Karnataka High Court
North West Karnataka Road Transport ... vs Venkatappa S/O Rajanna on 4 February, 2011
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
"C32
EN '?E"¥E§ Eéiiffli €f,{}§§E€T {E E3 Z?i3%?€I'é¥%'E'é§E;:%, iLf§.§%{)',U?'? E§§'?§¥_'§ {L71 3% 5%'?
E} S5 A Eiiifxffs E}
E}}§Z'§'E§ET} "FE-£23? 'I'Ir»§E§i- 4'5" §j}§'§';' <§§?=' E'EZE§E%iEs'§f%':' § 20% E
:BEZE'{I}I4%E§ :
"§'HE3 E-§(}i'\§'E3EL,Ej§; IE-'§'§%D 3L1:-7§T?£{JEi» I.'\E.§/Q. §3;a'1"':§,.
1VE'F'.A.NG& 1556 Q? 233'? {MY}
Biitwacsirta:
N«:.>:r:E2 K?'-.k:&~;:. E{z:im22%;.2:7§~:2»a,
§€(}21d "§"'rzm$p{:r: €<>3"p<>z'a:i<'m,
Sifsaé £}i:fi:--::i<>:.1, $iE"§:§§}
by' its Bivigkmezi C«:'>m:r<3Ei<~:;",
R:';3p:"€3S(31'}.ii€;'d by itsg,
{3§':.%.€f Law Offézicr.
App<:.%E2i1:'f:%',
(335 Sri. CB' P';-mi, Adi-=::ct.ai;s:}
Ftkrzci:
E . 'W322: }<2,-m;:_p;>g1,
5:3 C: D E3213 :1: 1": 1': ,
f%{i'L§§'£3
R/"<.:: ;%u:th';:%;.e:2. F€2.a.0 E/;':1j;_,"{E?.,»3§.,,
'.§'aiu§< : E3hir:*s:':§;z;z.
$3. §:3'%1z:.S;§<:a:;
E?§_;'::=. Ranézgziz,
, iiuii,
Eizéver 0%' §3*:i:='a.é.é;* Buss,
SE ,5 E}. {R3 "E's:m':'":;
E%hir§2~:'>§g;;2:..
{M}
U§"ziifii£§ E:";:«:';.:r2=.:m:a? =iJ{sI:1;L:;::§'éf~;' Lid,
E}:":r§s;és:f;1":gr2§ {)'}§f%<A:e::g
'mu
§I"22r<;;Ez-*c.?{4; it': 'i"§i:.<? é::%{ii'jfi£f§t:3""2ii. $3132-~:.%. <>r:<:L.:m;:<i 0:2. 23:19, ?;':.33*":£-E? :2: 2.} E}
33.2.12. :3 sa*;-1*" E§'E*":.:?:'2.2"»';~::r":':.:::*.
4. E2": '.£3:°ée,*f, i:.E2:% f'e2i::€:§z; U?' :"§'7<% {_i'£:"£f§{'? é-3_£"€'?:
The G(5.C'L;EI"1'°i3I1{3€i {sf 1:316 accid-53:1: and {"526 sézsmages:
caigsaci ie {be vehicie b{§a.réng; F\?<,>,§{.:%.{}E .P',8<5XE' am mm fir'; d.:E$§;;>L2?:€. ii is {E363 Case of {he a.p*p€iEa:n;: §.ha';, in fiche aficidem ma: QCC2J§"'§"€d on 23.9.E999§ §Z§"E€3 vehécée beafiing "N0" E<..f«\,GE,§",84'? s;*qs;'{ain€:d damages v;';:(§ {1} right side fmr:.%; camer damages, {2} right side head Eight um: damagecf {3} f:'om' Show damaged and {'4} {mm Wizad screen ggiass damaged fiue :9 {E16 rash anti msgéigené: driving by ithéi driver 05 the v€h2'c:E~3 bearing N0..E{A:E¥%g@EZ?:4' {fin EE,CC{}§,I1'1'C of wE3éc§1,, app€EEa§:§-- Ccwparaiéen fiiefi 52 cEa:'.m petéiifin. §3€i?§{ZrE"€ igiizé firibuaai 'uncier 3€ci:i.{>z: £625 of ,§s,:"'E.'*d': Acéz, <:Ee::Emi1';g €@1"{1p€E'§.:3£:iE§E}:"E against {"936 reggaondsizis, The Saki. céaém pazitiam had C{EE'}""5fE Lip 131:2?' s::{:ns;id6?a€f.<>§: %3:3=f::s§'°a E316 "§'§"*:;"i3L;:":a.E, 7?'?/16 'E°'r:3"bz,::"::;ii in ::u:m, z":f%e'r E:.i%S€S§--5§§E'2§ {he :;:re"2_§ zmd {Z§:;}CLiF1'Ei'33'é3:&%£"'};" €'%7ié{3E'E€&? 22*-geflgzbie 9;: {$6, Ema azifiewsscé $12363 Chaim ;:~€:§z2?<>:"; in part EEIECE emx:«'2.r<:i:'3d £2 szum 0:" ?§{},i}{}Q;"~ 2;v2':.h z':2.ir3:*e:«;: 2 :'js'frE:; gages. {mm t_¥::=; zézisie sf §<E'.ET:"{?'_}i'} zilé its é<«:§;z<>:;it, Beizzfgg a.gg;§:?imx's%<;i £3}; that q:'L22m_:.'z,:m :3?"
c0mpe::Sa'€ia.n awaxfiad bf." the Tribatnai, azppaéiazzzi ézas présentaci %,%1%$ ezppszaai far €n%2a.n<:ems:m; af aompemsaiémz, :3. E haw: hearé the 1earn.se:§ commas} far the appeflani ai <:<m_s§derabEe Eéngth 0%" i:i.me:a
63. After ca.:"ef:,§l psrusal sf {L363 rz:a£:ez°ia.}s avaiiabie an fifa ;'_:1ci2,:;%i:':g the impugned judgment Elfld award passed by ihs T:'ébunaE_, E dc: rm: find any EZTQ?' of Iaw GI' éfilegaiity, m'u::_h E633 maieréaé i:":°eguEaz'§.t}-Y, as such cemmirted by {$36 Yribunai in awazfiing ihés {3G§'E1§pE?f1S8.E§GfE. '§'h€ Tribunaé, afier agsessing tbs era} and dacumerztaégz' ew'den.cc3 awaéiabiés am £2153? taking mtg €(}E"18'E€§€i'a'fLi€3§.'E 232%: "£'E&EELE.f€ 0%" da.mag€s; Cazzseé. :29 {E16 aishicés, baa axa--='a1:r£§s3c§ 3 sf ?E{§,{}G€}f~ wiih §.:":':52:"€s€ at 6"?/E-; gzz, .:'é"{>:T: ::E":£% €32,531? 6:2? pe?;%;€1?<}r; iii} :33 ésipagéii. '§"h€ 83:3-Cf'§.€ 11% 31,233 2236 ?€E:$§}E"Ea§}§f3* ezziai therefare, :'_n:<s:~z°fe:%::zc::% fig , .»v'( M"
5'