Karnataka High Court
M/S Multitek Engineers vs Union Of India on 25 May, 2012
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar, B.Sreenivase Gowda
_ *3 at'j§:v'R;Ag;
EN THE EIGH QCEERT $3' 3TAIm AT B.§§;KG§E;§RE
i3;'%'{E§§> TE-E555; '§'§'£E§ 2%"? EBAY Ci? ?v'1AY, 1'/3312:
PRESEZNE'
11:3 HGNBLE MR. JUSTICE av. sHYLENQRg:.'
AND
THE HGNBLE MR" JUSTICE B: S"RE;E;1\%:V;§:$i:g:§'(::ix;f=n;aA V
WZA. Nos. 382238233 2ms::s % = '
'WZA. Nos. 2231+;2j233 0:202
WA. N<}s;';';';%182."O~3;8f'2«_i?_ . 3.2020
IN WA 38223823 2o1A9_ ' '
gg _ -
WA 223:~2233*'gg1; ~
BETWEEE; ' % V' " A
wzg. :5\z1L;L':'i':%::<:_E§:;3:NE:.:e:Rs, -
42$; 2;, 383' <::R<":»f.i%.;~::,_B3's' --R<i>--.::;};
mzigsgx V.
BANGAL€i:§<'_.E 5 55:3:
{RE§E%iESEN;'§TE§E}' 233:' {is §RC¥?REE'E'GR
* V ,é_§PEiLA?%'§
{::%:5;€ 3'5A:§{;"'§,§i1¥§'3§{E§gE§ N§%R;%°}i»%;F€A ESE §<:§?§gx; 5. ggxfggz gmafs.
2 §%3'J.§
3&3? .
:; ;'%::£>:x: GE? zwaégé
E-€'§Z?RE=SE?'§'E'EB 8'? {TS §§;€R§:?'E1%§%T'{,
H §'~fiEN§S'E"'RY GE" ?'§§A§\§€L€.,
E}E2P}':R'§E\/EEF§"§ CE? ;:€§§if"£;?§éEVEL
T"sE§Z'$':7 DEERE w E E8 £
"%
{Z??§{E{ZCT<3 R2'-X'?EZ 8? RES'? §§?\? U E iE¥E'f'E; iii G §*22'\.3 C £52
U.)
TEEEJZ SEEEEOR §N'E'E§§LLE{3V§§E\7€ET i319"? ICESR,
?§%§§:i9 335} 57%. CRGSS,
1.»;
6. M1 GMBIQ Li%§:'QU'§L B§§§\?:':SVxr':'§§}§, BA§'$ QEXLG RE THE S1i:iNEGRiNTEELLEGEE'\2'CE GFFECEP. 2 :-
DERECTQRKEE OF ;F%E%:VEiE\iQE :N?E;L:g:G;;?3€CV¥:Ta.,. ' gazmgamag, -
QANARA BANK, TOWNHALL BRANCH. 5;, A ., STOCK EXCHANGE 2'ovs;E:R$;- ._ 28'? CROSS, JC RSAB ; '-
BANGALORE, * BY ITS BRANCK MA§sAG}:.R;'v.._ CANARA BANK? ~ GANDHIPURAM, V . :
(:0IMBATc3.RE-- . » BY ITS BFiA,N'CH ..
CITIE§AI\J'K , M, <3. ;2o'A;;i3, BAN{;g%§;g§REf:A:."' _ BY Yrs; Bfég-NCH ';§i?£~;='€ACiERk Bszsc' BANK " " "
N@,?;<----Ey1;<;. R:3;:.§;-* ; %3ANG£L{>,RE?- 55:9 03:.
3 BRA§i"€C.E%T. ;¥EANASE§%.
* ~ :<;5§*::z:;}sv;%.a*;::1&,5§1r':§a%. gggxzx gm, :a;vaT§;--§::: {;R;@z.zN1: EESGR " "1V~'?zz:Ta::§{;:.P;<aL €jGR§GRA'E'§QE\§ A Gg_%i"~E§}E5£E BREAK Egggmggesjm B;%;E'§G£'iLC%EE ----» 5&3 $82343 'i*5._.§'"§E 8EZ§§E'\§'Q§£ §£ANE;GEE€, §%ES§.3€}§'aE§}E:E%EE7S {E3}: SQE. E7'. §%:9'§:3?i5-_E'€ zigifiif, $83 Rh E $312 'J. E}. RAE/"§RAJ.; €GC ;3"{Z3R '§{,2.; Rifég SR? EBREJEZSEE €§%AE'%§§L'?E*Z%% GEERU £1??? SEE' $§j§Ei§3'1E§}Rr'§ .%%i}'¥Sa ¥®§<3 Kai. £5, Rfi 'xi/'I¥?.i'§' AVPEEEEZEEE, S'E'AN§}S EEESMESSEEE} if/Ga E)E¥E'€Ef} Efi 1 EV 23$ 2% 3%.??? R8 W SEZE%VE%Z§}§ '§'E§!E§SE: 2553:'? ;"iE3§>E:f,%§E, FEEEEE 25/3 4 .."'$Ef*«._ "---E';'€E; ;<;f;§25\i%9;rAKA :~§:<;;~: CQ{iR'£' ACT PE~3J-§.Y§E\?G '§*€3~~Sff:'7¥' --.3,::;.€ THE QRDER PASSEZI} EN THE XIV 32?? E?
