Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 2, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

State Of Karnataka vs Sayyad Basha on 2 March, 2010

Bench: Manjula Chellur, B.Sreenivase Gowda

5%

 Simd§i§1n0@r§ §{§iQf§f1§£E" 1f"¥iSi'ric:?;. . 
 .V "§§£gy ":'T§ri,.:'§z%.p%'1i3g$:z&aSiédaypa, Afivzmaig

x-am:

EN 'E'E§'§L EEG-E-E {IOURT {I}? §{ART*€A.'E'AE{A
€§R€'§j"§.T BENCH A'? GU§.,B,:%.RGA

ij),:%'i'E';E} *§*:--§s firifi 2m §}A":' SF MARC}? 2A;.{f:f:';::éj  . K

?'RESE:"~§'E.'

';E_'E4£E §~§GE\?'B§E MRSJUSTICE ?~;éA:€§'U;ATT€::&E:;;;LV%v:R " _ 

A W
'§'Er£E;1 §i§1\E*BL.E E;'vER.&US'_§'ECEuE;'§:..§*£~%§":fiE\ii'»,55§S?f§<;: €;7e;;>if«;§}A
cE2;L,;:;__§@.  ;:m1?5«.%   A 'X

§Ei'§"WEE1\3:

States céf    
Through Ciificis_'Enép£2_;t{{Hj~:--., _ 

Qf Poficg',V_Si:'1d.l";--:2:3§:(}r.H  "  APPELLANT

{By Sfiif};£??u:3gg;;*é7d.1?r@;'~«§e$aigH;5.ddI.SPP}
AME}:   '   n
Sa:§;"':g?£3.§ Ba?s:'s'§f:2::,3V€} °_y.:€:A.':i:sV '

3_,f'0,?E%33'S&1iD:," RfG,E1ad7rs:§éif§€


 

  fer Sri.C.L.§§@:1§aiagi§ fiéfimcaia}

 " ._f'§"E:i5§'~:f:_?::%:'§:i2i§ apgiézai  fiigsé under $<':€:E:£(>':': ;'§'?'8{E}

a'néi__{3} Sf is gyaxfi. Esau.-*:-:2 is {figs an zzypézzzi 2:g§;3.iI1:~=;€

  . 3.233 _§i;:d§;--::1é§:'1i?;'. Eiéiti-352 2.13.2905 £12 $5c.:~:a« :a:2{:;§3 an age

";'.,':ik3 <3? f.i6:§§1-P0,. "Fags? 'E'mcE«: C{}LEZ'§~.E§§ §{a.§chu.r, 2:<:::;ui*E.'s.§:r1gf



 

R3

mi-3 ?§L';'3E}{}§1{§E3§1'§Lma.{i'{1'%,ES€€§ §<>:* {ha :>ffs>.:'3::e pa2;:_§$h23;b.E:-'é
é§fl€i{;'%E" $€*{f§,i{)E'E; 302 ai" EPC, ' 

 

JUDGMEf}"»_§.__

'Fh.§$ zipgseafi E3 flied; asS2iiE§r§g;:}§;iéT{i:*cEé'r _é£--'.:;r:.€

Cmzriz. :1": S,C'Na:>. E20/G3. L

2, The 2"z:::{::.;.s€§ iii  .é$p;3.é:aE §had $0
{ass itharge fax'  Sectmrzs
«Q83 and 382    husband Gf
deceased   he? ta Cmelty
during  '21 ';*:'§i&:':'i:1 'ah atmmpi ta Commit her

{EE'13%.f§€3}'.'"' &05'uz€5._E':;V5:*;.i_" €»2?§t'i'1, §_«g:er0&serié;% amd 542% he}: abfiaze in

 the i.ni§€:fi;-*£:':1in§'E1--§g§§}f;§_§}f° 18'-3"; anfi 193% Ma}? 2@@§3,

 .:3.~._"~fas:t:{f'<3:fd§n§§ Ea 'éhés §3'§°0Se<":a:?:1?{}2':, the a§<:u$6::§;

213$":§€<::iA21;;Eé:::§i:?"2v€r1*'e nzzzrréed f§V€'i years gsriar is the

 ;_aE3e§§€%€§..if;::;%§dé2n%: and '§'.hi3'§? dié §1<:=i; ha},-'§'. §s~§$1s;€s§ 923.1: 0? the
'~é_;i«-::é:EV§é2:'2::k. 'E'h<3L1gE:"; i'.E:.::§; .Ei2-":;*:£§ ?:azg:::pi§}; 1%? same 'éérrzix Ehé?

"*... ".22;{:{?:y:$%:%::i :§%_2:ri,é3:€i §.1§~i'.:°@a€§11g the :§§3+:':»i:%a$eci as E"i€3.' was

'E'§"2i3 akpgezai C£}3::';JZI:g§ 2122?: {Gr lrzaarigégg  
  " §¥L& CIiE£.LE'R J Qieiivereai the §_3::r;.}'i%;*6.z4.r§m;;;:j;:'>--A 1 ~



    z

&§§d§<:%;'.€{§ 11:2 23.i<%<:eE":.<_'>'§ :'»m{:§.  hzzzi ta faxes: p"a};:<s§.<:z:i zmé

m.s3n'£;a.§ %;,<>:"'?{ur{-3 at his %2a;'1&s;. 3%: was; i:13é:s%:§.§'2gg '£:{>;;vé{:i~:§:T'%_2;
Saaéenci wife as-3 i;:1f@§m€(§ hjg the {§e<:€5=2':s€:{§ €19 hfiffii kiA€.E';f};a;:€§v ~
kin durfi_;(:gg E1:-3:' °<ais;ifE.s is {he p2:'rené:a;E_4h0z'i5s:§§ *7§'3::é'  V

332$ Kin iherc=::f<}:§°€: {:<;::2**~;r<3:ze~:'E §21.n{7:h':3.3:g%fih" ;1§:éi:'-;:{§>:Iis;§:c§ ::E:é i

aéiitused to behaz-*6 §3Y{}p€§'§§}.'*»:t E7{€ §ii,i.__ "jhie;
affitude, 'E'hz3:°ef0r§-fig fi:h§; d:ag:Vé§27s..V«;~f ei:};":'E'V'£'c::j 21'b:é':::.A (32:16 year
stayeai with $16? §a:"':gi"§i'.S;V    Elififilfisfifig
AC€3{T:§'§iI1§.§ 'ta  before {he
incident 21:35   was held in the
pres€n»V§é:;W{::if"' and t,§'}€r€:af'£.er, the
d€€€a$e;:::7' J9:aVs'  matrimsnial hams after

