Karnataka High Court
Sri. Durganna S/O Sharnappa Since Died ... vs The Deputy Commissioner Anr on 1 June, 2012
Author: B.Manohar
Bench: B.Manohar
§}:'~'{§§iE} 1'7'E*'E§:§ .53-S': E}? E' SE: &UN§{; 28 E V BEFIEQEEEZ V 3%;
'§§"§§Ei E-E{}:\}E%LE7 i'éE§?i &US'E'§€E;Z Z%.E%5E37iP»§§I 'V . 2-'«.:%2§':' §:>§s:'?5'§<>;f~»; E'€ai;.§:§ 2 9 3 f:i«,52£}_-EA :>;A./f15C;';:éE::.S':%- ' $ A 3:3: §}U§~E<}z M:as>s;:$ ss;<i> SEE~Eé*:§'#3f'~;za§>§>sE ESZ;1{i§£§T}E§?:§}E3;E'§,R _ Tam": ?i':f"x{:}£%;E'/;EE\f€Z§';, ~;;<> ;~:>.:§=:<; a?~;r;:;x..._ , ' ,ga£::«:: §"§~3A§%iE~} ~ T . r I ' :'~2;;::> 93:1: fasa -~~§':*:'g:;;>:::»%;:
. . ' E3' E??? {E E R3 ;g<;::;;2--3§§ --.
:,:a;:'::-:3;
; A ':+;é>zJ:::
,§3;!:E1i£i2;"a~-- £3? 3.
:4" %:;:§;;~4;x":V';§ 'E 'W:>4:_V*>LJ,§é. :3, ' §,z 1 ' ' T J 5:§§{§ fT::v:§"fi1E'ifa%_;§"':,E~/g ?"x;"§;%,E€ 3%]? . _ E'§?%§'E' §?'§i'E'§"§'§' E33 E'§§_;E?3E} E§F*=§§.'}§:§§% 5'K§€i'E§{;' , .48 22%} zfaffii} «en :>§2,:§;aa;s:;; A 2%? V V :::§;::{:'i:V'§{>3%g {;i§A§i§/E *:':~£&: §:lf§':§'ai'VE;?,Z§Z {E y m %:;;_}e:>§<><:::<V>;:-- ;>a:::§2. 3:i§:§-i::;a3;:~: :3? ':'§ii§/»iE{'iiEi §«*<:s:% ::*a:€':::a:::x: s::u3':'s:>:::'{ 'gm: §3€'é'iii'§{}E'€€§% {E3 'maze §i'*J§%3é§{§EiE:'E1:B s,}§<V:3§::2_._:>;»;§:5@
2 :.<::4,;:2::;:: 2 gas; 5:'? A?€3?%§EZ}si§;§§{Ef2-- §?¥%..§3.§;EZ§} 5: 5 §::i§;::>;?£:>v2*~§::§::§'*§q.'_;*, EEK? z;::;2$§: wags.:?<><§z:v:s:<:;;:L:'§';:2~::@2 :92 EE1'«;'§;?;R ::;«:€3':<:;?éel__"3 i§ '{?T§* §§Eé}S§§§'$'§'§f%L {i{f}§:fE§%'§{}§}§'§";'§iE3 E'E}§3§ E} 3532?: §2Q, §§,%'i?,?"
EPC I} EZ'§'{L '%'EE§S; m2:'§' :[>z«:*2'm<1*a: {:<>:v§:«;'€;; .. E«'C>%":%: =é>'§<§:§;iI§i;:;?~J:;:2.§s.':' ;e:::za:s::»;<;; ':'z;;%5 2:252: <f:<:s:;m* 5 'E%EE£Z1'E3{Z%i,Eg{3E'C.§N{E:. ' " ' Qaagg.
