Veeragouda vs Shantakumar @ Shantappagowda on 5 November, 2008

[Cites 0, Cited by 17]

Karnataka High Court

Veeragouda vs Shantakumar @ Shantappagowda on 5 November, 2008

Bench: N.Kumar, Jawad Rahim

3% 'mm Ema mum' aw é aaaaama ;, s,3;ma::3 mag 's*a.~::«: ism may w§¥**..§§GvEM<3,§;3%. pEas§ﬁ$ 'rm §mwm,§g §m¢J"a?a?:*E£§i§~.§g ::

"

mm zwzmm V_.;:§:..w.2{.z® ﬂ§aT*§§£:E§§:_ 5..

.1. ,VEER2Ei§v{}Uf[}2% _ _' ii} 'xr:§:::3§t%€.{}Qa;§;A' ' '-

AéI3'sED ,m::;w'r._;~§6 ':rEA'm:' «:.:>4:::<.:': ; A.(}Ri'{i:i%LT§'i%R%E;v 32; G ,§*§~5}SFk15.R 'faf£LE;i§{§E ; ' em §3§f.€~.e"ﬁ', xmizzuzyge 584 mg.

% " §*ei;:;wmg;o:§u3§ ._ :3; :3» V«3R'U;§?A§°«§{'§={}U§)A m'3«§:m A;az;2»~aJ'£* 5;-'>2 Yams ' - 0{_:<.':"r.« ..Af%R§CU§.!'§"URE §?f;'.€.} E'§§}éI%£fR wzmaa '-- wag &:2">§$*:*. Eﬁﬁﬂﬂﬁﬁ 534 gm.

 %     5§§E';§§2HARAPE'AGf)£§DA

"  Si «:9» VERU?A£*EG£3E3.¥)2s%
 mam mom' 4% YEARS
«::;{:<:; : A£%§€§{3UL"§'URE
we HQSEJR VELLAGE
TQ &, mm: R*AiCHUR 5% mi.

4. S}§§VAE§é'%,JA¥*P'AG{}UD2%
3,511} V§§?$§j?!%.?§{}G£fDA i 

ﬁJ_,/'//

$ER}§(3¥.ﬁ'EV"Tj§a§%';;1¥E3§=¥:;5&'3§;"'A AGEQ AB{>§.,:*r 4:} YEARS -

(}€f;€.§ ; A.GR§'Ci}L'§'E_3RE V N we H(}$i,£R ''°.iELLA{.}:b .

TQ & mm': mxcnim 534 m1;».

5. mSAvARMA§>§>A@o£_:aAv--.}.1 age V'£§%E}Rf&E*==§G{}E.3Qﬁ * AGE?) ABGU'? 40,.-Y§:':AESa'"" -

GCC ; AGR§CUi!§'§}R%'3 5 , ~ _ Eff) zr§<}8wR"w:1;m«:;*« = * .

'3"Q 3% mar. mn::E--w§«z 3&4 '_ 1:33,. .4*&PPELLAP€Ti-15» my 3m_.rs:é5§;EE:§:=__ z<:§::«;é:.~m'4§é;é§§s::'£>%rgEaV;'A£>vc:(:A'ﬁ3*.} _5_:.§~m bémxuwiz Si-£A§'£T;&;§'§'é%€%QW.ﬁA $39 v*§;%.§.§.amA.:§z"3{;=::.;m=aV ' _- a::;r:;> AE{3=*§f'i"., 45:», ¥i:Ai%m 053:: : A(&R§€:€§L''§"E;5;§-1§E R; {:3 LHQSMR Vizmggt TQ Mi?) £}ESf?;. mzcmrsa

-V _ . mgpzasimmw _ V '3.'§"§'§€§'=.y\&5;Ri;5§' WPEMJ is §3'i'i,ED W3 4 mi?' "5'§~iE '§§;%.RN:'¥fA§{Ea §;3G§»§ {",'f~:}UR"§' ACT' PR&'%'E?~§'-i'.;- T0 SET ASEQE TE-§E ¥'J§€§';TnER' .i?i3:.S1;*:";E§:) 55% WZP. Nu. 1:J~.%33.3j2QC%'§' EZEATEED ¥ 'a ,. m.1's*a'§;£'}'?;' ' '~'_?§:ﬁ1!'i-"..'% WEE? EEPPEAL CGMENG _{)3'€ i3"'Q.R QRTQERS THEE V V' EE}1?;';'., KYL? J HELEVEREE TE-EE FGLLGWENG :~ sﬂﬁmﬁiﬁiﬁgfiiif '§°ihi3 is a piainﬁﬁa' appeai a.gam$% the vmtiaer mi" ﬂm imrnmi ssingie Judge: Whﬁ has amaw {aha "£12331 Cour': to by 'V " reaéézéveéé} 3}}? ' Li';

VV Vaiuzgxtian Act.

and dmidg iiassua N123 iaauez.

:3, "-am are $01' that grumaaﬁ af"'vL«:.£§:zvanée13{A :1-n_jt%m'm:gg,ina; $tii'£;

33 The pgmmﬁzws rim. =2-gﬁaziizﬁzsa am the 233:: 9.?"

the Aéfiiﬁﬁﬂfki' Juzigs i}ivi;:a?ﬁ§7n},v.§€:;§chur, far ma mﬁesf c;.t'7$a1r't1Tn72::sx3.' ifﬁth sham in ma szuii far a {Emma fcsr mﬁm§.. cf« ifmémmnmﬁam mwiveé by me ¢.§,&famiea3fz§:;. _ " '§'h£é fsied hia wrritéaen Smttsmam v:§~§& oommndexi that the mmpanmﬁan ém in mapmt ﬂf {ha Eaneﬁ acqujmd §:a»3«" that; Siam:

{"_2v{3véE*;3§ie:eant Vjwaé big cxciamiva pmgmriy. Ha spezrﬁnaiﬁy g,'*:'§~':-_§§iadV.i';§.'2é:;..- ﬂaw 'vmE'zm€1::E03::-. af that 3"§.1L§'3L ami payment 9%" ﬁxsd * ﬁat cﬁaim, cash piaiI:r$:iﬁ" écxmx to gay' ﬁrm Itbrguinari Cﬂﬂﬁ. Fee: é;.g31d:e3' $e~r:§:.é¢.>}:3 2.} «GE the Kzaxnamicza C0133': §3'a*:t:.s. and 311i? Cm we hams 0%" the afomaaid pkmixagsy $33226 rﬁziaﬁng is tins: fa: as C0m1"ffea§i. imam' Sxaczézétzn 3..:'":3(2} iza wmgxg, Maxi insuﬁwriwcni. A93 ', ./

5.

2/ /"

// CE»;n.mz beiesw framatai as; "many ax; ~;3s:m;;s3q I 'I'Wh%é'[ 333"' Visage ﬁamﬁd. by ?.§.'3.ﬁ Courri 313 E5253': tmeier :~~ 'W§':er£}1e.r' ﬁle £iEf@ﬁ£i%?%§i~§'£?€)E#E=S '3?:t:£V.£§;i{2 {T€}'f4i?"i fa?-E mid is; iigmgﬂffqieni?

