Karnataka High Court
Jakathi Ramanna vs The State Of Karnataka on 18 January, 2011
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
EN ":'m:%. m<_:;~;~{ €;'€;}Uf€:"I' :;_>E«-" £{L;';%»E€<E\é3?§.':'f%E{g¢;X <'m<_'.';14,;: :3' BE"---¥_ M' ;_::».;~--§,;-$2. \m_§:> :§zx.';'Ej3;3 Ems; mg-*-: 3:2" E1};-W <3?' .3.»-aNz_s;:R V5 :23:
3 iii ET} R E. '§'§-HE E~E{i}N"E%L.E1{. MR. 1.: ¥;.§f%§'§'E{"Ei~: ANJKNETE szgfsiié. T} €fE2'i[VI'INsxLAPPEAL?5§'o.i:S3Sis'24{)Q%?.,' A :%Ea*£T'xv%:«;:_::;:Is:: A %% fiéziéaiéii R3.:"r:a1:ma9 SEO R-"ILmi Déxidz-1 E."Ti:.:<:}1a;;>gE*$2:..,.« fxgaé 213791;: 4E3 jg.-"§2=:z's'~;, " ' {:}é.:<:: A;;g;;"'i.a:L:Eiu§"e' _ .
R;-'<> 4"' 'Es-izgmt 1\:'§£':4:f':'Vji;'£§E2'"1IE1 :-;éz%*é:%§'1aE ?: E « _ I '§'21E:£k.§--i(>s;:>e:§ Gigi: 'V /§§}}f7€3H&'ii3€ {E3}? Séhré 93$-21'E€:} M % ;. ...va' x 2 '"§Efi:;%' §§1ai:: M :5:':'21faaE;24;§<;a 'E3y-.E:'i'%;?a:v§x9;<;¥;:i§g,:zfLj'§- . §3'<f:£ ice; ,. . . R <;3:a»;;}m1:;i:~3:':E
-Eé: :ag:§~;;v;:g;;g:;;q ;*a<";;zj;
AA 'E"'§fi§:: {'.7:é:"z2ir:21E £':;'Tf§§}!::ji§ §EEa3:;'; unaiazz" 5%:-:::é§m 3?s€é{Z:'} <'>'fi.§";:3 . "-§_;f<.>;<;§e"'_«:}§{f'1*é:":2%§é:-:§ §3:*<:~a:<~::'i:;:'::; ;:::"a2,§_;§:\;§.;, as 336% ;if:§§:."§£.i" a:::sm:E:,:$;%»:';a'z
-- 2-2'.'.'=*::.,'§ 5;%:m'::;'z.s;:<3= gézfiecli {}.{L?;2€'}<'}"?., gmgsécai E33; fiéiigiiéifiiiéig §ii>%:.;:%;.:'%.s;: axzgé 2%
4..."
3,4...) §3%.I§1§E§;E"ié%bEC f3:T}i' <:\>i':'i'E:m:e::~; §§LéI}i§f1;Z§bEi'E uz1<.:§r;*r Saéczziur': 37%; mi' ihc Exiiiizm E'::3m1E Coe:§:;:.
'%. €32': iiuzé a%><>wz z1l§ega§§:7x'& 0% %;h& c<::ez72p§s.;§.:2;::2i; ;3;~;3€.ce:iis@__g§a. énéizizatczé and aéfiez" m:*:::'";":%1i:2:E Ef}i.:~;t:"§c.i anti f%§:2:~;5;Ecm:s: .§udgc:a, tits: t:"E;§§ was: e:<?n1<;im:E.e=:<;§. "VVfg§.3E:§.§§E"2._x?v:*i:1§"
€:{3I"EEi?E§'£ifCE by 322 1-<:<:z2:~_;a:<'L 'E'"§2a: :=p2*:::g§::f:;,i:%.z§:*: 7:354:-::*§:'i'~:*:'z:sc,"E wéirzezases 2:5; §~'W.} £13 I3W.8 £;%§2Li'§{i}E__ §':1.2irR_:;:.{:§ E Q d<;.:;'{:'z"':.1};::.z1_£V:: 2375; £25; RE :0 P; E9. '¥Xvf§E€§'€£ES {hast ;2a:c22.s;e<.§___;._§;::.iVv;§::;§r*§<<::§ 'gym:vc{0g:iE:_;'ne;1:
}§.':':<_5 iii zmd Z? m2:%';<3::'§:;:i {T?§'?_§£€': £5§1..1¥"éiE'€f';--,f1i1E§f*iii3'{§»:,5iE§.33»/§{.}§;. §. 3:: 1?? {)3 the §>2:::E:;"{§§" Z§3§§:f§3§£i{f§'Z'§Z3E' IE'E§i'{ xa.r;::§";'é'§_'2;%,<:<::<§ §i':e§'(m:. zine C<,>::;."i,, 'ihé-3 {'f'<éL:r"£ §7:':i'nf:eai. iézs.-,4:-ib§'24§w_:::g__ V§:§V1:'}i'§~";:Jg,V§,': £61" its :§:~:tm."mi:";2&i<*::"s: E .
