Karnataka High Court
Bangalore Metropolitan vs T Ramakrishna on 21 March, 2011
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
Bench: A.N.Venugopala Gowda
awaéfi éaiaé §_§,3§Z%3:_%fE yaggafi bag Em fiyesééing C%ffi:.::a:3 RE ééééiésmgai Labwr flazgfi, Bangaéase, in Rafaiefsaje §'%§@,13E2{':§% véée .«5xE'§?':€}~:'L%§'"€ ~52.
Thég geééiéen camérsg as far hearirzg gm gram §:?':§§ éfiga, iirée Cami madfi {he ffiéicvsgzségzg:
{ERDER W26 :*es3pm§e.r:: ,5 w{::r%<m§§x wag a £s';;n:§.§§§E::::. %%2 "%:§<€,e_' ' gatéégéerzer « ijargaratéen, HE :fz:;:«;?'%2aé:":efi'.4 ::_:":§é;-':'T%?_:_r::T:"§'§.§z'"~;'>-,~éE:g,>--»é at-=§§§%: far ziaizzgx "fha §s3§r:.}%: §v%a;:a§k§§ :<;:"%::":§é%:a'3.§ W23 353$ aéae $0223 iha §é§;':M:';:;,§i":,;2;r; {;fV__gg;,s:;-g§;;e§-,":'a2_é§%§';§V arzgsrwenéansa and §':a§:':i%f§%';Ep.«&t'£§ *?". §_'§fi 'E§'f3'2,s'G§§§FE§'~ gésbééa 5nd 353% m we §v'§.ar:ag§men':§ 'i:%?§feé¢;"3_;§@r: gazbméiiad E332 %:§":<;:V Sé§;=n:3é5._§==f§a'%§é'gé%*»§:sé ihfév aaié naééaé 365:1: %G we weriémégm' 25-;e.r§<ma:": fiéé me': r"5;3:::s§*"§ fin' fiuty, w%2%7::--?3_ :*é3%5;;§'%:§<§A§s%»*§"§%;:"§%:@:* é"e§0;"i: being $§§§§'%":%?*Ei$§ éy '€%s€--: Efkieggaggé: Fv?far:a§%%' ma" 3€},S§Gai; iwiéaieg sf Cééayga {Ema U3 "=.,_bev-':%__é§su;_§{§, 5%} :9::<;§"E§:"';"' Qxgéanatéan was $:,5§a;r::%%:*:€€i 3:33! ihe . ":?ix.__%é«3§ié§%fi Sigma: jieéfige wag afigfiifiififi $3 ihe e¥:':Qu§'r3: '{}?;*%';::§':*Vianfi the i5EE'"§j§{Z§*8;'7; :3? C§"':§.?'§€ ::=.s3S; subgfeesieé is an %~s:§aE%y;""T%'2e amaéry" having :3:i<€r2 gsissaa; wheyeég': we V"*»zz:;@;*i<:%:«:<s:::'garégécégaieifi 3:35 §§a<:e§ hég easééerzcaf iha €§"§§%_§EE"3;' "&5":.' i W'.
