Patna High Court
Vinay Kumar & Ors vs The State Of Bihar & Ors on 28 January, 2017
Author: Ajay Kumar Tripathi
Bench: Ajay Kumar Tripathi, Nilu Agrawal
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Letters Patent Appeal No.1975 of 2015
IN
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 16697 of 2009
===========================================================
1. Vinay Kumar S/o Ram Param Hansh R/o Village - Rajopatti, P.S.+District -
Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Bagha-2, West
Champaran
2. Md. Kamre Alam S/o Md. Jubair R/o Village - Hassanpur Barharwa, Via-
Bajpatti, District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Hayaghat Darbhanga
3. Upendra Kumar S/o Late Dhanu Prasad R/o Village + P.S. - Bairganiya, District
- Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Baheri
4. Ashok Kumar S/o Late Yogendra Pandey R/o Village - Heerapur, Via- Kundwa
Chainpur, District - East Champaran, at present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Bairganiya, District - Sitamarhi
5. Bimlesh Kumar Mishra S/o Sarvajeet Mishra R/o Village - Sahbajpur, Via-Riga,
District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Darbhanga
Sadar
6. Shambhu Singh S/o Late Babunandan Singh R/o Village - Basant Via Bajpatti,
District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Pradarshni Officer, Joint Director Officer,
Mithapur, Patna
7. Ram Babu Sah S/o Late Ram Swaroop Sah R/o Village - Belganj Via
Bairganiya, District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Pakri Dayal, East Champaran.
8. Chandra Bhushan Sahi S/o Shiv Shankar Sahi R/o Village - Panthpakar, Via
Bathraha, District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Yogapatti, West Champaran
9. Ajay Kumar Singh S/o Mahesh Prasad Singh R/o Village - Hardiya, P.S. -
Turkauliya, East Champaran
10. Nashimuddin Anshari S/o Md. Kamruddin Anshari R/o Village - Pakariya, Via
Chauradano, Motihari, East Champaran, Assistant Agriculture Officer, District
Agriculture Officer, Bettiah, West Champaran
11. Md. Nasim Ansari S/o Wazid Ansari R/o Bhovdeopur Ward No. 23, Sitamarhi
at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Bakhtiyarpur, Patna
12. Rajesh Jha S/o Shyamdeo Jha R/o Village - Garha, P.S. - Runnisaidpur, District
- Sitamarhi at present posted as Junior Agriculture Information Officer in the office
of Joint Director, Tirthut Division Muzaffarpur.
13. Ajay Kumar S/o Sri Ram Janam Singh R/o Village - Rampur, P.S. -
Runnisaidpur, District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Mushari
14. Mohit Chandra Paswan S/o Late Ganesh Paswan, R/o Village + P.S. - Sihyara,
District - Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Sakra
Muzaffarpur
15. Arun Kumar S/o Om Prakash Kumar R/o Village - Parsauni Kapur, P.S. -
Patahi, District - East Champaran at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Bochcha, Muzaffarpur
16. Arun Kumar Choudhary S/o Ram Ratan Choudhary R/o Village - Bishanpur
Mangal, P.O. - Rajla, District - Muzaffarpur at present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Tajpur, Samastipur
17. Md. Abulash Anwar S/o Md. Jalluddin R/o Village - Nayagao, P.S. - Shyampur
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
Bhatha, District - Shivhar at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Phulwarisarif, Patna
18. Janki Raman Prasad S/o Late Dhaga Sah R/o Village - Runnisaidpur, District -
Sitamarhi at present posted as Assistant Investigation Officer in the office of Joint
Director, Quality and Control, Bihar, Patna
19. Ram Prasad Singh S/o Satya Narain Singh R/o Village - Narsinghpur Via
Ramna, District-Muzaffarpur at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Khanpur, Samastipur