4, '"3'I§3m'%3::zﬂ'm", the: undar §3ee::$;%(:an .1 Ti {if§'§'i1:$~««7:V§§§Z3}'II!€z¥:Ei1§§i Suita Xfaiuaiian. A-3,1953 Via) $3.5 'the £3ss::t'} $53 $33! 3.11:5 ét:c:i£i;*% :A:iA§'é{e§§'ﬁ%'1.; ,§.<_=ss:3m:.. 'l?'§3«:*: said appﬁcgsﬁalaa 'wz»},<v.»3 v.*;'. _:i'I:24§' éiriai {.3::mr': 9223 mg. grurimmzi thai kiss: §!s312§."§r;_jgj§*eI1;ii£i§;gﬁ is a. mixed qu»3:'~3i"is:m mi' ﬁaw anti fza;s:?4.;j5§1':z.§L...ii {3ﬂIl3E:.';}1TJ§3$:£3 §.zt2.§=s.i::zi smﬁ ﬂied 315$ a gareﬁxnixxmy imuer. " 09:16:' ﬁm ciesfezmﬁazkt p31=:ﬁ=':11'e:=d_ a Wzﬁ {'.T»m.zIt, '3' §1'u":'. kramlad singité Jamgc aﬂm' 2i:§§;i':éng :«?c'_= :§-.=.-:-1ﬁ}~.<_=sa=.:n¢,:i'iva3:n {2} sf Bmtiiaxi 11 mi" that am, hetﬁd that {ha-:2 afqrigmiﬁ }_}.¥%'}E1'§3a§e€,?n mandafxta 333 qucsﬁama miating ta " §i§§mI'$aE:1at%an Of £3124: $13.2h=j§t2c'§; maﬁa: tsf '¥;'§'.&i£? smii: amﬁ yaymezxt V93' the max': saxrjsing can 'é:}.:e:: basés Bf the: gxﬁﬂint and waéimxx R ":=§'§;a£3°a:m@mf. ahaeii EM: hmrzi and aim:&de1»':d befam avédeacaa iﬁ Rﬁﬁﬁfiﬂiﬂii ﬂﬁﬁﬂﬁiig mach di-:fe3:2';:.im';$., 011 merits emf 'Eh: ciaém. '§'h€:r::f%:>3'E, he humid mat 333%: iﬁﬂllfi :I;a=:§a%;.i:.r»:;g :89 {L',{3é_i_fi »::};é.£:1§§Eai§ 13:: , aa 3 §I>3}i'm3'nm'§* ismm. ﬁ;ggi§:v§::j'£" Err}; aw _'€?i ($1-{§€)3',VV:'::."A me p§air3.i:§.f.¥':a am $11 aippeai' ii '§'Zm: Emmzmvzl mmmzmi f€:a*"'iii§;;- §§§;ai11f_i£¥$'&:;:5.aai§ing the impumaﬁ Eﬁfdﬂf 0f the A.g:.::r;;.?e_if::3r3£ist:€i than in mm 0%' ﬁm .§~mig.::am: /«3§§"*'é.%3.é:a éfkfizart. ﬂm mm £% the: imsagz: r4:g&:s?d§3:a.g crcauri; §vi§;:§:;§:%th+:r imuea and not aa a ﬁiﬁﬁmilgafj; iagﬁzﬁ Em far méﬂing asidza §',§}€.':

asssairi mf::is=:1*, ' 5;; "

¥&§£&".:=:: (raw, 'the: §e::%3a"§'a€.*::'i '--- :.=_«*.';£.:r,§.g§e=§ d."§1§i.:s§&é Q7§.§:h~i3 Cxxeuri hag ha-«iﬁ 33 m::ée*;§';~ ":3*i;:A:.2@ €§2»E pemmimjzg ju3isé§:z:ﬁ4::ia (3; am 5:21;; Civii j z€4)§{Q§r£i :15; mm 4:§2¢«3::~s£$°{arva%é¥. £53;-.a§:.' iamw af me paifafé Qf V " ez:Eeie7?m'ntz?:ion af{.?m,;r§ Fees mm be tried afnng zmﬂz A mhw 'éssmras. Fzaréiwr, Samiarz I [E {If the {;'}?.SE'" Ad, 3958 'iiﬁﬁﬁ? mxzdae R:é:«eg;3're.g in view: zhéa pamanﬁzmy j'2gr°z2<:§(3iec*£§:;n egg' ﬁrm: éhém .M'm>'13zf§" fawn: Civii «fuﬁge:

gliﬂiﬁtmj mad C3;'m"§ Jzmige {new £f}:"m'i z.§v¥,£$Z§§€ 'ﬁ¥ Em, aﬁer £525: Cfiiy fﬁivif Clﬁuii $493, J§§3'?9 «Emma irate s I"

E15',//A " '~ a§:.1:;f§_i€;r ,_§}i:r§s:ia3I1 Judgea, %x1%0r Divisian and '§a€:{':a*e.m:é;2e21£;§7';§1:}t'§$M§i::%it:s11 af thaw C-warts izava hm}: c:£m.":.'iy Kamataka eiﬁivii C{'3i§l'?;:':'e 55.9%., 196%. T316 Wifiga pawns' of the Caimré; tn 4.'$€:=::i<i€: that imsus miaﬁrzg ta ' *3;§S3'«w§3mt 0f smurf. fem 3:::s3.€it31' Sf3£?'§i{.>31 1.1 izef €313 Act if a Cfivii 44 _,,_«}§1dgﬁ, eéumecsrz' {)ivi:-simi, 3191653 ﬁmi. ﬁn? mziit 113 next 'Q1T3§J»€:ITif;' ﬁwm, Seriiana .3} 9}' the {1"FS%'_.,:'§::£._};zz3 cmzeyzriaaai, them is §ag%._f;§§r §5'm.:£§«f3§£r;§'~~ beiaw 19 try the iagam mining "az;z'£;'& s:1_£p'$é:3f Wag ' ' burden: is an the g;§a:"u7n.t;'ffI3_v'i:}..'ea5££é£z¥§i.3?z vi?Lii"a§ imgie pmperigg trained timer rmzi gﬁéziziéi T Cam}? Fee. Unﬁerzfé amérﬁ "a:§fm§a;s§an4w§§;~.,» ifiﬁ petiiionem _f2'§i:r2;§;r «czmu Qf C¢?rH,vrrim=si{3rz.g3r {gm}? ;m:;i§_2.m '§%'.)§.'§L.'35'if'L!'Eé3?'i'?t!:3'iEi* the: iZ?:31.§2'*§.v}33i--:«s-:7 Vg;za§;€¢:§_;ie iﬁaéjhrés. V ﬁﬁfaar iaasuess is u2i£h:.r:_g.3"gi3'z3; g;=;rat_;}e;;za§::..l..' "

Ts. it E fﬁgfﬁaii kiggé Qifivii C'»:;m:i"t at Bazalgafiezrm has 113113lx1z3i?2':ii jé3XTiS€§§§§'3'i§,?.7ii}v. w;%;;;m.as that Civii C.om*i:=.=. aittzamd i_?v"R.§§'.:%i:(3_:'.j i"}:zcL 'Ba§3ga}:aré"v{3if3? am Ciaaséﬁad .i;n'ﬁ:0 {_'.-mi}. Judga, ﬁﬁﬁgdiatkyn eiﬁﬁazexé in 32253 said diet is naming 31;: do vaitami £::11¢_i ?;§:z<r: vaiiaafrism 0f that suit is mane than im §w;:':1:_m.§ar§r 3'?%3.rim§iciiQ11 in 3'u«::h Circumatanmim it hm: in mham the igﬁs.-':.in*€.. _ \l&~(__,//v//A But, it has nutismg ix: sit; with Seu=3ﬁ»;:g:e1....§,_1_Qi' $261..