;i€£VVY§S_i1.':;'éik1',EX€'.V zz;€'i§:::zVS'a-fl "-21:16 he ag;}3"ei>:ing§ €10 leak af'{;§:r hey

  an E§.5.2GG3§ PW.l.., ithe eidatr

'._br{:ih::\r éwi" {he d€i'C€££S€f€§ Ri'£',%3i'»:'€€§ 2: §E":{>§1e caii fmm

VV§%3';E%;*,'§§#€'2::£§;:,2;$e:?§, iaimdisrii of a<'::":u;%e{i Eiéfiflléifiiig the:

  V' a<§mi5~;5.~si{%§": af £1318 giefieaisged Ea §":<3sp§':.21'§ wiih §3¥.Ei'E1S at 'zhér



:3;

§"Ef:'iIi£§§%3 Q15 i'}'1:i'% a::{t::2£2~s§=,{%, }<L£'i.§':: and Rig': 9:? i:h€% {£§§{3§f5c'§iE§€f{§z
came: ii} Sir:{ih:3_:'1<><}:* mad an iihe ;:{§'a7§s;;s3 sf éjzéé d<§::j§_,£§r$,

Shézt wszsg shif§.<-:-'£1 U; Vijazjgezzzagzzx' E§':s::f¥.i*(.n€:.€3 of _'f%gi§'é<ti;i'a::;fl

¥§Ci€3I1€E<'3., Baliazfys ?:'i0r 'ii: .<_=;h§fi:£ng {he 
S§:i:dh_a:m><}r :10 B<:=:%1a:":g: ai "the iE'1&'si.ai'}€;f{3  
Ofi'i<:<:'r, the p<>Ei<::e «::a_r;:::: and re<:{§ 1'E§€{§ «fghe 
the d.eC€as;<~3&, Whieéh waa '::°e.2:i<id  

ti'1e:* Ema": Camn. The $ame"is"--ai: EX;P'Z?, V ;3:;f_té:2i "£;h:f6€§ GI' -, L

'f0zz':" dayg, gm: dgieti an 22,5.2G'®:;57;1€; BéE":~;-1,_:§§r; -V-jifiiiying the
caurse Gf i:1ves€iga%io1i{_,_'"rtha  iandgiioéfi 017 the

accmsaé a'fidj5»_Vde1€:éas£:d" m?er€§ e':';quir€d and {heir
s§2:mmé:;m.s' are"'.V:Ee§f(ar{is:;j?';*-- ' "The p6:r:?~;c=ns.3 whiz: hfifid

pan;iha§ra'i;.E13*sm::*£;': "2:E:~3€> "fenguirstci 1"€3{tOE'd§fi§§ Siiaiemerjgtsg.

PerSQ:"::':«; .WhG we15*e':".:1°wé::*€ 35 ihe burn §':2j2;:r§<3s:e s;:,:&;'€ai§1<:é

V' <E:>y aéaé-': Qié-aiittsva-seé xz.;?%e*:'<:'::E80 Sxafiiiiififi. The {§{}(',"E.G3" 0p:i:r1€--:$

 {E131-Vthe;"a.ié:a2f:.ih.__s§;;>:§3 due :10 s3€p§;§<:e*:a::2ia as a 3;°<2suB; if

?"5$?i;._::}§"'§i,:':i=;:«g;§~,;."E328 §}{}§§(f€' 3f'é.:3:r <:r:;'rr:§§€"émg; Em-*esi,i§g;:ii§m

E15:/:i "'---- £i{7TE.i1€:3E§' filészé {thaxgfir i%f§.'1{3€§, {arr {}f§E%::€:€&; améier

 emai 332 E93 Bcifgrs {E263 E§'i:~,1.§ Cifiééfi, Er:





 

'fl

ail E)§"i€ p§'<}5sa<'tui.§.£>:': axzmzirméi Z21 '%}£"i§LE'}{':E§Si?i%$§ reéiiefii apex}

9 d<}{:t1z:":£::1{;.s and 4 mzzigrigzi <3§3_;T€:tE;s;. P:}rt,§:}':';.;~s"§0f

eiridemére of }i3.W. 3. wag mzaxked 21$ Exslfl 2-:::3;:_i;"E}2}.f_* 
lzzzmzésci ':,§§z~:§. Judge i.h{:rz.1gh ac<:€§t.e§§ £?:':1.As"'@x%:i§Ee*r:§:*:t:A <35' 

P.W.E and ot:'if":e':' Wi*::1e8s_~s<:ss sq} far as n::::1--%:.2:'§=.:ér;§i"-phg§g.§g2a;§  A

C£'ii€}."?{,jg meisd {mi 110 the d:':€;;as§'2:s_V_§f,€d; ;i:i"V:f;'2',¥;€a' 
acczxssezi is cimvict hizjrk for   ¥,iKTid€;"§~
Se3<:*:.iQ:1 4§8A EPC, fie  Cass 0? {he
p:*:>5;e€:ut.is:>12 S"(3 fs.21;f   under
Section 302   2: $€I1i€I1€f,€ Qf
Ewe   far 8:53 Sactiem <%98~A
fig gt9':':€_t$:':1%%(*§.V  *?ihE: jL1d.§_>;jn1€:":'£ {)5 a{':qui£'i:,ai S0

fa? agiiige €)%f€§€¥E:v.%;1f:§€f£: S€Cf.}:.{}§} 392 EPC, {he appeal is

" V :"'3i.§:.€;*§{"%>jg' 531$ Riiéfgzzite- """ H

 : "_~v..§_1}<.::?/.;:'«:':;'§".*§§I1§.m,§ €10 {E353 Eeafmsd éifidiiéfifléfl

-- p:*0§4€:£::§§{}r;' {Em izvidemte {sf 'P[V\?',E zemd P.¥'£I2 $5-;§:«.:b§:'sir:z:s
::_:{1:éE' iireaiimésnii Gf {E36 a5:<%'s.is.:é;€3«:i. 'E'h§:::'&§€:r€:,, éighs éiyzéngg

