Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Vidyadhar Manishankar Mhatre vs M/O Railways on 17 December, 2019
=
g
y
i
i
2
3
t
i
z
s
y
$
¢
3
3
3
3
+
>
wees
t
{
i
!
CENTRAL ADMINI
NEES
STRATIVE TRIBUNAL,
TBAT BENCH, MUMBAI
RIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.537, 872 & SiS of 2013
Dated this Tuesday, the 17" day of December, 2019
CORAM: R.VLIAYKUMAR, MEMBER (A)
RN.SINGH, MEMBER iW}
Harishchandea R. Shak 's 3, So Ramlakhan Shukla, Age about 79 ¥ ears,
Worked ag Fanic sincer Gril, in Central Railway at atinge
Workshop, Mumbai 4000 519 and Residing at Sudhakar Mama
Chal, Room No.3, Tulshi Pada Pee Line, Bhandup (West),
Mountbai 400 O78. » Applicant ia OA No, S3U2073
at
r * Manis bat ves} winatre, Ags abeny
- Sar (r-fT, in
Lop, 400 G19 and Re
al iding 1g 2 No (25, Mashal.
1B hagwatiprasad, Age about $9 years,
anior Engineer Gr-ll, in Central Rails fay at Mahinga
Mambat 80D O19 and Residing at: Vasturiinnan Co. Society
oom Nod, Asiad Nagar & Mira Road,
af 401 10S. . Applican? in GA Ne SFi01F
se Ad vacate Ms. Vaishalf Agane}
Versus
i. The Union of India Through the wenera xv
Comte Railway, CSTM, Munthal 400 661.
2, The Chief Workshops Man Matunga Workshop,
Central Railway, Minn
a. oe Workshre
five Wi arkshap,
Central Rally
Me mi nba 400 O12
(By Advocate Shri VS. Masurkay}
. Respondent in all OAs
COMMON ORAL ORDER
Per: R.Vijaykumar, Member (4)
-- pan oy oS RNa sy TR oe, ox 3 Ow oe so a S A AME LARS Mt a at A oe A LL o; * 3 wx M4 we hh odes : A At ae Redd SSAALE awe M jen he 4 Save + Ted ypera le Moss reyes eekiane SEIU a LS AOL, AFG SOS Kime ee MAY graciously p oy 4 wy "3 ya et t O ha @ CG Cy tl : me al a S Rd el & (2 ty 0 ey cM a £3 wd a> et wR as a od i) 35 5 "y se *
-- Oo a os S wd is 5 oo st 33 3 "ed mH IS o m , wo ) cA io ke + ee B @ & % 4 ee 3 erg rad 'y i « ee ry F a ar 44 ut ca Fa oS Gi es be mf 4 + mS v 4 es ~ i} et, sey oe ey {3 , roa ty bt ap 8 ti ced wy hee wen ara os Cy (Ct : ded cy ot XG x ty bak *s (2 Op ss . ' <E; tt Oe 0 rd 4 12 3 <3 a oS Lt ran oF ay ty gt pas " en oa a tft up $ ak nt q ry. nes sy 4 4 a3 ay on unk Q és Ww 4 84 4 pe Es ee wet ey « ot yd Xb reed IP a we 5 " j it op Lf . . ; % ie ged Y weed un 5 ES os m ped ae kG AG ba <S "et Q 5 f os weed 3 ' ot 13 a ed aA co x it qt Cy 4 «et i 3 ~ om J, 3 : S 4 uy x pa aA oy * ' ke . 