Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd vs Chandrappa on 22 June, 2011
Equivalent citations: 2011 AAC 3030 (KAR), 2011 (4) AIR KANT HCR 251 (2011) 4 KCCR 370, (2011) 4 KCCR 370
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
{J}
2. MANJ Ui.A.
I} ,5' O C.f"1.E§NE§R£':}7'PA,
i'*~§G'£7'v" AC} ESE} ABOUT' :22 '%"§§!XE9€S.
3' VE?=2?\é'E{E§'£"{€S}%,
3/C: CEA'IusKNI}E%:APE3z .
wax}; AGEJI} Azsam' :3 %z":~:_,s%..E%;.ia
SINCE MWOR R§::;>':":} :3"? ms GUAR.E}.L:§?'€.
E-LzaL,E:.sH '§'~§;'a.Ef<Z2'L 3,30 NGQE"~?."::':*1 NA£.E{.A;' ~ . , _, _ -V ,
waxy AG-El} ,!»'s.£i%0'U'{' 35% '?'f'EARS, _£§G}{.E{$j'LiE,,.-73?RES'?
ALL E2/O H£s8;x.§A»:AT:,;.,.: '%£ELE'_AGE<3, " .
§:3.HADRA\fA'Ij'I~iI TQK '
4. %££§LE<3SE*iA *
S/0 BASAVARAJEWPA, _
MAJGR, OCC: £)RIVE.'.R OF__'i'E§ACTE*O§€ ~
R,/C': G-UNJUGANOQR " * - 1 '
5. SM''{'. £{U£}RAMMA., - «V
W1/O LA_'E"EE~£z=;F~§{§?s/E;'1;E?§32*a. ram&':>§é, A '
SWNER GE? 'E'R£.£CTFGi'*${__-.'_ ~ '
RXO C;:;JNJz;G;§N<;;.€3.§::"'
A " mE?;.E€ZSPO£\IDEZI'~3'?S
{BY $31533:}::S:~§':'aégss;::>v§1;.';af:»<;:_, Ex-"OR £2: ,2 M2} 4.;
{aw SR1: SE;§3§§A;«3xsi«i;~.»a::>x;_;;~-§%"fr;R R33}
{R3 MENQI2 ::<»z;.._r2;s;..p~T§;a, By .';:~§.V.E-fi'~._GI;}'AR£)§AN 5:4}
'_ '§*§-12:3; lg z:*:::%:g';»..;:;.;§ :_:?3(3;; 0:? Mv AC? A«:";za::\::§'§.'
':a_'§»;:a: J'§;T§}€§§%«iE§'i"~§"E' gm; A.%?¥AR§} .m.'§*:s;>: E *3. 29.239? PASSES
2:2: Ii»?iT\?¥.'f'f, :%<;'&:31?;'2@@2€':>N '?"HE: mag: 03:' 3%:--3:1; 53%., JE;TBGEii
{SE5max.E3.;A:3;:2:";:?:;@m§,~'Magi: E3§:"§AE,}§{£§'v'A'E'E?'EEg :%3%:';%E%E}§?€G
A {:€2rxg?:22>_s:::=§€;%£c:';"§'a;%:'\§--: éfziz? R3323, §..3,€}GQ;'~» :m':§;2:4:~$? 53;?' 6% §~3'..{»*a
":'*"E%€f}E'v.§ 'E'§"%;'§$_§}57{E'E§ §>i:"T_a*:':-'§':{>:*~; "§'*;:,L ;?:z<:;mS;a':':<>N.
V
»r2:T
Q. HE: 23.1% reiiezi an 11.1%: m.:'.3i'm" vehiétéai defi.m"i::§<m_..__
uncier S€:(:*{ic:z:'2. 2 (28) w}_1i.c:%1 :":*zea..:1$ {f::'z.g; r:'2€c.*?1r:z.rzi::r5£:{.fg;. "'--
prapeiéed g:z2i2icZ.e adczpiied jar use uparxa. m{3;d.s; z2,;='§';é{§jw3;*"
paswer qf propxfisforz is z'ra;1sr72z":"f,'ed ' E'?:ei2€3'i9 '_,f'%';>.:?_"i"v gm
exi.em{;',Z and ir::em;aZ. ssource {Mei i:zé%€;::i$és'~ ::f':€;z:;Sé:f;' :5
zziftictft :2 body has Féfli. 1389:': £:1i.f;ra:::.ed afid Fa im V2535.'