'  {§€::{:§a:°atiq>§: 23;': EXE? {>:;:§§§";'§: ii) hazza %3<--:<i:': :°e.Ei€;*,<i zrgpan by



{9

'é:E"1a-"2 3;:r1;:5:i {3{2:.::'§; {:3 <f:<§:1e::':z:{§€: !:.h{:~ {"3f§.E'.§§.{% wh:=:.3"s3'§z";; de{7:a-%as:-gsfi

Ea-*a$ 63921:: is €i€3at.h 25%. ms: h2::'1«:§&a ::f%;ir1a=: g1<:{:us;{3é,

85 AS eagziizasi. EZEEES3 {hi-3 §&a:*'z:e{i {f(}1ifl§3€'?: §'{'§3'. {'%}{f

aititusfid pE€=23;d$, the :'@:3,s:«<>ning af ihe: Eiriai -§ié;:e.:z<¥i. if:'M:?:é:ii', V'

z1(:{':ep'£'.ing the etasse 65 the p'§"<::-?;::*?ri:i;mZe)r1.. SC:  §jZ5:I_' é?:5s.i';t,1?:~:€5

fifféiééffi 'p'::::iSha}3Eé: Lméer 5S€%{?"{lE{i§?__  §PC_.:s~ »basé&:'i% é*..§3i:1._V

Seuné §'€&§{}I1]§.7£'1g. in th€"'-., é§b:~5€§:<:1t3 V 0?  p§*:>$é'%::ut.i€;n V

e$ta.b§ish1§ng' {5).:is?;.<3z1£t%'~~<3f EX.9?*-'§'€}h1§Tfl,af"i1:§V"Wi"?:§'}.(}E1f. any
perauagien 9:' §:1s'§.igat4§-0:1 ' 1E"§"{§m_-~«._a;§_§. _ _qu21ri£:1'1, mud}.
reéiancs <:a#:";£1'0ii':;;%3€ piaced"":;'e§i:.ai;?:e::<é=am: E:X,P7. "Fherefere,

a:tc0r3Liing,§'t=:: fh;6"a._§§2€a§' dexemreg £0 '66 dismissed.

  'EVe'é<:'aX;*é gone ihraxzgh tha evidence sf

 x:%§'{ne:éé€'€§"'~.b€£b're "" $19 iriai €:{>ur'r and so aissm thé

 gaédgfizézifivQ'ff?:.¥;:*:*%€ €::'ia§ €<:au;"§..

~  The pain: "aha: E};F£S€;':S fer our eangisieratizén

.':§§f 4:

""§fifh€%;h€r 31351:? §:3;dgm€2':.é: sf a{:qz:§"?:f;:8;.E

2.-%;a:°:'21;'1*:.s3 §2:i::;=.:'feé3"€::1<%<:=. :55. €}i,§Zf° §"2z'a:1d§',?'"



Q 8;: far 21$ E3163: e1c§m.§$si:>.r: {'}If %::}":s": éiséitsziséiéi E10

§.hv:: hasspiiiai wiih hu§';":ss 53:2 £§'8.2G§3,_ kw? §1e::5;€§'~.a_§'§w_;€

€'ifid€'E3{E€:3i 0? RW.E.G--£}1*2'§'.Narzzsainma, zvhg  .

iziiiiai ?t.}:ea_i;mer:t and i:1%im2:{€<i_A:h§3 Pff§E""'£:.--§3'<}£:'%» "é,jE';:;_, 

Ei§fl'E§.:%Si€3'}'§ Sf meécééca Eéggzzl €f:é1S€i, .,z%:::<t{2'f<}i'§1g'TT€;:>"f§§<:'r::,. "és3E*£ié§./.i

was:-; admitted £9 E3a}§5pit,2:E"V.;}2Kii....V_ 21b;:fi:;:€:_' 3.   0n
1§.5g2QG;3 with the higziggry  i?:':::* T-- '?;fi.1%<;,.?:;§>z1:1::E at
303} A,1\fE in the b02155:'"£'?ief:%.V§%f§i-3;;\§7§%;1?'z§3§§rns ail Gazer
ihe b€)CifJ excegigicad,   arrivai {ref
the paiice,   fi:4'::r':;:&€§ cf the patiani
5:9 give §d€1'l'5Eifi{'3'd the saw;

éeczimevizt iii 'i:.{;§fl._.s§gna.§:::re at EX.P6{21). '§'he

letter ::Gr13(:5:r°:1c$& ' §S4V ai. ':{'§§;<;mP5. Théi' &nd{}r$@m€3:".:'i: 1%
identifieé at ';:;'"i';§;_:,P1§{,E3},'*A{3<:<::'éi1":g {5} her, P.WI9 rectarééfl

 ._f*;'.75:::';*-:  ef"pa.fi.§_€*;";%;. and iherezfiarg the p3.'{:1?§;:»r1t was

 ;ii%§{E::.*:3:*<:?;_V%:)M -)'i§':?Z\;'§S, E3€iHEiE'§f fag' .fL§'§'T.'}'3€1" ir€:at.m<:nt., Thé

é5*>ii<§.€:::Ai:§:~.E:»f:P.:FJ:f--;"§ gaeg {:9 ghmv §',§'Z8:€Z an rezéaivifigg {he

_§:1iifi;a§.i{}V:::. Eijggrz ithe §1<}s:;;§ié;;a§$ §7§.%I:'E "3-"%?'€*§.":?.'. :29 Sinsihgznssr

 .h<}$p§t:.~;E '2:;.";€E ;;"€:<:{>§*cE{:{3 :%"::'3 S§fi€i'E1€;'.R:1€ffEi'. 9%" 'ah:-3% r:%;e:%{i<:%z;2;ss;:%<'i ass

 