33 'Q%;'%7_c:h:::f'--;f;r€:::a:2§Em;%0zz ;;>:'<>'w-23:2 §?3€3jv'{}¥E(§ aié I'ii§ES£3§.1éEE§§€ .dm:¥f>"%.::é' '§§:--a:--:~{:r': ;-"?i§§':>.3€}{}¥i'"% 22.: abmét E p.321 in t§*::::E;md '§:>.{"§~E<'>_<>g:;az:" :'1a':z:;Ea;i2pz2 fiéiai' {Eu.na?z: $t:2's%.<>:3 3%' ?vi,E"z~fi' T"~:.. §fg'g§%,§E' 's:'§Eéziggszg £;§é'3CE§f,§€;':C§ %»"{}§§,§§'EE=;'%§'§[};' a:.aL:s€:c§ §"::;:f¥; '£9 '-§%«:§%§A":'1§i:sE22%n:::":i-;;31"0$:3a:;1i3°§><; EWV}-4% %:>y :2§:s;2z2E€.§:1g: Ezéir' 228;}: am: §'":.<-:E§?: 0? E';_:2:":<i:'<-'; zmd '{§ii3E'éf§'}'v' gztsmmiiizséi up' @§§3?<:=§*:';"::::;:: pm2%s;§mE°:§a::> §._..%C%:3.<:L§Z3 {:5 §?€_'_."?' very ratievam £79? Ebe purpasge if tixig case 3:3 ii: i'i'1€*i"i3;fl§--' ;*a,*\;§.":*3E€§ 'aha piase <35 fifffi3}'?;§Z1i3.
§. ii: 3:: far 233 2313 €'a:i.{§@;r1.£:e 9? ?.'%;I3 2>~;;;':::'-can;¢;~i:?§3:a*éi';'--T ' iézszzgh he wag iyeaieé :15 a héiastiie a.asé':z'm§~:.3 9:9; agééasgf. z";f_i':.%:é».. Efiflfif 8? Ezég €".»"id€:§f.'£C€ E":*«€fi32*e {Em {i°;£2*e2'fi_., Cauii' §2é:$.Vh§:E§§.; %:}=:::{i'». Sirzee fi?2e'r::.% wag an ac§'m§$3§<3§': by 'izvéfié-ihai iim? .'§"§£?.iVi'§'S} %€'8§M§?0ég€d a azampiairzi agaéagt §1"§,':"fir,_€}i'"' 2::i{m§.:;;fi:'i'déV;':1:,;_ <22:h€;f¢c¥'ir:'"s%:e was ai:"£a€.§<;€é §j,J him witéz 2: '%<i:*:%€s.%V a:.2§'v§'€Eg%'%:g~.;€E"§:$.ij~3&2' W33 0%' E0035 éharaczéi" Eéfié ;E'i"E$ .'£70r *:E3i:.;: -réaS's*:m7,j ':."§§'Tl}3_;}',. E}£% £:3r§_iim:ed her c§7:a;rac:€.,;=:::i*é§s2:s:éi,na'§§%§:ié' izi"s§¢5€:1g%:;g,§_"'§1c**' étate 3%: E26 haéi Seen the ;are$€cL:ir';x;?"€fi«",<§ V%5€§V:"§z;;_.<.:1;'T._'e' §';s__ vaféiil {he acsusad ami i:hs:"ef€3'r$, big '«.':3"-a'§.逧1€':€,'-- ha.:1b-56:2 %:.ega.:é:_§i 1 »;P¥%r'3,5 €{§'§" sérézga are {$13 §z1éz€sEiga§%§g i:T_§ff§c$:°3§, 333$ ;§'3lie:V 2:53: gérwgzzstarzsa Eda-5 rigfiiiy aasegied--ihe 'e%x;%§:§j$::£-§ £2? 