daes 2205:' £m:?Za:.d9 (1, vehicle r::r1r1i:'1g"'=:;j:zo:2 fz;=ai5d: :'€I£' §5; $3' ii'
vehzlcie 53;" a Space {ype adap:ed%fbg*----::é:é--Cfzégg in §::'j7E2c:Z'»:'irg;
or in any other encioseci premi3'es #3:" £12,' ;>é?1i§3§{é*?;.»a.piz1g £933
{titan faur uéheeis gfififfred z:ji'£'?:,= cfipgiétiigg 0f :19:
excreedirig £:1:erT2€;;;;'¥;ug é;:?;§_bfiC?'v{?§{§§f"£E"§'"§2'?'?;E§E.I'»f§f3~Sa ,
E8. i;::.»;'§fi:V'1*1€:»:'dV§§£"§11ié.f%§§iV of §§':0§{}§' ve.E2i§:}e
emci gig-.=fTi3*2£fz:££>v§:._&<:%:E.;?<§E:.i{:i.:s§V";2:£:3_{i.§t:§§%;:i§; iihaé: i;2"am5:):' E33; §%1s£:Ef
d€)€S Emil '§:>€:=<:<.>:fiz/?:_< §§;aVhi<:§e 115}? Si} it-:3z1SU*m":£,<:c§.
is ;ta§'*:f°:§; §c:.§i§%* §é21;%s3%;i "=';_,§5éff:* :3i',§'%;:3r €;E":21§f; 32%;': zirisrer, 'E':'a::£;<}r
a2;1:V',3£_:e":.<E'Ef"::':§iV' i;:i<:§% i."§':5;i'I§:§f E§V:%§fki3':v'n@:€~; 2: §§1{}i'.{}§' %ff;':§§§{'.';§;€ wE3§<:i.1 ES
{:a§.:%a:<.:§3fEr1?% :";:?i'.p:.;§E%:*;g;. ..":_';:*a§E€::". Eva? :"s3:Eiié»E:£i aim; Ei?.;§%_§:2.€§,;§::1<;%';§E:
as. §?%§§;&§ ' .
2 I.
<::sf' fhé?' £'}ivi:~:«;.i<3if: Bersgih. ix': ?v'IFfi 125E}'>'?,/'Z006 €i21'£:€*.d 25""
M21}; 201%,. an.e:i $ub:'r1iit:<'3<:i i',h211: thgis Ce:m1:*i: <é<3n$ick:r'i:1g*""2
the pcéini, wh€E,I:*:.err §§"i.f_-'i §I"ESf.,iE"{"fi." E33 1%aE:t§.e {<3 $21E:.i§~;:f§" €.§.3;;é;j?u
<:{:=n'1pe:1&'s21t:i.<):'1 £0 i,.I:':e :?§ai:'§1a:1'£. an 21<::éa>'i,?::'i.§:.'e:>E"*'_¢:i<:j.23.1fEig-V3):?
iz'1j1::"Et::s; ii} i:.h€+ p<;é;"s's0I': ':.r'aV<:=Eir1g an n'1:.1{§:'§§:1;3,_r{i {>5 ELEf,21£)%§:()f, "
hag; heici that f;;he palicy in
tm£:.i,0r which has get; Qniy ;:,:'1'.=§ sgcaf,i:1g!jvL.:{f;§§a§:ityt{xr%'1éc%':v:is;
pr<>V1?ded for the dr§V<3~r {if $5.-'wards
Whtsra {he enggimz isg. i:": reapeci:
2:}? fihs: driven £.};i='é" Q§3ii1€§ that éhe
'i":"'§bur1:g1E W233" iiabifiity 9:': the
in$1,2:*a:"2<te €{}f§Ti§&E.I'1y,A - V
E§.,._%.'A§;=:?'eg2:i*d§; A -:19 zihéi use Gf i:h:::=: ag.:'i{:u.EE.2z:'e1.§
:re%:ici€::. "€.-.?:"¢;%,(:*f:.{3§'"«.§€}'fi'iY;1'E3Sp{}r%: pL,::*p{}sse is 9.. {§i€f£:--}.'£" vi<3§a'£.:?e"§1.
$1: i;hi$' §%5;§_;;é:r<? f €'3f§i{f€3; 23'3"; €ih€:': <::":'r:":p§a§:f:a33§: 1-¥§'1€} is 2:3":
;géy€':&r§%:.::€;<§s§..it; 5::%:<;% imtiziezzéi. E2213 5:-"£§'L21'§',€:%{§ tézai, figs: arééhiitiizé
c "*s,r2«::e*9;:-;. :<}:':n §§'§?Ef{';° £§,E1{§ ssabm§i:i<':{§ Ehéié. SW33"; in <?:2:siz <3? higfiézig
1'?