6] <3 iS aged , : is « Re Bo Ms 9g & Gg a os ary os sod - (3 us tee re: Ct MA a oS Ep ey of a ty a rk a 4 a ° @ 4 4 ad o : v CS a E 3 Se oy ens &. rent weg a rn 44 ios Go fee ow 5 we *) ft © "3 Ss i © o 2 co 8 8 fg a 2 ey bosee ' " uy 'a an > 4 neg bs , ae 4 "3 Co Or ; a wr Ct ud . 4a aa i ke acs! m™ "es Lk . a vet We { * rt 6 er aes bot 3 G ao 43 te Wy oe "3 on ce gy 4 : $ me me m 2 ps we 2S ro ag i o + re st a ke QO 4 43 % ~ chet De Cy whee ct eee . ' the 3 ee - "iD Soe Es ot in 3 ba 4 c ' fa ¢ 4 ry ae 4 , iat Qo er '4 a £3 r 8 ae « ed ey x fa iy ; we SAG io we von bee CRA nepal xt ord vd ved oo £2 a 4 ee ut EP bs as wa gk . 4 ° % er G u ba 4 ' , i 's Pa : wa we Ci ca 44 opel ch a 4 bee oes wy ey > uh " et 2 Q tL tot we orn, pho 7 tn £ Ly Fa "5 = : Porn ceded 4 w - G 2 @ a ry £3 :
oO a fegeg Set red ae ar . C, yi 4.0 reef ie "y - a ry ot <i 2 ped Lt eo ty ¢ wr i ramet OG oF 4 t 4 at So Me st Sake oo Oe om a 'i ha ua bea § eed a KG fea ' @ 3 4 so "3 4 es i ai ca Ps "a . ~ uo at Si} uy i é 3 fe 44 od o 3 wn a "GO i 12 "4 5 ' vd : ct a oo § rd oye ~ 8 & 6 8 poo q cbf . whe i r + " aed a -
Ch a ms G £4 nd 5 a ba 4 FA 3 & ty "A wt : 3 643 3 42 2 od AG det u s re "4 S40 ed 4A ¥ oa CC wt 43 rm :
pees . sd co 'Se Shad ne Gp ; : a on a a UF Crd a et oO D 3) 43 byes Li, ste ae ™ 4 J .. .
"es O i o ey he D ;
& 3 it eh eet vod 43 nS int i 4.4 w be B re) @ iD a Ws a re bea 4 oy iy Fey 22 . G th &y aed y $3 a i "3 fa ; a Oo bs ; % as ;
Mt oS a Ot " as " it % o wy y ,, tos wh mS apd rd Udy rt ig ups ki i 4 8 gD ww "4 : o x - Sh
" 4 , ts a ny xa ' 4 M4 a @ +4 to ri if * ss RO ved Wy - pe a up mtn or 4 abd m a Cx Ch "e m we a oe 3 pa " i a "
wh vt ns a So La i ace ¢ ey : 4 .
ie & o 4 oe mm a "3 oy '' ie Be @ > oy o 3 oi i 44 a) 'A fs os go ie "O & G& © ng eS : oi 7 fe ra tt sf 2 Bed as u 7 ; et a , z G ¢ 4 is ut "eS G unt 6. > te oo B QO g 5 R Bo o ° £4 foe sh te ' £U, 3 ne ao a 5 i a 7 e C3 6 id AS et 4 i a te S iS od . "
5 io 4 ie om) " re a vf ws 4 2 40% As sc 4 end rh ie Oo og Ba mt 44 got " wy ' my i? a4 ae : &4 $4 .. we 44 oy ha orf . w ard is or ay us a G a) oD 4 a a ue tet 4 bed oe i wD ve " " eed B o us (3 oy ne, et cs) eg ib .
5 4 a a mh a a @ ve % a rd 42 ca 4 ~ ~ red, % i761 » b4 ws a > tea Ay m3 " . Md gs ved iy so nt As "4 het i. ne % a oh, Rh ae] ei ¥ i as a ' .