13§Z§£ 2:3 ':9 Eiag sag':::e§1_;::s 9%?' amgzggg gzazézgigyg ism: $326 "jizagé %::»&:e§;...':'L§ ifiziyzéa fiéaéééa is §§"§'€%*€?§§z"§ ffigé is-gm "Raga Efiaéié " . é;~:%7;s§'a%'és.§§:3..i E p.,m,5 w%;%§{a §'€'{'§§f§§§'Fig %2§§§2e 3% '%§="'3'§'i'§{§§ :9 <:a2§§2::%:, E <2 ziefzmli :0 :1:1{iz'::;g;a ::;%m;i>3e is2:;:w;*i.s:<:m11':c3:2.t :?:>:* cmc:»: ;"m;>:'1ih ;'3.E':€§ haéih Ehzs: :';::m:<31':c::s; v~;<:1'<: <':z*<§<:=:':=3:i {:2 mm <:<31*::2s;:2::,1i'§_2-*<;*.E.:a. '"E"he (four: has $39 iz2ke;:~z": ime &{:C(>mEt the ;::a::'%as:i g%z21*%ng_,; which ti-"sss: :i<:<:u2:e;>.<;i W215? in guciicizai c:..:s;t0«:ij;y;
9. E3 %;§':§:; _}udgg.jm:3:1E which. is Lliiiféfi' cfzzzi§_é::§gé{i''.E:fM§i€.._ . p:'<:*§:@;1i zagpezal. _ iii}. The Eezmzcd Cm,::1:'~:e<::E fiat' fE":.»:: 21:g§'pe'El2m'é.E:é f'~j:'.Li§"}"§f'§(:?%Ef'§:A§"::"V~:
the. g1*<mnds :'a§:§<::c§ ii: {hes §'v"Ec:zI2_{>zi-a£1_;€;é'L::f:'2. ::>~1";appe:;;;gV-:,;.;:sa;1cm4§;:i;; caxniand, ihzii fix: <:2.z:~;a12:§;-- é'?£§)§'}E'{':iE'§'é;:'§}A' {7'f' 'i§f§€3 C(}§j;*{ .:«;¢1{;w cezmi::§§aVe':ii_:§a*:'}é '--';f.7;*{:>.:fi'v:%"z«i:*«f§€a;3:_t};i%zzé; tide ra:c<:r<§ disciamsss éhai {E33 aiieged af:'é--:<§;'::3 Eéaéég t.€%};:::=z §§.ac.a <32"; 2§:a:'%;f3{}{)6 Em: E§'E€;Z' {Ta;§u.2':
.. _ b§E§<>v,-'.{:E.:a$'E3: :z1<>;"'e" iézgm we §_>Ea{:<-3 ;:m<:@céé:<i. ¥:<::s <:<3§:$%d»::%r Ehaé tini- :3?'§}:':':<:§: §?z;2$~:;2.5g.<§é':*:.._g?>§21g:.<:» gm Z-3%§(:"%.i?;i}{§{35 w§i2£::§*1 is 2: g§_2:1*%n§; £fE.'E"O§.* w'§9:i.a:§.*:'* ';};_:f7:*zi%§r;§§_g' §}:'-:':_§:u:::§::<:-<3 §%'1s:: :-":'':%::<;'; (.3? ibis: {[E:sz2:_'i in v.§3:"<}<:€:2{i~%2zg;. is fimé @1222: :;§1<.:~2 <;EaE:a:x in §:"E_E§§";g £513 E7-"E33; ifsféifé 'a-é':f>«;§>§;3i'%:f3£i §.._Z§.'»='ii*§'E ihéii the ¥QE.'€}E§éi'C'i§'E§T%f%: 2": Eiifiéigfir ::::":a:§ 52:1: ii £3 VA u {mi {$5 :2"1:":<,§§:5»;€:};' aémi $%a;:§':§:: 32:23' s.;%"::.