEE Ry. bf a 4 tg Lt 4 we $2; a SHORBELSH So BSHeedeagau ys ges g Ba 4 ° og "5
- o bee ' ten Teg 3 f.: yt Sees. ne «, -, ' a 3 wh i £4 Li? Kee '3 Wibs Co Ep oe ea 4) er a Qe Fe iH % bs e a C > "o 8 aad +5 . BS .
wt ae Sef be £9 4 < o o % 2p a ' nl Sa mt od oo ha Bd hi " 4 wy i ot re) is ae CG w a wy wed a we w .
- & mH a 6 my €3 4 ASSES f Md » gt nt aah 5 5 HoH B 6 & wy &* Wor =f Mee we + iD by 3 " ops ; Ch a or o on i a a ved B @ 8 i © jg ye = ry or "f ® gS ® & tn '4 A? ha Ra 9g rh rey in si ih tA Noe a Bk OD wm Pr & a ma 8 a GC 6 @ @ wy ~ @ oe os oO #4 B a ra) OG 4 we 3 @ wed ty SS a e it aon hd CB ® a 5 * cn a 4 . . ae a a me 3 , fs 5 oy ea ot be Oy tes e wo ca we > to ag Fed ed ad Yt cs te 4 sed © mc "
aa Se w «8 nm 2 © OG Gps 3 8 oy OR 2 6 & SS ESS Q Mo cs ° Bo 8 @ eo 8 8 * as go wm 3 w wo Ow im 3 . @ wed el a 4 Bs " b DO, Al MA ea 5 ms an wt uy £3 o 3 3 3 4 ed ops a Soy bt O 3 ~ a ay 4 et 8 rt g 2 ge cd fs tH Oo © mt " 4 6 Go io a S , o Sa rh as a 9 Abed 3 | UG "i wo - -- 2 8 SaaS mg by eS o ® ay of a rs, pA gs @ QO i) 8 i On fs x3 a "4 4 43 ct ou mi S t or oO if 8) © we aN sg © a v 4 Q 3 wn bi . 4 CAS ew @ + go "oa BB GR Qo ne a * Oo ~ ¢ BP eos & do oH oo § ¢@ 2s oe § eB 4g 8 a G a oD rn wy td 3 # iP: OUpOCOD w £2 Qo i fF 8 eo 2 2 8 8 6 Py 8 BM , fo» 2 @ Bi a 8 Od o @ * 5 @y & @ Set PM ee B® o # € & CO co oh; 4 3 hd B $4 be i od o Me S fe & a "hea i Sf 3 0 "ng a ay 6 D bet cs is - * 3 a 5 Mes spa « sO GC %, @ & eg @ 4 © e « fd ® Lobe i v md "tt , 4 Mi oO Le Go ae ch "4 $3 3 ved £5 i mt bog fa 3 i a "4 48 » of 2 GS Gop om do oo BP 6 @ 6 me B a 44 % a , mS v4 ved ve 3 as 4 44 5 mS Ad oe 3 w 7 a Hs MM a "~ 4 in ts Q mR G GS 3 4 h oO 8 8 Ss "e 8 oS So U8 lg 3 Bo ® i a moO 3 St ® So & FF © bed ns . Pa ba as ES G ie & sO ae OS uy o yO o oI G & Pa i e D> OQ a " Se © i a * bt 43 to cs a ma U v Q Dog Ot . & o 8 8 3 BY Q "e4 wd ef g @ i ip re ~ uf , 'et y ord at bs 0 i 4 *s a v © . od 2 ) 4 go # Dp WO wo i : Qn Q : O 1 ha fn ® M4 cs o Q : ra cs at ; wD a rs os fen on Oz wn @ os cs e a a i % ord he aa + 3) as wf g a 0 4 o an o 3 og * iS mE p @ 4 B&B FB a Gk ° "4 3 4 mq 3 Dy a a ae) (a Go ® , $4 ky bel Hoy + fF & pe 2 gy 8 Q 4 8 a 5 oe ~~ @ rect rt a 3 Ay Ss Q 3 ee F ty vt tt i Q ni & So 2 a ag , a ny a a 4 gq & ny : "4 as ss Go fob o Be oe 8 ¢ 4 M 1 em fa Ms @ i . 2 e Y oh . DB st og P u bi { 23 "3 OQ yD QO wn a = ; D o @ oS as tS Q 4 oad é 4 i Gy fs 4 Z fla 3 . ' ; @ w@ DQ v Ba 3 bes a wl ' a a in ci aie} tog es f 4 _ at ~ a4 44 ot 3 s » a i 6 ah @ © BR m3 a 44 ron % o oe 8 rt gy eS ee ® O a OH 43 we 3 & oO ry . Coot 3 td Woot ce i ri a ro Q 2 its aU re: uy ia yd ie ® g @ oy "4 Q Re D w o be vd oO e ct gi @ 6 vse Q 4 sed it a3 13 eed wer GS B&R ee a pod Be Soy Be ey ® an an " sa 3 a & w i in v fe as "4 ae op iY ved Q a « "; i 4 . y fh ee no $c} 4 hd + co a Os a a . Oh ® cs , 2 wo 38] 3 oe ea 2, < @ ey : + 4 @ aa Fe ed as ed AX uy & G a ia o a ; +3 » ft sheet ' Oo apf 3 * iy wy : 3 4 i , ne) re 2019, A049.