@{;2re;*:3::zé:13§ ;fi':.eii2'.<;a:%2:*;;éb'ii§ Egg} :':{3§is::'3 <32: fiehaéi' sf :*€§§{f::;ej<ir::;Z'§é:i~:<, ::::yj{'.2;,
2. féza ;3s3f§é:§§>;§€.:*, 5:2» fiiéis fi;>::§é: §é*§%§§§}:1 Bass Seaghf 3:}? <§§;:::Vs3E/21:25:; 'ihe éi,}":53;..s:=:f <A§23;f:2§§.'§.?:_§fi'}4§--L2§C> E2 ::;aé;§;s::¥. by ifirifi Eléepasgéy €f§®§:':fi:":§§:%;§{é:?;€:"_ 2?§§<1sézvr:é§;2 '---§j§é;é::"'.g3<2%:§€:is:212€:€ was éiyesiéezifi ':9 ":§1}e::,s::%' ?4i£}i'§a§{}§/~ £5?' Cs? "i:"2:<it':.<3§ §:::%;:駧 by t;;?:<5 ':',=§€;?{i{'}TfE{§ §'§S§}{}§E{§;€3E'E§; ;
A F?§"@8.§§f?4'.'§Z%€iEi§§Ei§;9 'i\§G9§{§a~£§2f'";%,~"€i:§»'b'!2§§=%?é 'E'::£: gaéfi 'E':";;:{::a:° ..:;mei§? ;3;j:V:s*€:': <33: :§"Ei§"E 3:3 ::-gggemiz :?«;%:§<:%Z%2, *3 in §;,«'s,»~./ m 'in éivgzg §§"2;'1§}$§}{f}§"'§§E'1§;? Séiéffiii? %%.:§$:i§ §;{§;.§:'?::s. :sa'3:C<>:'1§ ;':»:2::':::%;:/:=;3:
<.., éézss §3:>::>::§ §.§§'.E7i'Ef£E£ wézéés €§"£:§ES§{->§'?;§§Eg finzn: «3*:%§i':"'/5:76;'/d, §s::s:>: ggrazizia ?;»:3§<3:;::§e§ £15; 'E/%:s3 _;.,.}f:;3§' {Ff §'<20{:§ 23.;":{§ C§'\.fiE Stzppéééssg 523:3 *x,%.2"é3:"€ §:'_::;%*i&3§3<:éf%:~§z:§; égizs ' ,Ei'<I};§fi{? 2:;/§;::2éAZ§<>ri5gE;i%<i%}s' W%;::h . 22:5 zuzy :;}r:=:m;i:--;s:;%{:_:1 $<:é;«::3<i t,fn<3 v<:*E':iCE§% am? §{;<:<i_g:f2:§:2§L';f§'§.€€ %::V:v:%V%3:«:§":i:?: éf éiizéz"
p<3ié*:i<::::€3§" 21:: :~:§p§§e::aE;:?<}:: E,_.Sf3§;'1-{E E2 "§I}1"7;'€§€é3;i~3é* cf 2 $535: 'i':z1<:i;;ei* Qgad -7 '<.§:§s;€:rf2:rs:--::1 31?: §E§€£§ 53::
Eéfiébfifléiiu "E336 f3;:*:;::.._:§3V3§:s:zd§3?:é"{, €}F§€fifi§§ fa}? §"€§f3€iS€ sf '§§"f¢T%;{:i5i{}E§':"ééifig "7'§r';:2,§€:f, iééréeitiéii p$:%'{i{>:2€:" ':0 §':a:;m::5;?:1 Vii»? "<?¥'s_§{Z%€},;§}:i}€}g'~} 'E'%:e géziéisgner "§«s;1:':g:j 595 'stiasféeé 2E.{I%4§2§f:2 gazggezé $3}?