20. Triloki Kumar S/o Late Chulahai Thakur R/o Village - Mushari, District -
Muzaffarpur at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, Bitha, West
Champaran
21. Prem Nath Singh S/o Sri Bhola Singh R/o Village - Prem Nagar, District -
Sitamarhi at present posted as Block Agriculture Officer, in the office of Joint
Director Tirhut Division, Muzaffarpur
.... .... Appellant/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar
2. The Principal Secretary - Cum - Agriculture Production Commissioner
Department of Deptt. Agriculture, Govt. of Bihar, Patna
3. The Director, of Agriculture, Govt. of Bihar, New Secretariat, Bailey Road,
Patna
4. The Principal Secretary, Deptt. of Personnel and Administrative Reforms, Govt.
of Bihar, New Secretariat, Bailey Road, Patna
5. Sanjay Kumar Verma S/o Late Mukteshwar Sharan Verma R/o Mohalla - Purani
Gudari, P.S. - Town, Bettiah, District - West Champaran, at present posted as
Village Level Worker, at Block Ramnagar, District - West Champaran
6. Siddhnath Rai S/o Late Ramashray Prasad Rai R/o Village - Rampur, P.S. -
Rajapur, District- Buxar, at present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block
Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran
7. Vinod Kumar S/o Late Jai Narayan R/o Village - Main Road, Chanpatiya, P.S. -
Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran, at present posted as Village Level Worker,
At Block Bagha (I) District - West Champaran
8. Om Prakash Gupta S/o Sri Ramji Prasad Gupta R/o Mohalla - Ganj No. 1,
Shaheed Chowk, P.S. - Bettiah, District - West Champaran at present posted as
Village Level Worker, At Block Bagha (1) District - West Champaran
9. Virendra Kumar S/o Sri Ramji Shukla R/o Village - Naya Tola, P.S. - Choubey
Tola, At Chanpatia, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block Bagha-1, District - West Champaran
10. Ranjan Kumar S/o Sri Vidyanand Prasad R/o Mohalla - New Colony, P.S. -
Bettiah, District - West Champaran, At present as Village Level Worker, At Block
Narkatiaganj, District - West Champaran
11. Nandoo Thakur S/o Sri Bhola Thakur R/o Village - Parsa, Via+P.S. Bagha,
District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village - Level Worker, At Block
Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran
12. Anand Thakur S/o Bhola Thakur R/o Village - Parsa, Via+P.S. - Bagha, District
- West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block Yogapatti,
District - West Champaran
13. Raghaw Prasad S/o Sri Satyanarayan Sah R/o Village - Sugharehap, Post - Britti
Matriaria, P.S. - Laurya, District - West Champaran at present posted as Village
Level Worker, At Block Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran
14. Chhote Lal Rao S/o Late Kamal Rao R/o Village - Paroraha, P.O.- Dumra Bhat,
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
P.S. - Laurya, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker at Block- Gaunaha, District- West Champaran
15. Pramod Kumar Verma S/o Anirudh Prasad Verma R/o Village - Nautan Khurd,
Post- Harpura Tola, at Manjhoulia, P.S. - Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran,
At present posted as Village Level Worker at Block - Bettiah, District - West
Champaran
16. Shankar Prasad S/o Late Laxmi Prasad R/o Village + P.O. - Patilar, P.S. -
Choutarwa, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker
At Block Gaunaha District - West Champaran
17. Ghanshyam Tripathy S/o Sri Devta Tripathy R/o Mohalla - Shivganj, P.S. -
Narkatyaganj, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker at Block Chanpatya, District - West Champaran
18. Mohd. Mohuddin, S/o Mohd. Salamuddin R/o Mohalla - Kalibagh, P.S. -
Bettiah, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker at
Block- Thakrahaj, District - West Champaran
19. Banarsi Ram S/o Sri Gopal Ram R/o Mohalla - Jai Singhpur, P.S. - Sikta,
District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker At Block
Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran
20. Raj Kumar Verma S/o Late Krishneshwar Prasad Verma R/o Village - Pandey
Tola (Shantibagh) P.O. - Narkatyaganj, P.S. - Sikarpur, District - West Champaran,