$2 The ﬂaming {if 331 ahtsuii Law which ﬁg Cuntaixami vim .i:ht3 E'1%3Qa::§'a1n; EQQ8, far :§}.'B.ﬂ.'§'§. hetminaﬁmr (S330 2 'vﬁf}§;v:»§@:=v KEV emf the CFC 'gmésvidea far setiipmgnt s:a:E7'ji.1.*:"§':'?:e;2§§i$ uf amii' mm iﬁﬂklﬁﬁ {pf V' ,:§$$é§_§::3 arise in a Sui':

Wham a is ajﬁzmm by thc {me .'§:"7§.;§%'3:_ :i§'}ﬁ3:€1f§';VV§V;ﬁS?»E}.§3S am «af '§'.'W(} kixxair-5: {3} iezesuets agf 311 a aaxiig i:=§.*§sm:§ bath af iaw fa<:t1:":;":-:1a'y .223':-$5: 'f93'%§un3idemh7nn.. Them may éma imgtzas 'V V' _ e:..M_mix%ai'£;;a--.-aaﬁen 0%" fan': and Sam. VA'i?:§:?:p1'ema Sam": in the cam ui' . ' §:.¢m.m:@H mm mm % 4%;

ixxts-:2r§é:'g§:A§§1g Chtissl" 1*-3» Rule: 2 {sf {ha CFC prinar ts» amcnaimezré. 5i'¥;}?ﬁ haﬁ a3 '§.Eﬂd#3."B'.':"~ "ifrsgtier {krder I 4 Ewe 2*. whem ismzwﬁ émﬁizs Qf Eatw and 0f fact mitsea in 333:9: ﬁmte gmii, and the (bar? 235 {Eff apinian. ifam the case car any paﬂ ihemaf may Em dispmseeré af an we £55ue5 of Esxw ezniy, 353% /~ /' // Lr ahaif £1611; tiume iS51.£€$ ﬁmé, ayaé _ .V may, if 5;' ihinﬁca ﬁi, pasipane £hEg saiiiéivméiﬁﬁi isasrues Gf ftmi mmii after the iS§:;e$' ~_::§f imx§ _--§zm:eza 2 n K Ewen. ¢£«a*£ée:rw1.ined Wee juﬁigéiﬁéan ii: 3,'r;r;;.i;-.m»:;é::~:a«:._§gg"VV $9.11: @4131 _;'"mm 2&6: '§S'5'¥.h'?:&"§ rmy €.i'Fi.§'_§§ wézzeére in She é3,;:*.:2_27:v'a.:'9;~'ir;'Vi:§14,?" efféegri the? éiihrrfke :§;2£:'€ m.¢tz;g; £38 dispagééi Q3? éigaisgaﬁ Saw aierw, bui me i:"f::3»:§»g_(:z':;r §:r;=§..n§_.;,}m {Faun £43 £33; .12 41);'; _f::zd as p:reEz'r?g§3m;?3g .§§'€>zgn.t§£333 aa§E the iasrues in a Sm} : mm :4; {$1} $0, 'i.?2§é ~::§Eé,>'::§Sia§'_é: Véiiyvissuas even. :23' im; cf ESSEXBS affam umuﬁari mﬁmii in :1 §f§A§¥°S}§{§E£?E'.'§;ﬁ§é§ bf aha suit. "

Elxxia hag-« 'Sagan suhaﬁttztmd by {$96 fimmndmﬁnt ' .&°i€§:'{ CEIREE inm iiﬁbzsi ﬁnm I.2,3§'3'""é'. it maﬁa 5&3 isndari ' ;:::;: ma «R T z'§$%$"E$§a3.« {E} 4}§*§2€:a;i£§z:5£e31z::/25335:; iizm" 0: game may be V " ziéspacmxi {pf an at pr«z-ﬁéimémang iemue, the {ham .8fm§?, A azmfﬁerd is} £319 pravﬁiazgs af m.¢b«~mie £2}, ywmmimm judggraeraé an ad! §::~"sm,5:3&.

{2} Wham "éaazms bath uf ism.' mus? afﬁwﬁ arﬁae in the éﬁiﬂﬂﬂ mgii, mid 25% Quart is af upinian /.

fizzy the mime 93* may mm £}w:reaf may 3%.: zﬁxprmesi x :./' /, / af an em, issue if my azﬁyﬁ ié :'.z*_u3.y__i:vy jfm£§:f'z§'at1iia*.*su3 raé:3m,£¢=::=; aw ' '4 h < {ii} ii3e'¥;€:?j¥.é3"¥:'f§£.'?.3Tt£'.§§5{3'§'; sf ihé 03"

g5} 51 bar $43 $23 fits? me Sime baiwg ;i'm.°am,, and fa;¥'t;p;;z 3*: zhmm ﬁi, pG5;£;m;3~;ae:i'h£: ':sr§23$§€}:§?::3n5i' aihm"

' ' "junﬁi '§fté'2i' "§F§.§'T§:;Q'£ has éamm ' dam' with ﬁw * i;2._';$;c%$i2%£§s32%§§fue iggith me desiﬁian an 'V Thez sub3'é,tu'md §;?§'%}'$i(§.B&1 §;B:ea'é:, a C('.}ﬂL'ﬂ'§. miemf. givg _§u.cEgf_je::i4:*é1§: an aii .2l;_a$é;m::*s §:r1§t W}'.3.f.'>1'ﬁ may 3'$sm4:*, {rf law miaica ta " £t'i1;({?' 9f the: Court mg' bar iii)» zmii', the: Cﬂtlﬁi may pqggqwgzaé'-«.3§Vi?.E£m::ni elf :7=t§:1&:' iamxm 'untﬁ ﬂat aﬁumsaid iamm }.aa:f~§ V§'3€;e%x:.d%';--§x:n:1i31e,ai as 8 pmiiminazy issue and the Emir:

may $1533 with the amt in accuréazzm with ma dacréaiatzm e'.m that " ';§3E€§imi31m§* imue. "rm-2 gmwm {Jf ﬁm Czmmt ta émﬁiéa the: ﬁgsrﬁliminaxjy iaaua and paatpone satﬁemani of ether iaaiaea £3 a éiacreﬁanmy and mat mandamajn Aftﬁr 1§"§""€.e fkmtzndmaxlt, my atiisasr immitss m'$§r.u;:;r than the iaaues of imv mﬁaﬁng in {$3 ii} jurisdictien af §:h.¢°: €".im11't, {ii} bar to iha_suiji._ §::m3."3ﬁ§.' gigggg be desicidtzd as pmiiﬂkﬂaaxy iszaue. '.1"h(:->i$5 i; quazsticxn emf ﬂaw am ziistiizgfaaishazi ﬁxixﬁti £;;:1g:§§?§;é~3§$5:§$%ri' and :i'em'ii. While iméazr the aid E 203: vhf ugly, a suit might Em d:s;;wm3:¢§§_ the; :§?§{:%;f§$'3;:;}13J$£iVvi'§) ¥;%§~y thaw iﬁﬁnﬁﬁ ﬁmt, Linda" the may B0-magi in my these: issum in. the: Suit, mibjexzt ta .7§m'iséicii«:_:«n ansri Ram' mi' guilt, "ih..'2..cc>»c;'s§3.:'%: may mam: iamzewa ﬁrm. ..-*§'h§: gjvem rm §'a11":3ME§{:ﬁ::an £10 1z':::*y an aguemiam czef iaw and fact as is5i'ws:_V_aﬂ '§'hé:. ar.whjzH:*a'_ «(sf Qlﬂar KEV' 22 $3 $9 axrgiai tfiai anﬁ «scan:-*.:::q=s1s;'2%".é§s1 pmt;"a«c£€:ai Eiﬁgahien. it wa:m§7d v..vIs*a:;;;;; }2<;;;:;.m¢:*.>cr»::&s:§s51z:£*3»* mmmxﬁ and thtm at SGEEIYJE mi"