L :":%2*:'<@ N .
NG;22838;'2{}1CI AM) 24533w3r3/29:@(f:f»fi*gg;i=;3;:*:*E:f>u ESXOQEZGEG.
WA 3820-3821 2019 BETWEEN EVE/S. M~PC)WER BEZLTENGS A353-.:1;L::_s?®§::{a:§$, 98/ L 4% QROSS, VZX5:'?KANAl\?b5A.?§AG;<3;Rg ' BEG UR ROAD, 30M3§;:m:AH;a;;.;:g. "
BANG;§LC>RE----56Q S88, REPRESENTED BY H"S;..RAR?N'ER,T§ DEVERAJ .. .§.£;PPELiAN'£' {By 8:3. Lgzésiim. .:\i:'gx5RAj::é§m_ §"_@"§: {GRAN S. JAVALE, ADEES. 3: SR}; {:H;%J\f_DRA.SHEKAR'K»§ gay;
AND.
;. UE'§'E'GE'=J $5' 1N'§,:;%;, REPRE;$§E:N'E'E:§ABY.§E"S :3ECREZ}'%.R'yZ V .?\gflNiSTEE§f' Q:§?7'§'iE':1¢;;\§CE, ,. 3 E'§z%R'§'E':rEE--N'§' C317?' RE'VE',E%§i3E1, F§E';;'fx? ;:*:.§;:~§: ~» iéo Q91, V T_ " s§i;~:;{;.;'e §1'\?1§'EZLLES§::EC§:'i §3§<*:«§{:§é:3a; %E%§;i:"?€;3;§§%'fE <2? REEz'E:2'%Ei£%Z §m'%::,mG§:;'x;cE, ;§;%,. '3'"-i.»"A Caasgg gxszgg: 'myasm: B53$€ASW;i§}E., E5_;s':E'€if_§»AiQ§.E. «W31 , 1. .3: s:«:::;:Qs;:i §'«§?EZL§,EG§5';E'§{?TE? §3:?§:'€§::~f€, ' E}§§2E§C'§C%R:3,»f?E SE3 E{§Z!¥fE§N{§;§ §;"\s§",?}ZL£.£{C%E§§%€ (33711, fi:G§'s;'§ EE'{§O E73; E2, 4%. $'§35'E"fE§ B;'%E"€E{ 8%' ENEEEA '£VIL8Ci?€ GEEMREDEN E3R%NCE'"L E\fCL4~?4a E27'? CE{GS$§E£;E,i4SQN GAR§E1N? BANGALQEEEZ ~ 55$ 8217, BY {TS BEE;/§E\ECE"£' MANAGEZ '.
