Punjab-Haryana High Court
M/S Mohit Singhania And Sons And Another vs Suresh Jain And Others on 10 February, 2026
121 45 678 7497 6 5 7 5 6 7 5 49 7 1 1 1 2 !"# $ %&'()*+(,-.-)/021 1
2. )3-'4-/53&/-)/&&/+&/)'3(6 11117('-'-)/(6.
8(6.9.
431496(.3:&-/&/+)'3(6.
11 (.;)/+(/'.
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of 7 ::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:21 ::: 121 345151678912 7 5 8 2 2 2 27 2 2 2 !" # " "
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``aMbMcdMeMZa]M$?$$fghgKi$$A$@$HH$$jAg$1$&)$$'%-0+'%)$0$1%$$+')%'$+$/$$01%$$0'6&.$ $H+,'0$&..+96(7$01%$&5%()5%(0?$48$+4-%'G6(7$01,-k$ $lj:$$m1%$$6--,%?$9$1%01%'$&$$$*'656(&.$$*+,'0$$1&-$3$+9%'$$0+$ $+')%'$$&5%()5%(0$$+/$&$$*$+53.&6(0$$/6.%)$$,()%'$$@%*06+($ $ghhH'nH?$6$-$($+$$.+(7%'$$'%-$6$(0%7'&:$$>($@$:o:$@$,J,5&'$G$:$ $@:$$ @,(&&)$$o&71,'&5$$p@:o:$$@,J,5&'$G$:$$@:$$@,(&&)$ $o&71,'&5?$f$ghA=i$$q$$@HH$$Khq$$k$$fghA=i$$;$@$HH$$fH'6i$ $;;r?$016-$H+,'0$1%.)$&-$,()%'$k$f@HH$3:$Kgh?$3&'&$Aqi$ $lAq:$$s1&0$6$-$$)6-*%'(64.%$$/'+5$$t:n:$$n+..,06+($ $H+(0'+.$$ u+&')$$ *&-%$$pt:n:$$ n+..,06+($$ H+(0'+.$ $u+&')$$G:$$v+)6$w$6-06..%'8?$f$AqCji$$B$$@HH$K$C;$$k$ $AqCj$@$HH$$fH'6i$K$Bg$$k$$fAqCCi$$KB$$H+53$$H&-$$jjr$ 6-$$01&0$$&($$%&-6.8$$*,'&4.%$$.%7&.$$6(/6'5608$$*+,.)$$4%$ $ 2 of 7 ::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 ::: 121 34515126789196 5 ! !" # !$ ! %$! ! ! ! ! &$ $ ! & % $ !' ( ! !$ !$ ' !&!$ ! % !$ ! !$ ! !$ % ) ! $ * ! ! % $ !' !$ ! ! $ ! ! " + !$ ! ' !$ ! %$! ! ! $ ! ! ! !$ ! ! !$ ! ! ! ! $ , $ ( ! !$ !$ ' !$ !$ ! $ ! & $ ! ! $ !"-
." / $ !$ ! %$! !
! % $ !$ ( % ! 0 "1" 0 , 20"1"
0 , ) " 0" 0 1 %$ ' 345678 9 0 ** :59 ;
345678 < 0 ** 3* 8 < <= ! % !$ ! !$
! & %$! & ! !$
> % ? ! % $ !$
$ ) ! $ " @ !
! !$ " A %
!$ ( % ! 0 "1" 0 , 2 0"1" 0 , ) "
0" 0 1 %$ ' 345678 9 0** :59 ; 345678 <
0** 3* 8 < <= ) !$ ! !$ ( % ! &
!$ ( % ! !$ * ! B "C" C !
* ! D )" E F ! 2B"C" C !
* ! D ) " E F ! ' 369.G8 H 0 ** : .< ;
69.G 0 ** 3* 8 : H4 ; 369..8 :H * * GG= " #
E F ! 2B"C" C ! * ! D ) " E
F ! ' 3 69.G8 H 0** :.< ; 69.G 0 ** 3* 8 : H4 ;
369..8 :H * * G G= ' ! !$ &
! ! $ ! !$ ' ) & &
! $ 0 ! <.4 !! &
& !$ " # ) , % ! $ ) ( ! '
!$ I%$ * ! 2J"K" E )" 0! ! B"C"' 69.< 0**
+ L A H<9= M $ !$ % $ % ! $ !