~: mégfizé; Emgszfz: :':;%s;i:'::%.:3<:<§ '§.%°{t::";:': 2: §"1:,:c an iliji 21% that times. of' f§."£€ aziiegeci ézzcidasnt my has} :'~;h<«: zazkcrz imm:3<.%%_:2i::= smspg in me §"3:*:«;t insi:m<:<2 E0 §ni'E>:"1':::-.__E'z@r hmbzami' "SEES; m_>:.1E:;€ d§s:<.:E03<:* {$2221 a faisgz-:6 Liaise": $.31 :'§{'3'Li§:?f,§"§'V£'VE{§V§Z'3'%E:?~ f0is;'z<:d f1:>:' 2':;:21:&;m:; Eaaai §s;:zowr:s to zéée p:'ci>:;<=:¢:u:*;r1f_i>«; v;j:'miL' :E2i:;:..f ;>:"<;sa:*<:uE;i<">:': in geekigzg E0 21}§e;§,:-3 <¢fi'<:m:7é: gag':/¥;ii::::*:."'?;'_E"::.:i 1:«.is1:Q_.V'Ll'i:§_%{:'"iV. 'V
-s {En 2-:2': {iTs=§ié;:'i' 221% vizsaa,-' <7s§ji§.:.s,;: :";:a:ié'm'a%'i an 1;»a3'<rgt::t;<,§_ afiiézef ${;3fJ§LEi;3E"£{."sf;'f 0.§i'ev<3r:t:'«;,, Ehé: §§.':£':I'§.'E€3CE {'7:){é'n§;{3'§.wivuifii' :~.:u{7mi: Eahai it £3; o§:w§<.>2;s;§y ai C2186 <3? $£S~(K':Z\I_§£/:31": _§z";:::%:'a;::;>;:i*':;¢'V.bywiiifiii cmzsarrnz '::e{w<:::*;2 {Em zzccassed am? :¢:L:i:iEx caéfgai Céiifiii :3{T?E.§:.§§EE Ea ai§<;3§.5;s;3{§°:»;,A'2e.:?§7i.0-.%1E§:'"§7:t:i*'~.#'>;t:'2i§'1;§{i%':;r$ ;'<;222:~;e3:";s; Va.-'§"2§<':.§§ is; mm': 2*e3%::%:2m%g :-iinzge n<';:-caéssi'%:sT'm;1i:é¢a:?:;.:1 E'§§§Eii§1Si ihéfi azcgzzged' {FIE ..,:.§:_'s;:""a>::§:V:'&:' §';2"2_;'":<.§,§ iixé §:%2::"::e<:£ {E:;>vg:'m":3@:2%: }%;«:§.§=<%Vk;--:::<z:"'43.23::Ed sazuizamfii E.§'1é'.%E the {:E.::§:':y in §:1><,§g;§n;i_§ $26 ::a"::3mf:=§2':%r2.*a' ::l:z:j}:'*::Q}_: ;b::f'v§'%%i~:.§;._i '£';':%e:E E1'? ah:-3 5:232 <33: iézmai _§--is wa'}£!k§ pizzas _ :'c§%z:r'§€:~s§ {xi :%éé3":_§L:é§g323:::'1i <'}{i§'m= Apia:-:1; {}'i<_§:.m in :.%m CEESSE3 0?' fééfiiie }:;s€£'§EI§a::;aé§é::E E§r;:§§se$,E: me. {E-ézm {:T§'§§:~g§'§{i-g ,%§E{ ZEREE 2€§"?;% C323 "'%§§"":%:=:«; :°::g;;;3;:"::§.. §":<';"§{§ ?,§Eé.i'3' §§Lz;§:'<:2f:':s {'<:::.::f'é.; '£1.22: 23 $55; §