f cf 326 § 2019 to 439/2019. O19 to 4 3/2019, i"
ae > 449;3
toe, i
38) * net 3 2019, 4 2019, 3 3 SB 2s 66 » x 12 oe wo ny bg co , 4 i OD "3 - rs oS 5 8 0 £ 6 @ 5 & n 2 0 OC » Mm @ " ; } ec} i 4 . 43 cs Ae 3 ' ; ° es Oo vcd is if} » Gy 4 63 4) "rf = H A eS 5 ws 4s rd 3 a i) ra £ a cS a at ng ° a | 4H i oh} 3 ort My ed a bs o 4 s hy in O yO "ed a Q § ca Y oy 3 te ty "6 3 Gs a @ a hi Fa Bf 8 4a iS 6 & © Yo op @ O 4 eo @€ 4 BG oe
-- nt 4 v +4 O we Oo 1) Gs nt es 84 es A Dp & ny 42 AB a {3 ce wv m # 3 TH QD or " ' bed te a 4 ee as $4 re) a ip Ft ya oO ig 4 QB AG on 5 qh i (4 ' rd "es "rd M43 a ct {3 ' £5 ra 4 03 @ G "4 4 es 4 6 a rd Ss a hp bel ft oes Ct i Ae is) g rhe © iis a rd 43 ns -r4 hen hon, 5 é& orf o A 6 bef
3) in be LE 44 ip a4 "3 u # a ih sy * is) 'hy w 44 " SS "se ® re ts bef Bi a ry uy "4 - ) 4.
3 e 4 , So aa i} i oO 3 $ oP et et 3 "3 mS ia ka 38 ig w BD e 2 BE sed ceed G O coo» ty 9 C a O, @ od , od cs 6 " i va a oa te oe i . tS "ed t- ne GS ef n Bor ~ © ee ' a SE ag QO th Med if H ey wy ee a "3 54 ved a Ad wt nd B i ua i cmd ay Ke an wD f oy a o ef a " 4 B e, 84 4 6 z O ie) 3 ot wot C ia tt Ke mf , Ft C3 om ct $ 4 } in te a . C ed a "3 - < 4 cm 4 ioe O 9g & Bb oof mt BOO MS sd & © w 4 a n <3 oS we os "3 ord . @ Q aye " 4 ha ; 4 oe © yi 33 rot Fs) 4 ; " 5 a + @ ts . Ad G MH ey 5) w 3 @ : 3 4 '#) OG es bs wd as " os is Du 4 2 vee} 0, Ae , wn - Y eee ~ ' « 43 4, C5 3 . Q oh, v i i % © @ we i w a 43 43 a4 , mf GES Ret ga an ef 2 U va a 3 6 os w C = go wy, a os : ® w © rs Gj Ok : ht ot ra mn ne uo oO 8 3 we a kt Be ha es v8] 4 ved : t Oy & red at $d rhe Mi o a SE j od Oy O a oy es . . = H fw » # 8 + i of GG & go FS . & a © a 4 0 é Bart G 0) & . @ i
6) ae @ % vee is a @ a ao ng "3 Q ° be z e) 43 wy Py on An er 3 " od a 4 £3 4 a nh Sed oy ue aa a eo BOB BH gy BS 7 ® a 5 Oo fe a re Sef @ cs ° & . is a ~ 44 4 q » wo 5 are ° "re an eg " ' onf £ 7 4 a a a o 43 oo | fp 7 ct ed as | wi wy 33 6 n 4 avd 5 . 1s) os " . ed ® co 3 $ a 2, 43 43 "A * O fi "4 @ 5 hd " eo :
on . o Th ond 3 wy 4 ® i wt 4 4 D 5 o ks an . 3 oO ie) ce "sy e om 73 "4 sed " ag $23 o 3 s aU fe a a é «a & en bef . os » a © HGF eA BE ord v4 Qa 7 A v Goo™ an?) ord a 3 cf i 4 Ad aq G ° a a 44 ta a be re a) O 3 4 rg wD % ve wy ri Q 4 fe a 1 om mo a gt 2 ne " a6 ct 3.3 4 j rt 03 % oof % ; 44 "a wy "rf a 3 a a 43 de 3 a es wy cea ry $e tx 4 cd w gt ni, 6) 42 4 os bs | ci "GB he oo, & oot om & 4s arse i} q ved ret s , 4 ; red a ay ' . a "vt wef m4 ; rt me ms Gi = a iB & 6G Pe bei dtd aw 5 e : B a 7 f 43 4 m7 . ¢ 3 ' # "
SB «@ @ oe 3 fo Yo & so mw eo we OY . ¢ & 8 Se Mary " - {2 aS 44 oO BS ee w o ra 0 a a 0, "cs a a a 019 te f f vt ey | 4
-3
O18, ot
4) G19, 323 Oy OA No.7 13 2019,
6. 3 2019 ;
é iy "
2 2503266/2019, 436/2019 to 4939/2019, O19, $4 44972019 to 4 ~ > Ws Meo * eat ke LA 3 ret fa 4d ord 4 20, GOSSs.