At present posted as Village Level Worker At Block Gaunaha, District - West
Champaran
21. Shambhu Nath Pandey S/o Late Mathura Pandey R/o Village - Baotjamao, P.S.
- Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker At Block Mouriatand, District - West Champaran
22. Chandra Mani Shukla S/o Late Ganesh Shukla R/o Village - Pakdhihar, Post-
Tikulia, P.S. - Chanpatya, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village
Level Worker At Block Narkatiaganj, District - West Champaran
23. Brajesh Kumar Mishra S/o Late Jagdish Mishra R/o Village + Post - Choubey
Tola, P.S. - Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village
Level Worker At Block Maunatained, District - West Champaran
24. Parasnath Kaji S/o Sri Surendra Kaji R/o Village - Chtrataul, Post - Harnatand,
P.S. - Laurya Bagha, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker at Block Yogapatti, District - West Champaran
25. Yogendra Ram S/o Sri Sanhu Ram R/o Village - Bairya, P.S. - Bairya, District -
West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker at Block Thakraha,
District - West Champaran
26. Lal Babu Prasad S/o Haridwar Prasad R/o Mohalla - Ganj No.2, Goldar Patti,
P.S. - Bettiah, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level
Worker At Block - Rampur, District - West Champaran
27. Gobind Chandra Jha S/o Sri Sheo Chandra Jha R/o Village + Post -
Bannchapar, P.S. -Muffassil At Bettiah, District - West Champaran, At present
posted as Village Level Worker At Block - Nautan, District - West Champaran
28. Gopal Jee Tiwari S/o Sri Raghan Sharan Tiwari R/o Mohalla - Kamal Nath
Nagar, P.S. - Bettiah, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village
Level Worker, At Block Bagha (1) District - West Champaran
29. Ganesh Prasad S/o Sri Sukai Sah R/o Village - Lagunaha, P.S. - Patilar, At
Bagha, District - West Champaran at present posted as Village Level Worker, At
Block Bairia, District - West Champaran
30. Dhrub Narayan Kumar S/o Sri Prahalad Prasad R/o Village - Ganj No. 2, At
Bettiah, P.S. - Bettiah Sadar, District - West Champaran At present posted as
Village Level Worker, At Block - Bagha, District - West Champaran
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
31. Bijendra Singh S/o Yugal Kishore R/o Village - Paras Pakri, Post - Chanayan
Bandh, P.S. - Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village
Level Worker, At Block - Yogapatti, District - West Champaran
32. Shambhu Ray S/o Sri Bhikhari Ray R/o Village - Mahuakuli, P.S. - Chanpatiya,
District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block -
Thakraha, District - West Champaran
33. Sri Kant Bhagat S/o Sri Mahadeo Bhagat R/o Village - Shiv Rajpur, P.S. -
Nautan, District - West Champaran, At present posted as Village Level Worker, At
Block - Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran
34. Arun Kumar S/o Sri Ramdhari Prasad R/o Mohalla - Purani Bazar, P.O. -
Narkatyaganj, P.S. - Narkatyaganj, District - West Champaran, At present posted as
Village Level Worker, At Block - Bairiya, District - West Champaran
35. Pramod Kumar Mishra S/o Late Babu Saheb R/o Village - Roari, P.S. - Sholar,
District - West Champaran. At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block -
Laurya, District - West Champaran
36. Nasimuddin S/o Ghniasuddin R/o Village - Sabeya, P.S. - Ramnagar, District -
West Champaran at present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block Laurya,
District - West Champaran
37. Bageshwari Yadav S/o Sri Laxmi Yadav R/o Village + Post - Rampurva, P.S. -
Mauriatand District West Champaran at present posted as Village Level Worker, At
Block- Manjhaulia, District West Champaran
38. Awadh Kishore Pandey S/o Bharat Pandey R/o Village - Badwa (Jamadar