ICES} BANE': LH\zHTE2D§ 8G;'?", ELEPHANT ROCK EEQAI}, JAYANAGAR, CW1} BLOCK' BANGALORE - 560 G} 1. "
BY ITS BRANCH MAN_AGER.3_ LA {BySfi.VJ)§%%fi%§L§QCF§R£{3駧$€3S R£JL%R5»SHfi@Q}_ '-T' 2 KARMgTAKA%Hfi3E cQ:§5*§£fiiP§ms§§§;T@ SET'ASE}E $35 QRDERV PAS%fi§a£Nu H§§*Efi@T asgnom NCLZZSS?/203$', 23: n2453§j2®IfiflYEAR) :;%3a@ :5/egrzoiaf ' M '= 3"" 'A."'""* THESE x¥Rr€]fi?PE§;,1%L3@'«fi;5 4: <3? THE "!'h€§§: 2§jf§§;}oVé:Va.I's '(in Preliminary E/isarirsg, this fia}A "Z".i:;;: Sh;g1end:a"'V;";:1mar J; éeéézrered thé feiiaxazjingg . ' 'z g§§éMENT Ezrzwaéi ?£h €':a§: vgzpgszzis {E252 ;:ppé:%§§a:@£i§:» are zgziégiianéxég .a"«::i§:1(:1i::':a:%.:%3'.4_§i:/fisi' pagsad by ihfi Esarészéd Singié ufziége in évsééi p€i:'faé<>I:$ whszem fE1€ isagnéé; Siagié zjiiétgff. fsmnd 32:3: a£{2:£:§::::€:%f,:;i; 2:}? 331 'asmiée:
:3? éi}'}pE?§E':§31i$§ bf; :i;Z?:.€ Qiffiififif {sf Ri?i'§='%?E'i?.3;€ ' '§hf§%:'%E'§,{;ez:§:9 {E33 iiiffii ;s'a§23<-"~, Sififfé was :3{:s§ 32/:$t:;Zf3;€:fi 2:2 E321? rm}? §§u;;pc2:"?:,5:<:% 21:": Ezzxac ;%1<3v%:>ri:§:€1{:?s;a; «:£§:*<-f:{5:ééa:'% 33:2? H;RESPGN§§flfS, U'! r&:i~:§::<:2§::s:i<a--?:mi 31$ raises? &ii:';21e:?:}::33€%:1§: by im§.}<}§é:2g <::{>1::{E§i:}Z@::
{£3 sszzfe g:,,1;1;*i% EE";::% i:1%é%1'£%$% of éihe :"<~%sp{>:2{i{*':m;; §§_§;}§}{%§EiZiT 'was it; fuimiaféz EEEEIEK §._§L2éTiI"Ei§1€i§'?€ far 22:": 2:m0:.a--:;j'é:--w_{i=f R562 <:r::>::*€s pm: §:<:rgé?tth€2: in :<'€=,s§,>€<ét {)5 v.¢:«',:V{.';é;?2:"}':%;é--E'V1rES,'." subjecé, matter sf tam baiiches,c:-f»wriziiT_p€:§{i<2%::§; 35; $36 wfif; peiitignérs' esiabiishméntés ziffé" .1/?.H i}.'WE'l€{;3. ind2'V£duaE., namzéiy Te D€:'izfé§*?3jg V.L€a'2":35é:i A§i?%i:5ifgE€ has' furéher pérmitiéd Aappé§i--.i«2iVé':$ b3.?"'2a7a§r of an abiernaiiva C{}§T%§§7i§GFE9 .*£}%}_* C>1f1%§."vS€CE.§_f§'ijQ?{E6 said sum,
2. H<3w€1iér,::1:he 2.?I.4}L}.}'3§1/fiV?:';1"1Ti'.;'L%:hé,'»'<$"':5V;L};}"'S1i€d ths mafia:
in app€a1:s--v..Cé§:iéi§3';3{i--it;g ':/hat the attachment is :10: j::[st§fir3d 'i:'":VEzgéxs >a31'::§ %ha.: it is Kare}: Ssified in iavaf by high 3.:/:f:vE:{}:V*,E§ty"§7§"1éi:*V 1-héE'_;cusi0m§ Gfféaitials or efficigis 95 §h$4;:§§r§{:€@:a; i€;.._:};f }:"*fi3Y€f£u€ i§;?L€§ig€§%C€?. Whfia €fX€fCi8§fEg §z";;%€:§A file Cugioms AGE; P3539 do E38? :¥'18sfif€ gawsr "if?'a.§:§35f:E";"."_E:%.a:i7aE%:x ;;/wégeamiaa ax: i;;?:§: sfage 9%' §§}§'€3Sf§§;E:fi0E}, Lzniésss may 2112: :§~3?EG"x7if '£38 gufagissi ::13'{.:€:=:' is Gné f.,§;:;:§*E§: fix" {.f{)i1§:€~${':::Tifi{3Z1Z §:h::'s_§ 'ifsééfzfé :26; i§,§E§?E§§:':1fy" }fz:Vé~ae%:£%':f:{%::§ " 33:: am-2 z:p§3e5§aV::§:$ é€:%:€r:::§nV§::g' %;%3{% zégzsmsrys {E236 éi':"Ed€'§"' 2:2:":j; g1§§:z{§£{:§;€i:§:é:2 éZ}';C§§?§2 {?€iE:ff}E"§"i5'/§Ef~§;'»{,3;.§'e':'iJ£}€?', 'iii; Efélfi baE5:::{:>£i% £3 £5: E/hi? 521:3}: 2:<:<:<}1m%i for 5; t:;»i:23l 2:m<>::m: of éakhg gznié S§Oi"IE€7 gzmgasmsa: 15:": @?;;he:* 3333?: £1{f€:i}?,§%"§'f,S beifig héici asp {£139 {<2 ;«2':§:2:<:hmeI";ii has ésffiééféégi b:Aisin€:éé;~sv. €3§":hs% appéflaniis for abaut mfg y<3%a:'s§ Whi<:--§é"' "g-;é:T. unr€as$nab};€ 3:153 iiei 21 pI_'Gp€?""iEX€}'CZ?'j3€ ha?"g>:;W€:{'.b:y9ga gubiirc autheriiy assuming far" ;1rg::::z"1emS..sak£:A., power is availabkj :0 fhéf' aiéaéhéng xgfficszf. H
3. We have heal:§':M'~ S12? L;ak$h'mi::3rayaVnaV§ Eearned Coungek for thgfr apps.§.E.3:i:is V Raju. Earned Qsurzsel fer3ihe;r€_spo';1den:sf. E . ' £9 5:53?'ie$E;SE":%fiin3§faj;§an2::, iéar°:3€d Casings: is? the app€iié:3j:'t:3_ 'v§'§af€:'§3;f_{g..¢.;'€£§az:<:a3 an 532% éaiisxxrifigf decsisigng: ~ ~%%%2@@é"g;::>:é: .6257 {Gag} «A31/E, Qverssas vzs «_L*';:§_on <31? Efiéia {£85} iii?' 33% {}':ELf:_W Rag§3%;:'am {Emh . Lid, vs Cemmiggianssr sf (EEK, 5: S€§"if§C€ V'Pa:s:..