'§;[3'??;f§".'§.'E£<\'ff?§§'.:$.<Z*="§#A":':r3;vf; éiﬁgation, 3%: WQ'§l3£i am-;iai 'W§':k$iZf:";* mi" time: and u1ma::i;:::$ézza3'3,I axyenms to 'Em: parhﬁgzze-as 11, Th€3Tf@fOE'€, that yssiez is? ihti €3¢:»~m'*'¥; ahafﬁ pmnaanm .--.§ud.g1m3;1'3.'i an $33 31331183. The army &XC€§3?§€3ﬂ is Wham iamutss mlatss; is 'f§a11:i:»taiia:'£i¢;2n af tbs Cami? 4375' ":3, ha!' tag the suit czmamd by any £3329 £4333: ma time haing in ibma", 'which mm &\//_W V E3 ;_1»'&1m§§r imaxesa 93" iaw, and $5: cam. cs3'_&3ef.=s.§i_§}:irt_' dig? emf in anﬁwwirxg ﬁmt iﬂE'iEﬁ,:'-,th€1:"{:§Gi1E"§L:"§$2E$:§jaI'j '§L'T§V if mane ﬁmt ﬁ.c:q., as a Tiasgie. v'i'i7':i3:4§:'V'1%",£1mx;: i;%§«: vé E3" the: Cicauréz .has:: Em ﬁzkﬁﬁciéciiun £393 sﬁiiw }¥J:§i$na:n'i mndemzti by §.*"9§.i{":}.§ £.:m.a:.ri' :3iaf:Li,':§;f«Va_:.:=_.,'Vvv:'r'.:::--..'r;{§ $2 ﬁjmzh gem z.1§:§§r:<.:ﬁ0n muid has aim: and :.=m.cE3. 3 §:¢::£.,:mz=: in mxﬁm' ta aavémid such mnﬁn;g%$:#%;'3z§ Ems: of the Cm'ar't arid paaiaiigt it 'basal an gcmai ﬁigbiixs 'pm£ﬁ€:u3v§:':'-.' Ema nuthmg ta do wiﬂa the Valaaﬁezazi £;h.e: :§*e.1<'i§"a>§'¢.:¢1.i'i.»-- cef that suii, :32' the: Smart fm '§3a§?§g¥'jE£t gm. :=§12(:fa;.§§§:E3?~t:>z:if matmr, Thrzr. law mizﬁiing in {Ewart fem " ::1;r;u:d¥"g;€ saaits and iﬁe diatﬁxminatims ad" the fag payabie = 'ihﬁ Kamaataéia fleuﬁ §'::l:t:=.% 3:21;} ﬁhxiiﬁ "§;és;3_;3a'¥.*§£;£;. Ps.4~':;:--§:, }958, Themfarss 'ﬁne iﬁﬁéiﬁ H::§ati1;.g to vaiuaﬁan csf atziis ézzad {";«::>ux't faez payahie: an Suita are m Essa a§a::.'£'m*min&d " 'aim: 'iEEii€i Act.

1'2. The Kargxataka Cam': Fem amﬂ S13:£'a:§3, Vahmﬁaasﬁ Acti, 3.958 was auactﬁd ta amﬁnd and rxxnaaeizéciaiﬁ $36: imam miaﬁng '£9 Ewart fam 312$ vaiuaiaimx. 01" aéaéis :33; ﬁgs: Siam af, /4,;

.2 Hazxzatakag iflhaptar E33 cf that Amt? r.EmaE,3..w:iji§3 of u x $336 §.3§:'$.§Y-£i§3t';'. Sacﬁon ii} (xi ﬂag Arci. mégﬂdﬁzﬁiﬁﬁ 7/ amaﬁ ﬁle witty} $316: piainii, 3 amtamengt in Vfiige' afvé :§}»'£iI'ﬁC¥.1§£11"§§ csf 'éfhe. Suhjeizaczt mattm _:f§§a'%tV $155 véﬁuaﬁezé. thaiwmf uniaﬂsa such ﬁrm: vaivﬁaﬁgnxz are Qceniraizlmié iu the piaizm. ' mi the {ZPQ pmvides that $736 0;? %.ha:=: vafhm Caf tiw m1i:3?:3{;t";£§:%f;~.a;3§%;51F 3,3113% Qfj'u1'iadici"§t:»:1 and 0:? :»i§:;~;:':fara%.§;--.w..a§dmita. Seafiwxs 13 (Is? ﬁm ﬁsaztti, €§§'§z~::§ﬁ.i4V;.';(L:i. €%2?I4'I;S:f;&I'.'F£i3. R3 in §15I'0'§f':I' few: in Caurfgz-3. ii: fﬁﬁdﬁ aynxzmim" :3 33 .

EV «m§%'£a»§@%par_§"m in ~ rfiﬁfn __ *¢32;f§3::**jgg amii in5'i£3:££1:§1é£3? in may e.'30uIi 3/he Cam': simfi ' " -. §}%°'j{;¥€«Q>fd£%r§ZV&g; the picairaé in» be mgimmed, deg-egim iaiggiéériafsa asmzi £:§.§§Egﬁ£ii£.?§f'l~$? mnzairmgi in the pfmizii §j_zr£:;? an the m,a;$€:riaiS mnéaineai £33. 'aha §f rxmy, ﬁfasd Wlfiﬂf mardian 30, 23223 pmpm"

fair §}a3;a£?!e £h»2rea:>r:,' ﬁhe &e.m'sia1r2; be'ireg' }wwm»~e;.r ' "'A.'.'S§.£§.3§€;?C2 £6» Tﬁﬁiiéfiif. _,é'w*"£§ze':':r review, esmeri mrmdimz in H ifw ?m:m3'2,er apemﬁaaed in tile 5.-tmmeetiirzg subw aeavzﬁéang.

13 52; A313; :iefey2.d{.§n,£ me_2}:;,... 524:; his" % .s3z'mILmn.¢z:§z£ ﬁieﬁ fsrqfhre thee: fimt %§;>¢,z;ar'i1fa,g;;3<s;;%'" £i'.=;;:v é~3zgiiI7--.(a§*" u Exafare miigigmte '£55 réamrrﬁemi an 'E.§:.¢é"af;92.:z«:2>**§z'.:a: g;=_f' '£f:.a*=>J~ attfézirn £21331', Subject In 3323 aggaméaﬁng 3u$éfve&1f§)i?ei;~ mi-3 imimf, pkatza'. them' time 3m?£}jee.f:;i~rz:fm.i£e?"cf$hé 31$:

mm mm' beaara f}?"(}§}%§§'§§;_1?€1§£&§3§§'{5i'L.:§?;t£2é§i"3»§i§3_f'ﬂéﬁé}d5iéi{§x§S nut suﬂidayai. 232'? aims ahxaji be hgzxrzi ermxf is mmrde££ mjfe;§ér'§q §e{en3;t§:i2;£,. ﬁfgjfﬁfzée mgriiﬁ Gf 'ggﬂmgggggg iixcm the Sﬁéijﬁﬂéw '§ta:,§'.:é?m2v:baéen fp}aperEy arafued :32"

saggﬁﬁéﬁig the ¢C?«::m*£ SEMI? ﬁx .vV:'3: :i£:¢té 22efk§»*é:'?;.§h£$,§éA' yitzint 3ha§§ he ammded in _£'}";?:.«e.°% r£L:"4:z:2g:'z"°.*,«3 ::im.*x':s:::'anV mad 331.6:

V_ §ief§t:f§"=f§é£§ .:§§§;£.a,§§"v_§:;§55"",gM;::'£§, 3}" the pimfnﬁ Em "mm mzwugedf ¢>;.«.)g;{11;;;+g.gieﬁc::;ge be moi paid'. within me éﬁigzzyed, Iihe piaimf shag'? be mjedmi and me T. gm:-2. pfsiﬁﬁ mach zmier am it {.iee;r1r:.ss jam ' re:g}::sf,c§i§é.{g (X15 £33 «:5? $3152 .:=3'ui£. {Z3} A ciezffmuiami miderd ggzféer issaxezs have ?}éé:n._freHr2.e§£ an £533 meriis-:2 qf ﬁne étgfliffk awn, in éfuee wriiien amienzazzt ﬂied by hint, piead ﬁmi £5228 subjem~m£z;iie'r of £323 aux? ha3 mi been pmperig zszzizmd 4:22" zffmf ihe fag paiai rm: smﬁicrieni. ﬁg}? Q ¢mfi&m_ éshéiif Em heard mazi sfzafded befcere evidmzm is mmrd3c§_gﬁ'3m5:zg 53.2.42}:

\2»/ M ziefénziawai. an iﬁﬁ menﬁig «:2»? the .v:':fs.'zé% aizéﬁd' ' mm? fimis ihai ihe mgbjemarrmiiéar QfT'2£}~.é"§1;§§£A ?':.s:2:Si:--.' 'V amt ﬁegn pmﬁézrfy vzzeiemﬁ at ﬁlm féﬁe gig 'Rm: V' a1.c;fﬁ4:jem.i, 33:49 mm': 5h£g3E'_fg§§'a:z§.:r £hé'§a2'ee:e:$z;w§e c.§:;m;n in mgbwﬁmbﬁem meciiara ' 2 2 ".f'¥}}tffzi?1:g;;:w '- . ~ '~°§§"€££3'"Sé¥C§§:€2R $53353 ﬂgipfy in :1 ::,i£=:fe::3mié23fa£ §erz<.§_ :;*m.s.s¢:::" er 4:; r*epre$gn§{;ii:3e i:%§Wé"f£ie':fea_£' éitefﬁidant wha wzm 0:3i3r@mv.§?§__.h2?j§2ra1:i§§5&££S: j"£:¥§e2*.é'_;'}'imw.aci am the znez/2':i;.:_¢_:f agaparfumtgg an j§?§:**'e:2_g;;é;c:f££e§'iii:;s§s:az€é3:r§*zazr2;2 ihmi ihe aubjeda-= Zffaaiiar ;m€.;;:4m;3e'r§g; vcziued 9:' 251%'?

éhe fag z}2zTc_§:..°::_rz'/<23'v._'§'§::»42_«g'.?'«w£'e9<e.2. *'?{£R} 'i»'§r'.?é:en«é:1:er m {use e:":{21rm.»::$ up befam at §;£:§4:f..A_ af 'iﬁ ssizzaff be Emgﬁgf fm* iim wwi, <'£v?,'3.,§§§7.E=i','§?'."v«€".3§'é'~'.*vi £33 awn maﬁnn 92* an the appéimaﬁ-an «sf " aﬁﬁy. bf _pe::;r'££¢e.*$, ta} mnsidm iiw m;r're2c:£rae.:=.:3 -ngf ag:3g?'.§§f:£«§:r }'}§3.~1"'3$€E?d by the Samar azmrﬁ aﬁeding éhe ' jiseg 3j>:iya.b§e an am; g:a§e:::1}z£ er in may aims?" gsmmreﬁing £22323 Egwer war: and daiewmine £529 prayer "fee V . . pmycifyie ﬁwmun A mag ::eEm.E£ Exes iimzrrwd in «Mme: ésvefam 4:; Cfmsjri of appeai mawsrz 2}" mg mppeai ?'e£a€e:.§s asrafy in aa Vpgﬂ 9}" the: 5:ui3jed«m,a£"£e::r 0;" me:

x / :.~:uii. }'5*/ xv"

3.5 {£2} .33' 3.52.423 mm €23?" appea3.z:§ec3§£Eas z"§:§:§éV"§;:g--'IVn;;«z»§é' pgzﬁd in time: Samar mm'? :35; rm§V=.A3z£ﬂ'i€§§,¥?'2.£,"=§§'éa.Ce?2°,e§'§' ahgzff mqzzirsa that gzmrﬁy Eigziefe §'apgé§;._£§'ae: fee I.ffi£§1i?'1 mmh ﬁirrze as Hwy ii? ' . V am} if 331:2,--- ?~,:;,».;§e::§::_;'aae --$§f ;='e,4}£* pmki ggyizg-af~;».:~:}m ﬁrm: ﬁxed {viii f§?'é; 4:}? £1. mﬁgf 'wﬁaiah hag beam iii}:-;*-.

zazhicth ¥§¥€3:%1§23?E§3{'.%B"£.i '_;1;;pe£§£* Siim €§§§§J*E:'£E§ 3.32135? if :13 in mmﬁpecﬁ (_:;!' déwéeﬁ E33; 3319: fewer .»e'.ii£.9'a"j;§3*'".{,, _€f£:s ;;'?"e3e"-..3§m§f'E"'§;e':'"remz:era:i'>§42 as if if ' 13:33:35.: -- gm. V iérraggf' -93? §éaI;fa££--- WEEIQHHE. {{3} £3'a5.¢ in 25%? iawer mm? £3 in ' --ve2;;:oa3.*§, ﬁfmii téimai fin": mﬁmﬁ of §§£8 ggsﬁaws 21:} £56 3}-.::5"éy m§m £3 mﬁiiad $9 $2. $3? egazeﬁ;-siéayas ass; ia Exgggge far mg ' Q Vg;g'm.VvV'L:~5$g; iyﬁng gins: ﬁwfadiﬁimrz mi' {mm e2_;i>*é:'ciIr& an 32.3 wriiéen sifggeameni wf a daienﬁaai " §§9§a,§§ ha heszrzi maxi fﬁgiﬁgﬁed befzam emiéanm £23.»: n 'T _a_:"_;_s;_;L__az;,:1r@ed e:2ﬁ2a~:3§':':ng 33¢: de emiéxygg, an rmeriis Gf ifaae ziaim In ihis Ea-eﬁiana the atwrexsssiain "merits 13;' the <:§m'm"' wfeam in Hmffem wiaiah aralw ﬁﬁf" ziemnniuatinn in mg maii, mii beﬁzg rzaaiﬁem LX /-

',.

merits ai" ﬁxes: sciaim. in cathar wmwissg mgmﬁing mum .f'E";t'5 is 1'aim°:».:'L ﬁm jivsiﬁésli' 7/ bcifam recaréiag aviaianm an viéfilzgy V vé nnanéate. wf iaw is wry ciaaz', N0 éisﬁﬁﬁpn (Baum far pemtpmmag the: :ﬁg17~3§;;:é§~.;3f muﬁ mam :~mc}3. :3 pkg ia taken in er bafam '£'.h¢t ¢::vid.¢:mc«3 is --

14. 'F§3~,g: i2a3:'g;;c .:z:ga3;?d5;§§;«.¢x§i:3'i fee: nmxnaiiy wmuki ha: 3 uzrixaii a:,§'u4:%3"£§€§iiIef;af _§a§§'*§ mgetﬁfacz', .* Eviatkinm £3 ta: he mwydmig Meamiy banana": i.':'§;V"Vi&~';':;jl'Iz'(':f€i',V"i'.5':_$'.i-.'} mcarﬁcd can that mid ésmm fhai Visa nut gzbunti §r}_€ii.£i=.m an that isssm": aaiwxxg wéﬁna .4 4. a3tb%:f*i3,s1:®:aM_s;rx3 W:§iie::3*s.----aisa avidenee $53 1'§¢."ﬁ.¥f3§3$33':';."£j§'. Ef {ha imam gffzza is heiii agaixmt the piaintiﬁ" amri the gm}: ﬁlm mvixrt Em pmacxébaé by Tim': Catsmi in %;h§3 :;:T£*¢"ié§:;;1j, 'iihéa law mandates; that éizste i'_'km:.e.'i 5333331 mjmrt the fgizxini, that? 'Rim '§smati¢;>§1:i timc 0:3' mmcnrding mridsnm an €J§'.§.}ﬁ.'i"

"i_é.s:;:s:'s: is gavmi am} ﬂéﬁ", dafeméaat is 110%: hamzﬁa-mi in me fe:>1':m M » aria}. Tharefom, 'thia Secﬁnn is §'sa:smi can gmzvd guiﬂic mail it has Bathing to $0 with the Buangaiam City iffsivﬁi ﬁfuurté A9: GI' its juzésdic-ﬂan in tijg the: swim bcfnm it imzﬁamaﬁiy,' gs" //,..

