Karnataka High Court
The Management Of Hal Helicopter ... vs L Fathima Mary W/O Late Antony Cruz T on 3 July, 2009
Equivalent citations: 2010 LAB. I. C. (NOC) 513 (KAR.), 2010 (1) AIR KAR R 337
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, C.R.Kumaraswamy
T. ?;:':§ Q.3't":"z;Z',s;ii% :::;m,:g ;' K3 ' ;.<_i'<{;' W x _ Z in; "mg HESS cam" Q? KAam'?A:<A ACE' 8,§?*$G;%§,§3?"§EJ;:: _ msrm Ti-€I$ we 93% SA?' 53? 39:3 zéiai-§s. f _ ' F. 3 PR§SE§? i m1%%% j .
'"§"E~§E §-§G§'€'8i.E :«§a.:::a:§":':cE;,Tvé<.5:.., ;s%:s2;:§§3a::a;mi%%%« Am %' % A V % "mg zé---«:a:*=:*a:_5 :vm..3us?:e:.E c%;*é%.'LMé§v:§ae;,éé;;:saa;,éré? MISCELLAMEQUS Ems? g§? éL§L'.b;§::éV;;5;?:§§*2§.c--4 {am} ?~--~:E :"~émNA§E!V%£?x§TfI§3§--* Hm. §~§E£...§£0?"?ER §Z"s£}_§§£%?x?;". ' mg? SQX f'éO.:.T?€3£§._ ' _ '*::v....
gawgazaag - 566 3:?' _
§%,EP*RE$;E§'~é_'TEQ '3fH".i:"§ V ' . -
C§~§§EE"~?9"¥aéf'€;1Q€§;§§';'_{?'E;a€2}'. :._,a9¢§;L:a?4T
{av 3%: T, E" Raifiiém; v;:é:3z¥3C:é'%E}
£2?':~§§.; " . V V" V
1; .g:%é2 'V2; mf'é':--::'::%g,éV':'»m§i;:¥ 2a:;::s__L.m"g fr.;1z~»;j%"::s&*-r' 52:92 ', miss. E-*2._,é?r\:;§§V {_5E€§LZ§ ';"*+'%§.§GP.
' »:::;:3 L;-&}TE 3*" £%.E'é°?Q5'xEY' QRBZ
-- _ zwmga
-. ass %_,§,"%"E T ;3$~§'%"C}?xé'{ tau:
RE?§.ESEf"~é7EB 3? %V§0T§~%§§.,., ; §*~é£3{§"i§§.A§ GQARQEAN R§$?$§\§§E€'*§?" N6. 3.4
aése ézaé ether aiiments far whécfi he wag taking %:s'a3:rr2:~§§:*::'ég%;T:"*.%A St. 3@hz;';'a §-Easpétai, Safigaiere. Yéiarafare, it was s;:A4'§;;*ate4.v,§§§§.*',L5=:Td~' ' £23; téza agpeiéant that 33% death sf Azz§;:;s:.y.__Cra:;%"%;%é§'g:'_';--;§s%'s:%_§*;~_ acmurgt 9? stress am strain §::r§':.*;g1'_'_'§%~':7e "::0_3s;,:s*{ae:
empiaeyment. The Csrnn:§§§§§:;-figs *fé §* .
Cemgersgatéart, €@;':$§§e?Er;§ tfie eia§§dAV:a4,§:§V%;sE§__§eZ;'in afirifes came ta the cancéagsiarz '€§*"é3V€"té'.-iA'&.A§éfE";E;§§§f%é5- 3§'»%§.§§fi_§§$C§"§ai"'§§¥"%§ §"z§§'§i2t:e$ duyiag ??§§§':t,v.§'3v§¥.££"S}.'?'§&'.%;. gain whicfi resiziieé in his §Ve::§}é;é*;1jL?j that the agpaefiant Es ,i§a§%é't;%$ §§§3.ij€%*:§"s:{§:*:2péé*§é'aétior:. The juégmerst &§"%€§ erée? §%" %%::a §aa.i';"§je:é'"~i:§:z*:§*::%ss§eraer far §5é@r§<m&:2's Qampansatésvn is c}'2ai5E§+:§'Eri"§2,é'::~':§:%§i:ar2 is": this Appéaé. .:S§.'«i;e&:'_V'é'f":é.«;:2'--.§c:--::§**:se§ fer the agsgaééarzt §a-iterating ifze g;::s:mé"§$" ..;;r§é»:§"_'v_»._§éf§é°'e ma Eeamad Cémmégséanes' fer i:~§£3§§asi%:r:§e::""$* €@!%é§e}:$at§ar2 and ?$§}'§?'§§ 2:35;'; the jafigmant 5? % sgrema Qazzrt Er; we §f 3mm: A§§%~%2'vi§ VES .4"~[f .V§g_§§"g§fé"".é%;5i:=?E%'*é§ER., §'éEi..LGRE 3:. AM?" s*$aefi:$d in 2385 am 逧 %f§ 'e:a:a:§te%°:ds that the aaafiani :5 mi fiaifie is gay 32% «EV 5 camsaensatécrs, if 3 aezson §§&S er: accmmt af ?sea;f£:"'a§:7t'§.n{3<;7 whfie diacharging his duties.