Tola), P.S. - Choutarwa, Post- Siswa Basantpur, District - West Champaran At
present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block Manjhoulia, District - West
Champaran
39. Amardeo Baitha S/o Sri Rajdhari Baitha R/o Village - Banwaria, P.O. - Anjura,
P.S. - Shikarpur, District - West Champaran at present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block - Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran
40. Deepak Kumar Verma S/o Sri Ishwari Sharan Verma R/o Mohalla - Kalibagh,
P.S. - Town Bettiah, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block - Lauriya, District - West Champaran
41. Paras Sah S//o Sri Sinhashan Shah R/o Village + Post - Anjjna At Narkatiaganj,
P.S. - Narkatyaganj, District - West Champaran at present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block Bairya, District - West Champaran
42. Vinod Rao S/o Sri Laganj Deo Rao R/o Village + Post - Laukaria, P.S. - Bairya,
District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block -
Mauriatand, District - West Champaran
43. Dhrub Pandey S/o Sri Adya Pandey R/o Village - Mausharia, P.O. - Chanpatia,
P.S. - Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block - Lauriya, District - West Champaran
44. Madan Prasad S/o Sri Ganesh Prasad Saha R/o Village + Post - Shivarajpur,
P.S. - Nautan, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block - Sikta District - West Champaran
45. Ramayan Rai S/o Late Gena Rai R/o Village+Post- Skotraha, P.S. - Nautan,
District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block
Sikta District West Champaran
46. Jai Prakash Narayan S/o Sri Yadupir Narayan Prasad R/o Village - Manjhoulia,
P.S. - Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block Narkatiaganj, District - West Champaran
47. Shambhu Saran Rai S/o Sri Krishna Deo Rai R/o Village -Sirsiya, Post -
Chahadi, P.S. - Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village
Level Worker, At Block Narkatiaganj, District - West Champaran
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
48. Chandra Shekhar Mishra S/o Sri Raghunath Mishra R/o Mohalla - Kila, P.S. -
Town Bettiah, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Lewvel
Worker, At Block - Bagaha (D), District - West Champaran
49. Virendra Prasad S/o Sri Raghaw R/o Village - Patu Kohia, Via Sikta, District -
West Champaran At present posted as Village Level Worker, At Block Chanpatiya,
District - West Champaran
50. Madan Mohan Dubey S/o Sri Vishwanath Dubey R/o Village + Post - Joykatia,
P.S. - Manjhoulia, District - West Champaran At present posted as Village Level
Worker, At Block - Madhubani District West Champaran
51. Chandeshwar Rao S/o Sri Lal Babu Rao R/o Village - Englishia, P.O. - Belwa
More, P.S. - Choutarwa, District - West Champaran at present posted as Village
Level Worker, At Block - Chanpatiya, District - West Champaran
52. Ratneshwar Shahi S/o Ram Udar Sahi R/o Village - Malikaria, P.S. - Prem
Nagart, P.S. - Dumra, District - Sitamarhi At present Block Agriculture Officer At
Block Sakra District Muzaffarpur
53. Bajrangi Singh Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Madhwapur, Madhubani
54. Pran Nath Singh Son of Not known At present posted as Assistant Sub
Divisional Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Samastipur
55. Sri Prabhat Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Sub Divisional
Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Samastipur
56. Vijay Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Shivhar
57. Ashok Kumar Panjiar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Kuseswar Asthan, Darbhanga (East)
58. Muneshwar Prasad Singh Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Deputy Agriculture Director (Farm), Soil Testing Lab, Purnia.