' 3; ;E§§%i§§ {E 23; E33' :ss§:3 {aim :33? {fzzgéia} ?'W';. E;{;{3L 'SS 5);'. §}§§"€':iZ?5i,€)E1 EERE 4%} G§s:§<é3* &211:€:{§ 2ii§§,2f§'§Q 9? fiégéz Cozzri :3? géuriicsj/:sF£.x Eviadrasz izifs E§s::":<:;e::::':: §::<i%;::V E§eé:i:r{2n§{::s §>;z*§i:a:2Vi:s:% Lfxzi. €73; Cam:m§3s§<>:V;s::" <12? §3::as~.t;<;:m3.
5} ZGES {E52} E35,?' F312 {D63} »~ Egczxmars Qvarseas 'VS U§1§<>:3«s:;fEndi23:; 1 sL:bm:'€s §';h:;sfié:aH these': »«:iecis§0:2$ BEG afi .~ ';I'L1ihQé§'i};j. §':>1*'g {he propgsitian that not: SI}§}'.:?i'§'ii%. }:3R4'l, é§:g.:3 '§§-:e Customs Qfficialg Carma': af:ta€h 'Ba7:1k 3.:::sé[i:s:;:'J:,. 331:-'§§' <5:$;é;r:, assuming ih€:§-* E21176 such ;3f<j&z::%:*& "ih,€ 'aJ;?::;:Cfi":né:*:i: as 9? EEGW' becemets bad in iaw..V-22y.$35"_§ssuing"si*§ew cause neiice afifir Lapse sf mégflé as}. 'fem {he dafiia sf a¥:i:a::hm€nt._ .
53 Gr: Ehei»-figher "E§~:_{::r::é:d Genital Ggvernmeni Sitanéfiéng Céu--i.:,$§3'S:*£, Ravi"Raj, far $36 §'€Sip0flC§€i'i§S, SEibfEi§iS"~7i2Vi?;?h %€%fé%5%n--:3:§"_.»%.ii0 provésiasn fif $663102 EH3 of :h€;g.§é'x<":iV;. '£§*:atv":i'§3.;£'::'€ is iimfi: E23133: fer ESSEEEIEQ; sghaxv $31335 ,ffflfiifé_§i33;EG"§«¥'i'i3,g $:3:';«:a:*€: 323$ it is Wiihiiz gix: monéhs 3336 '&é:'7:>::i'€ £3? six merzzha EEESEES sag": bs €X5£€fi§€(3 by fu§::4E;$r"".3V§X m§r:'{§3S by £239, Gmer if {he i:'!3§f§§}"i§SSi€}E_3€f; Eizaéi Eimiég $E:€:Vm :«:;3pEy E22 $8 fa'; fii€:§.2%:Ei'£"€ :3?