pr esant a AS 4 A ot a4 ved bt ay ea ry red 6 68 @ red 4s ord 43 w red reg ar Sate ten Ne ee bork oe 4s hey Yy wrths ii.
x teat &3 vend ra £22 "et weg up Le.
oi oO ard Ad weed 43 a pho, ft ws eens oanden A ty AN ke gp BM iy et w a o ) % g whas as (p th td , 2018, 2435/2019 to e oO. 763 y :
Ey OA so "eet DO ny '4 v g Qa >» 2 fs 6 ¢ @ 2 f & 9 UO @ te ow» ¢ ow @ gg ww -« oo SS rf oS Nd oO 5 ra a a @ a & 6) ms ved ' co a ao G Oo oy oa & " ra <4 o : " y 6 SS = : 4 ' yD he a3 G veo} ; CN EARS cS a cS i E ra « ¢ xy as ne At a 73 D 3 ¢ SOON Le, nm i $4 45 cs ° she 83 bf 44 rs, 4d 3 a as ry oem 1 3 : at gS sa @ a oy or 4 4 ky a toy ep i o ws @ 1 CG G a) ot @ 'be ry i 3 z "9 & , , : fy wt bs a oH i % eo, € 2 a eg wy gS : , i 5 q3 fy hg ge rd i fs a) @ or on BD n 3 "hb 44 bony ae ky ' 3 @ 4 "ef 4 a4 ca c w em & f Bo GE Dg ar' SBS 43 Se8 64 UB @ » § 2 wh ww & BBB i og 8 | 0 oe 8 4d a Th S&S moog tr GO ou Pi Mey GN re it sag 3 rf , i f+ 4 wha & 1s) a Sed oF SG 8 S ¢o yy 8 g Fw Be a 6806 gC ~ * ae : S ea me ny oc 0 . ied 4 " hs Bg ogg OD ma 22 ss Qo a 04 " B "3 3 oa) cS * at 7 wi iv i 3 ad n ef 4 wet o a os r 4 sed a iy can Vy A at os qd @ a a © i @ yw Gt wo e * 2 ort OG 4 he a 5 tod os 4 és by ec O gO w > Oo Sod " bee ae "4 $e &) a a 34 2 a 3 a £4 wy $4 Ct # a @ Ba i 5 Py "4 3 y "4 tS se 3 Ly . XG 0, ret i bet vel a © td veg ' 4 a @ " oO ved ved o ~ t E ry 3 ad ? " Eo ood ? rpee QO 44 BS, © a bts @ G 4 é $4, Set 44 fe ssed Oh, Bey Gh a 2 hy ft Dg Bp wm | ms 3 wg ® o @ O. a "rf ie rd i ra) "3 oy "rf 5 we a . ES ma i a Aa Qo ap m3 Pi 4 4 -
, ' a G3 43 a bey ry 6 a wy y 2 oO . 6] cs . a os t a . i? iB in 4 wt . re 4 cH ay rt eC Gg x ' y "3 i ; ¥ & uy " p23 on ° f ay wv £ bs . . : 5 GS bh "4 ve oy 5 "4 ui hes 44 23 & end . aS 43 5 no be w a mR '3 $f ry : 43 o 3 pO a a © of 3 a 3g OD wy a © 4 Q 4 og ; < A £ ". os 4 js ns ¢ % a 3 wo * @ n= a iB 4s . bx o & Go ow § 8 geo Ge wo eS 3s HB Gg Gi @g@ ° 3 3 Bort on "GO OB jg Cl om Se B® n 2 FF "3 0 a ret oad 34 3.4 £5 oy i oC ree) a ety cond eben a 0 Gy) Sg "8 2 6 8 i a Hom 8 @ Bf PB oo wy