) ! ! !$
F ! NE # ! L ! - &
" /$ ! ! $ ! $
NE F ! -' ! !
) !$ ! E F ! & " /$ I%$
* ! % !$ ! $ & !$ !
M $ ! $ % !$ !$ ! NE
# ! L ! - & ! "
9"
/$ * !' &$ & % !$ !$
! B"C" C ! * ! D ' $
& ; 3E F ! 2B"C" C ! * !
3 of 7
::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 :::
121
34515167289197 5
! "#$%& ' ()) *$+ , "#$% ()) !) & * '- , ! "#$$& *' ) ./ ) %%0 ( )) // *$#1#2 / *& 3* 4 5 6 7 ( 78 9 : 8 6 ; <:
6 7 7 7 7 6 <67 < ; = 7 6 < ./ 7 7 6 ; < ./ 6 7 6 6 ; = 6 <<: : 6 < < 7 :
; 7 ;: 6 . 6 7; .
7 = 6 <6 < : > . > 6 78
6 . .
6 )6 ; 9: <
8 = 6 < 7 < :/ 7 6
// 7 . ? 6 ; . . 7 . 7 6
. 7 < 7 7 7 @ - ; 6 < ./ 7
. ? 6 < 7 78 < ./ 7 ; 6
7 : :7 ; 8: 6 <<: < 7< 7
7 6 < ./ 7 A 6 6 > 7 6
. ? 78 ; ; . // < 7 ; . 7 . 7
> 6 // 7 ; . 7 >
:> : 78 6 7 . ; B7 :
C . 6 < ./ 7 =7 78 6 7 :
:7 7 / < ; A 6 :86
/: / / 7 ; = 7 6 > < 6
7 ( 78 9: 8 D = 6 6 < 7 > 7
< : > ; 6 )6 . 7
E < 1)6 . 7 7 8 78 < 7
. .>
; 6 ; < :7
:>1 < 7 !"& !-& ; ( < 7 +% ; 6 A<
:7 6 = / <: 7 8 7
B7 : C . 6 < ./ 7 =7 78 6
7 : :7 < 7 > . < < 6
>F < 7 > 6 / 7 > ; 6
G 86 ) : :86 6 > 7 = 7 7
7 >: 7 6 < 7 / < :
; ; < 7
7 7 7 7 <::. H 6
/ 7 : 6 6 <67 < ; = 7 6
< ./ 7 >: > 6 ; : ; 6
7 : :7 ;: 7 6 6 I:
7; . 7 < ; > 6
J: 6 . 6 8 7; . ; :<6
7 : =6 <6 < : > <: A7 6
< <:. 7< =6 <6
> 78 : 6 7 =
/ / < ; 6 7 ( 78 9: 8 6
; : // < 6 ; < 6 6 . 7 7
@ - 6 > < 7 : 7 6 86 ; 6
. 7 < 7 7 7 @ " % "$ 7 "#
=6 <6 6 ;; < 6 6 )6 . 7
E < 1)6 . 7 7 8 78 < 7
. .> ; 6 ; < =
> ; 6 8 ;; 7< < .. > 6
) ./ 7 K
! ./6 :// &
4 of 7
::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 :::
121
34515167891 7 5
!" # $ %&'(' ( " ")
*") " + " , ' ! " # $ -./01 2 3 ** 4 /5
-./0 3 ** * 1 4 26 -.//1 42 *"78 * 009 3**
8' 4.- 8 01
:0' ; < " = , $ "> ? @ > = A
= ) " "> !" <) B 7
" " > 8 " @ ") )@ )
," > @ )A " ) @ ) @ > @
)" )@ = >" A = )
> = @ ">
8 ", ") @") ) )
3 @ ") 6C-1 ) 64 7 8 ) = )
3 @ ") 55 3 @ ") 50 "> D@ ' E
78 88 1
FFF F FF F FF
--' G , )A = @H " 3 'G' 3 H 7 % 3'G' 3 H 7 , '
3' 3 ) G A 7 6I-C1 . 3** 4I. 6I-C1 5
3** * 1 5 59 " )" >" " > "7 ? A7 )
8" J@"A) K )@ )" 7 ) 7 ) @ ) = " '
<) > @ )A " > 8 ) 7 8 A 8 " >
? A7 ) @ $ = )A " > @ >" )@
") A , ) 3** 88' 46IJ6- 8 6I1
:6I' <) ) ) @ 7 ) 7 )
88 @ ") > " ) 65JCJ6II0 " @ $ "
7 ) 7 ) =$ )A ( - - 1 ) --=1'
L " A 8 "8" 7 ) 7 ) )"
>" 7 7 ) 7 ) = = ) ")
! A " 7 ) 7 ) 88 @ ")
7 ) $ " ) A " ) )" @"A) K )@
H ) " > @"78 ) = >" 8" ">
7 ) 7 ) 88 @ ")' $ ! A
$ " 88 $ ? @ 7 ) "
@") ) " > @"78 ) ) )" H )
@"A) K )@ "> 7 ' 3 @") $ )@
77") $ " = " " = "
@@ )" 8 ? @ " = @ "
@@ ' L $ 7 ) 7 ) )" @ )A
" A ) ) " > @"78 ) = )A ")
>" > 7 ")' " $ 8 = @ ") ">
8" 7 M ) $ H = )A ) ) ">
= N ) , ) @ ) @ "> @ ")
) > ," "> 8") ) @ @" ,
= ) 8 " @ = $ 8") ) =$ > )A
8 @"78 ) )
>" " ,"
7 8 @ $ "> 8 "@ )A
@"
" 7 ) 7 ) 88 @ ")'
*") )A > @ " @ A )
7 ) " > @" = " ) " , O A
5 of 7
::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 :::
121
34515167891 7 5
!