" a§'}f§€§€S is; C&3ifE{?é3i°fi€ff€;§ 2:3 é=::"::2:i}Es:5E 2232226? gab :8¢':T',.{.'€§Qf} {3} s:3f .4 Ssstéan 3&5 @231': zmdaz" $123.31 s.€<::*é%::}:: {4} (2? 38:1: éééi in 535; €21? asgz s~;€--%i:»:<?ci {§:}{::2n':{t%:§§ée f:E§"{'? <7::}:";<:€?€:{:<%5i éiézis §}§€}'%:'§S§€}Z} £2123}; éézzgzbétés 22 pe;r's«3<fm E153 sacéi Eb: iiféigé}? 121" 'égiés dG<:2,:::1<:-Ems: ihai; 3:0 time Eimii; is s§ip:,2Ez:i€e€ZEa':f:2*«;:§";;;3§ éheérsféréé 22 §<.>rs«::>n Eaying gtiairn to {i;<><::1i:fi'€::§;:~§ "z:§é1;}§1'<:=€i'~¢ 366%: r§t:,1;'r3 0:" CiG€fuf1"1ff:F}{S jL1s.?»b::é<::2:VL::§e a 'pe:*§<)é;%-.2;f"EA2 menths has expiraci 6 Sri Ray': Raj, that the pmcesds Q5 3. Bang the pmceeds ef 331% cf Contfabafid are Qihemn?s€ Eiabis fer of {he Cugtsms Act net the Eiabfiity but aiso ggfiéisijaténg 5:6 gaoég séizsd.
Sr: an Ehfi d€i3§SiCé§} 3? {I36 Bssfigié' Eiégiz C@.:; :f€, {E26 @2256 :35 Efiiéas Gzsmbsg' as f :;:s:§m,'}'Aq§*:g§::%ia reparéééfi it: 2&9 g2:aa;3 am: 43% {Egg "i»::§'s,;2bi*3";§?:_'~::}:;;39£, e:%vi%:2 avhiie gziaang 25: artist for Eifiing a:"zai§::i::"f:¢:r§'{, am? é€:§%e<%;:§;r2g' Bank a:':{:@1,:::%;, iihs Beihi {$92333 Eéass impassagi gs a::{::::<i:'fé::>::: 0:: €;Z?'§:= §2:3§§§i{)z:€§ is; féifr: 22:: zznsisriezking €91" :i{2:'s~2i:E:':%:::ag§§Q§: 3? his p:"€;g3€;":§<:%§; am? éhci-7 %::?%a:":":€<i Séngfié E3225 ;2z'{:%<:§§si3§j: iiazsiééé sami §i§1€f§'§E? :73 :15} neéci €23: i§E{€§'f<%:"€3£3{'t€? 2:3 wzfi: agégzsrafa 332:3 $5 is Grziy dais? Ezzxiijgz €31": §E'§€?? pair": €32?' {E157 :2§T>p«:7%ii¢:«1:1€s; in ::{'_;2.:_; g§iV:?::g_§ €i~E't§;21fiS sf baaii a<::::c3Lz::€:3 £113: is e:t{:=m<<'3 Er; '"'2=s;3Ljy' impaainfgj Cone:iitie:>n zxgainsé {E16 r€m::§ningg"ar::QVL:f%"€/ 9:31 due E0 any default an ih€.~pa.ri'z,A "{lj: é% [:;vé§g§0:iéfié::fig, b ihfiffifbfé? uzfgrsrs far dismissai af"i:h€--.xa}r:"i a;pp€aEs.. " V' '?. Seciian 316 sf the Ctfieficmis reads as unéer:
119} $35-2:.uII,'.<°»'"= sift ',§3,'o"«::!"'*'53_S§" vflocuments and thizggs -im_, 1:? thé'v';:§Qp€:ir affiser has :'ea30f3_ t0;i':;éeEiev€ {hat an3:igo10:'ti's ans: Eiabie Ea CQ1flf1'éC ';i=fi§'E?é --.__L§I'f£§E?f "Ch:i7Sugféxiifi, he may seize suck:-v..gG:x§s:
' _ ~ V?Jh€?€ it is :26':
;g"::aVL?.tiéab1é:V any saith gesés, €336 prepw 9f§:'<é€5i<fziézj-§€:"v€ Gr: tins gzvner £3? éha _g@0d4$~ s':1:,C.:-rdér ':E1at he ghaii :10: §'€§I1'2GV€, §a.r{ 3/sI*i%E2.,__e;" €§?;h€E"ifif'§S€ deg} with Eihe gaség axcegejg :.>s:i%.EiV%i'i*ié prfiviaus '§3€§T£"E§SS}§Ofi 9:? $355 ci§§§:€:§"~«. _ 'V ' "_'j~.?E{:Z£--":} "$16 533:1:/:"a:i Gfivfifflffififif may, Arsgard :9 the §3«s::*:is%:abE<;~': 9:' Eaagiaréiesia ;:§2:'f::z§€ sf .2232}? gaaésg deprficiaéiezz in the §z*3E'£;':2i': 0}? 3:6: ggads with {E38 ;:>2:ss:::V§§€ :32" éima ' §:@§:3i;r2:§n€$ sf siaisagé Syfiiséiiié? 59:' iii/:6 0:"