- ve Ve be =r 2 % ay ct Gy wa & G u 4 u g ° hd % '2 2, 3 "S a e t 5 4 » wet te} et et ar i rt 4 : ye 9 a 2 Moy ' , O . ad ¢ £ eB 6 & 8 BT BR ye S OG g te ef og FP "4 ' a j " an {6 3 O io 44 tn t C «s CO : a on + a 4s @ oh © f wz 7 ra hee cs + & a td g & . 8 go te 6; ig BD BB ger iL _ 4 as a hed v4 f r 4 bo A cy 3 a oo n nt ot 3 c o F-3 oe voy e) b at Dr " 4 a3 te mS a gi d 44 ot C pa : a i o a 4 2 1 ced és ' hy 43 el, w . a oe a w tet tn Co ore i) ty, ho yp a2 bes MS tg . BG Tg eo @ oP eB ' t --S a tf a ae Cs aS D AD od a 4 44 bes ved G QD is he weed Dp rhe of 4 oe SS ot a Fa ' Gj c aS iD i @ 4 te fm Cs 5 43 «rf 4 2' ¥ C rn a GM « ' mo» «¢ 4 @ OM . _ 4 rn - % . % . 4 me g @ a 3) ra a fo 44 rd ra " yp ce "4 yo wo ; th oh cs fe 3 3 8) By 3 @ 83 a 44 a 1 " 3 + wy re) be ga A re CO & 8 8 BD FP gc dg 8 & BR B 8 B& rw oe om mw € « #2 Fe + as s 4 3 a op a) $4 "g Gd 4h me ® fe O Pe nah at hed Ad Q Ld 4A rf 26/2019, f2019 to 3
a) O19 O15 to 454/2019, ae 2019, 323;
ae Z, om ee i '
449) > é é O19, 4356/2019 to 439/2019, OA No. 764/2018, 24 Q 5 a Gs AY @ v 3) @ be ' > & c G As nes 8 G 3 a 4 1 b a . = 43 G A BF ray al RS * ig a « " "A tS iis & M 4 4 1 od 5 4 c Pa "E Ch tee, 3 bs Ci Q 4 go AG c @ rt $2 oh, mp mt O of tt arg ii wn oO mw
5) ht w Be " zw a ' \ 44 wo p ' ' w : % @ vf g $4 as 4 i Met a ® @ a re: ot oO O 2 Sb & 7 eo 8 i eg B wg af ma het Ma : ¢ ay GO ; gc 43 Oh Gord a Sa a3 G «s i?) a 3 wy m% ey eed ee) Q a ns aS oO ~-- 4 . £ ¢ oO Se ow EO BF i Ss OC wf om ho ob ra 4 n a 4 ha o $e a b4 " cs) rp \ Ad 43 ? hd p i ne orf D C5 re) Oo i Ww me 4M BG Sp gk i 3 gm 4 ge Oo 6 1 w * ved % & ge 43 th a Cc 3 Ch / et tT Ut £4 a a . it veg y oF a g 3 wo w ee 5 eo «= 8 F SY G 8 8 a ot © i x ; oy we " a 4 % wo 8 ~ Oo s a 43 4 ey * am of o ey F 8 tg w 7 8S 4 7 vt fF / L. + . fia @ a 6 Sy 4) G O : wy sf Por rt ay tf GY pt ea ot a nm wy 3 wh ta + r ab. * & rm 2 » oo BD ce ¢ yy oO ; ¢ 4 a Ly 6) as ne, x ° a tay a GQ ma ne ~ i} th ty in ey 4 O us: we $4 ms o @ gw & 6 fe 3 Sy OH ed 43 hs ord : rot im arf a nm eS =f a J 3 va] m 4 ny omy far 6s eed qed a 9 nM &e @ ww HA # CG | , eB 2 8 £ o § § B "3 fs a ped ( . . Q a 3 g) OQ CO tm G8 8 Rm SS we OO : :
"$ cs a ig i a2 ma wd 3 $4 wt mG . GH ee Sed 6 a i gett GO 4 -- o> SSS ATI IE BI MII HHIW wadg aaa dene dada weneee eee .