59. Nagendra Purway Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Kishanganj
60. Jay Prakash Mishra Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Extension
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Darbhanga
61. Ram Balak Singh Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Jehanabad
62. Reyaz Ali Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Andhara Tharhi, Madhubani
63. Ravindra Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agricluture
Officer, Andhra Tharhi, Madhubani
64. Awadhesh Shukla Son of not known At present posted as Block Agricluture
Officer, Bhagwanpur, Vaishali
65. Satrudhan Pandit Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Plant
Extension Officer, District Agriculture Office, Muzaffarpur
66. Prabhu Ram Son of not known At present posted as Agriculture Extension
Officer, Sub-Divisional Office (West) West Sitamarhi
67. Ram Pukar Paswan Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Paterhi Belsar (Vaishali), District - Vaishali
68. Ram Das Ram Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Shivhar
69. Kamal Dev Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Lahladpur, Sharan
70. Ratnesh Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Fenharh, East Champaran
71. Ajit Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
Dariyapur, Sharan
72. Viveka Nand Jha Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Benipatti, Madhubani
73. Ajay Kumar Jha Ajey Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Rahika, Madhubani
74. Sakil Ahmad Khan Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Seed
Production Officer, Office of Deputy Director Agriculture (Potato), Patna
75. Md. Mustafa Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Sub-Divisional
Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Sharan
76. Nashimuddin Anshari Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Plant
Extension Officer, District - Agriculture Office, Bettiah
77. Lal Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Hathwa, Gopalganj
78. Ram Parash Mukhia Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Plant
Extension Officer, Begusarai District Agriculture Office.
79. Vinay Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Office,
Bagaha 1. West Champaran
80. Ashok Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Bairganiya, Sitamarhi
81. Anil Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Bairganiya, Sitamarhi
82. Gopal Ji Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Sanjhauli, Rohtas
83. Nand Ji Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Suryapura Rohtas
84. Rajesh Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Gamhariya Madhepura
85. Mahesh Chaudhari Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Maskaur, Nawada
86. Shami Kapoor Das Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Buxar
87. Anil Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Nawa Nagar, Buxar
88. Surya Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Chakki Bazar
89. Krishandev Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Tiling, Rohtas
90. Arun Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Nawada
91. Raj Bihari Harijan Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Hisuwa, Nawada
92. Sahadev Roy Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Lakhnaur, Madhubani
93. Rajesh Choudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Dhanarua, Patna
94. Janardan Prasad Yadav Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Parsha, Sharan
95. Shyam Sundar Mishra Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Shivajhi Nagar, Samastipur
96. Sanjay Kumar Singh Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Munger
97. Dinesh Kumar Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
Officer, Tetaria, East Champaran
98. Giraji Nand Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Adhora, Bhabhua
99. Abhishek Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Chhorahi, Begusarai
100. Kailesh Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Birpur Begusarai
101. Rajeshwar Ram Sonof not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Gadhpura, Begusarai
102. Bijay Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Tekari, Gaya
103. Amrendra Kumar Sonof not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Karakat Rohtas
104. Gurucharan Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture officer, Matihani Begusarai
105. Om Prakash Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Kohdawanpur, Begusarai
106. Umesh Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Barauni, Begusarai
107. Ramdeo Paswan Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Karakat, Rohtas
108. Chandrabhushan Paswan Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Balia, Begusarai
109. Saryug Rabidas Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Gharhara, Munger
110. Ganauri Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Chanan, Lakhisarai
111. Indradeo Das Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Ghatkutumb, Sheikhpura
112. Ishwari Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Arari, Sheikhpura
113. Satrendra Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Offricer, Gurva, Gaya
114. Masudan Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Patarghat, Saharsa
115. Devanand Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Bhabhua
116. Bindeshwar Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Rafiganj, Aurangabad
117. Arbind Rabidas Sonof not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Goh, Aurangabad
118. Manohar lal Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Nabinagar Aurangabad
119. Kapildeo Paswan Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Vaishali
120. Shankar Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Akharigola, Rohtas
121. Ramadhar Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Kesath, Buxar
122. Ramdeo Ram, Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Hilsa, Nalanda
123. Mahendra Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
Officer, Guraru Gaya
124. Dilip Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Madanpur Aurangabad
125. Surya Kumar Ram Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Tharthari, Nalanda
126. Mohan Das Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Mainatand, West Champaran
127. Awadhesh Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Ghoraiya, Banka