.'é3;§':§; eéhsr :*€5:E§>:iigné, <:@:1s:*e;fe:"afé@:is§ by :3:3::'fé€a%,§€3:: is"; 3326: Gfféstzéaé Geizeéiéég sggiwiffg' aha gagzig er ('E353 g'G{2s:i;s wfzigés shag, as 5500:} as meg}? be 523:9? iis ::~;::%§,:e:1::'«:%t azzzdsr 313% sa:::':«:::§§(3:: 53; E26: ::f§:*V:':;;;%::e:>:--:§>/{E {>5 '£325: §}.i"{)}}{'[',I"' IS Gf§E¢:sf:z* in :«;:,:<:h mzmrae/3* 3:59 3326 Ceémrai $GV{?Z"I}§"Ii{?I:f Higzy, §r<>m time: {:0 *i:§m€: <,§;€:{:%§'::2iz§€t §:1f'{.€?f fsfiowéng {he g)r§;s::€ed:::':;: h€3"€:2'naff,:.¢:' SE36'/€,'§f§fE':{i.§ 7 35'?-LB} 's?'Jh€r<% any goods; be§n_g;""'g@s:;és"
spe<%£fied iilliifiii' Sub-»se:ct,is:1 {EA}, h:a:fieVbéé:n"'% T '"
seizéed by a proper C)ffiC€I" ands? .SL1bf} $€Cf.i:{}H {I}, ha shafl prepare ' $310317' ' goods Containing szzchdetafls. :'€Za,t§:2g"'Vi-£3 their descyiption, quality, 'q..:ian:§f,j,:é 'ma.r1¥;Q' nmnbers, C0un1:rjg* ' etgfrf Gfigiig a::;"d<::.£;h€r3 part§<:'ula.rs as ih«::~.._ 'p.:fope:' éfficér Consider reisvanf is fhé'=§§€?§i€ify fi>f :h€ géeds in any proceeding u1i:d5r :'ihi;3_.AC: 9;ri'd"ShaH make an app1'i::é';<ionA_ ?:Q~ Eaiiagzistrate for the §L:z"}z3C2s§ r:;f--~ ' ' -.
{3} Cfizftifyingg '<.C§:i'f€C§H§$S cf the i?:f1vefsa:;>:"y 530 1p1°€p;.:rj<:Ci; of
(b) 'T '£23:-.._ "prtssence Gf the
--§\zIag'%;stra:e'; jiéoiggrajéhs 9f such goads, "" ..g::;d "{%:éfii§}:%;::?:g phatographs a5 1 _ .:ft:;--"e:V:--~Qi*« ._ ' -
{it} " ._z'3~;i}_9w'i;ig draw §"€pi"€S€FE?:8;€§V€ A S8,ffi§31€.:SAA:O§S:€;C?i gaefis, in éhe pregfifisfi 'éE1é;-- Ex/i'ag'i'Ts3:;"a:€, ané {f€§"'{§f§,FiE"§§ {ha céiréésizzess of any ES: 0? S§E'1'1§§€8 sf ».{§ra:>J:';§§ """
_ Whérg aa appiécgiéon ES EE"§_3.{i€ _ " --._;ur:sf_5€:'_$;:§«se<:ti9n 538}, {he E'a§ag:'sL§a*:€ shali ' asv3.{3_G;.?aV$ may ha 3;Ei:}w {he apgiicaéianj {2} Whszé grzzgy g€}0{%:5 2:55 seizeé '*=,_z:a{Eg§:* §:.:b--~§E:::%.ia>:: {2} azzai 12:9 Ezsiécé 3?;/2 _ §'€S§€'{??{7 Ehfirsef £5 gévciiz zzafiér Ciaugéi {3} 85 s;;ze£::i§o:2 E24 zviihzpa 3%}: m<>::{h3 {>5 éhe: Séfiiriéiffi z}f1*,%1£a gfaads, the gsaéis gfnzfii ha r»:%f:in16é§ :9 {E23 p€::~'~;0:3 'fmrz: a>:/'h83§€: giassfissiam éfzey %V€:'€ Efiizfifédi E'm:r§ds%<;i i:%*s21i: 2336 ;:Vi'»:>1'€sa§& g3<5%:*§<>{i 0? six F€£{}?ii',hE% maijyz ea sgufficisrmi (Tf2F£L§S(~'i b*E'f§§}_§ sham}. ha? €?XIZ€%E1{§€f£§ by the {C::>r:2r:zi5$i<>:":€:'.__éf"._ §L§S§i:'33"},3S§ far 22 ;3§:ri<>{1 net: €x£:€é%di:§§'V"'$§§;._ :':2<:>r:i;hse l ' {3} "Phi? proper efiicer m21.y«s:%'§z€"'z:V:i3;i giscumenis or things Wh.f(;t'}'};----§11 f1is_..op§r;fQr:;~' 4 221213: be ussfui for, 9?, reléivgilrit, :0; :5/f:y:_ prscsefiding under this Aci ;