13 '£2333, iﬁﬁuti mgmmiing mun £68 may 3130 énvnivee égagaatiﬁxg azxf T' p@v;3u:{;;im"3=' j'&3zﬁi:=;£1;i4:.f3lam1. in anawazing ihé ' aaié i$:~.:re1§:é',«.:;§ ﬂrxet Cmﬂrt hams that the stabjmt §§;zgi:€.s:=:1' ii-;3l_..;§m'«{:z:s"a3«. "

that vaiue QVQI which than maid C-1';'1>".¥,"£:E:3';'.*~33.%':k£':'a }'Ei£*§;;§£iiI};15:i(.'21f1,VV"§.7é";"§'§..*é£:~.%s$9 x&=:%Em'n «rm: gpiaint far §3'€s2;n§:aﬁcan3i:9 "§3?T§?3I)€if}"§.:1«€J="{§Iff$.,

15. {Eider KW thc g:°::m°:m§ guemvisiasn arxf V a§isf"'Vj:~§%:1iL=§ and iﬁﬁﬁﬂﬁ incfiudmg a§;§\ ias_s:s:w;. '§'Zw.: Eiagnaiaizea imam": £3 a S 2.3%', it hm;

3*r_':<3t;iW::f3 '- V2"E::§c£Mv.i§:%:z'2:;'.%iti{§n$; of india, it pmvmiis mm? ighs: gtt11€:1'%&§L}EgW. "it 'i};<:.vA'§a;fe2§l.}E'--.;aét%;[email protected] Whﬁﬂ a spméai mmia has %mr::;af;§"§*;;1:f::::-;§e;':,2:°i§:$e:r;'£ fhgéggr' Q3 ggeeiai Ema? in ﬁes: a pa§'§:ic2;,iaaex" jwb 8:23' ta} 3:v<ei'{':i3é ':'L§1¢ '~§ﬂW'=§'3X' in 31:;:T§z::Ii".i4,m Lia; 1-"§'%.R§)§i't{t"§. theretmdar, than V' §§§3;g.:ciaE.V ".°r::e.?e_m £§;2e ;p:'t*;vaé.§T mm? the gtmerai. Em»? and ﬁtm mmiss:

apcciai Eaw wabtﬁai I%3.av¢a mu ha fez-ﬂawed ia GE maitxsm cevecreﬁ 'Ehi%I"f,.'iE3.. Se:-«::fim.1:, 13 {If that Ami, " sﬁéicﬁﬁcaiﬁy eicztaia with €"§&fX§i5ii%Z3}1 am his "prayer f®@ in Cnuﬁia, Et givsaa: 23. gpearriai diizwtﬁmu $13 'that Cxaurﬁ; in ﬁmidzs 'firm i$:3$'£3ﬁ3 " 19t:1£z§:i;;'3g as waiuation and Camuré. far, §3e::.f<:m: armfmﬁing {sf Eviémltrﬂ can m:°:1'ii§_»'. {if ﬁgs Qastt. Thﬂmfana, in at} far as tint EV /' ' .»5'¢ 19 iﬁﬁlieifﬁ miaﬁng ta valuation and Ca::_¢;z;7§,_§&:-at "¢Emf1;q::::~,:';*2;:§Q:i§ Qcnrim' LX133' .§9€1:§Et?. -Hf 333%: {E 3 has $32': 3fi§-;LE€ifi»z_v ii if A{:§.. '§'i1:_:m3E%::3*¢':, .2-115 [email protected];3:':.5; aIi:"a§1_:'g_"with é'a?_:ilé1*e":1*a4:ts:; 'E45: A.§fr£3E¥{£§;¥T.§§;E?ﬂ 2312:} {3am1r'fa p€:i3?Ei§.'§§€5 :=5s%:m}i§ 'E*.z:»<;".*.v'vL4j'Mi'.'»:=;.;'fa§*r._iVV 'i";£:.§2:»'m3:

€3,'632§d.€3.3.(3ﬁ 51$ remggﬁmi aifex-%§§.ng «rm fgxeﬁiﬂ Inf iha ciaim. "i'hi$~:. ﬁﬁptfﬁi; in §§'&£§.'z~S€C§;i€}E&g {:'~':}}' I .~§'he;~€::§Z'::7m, tbs inigsmimn Tm: wazriiﬁ "$1233 ha hamﬂ" gmviaiaaa, meégm it aﬂmr tﬁai £3 ardatrr to amide the :=;:.>ria"§ i$:a:§&"*%§%h¢eth€§I is :3 hrs mefsnréad or mm: is ixnmaiéxiai. it ia. i:ﬁ.mat€Xéai in ﬁnd um; whcthm" wfhc issue, 'A mgémiizig v3a3'a.'.s:a?é~;33ztL 3.1m} €i"Xmrt fast is a yum agguaamiigxa ssxf haw m' iii Vmi:ile:dVV4k;;.3faéé:$3V§E§v;§;;($~' of iaw mad fact 43:" an paazm <§'a3¢;::'«.%tiacs-1.: czaf fmt'{.. Wi3.g§a is takssn that the. suit has mist basin pmpzzﬁy V2-£1166}? ,;:J'f%~ fhai iht': fat: paié is ﬂﬁf. suﬁcient isaua arising can V' pims shaii has hmrﬁ and dmsidctd bafem ﬁvﬁﬁaiznce £3 7E§€i€?£')I'£'§,§3{§ em. ."§§}ﬁ"K°.i§'.$ csf ﬁlm ciaim.

36. '§'3_1.i.=-3' "%i'.'E€:'W 03? <.>'m':% is; szagvgaezigxi by 53 péethozm Q2? 0333?» rieciséémi by ﬂit: Apt-:1»: C:3m"£ as waﬁ ax this: Camxrt. Tim Sugammr:

2.xV/ V H Héﬁhaptm iii {pf €3.16 ﬁat.