Mfi

par ELx,P'?' amgé reg;g§_ssi.e§a%5E Criaza §\§a.é3_E/{E3 {ii}? <}§'E?:=;:1{t{:i:;
pimiaézezbie :.m<:':e:°° Ss:c::%:i:::>1§ é§8A zmd i§€}Z? §.P{'f. Laiifif. iiim

decésasséaé :"~m€:<:':2mb€:d E0 injuries» an Z2,3.2@Q5 Quid v;}_é»::.s'ié'.~

mertém "W313 €i'(3}}§E,1£3TiZ€C§ an 235.2083 at 3%/Eed£{§a§--  
Eéespiiai {>5 E/EMS, E-Eaiiary.  per $36   ._%;h%;é"
a;z2*€.<)ps§; §<>::1;'.0::, Efih€ z1Ee<:e21é~:g<3c§ I-..;53a,:s§;--:2£i:i€:»:i =.'~.T7§5% f

a:2§;emert,em burns and 9&3 vfiiézd  .:§:3§e 'iii? S€§p{f_C£i€§'fl}i{i 

Shack as 2:: vesuéi if iz':f€{:ti_;_37i';:. _<:--:§nSeq::e:ii. 'iiziis 'Burris;
Sustained. Th€§'€fGE"tf3,' 3'E'{)}T}T'£.iCiCi:;'§.§ é'a;4;;ni,_E1* 9f the deceased

Surayya Begum' is eSE.'3;bii§§h€:éf..fméma:'i;Eie evidence GE

thaw:  {W0 €£¢:c£Gi¥sL .4"'5i--*i':e défeiica-2 ES not serésusly
<§.%$p:,:tinig;tEf2e c22.;is.:§:é~:}f ":§€9i§3fiZE*1 being bu'mS in 'ifhfi present

ca$eg*

  _ ;"§:E':er: Coming? to the r€ia't,i0:'::-ship Egetaarefizz tbs

a{é;t1;:&§€d§ £;§5_::? the &€€?€EiS{:'€jE E:%.':€'r€:=  :19 ::.?i$§}:;:%€ that

 §€<:e-:a:3€1c'i '2s:3;s §?l&f1"I§€€} £19 ihsi a:<:::u:'~;e<::§ >:w{} years; prim' 'ta

 _§i;§1:<: i:::a<':i{§€§:1: in q1;_§€:sE,§{§11 Afisr majrizzgggn Eéhifi was; iixsingz;

'xi

 . "Vi-°ii,3'1 the <*§e:<:<3:52.<,;€:s:§ in 122% i":'1?i§_.F§iE"££}}'§§&i§ hams fa)? game



is

iiime, 'E"§1<:3* *»;5:e:*e% €.::§r<iiga;E sang? §a'i,€::: ER: g;§<3'é: a{idis:é"::.e£§ is
drinks"; and S?I,8;Z"§€3d ii} €.;;':;-:2?z?:,£ng_§ ha'-ii' §:»hy§i<:a§1y magi
i"E'1€E'3.§,Z¥;R"3/1 '.E.'her£:f{>r'é3, fl'§€'§"€ 3.235% iii» be €r<2c;L:é3;:;':: {;:.fg§..1é*:*;£:E

between the {*:<}upEesa

1}, S0 fa? as ?.W'2 ;'1e.i,g.§E1§%:>:2<: '(Bf 'é.}'§{'3:"Z;§{7%;?'i§:§-éf:@ =

arid d€f{.',€E1E3€'d§ ha izlébrmed file €s:3%u,:'i.".5§,hai: ;:;:c::sm:%'

Cieiteagcédi were ':e:i1ani;S in E;E'§é:"E1.:V)7*{;.9s3 {}fV%;{::§'_§."£€i§§1.Vt3Z?Lfi» arié he
had 866:: the accztusedi and fiecéa-$ed3'~quar':*<éfl£f£g csffen',
A<::c0:°di"§_1g "£0 him, '§<1e" ._a§§s1_bf p'3,f&i{;ji;3é+.E,€c§ in 'aim

P§1:e£:ha3«"at,h7 '%*L?I/15{:;"f~¥:i:*s {E1613&i&§cii:3¢V£:1--V"?%>.*>1_§ afivised to Isak

aftar ths  Ltardiaily. But, hawevezz he

says '{hatvV'q.:;:arreV§s E:§:tW3r:%¥:::.";_ the azzcuaedi ancé decaaged

 '_ are :i{;::'maE "e;§:.1$_,§?_':;arh§cE: n{::rr;3a§§.y happerigg in any

 §:«3,_:1*;;;E.§,.:,;*. - __§3~i;:$;~;r:éi2'€t;1 he Saya 7' is 8 mozgiha she was Wiih

her ' §§£iF€§1'5E:::'§j_ 2:115} reizxrraad 2: aveek mi' go §£'i{}§" ':9 R531'

'fiieathg. E113 dew 319?. S§€Eik Q? .931}; £gu2:«:,.r:'€E$ b€§i'.?i9'€i--€;§i éhe

"'.éi:<?s:;:§5'E;': siuriag ihaé. iiigghi ciziysé ;}f}€i"Z§"'§fidA

 



ii}

126 PS§f*€'.3 fie Gudueeeg the Eandéeré ef {he

deeeaeed eeé eeeueedg whe aiee speaks abeui; file

deeeeeeé aeé aeeueed. Ezivieg as teeeeie in his bee;-Se

and the aveeetiee ef the accused as 

were hie itenanée fer efbeut 1% menthe   flee 

aiieged ineieierrik fie else speaks; ef:_:e§u;3;f:fe'iQ3'"ee?{?e>te'e§.f3,e_ }

{he eeuele in: eerzneetien ezithefihe fa€:'r§§§;" ma¢;ie3fs, e1éé':';hee

was aiee aweye of the deeeeeeei g'ei11g1'-- gway fie her
pereetai heuse aé Ma§i:1§§f;§u':fa.;V--_~Aee'ef£:i~:%ng fie him, mra

menihs Eater, eheawee brev1.1ght--bae1%: t_0; «';':§§I1€ii':aneer and

he éioee :1etfif:;ew7'§.4 é:;t_1fi1?eJ;f_' detafis. The evidenee of
v:iir:eeee~sl'$§e' §ar'as'i:fhe 'i*e§aii,enship between the parties?

quarreie evef :§1e'Vfa:ni§_y wreesttere, the deceased eiaying

 e;i.ifV§e:" ;§'";§é.;"e%::fi;.a;E hefiee far quite eeme iietxe arid her

reitaiéfgaiie:::1»e;:':é§1~:e'enia§ heme a week prier {ea fthe date 0:?