{4} The p€EFS{},?jT f15OfH whG:2:€_::"_c1:'3t0CEy aiiy doczzments are 36126;} s.:;1d<3r":~:~s,:_b~s€€§*gi0n {3} shali be sntified §s:V"fua._I_i':% C'3§)i€S Efiérévof" or {aka sxtraci fi1.€.f'i*}}f'I"{;:_1'I};V'§?3. Aiprsgence sf 3 sfficér ef c;:s€,9::1's3._ ' 'L 5' "
8 A sshgws {hat ifie siatutary 1: éxpressiy snabls an 2: bank a«::{:::;u:§€. éearneé Ceunse/'E E795? 3233 drawn our ai,t€::ti§n is sub4;Sét:{§Gr: [5:é}-- S€{:{iGfE iii} age? Sziémitg $13: ii is 3 Vséiigaégfgfi.a§"~-:;:%::::2r<3 :3? d@{:*:1m€::':;§ or Ehzézgsg amd 27:
'i;3_$§::;§€§§ ';éf'_vE3;21':f:E: ::;z::::::<}s;:I1;§, '§éf}::i=$: if is; érus: fzfihgai; {E123 €:§':a::bEiz:g' p@*a%:€r far Sfiézéiffi A {§GC1:§§13€?i"%§,$ 92:" §':"Ei§"§§?:$3 é3:%::'{::h, 13:: am" <}g}§r:§(2z:? zaziié .bfa 12$€%§3;2§ ikzrzg :*r:?:fEc%¥2%;23V'i: $19, 2223? §}r%::::2::%€t{£iz:g :;§:z(§{~%; ifiég Aaié: E3 &1%"2%§iE:§3§»fff 2,21/sgész" s:;L::§:> Se:::é<>:3{E3} :3? Séstcrgiszz iii'? :3? {he AC: }}§'i§EE(:'i fasésé if shgxilci E8 showy: is be Efk EVSEE whika fhfii qzzésliifin whmihsr {he ;j:*Q{§é'<%.<i§ bank azitscumi {tan bfi? canfigcated '§?§7§'1{,'h'i'fu';=.i;V3€ "SCiT??€__5?. sub S€<:r:ic:r:{3) «:3? Secticm assumed to $6 $0 far U15§}LZ_§"pQS€5x€3§€*Xal;f§fi§:1'1§.fV,Qf*'Eh€St3. ' appeals and we pressed :<>1é::x;ézni:g'::6 it/E:-:f%_n":€1f?:ts sf éhfi (33,863 M. LeaVr::e_§j¥.--}§i::4g1€;A' indicated that the find that geizure €V€T1 if Wa:3.J§'::,'s':%.. éneluéing atiiachmant C2? £33 which F€SpGfid€f2f€S have c0I3{iii€:€id..§:.?f:f/6:'; Eégizee much :0 be és/=:s£r€§ as 3. ._'Shfliif€33.iS{3z}T";Qf§CA€%?;3§'fid€§' Seeiiozé £24 £3? E1316 ACE, is ye? _§%'jL*' £36' £$fs«:.;€z;?§ Efgaiii ami 31231888 81 $3131? atazzgs :3<:>§Ei«::€ is iséigfié Sz:%€:{i@n £252 :3? ihe ACE, fi'§€E"€ :3 :30 :"§i2€S§:§G :'T?_§T,'i:{' any fi':ii§%" Eéahéiféjg bsiifig fifiiarménaé unéééy A :':7§1€:.,.§';;:{?. :24}? sC§§e fer Eta/*}7:?§:éf any pszzgiéja :25}? 53%;: E531' % .. §>;a.$:9:';Qgf;' an ;>r<§:ir 3%}? <7az:§E3<:aé2E{:::":. E29 5:: E329 _§:siEg.;":11€:3i: <2? E3332: Couré: E:h<:% §:r<>Ce§%{%§:<2g;*:'§ 2°.;"1§i:i2::€i§ vs;3::% afiisz" E;1§:»s€: :3? 4 jJ'€?EiI';'5 223:3 §%2{--::*t3.