2% Cimjri in thc cage. Qf .5 gm 3%.: m .3395} étzaiing with me gmﬁ :A«;~:":%§eid'* E_§a;.a'i, 1:132: C-é)§}1"{ §'e¢~::s. fie': was>:51':z%ta{i "ii? 'i:s:»i§»:*ci'V5I3ft:.*§{a:::7;Vv_.;5 far VM ma beneﬁt {sf the Sm't».t mad mm a}Vs:103V1"*&it:::r:éfii:tr1g: vaﬁh :5: wa&p<">i1 of dﬁffilliﬁfi Bf acﬁedan. ¥ae7hsE%ﬂ3E::1~ gm: prayer C£>1l3"$Wff€'?:Ei' Avia' am.:[V§." £5 primmﬁy quagfian batgvmu' Qmly {'3.'Bil3E3.§.}.§.i.3S am in this pmfpaar c.»:m;:"é 'E23322. ' ';*+,e;1r%.a:1:v"j§:az:2 aassiat iha {_'5r:mz'!:. in ::?;.1";"i%2i"n;:g a'£' =8; j&3V§§'§V iguestinn. That fact pmvédvta that fear ﬁiiz whcﬁam we mabjaﬁ: maéitm af t}xe_3$iii'i;<:}1" ::>'é;*::«*:3;fVVVp;:'(:«sr.,'Vé>::di11g has bmn. pmpcrly vaiuﬁﬁ am"

'' w,hé"?(3r1£3§ §.}:1§:'ifa:§@ paws} 13$ m1L§f3:.t§:r::3t, €314? {.7-misfé. '1rna3=* .':».aid. fR'&{'3.h A §:1:aq31ii';;r.€t=:y it ezjéimsaidmia 'gmgsaar and .i¥:'3»§3u»':3 3-Ii Eﬂﬂmﬂﬁﬁiﬂh in any {:§:§;fﬁ him its make: 511433;: Kauai ea" 9&3:

mvaaﬁgaﬁstan ass» may be: xlmmsmay am} .1§i'£:p{'.>I'§'. ¥.i1t:m03a, T1159 " <2-vf the Leﬁsmturﬁ in mﬂaci ceurt fat: dim ﬁam this §.i¥"ig§ar3,?_ is; :m::;:xnif§::§'zV £39131 'the dssttaiiw pmviﬁiitms made in ' x "é«/'/ /"'> ,.

eﬁerwiicvrz 3 3 pm' $3 mveals and Hwnxiaéas ?§&«;2?.fV rgfrziiragg ix} p.m;3é:r'3;a:aiut1i£€3n. cf £5242? ﬁtzbfacﬁ ;?§§zat~»§3a='5sfizg,f' ﬁ'?nE?3"€2"B,.£§'§'.;ff€;?f££;,§:./.A gmyrneyivi Qf ggmgaxer mw'£ fag: asiﬁng an £533' é:aasm {éf.A:i?*.:eh _{1-§4_é'm€ waé zzsriﬁéesng Smtﬁmgni shaff bejizzm eviziemw is; mwxzieci an :55?

gm ztiairzr. sSesaEi{;n.V E 3 9}' agazinai ordéa?' {If 3&8 Cawazgri if? 456:} {wui {3}} iimmcgf' "(}$:«;?'§1§$2§§3:§'éx:r:;§f%;é"'g;g*'.V;1{£it;wz. at gmsagwrr smge pm1:ia£s:aiA'§h¢§é£n' 53$ iéaeijf.

uﬁgain :a;11?<:f%}:ae:é"V'3;::;%A21'3**;}¢§a:i ssimgie Jﬁﬁm: of this ﬁffxmﬁi in {ha cizaw uf = 'V * _ §fI21{33é.VA_aa "

:v"v?",:;§";'a:<5.:*r'é;)'i:>1?*x@;. 1525mm ihe Spgciai ammie 53:12.3 . %}'a%§:f£e__ an the irim' mm'? is; éamﬁe 6&9:

§§as=m«;é '..-Q} mmvi fee befam remrciing eridermm an ' .. ;°}z£.<§r§$a «sf the F8SpBﬂ§§13@ siaim 9}' the gmriieg, £333 £ﬁ'§_1§ Couré fms £a_,ﬁ3£'§m;§ ﬁw nwaradaie 2:} mm. Ii £3 Mai penmisaibie fa» give a g9-by in mm arnzmdaie in 3\/""' me apee:im.E afamie, * ﬁmwgé .

135?} htziii as: 1::.;e:§g;..,?"

"A rﬂryﬁxi mmfiragg 0f'$2zf2-$e'a§:z§r§§: giéfugf Saazfégﬁnj I Ema? f§{J'i :5.:hc":w»s; i?aa£'"e;'£1:$ :§ag#::éf;§{§3§;§39:¢:¢f.1?4§é;irag regﬁﬁﬁfiig ihe pmper vaiuaaiiaii [Sim ﬁsgard mm?

giénziérieri fmgfare me gaiirﬁkgngm vies; §73z$§reié€$§ I_?'m=3mfz.&m, it is i:gf2€é§:ea$e¥f'§z;e5_§id%%z miaﬁng £0 'g:ai$m§€z:;w;"Qf 5A§T'.§;se-ref. mgii :r_'§:;' :}Qn::§::§§;e2::§, ﬁw ﬁame shaif be izriéii . inﬁiarmg befiarrasi:

(my ém'€¥A:4.¥.1'me xmca' 'ﬁﬁ an _ii2?é§'£i.az T§mre;:'§>ré.:; ":;_;E*zx:.a_;f§. 'iiw spédai smmfg has _:_naG§e ;'.€ frimamgﬁeﬁi éé*a=j £he Trim? Cami to eziiemide me isame am ifavsgrt fay Emfarw mmrdfiizrzg mzidenvtxe em zI3"':..'~:{?i§'1:»:€ 13?' Em respmﬁare dzaiwi. of ifw: gxzﬂiw, éhér H . ﬁééagﬂ' in faffow £359: mmruizm=: {sf Ema ami it 'h " is gﬁséﬁmssibiéz in gime :3 3:39 £353; £43 iikiaa"

fi§f£}!J?h'.-'3t'5i'€i??""?;5 grmvisiian xamtaegstamzi in éhea spe.=:z:i::§.i ﬁmmée "fiiéé Kanmiaka Gmm §5'ee=:5 and 525535 Vafizmiion gm .'i'§'w: pmviafam Qf Graig? Eda' Rafe ,3? am a'n§y gznrmzmisarai and Em: s::(m:.a=: mzrmm r::r2.:i':,§;es=:31§;}: 332$ mmraémmry ﬁraaiiﬁiarm cf ﬂw: Kﬁnzmeiisza ﬁmari F=?:?§§ and Suiis '£r"E:z1ua.2'ian Am. '°' /fN"'4 \5§\'/"

22: 'iittt anothm' iezaxsztgmii s§11gi;E2 §_§k.k,£bi'ga% .§>£7_thi§£s-- gm mmm ma mm 1 H33} usf that Aa=::E. htéid as §1".%E1§i3}' 1- . $6,? 9. A;§nai§2e2i.._a,$pemf @f 55:32:?' 1.€:.=; af f%4ar2:"£mrge;x§,i{£E_V 'ﬁn at V' {ha pmataeng' cznaz is «&':§*§;:z§__ $20 :#'§1mﬁ§n, 9}" iﬁw 3E£.éPj8%1&§.V.??E£:i3.§V§?§F 4:2} :§;n:V§";«§z§_.2£z; *§;:3.§z.iv§g mm. mm ﬁred :1/isé§éé;é(,2;3".:¢g:g};f,f¢:v .~rﬁf?a:;§i'::£ efﬂaurﬁ fee _pz;zgm/bE«a=:

53:13.? 'me. fﬁeziﬁﬁaﬁciiaw; cf the f.'.l*4ma°*€j., a,§may.°_=; §ii5c»;5 }*i.=are éesua Qfﬁf;2xl.'i'£ and mm ami V _ £v§'iE'§'\°?3f'{§?'€3' ?':§%{)gB::3357§£;';£ieVi54'5'.V£?£;Vi mqmfry ms; m;me=m'ap£ma>e'i u?és:Z:-'er {:33 ﬁff the Ad. ﬁﬁﬁmvejkrre, szasdz. am by £33 very nmmm 3%: £;ie3vz:§d£=:¢'§ met «:3: V T. ismma '2m'£§i1?n £4529 meaning cf tilémier X3?' " - R§:§%é'.':3{2}: 5} ms 694:: mama. mzqﬁzerss atlﬁwaﬁmn £1: mg.» ﬁestrizie 3&9 £33156 £253" ham: aamﬁgg am: a; ";??%%J3%:rai2%m"g iaswa and that 20:}; if ii iaudws upon 'A ihie ﬁuriﬁaﬁimﬁan, £1f§?§;é3 éiirmzré {yr imvsiimtiara 43;' macirh £3; ssmzii is Emrmd by any mm.