"it, ay 2g Mt od UA 4 ¢ LS BPE REE CREE MAES 4.3 qo i mi 2 Lee to as Oe . oo ' re, GD GE ant mt ede ote ete Th Oe eS hts. wy TE ng it ee, od wd wm tg 6G ' ta tz eS ED my EE un ma i : 4 ae ee ty . a a Be 4 te "ae 2 a 43 Go Be aoe oR OSS moa oe b yg 2h SS wees "be fe Se OD os ay ED pt, op TA ae 4 oF BY Ca 9 ES hy OS 3 ag we fo sf ES on 4 eye oO "3 & 5 ex, : Pom YY ies ob : ke Se ota ¢ ? eo a OR 4 * os "ct est & Bg 7 wt TE te TH mo = BLS we el okt cd ods ee 540 OR ee gt | We ng Ga ' sp) sat oS oe ony ra we 3 ee "A oo ' cn ey at gt uo & ah bet :
"3 3 we "™ 2ES ay & Bee BO ey ag peo gy Ee oon ot I ra pe oes 2h EE Bg 4 'tp eM SO OR. a! ent . 3 oe OT oo ey . Pal ay BN ee tt * i3 on ae » ob of mt a te Ce ay G "eh BS gt o oe fy & 3 > eo z BS 6S ¢ Bo» % peti a me ee 3 we as) SEG Be ma 4 ae ES te or 6 me gs "ry Gg , , SRD EE ay 1 ~ hoe o2 ¥ ' ct pa eke Ba bet baa rie ¢ & sige oR EE ® 66 & Js Oe & ee Gens . 3 "SL By A te ot & we a3 3 OLS ox ob re a sh ae wr é 7k vee 4 CD ee ? yt rae SO og 2 EA ow 2 » k, ts pe ee oe oo tS st te 83 2 OY we aed 2 a " + VERS 2G By a @ oy aoe By eZ 2
5 Q a 2 o bee OG ee fe, ee ; Sea Ss i Pe A -- te oe oo S % aS Bo ek ht os EB # eo Oe fe ra 7 tr Bs wane as fo to Th By oo ay OF = ka ct 4a ay
- bag oO) Sm FS te Berm, 9 a oF Be Me at At es nm ": ps ie org 7 mn 2, 4 a wa ES rm . Se &, peng : Y & 9 % SP eee eS eSse baad se ger os k = a Oo eet spe Ae eh wh Hm tr Sg a a mY Y a ce Be OM €} SA ge be ot a eS Ch, (a We ba & bea as set 2 red "i > a mx eee bs a ¥ RS 3 (5 ee st @ © s ot ee & ee : =a} i : x ot oo @ . Bow CER me oS ye SH 4 Oo G 2 a Safin! . " fa oe A ee, * oes jaa 7% * 6 oy TS o ' Bu Does SO fee ie ried a> be on .
"Set At ee yt Meek gee ge ut TR Oe ie pe eke pe So as bs i Uw 6 Be Pino a BEE Zee SES 5h thm BS a we oh i ay we " sg, SA get o et et ea 2. eS wt i} fe oy Mt oo Sf fe rs ba ab Gy 7S Pu "Boot & beg oR Ea "ed og a oS Sh 2 Boe ns he fos ee Oe & 7a os wa De + te ba oe e 'e = ae ped yg ts I ney aS BOE on : o : mn % 4, :
» oY oS Sb TB by B ® Bert Po Ae om Bt oy He OR vet a fo - - ro eS BD Ey Go mo a & EO oh xa ane mi oS se eh if} Ch rs YE. ot my O94 "yay rs oct OW e 4 eos et oe is ' be ae ts : Lot S 4 ane 8S oe ra cod > sd s Bowe Soe Bae en G 68 ; eS ' 3 s , --< n y = hy a z oa a * « Py i u a oe @e Wb Bets vee Se ge tee ny ay Ee wy 44 % ei "eS ee 5 < a e me Bop % Bo 2 . - %, nt oA : " m0 3 : 8 3 ES Le os ' Q & ty Bb oy 88 CEES ERS ECEE wee re oe SE are pend a * ow 29 ' oe oh got od wet cs OD ee o te 33s tf Sa be f , ay fo so ° Sed G 28 ay Ce cy OG pad co 54 nets a Bs Bee ke. bt Oftrea Ba A og c gy ay és ' £% 12 Bo 4 8 ws Re a Bi if 2 Bos BS 3 . ee Se & Eb SR es aie of , ver : es ta gt ah my oO ERS ved wa oo a i: oo 4 ae 8 het it eo On Le ES eS es 5 I £ 8 : Oy "Cy 4 a a Si " wn ws tee a ya it vet ~~ i i £7 i Pa Fras Ao "rs C2 '
- gm BAN Go ee ahs 8 GHA Nos 837, 372 & S73 of 20 In OA B1A/2008 hese applicants aml im GA 6352/20 thres out of four nave made a prayer for promotion tu the pos st of Rinier Engineer Gr on {lin the scale of Rs 50G0-8000. The other two cases are also 4 OF etlappi ng. OA S1T6/2004 is fled by six apy Yin Joauts and relief sought ig promotion te the post of Junior Fugineer Grade LL Ader three of the applicants in GA 3162004 have been promoted to Junior Engineer Grade ff there isa fresh DA" M2004 against the reversion order dated O5/09/20048, As we have discussed above, no ground has been made te fo give promotion as Jenior eenece Grade 1 io those Supervisors (Mistries} also wii are above the cadre strength amd, therefors, the five apy otic amis. in the three cases namely ~ GA Nos.@142004, GS /20n¢ and 552/004 and three applicants in the other two cases, namely - OA 3142004 & aad PSO 2004 cannot be giver the relief as regards promot mi ig the cadre of Janice Engineer Grade If in the higher pay scale.