%%;_§€ zhs Deéhii Sigh €{>z/:3: {:har21€:':€r:'s6{i if 213 :10? "§::%a::::i}::.T.V'f§{§€ attachment and ':iher::%fe:':% giizz->ci<%(i lifiing of 331 bank acccszznis. om}; €§§'ff€:7T€iHC'f3 in fi: <: vp1*€:'s€i.=t sasrs is iha: {E16 bank a<:::0un€;<,~: ai--*$zund.€_:f ::*:f:5:éii:;%:{;%:":'i:..L for about info yesars, but vv;%f_.ii0.;:t issezgsscf Show' Cauga naiice uncfer Section p€r:'c>«:§ $5 izrsaciion is fer §ou:' <§«:% is one of {£16 mannezi -_- authsriiy has sxercised 'E233 inaction for two ye:a:*s issuing Show 5331156 szoéééevifiriééér 9? {ha AC: whésh in our Gpinian is "'3:3' :;:%;r€gs@EiabE€% as: 0:: $526 part: 9;? "£118 ._V33:i};:_{';ri?:§gi and if Esfiiiifair {G 836% <:<>:{:€:€:*ne::Ii pergeng 333$:
§;a3{_f::sé:E.:€5§Mé:f: ;.:*%:}:'i:'a2"§,7 U36 9? éh€ ava.§Ee:~;E3E€ §C%§'*;7€3EI in {he §_fiSfE;,§§ 321636 is HQ €«e§:::z:r€ 92" 3:32;? gagds iT§3§§€3 féiéf <:o§2f§..:s{i'a%:i0:2 grad 32 3:292': 3 $§::z2:;U;r§en <:<:3":£ii::z;2*:%.§@:: 95 A ":5;i::,'a;{:A§,i{:n€22§ ef baaéi i:7%€'€8§.Ei2'§ £3 :39: 32:; 32% i3€¥m::7fiV€»§ by 1 E43 W in ? FE izzksizmisézéssajganzzz, §:s%22rin€%<;E C<>:V:::S§%E f<:»:* iihii? ;2§3ps-*:§E2mi'i s32,?;b;'§:ii::ée: {E12131 aézféégz if #2: that <::;~2é3<:%-._0§° Eh? {3;«3;}22:"€:§::~€%{;i,§ it may 23:1:/mci; 2: (imij; Eizibéiiiy 2233 penaiéy «:'T:&E3 be imperjsed in 3:26}: 2: situ21t~é.'Q%:,E:>1}:f'¥;?s?E"i§:r:W éhs rc3spond€n€:~; ham? moi iSSi;1'€i{§.4Sh"G1E7_..§(8;§2_Sfi"fi§ffi3€ after éziquizy azzd investigaiion 'i'Z:>:*"»:i_i§i§:rm §:3i:'1g? '3X§.;5i:';:.€T {iii urxisr vaIL:aI::'0n and <:or:'*=<s;3;:s>ndi:ég...{i2g.€:j§}_: ii'g:bi§§i}', 'W5? find no jufiificaéion in k€€p'i'f};g :Z*2é"fiasnk a{:"C0'5;méi fmzisn €62" €336 :3E'fl{){i1fi'{ in baiazégié iii-:.:.:-::*éi:*:;.&:i1:¥A:isit3"'"_aitachm€nt. 146 in éhaf: ever: {he Conditiani by the Esarimsd §;'Li2{1"£i§}'§€€ 31" S€CLE§"§i}' is 339: E323: €'€f€7}Y} 36:61" gasaing 05 33:6 ;:§r:i€3' by V€E3.:%: ieégzneezé ffiingkft fizsdgét 9:: E3¢C%9,2€}E@ ;.§1v=E:'j§i:'Sp<:%':'::i%5§?E_S bavsé ms: iggazaé any s:§:::2w itaziéséi EEGEECE ._<t'é;r{im*:2s%;3;m::{;% W€"E§{Tf3E £33521/zriy gasg ezgamsi E56 _ z*5$§E}:;x:i?$:i%,;§, _?E2€§*é:§{.2:"<%; V2.76 ;:V§:ls:_>v.r §°§2iE?S€? 2:;3§:}€%27:E$ and :§1?r{~%€?,: fi;%:é:> .. ;%i::%.:é§8:1&i2:1%is; :23 'E/EH': .2:§::z:<:§:r:2a:%:z':: 52%' éagzk a{:%::?:">:.:m';
Want {it f0§°é.3?m:'ifh, B': i;CF:<% (T:i:'(f'L§§§:E%E2i¥}{?€if% ¥J€? ff§ii'€:{i'{, §3:;::'i:i€::$ is $6232" t/hair E'€fS§}€?i{'§f,§V€ stegéis, EFEQ if ..
vnwmmw.m».w.mW...w.mW..... . .,