i".':%§:%§§E:2a§*3;' &a3z:hm*§é:~g =2»-gag gugiéféaé 3:: E'EG§s;'§§§"§§ Ehai, %3'T€E'% wga aaaatéesaégaé aisgense :32? im a:::arE<ma:: fmm ézéfiai 3::
2ai';z,E,@~<%-9 E><'5§"s"E§§"E§é"§§ 'aha Esgue am??? regaré ii"; §m;§=$:*%;é::'s?;3E§i:'s; $2' ;sur:é§%'z:*{:§n:§ meiigéag ihaa i:he:*e wag garaviaagg i*2Vé:;%<1;;§:i_V::sf u:m:;%.:h§riseaj aégamze am mirzm §%.§»"3%§?E_f"f';€FE'£S émgagedg. égking mm Cei3?%$%{i§E'&§:§%?s'"é 3:; S §r§Té:<'--;a§{S§é3fi~.::i2'~g " E"-»'%a:23§§:*:2&:2i; in §Z§*'%E =::§$a sf GE'?-If €;t<:s_é;<:f§v&:'5s?€' vasanih éézgmar, wheg; had-.___a%g<>._%::>mmE"'i:%:A:%%__v §§{§>駧;_"'L :*52%§<;§{:sfias€'zg gg wag aaz%éarz': '1?'r.§::%_ EX$.,"'§{E§_{".iG '§J'«£3; the La§$:;:" ifsasri: aE:§'s£.',=ug%*; tififiii-_,~ §iE*;:?:_'»%f3'é'*:;.<:§§%%§3as"~,r fiaéiharéigz was juaiéféefi éra §:a§§%é%ng;'...%h a'i:, $22.9; ..jws:%.:*'§=:r§r1¥;ér:---"§*:aaf csmmétiaé $23 m};§c§n:§{::%:--;, £32; '§EjE"?«§i}é'%7___h*?%§{§ 'séwai ihe ivéanggemeréi wag §'%{3"i gugiéfiaafi "é?"§g;"}Té§i__%%":,;,<:....--vt§'%3 E:><§§E'€*s"§"§E §un§$h:'.r:eni: 9? §§sn::§§:,~:a% ~".T_é'é§ Qs.";rj:§:i*§i;%;";s§:§'":§ wag §ub.§':é§:;ie{§' is x;»;§'gf":§"29§§§:":g 3? f~':_§ &::n:'::.;a§ E%;£.:_ie§:":':§§'jsE5 zsszéihaui C飧"§"§i§§8?.E'af€ Efffifféfil. "fiée "'-A:::;e":E--<%*s':;:~é';: was séiraiééé ifi $9 ffiififiifiififi EEEEILE' $€E"2z°§C% w%%:%'zas;i ':%a'i;<:s;a.gés;"vf:f?:;m iha aéaie 9:? éégméggai iii: tbs fiafte sf "grgéé:g§&%§:9%';a_nE3"°Téée Eazéaféé: G? ;:'$r:§i;':ué::g 0? gawéae wa: ' '¢?s€§"§§ §€":'%.--€;§a:1z.
f a§:a*5:_ia€§__;' ' gééng agggéaveé', we Man&§eme;:%: hag flied Ehig 3" 'réearé the éearneé cszmseé 8?"? §:s¢2t%: géfieg am gemgeé {ha rasestéa
4. "fie {gaging G? Em? iabaué Cami: iézat Eéze t samaaiéa erzaggirgz cazééascisezé by ih& ééaaggemant éa '§aéj::_5:'i':_§ gmger 'nag mi 33%;: ggaggstéaizeé 3; ma :ras{*;r§<;:";*é*a?':<:--;.V'_~--..§'§3g azwzécmafi hag 532:; as? qaéesazzéaaeé §:§'§€ _:f:'%:Vé"i..::ai§.@a:z ' cam E8 32% effsfiét that '£573 §§s:;:gs;;r:.a;a;
jugiéféefi in %:z;§%§%rsg the :*;%*:a:"gae::* éé &§§5§§§E"::?§"§€§ aaé ihe §=::§*;g§h:'::a'r €%;~».:._igf'§3 3:-Ja$V ' éy the §...3§§C3£JE" CGEXEV E5': iha :}:"é%é,;* éséni far Csngééarazéam $3 :r;{%:et§*':e§i..:§i§?&~--.L$'E,fi;;:*"§£":%§'a:'p:~;ifii,»V--¥$'a$ jagiéféeé Ea $ii:}S"§§Ei§§EE':g 'me";:;ssi':":§Aé§:.;%é':»3:f2"é;"fig nfgtéaeé gazgra? 3, Lfiré H.§v'§;.§v§ér€t3§:~dbLha;g, Sgameé cgzigzgéé agggsgafing "x_§_ :1=r ?§§_§};g§gefi'§éér2§...§.entemd$ E§"'§=§'E, Eh&:'§ 2% §:§si:Gs"gz Q? gag:
hag bear: :":£i'€§{ZE{§ E}? the éabaas' ism": Er:
;:alé;=§":::3 @f'i3§':_%.5Em§ugnafi fiilffiggrét Legrneé aaagngeé gsgémtafi 73.33 '{h::€'i%:é medécgé agriéfécaie gméascgé $3; 81% mzgrkman (fa:-éé:é§;'-..é§:":*a§@a;§r:%: §'"'§§§ réghétéy wen mi aacgpieé iv; Erirze "La7?;%z3ur Camrt aa §}§E' the fémirgg recgréad in gara 2:, '% :}_fl E3 Learnéé ::f:2a,m$e% gasbrrzétg ifigig ma €i§§$ 52%' Ct Dasfiéaéafi ég iataéiy éé?%é:*§{:: 33253 {W52 Said w~:>§§<m§:2 wag gaiiieni arzé $5 remsrted :3 have fiéeé, fl5<:<;ri§;§§----s3§A:€;':.:';§:""é:~§":%-*--T * Eaamgé {::(}§§..§§§:-Sag; N: we {:é:":::,:m$i:§::C.e€s,,4 V' mzag mi gzggizifiefi in %%"§':£'G§<i§S"5§§ fag gaéégjei1';§rix;§§rTT'E,L §;
iEnsiu§fz:*éa% §%gga..s*:e3 éaig Er~}4'§='_ a":.3é §3i'5,::i~3%:"r;§:T'E2.e "§§%:"g::;g"%:a§ fififififfia {in §:% L, Ehakay,-T.§§eg$;*:'é:;§ <_::§T%~'s:7":':}:«.,;=:'§ 1.a§pear§;:§ fgr E??? .:*§€~;,'ia:*:«::%e:j:.%i:"Q:':5'_'.iézéa '4%3€é'ré.{<_§.,V_5:.§f%:;3":%€;%;€é énat am w£:r§<;man g{:'éhe;?"--.éé%%'-g<_ §:%"-v?f5;?".:;é°C§,.§;:,%;i§ra~:f%czn gm 133,85 arm? $133 :,2:f:s§7§V5:éT'r:'2%.%f§?"<a;&§ :?:»:§€r:§§:;%,€; abaencgg asazééer {}£e:3g§{;:'§3 Sxazaé .égésk§a:;«.._%::"2:é.a>;f§£a rgasamg, wéeigég Wham exgiaégeéf £553" a;<:V«,_@§f:'.-'.;e§"~"'ib';:'* ihe ?'='§§E":&§%3m§§E'E aw Gfiiy gmn§3h:':zeh§:"*------was Emggsadi Laameé :::2:,:§:$z£=§ ;:<;':*»i:é:':[.§S,_i§"séé:,, 'ézége afigenrce w%:%<:%: betame five gufigigat ri*éa€i:ér sf ;e7':L:%:;;é:*";: is 'aha Emzasét €:as€ wgg aim gs"; §¥CC{3%3F"i?I 2g}? :%z& %:»;Q%*:§<:':§3:": being zgrzwafif 3% {mi Eni§;r:t§£:n3§ 52:15,? Ea %:§:@ '*a:%:t;*;:;%':*:.$ian::e\$, 3% La§}$s,:%' éieagri wag gaggtéféw in 3 ;§.fV":
..-4' y"
"'«..§%;':;é%:'%2~§'§3;':<;a§ a:s;%*é%'t'?'2~*'%': hag ;":z3té€:e§' in gara 32 5:? ice gufigiéiasiéség aha §:;r'a%§§'::*s2e:'*::f mm? _§&i*'€§€L?§§§'°E'g'", %3§<§r:g__§ni:-:,é €Z§f'§S§ij€?§i§G§"§ §Xf.§n§'§i ia W31:
E-*1 "%""§":§ fast §:E":§%:; {he zwarkmgfi §":3';'e:._VVré;§T:'f3a5'§;':@'a;§.4T 335%: fmm éfifirkeétg wéiheai éfafiaénéésg asérg2*-;$a~;'2<:%:§é:;;r; ;g"'nIe::§".