" _ the §£if';eid§eI'1'5:V§1é;1'e eetabiiehed.

 "  We eiee hesie flee evidence ef ?..W.%% e

 --..?"_-reeiéeei ef Séeéémneezg whe gartieipeteé in the



E. E

§}2m<;:E12:ya§:h git', S§:':di";2m<:ri>:° s;:<>:'f::ze:z&€:<i at :;h:=% %:1s3"é;.2,2.r:{::'-% £3?
PfiJ'v£'.2 zamsfi {3~1:;he:rs "»3'v'h€;',?€'T§E'1. P,Vxf,1, :3t:'§':e:" kiéih Eitlii Kin. {sf

thzi é€:<:<:%.:»1.<3€d 5%} aim} {£2.27 s;:<>:;pE€;=: W'€fI'€;'. p§"<;':s€:1%§., '"7£'};*:'r}'

azdvissd Eihfi'. .':1{i{?U;S€i{§ 110%; H} {:{>'n.3:.,m1é3 a§{:é:;'h<:§., '£i?:r,:.e.:g; T§.}'_};€*'é..VV

E1a:p';3§1§,: far a':;e:>u%: 8 {%a.§gs:: 2:315? E:};':é: {ié:a::e2>2.;<-:s§;fC§,:«3.;1_£é=f:_:ii:;£::{ 

burr: Efij'L1I"i€3S zafizer S €i§:1§x'S'

14. P"\?%:'.8-§~Z:~:3:3<>§s9f§3 iaééifg  ':&TbV€2.§,i*f' {he
§am:hay2a;i'.h heéd 2-33;, Si§*:'1a§ha§1e:§:'.*A }:<:é0rdimg'é.'@ mm, the
accussed was eking Gui; hiszi. iii";-*e--Ei§h<:a;ri1 >éf2vif{E ;bb1£jd§'1§}{}{}1' as 2:
Eiamzzii and f:';':t:::§z1§;(§:Vf;%1'{. q_L1a__zi%:.éi$'«.L1'Séjd.Vt0if'b€ beiween the

mupie. '<..A'}7'ht=:'ef€);*é';-._fE1e4"wife: 'had gene is Malingapura.

fie": br«:;4;i?1<3E,«...:I*§I1éf}t§;i«:%_:"4V %a;15'ci:_1::%:h::r Ea.m.3;1y mamberss bmught.

 «he? '%;e:}_ ::':a'{jfi:§1g_g;_:1iaE Ezeméz arzfi iiheié 3 §3a:f1gthaj.;a'{h

 -,W;;1§ "Ei2s:§s;:§, §a§:'c;§1'<'§§';:g;;§ U3 him? {he :'ea$e:§r:.:~3 far ihe qzxaxreé

xx-'<3:?¥:  :':§€; k:'i:.'i_*a.ir:'2 Ea} him,

A  ESQ" We §1a'i;z3 Eflfiié éhe s3:v:ifi<irz<:te of kiéh ;:1;1s:% kin 3.5:

E5;§?i2"; E; a%;§1{> ig :'::;>:*:€ {:ihe:* ilzaan %;.he:= E3m':.':':<:>,:" of "am:

 '§i€%<:€:a_s=;s%{iR §§{';{?f§ZIE'd§1Eg E0 Easing %:':":ej; 2-va:'e: axmiz-":2" {:{>rd;i;>d

 



§;,er'§n.s3 Fm' £:b:}:.:E. s;:m:'-:2 }-'€f:.§1E"". '§"§1:;:%:"§=:aE"z.a>::° his; 27u;§<:§§<':':;i0:: in

aktahési Ee:::£§ tr: iéi i;r€:z:t.:n€=§1i. <3? his; $§:«;E:e:§ and S0 fcii'f5_{'3'«§'£E~'.%
§§E',€'r:i;i{>r; *;1<3 m;1.:':;a 2::"1:fi;§1<f::' W<m:a:1. He 2:_:i*i.?is:§{i ~
siafier and Sfizlt, hez' back its znai.ri:>m€>:§.i;1E E"s_§:3'm"é;=fE3h<3._é§{%._ V

:30: Z':av=e c::%1:£i§éren. Ki yaars they  '§§1r"é»<.:§ 'zfi E%a;_;§:ja:E}g<}€."

far abmiii }§ mQr"3ih_s3 a§   yé'§2*:::__ '€:.§;_§§{  :3:
Sinéhaneor, when  'é;zé  Li%1%ii}§€:i§*:§ d_€:a'£i*1,
Acceréing £0 him, even V"_'i,:§§e:§,f Werfz Cfiféiéfi
far :-some   i:he:"6afi<~:r, he
gtariting  out {ilf the hause.
She caziéés'"2:§x%fif§* _Vi;§% V.'/§:c0§d§:1g to thsm, SEX
§Ii0I}i,1'1SvV'§E1%'.€E'5V  21 pE},IEC§'1E1}'ai:?1§ She wag

%:3;ka:1,--*:@ §na€f§":i§:1<}n32aE haszéiéa Within a Week? he {waived

'V2: ?€.faViE!<:_§:2hi1{%:'§séV" cail :§*!:'aii;"::g ihai: ae:tC:1§ed get her abiaze by

::};::>m::;izf:g»;"v  'wf';::';E':~' KEIFGSGEEG.