5, fizfimittedéy, the éeceaseé wa$}'1'.Su:§§3e';4§fig§["frf§:é9; bioeé §3¥'éSSE.1i'& ané éiabates. it Es5'és_§:$a:'sV_%rwtA'E"e3Véésgificé"%§.§§é"§:~I':'é wag a sszéiéed emgiayee arggwas VA;s.:%.pv:3s§e§:_ tag' iascrk aii threa sééfts. it is net Eav "é:§%:éguie_vf§:§a§: é§ .§e:r$os'1 wfia is suffaréng frcxrn high b§§}'<2e§ ,:sr§:si's'§z.ré::aV;§'é_':;€.§%get§§"gag éirectefi ta work during 4€;%§:Ef§%?:s§;%V§§t--._":;.~'.§1§¢.;§,;p:g m?9é3t£3i"&i?§', Efiefe wéfi be stress; which wauié have aéaveiagseé tifie' we are 3? the epénéarz that ting éevaEfié'p§_;}§_§% by the éecaeaseé wfiéie &Evfs.::".§*':a;*gE;'z:,;;{4I?*':vE1s'~figty ?2%i§?'§ §§ may an agmurgt cf st.é"a~ss af;:T:s:§:VVs';'a%iias'i«.r;°; 's':i;:é,%'i'.?§_3g the marge a? his emgiaymerzt}. We f-éersfiita.$'a:V$ré;%%é;L«..C%:'i:'é;t in tine cage :2? Eystifi Aéemma; an Vvfafiig, i*:a§"§*2:a%§ ?€'%:ét §:%*;e jéés 9? the éasgaasaé was aszéy ta _ ::52L..4;er Véff. ??2e§*efeg"e, iézasz' iarésbégzs have taken 3 sack sércismstancesg the hgar: &tta¢i< causefi is V' v__i§'§. émg3§9yea cazgid :19': be atiribateé E the rgatum 9? job. "Er: the érzstant case, aémétteéigg éaaceasaé was 3 skiééefi fig/% warkér 353$ wag reagisirea ta werk cm the machine '§Efi§'"€3i§§§"#$_§E.E ma aiafit. Yfierafeye, if he has deveéwed 532%: §eaé2'z_ 'eV.z:""§f._ 'v._ §CiC6L£E"'it G? téie stresa 3:23 strain, we am :3? the 3§§r:%::fri" E3 mfg: we :9 the giélb fitraéré, which rasz:é%:a::§..§;: Argteny Cruz, In the aértumgtances, {Eye imam by ihe iearrseci cmmsei Aé§p_e~E§_ga;%'é$ "§:$"""::»:;E ap§§ie:abEe ta {fie facts ané cEr:;smstaVrz:;駫:3f--~tLhe ;5:§'e'§é;fi;A,,=:'f;a§e. ?, Whan the damaged %§"aé.T_%:§eiz\:a%§E§E§a;d:éA?§'r:.%§s;i~$aér: we fig stress ané §trai:'z wifsééé va:°§§s§%:1%AVa::;§§§*g:§§ fi%'2é"_--:§;;:ti¥ée?3VV'vd:s§'Er:g night mars, we afa sf i;%zQV"é;--:§;§§r'je:§%;';;rj:"'i:5a?;.. ihé Ewmeé Camrraigsiafiar 1%?' ¥¥@:"kman'§"-L_€;Ma's:f¥':§&§§'s§?;»§é§'§'e_.»~ 4§$ jzssfiéféed if: amzaréirag sm:f=;':pe:zsa;;t_%;§é§ $5 thé~€fé§$=§¥"§fia%?%tS-~€§ai?§'33?§'{S. fife subgtarzééai §Vié'a$%§%:?a:'z._ :7}';' ééfig a7rE$es in this figgeaé, which aaéég §Q{ mgr intarf§&:;e7§%'{;;;a1, "'J:5§5'¢_e::;#::':di§;*§'§%§: we fipgeaé ég éégmégseé. sdl-:6 Judge' sal-
Judge ézzzé