128. Rajendra Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Bihpur, Bhagalpur
129. Shailendra Prasad Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Modanganj, Jehanabad
130. Chotelal Chaudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Ratani, Faridpur, Jehanabad
131. Dilip Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Suryagadha, Lakhisarai
132. Jitendra Kumar Das Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Arwal
133. Sumeshwar Kumar Mehta Son of not known At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Bodh Gaya
134. Jai Jayant Rajak Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Dumaria, Gaya
135. Saroj Kumar Mehta Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Sub - Divisional Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Gaya
136. Anil Choudhary Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Muhra Gaya
137. Vijay Kumar Das Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Sonbhadra Banshisurajpur, Arwal
138. Suresh Rajbanshi Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Deo Aurangabad
139. Sanjay Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Katarisarai, Nalanda
140. Anuj Kumar Sharma Son of not known At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Depo Director (Prachetra) Arrah
141. Ashok Paswan Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Athamalgola, Patna
142. Binod Rabidas Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Daudnagar, Aurangabad
143. Kapil Kumar Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Kutumba Aurangabad
144. Sukhdeo Mahto Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Wajirganj, Gaya
145. Keshav Kumar Sah Son of not known At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Chiraiya, East Champaran
146. Ramanand Das, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Harsidhi, East Champaran
147. Dilip Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Bhitha, West Champaran
148. Prahalad Mishra, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Sitamarhi
149. Jagdish Prasad Sinha, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Audio Vizusl
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
and Supervisor Officer, Assistant Agriculture Director Information, Patna
150. Ajay Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Sikta, Bettiah
151. Bijay Kumar Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Joint Agriculture Director (A.Anu), Patna
152. Uarvashi Verma, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Soil Testing Lab, Purnia
153. Nawal Kishore Singh, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional Officer, Joint Agriculture Director (A.Anu), Patna
154. Rajdeo Ram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Singhwara, Darbhanga
155. Abhay Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Sub-
Divisional
156. Om Prakash Yadav, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Darauli, Siwan
157. Dinesh Jha, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Mohiuddin Nagar (Samastipur)
158. Upendra Kumar Ojha, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Marauna (Supaul)
159. Tarun Kumar Mishra, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Birpur, Supaul
160. Yogendra Kumar Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Ekma, Saran
161. Sauad Ajam Rahmani, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Pusha, Samastipur
162. Mani Roshan Prasad Verma, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Sarmera, Nalanda
163. Ram Pravesh Prasad, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Narparganj (Araria)
164. Binay Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector,
Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Dalsingsarai (Samastipur)
165. Kishori Rajak, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Pothia, Kishanganj
166. Umesh Baitha Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Gwalpara, Madhepura
167. Mahendra Rai, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Barari, Katihar
168. Ram Kumar Mishra, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, (West), Sitamarhi (West)
169. Ganesh Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Singhwara, Darbhanga
170. Mahasheweta Ghosh, wife of not known, Junior Research Assistant, District
Farm, Musahari (Muzaffarpur)
171. Anand Mohan Choudhary, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Gaura Bauram Darbhanga
172. Deo Nath Chaudhary, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, District Agriculture Field Extension Service Office, East Champaran
173. Kedar Rai, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Junior Farm
Superintendent, District Farm, Parsa (West Champaran)
174. Tarkeshwar Prasad Singh, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant
Seed Production Officer of Deputy Agriculture Director (Potato), Patna
175. Ashok Kumar Sahani, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, General, Bagah (Bettiah)
176. Chandra Kishore Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant
Seed Production Officer, Office of Deputy Agriculture Director (Potato), Patna
177. Rakesh Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Research
Officer, Piprakothi, East Champaran
178. Amarnath Thakur, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant
Agriculture Officer (Botany), District Agriculture Office, Patna
179. Birendra Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (Farm), District Farm Manager, Sipaya, Gopalganj
180. Rajiv Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Puraini Madhepura
181. Uday Shankar Ram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Arariya
182. Bharti Sinha, Wife of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector,
District Farm, Musahari (Muzaffarpur)
183. Ashok Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector,
Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Kishanganj
184. Bijay Kumar Singh, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Danapur, Patna
185. Balkrishna Das, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Field Extension Service, Siwan
186. Fuldeo Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Singheshwar, Madhepura
187. Shivji Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector
(Field Extension Service), Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Chapra (Saran)
188. Ashok Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector,
(Field Extension Service) Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Purnea.