Tf'z0z;.gh it is C: motor veE'1ia:?ie:> but i:'f':e
c?0z'zsi?'L:c{i0r'z Qf st: z1'm{:t'0r 62085; 320:' providse (my
§')I"€}¥)§SZ}3R_fi:>?' ::*<:1,rr'ying a pCiSS€§'Z_Q'€?" Ofhéf' E'.'}':{m
the: driver. Tractor by i'£'S(3§;'" {ii}:-as riot: E2e<?az'3';{:;"""'
the émrfzsporz z;%e:>?1zic?£e :.:;,*-z'£.hou£ £'}'ze :'raiZe.'r:
£9' '£'r21.:Eer E12155 2:150 b@&t1'1,~<:ie.fi:1eL*§A :::ir1€§<;%:iSijrvxjiicrérz
2 Ciaussr: 46 'G'JI'}i{.'h reads 21:; fi3.11o\¥$'ViL'
If is a light rnfzéiésr iJe.ié'}1{§?fé*~.§3é$s 'CiQfi!1é?d
LHICZEI" Secriion :2 Clause .i33 E wEiz';;fi%.__.aEsé.fe{zds
as :,.::";::ier;
'"Z'?1£2 ;é:=a3_.S€fig'ér »a§e?f1--é;?Ee,._ Erczrzspari
zxsfzécia ---- E'}"fi§?§Gf;§::_. €'h;e3----v.....s:£2?:i{t£e£ by
z:F1e:rL§g<§E.zJe%5. V'2T':'€<::t¢ ' e;§a?'e;:§0*§. __b=e* faszgg zramparzisan
wézh {"3132ifar"zS;;::c§*E:. 'v¢?*s--i§£é£f G-gods; T?*a;r:spo:*i
::ef2€;:.Z£i :rz?§%zs~:p %:;:§'VC;€§<§';v?a. "J%'ra{?§'0z* is; {:0z:s;Em{:£:ed
{iflfi'3¥?E'EQ;§"£.;«§v{§CZ1§'€C5..__€}F"éE§;; pmzsiding {he a>:"zg€.ne
z2_V:(::i%r:;;-e?::§*"af2sj'zd if d0€s.~: 330$ pmvide am; SGCEE
Q?'-V.§2, p:"{;z:z'si0s'?; E8 §.{£§C€'3 {2;s'%g; Qiizer
p€£§;{m$.. . h L' A
5"; §;z'€z,<?z"::;*=:';' "3"?':.:3 ;fl§§i'.E. is; is": §'s3;<; ed 0 '$2.5-2 §%:'zs*i.§%;s:?
V L N V' .3'
1.8 20, "§'Ef:€: m<}i,{)§* vehi<":1::-E Ea %3:»3§.:eci 0:1 E¥:.:s'~; sii:.§;:in§§ <:21pa{:i£.y.3 m.z1>::imum '§i-"€§§_,_§§1§. ef;<*..,. me i:'1s;ur:%:' is:-s2:€:sje *-- p<}_1£{:}g* b££Si3{i an 'i.h<: :.1ai.1;;r&: 221..::1{i cE.21_s~:.§3 $2?" {$162 '2n:=:eh_:zZzjfE.<«*;'<." "
the v€;%E1i<:3;£;=: §'1a.s:; -:::2':I§g zirixrmgg ssezzjé'. zmci ma» otifga"
Thssr §I}SiEI°€'I' {E(}'J'f31" {E29, rissii 01' zizfiver Eiiiexazisw in t':ra;:'1s-:p::«}:"i', gczmds or p21:s53e%11g;€:r a1.ié0= .1_::h~s:~_ cmzered basard {H} the {fI&1SS3'ié}.;§}d :1éifl;:§{éj'.(£x;\i:"?'§._%'1e 'i'j'€%}V':1§(:}A{tfi , if éhera is :10 pr<>vi;':si<::2n GE' the %;.:*a:::t<>r 1?'£.seif ia 11§a§_":§§_-. any ethr l3€;;°s<>n {'}i§"'.i€I' &,'*_..ii'€3V'.' ':.<ff.','c"':"§"'}{':€)'{. izzszzre hi8 :;"§s%;.. I}iv:i$vi<>n "iE?r§i»:=fa{:§1.7' *5:-1.;" '»..§A£3,'§:;_i:"»s .C%:)m"? Er: iciétmiczzl {iiF{:u¥I1SL';"iE}{fi€'§'€§3Z'§"C{§ i.: §s§'V21'b::}}$%i:<.i"§"; IVIFQ §_258"?f2®fi5 at gparzz "£8 wE":i.{éh :'£34é§;r:is zzfizijédezi';