 ~§"*%:"*<,>anf: fihszz zibave eviflzemte. '§'.§".é€ §}§'G§€f{Til?;£€}IE

 ._2i;g:?si%L_;1?;3§ér"'é:<> a~:s;%,ab':i§sh éthaii: aa:?e::us<s:::E rii,rs:a.i.<5:€E ihfi é€<::é32is.sé3d

aé%E.E;.§§ si:rL:{»:=E§';§ gr: zzscayuizé. sf his 3.{%{%§z::E:§<2:1 Ea a;.E<::3h{}i arid



i:h.§ér§5f<>§*é3.; pa:3{:hzi};-'a:t.%:s; \..-z-*s::i'€: haégis Tht? 'iriaé C:3;,:_§'ig ass 2*:
n3;a15;%:€::'" af fé%_,£:€.g {1{}3'i'§:'§{?f.€.{§ éhét zzgtatusged E1121" iiafi V<}f§}::":':;:_:€:

purxishezbkz amégz St-éc:"'€.;::}'r:£_ 498$ IPC'

3?', The qzzesatien §:% 'whei',E:<;;-'A: an S113'"E-Ii'§§::*s:e1':::1g§ 

night gf 18.5.2033 is }';§.§.2£%83 §§1t:> j1%hé:1;~§§:aée%1'vmir_e; 

a;n in':é::1ii0§1 to cammii 315:  §~'f}L§§'{§.€§{' h%iS ?:.0..Sfé€I1.
Excepi. the: djging decézzratiagé §.rI llt:E1_€"fg:):*n1 @{..21AA§:;7s%:1pEaint.
at E§<:.P'?, we $0 not h'"av*e-Aar1_yfg--.fiv£h€§:f dirsrtacei SVEGEIICQ £0

€Oflfl€C'E the acijzgisxad *<3».?f§¥t 1i i'§':§3 éfiifiifi, 7

38.  E>%:§P?_ E133 (701315 mm <~3X_§s't:,e:i§ce withia 2:
spa}: Sf.'-43%'E:"3ifiLF:"§'€?AS imE'éE§17Ef}V"§'}.'i!iE'fifiiél ef admiissgion 0f the

deceased' aigé -"ih€:'= Zri09;§;:siifa§",4  This is evident {rem {he

<7:}1':?iai1:';s<}f E;~;.¢F?' étséif find raise ihe 53%-'i&€1f1{:<»: sf P.'§31="S.9

 A_Va;§1£§_' '3.GE,__  Efhe €:'c§2.é;§::ais; Q? 351?? _1'.2:1d1'ca'€e:s§ izhat afiei'
i:3:§£:'f:21i",§_:%'§':  fine S" atmeég, {E16 SEQ 211°':*§x.-*£5{§ at the

 }1€;:s§E':;.2*i£';._ '§"§':;.::§ Vafaifienstfi: and iihe recardsa reveai. 1:.ha'?*; ai

?;ii,&'§;'§ R3%?£7Lj§~:":§i§§:':a_:'.§Gz3 W218 Eéfiifi; ircsm She §'z@&§pi%:ai {.9 {E16

<:<;n{€§*rnvE::{i 'g:::'€:>E£{:{~3. SEES :;:§';*§v€:d at éhe §1{};~<spi'£:aE by ESQ

 



5%':

E4»
g%W}'irE} E332" 1,39 A..§v'§» *:'..'m-": c%s1«mm'1tL;s=s 5;? EXP? zftaitsie i§T:%:<}

€:>{i$%i.er:{:er. "E"§"}.<~:r=::*af%é:::z "EEK? {i<;%i%2=*;1§s€:€i w'e1:% s%1i£"{;@d 'sq; "vT§_?s§S
Eat: E$§=.E3a:"'}»*, Théé ea?_i€§{~:%:'2<":e. <33?' Pfi2%7$,§ emd ES {t{}iEp§§?{,§'i§fi?.%_}

the hcssggitai re§:'::>rc£s3 and Ex.?'? Wcméd :::{i_ig;f'2:'*?#i'~--£;h¢é%?§:. 
there was :10 1:27:53 Wher1 'zhés Ex.P'?' has *..:;;={3:*;:€._"i:{*§Eé:§ _"
€:'?X1'i$'€€E1{T€3i.€, namisfiy Ehs: kirk and R33 sf t}f.1'é%"Ci'c;*:=.'_e:%.S1e;I5'13% 

her giée Vfifhéill She gfzwe her sE.z;;ienj:r::11%. %tZZt§'3.§.W€).i"€i- 'P;E?»§'.E%.5 

",Fh{--3 Wi'}.C2§€~ pm<:€;3§ was z.>v<:';° w'§t:h§n £15 'Er:_11'11ut€é1~;,. A%a%.>%i1?€:§*: is
s:,:z'§ri$1?I1giy net, the n0rmaE%A?;'{j£.V_€3f E/§.é:;g.)1_;3:~:rVV1i1*2g_._;;f "<2;%i'§}'1 {he

inve$tiga€.mg :;1gé:E§(:yw

19, §3§C(:Vi§;fd:§§;;§"  ?fi,?s/9:18 in the Crass"
€X&l£}"iiE1EEi§{)fi§_ fizz-3'  ::1dmit'E1ed ziraund LS8
A.M. and SEES is§%;2;<:€:if . :".§1f:::_".§'ett€r 21%; LE5 _A,.M, Shff refers;
to EX-'f?:§,  E3t1.V"i. {E22;%efé;,:£ pfirusai Qf firzis ksiiésr inflicafizééa

 ?:.'§=?&a"i;'£%':  £§'f...i2g45w§}';R'§, and fa étarssfzii pétrusgai <12? .E:>{..P'7'

 i:ie:i§<§:{%,<:s§'--v.*§5£?:;%J':.§€;--haS {f{}I"i}€3 xizm: €3Xi§if3fi{3€ 21?, 36% P.E":!L

a;;:":s'§"§.:s.§gj«2§é'§{§_v.§;.'§§?E'§V am E9'$.2GG3, éhisé FIE 9921:'; <§§3_p;1%.<:E":e£§i

_azéiaz"V"":"€gé_;§;'{r;=2é§{>n of {3'fif§}€ mzmber. "E'h§i E3';/"i{§€'fi{f{i" Q?

 



R)":

?I'=.?€'iE ES {§'i;£.§§I€'? <':«:>:'1'é:r2=: E0 t:hi:~: <=:v%i§::*:n<::§-.;% £323 :*é:*.c<:::'€E.