Oe ~y a> a"
Zz th li. "The next question is relating to the reversion order dated G6,00/2004 by which the Su sarvisar Gviistry) in the wade of Rs dM-7000° + Bs.i0G SLA. have been reverted as Technician Grade Li ive] the scale of Ra 4500- 7060 or + Senior Technician in the sesle of Rs 3000-8000", fk is seen that Harish chandra Shukla, Kaingrayan Bhagy wwatiprasad, RR. Yadav 5am $.. Khan are reverted From the grade of Rs 4500-7000" + Rs LOO, SA to the post of Technician Grade ti in the grade of Rs.4500- oats, TOUR, This accor respondents ig im accordance with pera I3.2(b} o thes resiracturing order dated GOLO2003 where it is clearly provided that those Supervisors who do not get pramoted to the grad se of Rs S000-8000/- shall continne to hold the post in the existing grade o Rs. 4500-7000". + Rs. 1h) SA aS ergaral to them: to that extent the post ungraded to the ade of RsS0t 00. S300 will be operated in the lower rads of Re4$SG0-7000 + Rs.lGO SA HU the existing incumbent vacate the post by way of promotion, re irement etc. The reversion to the grade of Technician e Tin the light of these instructions does not seem ta be in order. In case the Sapervisor (Mistry) does not get promoted as Junior Engineering Grade TH, he has to comtinus in the seale of Rs, $00- 7000 * Rsl00/ as personal to them and, therefore, ey could not possibly be reverted ty the & pos st of Technician Gre ade i. fn this cormection, Shri Walla has argued that a portion of the order dated 24.03. 2004 ig not in acctordanse with the restracturing order. The order dated 24.03.2004 js as number dated si) have bron GO-8000 ARSRP) posts of Mistry effect fro rom mo cadre of x ar} e ox Oy.
wee Fas st a"
in tne one.
3 Et of Cena md oy a AY ay FEN, Hn, uo ween TOR" seis Sonh, Heed are a thy {Rl wen, t en) Bara! 3 oD ' el GS o "sane wee ed he £2 < 4.3 a enien 'fem a Bs Vrs oa 2 A t dé wh wt ey on ns a5 Prnas O e a 3 oe 0 he 5 a 4d 2 - bee Po Nad 2 wy Hi os ord a is : * ' . : " oy is aed 4 hy Et nS it Ahn, Rech a tp r vay mea 2 4 om, rp # ge gg be tay & oR bony Sg $4 a : uy 3 oo M4 De ee ad CS ay at rt hey vet meg a wi 13 et . ic ic a 4 oot Te 4 as i) a : " X uP, S3 sy met sy ser} ay f " Sd EE Ly wt irs ey cs ad ree} OF deal %, ot wy 1 Or et a me as . Es . a Kay th, mo o Bet tency 'es "hed bs "E a a i OS GQ me