" 'We E1339 peEi.£é;ed {E18 paiiity é$.§;L:ed. Egg; L' 3:11;? "5};.;:é;;:%:;?E£::?M=:iT,' '='§"'§':§2 z2p;:>£2iE.{2:1£:' Ezast é"f{}§E€~?{?€€?Ci 5; $;'3g:?"a+{3f" :3? :.;r'z¢:£€%" 553%? §7i€?{2§,, Eségizf §ia§32'§.i:;§; £Q:.§}'g:.r:i3*:~: €':'§%p§0§,z€;>e /' 5£r§.:2e'::: ;%zi:;*2£§.£z3a:£ig;; E5. is '\">§?;
20 H€i'fi{TtEx i:1}1.::.ry 0:' {§€;1i.§1 (Ef :a3'u{:h persmx {?:az1m)t. be Said to haxrté beésn C{)V€:"€d under" the s3t.21t::1%,{}':"y' pzziicéy €i}'{jh€?'§'K'£iE§€;'fi .,
22. Ass r§%g21rd$ 11:0 fhszér <:ie;%<:e;?:-,:<_;:;%-:i b€?£.'.{}I}'}€E% 33$": ..§3a%f_1:3,«-r L' 011 a<:<:<:m':i: :3? {£16 iz'1ju:"ie$ §9;h<;=. ~"§?;1§5;:€i£1.i1'1i%'£§; V§2?:._f'§.j.<:*::"=}éé}:.§:v.i3€:H fm::'1 the muci guard, 23 Learnezd gzcxzznsefi' VV§€§§I:§_i_{:nd thai.
diiceagfid WES 5$i§L{',;ii?"£'§«,:;');'«lQ'?'§ nggdgb €631}. éoxvsrz amd aftfir she wemi on hat' am? She traveiigag. '§"h<-3 {:<}1'z?::e§§E':§<m iE92':ai;'!s{>;§£q €:€;mf:3e:§ is devoid 0f rxaeriisa as-3:. 1131:: 'is§7'::;:§'1E: V§{'£.:'t.g>:r she a§.:gh'{:£:::i fmm the f::'fai<fi.::a:f {ET ' ixgizgaéaz zzavéig?' mm}. :.E1.{; i::ra<:§:{>'§: {E19 %.:'a::i.{>r ciazzmé-2 ;:_;i'}&' ».'§;§:§1?: " E"15'::;f.§~ E1z":'i.i:*1:* {éir<:un1$§:am?:e 8.§"§€§ "::he5 E%'%':Tz'§é.%:1e::é:f="«.{>32 V__§(:a:f;<:¥":*{i {iisgz,:E:;sc maxi. s::§1€: vi-¥e?:.$ $iE:E,i:2g: {rm féfrze "§%:€;::g£."g,;S1;T;::"{§ {>5 thss é,m<:%'.<:=2' =.:§:"E2§.-3;': ihe: :§_'z~z<:E',m"f mgvesi fihsé "p23§a;§;£§§%_%e:'§.s¢2:*a? §,§{:::£: %E.:'€:°,? iihzé €§E'ii»"'§fI° riéaimgéi €326 ':§'.2§£:'£.{::: 23§'i'.€i"' I34 Rss§2g258/'W per mG:1'£.h, ac7:<:1'€i:ém' is of {he year 200}. Consid€5rr'i.:1g" the C§I"{3L1E"£"§E«Z21.IE{3€f§ 22..mii 21E§s<> :::<f)::$i{,i2%7sfi1':g;; =?{:h€;_ E§21bi§1't:j,J fixing :33 the mxm.<:>.r, E fimti reas§{'>:;2z't§i€;2 L"
<:<:>:11pe::2s8.£.i:3:1 has been §;?£V.fE1!'Ci€3€§ by ifiisi A<:c:0rCii:";gi}; appawzi filed by the?T.<:Iz:ima.mf~..ah-;e:.:'.>§.:.g§:1{§s "
dismifised' Amaum'. in depasit b:i?' 'i"Ea3f§'fl*E-3i"£&:§f¢.";'§';¥iVi':v *2:._'ppe§Ea1'nt:~ énsuzreru H GH 2: "