5%<:::{>r€£i:1g ":2: him by {he {Ema he 5:212:19 {:3 the E":<;;si;~:_1?'i1:?;_'L

$1338 €E<}Ct<>r 'E'12§.ci e1h'«3ta{§y i:"2f{}mzz<3e:§ iiiae. p_<j3§i'<:'a .'_' ---é::_;§:1v__"« _
aqiatardingiyg the pahce had :*ec{};*de3§ .hé::' f3'i,E:'§4£?fI3{}f'}'£:T :as;m'3;__" 

%;',E:e:"eaf%.@r on {ha same €£é%y§-Y9 §'.§"3{*:j,,é' w<"3:i;f:53 %:=33,lq.:;:V£.:':35=:§f;a_n'é§;A

their sé:a"t€menfi;$ Wezfe §°if{?{}F*°i:'f§:;Ci_i  
a'D:>z::t 13$ A..?v€. the 1?:'_:<:§&e:1t__v:<§§§é;*:§:::sV_v 1':0:.}f:a;z:Vé?:; {};_ff£::urr€d§
an his enquiry wiézh   €:{:»n<:€--;:'::eé
Séiyfé at 3.80  fizz  in{i.m22t£an

and at }...3G__A c@:;f:§:C:ed--.."tE9%;c cazfifterneé e:i0ct::2r. if

he E?gad:vi§'{§fi:1:t'Fa;{3;f;5§>__d  :§:§:<§.:{::;=:*z:e§:éVV'cviaat%;<>r at LGG KM} by
206 Al??? "ha?ha"iCi.. ::i'i:g.§§{%:::%§g§ "aha crirras rmmbezx 80,
Within g  Czf }i21_.Evf*--A;1.i.:gE.1'0L:r ha took {he <ir:d;01°s€n1en'€.

Qf f:h§:; da>.s:é'{.0r :€'c.§§1é§d£§3g $1116 fiiimegg ef iihfi patient. and

':*e:€;<>%'d<éd'5~="L't'§';?e3A.'$ia'§€:z%§'é:1i {:35 "£7519 izijurfiii and '£:h.€:reaff,er

'-«,%;s':"2f{: '3;3E"é:€;?§*'{.' '3'5<:>.__%E2§% ;}{>§i€é: §si;a%;:§8:": ii} :'€:g;i;-a%:.<-3? like €::2,1:~:;€g

w£f:%:§°ic~;"§z:«3;  Says SE16 E'€ff£?{"§'€3d £318 Efiéfiliéfii K} Bszélayy

_ --§'<:2:'f fii.:'§:§':--%3z* "§fr€9;9:::1€;:é¢ G2": yeasaéydza 2%.»-"e fie am; §§E§,1--''§E
"  3:31}?'%:%3:?r:g.§VV__ {<3 siwzar $31533 {::x21<:€.E§; Shi? 2-'ma s:;§':.if§;€€E ii}



26
Beiéegrjg-*. 8:12. the faitt: :'<3r;":a£:T:.s§ 0:113; 21i"am' 2}r:'§vaE 05 heir
brséhézr Efizsy §'1;3:v@: 5::hi.f§'€c§ I'E€I" ix} §"3§{:?f§§E1£":'y', "fine. <:{>:1;i.:e»;n'{.5s

Sf EXP'? in:i1'<:.atli::§a i5.'}1eEi'iL shée wag :s%1%fi'.@d by 2.98 

a mafhérr Q? faifi, §3.W,_§.G 5-322378 fi*:2,1£. She 
§2¥Ii€2fEE§ zmci Shifi,€{§ her ta Bszflelzjgz '§A»"'ii"Z§."i§I"i  v"L:if§."%_§Ts~ 
daéis 110%. c::>rz'ab0'.21E,€3 with thg' ""%e'*~i;,~*.:E<:E:€1:;5';C<~:_:V."
because, {(2 came ti: S§Hd3h£m0o':"'-._fre:§r:'T;..-ifsfiaiinggjéipééfég '1é( 

 ;f§3:~.;:gj; 03:;

1932093; If thay arrivéai sgazgwen i*E,§5;i';f.*%33:"1.:a ;§VVV'?,O{}
A,M.,, she mus': have been a}3f€3,.CLE§z '3: VII\?iSvvhQs§piiai at

iakeg C? ta} 8 h<;2L:rs and I3Z§1€f.§,'.4_£;iE"E"§'{f'{;':_€§"'fr);i ?V.§5i';

B€HaI":§,7; as p}5€'r»*3j§1«:_§: ?$'{a1:.;é'1?:;e';"':fi. ef dor::'m:r« 'Fh€r€f0;'6, the
1.

-ery iiniii hf VE><:}';'7?",?L«.V€:=3,.r:*1*§;'§}.ug{.;;. énio exégtézizzes EOGEQ very suspic§aué';,__ Thé;':: E?-§ "_§.?'€f§: aiifiilhfif' reasaza ta a2"'3'iv{:: at 3118?';;a"C§3Q=:'E:vi§Ei/Qéfi %€é£};L1Sfi 0:? Zihe fazti; éihai, {Thmagh EER 'szazgzfizs €égi..?;:§: ":°§:gésté;:iéd ai 2.C%§ Alvi. on 19,82,693, it did

-,§*§{}f "g>{i;EC§f§"§;vE'§.€"€fOE"§{':€';§'1'i{3§ Mzzgigtraite til} Kfifi Fifi. an §"2¥;vE";%'._?;Q€;}83';'~v.,__izfiiéther w"<}:"£iS§ 3%: 3'€€1{fh€i'd éihéi <':<Hz{:€:r:1ed ??v'§2ég».§§§i:r22§:;:3 .2";j§.€,ér E? h{>ur;="s. T%;§$ iieigijg £5; mfg. éaxpiazifiefi §f;m§3é32*Ef§z'E;}:* ::E'2€ ;32*€';§<-:{'.::;:'E:§<};":, '?h€=:'€ aéaighé '£5 are 'bean E7 exgp§z2z1a€.i<m xzzhy FER 3.'€'Z'&?.€?i§1f;?€§ fihié €f<3:2._:"i: :1.f"i:g==s::'" E5'? I:_;}::'§°5; of iieéayx 'E'E'1e:z~z'<~:'f0'r€2, ii Wzyuiezi ssmiy mdiézate ééé 129$. meme Exits; €3}£"§.SiZ€3Ii€€ 95$ s.a':a'::a%zi by {$36 §f'{}$€3{?'Ei:{.§'{B§E'"1 ' at. abeui: 1.30 9;' 22.00 AWE. <31': 2.9;§,i»C§G.iE--' , "ii.;:;§v's;:v<'f.ii??:é»_ u inta eX§s'z.€r1{:€ Hzazch iaiarp 2%. Sq; far as the <:{:r:t.€.1fiE:§_ sf 5:: §;¢.§3:*'":;sV£;:.:'{3; <2? "