is fisgguia "E"%é& vgsrkmaa gu§%:§':§"._?2§ve é:"?§'\>'§?:'%i¢3L::3' '=-ghif' sfiésxésafégéeé Eaavef if": gage éhera ::i;'as ';~:. ;n§@§*"-?.{;:;*";-*7%i_2.*:": fig: E"%?§'§"2§§§'% £233? 3% ézséy eétiéer s::"Aa_£::a:;:Vfré'%: §§§?'":§i"*.§§§ famééig w§*':§z:,'%2 hag ié'eé;_;,."';<*:§t'§"s;i&<:§ Ceuri in ggara 3.53 as? iirée §§"§"§§?EE'§'i"逧§x.:i;.{E;a;§§':%'E<Z§L ' '%«{§':,a;5v%é:%;"":he L§§{':LE§" Cazurt '§fa§?§§£§"E E353 beéé"; génégrrezfi'j:;a!%é;%f:_ "'i.%f:é--~ }L§§'ES§§£i'E$§"'é Ea': examézéé we ;=re§@§"_%_"§§z'":§EL§'i:-3:"<3?-. fl-:_;§é'2:§%2§°:';€r2'{ an gzgcezsnt Q? ihe E §£?:;3:;:§§15eV'd,_£?::%é:;:"::€:§;.. ézas égéierferefl' wéih éhe pamigézmeni anzfi %r?'§:§} 5§Aefi _':"§%é:'1._::;E,:S€;E%:é;%.€é gwégfimeni, Eéze Lamar Cam":
5:21.33 jugziféefi £3 ieséfiérsg that me gunégéwmem".
"«.é:f;':,§gé'ef«3£ ES ti"j§E§§E'€?§§¥"§§$§"§§i€ is tééa gfazziiy-= G?1§'f':§§CS%"%2:T§UC'i; £3 jaggiéfégsi in @E'éZ5€§"§€%§ éha §::r:%$hme.n:: cf wi%%':':";s%éér:§ 2%
2 ~g$:r:s"""""
gnfiagai %?":r:,'?"E?'§'§€f%'§S wiffisggf €1"iff?"?£i§§:':"iV€ efféfjix Kaepéng Er:
eséevs; itééa 93$': €{}§'E{§§§C'§'i :1? fie w%5§<m3n, Er: ithe faaig am aimmmgianaes :§f fie cage! in my Gginésfif the Quaisféefnergi W?E§€Z§"% ahceasfsi haw beer: émgegga far the ' _',.\.
??E§$C53§"§§é§C'E; aaghi m have '5ee~:~m wéth%2§_§si:é.m§"""Q2-=., %r:z':;=""e:':":@;':i5 wéiéz gzgzzéaséaiéva effaii .... is '€§';'é"':'§a§%:§. é:~s::'e.{:?;; E%'"%'{8E*fiBE"€§'ECE in iém mafia? ég 53%£a§3§Gr;"'"T%7%§e ir:%;Gé*~§<_;*::3%:. §,;%'3é?%1%j.: §§ eniéiéeé is :§r:5@§ z;§:':téaE §:'éi3_:fi';-*:}§'é%:§ (Ema; {in §'"§§3Ai§éZ§z'"?-7£%.§VVV$333S 2 L %=§,, frgsm the fiata G? _§'i§:'::i2§§_§"':§E§*».%_f:§$ ési'-rrszgiaigfrsani 3:1: éuigzg ER figs»? :'€s:3AE'%:_.V ?:%2eas:>'ri»':- :§e%2':.é.{';=n %§'.a'§E"{>*r;ri:e§T in §a;""{ am' the a:?:m1§§:e{E VA':}';-'.a':'fi"ésm.§%cé----%.§3€s{3R fie wfirkman Ea Emfiasaeé as-g§%::%§ {he p§;:rjs%§s%1 ::*2%3r_:€:2 ? »--*-,.2%§'§":J.:.»%*:%":a€é§:"2g Q5 5 3§'%E'EL§&§ §E":£§'§§"§'§€f§§:'~3 aa_:§i:§";.§fi§§é"r':A:sEaEEaz"a* Theze :=:~;%2a§E 3%: $3 gaymani 0? my §a;:_§;«::=a:=3§e';¥§_§;.._Tz'E*:.ve %:;eme§§t cs? =C€}i"£§§"§£.§§§:'3z' G? ggrxzéae $?'%3§E $9 am §@f>§'s';3:i:a%"';::é~:::.;_§;;T;*"' §%*:i$er"'<:2'§ aaafinfimgégs, ;.T;<."?§.;