189. Sitaram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture Officer,
Ajamnagar (Katihar)
190. Ashok Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Seed
Production Officer, Office of Deputy Agriculture Director (Potato), Patna
191. Akhilesh Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (Farm), Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Aurangabad
192. Md. Shaukat Ali, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (Farm), Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Danapur (Patna)
193. Krishna Murari Sinha, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Maker (Saran)
194. Brajkishore Charan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (Farm), Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Patna
195. Ratnesh Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (Field Extension Service), District Agriculture Office, Samastipur
196. Nand Kishore Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Jute Extension Officer, East Champaran
197. Yugal Prasad Mehta, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Seed
Production Officer, Office of Deputy Agriculture Director (Potato), Patna
198. Azaz Ahmad, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer(Botany), District Agriculture Office, Samastipur
199. Md. Ali Khan Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer(Chemistry), District Agriculture Office, Sitamarhi
200. Shekhar Kumar Madhukar Son of Not Known, At present posted as
Agriculture Inspector (Field Extension Service), District Agriculture Office,
Sitamarhi
Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017
Pago/
201. Sushil Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture Inspector,
Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Bettiah
202. Ram Kumar Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Khagaria
203. Sanjay Kumar No. 2 Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector (General), Sub-Divisional Office, Rosra, Samastipur
204. Md. Faraque Azam, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Balrampur, Katihar
205. Ajit Kumar Sharma, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Agriculture
Inspector, Sub-Divisional Agriculture Office, Sitamarhi (East)
206. Vinay Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Office (Botany), District Agriculture Office, East Champaran
207. Himanshu Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present as Agriculture Inspector
(General), Sub-Divisional Agricutlure Office, Marhaura (Saran)
208. Sanjay Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer (Chemistry), Divisional Agriculture Office, Begusarai
209. Amir Chand Ram, Son of Not Known, Block Agriculture Officer, Chenari
(Rohtas)
210. Saroj Kumar, Son of Not Known, Block Agriculture Officer, Ghosi
(Jehanabad)
211. Yogendra Ram, Son of Not Known, Block Agriculture Officer, Paraiya (Gaya)
212. Arun Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Assistant Agriculture
Officer, District Agriculture Office, Arwal
213. Hari Lal Ram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Mehasi, District- Saharsa
214. Ram Chandra Ram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Chousa, District- Madhepura
215. Vinod Kumar, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Barhara Kothi, District- Purnea
216. Jay Kumar Ram, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Hasanpur, District- Samastipur
217. Mahendra Kumar Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block Agriculture
Officer, Rampur, District- Bhabua
218. Thakur Prasad Paswan, Son of Not Known, At present posted as Block
Agriculture Officer, Bhabua, District- Kaimur
.... .... Respondent/s
===========================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant/s : Mr. Shiva Shankar Sharma
For the Respondent/s : Mr. H. S. Roy,
AC to PAAG-I
===========================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI
And
HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. NILU AGRAWAL
ORAL JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI) Date: 28-01-2017 Heard learned counsel for the appellants and perused Patna High Court LPA No.1975 of 2015 dt.28-01-2017 Pago/ the limitation petition, which is I. A. No. 8806 of 2015, wherein there is a delay of 320 days.
The reason assigned that they did not have proper information and inputs about the decision, which has caused the delay, is a lame duck excuse, which cannot form the basis for condonation of delay.
The limitation petition is dismissed, so is the appeal.
(Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J) (Nilu Agrawal, J) SKM/-
AFR/NAFR N.A.F.R. CAV DATE
Uploading Date 30.01.2017 Transmission Date