c@:;§:':~nt.s§ 3.5 righiiy £ffi3Se'w5:€§---- 753:. :;:hAe *£.r§€{<§~-..C.i:3§.H£, an 18.52083? the az;:cuséd _T.9;ft'e:53*Z§:a1fi1ig. dinner fiifi not 816613 in {he hQ:,.s;--§ es;-._ Bsgcapigg: ag:i:{5:d§ir:g'»i.é2 the Si.af:6me3:':':
at EXP"? a{?:'C:é.:géééd""':>;:%:;r:t"-Qzgtisgigfiéé ¥t}:1@,.§1ouse Elfid sslepi on the payéii c:i"th;e5"VEt'{§5;:Se,ii%'ii_§i'a the de:::~::ase§ was inside the hem:-:8» SVVE::~:.VV§°2,,:r{}':.1e§"A.s'a§%§=;' thai 0:213: when she felt the A_hea%;;5'.Sh§ r€3E§zé€:§«3i§1a?é: she wa$ in fiazmea Aétaéarding {G E153," --wjEr::s::V'3= --€'}§€§3.€£i her eye& she: saw" her husband g0Ting'Va;Wa:;' f§E:*eif:: the §10i}.S€ ziiiagingg ihe $.03?' Qrgéy after xhezr hm? émé $337, 3716 {§3.1'fi€ mfiide éhe hgmseg $0 3350 the '.::§=:§gEi§3@%.:r$ ané {:e?;.h<3§'$. Th5}? 22.3% é2:fi.ing:2§S§':€{£ §:§/13 fiféi "a:1F::§ "§:<}:§E<_ herzz" ':10 {he hasgiéai. ';§"'h<:ré;': Esra SE16 S'§:z:'é.é3z§":s:';f:', sf E8 E§1:':"s E'iiT?i',i§'.E'.};, W§1i<:§: §}€.E"§§'L,EE1{§E:€% as :30 z::<_}:_":{:E1::i£% "zhai. thra {:{}:1*;<$n."?i'.s; 2:)? E}<;Z.P? 2:1? rfzzfi. Eihe wmais; of £1115? e:§:gi::;;; ;:f€£ff:§c>.:f: 911 théz éeaiih be'-idh She $€aysa» 21 cimgh was €:.ié:_r:§__ {}§<§.fte:;%;1¥f'=--§i_:.%:%s'?____V" .

mmzth Si} 2:53 E10 Step E16; {mm $:t;j::;1mi:}g';"'"'----:E3<:f§'n§%,€:E:;. Bgfifil" {§{}{§;"-iiZE7E§,§ her with ker<;$e:1s3 37:-:'":d;'53<:Af**i',§:i1g;?_ flag' zi'E;3V"¢L::€'9E;f ha" mg;-w::h ifiéiiid i'1€i}§i ilavée i:i%:%€;1 fig->:§?£:;1'; ii Gugfhi is be eariiei" R} s§:::V~A~V;<?:;L:iv§A§§=-. d"vb§'1:fi.g"hégr, if a ciaéh was put around her K} raise 2: hue and cry; gaifi EECEEGB of tha ezssa;Ia:;;s"§;.__ _'$»'é/"$'iLV7£§Q hasm apened hey eye;~_§ {iii she f€1i. {ha fire over E'iez; ?3©:efli_§;*" $%f;1°01r1g 8:361; sf keraseneg $316 2fi;<::1zkiV1%:2:¥;7::, s£::"_1s%:é' Oder «:3? keraaeneg but :f:<::n€ 0%" Ehsgse 'i'.hiEEgB__ Eéappisznefi, Thsrze was ac: qua:*:°e§ €%.rh;'i1i;%;<§é:<;?1<3s" Eéééizveerifiie seupie 0;} ?;.h<:~ §§"€"i:"i{}L3S yzighii. If §,_Ei§,f;'%§v'£'a*.i'VG:}'E.4VIii"fifiéi deeeaaéd were ':0 <--:§£mi:'121ia=: her, hf:

wG5:%E2:i'=:'1€2?:.'.§€%3:véE'gang {}u€:$§Z£§e:3 and $§é5;)i:, fie \,,%?<}1fld héwfi eig-,$:;*<:.fi" £:h'e:~;j {iii}? zzraé rat: av;.?ga3r {r{}m E336 5=3g3<:»i:e H013: shss *s§'i2;a:?éi.:;2L__i::<;%€i" iazzrrzsgi iihe Eiififléfifid m:%<--:5§ neé: es~:«i;a§:}§Es~:~;i: iii: é:.E:e:. presem: aka-55¢; 213 hi', $5253? 3':a<;s€, in §"1€?E' £:<>::1pa;::}a 'E'§'.;e: Q_'é:h<-3r :~=3uSp£c§<}'L1$ ::i:*<':un1.s§:a§':{:e azzdagéi' whiiih Ei;v;.?Z?' h22:f§"--f:}<";§:i:~:A izzia e:Q's;i:£5:1::€ Wm,:.3<E imiy i::ad_i_:;::;:'£:€ ihsazii me .:€{3:1i::::V:'£::-:is"M::>f'F V' EZXP? 212%: :":{}E: {macs 210:5 emci §}'i€j*:gF""£i'If-E" §f"s'fv'€i_1§1:é5L'i f{3E§7'--fl'E€.{'-- purposa 05 {ha pregem. {2€z£~3€', V

2 E; En ths Eight. €)§§"L1H1:{:3'£T:§§CV'}:3(?*§;'f3 0f the apirgigm i:.h;,-1%: the rsj&.$'ani:::§ '§:§§eLA.§{:r_§aEA'AC'0ié:'*?L;. is M31 perverse and the erder the offence "under Section cai§:;riC%e;;ai:{ifééec:1:.A§ii §;:s. §;§_§§j§iif§€é:. Aé2e1<:rd§1'ig1y._;4 téisfe :<1p;':i3;a1§ ES fifiamisssfici. gséfw /°"'§ : M.» as' 2' ",2 W £.,,.«»w§ gvwwfi M ..g $5 A VA L *a§b}'"-2 '