32. Ga 23249 mhe:ar' haragi, Smﬂitsn. 3.33;}; cf ﬁfw:

Act, iika Graig? X.W'f€'mfe 12$?) azf the {ﬁrm rem mr;f&r nmre dzisctmﬁan. an the Ckmri Emi 3% rmmzzriaias \§\,.// 35 that the wane zgf aaahgmﬁon af tag .:~suﬁj4ar$' _i?i:5u3§'§sa:}'_§;:-3'; V' ih-9.' smié mm far me pw'p«:1x§eS;_ Qf :{.:{?:'§.i?7'5ufEé',_fEE§€i'~. jzuiaiiiasfiﬁra has ta Ere dacvizied &>«a;%%wre1"+:;.emug2é;_;r:ee~ €55 «. " "

remrded. I: is: @339 it} §:9«a'}§p§§;v";ie5e% 2.5%. Af?3i?V'£5E.£'§1§i?v She?! ismzm Of va.§ua<i'ior& 1&3 decﬁfﬁgﬂ ﬂy ihzéé 253': £329 ymmrmr pmfzficigad the fééymsiiy a«2;g:zia'a.b£E: it} t'}§.?'E;§; §:§%ir.Ey.'i2'f;faz'}25.$_:31m}1 an msim' wifi ﬁg_e:m3g; scam £3 :3: Cmasri gf'{:§gg§=3a3 §sr~§:£§ie£§"é£§'::£§r 3 H4} fa} af.§§ar§' V. .f..A.;°;-1 i§.i3Gz?€;»S£é§'y mnéﬁmgzsaragw any resnmﬂgg. bjgg. iigcey amﬁm' Sgz:aE'£en.

31? :é:'a:;§ai§im', ;§»g' $#;§?"a:.i fa» é?é&:2§n€ainm§2Ee. " 'Beﬁ;':%:A§: £3 appmprime $3 ngaéim ih.s::§.i Ltffw: rxrzder the Act is a ﬁgieaéai 33?tie:xe£.£§._g§f$'_§fb?' ¢i9£enn£nin,g £4516 £.:s'.;m¢-2 reimiireg ii} §:;:2.§:w:1§£or& af the mzbjeci ??1€§§§4f:33°" iwming ivearing an V T. ':1? xﬁaa amé' jw":".+-gziiciiayt. Q' 332:3 ¢C7¢:m2r°£ asmi ' ii £13; €§$?é??'F'§£Ii§?tQ egffagx' aver me: _g3rsmedu3=*e3 agﬁiiixzaiaieci in me an i3':.i¢'s wmmjﬁc ﬂayed. It zit; " 551551 immuge, G:€i?'B'?§i£¥3{§§§, the suézjem' af (xvii A 'T yriawzizxm {Entry E3} 3355 mnm2r':rmc£ in Sim mnmgn"em ' iaiaé «sf me ;'5s_wa=:n.£h Scheduie 3}' She Carmiiﬁmiczn cf gradia and p§°'e'?§:'E33'§,§ Aettﬁ }¥_{".i§$ been bnmghﬁ mic; fame »:1,f£Br abéairagészg agsmané Qf ihe Preaﬁeiené Q?' fzmaifia. an ;2;%~«:':$~.3 998% 1""hmxv:»gf§:3re, !§¥'£i¢':§-1?: ;35'§gL2?} G} 33:43 A , Eu//M Ev-.3' 'ha \ Camsiiiuiian «raj imiia wary};-;=s _i.?Ti:,i(l'_ p§{$3;V ﬁedigms i}'e.o:.a,iL- 1 ' u ' ﬂriitﬁa L31?:E§4§ . Inca*zréa?'§ié3n.c§ A . bééiweeza' ' §m;;§.§s . 3Vﬂ'.e'_l{i€ $33; Pmiiaiaraent #33365 rnwzika' :}f"5-'i{2£mz,~ . ' ' i {,3} xxx ' " . x'xxj'§, 'V aa Eezﬁgé givy 'ii%~sa sf aj. '§§:f}.t..:'£§z i§;a§?:f$';T" 1f'§:::§;§ac,£ -£43 :jje:vr*e.ée the msximra @15'?;"é£3V}'¥£;%i&°f'4*:i£:;*.'.€=3+V'.£ i3"&V"??:5&.«€3V £353 my/iiaiyzs any '§'"£'3gI;?::£§f;{£V;}'}"i€##3'é;3'VV'»':-i) £§a§3 §p5?*i§tV:§us5i€;ra5 cf am eaﬁim frexizzié'§3;_:§5af§fe;§g§££?:'a£ im £3.11 eixmﬁing Ema: with résgﬁaﬁ id éi?"aéze'1, the mm em maﬁa by ifm _ _Leg3ié%'§::=:;t;§m'~.a 'Vi:-f é;:_m:§u"' .E:?ia£g shezzif, if it imam: Ewen V:$éa;e:n2e§.§?_§'ar mmiziermﬁarn sf me 3:2-2r'e_>:3ie:iem'. atzmi ﬁaisrzygigzsgzi I*:.i;*:=a zmsseraé, g:"me:2{ze:i§ in éhagt mates: V = _ ;§"F.-?T€Z¥:§i2f€;ii3£%£S§:;, 613 Tlzerefam, $33 fffmsri hag cazmisstanfiy haié that .. §:'3m3: issgsizstt mgmziiag vaiuatimm. 03' Km: suit, and paymmxt mi"

' V' i."mj.I'i. fﬁﬁ $13331 E36: triad am 8 Qmiilzzinazjy iﬁﬁﬂﬁ. 24, in mt': Eight of 'égim itfﬁfﬁﬁaiﬁ €£iacu&=3i€31135, the ssstammxy pmviainns and 'ihﬁ aaﬁimi ivaga} gzvngitnimmg thﬁi': imam ;ax':ga:miing vakzaﬁcn esf this 331%: and gxaymeai af éiiimlri Fm aimfii am/,.,A 2'?

ha ﬁéaii as :5; ;m333Zm.inm}* issmx, if nezrmazmw, 2$_f's::::1i ,1*é(;<mi2'V.1rzg:'§3§n eiziéeieszgcsﬁ and eisciiie: £.i1::e said ;,§x£:li1u;§f;9::9§.f§r £33113,' '§ﬁ:'3f4{'A¥'§':$ 2 eviaiezzea £3 mmaxﬁmi mﬁecﬁng .'£'?eV3€.?5.':§'§_V€§£fff':ﬁi¥ji§.§i?iIE'§;,, mi .i?th::,_m:5tr§.$::§ Q3"

the-. tyiaitxx. Aaauzriixxgiyg the Ema: iaié'-;§mv&::u in iii;-2*: Eﬁﬁii'. inf .. $i'Isﬁ%"$'.&'ﬁ ~~ aw 'J : .§:}:«€.R 3996 mm 4~§§3, {ii} no? '}..b'::yJ _"§:;§<:='%,-?'9i7_a_:§ '*_r_'E3%;=;:~; cérgfﬁi' a1=;-xi hancf: it is ¢ ugrﬁii haw armi "£3'£x':I'€?.'§r{}§é3;,""ii3.§;":§V.A:ifgggﬁ Hatmms, wt: pass ﬁw §i}3}€3%'i;§lg V' ' _ ii; NDV'¥£.?{3§_i-#3,

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Veeragouda vs Shantakumar @ Shantappagowda on 5 November, 2008

Bench: N.Kumar, Jawad Rahim