3 §}<;3g>zV2:;}? ?;?Q§;%$33533§é:::§:%:*E:3a3;{;>§%z:%" 25:55 §§Z"{f{7:§'§IE§_}: éjhéj §}é?§)'§§I%{}f§E€§' i§gE:,"?:$;E::§«; Eisz" 2: ?~'éi}€§Z%m%;'i£3j~, E1235 .%EEs:>{€ ' wéfiéi < .;::7%:*{V_i_é::§{>:":¢ §:;a:>:§;%§;;§a;:>::€:"'s ' ":%f§3§j;s~;'%:};ma:*E 2/3:: £éf§E'§{?éi§§;€§f§E~3'§,. ;:>:;:;:*§%;::,:E?;.:::"a§ §}:,::*§3a:>ss;e:~:», _' '§}'E§,§T°€fi§"§£%.5:3€{§ :%_:§%:€ "§"':7:%,e::§i<}:" '§A';:1i3§Es::é §%€ ééiiii :33:
€339 é§:§§;§§{iTfE,§§iE,E§"E1§ w::s:*'§:<:a ES; :15: 1T::A:§::::;s2:~_§é§3Es"% §<:::* iiiéfze ;3<3EA§i:§(:::#\€:" Iii; fa/:i§'§i ?:;§2s: {'i8§§{i§§'§{}'iEE§ §:{:';;:::::r;€~;<3£:E by $353 Efissspzzéy €:3§::;'::T§S§_§::a§§ <35 éizfi '§f':*2;:::::a/2:" zzmai '?2*z:§E§%:: §:"::;ei;€:3é <25 :%;:2:%;:":sE?:%':}:
<i;:i::_?::3:" 5§§:%{é2,::"§:fy fa? éiihéé §52%3éiV§:'§§é*:{3.:V¢%a};%:;--[ gfif {?i§§?§i§}'{:V'%$%i_§E§i £;£%_EiE":{.}E"§'iL}r'. 5:: 22:39 méiséaé :,:;;;m:/':' «§:_§1£»': <:s:"-{E22433 {ézziés §1'}€'zi§%f: ii": §%?é3,§~§:;,832E:§,i'2i}@§ §;%;:>:;<:d.._3a:y* '{;%'1:?:»~:VvC{;s;5z*'§,. E11 Shes s,e§:":':g3;§23r {i§E'%i}§,§fE7Ei§§'EiE1{i€iS§'"5'§'§"%.§S" {::.{§§};E"i:'.: '§Efi§{}€%§I%4*3€§ '$318 G§'€§.€§ gggzgsasd {E28 E3s:§;::§f:jg C0§f::::.§}§3§'::A:i'€:. Ek 'E'§m% *:f';:{;:::?:::f::é§:9:'€:::1*gH"5.'g:'7%;{£v<;i:%2:€1~$ 21ppe:s:§§:2g' fa? E315 ' 4!: 22?u";'<J.;2a§E:V:é3--<}§V' E/has '§':"g*z<:1:::é:' zmé '§:"22,;%§€:" is ' 'i}€"}::é:§I €€}E1§E§E3:E::EEiS§€}?E§:" zaséésés '§:*2:,<1:§{>:" zzgéii "§z:;:sfi<-31* {§:":3at:§/535; EQES Mg ?{:;::":§~: ;§::z1:':;':.::2.:;é:§3 52:}? <3 %?'é§;-€Z>§)«;{,?s%3€}§ is §§:§§:*§::§;§%' argai §:§'§"i§3;E;§§%}§§i%,f E22 {E36 V ifgrfisis" '€123 '}:':;>::::}g {:§ZéEE"E§'§EiSS§Gi"§€j%§"' ggzé :*:~;::::::.:g§":'s, fa);
° §f:E§§'£§€%§E, E222: §:::*z':i5E2i::g; {sf bzmiwg g:22::'a:::':a%e wézfiéj <>:*{§'é;é:*§:";g;§'§'{::f'-miss-:;:,Ss: ;§"%:;2.V:":A:;._:?s=s§:' .
3% :,12s;<>9. * vi;
(«my }'e i 3 E1;1:'2r*€: <:':=z§$f:,:EE}f <i:{}:';:§§é:'i€:*€<E '{E':{2 gi::§e:§1:"<*:&%;:<3é;=e:ii 3;}?
§E'::':% Z? §':-E§:r1:?':;::€i§i§},a £%x;':: §:§€éiéf;§<>::::%;" {:23} .2zg:"i<::'a/:§{;Lz;§*;%_s§§;,f-SE15?E335"
Ezssé hes'/2* h::s;§3;1:3::§, :32': EZV.Gé§2GE§:';M"?€*§:i:i:2:i:{2:*f:S'._h.;:Sb22i32.é §";1::<§:;>: are £i§}§}§i{i!;1f§f}2"3 £133' i§hfivf€§€é1'i§<3'é'3;_f 'aha vf:?%é§:'i::§€,'=--¢ '"'fhT{:w <,i{L>Q{§§i}:",}3"E §:z2p:;:s<*:x;i by Eiiiéi "'~i}€§}:,:f':j; i::{:%'i§":§E3§§':§§{>§';€§" is §§3}g}{}E§ES§3§é? fer E326 ggi/:ii:;_%::::3<%;':". §&::s~~ :é%,:EE:'E 3.§1i"§; :5{;:z§.§;E2:: 59:"
€§L§.EiS}€E§E'§§,§ 1'/32%? Cgndiiégzi 5}? ':":;:':é:s9?:§:1.§,§.v%';:§;i::.'--~g';:;2§an&%§ 22:35 pémzét 336:" {La} :;€E":§::*: S'${fTi§f'§§i:?';-- *'E7.'i.::.€ Ezaysi f€§i":.':1§I3'.f:§ fihsi '§'r23::*is:>§ aszri 'i":*a:§Eé;: ix./ézs» %;:s:-2' Eéigzfié is SQ:?E"2€ §5:'s<';::§ Es z"""'?'"