"#$$ % &# $ # # !
#' ' #"" # # '"
$ $ ' # $ $ '
!# # ( $
) $ * +,-
$ ./
0 '" #$ $
$ "" 1
2 3 $ # # $ #
'$ # # #' ' $ '" # $ %
# ! # 4# $ #5 .
((( ( (( ( ((
+6. 7 #8 # " $ '" # #
#"" # #' ' . 9 #' ' !#$
' 8 # # $ # ! # $ '' $ % $$
$" $3 (#' #
'" # # # # !
$$: (#' # !#$ #!# . 9 #' ' '#
$ # $ ! # " $ $ "" .
* '" # # 3 ! ! # !#$
$ "" !#$ ;' 5/3 % # # 8 ; $
0 ' 5 " $1/ !#$ ' . 9 !
# !#$ #
'" # # $ .
<=. > # $ " $ #$ # $
$ # # 3 ! # #%$ " )
! % # $ # $ ? $" $. 9
# # # $ ! #8 % #$ # # . * $
! # '"# #' ' ! #8
( $ % #% $ #
%#$ 8 . @ ! #$ # #%
# ! # # $$ %
# ! #' ' . @ % $# # %
# ! #' ' # # $ # ! 8
'" # # !#$ '" 3 # ) $
! #$ . /
AB CDE FGH IJKLIMH JNOPHQRSEDFHR DJE DOLNJFJLFPHHJ
OHJFILJHEIJFGHFDPNTDFHEULQOSLQDMLQQHMFILJFGHQHLUVDRWQDXHESFGH QHRWLJEHJFRMLNTEGDKHRFITTQHRIRFHEFGHDOHJEOHJFRFDFIJYFGDFRLOH WQHZNEIMH MLNTE PH MDNRHE IUFGH RDOH VDR DTTLVHEB[LFDPTXSFGH DOHJEOHJFRLNYGFPXFGHWHFIFILJHQRPHIJYLJTXFLFGHGHDEIJYLUFGH FDPTHDRQHWQLENMHEIJWDQD[LB LUFGHMLOWTDIJFDJEJLFLUFGHFDPTH 6 of 7 ::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 ::: 121 34515167891 7 5 ! ! " # $ $ ! $ % "3 ! # % & & # $ $ ! $ # ! $ '! $ "( ) *!& 3 ! +,-.-/+0+1+2+343+5+63+7+8.9:++;<6:0=/++>?@-.+ 8 *33 A7B CDEC CFGCCHCCIJKJLLHKMCCNOPKPNJQCCNOPCCRSTUVWPXCCJKXPKGCHCKPCGCPNCCHGRXPCCHWXC NOPCCHTTLRIHNRJWCCYJKCHCSPWXSPWNCCGNHWXGCCHLLJZPXEC[ & $ $ C & " ! 4 B \1 & $ B C]EC ^ % $ % ! $ _& & "
" &! & $'!$ & B
BB A +̀727a+bc7dec7fgh+
$ +ide>j+
k & l \ $ mn \^
k & mn \^
7 of 7
::: Downloaded on - 12-02-2026 22:55:22 :::