wag '::"a,i3:«:g}::;':*1:£f;;:;j 'i,'§2;s .4 §'7{}C%C§ §__§E'E?i§§}E~; §:>:f3E§;:':g;;eé 0 {E16 {§;€p;i::*§:23é§:':'é; ""£'?:5 '§§;;3_:,éé:E:a.§ Ea §€:::?é€:§; iézsaziijg. g A. §}€§f§'i{§.§3'§E{,,?.}" %:':::' ::%::<ws ;3:"::}€:3€;?§i::gsg $5 $26 Mm"?
} (mod M 2 :3"
wow E s:§$§:;§;%;"§{;r;2'::%§§ 3:; :°a.§z1§; J3 < x 5" W"-1 ,..¢ luwzt 'MD Jmm ("C2 saw» (i4 WW» I?"
("N W. ' K W...» W W m 4% W W M. Wm.
8%? 3:: zsisw :35 éihaség fies €:$n§?:%§t§::2;n Eggs:-.Ei%; bee 5{}fé§2:";§~?:jd %E€::::€§ {ha {EQEEQEEEGEE £2? "5'.§':;::'%;:g§:§:3g""53:6: §é§,£§:?€zE"§'§€E=§ $3 ?fi{}€Zi§§§.€§ ané £26 :é':r:~g:ée:";::'<E§3:3: 522%}: 25:; éziésiszaé 2;23?:§e::§s:= ii:/:§::2s§§::;g 251$" s'§vs.;:E'§ zéfiéga EEE.':3'§'€ §::f:":2s;~';<f:E§ ;;:v2":;:1§:;é£:£<-3 32$ E? '§'§:::% §>ei:é'£,%::%:::';'%z 22'::;>:%£{E :;%:>g%<f:::§:% 21722:": ézéiéerzéizéégi §;}€}Tfi§'3:
$2': 2: .;<;m":; ii}? %'é3:gfE€ja{'3{}§§;Z mm .
)-wc m 'Hvnrmm/ .1 va§3{> Eézavré fimz :*s::{>*;::s 31:": 'ihe :Is;a';a::i§?::y» 2:5' §:E1fE3{}i?2L§{}§€? §}§"{}§3é'E"i§fiE§, ;3}::r jE'3§;§f1E $215332, %'Ti1E'%f 2% 'J .
3 iv} He gghaéi :29: ::;.s:j:},: h§%'§s{)ii';3.;;¢é3.'{,§:3fz"s 9:' {:E3arg€ V} __ §:%%§f:--i:{:a_ E25: EVQEEESEE '§s§{>r{3 ihszi é:>::%z::::* 2::::'£:?:<;>:'§'i.};:
~ . é E "v.§:T%:§:f:E:s, fix: E3:§1£:1§ {Eggs §:::"s.:g3<:%:* {:6 zmzf; <33 §>;:y§:::§b *:E3s3 :;:::3z:r:3g:€;::$ ;";:*§::'§§V::::2 9:5 3:35; 2ar.":::%:V'; E'§*§=:3§ :f':;§§ iééééf ézz *;a3S§§3::?:%: ::2§'{:1?:é3 Sgéfi '§'?:as:: ::>e='::§i§<sn$:* s2.%1;i§ fz2:":§§s%3 é:w<": 3{';§_%;":;::1'{. "S;::*€::§;:%S; hi} <;V\:?;": V. ,,_WWw m ¥':f§":§: 3152:: a;?z§;3<>&r<;% <>§:z55;ii;':»'21":;§::z::3§E éiéss wrééfz g:::'--':i-§i;;_§::;:;¢'2 E3 gfésggééiaégisai ail 'fizz? {}{V>v{5::*:1::":§>n§ A<iv{2<72:1§:;% $553 §3€3§'fi"EZ§§j§7'3%C§'§€i:§§§€f -m'~;;%,mx::: {E7 L' :2§::§3€;:2m:3<:::é 'SJEEEEEEE 2: p€:'§e:3eii 5:? §:{}a§1'».}A'if:;;'§{S*§ T22